Kathryn Schulz: Don't regret regret

So that's Johnny Depp, of course.

And that's Johnny Depp's shoulder.

And that's Johnny Depp's famous shoulder tattoo.

Some of you might know that, in 1990,

Depp got engaged to Winona Ryder,

and he had tattooed on his right shoulder

"Winona forever."

And then three years later --

which in fairness, kind of is forever by Hollywood standards --

they broke up,

and Johnny went and got a little bit of repair work done.

And now his shoulder says, "Wino forever."

(Laughter)

So like Johnny Depp,

and like 25 percent of Americans

between the ages of 16 and 50,

I have a tattoo.

I first started thinking about getting it in my mid-20s,

but I deliberately waited a really long time.

Because we all know people

who have gotten tattoos when they were 17

or 19 or 23

and regretted it by the time they were 30.

That didn't happen to me.

I got my tattoo when I was 29,

and I regretted it instantly.

And by "regretted it,"

I mean that I stepped outside of the tattoo place --

this is just a couple miles from here

down on the Lower East Side --

and I had a massive emotional meltdown in broad daylight

on the corner of East Broadway and Canal Street.

(Laughter)

Which is a great place to do it because nobody cares.

(Laughter)

And then I went home that night, and I had an even larger emotional meltdown,

which I'll say more about in a minute.

And this was all actually quite shocking to me,

because prior to this moment,

I had prided myself

on having absolutely no regrets.

I made a lot of mistakes

and dumb decisions, of course.

I do that hourly.

But I had always felt like, look, you know,

I made the best choice I could make

given who I was then,

given the information I had on hand.

I learned a lesson from it.

It somehow got me to where I am in life right now.

And okay, I wouldn't change it.

In other words, I had drunk our great cultural Kool-Aid about regret,

which is that lamenting things that occurred in the past

is an absolute waste of time,

that we should always look forward and not backward,

and that one of the noblest and best things we can do

is strive to live a life free of regrets.

This idea is nicely captured by this quote:

"Things without all remedy

should be without regard;

what's done is done."

And it seems like kind of an admirable philosophy at first --

something we might all agree to sign onto ...

until I tell you who said it.

Right, so this is Lady MacBeth

basically telling her husband to stop being such a wuss

for feeling bad about murdering people.

And as it happens, Shakespeare was onto something here,

as he generally was.

Because the inability to experience regret

is actually one of the diagnostic characteristics

of sociopaths.

It's also, by the way, a characteristic of certain kinds of brain damage.

So people who have damage

to their orbital frontal cortex

seem to be unable to feel regret

in the face of even obviously very poor decisions.

So if, in fact, you want to live a life free of regret,

there is an option open to you.

It's called a lobotomy.

But if you want to be fully functional

and fully human

and fully humane,

I think you need to learn to live, not without regret, but with it.

So let's start off by defining some terms.

What is regret?

Regret is the emotion we experience

when we think that our present situation

could be better or happier

if we had done something different in the past.

So in other words, regret requires two things.

It requires, first of all, agency -- we had to make a decision in the first place.

And second of all, it requires imagination.

We need to be able to imagine going back and making a different choice,

and then we need to be able to kind of spool this imaginary record forward

and imagine how things would be playing out in our present.

And in fact, the more we have of either of these things --

the more agency and the more imagination

with respect to a given regret,

the more acute that regret will be.

So let's say for instance

that you're on your way to your best friend's wedding

and you're trying to get to the airport and you're stuck in terrible traffic,

and you finally arrive at your gate

and you've missed your flight.

You're going to experience more regret in that situation

if you missed your flight by three minutes

than if you missed it by 20.

Why?

Well because, if you miss your flight by three minutes,

it is painfully easy to imagine

that you could have made different decisions

that would have led to a better outcome.

"I should have taken the bridge and not the tunnel.

I should have gone through that yellow light."

These are the classic conditions that create regret.

We feel regret when we think we are responsible

for a decision that came out badly,

but almost came out well.

Now within that framework,

we can obviously experience regret about a lot of different things.

This session today is about behavioral economics.

And most of what we know about regret

comes to us out of that domain.

We have a vast body of literature

on consumer and financial decisions

and the regrets associated with them --

buyer's remorse, basically.

But then finally, it occurred to some researchers to step back

and say, well okay, but overall,

what do we regret most in life?

Here's what the answers turn out to look like.

So top six regrets --

the things we regret most in life:

Number one by far, education.

33 percent of all of our regrets

pertain to decisions we made about education.

We wish we'd gotten more of it.

We wish we'd taken better advantage of the education that we did have.

We wish we'd chosen to study a different topic.

Others very high on our list of regrets

include career, romance, parenting,

various decisions and choices about our sense of self

and how we spend our leisure time --

or actually more specifically,

how we fail to spend our leisure time.

The remaining regrets

pertain to these things:

finance, family issues unrelated to romance or parenting,

health, friends,

spirituality and community.

So in other words, we know most of what we know about regret

by the study of finance.

But it turns out, when you look overall at what people regret in life,

you know what, our financial decisions don't even rank.

They account for less than three percent of our total regrets.

So if you're sitting there stressing

about large cap versus small cap,

or company A versus company B,

or should you buy the Subaru or the Prius,

you know what, let it go.

Odds are, you're not going to care in five years.

But for these things that we actually do really care about

and do experience profound regret around,

what does that experience feel like?

We all know the short answer.

It feels terrible. Regret feels awful.

But it turns out that regret feels awful

in four very specific and consistent ways.

So the first consistent component of regret

is basically denial.

When I went home that night after getting my tattoo,

I basically stayed up all night.

And for the first several hours,

there was exactly one thought in my head.

And the thought was,

"Make it go away!"

This is an unbelievably primitive emotional response.

I mean, it's right up there with, "I want my mommy!"

We're not trying to solve the problem.

We're not trying to understand how the problem came about.

We just want it to vanish.

The second characteristic component of regret

is a sense of bewilderment.

So the other thing I thought about there in my bedroom that night

was, "How could I have done that?

What was I thinking?"

This real sense of alienation

from the part of us that made a decision we regret.

We can't identify with that part.

We don't understand that part.

And we certainly don't have any empathy for that part --

which explains the third consistent component of regret,

which is an intense desire to punish ourselves.

That's why, in the face of our regret,

the thing we consistently say is, "I could have kicked myself."

The fourth component here

is that regret is what psychologists call perseverative.

To perseverate means to focus obsessively and repeatedly

on the exact same thing.

Now the effect of perseveration

is to basically take these first three components of regret

and put them on an infinite loop.

So it's not that I sat there in my bedroom that night,

thinking, "Make it go away."

It's that I sat there and I thought,

"Make it go away. Make it go away.

Make it go away. Make it go away."

So if you look at the psychological literature,

these are the four consistent defining components of regret.

But I want to suggest that there's also a fifth one.

And I think of this

as a kind of existential wake-up call.

That night in my apartment,

after I got done kicking myself and so forth,

I lay in bed for a long time,

and I thought about skin grafts.

And then I thought about how,

much as travel insurance doesn't cover acts of God,

probably my health insurance did not cover acts of idiocy.

In point of fact, no insurance covers acts of idiocy.

The whole point of acts of idiocy

is that they leave you totally uninsured;

they leave you exposed to the world

and exposed to your own vulnerability and fallibility

in face of, frankly, a fairly indifferent universe.

This is obviously an incredibly painful experience.

And I think it's particularly painful for us now in the West

in the grips of what I sometimes think of

as a Control-Z culture --

Control-Z like the computer command,

undo.

We're incredibly used to not having to face

life's hard realities, in a certain sense.

We think we can throw money at the problem

or throw technology at the problem --

we can undo and unfriend

and unfollow.

And the problem is that there are certain things that happen in life

that we desperately want to change

and we cannot.

Sometimes instead of Control-Z,

we actually have zero control.

And for those of us who are control freaks and perfectionists --

and I know where of I speak --

this is really hard,

because we want to do everything ourselves and we want to do it right.

Now there is a case to be made

that control freaks and perfectionists should not get tattoos,

and I'm going to return to that point in a few minutes.

But first I want to say

that the intensity and persistence

with which we experience these emotional components of regret

is obviously going to vary

depending on the specific thing that we're feeling regretful about.

So for instance, here's one of my favorite

automatic generators of regret in modern life.

(Laughter)

Text: Relpy to all.

And the amazing thing

about this really insidious technological innovation

is that even just with this one thing,

we can experience a huge range of regret.

You can accidentally hit "reply all" to an email

and torpedo a relationship.

Or you can just have an incredibly embarrassing day at work.

Or you can have your last day at work.

And this doesn't even touch

on the really profound regrets of a life.

Because of course, sometimes we do make decisions

that have irrevocable and terrible consequences,

either for our own or for other people's

health and happiness and livelihoods,

and in the very worst case scenario, even their lives.

Now obviously, those kinds of regrets

are incredibly piercing and enduring.

I mean, even the stupid "reply all" regrets

can leave us in a fit of excruciating agony for days.

So how are we supposed to live with this?

I want to suggest that there's three things

that help us to make our peace with regret.

And the first of these

is to take some comfort in its universality.

If you Google regret and tattoo,

you will get 11.5 million hits.

(Laughter)

The FDA estimates

that of all the Americans who have tattoos,

17 percent of us regret getting them.

That is Johnny Depp and me

and our seven million friends.

And that's just regret about tattoos.

We are all in this together.

The second way that we can help make our peace with regret

is to laugh at ourselves.

Now in my case, this really wasn't a problem,

because it's actually very easy to laugh at yourself

when you're 29 years old and you want your mommy

because you don't like your new tattoo.

But it might seem like a kind of cruel or glib suggestion

when it comes to these more profound regrets.

I don't think that's the case though.

All of us who've experienced regret

that contains real pain and real grief

understand that humor and even black humor

plays a crucial role in helping us survive.

It connects the poles of our lives back together,

the positive and the negative,

and it sends a little current of life back into us.

The third way that I think we can help make our peace with regret

is through the passage of time,

which, as we know, heals all wounds --

except for tattoos, which are permanent.

So it's been several years

since I got my own tattoo.

And do you guys just want to see it?

All right.

Actually, you know what, I should warn you,

you're going to be disappointed.

Because it's actually not that hideous.

I didn't tattoo Marilyn Manson's face

on some indiscreet part of myself or something.

When other people see my tattoo,

for the most part they like how it looks.

It's just that I don't like how it looks.

And as I said earlier, I'm a perfectionist.

But I'll let you see it anyway.

This is my tattoo.

I can guess what some of you are thinking.

So let me reassure you about something.

Some of your own regrets

are also not as ugly as you think they are.

I got this tattoo

because I spent most of my 20s

living outside the country and traveling.

And when I came and settled in New York afterward,

I was worried that I would forget

some of the most important lessons that I learned during that time.

Specifically the two things I learned about myself

that I most didn't want to forget

was how important it felt to keep exploring

and, simultaneously, how important it is

to somehow keep an eye on your own true north.

And what I loved about this image of the compass

was that I felt like it encapsulated both of these ideas

in one simple image.

And I thought it might serve as a kind of permanent mnemonic device.

Well it did.

But it turns out, it doesn't remind me of the thing I thought it would;

it reminds me constantly of something else instead.

It actually reminds me

of the most important lesson regret can teach us,

which is also one of the most important lessons life teaches us.

And ironically, I think it's probably the single most important thing

I possibly could have tattooed onto my body --

partly as a writer,

but also just as a human being.

Here's the thing,

if we have goals

and dreams,

and we want to do our best,

and if we love people

and we don't want to hurt them or lose them,

we should feel pain when things go wrong.

The point isn't to live without any regrets.

The point is to not hate ourselves for having them.

The lesson that I ultimately learned from my tattoo

and that I want to leave you with today

is this:

We need to learn to love

the flawed, imperfect things

that we create

and to forgive ourselves for creating them.

Regret doesn't remind us that we did badly.

It reminds us that we know we can do better.

Thank you.

(Applause)