Israel and Iran: A love story?

437,092 views ・ 2012-12-21

TED


Please double-click on the English subtitles below to play the video.

00:00
Translator: Joseph Geni Reviewer: Morton Bast
0
0
7000
00:15
On March 14, this year,
1
15879
2799
00:18
I posted this poster on Facebook.
2
18678
2880
00:21
This is an image of me and my daughter
3
21558
2425
00:23
holding the Israeli flag.
4
23983
2734
00:26
I will try to explain to you about the context of why
5
26763
3039
00:29
and when I posted.
6
29802
2606
00:32
A few days ago, I was sitting waiting
7
32408
3121
00:35
on the line at the grocery store,
8
35529
2304
00:37
and the owner and one of the clients
9
37833
3286
00:41
were talking to each other,
10
41119
1690
00:42
and the owner was explaining to the client
11
42809
2058
00:44
that we're going to get 10,000 missiles on Israel.
12
44867
3476
00:48
And the client was saying, no, it's 10,000 a day.
13
48343
4713
00:53
(Laughter)
14
53056
2661
00:55
("10,000 missiles") This is the context. This is where we are now in Israel.
15
55717
5001
01:00
We have this war with Iran coming for 10 years now,
16
60718
3588
01:04
and we have people, you know, afraid.
17
64306
3375
01:07
It's like every year it's the last minute
18
67681
3563
01:11
that we can do something about the war with Iran.
19
71244
2475
01:13
It's like, if we don't act now, it's too late forever,
20
73719
3672
01:17
for 10 years now.
21
77391
2252
01:19
So at some point it became, you know, to me,
22
79643
2397
01:22
I'm a graphic designer, so I made posters about it
23
82040
3050
01:25
and I posted the one I just showed you before.
24
85090
3975
01:29
Most of the time, I make posters, I post them on Facebook,
25
89065
3062
01:32
my friends like it, don't like it,
26
92127
1657
01:33
most of the time don't like it, don't share it,
27
93784
1731
01:35
don't nothing,
28
95515
2223
01:37
and it's another day.
29
97738
1993
01:39
So I went to sleep, and that was it for me.
30
99731
3952
01:43
And later on in the night, I woke up
31
103683
2916
01:46
because I'm always waking up in the night,
32
106599
1833
01:48
and I went by the computer and I see all these red dots,
33
108432
2575
01:51
you know, on Facebook, which I've never seen before.
34
111007
3152
01:54
(Laughter)
35
114159
1083
01:55
And I was like, "What's going on?"
36
115242
2337
01:57
So I come to the computer and I start looking on,
37
117579
3504
02:01
and suddenly I see many people talking to me,
38
121083
3025
02:04
most of them I don't know,
39
124108
2363
02:06
and a few of them from Iran,
40
126471
2585
02:09
which is -- What?
41
129056
3481
02:12
Because you have to understand,
42
132537
2617
02:15
in Israel we don't talk with people from Iran.
43
135154
3654
02:18
We don't know people from Iran.
44
138808
1970
02:20
It's like, on Facebook, you have friends only from --
45
140778
4365
02:25
it's like your neighbors are your friends on Facebook.
46
145143
3454
02:28
And now people from Iran are talking to me.
47
148597
2737
02:31
So I start answering this girl, and she's telling me
48
151334
3509
02:34
she saw the poster and she asked her family to come,
49
154843
4860
02:39
because they don't have a computer, she asked her family
50
159703
1616
02:41
to come to see the poster, and they're all sitting in the living room crying.
51
161319
4548
02:45
So I'm like, whoa.
52
165867
1682
02:47
I ask my wife to come, and I tell her, you have to see that.
53
167549
3418
02:50
People are crying, and she came, she read the text,
54
170967
3049
02:54
and she started to cry.
55
174016
2700
02:56
And everybody's crying now. (Laughter)
56
176716
2638
02:59
So I don't know what to do, so my first reflex,
57
179354
2800
03:02
as a graphic designer, is, you know, to show everybody
58
182154
3314
03:05
what I'd just seen, and people started to see them
59
185468
3698
03:09
and to share them, and that's how it started.
60
189166
2600
03:11
The day after, when really it became a lot of talking,
61
191766
3739
03:15
I said to myself, and my wife said to me,
62
195505
2223
03:17
I also want a poster,
63
197728
1266
03:18
so this is her. (Laughter)
64
198994
3462
03:22
Because it's working, put me in a poster now.
65
202456
4982
03:27
But more seriously, I was like, okay, these ones work,
66
207438
3110
03:30
but it's not just about me, it's about people from Israel
67
210548
3298
03:33
who want to say something.
68
213846
903
03:34
So I'm going to shoot all the people I know, if they want,
69
214749
2837
03:37
and I'm going to put them in a poster and I'm going to share them.
70
217586
2088
03:39
So I went to my neighbors and friends and students
71
219674
3682
03:43
and I just asked them, give me a picture, I will make you a poster.
72
223356
4091
03:47
And that's how it started. And that's how, really,
73
227447
2897
03:50
it's unleashed, because suddenly people
74
230344
3413
03:53
from Facebook, friends and others,
75
233757
2450
03:56
just understand that they can be part of it.
76
236207
2957
03:59
It's not just one dude making one poster,
77
239164
1734
04:00
it's -- we can be part of it, so they start sending me pictures
78
240898
3513
04:04
and ask me, "Make me a poster. Post it.
79
244411
2376
04:06
Tell the Iranians we from Israel love you too."
80
246787
4634
04:11
It became, you know, at some point it was really, really intense.
81
251421
3368
04:14
I mean, so many pictures, so I asked friends
82
254789
4315
04:19
to come, graphic designers most of them,
83
259104
3123
04:22
to make posters with me, because I didn't have the time.
84
262227
2603
04:24
It was a huge amount of pictures.
85
264830
2656
04:27
So for a few days, that's how my living room was.
86
267486
3395
04:30
And we received Israeli posters, Israeli images,
87
270881
4523
04:35
but also lots of comments, lots of messages from Iran.
88
275404
4686
04:40
And we took these messages and we made posters out of it,
89
280090
3682
04:43
because I know people: They don't read, they see images.
90
283772
3465
04:47
If it's an image, they may read it.
91
287237
2976
04:50
So here are a few of them.
92
290213
2717
04:52
("You are my first Israelian friend. I wish we both get rid of our idiot politicians, anyway nice to see you!")
93
292930
2273
04:55
("I love that blue. I love that star. I love that flag.") This one is really moving for me because it's the story
94
295203
3536
04:58
of a girl who has been raised in Iran
95
298739
3814
05:02
to walk on an Israeli flag to enter her school every morning,
96
302553
5278
05:07
and now that she sees the posters that we're sending,
97
307831
3331
05:11
she starts -- she said that she changed her mind,
98
311162
2675
05:13
and now she loves that blue, she loves that star,
99
313837
3341
05:17
and she loves that flag, talking about the Israeli flag,
100
317178
2335
05:19
and she wished that we'd meet and come to visit one another,
101
319513
3820
05:23
and just a few days after I posted the first poster.
102
323333
5083
05:28
The day after,
103
328416
2612
05:31
Iranians started to respond with their own posters.
104
331028
2717
05:33
They have graphic designers. What? (Laughter)
105
333745
3426
05:37
Crazy, crazy.
106
337171
2342
05:39
So you can see they are still shy, they don't want to show their faces,
107
339513
3525
05:43
but they want to spread the message.
108
343038
1572
05:44
They want to respond. They want to say the same thing.
109
344610
2136
05:46
So. And now it's communication.
110
346746
3105
05:49
It's a two-way story. It's Israelis and Iranians
111
349851
3426
05:53
sending the same message, one to each other.
112
353277
2656
05:55
("My Israeli Friends. I don't hate you. I don't want War.")
113
355933
1678
05:57
This never happened before, and this is two people
114
357611
4160
06:01
supposed to be enemies, we're on the verge of a war,
115
361771
2917
06:04
and suddenly people on Facebook are starting to say,
116
364688
2619
06:07
"I like this guy. I love those guys."
117
367307
4151
06:11
And it became really big at some point.
118
371458
4438
06:15
And then it became news.
119
375896
3312
06:19
Because when you're seeing the Middle East, you see only the bad news.
120
379208
4200
06:23
And suddenly, there is something that was happening
121
383408
2299
06:25
that was good news. So the guys on the news,
122
385707
2826
06:28
they say, "Okay, let's talk about this."
123
388533
1688
06:30
And they just came, and it was so much,
124
390221
3199
06:33
I remember one day, Michal,
125
393420
2439
06:35
she was talking with the journalist, and she was asking him,
126
395859
2800
06:38
"Who's gonna see the show?"And he said, "Everybody."
127
398659
4058
06:42
So she said, "Everybody in Palestine, in where? Israel?
128
402717
5497
06:48
Who is everybody?""Everybody."
129
408214
2916
06:51
They said, "Syria?" "Syria."
130
411130
1614
06:52
"Lebanon?""Lebanon."
131
412744
1740
06:54
At some point, he just said, "40 million people are going to see you today.
132
414484
3971
06:58
It's everybody." The Chinese.
133
418455
2712
07:01
And we were just at the beginning of the story.
134
421167
5626
07:06
Something crazy also happened.
135
426793
2082
07:08
Every time a country started talking about it,
136
428875
3188
07:12
like Germany, America, wherever,
137
432063
3269
07:15
a page on Facebook popped up with the same logo
138
435332
5428
07:20
with the same stories, so at the beginning
139
440760
1757
07:22
we had "Iran-Loves-Israel," which is an Iranian
140
442517
3815
07:26
sitting in Tehran, saying, "Okay, Israel loves Iran?
141
446332
5078
07:31
I give you Iran-Loves-Israel."
142
451410
1910
07:33
You have Palestine-Loves-Israel.
143
453320
1602
07:34
You have Lebanon that just -- a few days ago.
144
454922
2628
07:37
And this whole list of pages on Facebook
145
457550
3468
07:41
dedicated to the same message,
146
461018
2100
07:43
to people sending their love, one to each other.
147
463118
5837
07:48
The moment I really understood that something was happening,
148
468955
3696
07:52
a friend of mine told me,
149
472651
2450
07:55
"Google the word 'Israel.'"
150
475101
2002
07:57
And those were the first images on those days
151
477103
3707
08:00
that popped up from Google
152
480810
2279
08:03
when you were typing, "Israel" or "Iran."
153
483089
3606
08:06
We really changed how people see the Middle East.
154
486695
4314
08:11
Because you're not in the Middle East.
155
491009
1769
08:12
You're somewhere over there, and then you want to see the Middle East,
156
492778
2291
08:15
so you go on Google and you say, "Israel,"
157
495069
1656
08:16
and they give you the bad stuff.
158
496725
1209
08:17
And for a few days you got those images.
159
497934
4769
08:22
Today the Israel-Loves-Iran page
160
502703
2399
08:25
is this number, 80,831, and two million people last week
161
505102
5388
08:30
went on the page and shared, liked, I don't know,
162
510490
2863
08:33
commented on one of the photos.
163
513353
2592
08:35
So for five months now, that's what we are doing,
164
515945
4508
08:40
me, Michal, a few of my friends, are just making images.
165
520453
4750
08:45
We're showing a new reality
166
525203
2287
08:47
by just making images
167
527490
2203
08:49
because that's how the world perceives us.
168
529693
2897
08:52
They see images of us, and they see bad images.
169
532590
2801
08:55
So we're working on making good images. End of story.
170
535391
5051
09:00
Look at this one. This is the Iran-Loves-Israel page.
171
540442
4915
09:05
This is not the Israel-Loves-Iran. This is not my page.
172
545357
2518
09:07
This is a guy in Tehran on the day of remembrance
173
547875
3779
09:11
of the Israeli fallen soldier
174
551654
2542
09:14
putting an image of an Israeli soldier on his page.
175
554196
3963
09:18
This is the enemy.
176
558159
3391
09:21
What?
177
561550
1472
09:23
("Our heartfelt condolences to the families who lost their dearests in terror attack in Bulgaria")
178
563022
2042
09:25
And it's going both ways.
179
565064
1705
09:26
It's like, we are showing respect, one to each other.
180
566769
4538
09:31
And we're understanding. And you show compassion.
181
571307
4986
09:36
And you become friends.
182
576293
4761
09:41
And at some point, you become friends on Facebook,
183
581054
3227
09:44
and you become friends in life.
184
584281
1777
09:46
You can go and travel and meet people.
185
586058
2816
09:48
And I was in Munich a few weeks ago.
186
588874
3378
09:52
I went there to open an exposition about Iran
187
592252
3827
09:56
and I met there with people from the page
188
596079
2457
09:58
that told me, "Okay, you're going to be in Europe,
189
598536
2306
10:00
I'm coming. I'm coming from France, from Holland,
190
600842
2604
10:03
from Germany," of course, and from Israel people came,
191
603446
2721
10:06
and we just met there for the first time in real life.
192
606167
4575
10:10
I met with people that are supposed to be my enemies
193
610742
4517
10:15
for the first time. And we just shake hands,
194
615259
2614
10:17
and have a coffee and a nice discussion,
195
617873
2003
10:19
and we talk about food and basketball.
196
619876
2720
10:22
And that was the end of it.
197
622596
1738
10:24
Remember that image from the beginning?
198
624334
2754
10:27
At some point we met in real life, and we became friends.
199
627088
8381
10:35
And it goes the other way around.
200
635469
2664
10:38
Some girl that we met on Facebook
201
638133
2793
10:40
never been in Israel, born and raised in Iran,
202
640926
2910
10:43
lives in Germany, afraid of Israelis
203
643836
3558
10:47
because of what she knows about us,
204
647394
2230
10:49
decides after a few months of talking on the Internet
205
649624
3614
10:53
with some Israelis to come to Israel,
206
653238
3044
10:56
and she gets on the plane and arrives at Ben Gurion
207
656282
4497
11:00
and says, "Okay, not that big a deal."
208
660779
6127
11:06
So a few weeks ago, the stress is getting higher,
209
666906
3587
11:10
so we start this new campaign
210
670493
2473
11:12
called "Not ready to die in your war."
211
672966
3372
11:16
I mean, it's plus/minus the same message,
212
676338
2813
11:19
but we wanted really to add some aggressivity to it.
213
679151
3674
11:22
And again, something amazing happened,
214
682825
2951
11:25
something that we didn't have on the first wave of the campaign.
215
685776
3338
11:29
Now people from Iran, the same ones who were shy
216
689114
4270
11:33
at the first campaign and just sent, you know,
217
693384
2105
11:35
their foot and half their faces,
218
695489
2188
11:37
now they're sending their faces, and they're saying,
219
697677
2400
11:40
"Okay, no problem, we're into it. We are with you."
220
700077
9065
11:49
Just read where those guys are from.
221
709142
3520
11:52
And for every guy from Israel,
222
712662
2315
11:54
you've got someone from Iran.
223
714977
3291
12:06
Just people sending their pictures.
224
726344
2724
12:26
Crazy, yes?
225
746391
2183
12:28
So --
226
748574
1636
12:30
(Applause)
227
750210
8342
12:39
So you may ask yourself, who is this dude?
228
759467
7397
12:46
My name is Ronny Edry, and I'm 41, I'm an Israeli,
229
766864
3654
12:50
I'm a father of two, I'm a husband,
230
770518
4280
12:54
and I'm a graphic designer. I'm teaching graphic design.
231
774798
4980
12:59
And I'm not that naive, because a lot of the time
232
779778
3768
13:03
I've been asked, many times I've been asked, "Yeah, but,
233
783546
3383
13:06
this is really naive, sending flowers over, I mean — "
234
786929
3226
13:10
I was in the army. I was in the paratroopers for three years,
235
790155
4051
13:14
and I know how it looks from the ground.
236
794206
3550
13:17
I know how it can look really bad.
237
797756
4326
13:22
So to me, this is the courageous thing to do,
238
802082
4137
13:26
to try to reach the other side before it's too late,
239
806219
3439
13:29
because when it's going to be too late, it's going to be too late.
240
809658
1915
13:31
And sometimes war is inevitable, sometimes,
241
811573
4421
13:35
but maybe [with] effort, we can avoid it.
242
815994
4070
13:40
Maybe as people, because especially in Israel,
243
820064
3355
13:43
we're in a democracy. We have the freedom of speech,
244
823419
3413
13:46
and maybe that little thing can change something.
245
826832
3443
13:50
And really, we can be our own ambassadors.
246
830275
4345
13:54
We can just send a message and hope for the best.
247
834620
6736
14:01
So I want to ask Michal, my wife, to come with me
248
841356
2342
14:03
on the stage just to make with you one image,
249
843698
4780
14:08
because it's all about images.
250
848478
2125
14:10
And maybe that image will help us change something.
251
850603
4571
14:15
Just raise that. Exactly.
252
855174
3507
14:18
And I'm just going to take a picture of it,
253
858681
2501
14:21
and I'm just going to post it on Facebook
254
861182
2802
14:23
with kind of "Israelis for peace" or something.
255
863984
5131
14:31
Oh my God.
256
871900
2510
14:34
Don't cry.
257
874410
2362
14:36
Thank you guys.
258
876772
1691
14:38
(Applause)
259
878463
12038

Original video on YouTube.com
About this website

This site will introduce you to YouTube videos that are useful for learning English. You will see English lessons taught by top-notch teachers from around the world. Double-click on the English subtitles displayed on each video page to play the video from there. The subtitles scroll in sync with the video playback. If you have any comments or requests, please contact us using this contact form.

https://forms.gle/WvT1wiN1qDtmnspy7