New experiments in self-teaching | Sugata Mitra

984,923 views ・ 2010-09-07

TED


Please double-click on the English subtitles below to play the video.

00:17
Well, that's kind of an obvious statement up there.
0
17260
2000
00:19
I started with that sentence about 12 years ago,
1
19260
3000
00:22
and I started in the context
2
22260
3000
00:25
of developing countries,
3
25260
2000
00:27
but you're sitting here from every corner of the world.
4
27260
3000
00:30
So if you think of a map of your country,
5
30260
3000
00:33
I think you'll realize
6
33260
2000
00:35
that for every country on Earth,
7
35260
2000
00:37
you could draw little circles to say,
8
37260
2000
00:39
"These are places where good teachers won't go."
9
39260
3000
00:43
On top of that,
10
43260
2000
00:45
those are the places from where trouble comes.
11
45260
3000
00:48
So we have an ironic problem --
12
48260
2000
00:50
good teachers don't want to go
13
50260
2000
00:52
to just those places where they're needed the most.
14
52260
3000
00:55
I started in 1999
15
55260
3000
00:58
to try and address this problem with an experiment,
16
58260
3000
01:01
which was a very simple experiment in New Delhi.
17
61260
3000
01:06
I basically embedded a computer
18
66260
3000
01:09
into a wall of a slum in New Delhi.
19
69260
3000
01:13
The children barely went to school, they didn't know any English --
20
73260
3000
01:16
they'd never seen a computer before,
21
76260
2000
01:18
and they didn't know what the internet was.
22
78260
3000
01:21
I connected high speed internet to it -- it's about three feet off the ground --
23
81260
3000
01:24
turned it on and left it there.
24
84260
2000
01:26
After this,
25
86260
2000
01:28
we noticed a couple of interesting things, which you'll see.
26
88260
3000
01:31
But I repeated this all over India
27
91260
3000
01:34
and then through
28
94260
2000
01:36
a large part of the world
29
96260
2000
01:38
and noticed
30
98260
2000
01:40
that children will learn to do
31
100260
2000
01:42
what they want to learn to do.
32
102260
3000
01:45
This is the first experiment that we did --
33
105260
2000
01:47
eight year-old boy on your right
34
107260
2000
01:49
teaching his student, a six year-old girl,
35
109260
3000
01:52
and he was teaching her how to browse.
36
112260
3000
01:56
This boy here in the middle of central India --
37
116260
3000
02:00
this is in a Rajasthan village,
38
120260
2000
02:02
where the children recorded their own music
39
122260
3000
02:05
and then played it back to each other
40
125260
3000
02:08
and in the process,
41
128260
2000
02:10
they've enjoyed themselves thoroughly.
42
130260
2000
02:12
They did all of this in four hours
43
132260
2000
02:14
after seeing the computer for the first time.
44
134260
3000
02:17
In another South Indian village,
45
137260
3000
02:20
these boys here
46
140260
2000
02:22
had assembled a video camera
47
142260
2000
02:24
and were trying to take the photograph of a bumble bee.
48
144260
2000
02:26
They downloaded it from Disney.com,
49
146260
2000
02:28
or one of these websites,
50
148260
2000
02:30
14 days after putting the computer in their village.
51
150260
3000
02:36
So at the end of it,
52
156260
2000
02:38
we concluded that groups of children
53
158260
2000
02:40
can learn to use computers and the internet on their own,
54
160260
3000
02:43
irrespective of who
55
163260
2000
02:45
or where they were.
56
165260
3000
02:48
At that point, I became a little more ambitious
57
168260
3000
02:51
and decided to see
58
171260
3000
02:54
what else could children do with a computer.
59
174260
3000
02:57
We started off with an experiment in Hyderabad, India,
60
177260
3000
03:00
where I gave a group of children --
61
180260
3000
03:03
they spoke English with a very strong Telugu accent.
62
183260
3000
03:06
I gave them a computer
63
186260
2000
03:08
with a speech-to-text interface,
64
188260
2000
03:10
which you now get free with Windows,
65
190260
3000
03:13
and asked them to speak into it.
66
193260
2000
03:15
So when they spoke into it,
67
195260
2000
03:17
the computer typed out gibberish,
68
197260
2000
03:19
so they said, "Well, it doesn't understand anything of what we are saying."
69
199260
2000
03:21
So I said, "Yeah, I'll leave it here for two months.
70
201260
2000
03:23
Make yourself understood
71
203260
2000
03:25
to the computer."
72
205260
2000
03:27
So the children said, "How do we do that."
73
207260
2000
03:29
And I said,
74
209260
2000
03:31
"I don't know, actually."
75
211260
2000
03:33
(Laughter)
76
213260
2000
03:35
And I left.
77
215260
2000
03:37
(Laughter)
78
217260
2000
03:40
Two months later --
79
220260
2000
03:42
and this is now documented
80
222260
2000
03:44
in the Information Technology
81
224260
2000
03:46
for International Development journal --
82
226260
2000
03:48
that accents had changed
83
228260
2000
03:50
and were remarkably close to the neutral British accent
84
230260
3000
03:53
in which I had trained the speech-to-text synthesizer.
85
233260
3000
03:56
In other words, they were all speaking like James Tooley.
86
236260
3000
03:59
(Laughter)
87
239260
2000
04:01
So they could do that on their own.
88
241260
2000
04:03
After that, I started to experiment
89
243260
2000
04:05
with various other things
90
245260
2000
04:07
that they might learn to do on their own.
91
247260
2000
04:09
I got an interesting phone call once from Columbo,
92
249260
3000
04:12
from the late Arthur C. Clarke,
93
252260
2000
04:14
who said, "I want to see what's going on."
94
254260
2000
04:16
And he couldn't travel, so I went over there.
95
256260
3000
04:19
He said two interesting things,
96
259260
2000
04:21
"A teacher that can be replaced by a machine should be."
97
261260
5000
04:26
(Laughter)
98
266260
2000
04:28
The second thing he said was that,
99
268260
2000
04:30
"If children have interest,
100
270260
2000
04:32
then education happens."
101
272260
3000
04:35
And I was doing that in the field,
102
275260
2000
04:37
so every time I would watch it and think of him.
103
277260
2000
04:39
(Video) Arthur C. Clarke: And they can definitely
104
279260
3000
04:42
help people,
105
282260
2000
04:44
because children quickly learn to navigate
106
284260
2000
04:46
the web and find things which interest them.
107
286260
3000
04:49
And when you've got interest, then you have education.
108
289260
3000
04:52
Sugata Mitra: I took the experiment to South Africa.
109
292260
3000
04:55
This is a 15 year-old boy.
110
295260
2000
04:57
(Video) Boy: ... just mention, I play games
111
297260
3000
05:00
like animals,
112
300260
3000
05:03
and I listen to music.
113
303260
3000
05:06
SM: And I asked him, "Do you send emails?"
114
306260
2000
05:08
And he said, "Yes, and they hop across the ocean."
115
308260
3000
05:12
This is in Cambodia,
116
312260
2000
05:14
rural Cambodia --
117
314260
3000
05:17
a fairly silly arithmetic game,
118
317260
3000
05:20
which no child would play inside the classroom or at home.
119
320260
2000
05:22
They would, you know, throw it back at you.
120
322260
2000
05:24
They'd say, "This is very boring."
121
324260
2000
05:26
If you leave it on the pavement
122
326260
2000
05:28
and if all the adults go away,
123
328260
2000
05:30
then they will show off with each other
124
330260
2000
05:32
about what they can do.
125
332260
2000
05:34
This is what these children are doing.
126
334260
2000
05:36
They are trying to multiply, I think.
127
336260
3000
05:39
And all over India,
128
339260
2000
05:41
at the end of about two years,
129
341260
2000
05:43
children were beginning to Google their homework.
130
343260
3000
05:46
As a result, the teachers reported
131
346260
2000
05:48
tremendous improvements in their English --
132
348260
2000
05:50
(Laughter)
133
350260
4000
05:54
rapid improvement and all sorts of things.
134
354260
2000
05:56
They said, "They have become really deep thinkers and so on and so forth.
135
356260
3000
05:59
(Laughter)
136
359260
3000
06:02
And indeed they had.
137
362260
2000
06:04
I mean, if there's stuff on Google,
138
364260
2000
06:06
why would you need to stuff it into your head?
139
366260
3000
06:10
So at the end of the next four years,
140
370260
2000
06:12
I decided that groups of children can navigate the internet
141
372260
3000
06:15
to achieve educational objectives on their own.
142
375260
3000
06:18
At that time, a large amount of money
143
378260
2000
06:20
had come into Newcastle University
144
380260
2000
06:22
to improve schooling in India.
145
382260
3000
06:25
So Newcastle gave me a call. I said, "I'll do it from Delhi."
146
385260
3000
06:28
They said, "There's no way you're going to handle
147
388260
2000
06:30
a million pounds-worth of University money
148
390260
3000
06:33
sitting in Delhi."
149
393260
2000
06:35
So in 2006,
150
395260
2000
06:37
I bought myself a heavy overcoat
151
397260
2000
06:39
and moved to Newcastle.
152
399260
2000
06:42
I wanted to test the limits
153
402260
2000
06:44
of the system.
154
404260
2000
06:46
The first experiment I did out of Newcastle
155
406260
2000
06:48
was actually done in India.
156
408260
2000
06:50
And I set myself and impossible target:
157
410260
3000
06:53
can Tamil speaking
158
413260
3000
06:56
12-year-old children
159
416260
2000
06:58
in a South Indian village
160
418260
3000
07:01
teach themselves biotechnology
161
421260
2000
07:03
in English on their own?
162
423260
2000
07:05
And I thought, I'll test them, they'll get a zero --
163
425260
3000
07:08
I'll give the materials, I'll come back and test them --
164
428260
2000
07:10
they get another zero,
165
430260
2000
07:12
I'll go back and say, "Yes, we need teachers for certain things."
166
432260
4000
07:16
I called in 26 children.
167
436260
2000
07:18
They all came in there, and I told them
168
438260
2000
07:20
that there's some really difficult stuff on this computer.
169
440260
2000
07:22
I wouldn't be surprised if you didn't understand anything.
170
442260
3000
07:25
It's all in English, and I'm going.
171
445260
3000
07:28
(Laughter)
172
448260
2000
07:30
So I left them with it.
173
450260
2000
07:32
I came back after two months,
174
452260
2000
07:34
and the 26 children marched in looking very, very quiet.
175
454260
2000
07:36
I said, "Well, did you look at any of the stuff?"
176
456260
3000
07:39
They said, "Yes, we did."
177
459260
2000
07:41
"Did you understand anything?" "No, nothing."
178
461260
3000
07:44
So I said,
179
464260
2000
07:46
"Well, how long did you practice on it
180
466260
2000
07:48
before you decided you understood nothing?"
181
468260
2000
07:50
They said, "We look at it every day."
182
470260
3000
07:53
So I said, "For two months, you were looking at stuff you didn't understand?"
183
473260
2000
07:55
So a 12 year-old girl raises her hand and says,
184
475260
2000
07:57
literally,
185
477260
2000
08:00
"Apart from the fact that improper replication of the DNA molecule
186
480260
3000
08:03
causes genetic disease,
187
483260
2000
08:05
we've understood nothing else."
188
485260
2000
08:07
(Laughter)
189
487260
2000
08:09
(Applause)
190
489260
7000
08:16
(Laughter)
191
496260
3000
08:19
It took me three years to publish that.
192
499260
2000
08:21
It's just been published in the British Journal of Educational Technology.
193
501260
3000
08:24
One of the referees who refereed the paper said,
194
504260
3000
08:27
"It's too good to be true,"
195
507260
3000
08:30
which was not very nice.
196
510260
2000
08:32
Well, one of the girls had taught herself
197
512260
2000
08:34
to become the teacher.
198
514260
2000
08:36
And then that's her over there.
199
516260
2000
08:46
Remember, they don't study English.
200
526260
2000
09:01
I edited out the last bit when I asked, "Where is the neuron?"
201
541260
3000
09:04
and she says, "The neuron? The neuron,"
202
544260
2000
09:06
and then she looked and did this.
203
546260
3000
09:09
Whatever the expression, it was not very nice.
204
549260
3000
09:12
So their scores had gone up from zero to 30 percent,
205
552260
3000
09:15
which is an educational impossibility under the circumstances.
206
555260
3000
09:18
But 30 percent is not a pass.
207
558260
3000
09:21
So I found that they had a friend,
208
561260
2000
09:23
a local accountant, a young girl,
209
563260
2000
09:25
and they played football with her.
210
565260
2000
09:27
I asked that girl, "Would you teach them
211
567260
2000
09:29
enough biotechnology to pass?"
212
569260
2000
09:31
And she said, "How would I do that? I don't know the subject."
213
571260
2000
09:33
I said, "No, use the method of the grandmother."
214
573260
2000
09:35
She said, "What's that?"
215
575260
2000
09:37
I said, "Well, what you've got to do
216
577260
2000
09:39
is stand behind them
217
579260
2000
09:41
and admire them all the time.
218
581260
3000
09:44
Just say to them, 'That's cool. That's fantastic.
219
584260
2000
09:46
What is that? Can you do that again? Can you show me some more?'"
220
586260
3000
09:49
She did that for two months.
221
589260
2000
09:51
The scores went up to 50,
222
591260
2000
09:53
which is what the posh schools of New Delhi,
223
593260
2000
09:55
with a trained biotechnology teacher were getting.
224
595260
3000
09:58
So I came back to Newcastle
225
598260
2000
10:00
with these results
226
600260
2000
10:02
and decided
227
602260
2000
10:04
that there was something happening here
228
604260
2000
10:06
that definitely was getting very serious.
229
606260
3000
10:10
So, having experimented in all sorts of remote places,
230
610260
3000
10:13
I came to the most remote place that I could think of.
231
613260
3000
10:16
(Laughter)
232
616260
2000
10:19
Approximately 5,000 miles from Delhi
233
619260
3000
10:22
is the little town of Gateshead.
234
622260
2000
10:24
In Gateshead, I took 32 children
235
624260
3000
10:27
and I started to fine-tune the method.
236
627260
3000
10:30
I made them into groups of four.
237
630260
3000
10:33
I said, "You make your own groups of four.
238
633260
2000
10:35
Each group of four can use one computer and not four computers."
239
635260
3000
10:38
Remember, from the Hole in the Wall.
240
638260
3000
10:41
"You can exchange groups.
241
641260
2000
10:43
You can walk across to another group,
242
643260
2000
10:45
if you don't like your group, etc.
243
645260
2000
10:47
You can go to another group, peer over their shoulders, see what they're doing,
244
647260
3000
10:50
come back to you own group and claim it as your own work."
245
650260
3000
10:53
And I explained to them
246
653260
2000
10:55
that, you know, a lot of scientific research is done using that method.
247
655260
3000
10:58
(Laughter)
248
658260
2000
11:00
(Applause)
249
660260
5000
11:07
The children enthusiastically got after me and said,
250
667260
2000
11:09
"Now, what do you want us to do?"
251
669260
2000
11:11
I gave them six GCSE questions.
252
671260
3000
11:14
The first group -- the best one --
253
674260
2000
11:16
solved everything in 20 minutes.
254
676260
2000
11:18
The worst, in 45.
255
678260
3000
11:21
They used everything that they knew --
256
681260
2000
11:23
news groups, Google, Wikipedia,
257
683260
2000
11:25
Ask Jeeves, etc.
258
685260
2000
11:27
The teachers said, "Is this deep learning?"
259
687260
3000
11:30
I said, "Well, let's try it.
260
690260
2000
11:32
I'll come back after two months.
261
692260
2000
11:34
We'll give them a paper test --
262
694260
2000
11:36
no computers, no talking to each other, etc."
263
696260
2000
11:38
The average score when I'd done it with the computers and the groups
264
698260
2000
11:40
was 76 percent.
265
700260
2000
11:42
When I did the experiment, when I did the test,
266
702260
2000
11:44
after two months, the score
267
704260
3000
11:47
was 76 percent.
268
707260
3000
11:50
There was photographic recall
269
710260
2000
11:52
inside the children,
270
712260
2000
11:54
I suspect because they're discussing with each other.
271
714260
3000
11:57
A single child in front of a single computer
272
717260
2000
11:59
will not do that.
273
719260
2000
12:01
I have further results,
274
721260
2000
12:03
which are almost unbelievable,
275
723260
2000
12:05
of scores which go up with time.
276
725260
2000
12:07
Because their teachers say
277
727260
2000
12:09
that after the session is over,
278
729260
2000
12:11
the children continue to Google further.
279
731260
3000
12:14
Here in Britain, I put out a call
280
734260
2000
12:16
for British grandmothers,
281
736260
2000
12:18
after my Kuppam experiment.
282
738260
2000
12:20
Well, you know,
283
740260
2000
12:22
they're very vigorous people, British grandmothers.
284
742260
2000
12:24
200 of them volunteered immediately.
285
744260
2000
12:26
(Laughter)
286
746260
2000
12:28
The deal was that they would give me
287
748260
3000
12:31
one hour of broadband time,
288
751260
2000
12:33
sitting in their homes,
289
753260
2000
12:35
one day in a week.
290
755260
2000
12:37
So they did that,
291
757260
2000
12:39
and over the last two years,
292
759260
2000
12:41
over 600 hours of instruction
293
761260
2000
12:43
has happened over Skype,
294
763260
2000
12:45
using what my students call the granny cloud.
295
765260
3000
12:48
The granny cloud sits over there.
296
768260
3000
12:51
I can beam them to whichever school I want to.
297
771260
3000
13:00
(Video) Teacher: You can't catch me.
298
780260
2000
13:02
You say it.
299
782260
3000
13:05
You can't catch me.
300
785260
3000
13:08
Children: You can't catch me.
301
788260
3000
13:11
Teacher: I'm the gingerbread man.
302
791260
3000
13:14
Children: I'm the gingerbread man.
303
794260
2000
13:16
Teacher: Well done. Very good ...
304
796260
2000
13:24
SM: Back at Gateshead,
305
804260
2000
13:26
a 10-year-old girl gets into the heart of Hinduism
306
806260
2000
13:28
in 15 minutes.
307
808260
2000
13:30
You know, stuff which I don't know anything about.
308
810260
3000
13:36
Two children watch a TEDTalk.
309
816260
2000
13:38
They wanted to be footballers before.
310
818260
2000
13:40
After watching eight TEDTalks,
311
820260
2000
13:42
he wants to become Leonardo da Vinci.
312
822260
3000
13:45
(Laughter)
313
825260
3000
13:48
(Applause)
314
828260
3000
13:51
It's pretty simple stuff.
315
831260
2000
13:53
This is what I'm building now --
316
833260
2000
13:55
they're called SOLEs: Self Organized Learning Environments.
317
835260
3000
13:58
The furniture is designed
318
838260
2000
14:00
so that children can sit in front of big, powerful screens,
319
840260
3000
14:03
big broadband connections, but in groups.
320
843260
3000
14:06
If they want, they can call the granny cloud.
321
846260
3000
14:09
This is a SOLE in Newcastle.
322
849260
2000
14:11
The mediator is from Pune, India.
323
851260
2000
14:13
So how far can we go? One last little bit and I'll stop.
324
853260
3000
14:16
I went to Turin in May.
325
856260
3000
14:20
I sent all the teachers away from my group of 10 year-old students.
326
860260
3000
14:24
I speak only English, they speak only Italian,
327
864260
3000
14:27
so we had no way to communicate.
328
867260
2000
14:29
I started writing English questions on the blackboard.
329
869260
3000
14:33
The children looked at it and said, "What?"
330
873260
2000
14:35
I said, "Well, do it."
331
875260
2000
14:37
They typed it into Google, translated it into Italian,
332
877260
3000
14:40
went back into Italian Google.
333
880260
2000
14:42
Fifteen minutes later --
334
882260
3000
14:52
next question: where is Calcutta?
335
892260
3000
14:57
This one, they took only 10 minutes.
336
897260
3000
15:04
I tried a really hard one then.
337
904260
3000
15:07
Who was Pythagoras, and what did he do?
338
907260
3000
15:12
There was silence for a while,
339
912260
2000
15:14
then they said, "You've spelled it wrong.
340
914260
2000
15:16
It's Pitagora."
341
916260
3000
15:23
And then,
342
923260
2000
15:25
in 20 minutes,
343
925260
2000
15:27
the right-angled triangles began to appear on the screens.
344
927260
2000
15:29
This sent shivers up my spine.
345
929260
3000
15:32
These are 10 year-olds.
346
932260
2000
15:47
Text: In another 30 minutes they would reach the Theory of Relativity. And then?
347
947260
3000
15:50
(Laughter)
348
950260
2000
15:52
(Applause)
349
952260
9000
16:01
SM: So you know what's happened?
350
961260
2000
16:03
I think we've just stumbled across
351
963260
2000
16:05
a self-organizing system.
352
965260
2000
16:07
A self-organizing system is one
353
967260
2000
16:09
where a structure appears
354
969260
2000
16:11
without explicit intervention from the outside.
355
971260
3000
16:14
Self-organizing systems also always show emergence,
356
974260
3000
16:17
which is that the system starts to do things,
357
977260
2000
16:19
which it was never designed for.
358
979260
2000
16:21
Which is why you react the way you do,
359
981260
2000
16:23
because it looks impossible.
360
983260
3000
16:26
I think I can make a guess now --
361
986260
3000
16:29
education is self-organizing system,
362
989260
2000
16:31
where learning is an emergent phenomenon.
363
991260
2000
16:33
It'll take a few years to prove it, experimentally,
364
993260
2000
16:35
but I'm going to try.
365
995260
2000
16:37
But in the meanwhile, there is a method available.
366
997260
3000
16:40
One billion children, we need 100 million mediators --
367
1000260
3000
16:43
there are many more than that on the planet --
368
1003260
2000
16:45
10 million SOLEs,
369
1005260
2000
16:47
180 billion dollars and 10 years.
370
1007260
3000
16:51
We could change everything.
371
1011260
2000
16:53
Thanks.
372
1013260
2000
16:55
(Applause)
373
1015260
11000
About this website

This site will introduce you to YouTube videos that are useful for learning English. You will see English lessons taught by top-notch teachers from around the world. Double-click on the English subtitles displayed on each video page to play the video from there. The subtitles scroll in sync with the video playback. If you have any comments or requests, please contact us using this contact form.

https://forms.gle/WvT1wiN1qDtmnspy7