Poverty isn't a lack of character; it's a lack of cash | Rutger Bregman

1,807,755 views ・ 2017-06-13

TED


Please double-click on the English subtitles below to play the video.

00:13
I'd like to start with a simple question:
0
13395
3107
00:17
Why do the poor make so many poor decisions?
1
17820
3840
00:23
I know it's a harsh question,
2
23672
1551
00:25
but take a look at the data.
3
25247
1965
00:27
The poor borrow more, save less,
4
27236
1843
00:29
smoke more, exercise less, drink more
5
29103
2659
00:31
and eat less healthfully.
6
31786
1520
00:34
Why?
7
34192
1161
00:36
Well, the standard explanation
8
36271
1527
00:37
was once summed up by the British Prime Minister, Margaret Thatcher.
9
37822
3380
00:41
And she called poverty "a personality defect."
10
41226
3385
00:44
(Laughter)
11
44635
1840
00:46
A lack of character, basically.
12
46499
1906
00:49
Now, I'm sure not many of you would be so blunt.
13
49285
3991
00:54
But the idea that there's something wrong with the poor themselves
14
54317
3850
00:58
is not restricted to Mrs. Thatcher.
15
58191
1983
01:01
Some of you may believe that the poor should be held responsible
16
61105
3203
01:04
for their own mistakes.
17
64332
1753
01:06
And others may argue that we should help them to make better decisions.
18
66109
3897
01:10
But the underlying assumption is the same:
19
70674
3229
01:14
there's something wrong with them.
20
74470
2574
01:17
If we could just change them,
21
77877
1858
01:19
if we could just teach them how to live their lives,
22
79759
2492
01:22
if they would only listen.
23
82275
1533
01:25
And to be honest,
24
85053
1697
01:26
this was what I thought for a long time.
25
86774
3338
01:30
It was only a few years ago that I discovered
26
90898
2114
01:33
that everything I thought I knew about poverty was wrong.
27
93036
3497
01:38
It all started when I accidentally stumbled upon a paper
28
98106
2651
01:40
by a few American psychologists.
29
100781
1608
01:42
They had traveled 8,000 miles, all the way to India,
30
102413
2553
01:44
for a fascinating study.
31
104990
1575
01:47
And it was an experiment with sugarcane farmers.
32
107065
2768
01:50
You should know that these farmers collect about 60 percent
33
110658
3348
01:54
of their annual income all at once,
34
114030
2133
01:56
right after the harvest.
35
116187
1708
01:57
This means that they're relatively poor one part of the year
36
117919
3540
02:01
and rich the other.
37
121483
1594
02:04
The researchers asked them to do an IQ test before and after the harvest.
38
124415
4056
02:09
What they subsequently discovered completely blew my mind.
39
129722
4020
02:14
The farmers scored much worse on the test before the harvest.
40
134979
4449
02:20
The effects of living in poverty, it turns out,
41
140277
2300
02:22
correspond to losing 14 points of IQ.
42
142601
3368
02:25
Now, to give you an idea,
43
145993
1869
02:27
that's comparable to losing a night's sleep
44
147886
2441
02:30
or the effects of alcoholism.
45
150351
2173
02:34
A few months later, I heard that Eldar Shafir,
46
154505
2259
02:36
a professor at Princeton University and one of the authors of this study,
47
156788
3547
02:40
was coming over to Holland, where I live.
48
160359
2319
02:42
So we met up in Amsterdam
49
162702
1402
02:44
to talk about his revolutionary new theory of poverty.
50
164128
3551
02:48
And I can sum it up in just two words:
51
168210
2103
02:51
scarcity mentality.
52
171235
2017
02:54
It turns out that people behave differently
53
174467
2154
02:56
when they perceive a thing to be scarce.
54
176645
2486
02:59
And what that thing is doesn't much matter --
55
179155
2215
03:01
whether it's not enough time, money or food.
56
181394
3013
03:04
You all know this feeling,
57
184900
1658
03:06
when you've got too much to do,
58
186582
1963
03:08
or when you've put off breaking for lunch
59
188569
2016
03:10
and your blood sugar takes a dive.
60
190609
1663
03:12
This narrows your focus to your immediate lack --
61
192296
2828
03:15
to the sandwich you've got to have now,
62
195148
2010
03:17
the meeting that's starting in five minutes
63
197182
2262
03:19
or the bills that have to be paid tomorrow.
64
199468
2879
03:22
So the long-term perspective goes out the window.
65
202868
3216
03:27
You could compare it to a new computer
66
207655
2531
03:30
that's running 10 heavy programs at once.
67
210210
2187
03:33
It gets slower and slower, making errors.
68
213021
2773
03:35
Eventually, it freezes --
69
215818
1822
03:37
not because it's a bad computer,
70
217664
2106
03:39
but because it has too much to do at once.
71
219794
2620
03:43
The poor have the same problem.
72
223279
2868
03:46
They're not making dumb decisions because they are dumb,
73
226654
2790
03:49
but because they're living in a context
74
229468
1922
03:51
in which anyone would make dumb decisions.
75
231414
2344
03:54
So suddenly I understood
76
234362
2948
03:57
why so many of our anti-poverty programs don't work.
77
237334
3966
04:02
Investments in education, for example, are often completely ineffective.
78
242467
4524
04:07
Poverty is not a lack of knowledge.
79
247015
2812
04:10
A recent analysis of 201 studies
80
250580
2555
04:13
on the effectiveness of money-management training
81
253159
2312
04:15
came to the conclusion that it has almost no effect at all.
82
255495
3749
04:19
Now, don't get me wrong --
83
259268
1445
04:20
this is not to say the poor don't learn anything --
84
260737
2496
04:23
they can come out wiser for sure.
85
263257
1905
04:25
But it's not enough.
86
265832
1638
04:27
Or as Professor Shafir told me,
87
267494
3002
04:30
"It's like teaching someone to swim
88
270520
1984
04:32
and then throwing them in a stormy sea."
89
272528
3026
04:36
I still remember sitting there,
90
276508
1595
04:39
perplexed.
91
279023
1255
04:41
And it struck me
92
281111
1157
04:42
that we could have figured this all out decades ago.
93
282292
2513
04:44
I mean, these psychologists didn't need any complicated brain scans;
94
284829
3251
04:48
they only had to measure the farmer's IQ,
95
288104
2009
04:50
and IQ tests were invented more than 100 years ago.
96
290137
2508
04:53
Actually, I realized I had read about the psychology of poverty before.
97
293039
3709
04:57
George Orwell, one of the greatest writers who ever lived,
98
297367
3674
05:01
experienced poverty firsthand in the 1920s.
99
301065
2903
05:04
"The essence of poverty," he wrote back then,
100
304676
2178
05:06
is that it "annihilates the future."
101
306878
2934
05:10
And he marveled at, quote,
102
310967
2187
05:13
"How people take it for granted they have the right to preach at you
103
313746
3286
05:17
and pray over you
104
317056
1151
05:18
as soon as your income falls below a certain level."
105
318231
2472
05:20
Now, those words are every bit as resonant today.
106
320727
3905
05:26
The big question is, of course:
107
326965
1981
05:28
What can be done?
108
328970
1340
05:30
Modern economists have a few solutions up their sleeves.
109
330334
2795
05:33
We could help the poor with their paperwork
110
333153
2059
05:35
or send them a text message to remind them to pay their bills.
111
335236
2982
05:38
This type of solution is hugely popular with modern politicians,
112
338242
4707
05:42
mostly because,
113
342973
1703
05:44
well, they cost next to nothing.
114
344700
2060
05:47
These solutions are, I think, a symbol of this era
115
347955
4010
05:51
in which we so often treat the symptoms,
116
351989
2177
05:54
but ignore the underlying cause.
117
354190
1843
05:57
So I wonder:
118
357494
1254
05:59
Why don't we just change the context in which the poor live?
119
359606
3347
06:03
Or, going back to our computer analogy:
120
363545
2125
06:05
Why keep tinkering around with the software
121
365694
2137
06:07
when we can easily solve the problem by installing some extra memory instead?
122
367855
4065
06:11
At that point, Professor Shafir responded with a blank look.
123
371944
3398
06:16
And after a few seconds, he said,
124
376112
1637
06:18
"Oh, I get it.
125
378742
2125
06:21
You mean you want to just hand out more money to the poor
126
381480
3731
06:25
to eradicate poverty.
127
385964
1851
06:27
Uh, sure, that'd be great.
128
387839
2801
06:31
But I'm afraid that brand of left-wing politics
129
391734
2301
06:34
you've got in Amsterdam --
130
394059
1844
06:35
it doesn't exist in the States."
131
395927
1663
06:38
But is this really an old-fashioned, leftist idea?
132
398342
3975
06:43
I remembered reading about an old plan --
133
403214
1987
06:45
something that has been proposed by some of history's leading thinkers.
134
405225
3484
06:48
The philosopher Thomas More first hinted at it in his book, "Utopia,"
135
408733
3816
06:52
more than 500 years ago.
136
412573
1899
06:55
And its proponents have spanned the spectrum from the left to the right,
137
415025
3550
06:58
from the civil rights campaigner, Martin Luther King,
138
418599
2770
07:01
to the economist Milton Friedman.
139
421393
2751
07:05
And it's an incredibly simple idea:
140
425093
2820
07:09
basic income guarantee.
141
429063
2635
07:13
What it is?
142
433285
1158
07:14
Well, that's easy.
143
434824
1162
07:16
It's a monthly grant, enough to pay for your basic needs:
144
436547
2731
07:19
food, shelter, education.
145
439302
1678
07:21
It's completely unconditional,
146
441503
1821
07:23
so no one's going to tell you what you have to do for it,
147
443348
2760
07:26
and no one's going to tell you what you have to do with it.
148
446132
2818
07:28
The basic income is not a favor, but a right.
149
448974
2290
07:31
There's absolutely no stigma attached.
150
451288
2133
07:34
So as I learned about the true nature of poverty,
151
454192
2630
07:36
I couldn't stop wondering:
152
456846
1490
07:39
Is this the idea we've all been waiting for?
153
459028
2840
07:42
Could it really be that simple?
154
462518
2181
07:46
And in the three years that followed,
155
466168
1800
07:47
I read everything I could find about basic income.
156
467992
2538
07:50
I researched the dozens of experiments
157
470554
1937
07:52
that have been conducted all over the globe,
158
472515
2121
07:54
and it didn't take long before I stumbled upon a story of a town
159
474660
3068
07:57
that had done it -- had actually eradicated poverty.
160
477752
2472
08:00
But then ...
161
480248
1270
08:02
nearly everyone forgot about it.
162
482298
1570
08:05
This story starts in Dauphin, Canada.
163
485406
2529
08:08
In 1974, everybody in this small town was guaranteed a basic income,
164
488871
5580
08:14
ensuring that no one fell below the poverty line.
165
494475
2735
08:17
At the start of the experiment,
166
497234
1596
08:18
an army of researchers descended on the town.
167
498854
3473
08:23
For four years, all went well.
168
503187
2531
08:26
But then a new government was voted into power,
169
506331
3432
08:29
and the new Canadian cabinet saw little point to the expensive experiment.
170
509787
3510
08:33
So when it became clear there was no money left to analyze the results,
171
513321
4253
08:37
the researchers decided to pack their files away in some 2,000 boxes.
172
517598
4802
08:43
Twenty-five years went by,
173
523995
2790
08:46
and then Evelyn Forget, a Canadian professor,
174
526809
2688
08:49
found the records.
175
529521
1216
08:50
For three years, she subjected the data to all manner of statistical analysis,
176
530761
3967
08:54
and no matter what she tried,
177
534752
1586
08:56
the results were the same every time:
178
536362
2736
08:59
the experiment had been a resounding success.
179
539788
3818
09:05
Evelyn Forget discovered
180
545131
1160
09:06
that the people in Dauphin had not only become richer
181
546315
2584
09:08
but also smarter and healthier.
182
548923
1531
09:10
The school performance of kids improved substantially.
183
550478
3506
09:14
The hospitalization rate decreased by as much as 8.5 percent.
184
554976
4228
09:19
Domestic violence incidents were down,
185
559942
1810
09:21
as were mental health complaints.
186
561776
1791
09:23
And people didn't quit their jobs.
187
563973
2056
09:26
The only ones who worked a little less were new mothers and students --
188
566329
3734
09:30
who stayed in school longer.
189
570087
1445
09:32
Similar results have since been found
190
572708
1875
09:34
in countless other experiments around the globe,
191
574607
2396
09:37
from the US to India.
192
577027
2247
09:41
So ...
193
581433
1220
09:43
here's what I've learned.
194
583500
1334
09:45
When it comes to poverty,
195
585815
2156
09:47
we, the rich, should stop pretending we know best.
196
587995
5116
09:54
We should stop sending shoes and teddy bears to the poor,
197
594031
2754
09:56
to people we have never met.
198
596809
1521
09:58
And we should get rid of the vast industry of paternalistic bureaucrats
199
598354
3533
10:01
when we could simply hand over their salaries
200
601911
2181
10:04
to the poor they're supposed to help.
201
604116
1806
10:05
(Applause)
202
605946
2296
10:08
Because, I mean, the great thing about money
203
608266
2873
10:11
is that people can use it to buy things they need
204
611163
2351
10:13
instead of things that self-appointed experts think they need.
205
613538
3153
10:17
Just imagine how many brilliant scientists and entrepreneurs and writers,
206
617702
4404
10:22
like George Orwell,
207
622130
1151
10:23
are now withering away in scarcity.
208
623305
2790
10:26
Imagine how much energy and talent we would unleash
209
626119
2456
10:28
if we got rid of poverty once and for all.
210
628599
2739
10:31
I believe that a basic income would work like venture capital for the people.
211
631362
4352
10:36
And we can't afford not to do it,
212
636913
2044
10:38
because poverty is hugely expensive.
213
638981
2845
10:42
Just look at the cost of child poverty in the US, for example.
214
642366
3392
10:45
It's estimated at 500 billion dollars each year,
215
645782
4232
10:50
in terms of higher health care spending, higher dropout rates,
216
650038
2948
10:53
and more crime.
217
653010
1383
10:54
Now, this is an incredible waste of human potential.
218
654417
3880
11:00
But let's talk about the elephant in the room.
219
660185
2201
11:03
How could we ever afford a basic income guarantee?
220
663146
3012
11:06
Well, it's actually a lot cheaper than you may think.
221
666872
3099
11:09
What they did in Dauphin is finance it with a negative income tax.
222
669995
3564
11:13
This means that your income is topped up
223
673583
2008
11:15
as soon as you fall below the poverty line.
224
675615
2412
11:18
And in that scenario,
225
678051
1362
11:19
according to our economists' best estimates,
226
679437
2514
11:21
for a net cost of 175 billion --
227
681975
3025
11:25
a quarter of US military spending, one percent of GDP --
228
685024
4907
11:29
you could lift all impoverished Americans above the poverty line.
229
689955
3554
11:34
You could actually eradicate poverty.
230
694386
3141
11:37
Now, that should be our goal.
231
697962
1802
11:40
(Applause)
232
700536
1084
11:41
The time for small thoughts and little nudges is past.
233
701644
2932
11:44
I really believe that the time has come for radical new ideas,
234
704600
3308
11:47
and basic income is so much more than just another policy.
235
707932
3200
11:51
It is also a complete rethink of what work actually is.
236
711156
4638
11:55
And in that sense,
237
715818
1670
11:57
it will not only free the poor,
238
717512
1792
12:00
but also the rest of us.
239
720352
1468
12:03
Nowadays, millions of people feel
240
723081
2246
12:05
that their jobs have little meaning or significance.
241
725351
2506
12:07
A recent poll among 230,000 employees
242
727881
2817
12:10
in 142 countries
243
730722
1906
12:12
found that only 13 percent of workers actually like their job.
244
732652
4665
12:18
And another poll found that as much as 37 percent of British workers
245
738420
3667
12:22
have a job that they think doesn't even need to exist.
246
742111
2930
12:26
It's like Brad Pitt says in "Fight Club,"
247
746207
2294
12:28
"Too often we're working jobs we hate so we can buy shit we don't need."
248
748525
3656
12:32
(Laughter)
249
752205
1478
12:33
Now, don't get me wrong --
250
753707
1397
12:35
I'm not talking about the teachers and the garbagemen
251
755128
2554
12:37
and the care workers here.
252
757706
1482
12:39
If they stopped working,
253
759212
1614
12:40
we'd be in trouble.
254
760850
1317
12:42
I'm talking about all those well-paid professionals with excellent résumés
255
762810
3625
12:46
who earn their money doing ...
256
766459
1805
12:48
strategic transactor peer-to-peer meetings
257
768288
2036
12:50
while brainstorming the value add-on of disruptive co-creation
258
770348
3032
12:53
in the network society.
259
773404
1173
12:54
(Laughter)
260
774601
1023
12:55
(Applause)
261
775648
1018
12:56
Or something like that.
262
776690
1202
12:57
Just imagine again how much talent we're wasting,
263
777916
2924
13:00
simply because we tell our kids they'll have to "earn a living."
264
780864
3840
13:05
Or think of what a math whiz working at Facebook lamented a few years ago:
265
785458
3742
13:09
"The best minds of my generation
266
789224
1862
13:11
are thinking about how to make people click ads."
267
791110
3113
13:16
I'm a historian.
268
796519
1245
13:18
And if history teaches us anything,
269
798812
2069
13:20
it is that things could be different.
270
800905
2792
13:23
There is nothing inevitable
271
803721
1391
13:25
about the way we structured our society and economy right now.
272
805136
2957
13:28
Ideas can and do change the world.
273
808117
2356
13:30
And I think that especially in the past few years,
274
810497
2511
13:33
it has become abundantly clear
275
813032
1429
13:34
that we cannot stick to the status quo --
276
814485
1953
13:36
that we need new ideas.
277
816462
1575
13:40
I know that many of you may feel pessimistic
278
820319
3213
13:43
about a future of rising inequality,
279
823556
2063
13:45
xenophobia
280
825643
1277
13:46
and climate change.
281
826944
1196
13:48
But it's not enough to know what we're against.
282
828806
2218
13:51
We also need to be for something.
283
831048
1612
13:52
Martin Luther King didn't say, "I have a nightmare."
284
832684
2534
13:55
(Laughter)
285
835242
1873
13:57
He had a dream.
286
837139
1159
13:58
(Applause)
287
838322
1079
13:59
So ...
288
839425
1152
14:01
here's my dream:
289
841655
1225
14:04
I believe in a future
290
844123
1638
14:05
where the value of your work is not determined
291
845785
2353
14:08
by the size of your paycheck,
292
848162
1477
14:09
but by the amount of happiness you spread
293
849663
2032
14:11
and the amount of meaning you give.
294
851719
1977
14:13
I believe in a future
295
853720
1232
14:14
where the point of education is not to prepare you for another useless job
296
854976
3660
14:18
but for a life well-lived.
297
858660
1610
14:21
I believe in a future
298
861024
1279
14:22
where an existence without poverty is not a privilege
299
862327
3094
14:25
but a right we all deserve.
300
865445
2013
14:27
So here we are.
301
867482
1465
14:28
Here we are.
302
868971
1151
14:30
We've got the research, we've got the evidence
303
870146
2190
14:32
and we've got the means.
304
872360
1163
14:33
Now, more than 500 years after Thomas More first wrote about a basic income,
305
873547
3909
14:37
and 100 years after George Orwell discovered the true nature of poverty,
306
877480
4055
14:41
we all need to change our worldview,
307
881559
2441
14:44
because poverty is not a lack of character.
308
884024
2989
14:47
Poverty is a lack of cash.
309
887652
2568
14:51
Thank you.
310
891141
1184
14:52
(Applause)
311
892349
4423
About this website

This site will introduce you to YouTube videos that are useful for learning English. You will see English lessons taught by top-notch teachers from around the world. Double-click on the English subtitles displayed on each video page to play the video from there. The subtitles scroll in sync with the video playback. If you have any comments or requests, please contact us using this contact form.

https://forms.gle/WvT1wiN1qDtmnspy7