A civil response to violence (with English subtitles) | Emiliano Salinas

74,173 views ・ 2011-06-24

TED


Please double-click on the English subtitles below to play the video.

00:00
Translator: Carolina Montero Reviewer: Sebastian Betti
0
0
7000
00:15
My name is Emiliano Salinas
1
15960
1500
00:17
and I'm going to talk about the role
2
17460
4200
00:21
we members of society play
3
21660
2100
00:23
in the violent atmosphere
4
23760
1300
00:25
this country is living in right now.
5
25060
3330
00:28
I was born in 1976.
6
28400
3060
00:31
I grew up in a traditional Mexican family.
7
31460
3400
00:34
As a child, I had a pretty normal life:
8
34860
2000
00:36
I would go to school, play with my friends and cousins.
9
36860
4100
00:40
But then my father became President of Mexico
10
40960
2300
00:43
and my life changed.
11
43260
3500
00:46
What I'm about to say,
12
46760
2300
00:49
at least some of what I'm about to say,
13
49060
1500
00:50
will cause controversy.
14
50560
1800
00:52
Firstly, because I'm the one who's going to say it.
15
52360
3100
00:55
And secondly, because what I'm going to say is true,
16
55460
3000
00:58
and it will make a lot of people nervous
17
58460
2000
01:00
because it's something we don't want to hear.
18
60460
2650
01:03
But it's imperative that we listen
19
63110
2050
01:05
because it's undeniable and definitive.
20
65160
2358
01:07
It will also make members of
21
67518
1742
01:09
criminal organizations nervous
22
69260
1935
01:11
for the same reasons.
23
71195
1765
01:12
I'm going to talk about the role
24
72960
3200
01:16
we members of society play
25
76160
1838
01:17
in this phenomenon,
26
77998
1562
01:19
and about four different response levels
27
79560
1700
01:21
we citizens have against violence.
28
81260
4300
01:25
I know many will find it difficult to separate the fact
29
85560
2200
01:27
that I'm Carlos Salinas de Gortari's son
30
87760
1900
01:29
from the fact that I'm a citizen
31
89660
1800
01:31
concerned about the country's current situation.
32
91460
1800
01:33
Don't worry.
33
93260
1200
01:34
It's not necessary for understanding
34
94460
2000
01:36
the importance of what I'm going to say.
35
96460
3500
01:39
I think we have a problem in Mexico.
36
99960
1700
01:41
We have a big problem.
37
101660
1300
01:42
I think there's consensus on this.
38
102960
2000
01:44
No one argues --
39
104960
1000
01:45
we all agree there's a problem.
40
105960
1300
01:47
What we don't agree on
41
107260
1500
01:48
is what the problem actually is.
42
108760
3300
01:52
Is it the Zetas? The drug traffickers? The government?
43
112060
4700
01:56
Corruption? Poverty? Or is it something else?
44
116760
4200
02:00
I think none of these is the problem.
45
120960
2200
02:03
I don't mean they don't deserve attention.
46
123160
2300
02:05
But we won't be able to take care of any of those things
47
125460
2470
02:07
if we don't solve the real problem
48
127930
2130
02:10
we have in Mexico first.
49
130060
1500
02:11
The real problem we have is
50
131560
1390
02:12
most of us Mexicans, we believe we are victims
51
132950
3210
02:16
of our circumstances.
52
136160
1746
02:17
We are a country of victims.
53
137906
2354
02:20
Historically, we've always acted as victims
54
140260
2750
02:23
of something or somebody.
55
143010
1770
02:24
We were victims of the Spaniards.
56
144780
2280
02:27
Then we were victims of the French.
57
147060
2020
02:29
Then we were victims of Don Porfirio.
58
149080
2444
02:31
Then we were victims of the PRI.
59
151524
2152
02:33
Even of Salinas.
60
153676
1684
02:35
And of El Peje.
61
155360
2121
02:37
And now of the Zetas and the traffickers and the criminals and the kidnappers ...
62
157481
2986
02:40
Hold on! Wait a minute!
63
160467
2480
02:42
What if none of these things is the problem?
64
162947
3535
02:46
The problem is not the things we feel victims of.
65
166482
3303
02:49
The problem is that we play the role of victims.
66
169785
4200
02:53
We need to open our eyes and see that we are not victims.
67
173985
3775
02:57
If only we stopped feeling like victims,
68
177760
2200
02:59
if we stopped acting as victims,
69
179960
1300
03:01
our country would change so much!
70
181260
3222
03:04
I'm going to talk about how to go from a society
71
184495
3465
03:07
that acts as a victim of circumstances
72
187960
1699
03:09
to a responsible, involved society
73
189659
2901
03:12
that takes the future of its country in its own hands.
74
192560
3536
03:16
I'm going to talk about four different levels
75
196096
2464
03:18
of civil response against violence,
76
198560
2100
03:20
from weakest
77
200660
2300
03:22
to strongest.
78
202960
2300
03:25
The first level, the weakest level of civil response against violence,
79
205260
2500
03:27
is denial and apathy.
80
207760
2900
03:30
Today, much of Mexican society is in denial
81
210660
2600
03:33
of the situation we're going through.
82
213260
2000
03:36
We want to go on with our daily life
83
216260
2258
03:38
even though we are not living under normal circumstances.
84
218518
2542
03:41
Daily life in our country is,
85
221060
2700
03:43
to say the least,
86
223760
3229
03:46
under extraordinary, exceptional circumstances.
87
226989
1964
03:48
It's like someone who has a serious illness
88
228953
3807
03:52
and pretends it's the flu
89
232760
2000
03:54
and it will just go away.
90
234760
1970
03:56
We want to pretend that Mexico has the flu.
91
236730
3241
03:59
But it doesn't.
92
239971
2102
04:02
Mexico has cancer.
93
242073
2217
04:04
And if we don't do something about it,
94
244290
2170
04:06
the cancer will end up killing it.
95
246460
3154
04:09
We need to move Mexican society
96
249614
2446
04:12
from denial and apathy
97
252060
2000
04:14
to the next level of citizen response,
98
254060
2400
04:16
which is, effectively, recognition.
99
256460
3132
04:19
And that recognition will sow fear --
100
259592
3834
04:23
recognizing the seriousness of the situation.
101
263426
3159
04:26
But, fear is better than apathy
102
266585
3647
04:30
because fear makes us do something.
103
270232
3314
04:33
Many people in Mexico
104
273546
3243
04:36
are afraid today.
105
276789
1957
04:38
We're very afraid.
106
278746
1476
04:40
And we're acting out of that fear.
107
280222
2138
04:42
And let me tell you what the problem is
108
282360
1700
04:44
with acting out of fear --
109
284060
1700
04:45
and this is the second level of civil response:
110
285760
2500
04:48
fear.
111
288260
1600
04:49
Let's think about Mexican streets:
112
289860
2400
04:52
they're unsafe because of violence,
113
292260
3500
04:55
so people stay at home.
114
295760
2500
04:58
Does that make streets more or less safe?
115
298260
4200
05:02
Less safe!
116
302460
1000
05:03
So streets become more desolate and unsafe,
117
303460
1800
05:05
so we stay home more --
118
305260
1400
05:06
which makes streets even more desolate and unsafe,
119
306660
2400
05:09
and we stay home even more.
120
309060
1500
05:10
This vicious circle ends up with the whole population
121
310560
2700
05:13
stuck inside their houses, scared to death --
122
313260
2000
05:15
even more afraid than when we were out on the streets.
123
315260
2500
05:17
We need to confront this fear.
124
317760
2500
05:20
We need to move Mexican society,
125
320260
2400
05:22
the members of society who are at this level,
126
322660
2600
05:25
to the next level, which is action.
127
325260
2200
05:27
We need to face our fears and take back our streets,
128
327460
4000
05:31
our cities, our neighborhoods.
129
331460
2800
05:34
For many people, acting involves courage.
130
334260
6200
05:40
We go from fear to courage.
131
340460
2000
05:42
They say, "I can't take it anymore.
132
342460
2800
05:45
Let's do something about it."
133
345260
3000
05:48
Recently --
134
348260
2000
05:50
this is a sensitive figure --
135
350260
3000
05:53
35 public lynchings have been recorded
136
353260
3200
05:56
so far in 2010
137
356460
1600
05:58
in Mexico.
138
358060
4200
06:02
Usually it's one or two a year.
139
362260
3400
06:05
Now we're experiencing one every week.
140
365660
2600
06:08
This shows that society is desperate
141
368260
3000
06:11
and it's taking the law into its own hands.
142
371260
3500
06:14
Unfortunately, violent action --
143
374760
2500
06:17
though action is better than no action --
144
377260
3000
06:20
but taking part in it
145
380260
3000
06:23
only disguises violence.
146
383260
2500
06:25
If I'm violent with you
147
385760
2500
06:28
and you respond with violence,
148
388260
2000
06:30
you become part of the violence
149
390260
2000
06:32
and you just disguise my violence.
150
392260
4000
06:36
So civil action
151
396260
2200
06:38
is vital,
152
398460
1800
06:40
but it's also vital to take people
153
400260
2000
06:42
who are at the level of courage
154
402260
2200
06:44
and violent action
155
404460
1800
06:46
to the next level,
156
406260
2000
06:48
which is non-violent action.
157
408260
1600
06:49
It's pacific, coordinated civil action,
158
409860
2900
06:52
which doesn't mean passive action.
159
412760
2000
06:54
It means it's determined and effective,
160
414760
2800
06:57
but not violent.
161
417560
2500
07:00
There are examples of this kind of action in Mexico.
162
420060
2700
07:02
Two years ago, in Galena City, Chihuahua,
163
422760
4700
07:07
a member of the community was kidnapped,
164
427460
1800
07:09
Eric Le Barón.
165
429260
1700
07:10
His brothers, Benjamín and Julián,
166
430960
1600
07:12
got together with the rest of the community
167
432560
2000
07:14
to think of the best course of action:
168
434560
2400
07:16
to pay the ransom,
169
436960
2100
07:19
to take up arms and go after the kidnappers
170
439060
4500
07:23
or to ask the government for help.
171
443560
2300
07:25
In the end, Benjamín and Julián decided
172
445860
2400
07:28
the best thing they could do
173
448260
2000
07:30
was to organize the community and act together.
174
450260
2800
07:33
So what did they do?
175
453060
1700
07:34
They mobilized the whole community of Le Barón
176
454760
2300
07:37
to go to Chihuahua,
177
457060
2800
07:39
where they organized a sit-in
178
459860
2400
07:42
in the central park of the city.
179
462260
2300
07:44
They sent a message to the kidnappers:
180
464560
1900
07:46
"If you want your ransom come and get it.
181
466460
3000
07:49
We'll be waiting for you right here."
182
469460
2400
07:51
They stayed there.
183
471860
2000
07:53
Seven days later, Eric was set free
184
473860
2500
07:56
and was able to return home.
185
476360
2000
07:58
This is an example of what an organized society can do,
186
478360
3800
08:02
a society that acts.
187
482160
2600
08:04
Of course, criminals can respond.
188
484760
2200
08:06
And in this case, they did.
189
486960
2000
08:08
On July 7th, 2009,
190
488960
3300
08:12
Benjamín Le Barón was murdered.
191
492260
2500
08:14
But Julián Le Barón keeps working
192
494760
2700
08:17
and he has been mobilizing communities in Chihuahua
193
497460
2200
08:19
for over a year.
194
499660
2600
08:22
And for over a year he has known that a price has been put on his head.
195
502260
2700
08:24
But he keeps fighting.
196
504960
1800
08:26
He keeps organizing.
197
506760
1500
08:28
He keeps mobilizing.
198
508260
2000
08:30
These heroic acts are present all over the country.
199
510260
2600
08:32
With a thousand Juliáns working together,
200
512860
2400
08:35
Mexico would be a very different country.
201
515260
2000
08:37
And they're out there!
202
517260
1500
08:38
They just have to raise their hands.
203
518760
4500
08:43
I was born in Mexico, I grew up in Mexico
204
523260
6000
08:49
and along the way, I learned to love Mexico.
205
529260
5000
08:54
I think anyone who has stepped foot on this land --
206
534260
3200
08:57
not to mention all Mexican people --
207
537460
2000
08:59
will agree that it's not difficult
208
539460
2800
09:02
to love Mexico.
209
542260
3000
09:05
I've traveled a lot
210
545260
2500
09:07
and nowhere else have I found the passion Mexicans have.
211
547760
5500
09:13
That devotion we feel
212
553260
2000
09:15
for the national football team.
213
555260
2000
09:17
That devotion we show
214
557260
2000
09:19
in helping victims of disasters,
215
559260
2000
09:21
such as the earthquake in 1985
216
561260
2000
09:23
or this year's floods.
217
563260
2500
09:25
The passion with which we've been singing the national anthem
218
565760
5500
09:31
since we were kids.
219
571260
1500
09:32
When we thought Masiosare
220
572760
1500
09:34
was the strange enemy,
221
574260
3000
09:37
and we sang, with a childlike heart,
222
577260
2500
09:39
"a soldier in each son."
223
579760
5200
09:44
I think the biggest insult,
224
584960
2300
09:47
the worst way you can offend a Mexican
225
587260
2000
09:49
is to insult their mother.
226
589260
1800
09:51
A mother is the most sacred thing in life.
227
591060
4200
09:55
Mexico is our mother and today she cries out for her children.
228
595260
3000
09:58
We are going through the darkest moment
229
598260
3000
10:01
in our recent history.
230
601260
2000
10:03
Our mother, Mexico, is being violated before our very eyes.
231
603260
3700
10:06
What are we going to do?
232
606960
3000
10:09
Masiosare, the strange enemy, is here.
233
609960
2500
10:12
Where is the soldier in each son?
234
612460
4800
10:17
Mahatma Gandhi,
235
617260
2000
10:19
one of the greatest civil fighters of all time, said,
236
619260
3800
10:23
"Be the change you wish to see in the world."
237
623060
4000
10:27
Today in Mexico we're asking for Gandhis.
238
627060
3200
10:30
We need Gandhis.
239
630260
2500
10:32
We need men and women who love Mexico
240
632760
3000
10:35
and who are willing to take action.
241
635760
3000
10:38
This is a call for every true Mexican
242
638760
5000
10:43
to join this initiative.
243
643760
2000
10:45
This is a call
244
645760
1500
10:47
so that every single thing we love about Mexico --
245
647260
3000
10:50
the festivals, the markets,
246
650260
2000
10:52
the restaurants, the cantinas,
247
652260
2000
10:54
the tequila, the mariachis, the serenades,
248
654260
3000
10:57
the posadas, El Grito, the Day of the Dead,
249
657260
3800
11:01
San Miguel, the joy, the passion for life,
250
661060
3400
11:04
the fight and everything it means to be Mexican --
251
664460
4200
11:08
doesn't disappear from this world.
252
668660
4400
11:13
We're facing a very powerful opponent.
253
673060
3200
11:16
But we are many more.
254
676260
2500
11:18
They can take a man's life.
255
678760
2500
11:21
Anyone can kill me,
256
681260
2000
11:23
or you, or you.
257
683260
1500
11:24
But no one can kill
258
684760
2500
11:27
the spirit of true Mexicans.
259
687260
2500
11:29
The battle is won,
260
689760
2000
11:31
but we still have to fight it.
261
691760
2900
11:34
2000 years ago, the Roman poet Juvenal
262
694660
5600
11:40
said something that today echoes
263
700260
3000
11:43
in the heart of every true Mexican.
264
703260
3000
11:46
He said, "Count it the greatest sin
265
706260
4300
11:50
to prefer life to honor,
266
710560
5700
11:56
and for the sake of living
267
716260
4000
12:00
to lose what makes life worth living."
268
720260
3600
12:03
Thank you.
269
723860
1400
12:05
(Applause)
270
725260
3000
About this website

This site will introduce you to YouTube videos that are useful for learning English. You will see English lessons taught by top-notch teachers from around the world. Double-click on the English subtitles displayed on each video page to play the video from there. The subtitles scroll in sync with the video playback. If you have any comments or requests, please contact us using this contact form.

https://forms.gle/WvT1wiN1qDtmnspy7