A boat carrying 500 refugees sunk at sea. The story of two survivors | Melissa Fleming

131,191 views ・ 2015-11-30

TED


Please double-click on the English subtitles below to play the video.

00:13
Every day, I listen to harrowing stories of people fleeing for their lives,
0
13372
6149
00:19
across dangerous borders and unfriendly seas.
1
19545
3913
00:24
But there's one story that keeps me awake at night,
2
24109
4495
00:28
and it's about Doaa.
3
28628
1556
00:30
A Syrian refugee, 19 years old,
4
30208
2823
00:33
she was living a grinding existence in Egypt working day wages.
5
33055
5836
00:38
Her dad was constantly thinking of his thriving business back in Syria
6
38915
5387
00:44
that had been blown to pieces by a bomb.
7
44326
3348
00:48
And the war that drove them there was still raging in its fourth year.
8
48238
6056
00:54
And the community that once welcomed them there
9
54999
3209
00:58
had become weary of them.
10
58232
2365
01:01
And one day, men on motorcycles tried to kidnap her.
11
61248
3058
01:05
Once an aspiring student thinking only of her future,
12
65084
4749
01:09
now she was scared all the time.
13
69857
3578
01:14
But she was also full of hope,
14
74269
2009
01:16
because she was in love with a fellow Syrian refugee named Bassem.
15
76302
5023
01:21
Bassem was also struggling in Egypt, and he said to Doaa,
16
81349
5010
01:26
"Let's go to Europe; seek asylum, safety.
17
86383
3366
01:29
I will work, you can study -- the promise of a new life."
18
89773
4143
01:34
And he asked her father for her hand in marriage.
19
94829
3228
01:38
But they knew to get to Europe they had to risk their lives,
20
98724
5516
01:44
traveling across the Mediterranean Sea,
21
104264
2500
01:46
putting their hands in smugglers', notorious for their cruelty.
22
106788
5457
01:53
And Doaa was terrified of the water.
23
113173
3389
01:57
She always had been. She never learned to swim.
24
117292
3050
02:02
It was August that year, and already 2,000 people had died
25
122222
4753
02:06
trying to cross the Mediterranean,
26
126999
1954
02:08
but Doaa knew of a friend who had made it all the way to Northern Europe,
27
128977
3970
02:12
and she thought, "Maybe we can, too."
28
132971
2269
02:15
So she asked her parents if they could go,
29
135999
3002
02:19
and after a painful discussion, they consented,
30
139025
3342
02:22
and Bassem paid his entire life savings -- 2,500 dollars each --
31
142391
6130
02:28
to the smugglers.
32
148545
1396
02:30
It was a Saturday morning when the call came,
33
150821
3215
02:34
and they were taken by bus to a beach, hundreds of people on the beach.
34
154060
4479
02:38
They were taken then by small boats onto an old fishing boat,
35
158873
4048
02:42
500 of them crammed onto that boat,
36
162945
2558
02:45
300 below, [200] above.
37
165527
2876
02:49
There were Syrians, Palestinians, Africans, Muslims and Christians,
38
169466
4538
02:54
100 children, including Sandra -- little Sandra, six years old --
39
174028
5328
02:59
and Masa, 18 months.
40
179380
2816
03:03
There were families on that boat, crammed together shoulder to shoulder,
41
183498
3898
03:07
feet to feet.
42
187420
1532
03:08
Doaa was sitting with her legs crammed up to her chest,
43
188976
3808
03:12
Bassem holding her hand.
44
192808
2515
03:16
Day two on the water, they were sick with worry
45
196386
2707
03:19
and sick to their stomachs from the rough sea.
46
199117
3079
03:23
Day three, Doaa had a premonition.
47
203109
2975
03:27
And she said to Bassem, "I fear we're not going to make it.
48
207068
4553
03:31
I fear the boat is going to sink."
49
211645
2039
03:34
And Bassem said to her, "Please be patient.
50
214517
3149
03:37
We will make it to Sweden, we will get married
51
217690
3182
03:40
and we will have a future."
52
220896
1554
03:43
Day four, the passengers were getting agitated.
53
223751
3853
03:47
They asked the captain, "When will we get there?"
54
227628
3136
03:50
He told them to shut up, and he insulted them.
55
230788
3388
03:54
He said, "In 16 hours we will reach the shores of Italy."
56
234740
3742
03:58
They were weak and weary.
57
238506
3174
04:01
Soon they saw a boat approach -- a smaller boat, 10 men on board,
58
241704
4271
04:05
who started shouting at them, hurling insults,
59
245999
3415
04:09
throwing sticks, asking them to all disembark
60
249438
4350
04:13
and get on this smaller, more unseaworthy boat.
61
253812
3715
04:17
The parents were terrified for their children,
62
257551
3518
04:21
and they collectively refused to disembark.
63
261093
4001
04:26
So the boat sped away in anger,
64
266157
3116
04:29
and a half an hour later, came back
65
269297
4230
04:33
and started deliberately ramming a hole in the side of Doaa's boat,
66
273551
6052
04:39
just below where she and Bassem were sitting.
67
279627
2613
04:43
And she heard how they yelled,
68
283764
3339
04:47
"Let the fish eat your flesh!"
69
287127
3361
04:51
And they started laughing as the boat capsized and sank.
70
291599
5838
04:57
The 300 people below deck were doomed.
71
297999
3059
05:01
Doaa was holding on to the side of the boat as it sank,
72
301757
4589
05:06
and watched in horror as a small child was cut to pieces by the propeller.
73
306370
6818
05:14
Bassem said to her, "Please let go,
74
314355
2199
05:16
or you'll be swept in and the propeller will kill you, too."
75
316578
3165
05:20
And remember -- she can't swim.
76
320267
2048
05:22
But she let go and she started moving her arms and her legs,
77
322999
4188
05:27
thinking, "This is swimming."
78
327211
1436
05:28
And miraculously, Bassem found a life ring.
79
328671
4373
05:33
It was one of those child's rings
80
333806
2048
05:35
that they use to play in swimming pools and on calm seas.
81
335878
4097
05:39
And Doaa climbed onto the ring,
82
339999
2045
05:42
her arms and her legs dangling by the side.
83
342068
3720
05:46
Bassem was a good swimmer,
84
346835
1941
05:48
so he held her hand and tread water.
85
348800
3794
05:54
Around them there were corpses.
86
354064
1938
05:56
Around 100 people survived initially,
87
356026
2468
05:58
and they started coming together in groups, praying for rescue.
88
358518
4541
06:03
But when a day went by and no one came,
89
363083
4317
06:07
some people gave up hope,
90
367424
1825
06:09
and Doaa and Bassem watched
91
369273
2174
06:11
as men in the distance took their life vests off and sank into the water.
92
371471
6581
06:19
One man approached them with a small baby perched on his shoulder,
93
379052
5923
06:24
nine months old -- Malek.
94
384999
1650
06:26
He was holding onto a gas canister to stay afloat, and he said to them,
95
386673
5079
06:31
"I fear I am not going to survive.
96
391776
1950
06:33
I'm too weak. I don't have the courage anymore."
97
393750
2666
06:36
And he handed little Malek over to Bassem and to Doaa,
98
396829
5146
06:41
and they perched her onto the life ring.
99
401999
2712
06:45
So now they were three, Doaa, Bassem and little Malek.
100
405774
5414
06:51
And let me take a pause in this story right here
101
411212
3129
06:54
and ask the question:
102
414365
2298
06:56
why do refugees like Doaa take these kinds of risks?
103
416687
4793
07:03
Millions of refugees are living in exile, in limbo.
104
423061
4843
07:09
They're living in countries [fleeing] from a war that has been raging
105
429232
4300
07:13
for four years.
106
433556
2284
07:17
Even if they wanted to return, they can't.
107
437634
3161
07:20
Their homes, their businesses,
108
440819
2762
07:23
their towns and their cities have been completely destroyed.
109
443605
3522
07:27
This is a UNESCO World Heritage City,
110
447151
2824
07:29
Homs, in Syria.
111
449999
1757
07:33
So people continue to flee into neighboring countries,
112
453097
4565
07:37
and we build refugee camps for them in the desert.
113
457686
3599
07:41
Hundreds of thousands of people live in camps like these,
114
461309
4010
07:45
and thousands and thousands more, millions, live in towns and cities.
115
465343
4973
07:50
And the communities,
116
470340
1218
07:51
the neighboring countries that once welcomed them
117
471582
2856
07:54
with open arms and hearts
118
474462
1762
07:56
are overwhelmed.
119
476248
1618
07:58
There are simply not enough schools, water systems, sanitation.
120
478731
4452
08:03
Even rich European countries could never handle such an influx
121
483747
4623
08:08
without massive investment.
122
488394
3243
08:13
The Syria war has driven almost four million people over the borders,
123
493407
5026
08:18
but over seven million people are on the run inside the country.
124
498457
4937
08:23
That means that over half the Syrian population
125
503418
3691
08:27
has been forced to flee.
126
507133
2260
08:29
Back to those neighboring countries hosting so many.
127
509766
4293
08:35
They feel that the richer world has done too little to support them.
128
515114
5033
08:41
And days have turned into months, months into years.
129
521401
4397
08:46
A refugee's stay is supposed to be temporary.
130
526483
3572
08:50
Back to Doaa and Bassem in the water.
131
530079
3321
08:53
It was their second day, and Bassem was getting very weak.
132
533424
4349
08:58
And now it was Doaa's turn to say to Bassem,
133
538764
4001
09:02
"My love, please hold on to hope, to our future. We will make it."
134
542789
5683
09:09
And he said to her,
135
549376
2681
09:12
"I'm sorry, my love, that I put you in this situation.
136
552081
4437
09:16
I have never loved anyone as much as I love you."
137
556542
4677
09:22
And he released himself into the water,
138
562871
3398
09:26
and Doaa watched as the love of her life drowned before her eyes.
139
566293
6256
09:35
Later that day,
140
575888
2416
09:38
a mother came up to Doaa with her small 18-month-old daughter, Masa.
141
578328
5651
09:44
This was the little girl I showed you in the picture earlier,
142
584741
2925
09:47
with the life vests.
143
587690
1848
09:49
Her older sister Sandra had just drowned,
144
589562
2193
09:51
and her mother knew she had to do everything in her power
145
591779
4119
09:55
to save her daughter.
146
595922
1492
09:57
And she said to Doaa, "Please take this child.
147
597993
3857
10:01
Let her be part of you. I will not survive."
148
601874
4028
10:07
And then she went away and drowned.
149
607125
3342
10:11
So Doaa, the 19-year-old refugee who was terrified of the water,
150
611825
4234
10:16
who couldn't swim,
151
616083
1892
10:17
found herself in charge of two little baby kids.
152
617999
5592
10:23
And they were thirsty and they were hungry and they were agitated,
153
623615
3681
10:27
and she tried her best to amuse them,
154
627320
2698
10:30
to sing to them, to say words to them from the Quran.
155
630042
4033
10:35
Around them, the bodies were bloating and turning black.
156
635234
4434
10:39
The sun was blazing during the day.
157
639692
1746
10:41
At night, there was a cold moon and fog.
158
641462
2720
10:44
It was very frightening.
159
644206
1976
10:46
On the fourth day in the water, this is how Doaa probably looked
160
646976
4739
10:51
on the ring with her two children.
161
651739
2121
10:53
A woman came on the fourth day and approached her
162
653884
3547
10:57
and asked her to take another child --
163
657455
3111
11:00
a little boy, just four years old.
164
660590
3015
11:04
When Doaa took the little boy and the mother drowned,
165
664999
4017
11:09
she said to the sobbing child,
166
669040
1960
11:11
"She just went away to find you water and food."
167
671024
3436
11:16
But his heart soon stopped,
168
676388
1993
11:18
and Doaa had to release the little boy into the water.
169
678405
3673
11:23
Later that day,
170
683023
2025
11:25
she looked up into the sky with hope,
171
685072
3279
11:28
because she saw two planes crossing in the sky.
172
688375
4015
11:32
And she waved her arms, hoping they would see her,
173
692414
4499
11:36
but the planes were soon gone.
174
696937
1856
11:39
But that afternoon, as the sun was going down,
175
699317
2903
11:42
she saw a boat, a merchant vessel.
176
702244
2856
11:46
And she said, "Please, God, let them rescue me."
177
706109
4017
11:50
She waved her arms and she felt like she shouted for about two hours.
178
710150
3960
11:54
And it had become dark, but finally the searchlights found her
179
714134
4610
11:58
and they extended a rope,
180
718768
2207
12:00
astonished to see a woman clutching onto two babies.
181
720999
4969
12:06
They pulled them onto the boat, they got oxygen and blankets,
182
726770
3488
12:10
and a Greek helicopter came to pick them up
183
730282
3007
12:13
and take them to the island of Crete.
184
733313
2112
12:16
But Doaa looked down and asked, "What of Malek?"
185
736353
3507
12:20
And they told her the little baby did not survive --
186
740400
3575
12:23
she drew her last breath in the boat's clinic.
187
743999
3387
12:28
But Doaa was sure that as they had been pulled up onto the rescue boat,
188
748203
5772
12:33
that little baby girl had been smiling.
189
753999
3247
12:39
Only 11 people survived that wreck, of the 500.
190
759278
6002
12:46
There was never an international investigation into what happened.
191
766304
4671
12:50
There were some media reports about mass murder at sea,
192
770999
4095
12:55
a terrible tragedy,
193
775118
1325
12:56
but that was only for one day.
194
776467
2467
12:59
And then the news cycle moved on.
195
779490
3824
13:04
Meanwhile, in a pediatric hospital on Crete,
196
784536
4542
13:09
little Masa was on the edge of death.
197
789102
3372
13:13
She was really dehydrated. Her kidneys were failing.
198
793681
3710
13:17
Her glucose levels were dangerously low.
199
797415
2024
13:19
The doctors did everything in their medical power to save them,
200
799463
3566
13:23
and the Greek nurses never left her side,
201
803053
3660
13:26
holding her, hugging her, singing her words.
202
806737
2127
13:28
My colleagues also visited and said pretty words to her in Arabic.
203
808888
5569
13:34
Amazingly, little Masa survived.
204
814481
4196
13:40
And soon the Greek press started reporting about the miracle baby,
205
820192
5936
13:46
who had survived four days in the water without food or anything to drink,
206
826152
5667
13:51
and offers to adopt her came from all over the country.
207
831843
4734
13:57
And meanwhile, Doaa was in another hospital on Crete,
208
837466
3390
14:00
thin, dehydrated.
209
840880
1612
14:03
An Egyptian family took her into their home as soon as she was released.
210
843571
5545
14:10
And soon word went around about Doaa's survival,
211
850248
4747
14:15
and a phone number was published on Facebook.
212
855019
3178
14:19
Messages started coming in.
213
859300
2565
14:22
"Doaa, do you know what happened to my brother?
214
862999
4788
14:27
My sister? My parents? My friends? Do you know if they survived?"
215
867811
6541
14:35
One of those messages said,
216
875201
3774
14:38
"I believe you saved my little niece, Masa."
217
878999
4448
14:44
And it had this photo.
218
884249
2492
14:47
This was from Masa's uncle,
219
887741
2262
14:50
a Syrian refugee who had made it to Sweden with his family
220
890027
4722
14:54
and also Masa's older sister.
221
894773
2207
14:57
Soon, we hope, Masa will be reunited with him in Sweden,
222
897647
5684
15:03
and until then, she's being cared for in a beautiful orphanage in Athens.
223
903355
5524
15:10
And Doaa? Well, word went around about her survival, too.
224
910221
5782
15:16
And the media wrote about this slight woman,
225
916999
3713
15:20
and couldn't imagine how she could survive all this time
226
920736
3912
15:24
under such conditions in that sea,
227
924672
2994
15:27
and still save another life.
228
927690
3031
15:32
The Academy of Athens, one of Greece's most prestigious institutions,
229
932459
5387
15:37
gave her an award of bravery,
230
937870
3356
15:41
and she deserves all that praise,
231
941250
2991
15:44
and she deserves a second chance.
232
944265
2421
15:47
But she wants to still go to Sweden.
233
947999
3440
15:51
She wants to reunite with her family there.
234
951463
2230
15:53
She wants to bring her mother and her father and her younger siblings
235
953717
4111
15:57
away from Egypt there as well,
236
957852
2318
16:00
and I believe she will succeed.
237
960194
3181
16:03
She wants to become a lawyer or a politician
238
963399
2722
16:06
or something that can help fight injustice.
239
966145
4894
16:11
She is an extraordinary survivor.
240
971063
3064
16:15
But I have to ask:
241
975215
2564
16:17
what if she didn't have to take that risk?
242
977803
2272
16:20
Why did she have to go through all that?
243
980099
2476
16:23
Why wasn't there a legal way for her to study in Europe?
244
983226
5064
16:28
Why couldn't Masa have taken an airplane to Sweden?
245
988314
4296
16:32
Why couldn't Bassem have found work?
246
992634
2372
16:36
Why is there no massive resettlement program for Syrian refugees,
247
996125
5422
16:41
the victims of the worst war of our times?
248
1001571
3620
16:45
The world did this for the Vietnamese in the 1970s. Why not now?
249
1005778
5505
16:52
Why is there so little investment in the neighboring countries
250
1012624
4617
16:57
hosting so many refugees?
251
1017265
2666
17:01
And why, the root question,
252
1021113
2862
17:03
is so little being done to stop the wars, the persecution
253
1023999
6396
17:10
and the poverty that is driving so many people
254
1030419
4556
17:14
to the shores of Europe?
255
1034999
1852
17:17
Until these issues are resolved,
256
1037999
2609
17:20
people will continue to take to the seas
257
1040632
3335
17:23
and to seek safety and asylum.
258
1043991
3429
17:28
And what happens next?
259
1048103
1658
17:30
Well, that is largely Europe's choice.
260
1050253
2831
17:33
And I understand the public fears.
261
1053108
3031
17:37
People are worried about their security, their economies, the changes of culture.
262
1057005
5927
17:43
But is that more important than saving human lives?
263
1063893
4141
17:48
Because there is something fundamental here
264
1068859
2779
17:51
that I think overrides the rest,
265
1071662
2804
17:54
and it is about our common humanity.
266
1074490
3562
17:58
No person fleeing war or persecution
267
1078719
4469
18:03
should have to die crossing a sea to reach safety.
268
1083212
5161
18:08
(Applause)
269
1088397
6332
18:14
One thing is for sure,
270
1094753
1167
18:15
that no refugee would be on those dangerous boats
271
1095944
3183
18:19
if they could thrive where they are.
272
1099151
2348
18:21
And no migrant would take that dangerous journey
273
1101523
3278
18:24
if they had enough food for themselves and their children.
274
1104825
3886
18:28
And no one would put their life savings
275
1108735
2619
18:31
in the hands of those notorious smugglers
276
1111378
2793
18:34
if there was a legal way to migrate.
277
1114195
2427
18:37
So on behalf of little Masa
278
1117471
3595
18:41
and on behalf of Doaa
279
1121090
2269
18:43
and of Bassem
280
1123383
1724
18:45
and of those 500 people who drowned with them,
281
1125131
5137
18:50
can we make sure that they did not die in vain?
282
1130292
3143
18:54
Could we be inspired by what happened,
283
1134308
3667
18:57
and take a stand for a world in which every life matters?
284
1137999
5951
19:04
Thank you.
285
1144999
1311
19:06
(Applause)
286
1146334
6594
About this website

This site will introduce you to YouTube videos that are useful for learning English. You will see English lessons taught by top-notch teachers from around the world. Double-click on the English subtitles displayed on each video page to play the video from there. The subtitles scroll in sync with the video playback. If you have any comments or requests, please contact us using this contact form.

https://forms.gle/WvT1wiN1qDtmnspy7