Phil Plait: How to defend Earth from asteroids

148,834 views ・ 2011-11-21

TED


Please double-click on the English subtitles below to play the video.

00:16
I want to talk to you about something
0
16260
2079
00:18
kind of big.
1
18363
1238
00:21
We'll start here.
2
21942
1214
00:24
Sixty-five million years ago --
3
24837
1949
00:26
(Laughter)
4
26810
1037
00:27
the dinosaurs had a bad day.
5
27871
3039
00:30
(Laughter)
6
30934
2611
00:33
A chunk of rock six miles across,
7
33569
3275
00:36
moving something like 50 times the speed of a rifle bullet,
8
36868
3741
00:40
slammed into the Earth.
9
40633
1781
00:42
It released its energy all at once,
10
42438
2456
00:44
and it was an explosion that was mind-numbing.
11
44918
3528
00:48
If you took every nuclear weapon ever built
12
48470
2861
00:51
at the height of the Cold War,
13
51355
1559
00:52
lumped them together,
14
52938
1372
00:54
and blew them up at the same time,
15
54334
2502
00:56
that would be one one-millionth of the energy released at that moment.
16
56860
4709
01:02
The dinosaurs had a really bad day.
17
62256
3490
01:05
OK?
18
65770
1165
01:06
Now, a six-mile-wide rock is very large.
19
66959
2341
01:09
We all live here in Boulder.
20
69324
1365
01:10
If you look out your window and see Longs Peak --
21
70713
2400
01:13
you're probably familiar with it --
22
73137
1715
01:14
now, scoop up Longs Peak and put it out in space.
23
74876
3013
01:17
Take ... Meeker, Mt. Meeker.
24
77913
2685
01:20
Lump that in there, and put that in space as well.
25
80622
2737
01:23
And Mt. Everest. And K2.
26
83383
3028
01:26
And the Indian peaks.
27
86435
1563
01:28
Then you're starting to get an idea of how much rock we're talking about, OK?
28
88022
3864
01:31
We know it was that big
29
91910
1177
01:33
because of the impact it had and the crater it left.
30
93111
2836
01:35
It hit in what we now know as Yucatan, the Gulf of Mexico.
31
95971
3965
01:39
You can see here, there's the Yucatan Peninsula,
32
99960
2610
01:42
if you recognize Cozumel off the east coast there.
33
102594
2373
01:44
Here is how big of a crater was left.
34
104991
2716
01:47
It was huge.
35
107731
1173
01:48
To give you a sense of the scale ... there you go.
36
108928
2588
01:51
The scale here is 50 miles on top, a hundred kilometers on the bottom.
37
111540
3993
01:55
This thing was 300 kilometers across -- 200 miles --
38
115557
3052
01:58
an enormous crater that excavated out vast amounts of earth
39
118633
3577
02:02
that splashed around the globe and set fires all over the planet,
40
122234
4571
02:06
threw up enough dust to block out the sun.
41
126829
2245
02:09
It wiped out 75 percent of all species on Earth.
42
129098
4346
02:13
Now, not all asteroids are that big.
43
133468
2888
02:16
Some of them are smaller.
44
136380
1325
02:18
Here is one that came in
45
138610
2859
02:21
over the United States in October of 1992.
46
141493
4355
02:25
It came in on a Friday night.
47
145872
1736
02:27
Why is that important?
48
147632
1256
02:28
Because back then, video cameras were just starting to become popular,
49
148912
3772
02:32
and parents would bring them to their kids' football games
50
152708
3952
02:36
to film their kids playing football.
51
156684
1823
02:38
And since this came in on a Friday,
52
158531
2127
02:40
they were able to get this great footage of this thing breaking up
53
160682
3441
02:44
as it came in over West Virginia, Maryland, Pennsylvania and New Jersey
54
164147
3455
02:47
until it did that
55
167626
1310
02:48
to a car in New York.
56
168960
1430
02:50
(Laughter)
57
170414
1576
02:52
Now, this is not a 200-mile-wide crater,
58
172014
3498
02:55
but then again, you can see the rock, which is sitting right here,
59
175536
3481
02:59
about the size of a football,
60
179041
1394
03:00
that hit that car and did that damage.
61
180459
2382
03:02
Now, this thing was probably about the size of a school bus
62
182865
2811
03:05
when it first came in.
63
185700
1157
03:06
It broke up through atmospheric pressure,
64
186881
1977
03:08
it crumbled, and then the pieces fell apart
65
188882
2099
03:11
and did some damage.
66
191005
1484
03:12
Now, you wouldn't want that falling on your foot or your head,
67
192513
3926
03:16
because it would do that to it.
68
196463
1496
03:17
That would be bad.
69
197983
1953
03:19
But it won't wipe out, you know, all life on Earth, so that's fine.
70
199960
3264
03:23
But it turns out, you don't need something six miles across
71
203248
3688
03:26
to do a lot of damage.
72
206960
1243
03:28
There is a median point between tiny rock and gigantic rock,
73
208227
3695
03:31
and in fact, if any of you have ever been to near Winslow, Arizona,
74
211946
3868
03:35
there is a crater in the desert there that is so iconic
75
215838
3519
03:39
that it is actually called "Meteor Crater."
76
219381
2560
03:41
To give you a sense of scale, this is about a mile wide.
77
221965
2977
03:44
If you look up at the top, that's a parking lot,
78
224966
3239
03:48
and those are recreational vehicles right there.
79
228229
2894
03:51
So it's about a mile across, 600 feet deep.
80
231147
3074
03:54
The object that formed this was probably about 30 to 50 yards across,
81
234245
5425
03:59
so roughly the size of Macky Auditorium here.
82
239694
3694
04:03
It came in at speeds that were tremendous,
83
243412
2579
04:06
slammed into the ground, blew up,
84
246015
2324
04:08
and exploded with the energy of roughly a 20-megaton nuclear bomb --
85
248363
3793
04:12
a very hefty bomb.
86
252180
1567
04:13
This was 50,000 years ago,
87
253771
2110
04:15
so it may have wiped out a few buffalo or antelope,
88
255905
2870
04:18
or something like that out in the desert,
89
258799
2558
04:21
but it probably would not have caused global devastation.
90
261381
3801
04:25
It turns out that these things don't have to hit the ground
91
265206
3623
04:28
to do a lot of damage.
92
268853
1583
04:30
Now, in 1908, over Siberia, near the Tunguska region --
93
270460
3857
04:34
for those of you who are Dan Aykroyd fans and saw "Ghostbusters,"
94
274341
3181
04:37
when he talked about the greatest cross-dimensional rift
95
277546
2636
04:40
since the Siberia blast of 1909,
96
280206
1934
04:42
where he got the date wrong, but that's OK.
97
282164
2609
04:44
(Laughter)
98
284797
1112
04:45
It was 1908. That's fine. I can live with that.
99
285933
2267
04:48
(Laughter)
100
288224
1833
04:50
Another rock came into the Earth's atmosphere
101
290081
3075
04:53
and this one blew up above the ground,
102
293180
2192
04:55
several miles up above the surface of the Earth.
103
295396
2313
04:57
The heat from the explosion set fire to the forest below it,
104
297733
5176
05:02
and then the shock wave came down and knocked down trees
105
302933
3177
05:06
for hundreds of square miles.
106
306134
2818
05:08
This did a huge amount of damage.
107
308976
1977
05:10
And again, this was a rock probably roughly the size
108
310977
2745
05:13
of this auditorium that we're sitting in.
109
313746
2078
05:15
In Meteor Crater, it was made of metal,
110
315848
1977
05:17
and metal is much tougher, so it made it to the ground.
111
317849
2644
05:20
The one over Tunguska was probably made of rock,
112
320517
2307
05:22
and that's much more crumbly, so it blew up in the air.
113
322848
2794
05:25
Either way, these are tremendous explosions -- 20 megatons.
114
325666
4685
05:30
Now, when these things blow up,
115
330375
2049
05:32
they're not going to do global ecological damage.
116
332448
3387
05:35
They're not going to do something like the dinosaur killer did.
117
335859
3168
05:39
They're just not big enough.
118
339051
1469
05:40
But they will do global economic damage,
119
340544
2686
05:43
because they don't have to hit, necessarily,
120
343254
2518
05:45
to do this kind of damage.
121
345796
1509
05:47
They don't have to do global devastation.
122
347329
2607
05:49
If one of these things were to hit pretty much anywhere,
123
349960
2812
05:52
it would cause a panic.
124
352796
1155
05:53
But if it came over a city, an important city --
125
353975
2265
05:56
not that any city is more important than others,
126
356264
2264
05:58
but some of them we depend on more on the global economic basis --
127
358552
3339
06:01
that could do a huge amount of damage to us as a civilization.
128
361915
5206
06:07
So, now that I've scared the crap out of you --
129
367145
3522
06:10
(Laughter)
130
370691
1105
06:11
what can we do about this?
131
371820
1977
06:13
This is a potential threat.
132
373821
2087
06:15
Let me note that we have not had a giant impact like the dinosaur killer
133
375932
4386
06:20
for 65 million years.
134
380342
1287
06:21
They're very rare.
135
381653
1337
06:23
The smaller ones happen more often,
136
383014
2119
06:25
but probably on the order of a millennium,
137
385157
2527
06:27
every few centuries or every few thousand years.
138
387708
3376
06:31
But it's still something to be aware of.
139
391108
2052
06:33
Well, what do we do about them?
140
393184
1540
06:34
The first thing we have to do is find them.
141
394748
2107
06:36
This is an image of an asteroid that passed us in 2009.
142
396879
4242
06:41
It's right here.
143
401145
1797
06:42
But you can see that it's extremely faint.
144
402966
2471
06:45
I don't know if you can see that in the back row.
145
405461
2333
06:47
These are just stars.
146
407818
1415
06:49
This is a rock that was about 30 yards across,
147
409257
2233
06:51
so roughly the size of the ones that blew up over Tunguska
148
411514
2879
06:54
and hit Arizona 50,000 years ago.
149
414417
2226
06:56
These things are faint.
150
416667
1162
06:57
They're hard to see, and the sky is really big.
151
417853
2426
07:00
We have to find these things first.
152
420303
1920
07:02
Well, the good news is, we're looking for them.
153
422247
2279
07:04
NASA has devoted money to this;
154
424550
2293
07:06
the National Science Foundation and other countries
155
426867
2401
07:09
are interested in doing this.
156
429292
1415
07:10
We're building telescopes that are looking for the threat.
157
430731
2753
07:13
That's a great first step. But what's the second step?
158
433508
2566
07:16
The second step is if we see one heading toward us, we have to stop it.
159
436098
3448
07:19
What do we do?
160
439570
1151
07:20
You've probably heard about the asteroid Apophis.
161
440745
2352
07:23
If you haven't yet, you will.
162
443121
2140
07:25
If you've heard about the Mayan 2012 apocalypse,
163
445285
2665
07:27
you're going to hear about Apophis,
164
447974
1692
07:29
because you're keyed in to all the doomsday networks, anyway.
165
449690
3293
07:33
(Laughter)
166
453007
1708
07:34
Apophis is an asteroid that was discovered in 2004.
167
454739
3022
07:37
It's roughly 250 [meters] across, so it's pretty big --
168
457785
3732
07:41
bigger than a football stadium.
169
461541
2309
07:43
And it's going to pass by the Earth in April of 2029.
170
463874
3496
07:47
And it's going to pass us so close
171
467394
1721
07:49
that it's actually going to come underneath our weather satellites.
172
469139
3715
07:52
The Earth's gravity is going to bend the orbit of this thing so much
173
472878
3699
07:56
that if it's just right,
174
476601
1402
07:58
if it passes through this region of space,
175
478027
2461
08:00
this kidney-bean-shaped region called the keyhole,
176
480512
3457
08:03
the Earth's gravity will bend it just enough that seven years later,
177
483993
3500
08:07
on April 13 -- which is a Friday, I'll note -- in the year 2036 --
178
487517
3997
08:11
(Laughter)
179
491538
1023
08:12
you can't plan that kind of stuff --
180
492585
1740
08:14
(Laughter)
181
494349
1062
08:15
Apophis is going to hit us.
182
495435
1478
08:16
And it's 250 meters across, so it would do unbelievable damage.
183
496937
4359
08:21
The good news is that the odds of it actually passing through this keyhole
184
501320
3597
08:24
and hitting us next go-around are one in a million, roughly --
185
504941
2971
08:27
very, very low odds.
186
507936
1151
08:29
So I personally am not lying awake at night worrying about this at all.
187
509111
3406
08:32
I don't think Apophis is a problem.
188
512541
1694
08:34
In fact, Apophis is a blessing in disguise,
189
514259
2268
08:36
because it woke us up to the dangers of these things.
190
516551
2585
08:39
This thing was discovered just a few years ago
191
519160
2177
08:41
and could hit us a few years from now.
192
521361
1843
08:43
It won't, but it gives us a chance to study these kinds of asteroids.
193
523228
3614
08:46
We didn't really necessarily understand these keyholes, and now we do,
194
526866
3506
08:50
and it turns out that's really important,
195
530396
2144
08:52
because how do you stop an asteroid like this?
196
532564
2478
08:55
Well, let me ask you:
197
535066
1522
08:56
What happens if you're standing in the road and a car's headed for you?
198
536612
3422
09:00
What do you do?
199
540058
1170
09:01
You do this. Right? Move, and the car goes past you.
200
541252
2454
09:03
But we can't move the Earth, at least not easily,
201
543730
2320
09:06
but we can move a small asteroid.
202
546074
1714
09:07
And it turns out, we've even done it.
203
547812
2195
09:10
In the year 2005, NASA launched a probe called Deep Impact,
204
550031
3961
09:14
which slammed a piece of itself into the nucleus of a comet.
205
554016
4461
09:18
Comets are very much like asteroids.
206
558501
1869
09:20
The purpose wasn't to push it out of the way;
207
560394
2119
09:22
the purpose was to make a crater to excavate the material
208
562537
3135
09:25
and see what was underneath the surface of this comet,
209
565696
2555
09:28
which we learned quite a bit about.
210
568275
1696
09:29
We did move the comet a little tiny bit --
211
569995
2279
09:32
not very much, but that wasn't the point.
212
572298
1977
09:34
However, think about this:
213
574299
1837
09:36
This thing is orbiting the Sun at 10, 20 miles per second.
214
576160
4352
09:40
We shot a space probe at it and hit it, OK?
215
580536
2699
09:43
Imagine how hard that must be, and we did it.
216
583259
2631
09:45
That means we can do it again.
217
585914
1803
09:47
If we see an asteroid that's coming toward us, headed right for us,
218
587741
4139
09:51
and we have two years to go?
219
591904
1682
09:53
Boom! We hit it.
220
593610
1346
09:54
You know, if you watch the movies --
221
594980
2523
09:57
(Laughter)
222
597527
1058
09:58
you might think:
223
598609
1152
09:59
Why don't we use a nuclear weapon?
224
599785
1637
10:01
Well, you can try that, but the problem is timing.
225
601446
2353
10:03
Shoot a nuclear weapon at this thing,
226
603823
1790
10:05
you have to blow it up within a few milliseconds of tolerance,
227
605637
2932
10:08
or else you'll miss it.
228
608593
1176
10:09
And there are a lot of other problems with that; it's very hard to do.
229
609793
3301
10:13
But just hitting something? That's pretty easy.
230
613118
2203
10:15
I think even NASA can do that, and proved that they can.
231
615345
2638
10:18
(Laughter)
232
618007
1009
10:19
The problem is, if you hit this asteroid, you've changed the orbit,
233
619040
3429
10:22
you measure the orbit,
234
622493
1152
10:23
then you find out, oh yeah, we just pushed it into a keyhole,
235
623669
2927
10:26
and now it's going to hit us in three years.
236
626620
2077
10:28
Well, my opinion is: fine!
237
628721
2128
10:30
It's not hitting us in six months --
238
630873
1869
10:32
that's good.
239
632766
1162
10:33
Now we have three years to do something else.
240
633952
2768
10:36
And you can hit it again.
241
636744
1368
10:38
That's kind of ham-fisted;
242
638136
1310
10:39
you might just push it into a third keyhole or whatever,
243
639470
2669
10:42
so you don't do that.
244
642163
1173
10:43
And this is the part --
245
643360
1171
10:45
it's the part I just love.
246
645026
1300
10:46
(Laughter)
247
646350
2615
10:48
After the big macho "Grr ... bam! We're gonna hit this thing in the face,"
248
648989
4458
10:53
then we bring in the velvet gloves.
249
653471
2798
10:56
(Laughter)
250
656293
1843
10:58
There's a group of scientists and engineers and astronauts,
251
658160
2889
11:01
and they call themselves The B612 Foundation.
252
661073
2433
11:03
For those of you who've read "The Little Prince,"
253
663530
2346
11:05
you understand that reference, I hope --
254
665900
1968
11:07
the little prince lived on an asteroid called B612.
255
667892
2455
11:10
These are smart guys -- men and women -- astronauts, like I said, engineers.
256
670371
3712
11:14
Rusty Schweickart, who was an Apollo 9 astronaut, is on this.
257
674107
3260
11:17
Dan Durda, my friend who made this image,
258
677391
2119
11:19
works here at Southwest Research Institute in Boulder, on Walnut Street.
259
679534
3907
11:23
He created this image for this.
260
683465
1535
11:25
He's actually one of the astronomers who works for them.
261
685024
2654
11:27
If we see an asteroid that's going to hit the Earth
262
687702
2603
11:30
and we have enough time,
263
690329
1713
11:32
we can hit it to move it into a better orbit.
264
692066
2355
11:34
But then what we do is launch a probe that has to weigh a ton or two.
265
694445
4801
11:39
It doesn't have to be huge -- a couple of tons, not that big --
266
699270
2986
11:42
and you park it near the asteroid.
267
702280
1713
11:44
You don't land on it, because these things are tumbling end over end.
268
704017
3331
11:47
It's very hard to land on them.
269
707372
1596
11:48
Instead you get near it.
270
708992
1162
11:50
The gravity of the asteroid pulls on the probe,
271
710178
2224
11:52
and the probe has a couple of tons of mass.
272
712426
2024
11:54
It has a little tiny bit of gravity,
273
714474
1733
11:56
but it's enough that it can pull the asteroid,
274
716231
3229
11:59
and you have your rocket set up --
275
719484
1625
12:01
you can barely see it here, but there's rocket plumes --
276
721133
2869
12:04
and these guys are connected by their own gravity,
277
724026
3374
12:07
and if you move the probe very slowly -- very, very gently,
278
727424
3548
12:10
you can very easily finesse that rock into a safe orbit.
279
730996
5023
12:16
You can even put in orbit around the Earth where we could mine it,
280
736043
3125
12:19
although that's a whole other thing; I won't go into that.
281
739192
2794
12:22
(Laughter)
282
742010
1027
12:23
But we'd be rich!
283
743061
1752
12:24
(Laughter)
284
744837
5434
12:30
So think about this, right?
285
750295
2024
12:33
There are these giant rocks flying out there, and they're hitting us,
286
753005
3288
12:36
and they're doing damage to us.
287
756317
1522
12:37
But we've figured out how to do this,
288
757863
1809
12:39
and all the pieces are in place to do this.
289
759696
2217
12:41
We have astronomers with telescopes, looking for them.
290
761937
3201
12:45
We have very, very smart people,
291
765162
2271
12:47
who are concerned about this and figuring out how to fix the problem,
292
767457
3392
12:50
and we have the technology to do this.
293
770873
1832
12:52
This probe actually can't use chemical rockets.
294
772729
2202
12:54
Chemical rockets provide too much thrust, too much push.
295
774955
2658
12:57
The probe would just shoot away.
296
777637
1562
12:59
We invented something called an ion drive,
297
779223
2051
13:01
which is a very, very, very low-thrust engine.
298
781298
2554
13:03
It generates the force a piece of paper would have on your hand --
299
783876
3309
13:07
incredibly light, but it can run for months and years,
300
787209
3964
13:11
providing that very gentle push.
301
791197
2330
13:13
If anybody here is a fan of the original "Star Trek,"
302
793551
2589
13:16
they ran across an alien ship that had an ion drive,
303
796164
2795
13:18
and Spock said, "They're very technically sophisticated.
304
798983
2692
13:21
They're a hundred years ahead of us with this drive."
305
801699
2501
13:24
Yeah, we have an ion drive now.
306
804224
1546
13:25
We don't have the Enterprise, but we've got an ion drive now.
307
805794
2982
13:28
(Laughter)
308
808800
1946
13:30
(Applause)
309
810770
2116
13:32
Spock.
310
812910
1226
13:34
(Laughter)
311
814160
2132
13:36
So ...
312
816316
1197
13:39
That's the difference --
313
819048
1644
13:40
that's the difference between us and the dinosaurs.
314
820716
2937
13:43
This happened to them.
315
823677
1442
13:45
It doesn't have to happen to us.
316
825898
1815
13:47
The difference between the dinosaurs and us
317
827737
3158
13:50
is that we have a space program
318
830919
2115
13:53
and we can vote,
319
833058
1722
13:54
and so we can change our future.
320
834804
2332
13:57
(Laughter)
321
837160
1637
13:58
We have the ability to change our future.
322
838821
2092
14:00
Sixty-five million years from now,
323
840937
1977
14:02
we don't have to have our bones collecting dust in a museum.
324
842938
3904
14:06
Thank you very much.
325
846866
1168
14:08
(Applause)
326
848058
3006
About this website

This site will introduce you to YouTube videos that are useful for learning English. You will see English lessons taught by top-notch teachers from around the world. Double-click on the English subtitles displayed on each video page to play the video from there. The subtitles scroll in sync with the video playback. If you have any comments or requests, please contact us using this contact form.

https://forms.gle/WvT1wiN1qDtmnspy7