Alex Steffen: The route to a sustainable future

46,018 views ・ 2007-05-01

TED


Please double-click on the English subtitles below to play the video.

00:25
When I'm starting talks like this,
0
25000
2000
00:27
I usually do a whole spiel about sustainability
1
27000
3000
00:30
because a lot of people out there don't know what that is.
2
30000
2000
00:32
This is a crowd that does know what it is,
3
32000
2000
00:34
so I'll like just do like the 60-second crib-note version. Right?
4
34000
4000
00:38
So just bear with me. We'll go real fast, you know?
5
38000
2000
00:40
Fill in the blanks.
6
40000
1000
00:41
So, you know, sustainability, small planet.
7
41000
3000
00:44
Right? Picture a little Earth, circling around the sun.
8
44000
2000
00:46
You know, about a million years ago,
9
46000
1000
00:47
a bunch of monkeys fell out of trees,
10
47000
2000
00:49
got a little clever, harnessed fire,
11
49000
2000
00:51
invented the printing press,
12
51000
1000
00:52
made, you know, luggage with wheels on it.
13
52000
2000
00:54
And, you know, built the society that we now live in.
14
54000
4000
00:58
Unfortunately, while this society is, without a doubt,
15
58000
3000
01:01
the most prosperous and dynamic the world has ever created,
16
61000
4000
01:05
it's got some major, major flaws.
17
65000
3000
01:08
One of them is that every society has an ecological footprint.
18
68000
4000
01:12
It has an amount of impact on the planet that's measurable.
19
72000
4000
01:16
How much stuff goes through your life,
20
76000
3000
01:19
how much waste is left behind you.
21
79000
3000
01:22
And we, at the moment, in our society,
22
82000
3000
01:25
have a really dramatically unsustainable level of this.
23
85000
4000
01:29
We're using up about five planets.
24
89000
2000
01:31
If everybody on the planet lived the way we did,
25
91000
3000
01:34
we'd need between five, six, seven,
26
94000
2000
01:36
some people even say 10 planets to make it.
27
96000
3000
01:39
Clearly we don't have 10 planets.
28
99000
2000
01:41
Again, you know, mental, visual, 10 planets, one planet,
29
101000
2000
01:43
10 planets, one planet. Right?
30
103000
2000
01:45
We don't have that. So that's one problem.
31
105000
3000
01:48
The second problem is that the planet that we have
32
108000
2000
01:50
is being used in wildly unfair ways. Right?
33
110000
4000
01:54
North Americans, such as myself, you know,
34
114000
3000
01:57
we're basically sort of wallowing, gluttonous hogs,
35
117000
2000
01:59
and we're eating all sorts of stuff.
36
119000
2000
02:01
And, you know, then you get all the way down
37
121000
2000
02:03
to people who live in the Asia-Pacific region, or even more, Africa.
38
123000
4000
02:07
And people simply do not have enough to survive.
39
127000
2000
02:09
This is producing all sorts of tensions,
40
129000
2000
02:11
all sorts of dynamics that are deeply disturbing.
41
131000
3000
02:14
And there's more and more people on the way. Right?
42
134000
4000
02:18
So, this is what the planet's going to look like in 20 years.
43
138000
4000
02:22
It's going to be a pretty crowded place, at least eight billion people.
44
142000
3000
02:25
So to make matters even more difficult, it's a very young planet.
45
145000
4000
02:29
A third of the people on this planet are kids.
46
149000
3000
02:32
And those kids are growing up in a completely different way
47
152000
3000
02:35
than their parents did, no matter where they live.
48
155000
2000
02:37
They've been exposed to this idea of our society, of our prosperity.
49
157000
5000
02:42
And they may not want to live exactly like us.
50
162000
3000
02:45
They may not want to be Americans, or Brits,
51
165000
2000
02:47
or Germans, or South Africans,
52
167000
2000
02:49
but they want their own version
53
169000
2000
02:51
of a life which is more prosperous, and more dynamic,
54
171000
2000
02:53
and more, you know, enjoyable.
55
173000
2000
02:55
And all of these things combine to create
56
175000
3000
02:58
an enormous amount of torque on the planet.
57
178000
3000
03:01
And if we cannot figure out a way to deal with that torque,
58
181000
3000
03:04
we are going to find ourselves more and more and more quickly
59
184000
4000
03:08
facing situations which are simply unthinkable.
60
188000
4000
03:12
Everybody in this room has heard the worst-case scenarios.
61
192000
2000
03:14
I don't need to go into that.
62
194000
2000
03:16
But I will ask the question, what's the alternative?
63
196000
2000
03:18
And I would say that, at the moment, the alternative is unimaginable.
64
198000
5000
03:23
You know, so on the one hand we have the unthinkable;
65
203000
3000
03:26
on the other hand we have the unimaginable.
66
206000
2000
03:28
We don't know yet how to build a society
67
208000
3000
03:31
which is environmentally sustainable,
68
211000
2000
03:33
which is shareable with everybody on the planet,
69
213000
3000
03:36
which promotes stability and democracy and human rights,
70
216000
4000
03:40
and which is achievable in the time-frame necessary
71
220000
3000
03:43
to make it through the challenges we face.
72
223000
3000
03:46
We don't know how to do this yet.
73
226000
2000
03:48
So what's Worldchanging?
74
228000
2000
03:50
Well, Worldchanging you might think of
75
230000
2000
03:52
as being a bit of a news service for the unimaginable future.
76
232000
5000
03:57
You know, what we're out there doing is looking
77
237000
2000
03:59
for examples of tools, models and ideas,
78
239000
3000
04:02
which, if widely adopted, would change the game.
79
242000
4000
04:06
A lot of times, when I do a talk like this, I talk about things
80
246000
3000
04:09
that everybody in this room I'm sure has already heard of,
81
249000
3000
04:12
but most people haven't.
82
252000
2000
04:14
So I thought today I'd do something a little different,
83
254000
2000
04:16
and talk about what we're looking for, rather than saying, you know,
84
256000
3000
04:19
rather than giving you tried-and-true examples.
85
259000
3000
04:22
Talk about the kinds of things we're scoping out.
86
262000
2000
04:24
Give you a little peek into our editorial notebook.
87
264000
2000
04:26
And given that I have 13 minutes to do this, this is going to go kind of quick.
88
266000
3000
04:29
So, I don't know, just stick with me. Right?
89
269000
2000
04:31
So, first of all, what are we looking for? Bright Green city.
90
271000
3000
04:34
One of the biggest levers that we have in the developed world
91
274000
3000
04:37
for changing the impact that we have on the planet
92
277000
2000
04:39
is changing the way that we live in cities.
93
279000
2000
04:41
We're already an urban planet;
94
281000
1000
04:42
that's especially true in the developed world.
95
282000
3000
04:45
And people who live in cities in the developed world
96
285000
2000
04:47
tend to be very prosperous, and thus use a lot of stuff.
97
287000
2000
04:49
If we can change the dynamic,
98
289000
2000
04:51
by first of all creating cities that are denser and more livable ...
99
291000
3000
04:54
Here, for example, is Vancouver, which if you haven't been there,
100
294000
2000
04:56
you ought to go for a visit. It's a fabulous city.
101
296000
2000
04:58
And they are doing density, new density,
102
298000
2000
05:00
better than probably anybody else on the planet right now.
103
300000
2000
05:02
They're actually managing to talk North Americans out of driving cars,
104
302000
3000
05:05
which is a pretty great thing.
105
305000
2000
05:07
So you have density. You also have growth management.
106
307000
2000
05:09
You leave aside what is natural to be natural.
107
309000
3000
05:12
This is in Portland. That is an actual development.
108
312000
3000
05:15
That land there will remain pasture in perpetuity.
109
315000
2000
05:17
They've bounded the city with a line.
110
317000
2000
05:19
Nature, city. Nothing changes.
111
319000
2000
05:22
Once you do those things, you can start making all sorts of investments.
112
322000
3000
05:25
You can start doing things like, you know,
113
325000
2000
05:27
transit systems that actually work to transport people,
114
327000
3000
05:30
in effective and reasonably comfortable manners.
115
330000
3000
05:33
You can also start to change what you build.
116
333000
2000
05:35
This is the Beddington Zero Energy Development in London,
117
335000
3000
05:38
which is one of the greenest buildings in the world. It's a fabulous place.
118
338000
3000
05:41
We're able to now build buildings that generate all their own electricity,
119
341000
3000
05:44
that recycle much of their water,
120
344000
2000
05:46
that are much more comfortable than standard buildings,
121
346000
3000
05:49
use all-natural light, etc., and, over time, cost less.
122
349000
4000
05:53
Green roofs. Bill McDonough covered that last night, so I won't dwell on that too much.
123
353000
4000
05:57
But once you also have people living
124
357000
2000
05:59
in close proximity to each other,
125
359000
2000
06:01
one of the things you can do is --
126
361000
2000
06:03
as information technologies develop --
127
363000
2000
06:05
you can start to have smart places.
128
365000
2000
06:07
You can start to know where things are.
129
367000
2000
06:09
When you know where things are, it becomes easier to share them.
130
369000
2000
06:11
When you share them, you end up using less.
131
371000
3000
06:14
So one great example is car-share clubs,
132
374000
2000
06:16
which are really starting to take off in the U.S.,
133
376000
2000
06:18
have already taken off in many places in Europe, and are a great example.
134
378000
3000
06:21
If you're somebody who drives, you know, one day a week,
135
381000
2000
06:23
do you really need your own car?
136
383000
2000
06:26
Another thing that information technology lets us do
137
386000
2000
06:28
is start figuring out how to use less stuff
138
388000
2000
06:30
by knowing, and by monitoring, the amount we're actually using.
139
390000
5000
06:35
So, here's a power cord which glows brighter the more energy that you use,
140
395000
3000
06:38
which I think is a pretty cool concept,
141
398000
2000
06:40
although I think it ought to work the other way around,
142
400000
2000
06:42
that it gets brighter the more you don't use.
143
402000
3000
06:45
But, you know, there may even be a simpler approach.
144
405000
2000
06:47
We could just re-label things.
145
407000
2000
06:49
This light switch that reads, on the one hand, flashfloods,
146
409000
2000
06:51
and on the other hand, off.
147
411000
2000
06:53
How we build things can change as well.
148
413000
2000
06:55
This is a bio-morphic building.
149
415000
2000
06:57
It takes its inspiration in form from life.
150
417000
4000
07:01
Many of these buildings are incredibly beautiful,
151
421000
2000
07:03
and also much more effective.
152
423000
2000
07:06
This is an example of bio-mimicry,
153
426000
2000
07:08
which is something we're really starting to look a lot more for.
154
428000
2000
07:10
In this case, you have a shell design
155
430000
2000
07:12
which was used to create a new kind of exhaust fan, which is greatly more effective.
156
432000
4000
07:16
There's a lot of this stuff happening; it's really pretty remarkable.
157
436000
3000
07:20
I encourage you to look on Worldchanging if you're into it.
158
440000
2000
07:22
We're starting to cover this more and more.
159
442000
2000
07:24
There's also neo-biological design,
160
444000
2000
07:26
where more and more we're actually using life itself
161
446000
2000
07:28
and the processes of life to become part of our industry.
162
448000
3000
07:31
So this, for example, is hydrogen-generating algae.
163
451000
3000
07:34
So we have a model in potential, an emerging model that we're looking for
164
454000
4000
07:38
of how to take the cities most of us live in,
165
458000
3000
07:41
and turn them into Bright Green cities.
166
461000
2000
07:43
But unfortunately, most of the people on the planet don't live in the cites we live in.
167
463000
5000
07:48
They live in the emerging megacities of the developing world.
168
468000
3000
07:51
And there's a statistic I often like to use,
169
471000
2000
07:53
which is that we're adding a city of Seattle every four days,
170
473000
3000
07:56
a city the size of Seattle to the planet every four days.
171
476000
3000
07:59
I was giving a talk about two months ago,
172
479000
2000
08:01
and this guy, who'd done some work with the U.N., came up to me
173
481000
2000
08:03
and was really flustered, and he said, look,
174
483000
2000
08:05
you've got that totally wrong; it's totally wrong.
175
485000
2000
08:07
It's every seven days.
176
487000
2000
08:10
So, we're adding a city the size of Seattle every seven days,
177
490000
3000
08:13
and most of those cities look more like this than the city that you or I live in.
178
493000
4000
08:17
Most of those cites are growing incredibly quickly.
179
497000
3000
08:20
They don't have existing infrastructure;
180
500000
2000
08:22
they have enormous numbers of people who are struggling with poverty,
181
502000
3000
08:25
and enormous numbers of people are trying to figure out
182
505000
2000
08:27
how to do things in new ways.
183
507000
2000
08:29
So what do we need in order to make developing nation
184
509000
4000
08:33
megacities into Bright Green megacities?
185
513000
3000
08:36
Well, the first thing we need is, we need leapfrogging.
186
516000
3000
08:39
And this is one of the things that we are looking for everywhere.
187
519000
3000
08:42
The idea behind leapfrogging is that
188
522000
2000
08:44
if you are a person, or a country, who is stuck in a situation
189
524000
3000
08:47
where you don't have the tools and technologies that you need,
190
527000
3000
08:50
there's no reason for you to invest in last generation's technologies. Right?
191
530000
6000
08:56
That you're much better off, almost universally,
192
536000
2000
08:58
looking for a low-cost or locally applicable version of the newest technology.
193
538000
5000
09:03
One place we're all familiar with seeing this is with cell phones. Right?
194
543000
4000
09:07
All throughout the developing world, people are going directly to cell phones,
195
547000
4000
09:11
skipping the whole landline stage.
196
551000
2000
09:13
If there are landlines in many developing world cities,
197
553000
2000
09:15
they're usually pretty crappy systems that break down a lot
198
555000
3000
09:18
and cost enormous amounts of money.
199
558000
2000
09:20
So I rather like this picture here.
200
560000
2000
09:22
I particularly like the Ganesh in the background, talking on the cell phone.
201
562000
4000
09:26
So what we have, increasingly, is cell phones just permeating out through society.
202
566000
4000
09:30
We've heard all about this here this week,
203
570000
2000
09:32
so I won't say too much more than that, other than to say
204
572000
2000
09:34
what is true for cell phones is true for all sorts of technologies.
205
574000
5000
09:39
The second thing is tools for collaboration,
206
579000
3000
09:42
be they systems of collaboration, or intellectual property systems
207
582000
3000
09:45
which encourage collaboration. Right?
208
585000
2000
09:47
When you have free ability for people to freely work together and innovate,
209
587000
4000
09:51
you get different kinds of solutions.
210
591000
2000
09:53
And those solutions are accessible in a different way
211
593000
3000
09:56
to people who don't have capital. Right?
212
596000
2000
09:58
So, you know, we have open source software,
213
598000
3000
10:01
we have Creative Commons and other kinds of Copyleft solutions.
214
601000
5000
10:06
And those things lead to things like this.
215
606000
2000
10:08
This is a Telecentro in Sao Paulo.
216
608000
3000
10:11
This is a pretty remarkable program
217
611000
2000
10:13
using free and open source software, cheap, sort of hacked-together machines,
218
613000
4000
10:17
and basically sort of abandoned buildings --
219
617000
3000
10:20
has put together a bunch of community centers
220
620000
2000
10:22
where people can come in, get high-speed internet access,
221
622000
3000
10:25
learn computer programming skills for free.
222
625000
3000
10:29
And a quarter-million people every year use these now in Sao Paulo.
223
629000
3000
10:33
And those quarter-million people are some of the poorest people in Sao Paolo.
224
633000
3000
10:36
I particularly like the little Linux penguin in the back. (Laughter)
225
636000
3000
10:40
So one of the things that that's leading to is a sort of southern cultural explosion.
226
640000
5000
10:45
And one of the things we're really, really interested in at Worldchanging
227
645000
3000
10:48
is the ways in which the south is re-identifying itself,
228
648000
4000
10:52
and re-categorizing itself in ways
229
652000
3000
10:55
that have less and less to do with most of us in this room.
230
655000
3000
10:58
So it's not, you know, Bollywood isn't just answering Hollywood. Right?
231
658000
5000
11:03
You know, Brazilian music scene isn't just answering the major labels.
232
663000
3000
11:06
It's doing something new. There's new things happening.
233
666000
3000
11:09
There's interplay between them. And, you know, you get amazing things.
234
669000
3000
11:12
Like, I don't know if any of you have seen the movie "City of God?"
235
672000
3000
11:15
Yeah, it's a fabulous movie if you haven't seen it.
236
675000
3000
11:18
And it's all about this question, in a very artistic and indirect kind of way.
237
678000
3000
11:21
You have other radical examples
238
681000
2000
11:23
where the ability to use cultural tools is spreading out.
239
683000
3000
11:26
These are people who have just been visited by
240
686000
2000
11:28
the Internet bookmobile in Uganda.
241
688000
2000
11:30
And who are waving their first books in the air,
242
690000
2000
11:32
which, I just think that's a pretty cool picture. You know?
243
692000
3000
11:35
So you also have the ability for people to start coming together
244
695000
4000
11:39
and acting on their own behalf in political and civic ways,
245
699000
5000
11:45
in ways that haven't happened before.
246
705000
3000
11:48
And as we heard last night, as we've heard earlier this week,
247
708000
2000
11:50
are absolutely, fundamentally vital to the ability to craft new solutions,
248
710000
6000
11:56
is we've got to craft new political realities.
249
716000
3000
11:59
And I would personally say that we have to craft new political realities,
250
719000
4000
12:03
not only in places like India, Afghanistan, Kenya, Pakistan,
251
723000
5000
12:08
what have you, but here at home as well.
252
728000
2000
12:10
Another world is possible.
253
730000
2000
12:12
And sort of the big motto of the anti-globalization movement. Right?
254
732000
4000
12:16
We tweak that a lot.
255
736000
2000
12:18
We talk about how another world isn't just possible; another world's here.
256
738000
3000
12:21
That it's not just that we have to sort of imagine
257
741000
2000
12:23
there being a different, vague possibility out there,
258
743000
4000
12:27
but we need to start acting a little bit more on that possibility.
259
747000
4000
12:31
We need to start doing things like Lula, President of Brazil.
260
751000
3000
12:34
How many people knew of Lula before today?
261
754000
3000
12:37
OK, so, much, much better than the average crowd, I can tell you that.
262
757000
4000
12:41
So Lula, he's full of problems, full of contradictions,
263
761000
2000
12:43
but one of the things that he's doing is,
264
763000
2000
12:45
he is putting forward an idea of how we engage in international relations that
265
765000
6000
12:51
completely shifts the balance from the standard sort of north-south dialogue
266
771000
6000
12:57
into a whole new way of global collaboration.
267
777000
4000
13:01
I would keep your eye on this fellow.
268
781000
2000
13:04
Another example of this sort of second superpower thing
269
784000
3000
13:07
is the rise of these games that are what we call "serious play."
270
787000
4000
13:11
We're looking a lot at this. This is spreading everywhere.
271
791000
2000
13:13
This is from "A Force More Powerful." It's a little screenshot.
272
793000
3000
13:16
"A Force More Powerful" is a video game that,
273
796000
2000
13:18
while you're playing it, it teaches you how to engage
274
798000
3000
13:21
in non-violent insurrection and regime change. (Laughter)
275
801000
2000
13:23
Here's another one. This is from a game called "Food Force,"
276
803000
3000
13:26
which is a game that teaches children how to run a refugee camp.
277
806000
3000
13:30
These things are all contributing in a very dynamic way
278
810000
4000
13:34
to a huge rise in, especially in the developing world,
279
814000
5000
13:39
in people's interest in and passion for democracy.
280
819000
3000
13:42
We get so little news about the developing world
281
822000
3000
13:45
that we often forget that there are literally
282
825000
4000
13:49
millions of people out there struggling to change things
283
829000
2000
13:51
to be fairer, freer, more democratic, less corrupt.
284
831000
4000
13:55
And, you know, we don't hear those stories enough.
285
835000
2000
13:57
But it's happening all over the place,
286
837000
2000
13:59
and these tools are part of what's making it possible.
287
839000
2000
14:01
Now when you add all those things together,
288
841000
2000
14:03
when you add together leapfrogging and new kinds of tools,
289
843000
2000
14:05
you know, second superpower stuff, etc., what do you get?
290
845000
4000
14:09
Well, very quickly, you get a Bright Green future for the developing world.
291
849000
4000
14:13
You get, for example, green power spread throughout the world.
292
853000
4000
14:17
You get -- this is a building in Hyderabad, India.
293
857000
2000
14:19
It's the greenest building in the world.
294
859000
2000
14:21
You get grassroots solutions, things that work
295
861000
2000
14:23
for people who have no capital or limited access.
296
863000
2000
14:25
You get barefoot solar engineers carrying solar panels into the remote mountains.
297
865000
4000
14:29
You get access to distance medicine.
298
869000
2000
14:31
These are Indian nurses learning how to use PDAs
299
871000
3000
14:34
to access databases that have information
300
874000
2000
14:36
that they don't have access to at home in a distant manner.
301
876000
3000
14:39
You get new tools for people in the developing world.
302
879000
3000
14:42
These are LED lights that help the roughly billion people out there,
303
882000
4000
14:46
for whom nightfall means darkness,
304
886000
2000
14:48
to have a new means of operating.
305
888000
2000
14:50
These are refrigerators that require no electricity;
306
890000
3000
14:53
they're pot within a pot design.
307
893000
2000
14:55
And you get water solutions. Water's one of the most pressing problems.
308
895000
3000
14:58
Here's a design for harvesting rainwater that's super cheap
309
898000
2000
15:00
and available to people in the developing world.
310
900000
2000
15:02
Here's a design for distilling water using sunlight.
311
902000
4000
15:07
Here's a fog-catcher, which, if you live in a moist, jungle-like area,
312
907000
5000
15:12
will distill water from the air that's clean and drinkable.
313
912000
3000
15:15
Here's a way of transporting water.
314
915000
2000
15:17
I just love this, you know -- I mean carrying water is such a drag,
315
917000
3000
15:20
and somebody just came up with the idea of well, what if you rolled it. Right?
316
920000
3000
15:23
I mean, that's a great design.
317
923000
2000
15:25
This is a fabulous invention, LifeStraw.
318
925000
3000
15:28
Basically you can suck any water through this
319
928000
3000
15:31
and it will become drinkable by the time it hits your lips.
320
931000
3000
15:34
So, you know, people who are in desperate straits can get this.
321
934000
3000
15:37
This is one of my favorite Worldchanging kinds of things ever.
322
937000
3000
15:40
This is a merry-go-round invented by the company Roundabout,
323
940000
3000
15:43
which pumps water as kids play. You know?
324
943000
4000
15:48
Seriously -- give that one a hand, it's pretty great.
325
948000
3000
15:51
And the same thing is true for people who are in absolute crisis. Right?
326
951000
4000
15:55
We're expecting to have upwards of 200 million refugees by the year 2020
327
955000
4000
15:59
because of climate change and political instability.
328
959000
2000
16:01
How do we help people like that?
329
961000
2000
16:03
Well, there's all sorts of amazing new humanitarian designs
330
963000
2000
16:05
that are being developed in collaborative ways all across the planet.
331
965000
3000
16:08
Some of those designs include models for acting,
332
968000
3000
16:11
such as new models for village instruction in the middle of refugee camps.
333
971000
3000
16:14
New models for pedagogy for the displaced.
334
974000
3000
16:17
And we have new tools.
335
977000
2000
16:19
This is one of my absolute favorite things anywhere.
336
979000
2000
16:21
Does anyone know what this is?
337
981000
2000
16:23
Audience: It detects landmines.
338
983000
1000
16:24
Alex Steffen: Exactly, this is a landmine-detecting flower.
339
984000
3000
16:28
If you are living in one of the places
340
988000
2000
16:30
where the roughly half-billion unaccounted for mines are scattered,
341
990000
3000
16:33
you can fling these seeds out into the field.
342
993000
3000
16:36
And as they grow up, they will grow up around the mines,
343
996000
4000
16:40
their roots will detect the chemicals in them,
344
1000000
3000
16:43
and where the flowers turn red you don't step.
345
1003000
3000
16:48
Yeah, so seeds that could save your life. You know?
346
1008000
4000
16:52
(Applause)
347
1012000
1000
16:53
I also love it because it seems to me
348
1013000
2000
16:55
that the example, the tools we use to change the world,
349
1015000
6000
17:01
ought to be beautiful in themselves.
350
1021000
3000
17:04
You know, that it's not just enough to survive.
351
1024000
2000
17:06
We've got to make something better than what we've got.
352
1026000
3000
17:10
And I think that we will.
353
1030000
2000
17:13
Just to wrap up, in the immortal words of H.G. Wells,
354
1033000
3000
17:16
I think that better things are on the way.
355
1036000
2000
17:18
I think that, in fact, that "all of the past is but the beginning of a beginning.
356
1038000
4000
17:22
All that the human mind has accomplished
357
1042000
2000
17:24
is but the dream before the awakening."
358
1044000
2000
17:26
I hope that that turns out to be true.
359
1046000
3000
17:29
The people in this room have given me more confidence than ever that it will.
360
1049000
3000
17:32
Thank you very much.
361
1052000
1000
17:33
(Applause)
362
1053000
2000
About this website

This site will introduce you to YouTube videos that are useful for learning English. You will see English lessons taught by top-notch teachers from around the world. Double-click on the English subtitles displayed on each video page to play the video from there. The subtitles scroll in sync with the video playback. If you have any comments or requests, please contact us using this contact form.

https://forms.gle/WvT1wiN1qDtmnspy7