You are fluent in this language (and don't even know it) | Christoph Niemann
1,643,465 views ・ 2018-08-22
請雙擊下方英文字幕播放視頻。
譯者: Dai-Yun Wu
審譯者: Helen Chang
00:12
I'm an artist.
0
12760
1240
我是一個藝術家
00:15
Being an artist
is the greatest job there is.
1
15240
2640
藝術家是最棒的工作
00:18
And I really pity
each and every one of you
2
18760
2296
而我真的很憐憫你們每一個人
00:21
who has to spend your days
discovering new galaxies
3
21080
2696
你們必須花時間探索宇宙
00:23
or saving humanity from global warming.
4
23800
2656
或將人類從全球暖化中拯救出來
00:26
(Laughter)
5
26480
2456
(笑聲)
00:28
But being an artist
is also a daunting job.
6
28960
2920
但其實藝術家也是份令人氣餒的工作
00:32
I spend every day,
from nine to six, doing this.
7
32880
3600
我每天從九點到六點都在做這個:
00:37
(Laughter)
8
37200
1896
(笑聲)
00:39
I even started a side career
that consists entirely
9
39120
3976
我甚至開始一份副業
而這份副業都在抱怨創造過程的難處
00:43
of complaining about the difficulty
of the creative process.
10
43120
2816
00:45
(Laughter)
11
45960
1096
(笑聲)
00:47
But today, I don't want to talk
about what makes my life difficult.
12
47080
3760
但今天我不想討論那些
讓我的人生變得困難的事
00:51
I want to talk about what makes it easy.
13
51480
2616
我想談那些讓我的人生變得簡單的事
00:54
And that is you --
14
54120
1496
而那就是你
00:55
and the fact that
you are fluent in a language
15
55640
2656
以及一個你可能從未發覺的事實:
你的某種語言能力其實很流暢
00:58
that you're probably not even aware of.
16
58320
1858
01:01
You're fluent in the language
of reading images.
17
61480
3080
你其實很會解讀圖像語言
01:06
Deciphering an image like that
18
66720
1456
要解碼一個像這樣的圖像
01:08
takes quite a bit
of an intellectual effort.
19
68200
2056
需要運用一些智力
01:10
But nobody ever taught you how this works,
20
70280
2216
但沒有人曾教導過你怎麼做
01:12
you just know it.
21
72520
1240
你就是知道怎麼做
01:15
College, shopping, music.
22
75280
2096
大學、逛街、音樂
01:17
What makes a language powerful
is that you can take a very complex idea
23
77400
3776
讓語言強大的關鍵是
你能將一個很複雜的想法
01:21
and communicate it
in a very simple, efficient form.
24
81200
2880
以很簡單又有效率的形式傳達
01:25
These images represent
exactly the same ideas.
25
85760
3200
這些圖像與文字代表完全相同的意思
01:30
But when you look, for example,
at the college hat,
26
90680
2416
舉例來說,當你看著那頂學士帽時
你知道它不只是代表那個
你在接過你的文憑時
01:33
you know that this doesn't represent
the accessory you wear on your head
27
93120
3416
01:36
when you're being handed your diploma,
28
96560
1856
頭上戴的裝飾品
01:38
but rather the whole idea of college.
29
98440
1800
而是「大學」這整個概念
01:42
Now, what drawings can do
is they cannot only communicate images,
30
102040
4136
圖畫不僅僅能夠傳遞圖像
01:46
they can even evoke emotions.
31
106200
2816
也能激發情感
01:49
Let's say you get to
an unfamiliar place and you see this.
32
109040
3296
假設你去到不熟悉的地方看到這個:
01:52
You feel happiness and relief.
33
112360
1576
你就覺得開心、鬆了口氣
01:53
(Laughter)
34
113960
1776
(笑聲)
01:55
Or a slight sense of unease
or maybe downright panic.
35
115760
5416
或許感到有些焦慮,或者極度恐慌
02:01
(Laughter)
36
121200
2536
(笑聲)
02:03
Or blissful peace and quiet.
37
123760
3456
或幸福安詳
02:07
(Laughter)
38
127240
1616
(笑聲)
02:08
But visuals, they're of course
more than just graphic icons.
39
128880
3440
但視覺當然不只是圖示
02:13
You know, if I want to tell the story
of modern-day struggle,
40
133360
3376
如果我今天要講關於現代奮鬥的故事
02:16
I would start with the armrest
between two airplane seats
41
136760
3216
我會從兩個飛機座位之間的扶手
02:20
and two sets of elbows fighting.
42
140000
2136
與兩組手肘之間的打鬥開始
02:22
What I love there is this universal law
43
142160
2896
這個例子迷人的是這個共同定律:
02:25
that, you know, you have
30 seconds to fight it out
44
145080
2416
你有三十秒的時間爭奪
02:27
and once it's yours, you get to keep it
for the rest of the flight.
45
147520
3176
一旦搶到了,這個扶手的使用權
整個航程都屬於你
02:30
(Laughter)
46
150720
2096
(笑聲)
02:32
Now, commercial flight
is full of these images.
47
152840
3896
商業航班滿是這類意象
02:36
If I want to illustrate
the idea of discomfort,
48
156760
3496
如果我要描述「不舒服」的概念
02:40
nothing better than these neck pillows.
49
160280
1896
沒有什麼比得上這些頸枕
02:42
They're designed
to make you more comfortable --
50
162200
3056
它們是設計來讓你感到更舒適的
02:45
(Laughter)
51
165280
1816
(笑聲)
02:47
except they don't.
52
167120
1216
可是它們沒有
02:48
(Laughter)
53
168360
2960
(笑聲)
02:52
So I never sleep on airplanes.
54
172200
1440
所以我在飛機上從不睡覺
02:54
What I do occasionally
is I fall into a sort of painful coma.
55
174880
4096
我偶爾陷入一種類似痛苦的昏迷狀態
02:59
And when I wake up from that,
56
179000
3496
然後當我醒來
03:02
I have the most terrible
taste in my mouth.
57
182520
2656
我的嘴巴有股最可怕的味道
03:05
It's a taste that's so bad,
it cannot be described with words,
58
185200
3336
那股味道糟到我無法以言語形容
03:08
but it can be drawn.
59
188560
1376
但可以畫出來
03:09
(Laughter)
60
189960
5936
(笑聲)
03:15
The thing is, you know, I love sleeping.
61
195920
2600
事情是這樣的,我愛睡覺
03:19
And when I sleep, I really
prefer to do it while spooning.
62
199160
3736
當我要睡的時候
我真的比較喜歡在背後抱時睡著
03:22
I've been spooning on almost a pro level
for close to 20 years,
63
202920
3936
二十年來以這個湯匙姿勢入睡
我可是專家級的
03:26
but in all this time,
I've never figured out
64
206880
2896
但過了這麼多年,我還是不知道
03:29
what to do with that bottom arm.
65
209800
1656
壓在下面那隻手要怎麼辦
03:31
(Laughter)
66
211480
2616
(笑聲)
03:34
(Applause)
67
214120
1936
(掌聲)
03:36
And the only thing --
68
216080
2280
而唯一一件
03:39
the only thing that makes sleeping
even more complicated
69
219640
2856
唯一一件讓睡覺變得
03:42
than trying to do it on an airplane
70
222520
1696
比在飛機上睡覺更複雜的事
03:44
is when you have small children.
71
224240
1560
就是當你有小小孩的時候
03:47
They show up at your bed at around 4am
72
227040
2040
他們會在凌晨四點左右出現在你床邊
03:50
with some bogus excuse of,
"I had a bad dream."
73
230040
3216
告訴你一些假的藉口
像是「我做惡夢了」
03:53
(Laughter)
74
233280
2256
(笑聲)
03:55
And then, of course you feel
sorry for them, they're your kids,
75
235560
2946
然後你當然憐憫他們
他們是你的小孩
03:58
so you let them into your bed.
76
238520
1426
所以你讓他們過來跟你一起睡
03:59
And I have to admit, at the beginning,
they're really cute and warm and snugly.
77
239960
3715
我得承認,一開始他們真的
很可愛、很溫暖也很舒服
04:03
The minute you fall back asleep,
they inexplicably --
78
243685
3171
就在你要再度入睡的那一刻
他們不知為何開始
04:06
(Laughter)
79
246880
1656
(笑聲)
04:08
start rotating.
80
248560
1256
開始轉動
04:09
(Laughter)
81
249840
2576
(笑聲)
04:12
We like to call this the helicopter mode.
82
252440
1953
我們稱此為「直升機模式」
04:14
(Laughter)
83
254417
1839
(笑聲)
04:16
Now, the deeper something is etched
into your consciousness,
84
256280
5016
那更深層的東西已經嵌入你的意識中
04:21
the fewer details we need
to have an emotional reaction.
85
261320
3360
少少的資訊就足夠引起情緒反應
04:25
(Laughter)
86
265360
2856
(笑聲)
04:28
So why does an image like this work?
87
268240
1920
為什麼像這樣的圖像可以達到效果?
04:31
It works, because we as readers
88
271000
2616
它能被看懂,因為身為讀者的我們
04:33
are incredibly good
at filling in the blanks.
89
273640
2240
非常擅長填空
04:37
Now, when you draw,
there's this concept of negative space.
90
277000
4016
當你畫畫時,有一個概念
叫做「實體周圍的空間」
04:41
And the idea is, that instead
of drawing the actual object,
91
281040
2896
這概念是我們不畫物品的實體
04:43
you draw the space around it.
92
283960
2016
而是畫它周圍的空間
04:46
So the bowls in this drawing are empty.
93
286000
2400
所以這幅畫裡的碗是空的
04:49
But the black ink prompts your brain
to project food into a void.
94
289360
3880
但那黑色墨水促使你的腦
將食物投射至空白的區塊中
04:56
What we see here is not a owl flying.
95
296200
3160
我們在這幅圖中看到的
不是一隻在飛的貓頭鷹
05:00
What we actually see
is a pair of AA batteries
96
300113
2143
它其實是兩個 AA 電池
05:02
standing on a nonsensical drawing,
97
302280
2176
站在一幅荒謬的畫上
05:04
and I animate the scene
by moving my desk lamp up and down.
98
304480
3536
然後我藉著上下移動我的桌燈
讓畫面動起來
05:08
(Laughter)
99
308040
2056
(笑聲)
05:10
The image really only exists in your mind.
100
310120
2600
這圖像真的只存在於你的腦中
05:13
So, how much information do we need
to trigger such an image?
101
313640
3120
那究竟需要多少資訊
才能激發這種圖像?
05:18
My goal as an artist
is to use the smallest amount possible.
102
318040
4080
身為藝術家
我的目標是使用越少資訊越好
05:23
I try to achieve a level of simplicity
103
323120
2816
我試著達到簡潔的境界
05:25
where, if you were to take away
one more element,
104
325960
2416
簡潔到若你再抽掉一個元素
05:28
the whole concept would just collapse.
105
328400
2040
整個概念就會崩解
05:31
And that's why my personal favorite tool
as an artist is abstraction.
106
331520
3640
這也是為什麼身為藝術家
我最喜歡的工具是抽象
05:36
I've come up with this system
which I call the abstract-o-meter,
107
336520
3016
我發明了一個系統
我叫它「抽象量計」
05:39
and this is how it works.
108
339560
1336
它是這樣使用的:
05:40
So you take a symbol, any symbol,
for example the heart and the arrow,
109
340920
3896
取任何一個符號,例如愛心與箭
05:44
which most of us would read
as the symbol for love,
110
344840
2816
大多數的人會將它們解讀為愛的象徵
05:47
and I'm an artist, so I can draw this
111
347680
1816
而我是個藝術家,所以我可以
05:49
in any given degree
of realism or abstraction.
112
349520
2960
決定用多少寫實
或多少抽象元素來畫它
05:53
Now, if I go too realistic on it,
it just grosses everybody out.
113
353320
4376
如果我太寫實,大家就會覺得噁心
05:57
(Laughter)
114
357720
2016
(笑聲)
05:59
If I go too far on the other side
and do very abstract,
115
359760
3936
如果我又畫得太抽象
06:03
nobody has any idea
what they're looking at.
116
363720
2256
沒有人知道這是什麼
06:06
So I have to find
the perfect place on that scale,
117
366000
2376
所以我必須在那量尺中
找到最完美的位置
06:08
in this case it's somewhere in the middle.
118
368400
2040
以這個範例來說
大概是在中間的位置
06:11
Now, once we have reduced an image
to a more simple form,
119
371320
3520
當我們將一個圖像
簡化到更簡潔的形式
06:16
all sorts of new connections
become possible.
120
376080
2120
各種新連結開始變得可行
06:20
And that allows for totally
new angles in storytelling.
121
380760
3776
也可以用新的觀點說故事
06:24
(Laughter)
122
384560
3376
(笑聲)
06:27
And so, what I like to do is,
123
387960
1456
所以,我想做的是
06:29
I like to take images from really remote
cultural areas and bring them together.
124
389440
4200
我希望能結合遙遠文化地區的圖像
06:36
Now, with more daring references --
125
396000
2376
運用更多大膽的引用
06:38
(Laughter)
126
398400
2656
(笑聲)
06:41
I can have more fun.
127
401080
1720
我就能創造更多樂趣
06:43
But of course, I know that eventually
things become so obscure
128
403560
2976
但當然,我知道事情到最後變得很難懂
06:46
that I start losing some of you.
129
406560
1896
你們有些人會失去興趣
06:48
So as a designer, it's absolutely key
to have a good understanding
130
408480
4616
所以身為一個設計師
充分了解觀眾的視覺
與文化詞彙是很關鍵的
06:53
of the visual and cultural
vocabulary of your audience.
131
413120
3320
06:58
With this image here,
a comment on the Olympics in Athens,
132
418000
5256
這個圖像:一篇關於雅典奧運的評論
07:03
I assumed that the reader
of the "New Yorker"
133
423280
2096
我假設「紐約客」的讀者
07:05
would have some rudimentary
idea of Greek art.
134
425400
2936
多少對於希臘藝術
會有一些初步的了解
07:08
If you don't, the image doesn't work.
135
428360
1840
如果你不了解希臘藝術
這個圖像就不會達到它的效果
07:10
But if you do, you might
even appreciate the small detail,
136
430880
2736
但如果你了解
你甚至會欣賞它的小細節
07:13
like the beer-can pattern here
on the bottom of the vase.
137
433640
2856
例如這個花瓶底部的
啤酒罐般的圖騰
07:16
(Laughter)
138
436520
1680
(笑聲)
07:19
A recurring discussion I have
with magazine editors,
139
439600
4136
我跟雜誌編輯反覆討論著一件事
07:23
who are usually word people,
140
443760
1976
而雜誌編輯們通常是很在意詞彙的人
07:25
is that their audience, you,
141
445760
2600
我們討論的是觀眾們
你們比起圖像原意
07:29
are much better at making
radical leaps with images
142
449320
3576
更會跳躍式解讀圖像意義
07:32
than they're being given credit for.
143
452920
1720
07:35
And the only thing I find frustrating
is that they often seem to push me
144
455240
4296
而唯一讓我覺得挫敗的是
它們似乎總把我推向一系列老套
07:39
towards a small set
of really tired visual clichés
145
459560
3576
被認為保險的視覺效果
07:43
that are considered safe.
146
463160
1616
07:44
You know, it's the businessman
climbing up a ladder,
147
464800
2976
就像,有個商人正在爬梯
07:47
and then the ladder moves,
morphs into a stock market graph,
148
467800
3096
然後梯子動了,變成股市趨勢圖
07:50
and anything with dollar signs;
that's always good.
149
470920
2416
任何有錢幣符號的東西,總是很好
07:53
(Laughter)
150
473360
1616
(笑聲)
07:55
If there are editorial decision makers
here in the audience,
151
475000
3816
如果今天的觀眾裡有編輯決策者
07:58
I want to give you a piece of advice.
152
478840
1776
我想給你一個建議
08:00
Every time a drawing
like this is published,
153
480640
2896
每當這種圖被出版一次
08:03
a baby panda will die.
154
483560
1856
就會死一隻熊貓寶寶
08:05
(Laughter)
155
485440
1096
(笑聲)
08:06
Literally.
156
486560
1216
真的
08:07
(Laughter)
157
487800
1336
(笑聲)
08:09
(Applause)
158
489160
4576
(掌聲)
08:13
When is a visual cliché good or bad?
159
493760
3296
那老套的視覺效果什麼時候好
什麼時候不好?
08:17
It's a fine line.
160
497080
1816
兩者差別很微妙
08:18
And it really depends on the story.
161
498920
2296
端看你的故事內容
08:21
In 2011, during the earthquake
and the tsunami in Japan,
162
501240
3736
2011 年,日本發生地震與海嘯時
08:25
I was thinking of a cover.
163
505000
2176
我正在籌劃一個封面
08:27
And I went through the classic symbols:
164
507200
2456
我把典型符號都想過了一遍:
08:29
the Japanese flag,
165
509680
1296
日本國旗
08:31
"The Great Wave" by Hokusai,
one of the greatest drawings ever.
166
511000
3360
葛飾北齋的「神奈川沖浪裏」
史上最厲害的畫作之一
08:35
And then the story changed
167
515520
2616
然後故事就變了
08:38
when the situation at the power plant
in Fukushima got out of hand.
168
518160
3160
在福島的電廠失控之後
08:42
And I remember these TV images
of the workers in hazmat suits,
169
522200
4616
我記得電視裡
充滿穿著防護衣工人們的圖像
08:46
just walking through the site,
170
526840
1456
在現場穿梭
08:48
and what struck me
was how quiet and serene it was.
171
528320
3656
而讓我感到震撼的是
那畫面是如此平靜
08:52
And so I wanted to create an image
of a silent catastrophe.
172
532000
3400
因此我就想創造一幅
表達平靜災難的圖像
08:56
And that's the image I came up with.
173
536200
1720
這就是我當時的作品
08:59
(Applause)
174
539120
1616
(掌聲)
09:00
Thank you.
175
540760
1216
謝謝
09:02
(Applause)
176
542000
2640
(掌聲)
09:05
What I want to do is create
an aha moment, for you, for the reader.
177
545280
4320
我想為讀者創造
一個「啊哈!」的時刻
09:10
And unfortunately, that does not mean
178
550200
1816
而不幸的是,這並不代表
我在創造這些圖像的時候
09:12
that I have an aha moment
when I create these images.
179
552040
2520
也有「啊哈」的時刻
09:15
I never sit at my desk
180
555520
1256
我坐在書桌前時
09:16
with the proverbial light bulb
going off in my head.
181
556800
2960
腦中的那顆「燈泡」從不熄滅
09:21
What it takes is actually a very slow,
182
561200
2816
設計過程其實非常緩慢
09:24
unsexy process of minimal design decisions
183
564040
3416
且是一點都不性感地
在做一些微小的設計決策
09:27
that then, when I'm lucky,
lead to a good idea.
184
567480
2320
如果幸運,這些決策將會引出好的概念
09:31
So one day, I'm on a train,
and I'm trying to decode
185
571960
2656
於是有一天,我在火車上試著解讀
09:34
the graphic rules for drops on a window.
186
574640
2200
窗戶上雨滴的圖像規則
09:37
And eventually I realize,
187
577520
1256
然後我終於瞭解到
09:38
"Oh, it's the background
blurry upside-down,
188
578800
3496
「噢,原來它是包含在清晰圖像裡的
模糊顛倒背景。」
09:42
contained in a sharp image."
189
582320
1376
09:43
And I thought, wow, that's really cool,
190
583720
1876
然後我想,哇,那真的是很酷
09:45
and I have absolutely no idea
what to do with that.
191
585610
2376
而對於如何處理它我完全沒有想法
09:48
A while later, I'm back in New York,
192
588016
2160
不久之後,我回到紐約
09:50
and I draw this image of being stuck
on the Brooklyn bridge in a traffic jam.
193
590200
4360
我畫了這個在布魯克林大橋上塞車的圖
09:55
It's really annoying,
but also kind of poetic.
194
595240
2360
塞車很煩人,也有點詩意
09:58
And only later I realized,
195
598960
1256
直到後來我才想到
10:00
I can take both of these ideas
and put them together in this idea.
196
600240
3280
我可以同時採用這兩種概念
然後將它們結合呈現
10:04
And what I want to do
is not show a realistic scene.
197
604760
3120
而我想做的不是呈現實景
10:09
But, maybe like poetry,
198
609160
2576
而是,有點詩意的
10:11
make you aware that you
already had this image with you,
199
611760
3456
讓你意識到其實這個圖像
已經存在你腦中
10:15
but only now I've unearthed it
200
615240
1856
而我現在將它挖掘出來
10:17
and made you realize that you
were carrying it with you all along.
201
617120
3600
讓你了解到它其實一直都跟著你
10:21
But like poetry,
this is a very delicate process
202
621760
3336
但像詩一樣,它是個很細緻的過程
10:25
that is neither efficient
nor scalable, I think.
203
625120
4360
我覺得這個過程
無法有效率也無法量化
10:30
And maybe the most
important skill for an artist
204
630720
3536
或許對一個藝術家來說
最重要的技巧其實是同理心
10:34
is really empathy.
205
634280
1200
10:36
You need craft and you need --
206
636640
3056
你需要技術,你也需要
10:39
(Laughter)
207
639720
1536
(笑聲)
10:41
you need creativity --
208
641280
1256
你需要創造力
10:42
(Laughter)
209
642560
1536
(笑聲)
10:44
thank you --
210
644120
1216
謝謝
10:45
to come up with an image like that.
211
645360
2136
來創造出像這樣的圖像
10:47
But then you need to step back
212
647520
2256
然而在那之後,你必須往後退一步
10:49
and look at what you've done
from the perspective of the reader.
213
649800
3120
以讀者的視角看你創造出來的東西
10:53
I've tried to become a better artist
by becoming a better observer of images.
214
653920
4640
藉由變成一個更好的圖像觀察者
我試著成為一個更好的藝術家
10:59
And for that, I started
an exercise for myself
215
659280
2336
為了這個目的,我開始了自己的練習
11:01
which I call Sunday sketching,
216
661640
2216
我將這個練習稱作「星期天速寫」
11:03
which meant, on a Sunday, I would take
a random object I found around the house
217
663880
5096
意思是,在星期天
我會取房子周邊的一個隨機物品
11:09
and try to see if that object
could trigger an idea
218
669000
4416
然後試著想想看該物品
是否能激發點子
11:13
that had nothing to do
with the original purpose of that item.
219
673440
2920
激發跟這個物品的
原始用途不同的點子
11:17
And it usually just means
I'm blank for a long while.
220
677160
3000
這通常意味著
我會有很長的一段時間腦中空白
11:21
And the only trick that eventually works
is if I open my mind
221
681160
3536
唯一能讓這件事成功的秘訣
是當我不持任何偏見地
11:24
and run through every image
I have stored up there,
222
684720
3336
掃描過每一個我存放在腦中的圖像
11:28
and see if something clicks.
223
688080
1560
看看是否有東西讓我突然開竅
11:30
And if it does, just add
a few lines of ink to connect --
224
690640
4376
如果有,就只要加上幾條線連結
11:35
to preserve this very short
moment of inspiration.
225
695040
2920
來保存這短暫的予人靈感的時刻
11:40
And the great lesson there
226
700200
2296
而這經驗中最寶貴的一課是
11:42
was that the real magic
doesn't happen on paper.
227
702520
3216
魔法不是發生在紙上
11:45
It happens in the mind of the viewer.
228
705760
1800
而是在觀看者的腦中
11:48
When your expectations and your knowledge
clash with my artistic intentions.
229
708320
5640
當你的期待與知識
和我的藝術撞擊時
11:55
Your interaction with an image,
230
715960
2896
你和圖像的互動
11:58
your ability to read, question,
be bothered or bored or inspired
231
718880
4296
你能閱讀、質疑或覺得圖像
很惱人、無聊或發人深省
12:03
by an image
232
723200
1216
12:04
is as important
as my artistic contribution.
233
724440
2440
這些都和我的藝術貢獻一樣重要
12:07
Because that's what turns
an artistic statement
234
727960
4240
因為那就是將藝術表現真正轉化成
12:13
really, into a creative dialogue.
235
733720
1600
創意對話的關鍵
12:17
And so, your skill at reading images
236
737040
2456
所以,你閱讀圖像的技巧
12:19
is not only amazing,
237
739520
1240
不僅是非常好
12:21
it is what makes my art possible.
238
741560
1840
更是讓我的藝術變得有可能性的關鍵
12:24
And for that, I thank you very much.
239
744880
2456
針對這點,我非常感謝你們
12:27
(Applause)
240
747360
3096
(掌聲)
12:30
(Cheers)
241
750480
4600
(歡呼)
12:36
Thank you.
242
756000
1216
謝謝
12:37
(Applause)
243
757240
3840
(掌聲)
New videos
Original video on YouTube.com
關於本網站
本網站將向您介紹對學習英語有用的 YouTube 視頻。 您將看到來自世界各地的一流教師教授的英語課程。 雙擊每個視頻頁面上顯示的英文字幕,從那裡播放視頻。 字幕與視頻播放同步滾動。 如果您有任何意見或要求,請使用此聯繫表與我們聯繫。