Thomas Hellum: The world's most boring television ... and why it's hilariously addictive

275,820 views ・ 2014-12-10

TED


Please double-click on the English subtitles below to play the video.

00:13
Thank you.
0
13167
1307
00:14
I have only got 18 minutes
1
14474
1509
00:15
to explain something that lasts for hours and days,
2
15983
2849
00:18
so I'd better get started.
3
18832
2270
00:21
Let's start with a clip from Al Jazeera's Listening Post.
4
21102
4857
00:26
Richard Gizbert: Norway is a country that gets relatively little media coverage.
5
26649
3847
00:30
Even the elections this past week passed without much drama.
6
30496
2991
00:33
And that's the Norwegian media in a nutshell:
7
33487
2658
00:36
not much drama.
8
36145
1477
00:37
A few years back,
9
37622
1337
00:38
Norway's public TV channel NRK
10
38959
2457
00:41
decided to broadcast live coverage of a seven-hour train ride --
11
41416
4177
00:45
seven hours of simple footage,
12
45593
2301
00:47
a train rolling down the tracks.
13
47894
2229
00:50
Norwegians, more than a million of them according to the ratings, loved it.
14
50123
3862
00:53
A new kind of reality TV show was born,
15
53985
2916
00:56
and it goes against all the rules of TV engagement.
16
56901
3135
01:00
There is no story line, no script,
17
60036
2440
01:02
no drama, no climax,
18
62476
2043
01:04
and it's called Slow TV.
19
64519
1924
01:06
For the past two months,
20
66443
1472
01:07
Norwegians have been watching a cruise ship's journey up the coast,
21
67915
3592
01:11
and there's a lot of fog on that coast.
22
71507
2059
01:13
Executives at Norway's National Broadcasting Service
23
73566
3073
01:16
are now considering broadcasting a night of knitting nationwide.
24
76639
4090
01:20
On the surface, it sounds boring,
25
80729
2481
01:23
because it is,
26
83210
1300
01:24
but something about this TV experiment
27
84510
2090
01:26
has gripped Norwegians.
28
86600
1858
01:28
So we sent the Listening Post's Marcela Pizarro to Oslo
29
88458
3157
01:31
to find out what it is, but first a warning:
30
91615
2531
01:34
Viewers may find some of the images in the following report disappointing.
31
94146
4503
01:38
(Laughter)
32
98649
1015
01:40
Thomas Hellum: And then follows an eight-minute story on Al Jazeera
33
100034
3516
01:43
about some strange TV programs in little Norway.
34
103550
3326
01:46
Al Jazeera. CNN. How did we get there?
35
106876
3058
01:49
We have to go back to 2009,
36
109934
2020
01:51
when one of my colleagues got a great idea.
37
111954
1999
01:53
Where do you get your ideas?
38
113953
1803
01:55
In the lunchroom.
39
115756
1481
01:57
So he said, why don't we make a radio program
40
117737
2977
02:00
marking the day of the German invasion of Norway in 1940.
41
120714
3585
02:04
We tell the story at the exact time during the night.
42
124299
4044
02:08
Wow. Brilliant idea, except
43
128343
2164
02:10
this was just a couple of weeks before the invasion day.
44
130507
2903
02:13
So we sat in our lunchroom and discussed
45
133410
2345
02:15
what other stories can you tell as they evolve?
46
135755
4208
02:19
What other things take a really long time?
47
139963
4138
02:24
So one of us came up with a train.
48
144421
2316
02:26
The Bergen Railway had its 100-year anniversary that year
49
146737
3992
02:30
It goes from western Norway to eastern Norway,
50
150729
2695
02:33
and it takes exactly the same time as it did 40 years ago,
51
153424
4163
02:37
over seven hours. (Laughter)
52
157587
3198
02:40
So we caught our commissioning editors in Oslo, and we said,
53
160785
2986
02:43
we want to make a documentary about the Bergen Railway,
54
163771
2987
02:46
and we want to make it in full length,
55
166758
1952
02:48
and the answer was,
56
168710
1354
02:50
"Yes, but how long will the program be?"
57
170064
1935
02:51
"Oh," we said, "full length."
58
171999
1858
02:53
"Yes, but we mean the program."
59
173857
1492
02:55
And back and forth.
60
175349
2107
02:57
Luckily for us, they met us with laughter, very, very good laughter,
61
177456
5487
03:02
so one bright day in September,
62
182943
2686
03:05
we started a program that we thought should be seven hours and four minutes.
63
185629
3986
03:09
Actually, it turned out to be seven hours and 14 minutes
64
189615
2864
03:12
due to a signal failure at the last station.
65
192479
4504
03:16
We had four cameras,
66
196983
1974
03:18
three of them pointing out to the beautiful nature.
67
198957
3306
03:22
Some talking to the guests, some information.
68
202263
3970
03:26
(Video) Train announcement: We will arrive at Haugastøl Station.
69
206233
4050
03:30
TH: And that's about it,
70
210283
1368
03:31
but of course, also
71
211651
1795
03:33
the 160 tunnels gave us the opportunity to do some archives.
72
213446
3841
03:37
Narrator [in Norwegian]: Then a bit of flirting while the food is digested.
73
217287
3896
03:42
The last downhill stretch before we reach our destination.
74
222483
4348
03:47
We pass Mjølfjell Station.
75
227901
3356
03:52
Then a new tunnel.
76
232207
2408
03:54
(Laughter)
77
234615
1150
03:55
TH: And now we thought, yes, we have a brilliant program.
78
235765
3257
03:59
It will fit for the 2,000 train spotters in Norway.
79
239022
4597
04:03
We brought it on air in November 2009.
80
243619
2601
04:06
But no, this was far more attractive.
81
246220
2447
04:08
This is the five biggest TV channels in Norway on a normal Friday,
82
248667
3822
04:12
and if you look at NRK2 over here,
83
252489
2299
04:14
look what happened when they put on the Bergen Railway show:
84
254788
3396
04:18
1.2 million Norwegians watched part of this program.
85
258984
3725
04:22
(Applause)
86
262709
2325
04:26
And another funny thing:
87
266624
2186
04:28
When the host on our main channel,
88
268810
1947
04:30
after they have got news for you,
89
270757
2467
04:33
she said, "And on our second channel,
90
273224
2438
04:35
the train has now nearly reached Myrdal station."
91
275662
2995
04:38
Thousands of people just jumped on the train
92
278657
2693
04:41
on our second channel like this. (Laughter)
93
281350
4016
04:45
This was also a huge success in terms of social media.
94
285366
3646
04:49
It was so nice to see all the thousands of Facebook and Twitter users
95
289012
4104
04:53
discussing the same view,
96
293116
2861
04:55
talking to each other as if they were on the same train together.
97
295977
4486
05:00
And especially, I like this one. It's a 76-year-old man.
98
300463
3285
05:03
He's watched all the program,
99
303748
1680
05:05
and at the end station, he rises up to pick up what he thinks is his luggage,
100
305428
4017
05:09
and his head hit the curtain rod,
101
309445
3558
05:13
and he realized he is in his own living room.
102
313003
2688
05:15
(Applause)
103
315691
4528
05:21
So that's strong and living TV.
104
321426
4644
05:26
Four hundred and thirty-six minute by minute on a Friday night,
105
326070
3344
05:29
and during that first night,
106
329414
1861
05:31
the first Twitter message came: Why be a chicken?
107
331275
2554
05:33
Why stop at 436 when you can expand that
108
333829
5669
05:39
to 8,040, minute by minute,
109
339498
3661
05:43
and do the iconic journey in Norway,
110
343159
2206
05:45
the coastal ship journey Hurtigruten from Bergen to Kirkenes,
111
345365
3442
05:48
almost 3,000 kilometers, covering most of our coast.
112
348807
3554
05:52
It has 120-year-old, very interesting history,
113
352361
4578
05:56
and literally takes part in life and death along the coast.
114
356939
4816
06:01
So just a week after the Bergen Railway,
115
361755
2371
06:04
we called the Hurtigruten company and we started planning for our next show.
116
364126
4746
06:10
We wanted to do something different.
117
370082
2163
06:12
The Bergen Railway was a recorded program.
118
372245
3281
06:15
So when we sat in our editing room,
119
375526
2090
06:17
we watched this picture -- it's all Ål Station --
120
377616
2604
06:20
we saw this journalist.
121
380220
1508
06:21
We had called him, we had spoken to him,
122
381728
1953
06:23
and when we left the station,
123
383681
1856
06:25
he took this picture of us and he waved to the camera,
124
385537
3191
06:28
and we thought,
125
388728
1460
06:30
what if more people knew that we were on board that train?
126
390188
3252
06:33
Would more people show up?
127
393440
1846
06:35
What would it look like?
128
395286
1973
06:37
So we decided our next project, it should be live.
129
397259
3530
06:40
We wanted this picture of us on the fjord and on the screen at the same time.
130
400789
4905
06:47
So this is not the first time NRK had been on board a ship.
131
407034
3321
06:50
This is back in 1964,
132
410355
1718
06:52
when the technical managers have suits and ties
133
412073
2856
06:54
and NRK rolled all its equipment on board a ship,
134
414929
4040
06:58
and 200 meters out of the shore, transmitting the signal back,
135
418969
4040
07:03
and in the machine room, they talked to the machine guy,
136
423009
3948
07:06
and on the deck, they have splendid entertainment.
137
426957
4153
07:11
So being on a ship, it's not the first time.
138
431110
5179
07:17
But five and a half days in a row, and live, we wanted some help.
139
437309
5026
07:22
And we asked our viewers out there, what do you want to see?
140
442335
4163
07:26
What do you want us to film? How do you want this to look?
141
446498
4112
07:30
Do you want us to make a website? What do you want on it?
142
450610
2708
07:33
And we got some answers from you out there,
143
453318
2238
07:35
and it helped us a very lot to build the program.
144
455556
4251
07:39
So in June 2011,
145
459807
2855
07:42
23 of us went on board the Hurtigruten coastal ship
146
462662
3784
07:46
and we set off.
147
466446
1718
07:48
(Music)
148
468164
3832
08:47
I have some really strong memories from that week, and it's all about people.
149
527373
3719
08:51
This guy, for instance,
150
531092
1640
08:52
he's head of research at the University in Tromsø
151
532732
2693
08:55
(Laughter)
152
535425
1763
08:57
And I will show you a piece of cloth,
153
537188
4883
09:02
this one.
154
542071
3227
09:06
It's the other strong memory.
155
546378
1544
09:07
It belongs to a guy called Erik Hansen.
156
547922
3854
09:12
And it's people like those two who took a firm grip of our program,
157
552796
8022
09:20
and together with thousands of others along the route,
158
560818
3821
09:24
they made the program what it became.
159
564639
2880
09:27
They made all the stories.
160
567519
2528
09:30
This is Karl. He's in the ninth grade.
161
570047
3044
09:33
It says, "I will be a little late for school tomorrow."
162
573091
3622
09:36
He was supposed to be in the school at 8 a.m.
163
576713
2670
09:39
He came at 9 a.m., and he didn't get a note from his teacher,
164
579383
3101
09:42
because the teacher had watched the program.
165
582484
2101
09:44
(Laughter)
166
584585
1461
09:46
How did we do this?
167
586046
1673
09:47
Yes, we took a conference room on board the Hurtigruten.
168
587719
3216
09:50
We turned it into a complete TV control room.
169
590935
3112
09:54
We made it all work, of course,
170
594047
3053
09:57
and then we took along 11 cameras.
171
597100
2159
09:59
This is one of them.
172
599259
1115
10:00
This is my sketch from February,
173
600374
1973
10:02
and when you give this sketch to professional people
174
602347
2508
10:04
in the Norwegian broadcasting company NRK,
175
604855
2229
10:07
you get some cool stuff back.
176
607084
2940
10:10
And with some very creative solutions.
177
610024
3607
10:14
(Video) Narrator [in Norwegian]: Run it up and down.
178
614201
2518
10:16
This is Norway's most important drill right now.
179
616719
3422
10:20
It regulates the height of a bow camera in NRK's live production,
180
620141
5913
10:26
one of 11 that capture great shots from the MS Nord-Norge.
181
626054
4736
10:30
Eight wires keep the camera stable.
182
630790
2671
10:33
Cameraman: I work on different camera solutions.
183
633461
3645
10:37
They're just tools used in a different context.
184
637106
3854
10:40
TH: Another camera is this one. It's normally used for sports.
185
640960
3344
10:44
It made it possible for us to take close-up pictures of people
186
644304
3599
10:47
100 kilomteres away,
187
647903
2020
10:49
like this one. (Laughter)
188
649923
4435
10:54
People called us and asked, how is this man doing?
189
654358
2832
10:57
He's doing fine. Everything went well.
190
657190
2949
11:00
We also could take pictures of people waving at us,
191
660139
3233
11:03
people along the route, thousands of them,
192
663372
2317
11:05
and they all had a phone in their hand.
193
665689
2425
11:08
And when you take a picture of them, and they get the message,
194
668114
2985
11:11
"Now we are on TV, dad," they start waving back.
195
671099
2855
11:13
This was waving TV for five and a half days,
196
673954
2160
11:16
and people get so extremely happy
197
676114
2159
11:18
when they can send a warm message to their loved ones.
198
678273
4817
11:23
It was also a great success on social media.
199
683090
3519
11:26
On the last day, we met Her Majesty the Queen of Norway,
200
686609
2809
11:29
and Twitter couldn't quite handle it.
201
689418
3599
11:33
And we also, on the web,
202
693017
2369
11:35
during this week we streamed more than 100 years of video
203
695386
4874
11:40
to 148 nations,
204
700260
3368
11:43
and the websites are still there and they will be forever, actually,
205
703628
4201
11:47
because Hurtigruten was selected
206
707829
1906
11:49
to be part of the Norwegian UNESCO list of documents,
207
709735
4532
11:54
and it's also in the Guinness Book of Records
208
714267
2991
11:57
as the longest documentary ever.
209
717258
3506
12:00
(Applause)
210
720764
3483
12:04
Thank you.
211
724247
3738
12:07
But it's a long program,
212
727985
3390
12:11
so some watched part of it, like the Prime Minister.
213
731375
3088
12:14
Some watched a little bit more.
214
734463
1742
12:16
It says, "I haven't used my bed for five days."
215
736205
4409
12:20
And he's 82 years old, and he hardly slept.
216
740614
4471
12:25
He kept watching because something might happen,
217
745085
3356
12:28
though it probably won't. (Laughter)
218
748441
2413
12:30
This is the number of viewers along the route.
219
750854
2649
12:33
You can see the famous Trollfjord
220
753503
1602
12:35
and a day after, all-time high for NRK2.
221
755105
4744
12:39
If you see the four biggest channels in Norway during June 2011,
222
759849
5822
12:45
they will look like this,
223
765671
2297
12:47
and as a TV producer, it's a pleasure to put Hurtigruten on top of it.
224
767968
3850
12:51
It looks like this:
225
771818
1723
12:53
3.2 million Norwegians watched part of this program,
226
773541
3367
12:56
and we are only five million here.
227
776908
1880
12:58
Even the passengers on board the Hurtigruten coastal ship --
228
778788
3034
13:01
(Laughter) --
229
781822
1614
13:03
they chose to watched the telly instead of turning 90 degrees
230
783436
4125
13:07
and watching out the window.
231
787561
2114
13:10
So we were allowed to be part of people's living room
232
790435
2981
13:13
with this strange TV program,
233
793416
2757
13:16
with music, nature, people.
234
796173
3373
13:19
And Slow TV was now a buzzword,
235
799546
2693
13:22
and we started looking for other things we could make Slow TV about.
236
802239
3834
13:26
So we could either take something long and make it a topic,
237
806073
3442
13:29
like with the railway and the Hurtigruten,
238
809515
2221
13:31
or we could take a topic and make it long.
239
811736
2531
13:34
This is the last project. It's the peep show.
240
814267
2508
13:36
It's 14 hours of birdwatching on a TV screen,
241
816775
2786
13:39
actually 87 days on the web.
242
819561
3181
13:42
We have made 18 hours of live salmon fishing.
243
822742
3622
13:46
It actually took three hours before we got the first fish,
244
826364
3065
13:49
and that's quite slow.
245
829429
1811
13:51
We have made 12 hours of boat ride into the beautiful Telemark Canal,
246
831240
5036
13:56
and we have made another train ride with the northern railway,
247
836276
3545
13:59
and because this we couldn't do live, we did it in four seasons
248
839821
4002
14:03
just to give the viewer another experience on the way.
249
843823
4075
14:09
So our next project got us some attention outside Norway.
250
849058
4540
14:13
This is from the Colbert Report on Comedy Central.
251
853598
2886
14:16
(Video) Stephen Colbert: I've got my eye on a wildly popular program from Norway
252
856484
3796
14:20
called "National Firewood Night,"
253
860280
2933
14:23
which consisted of mostly people in parkas chatting and chopping in the woods,
254
863213
4272
14:27
and then eight hours of a fire burning in a fireplace. (Laughter)
255
867485
3645
14:31
It destroyed the other top Norwegian shows,
256
871130
2601
14:33
like "So You Think You Can Watch Paint Dry"
257
873731
2415
14:36
and "The Amazing Glacier Race."
258
876146
3831
14:39
And get this, almost 20 percent of the Norwegian population tuned in,
259
879977
5205
14:45
20 percent.
260
885182
1668
14:46
TH: So, when wood fire and wood chopping can be that interesting,
261
886850
3877
14:50
why not knitting?
262
890727
1533
14:52
So on our next project,
263
892260
1718
14:53
we used more than eight hours to go live from a sheep to a sweater,
264
893978
5017
14:58
and Jimmy Kimmel in the ABC show,
265
898995
2307
15:01
he liked that.
266
901302
2149
15:03
(Music)
267
903451
6873
15:10
(Video) Jimmy Kimmel: Even the people on the show are falling asleep,
268
910324
3720
15:14
and after all that, the knitters actually failed
269
914044
2276
15:16
to break the world record.
270
916320
1676
15:17
They did not succeed,
271
917996
1346
15:19
but remember the old Norwegian saying,
272
919342
2243
15:21
it's not whether you win or lose that counts.
273
921585
2178
15:23
In fact, nothing counts, and death is coming for us all.
274
923763
2724
15:26
(Laughter)
275
926487
1444
15:27
TH: Exactly. So why does this stand out?
276
927931
2894
15:30
This is so completely different to other TV programming.
277
930825
3280
15:34
We take the viewer on a journey that happens right now in real time,
278
934105
4742
15:38
and the viewer gets the feeling of actually being there,
279
938847
3577
15:42
actually being on the train, on the boat,
280
942424
2164
15:44
and knitting together with others,
281
944588
1827
15:46
and the reason I think why they're doing that
282
946415
2457
15:48
is because we don't edit the timeline.
283
948872
2480
15:51
It's important that we don't edit the timeline,
284
951352
2368
15:53
and it's also important that what we make Slow TV about
285
953720
3199
15:56
is something that we all can relate to, that the viewer can relate to,
286
956919
4729
16:01
and that somehow has a root in our culture.
287
961648
3117
16:04
This is a picture from last summer
288
964765
1726
16:06
when we traveled the coast again for seven weeks.
289
966491
2577
16:09
And of course this is a lot of planning, this is a lot of logistics.
290
969068
4363
16:13
So this is the working plan for 150 people last summer,
291
973431
4112
16:17
but more important is what you don't plan.
292
977543
2845
16:20
You don't plan what's going to happen.
293
980388
2517
16:22
You have to just take your cameras with you.
294
982905
2986
16:25
It's like a sports event.
295
985891
1520
16:27
You rig them and you see what's happening.
296
987411
2159
16:29
So this is actually the whole running order
297
989570
2484
16:32
for Hurtigruten, 134 hours, just written on one page.
298
992054
4447
16:36
We didn't know anything more when we left Bergen.
299
996501
4052
16:40
So you have to let the viewers make the stories themselves,
300
1000553
3344
16:43
and I'll give you an example of that.
301
1003897
2229
16:46
This is from last summer,
302
1006126
1764
16:47
and as a TV producer,
303
1007890
1858
16:49
it's a nice picture, but now you can cut to the next one.
304
1009748
3647
16:53
But this is Slow TV,
305
1013395
1740
16:55
so you have to keep this picture until it really starts hurting your stomach,
306
1015135
3674
16:58
and then you keep it a little bit longer,
307
1018809
2360
17:01
and when you keep it that long,
308
1021169
1520
17:02
I'm sure some of you now have noticed the cow.
309
1022689
2764
17:05
Some of you have seen the flag.
310
1025453
2034
17:07
Some of you start wondering, is the farmer at home?
311
1027487
2406
17:09
Has he left? Is he watching the cow?
312
1029893
2447
17:12
And where is that cow going?
313
1032340
3227
17:15
So my point is, the longer you keep a picture like this,
314
1035567
3234
17:18
and we kept it for 10 minutes,
315
1038801
2292
17:21
you start making the stories in your own head.
316
1041093
3971
17:25
That's Slow TV.
317
1045064
4203
17:29
So we think that Slow TV is one nice way of telling a TV story,
318
1049267
5410
17:34
and we think that we can continue doing it,
319
1054677
2484
17:37
not too often, once or twice a year, so we keep the feeling of an event,
320
1057161
4504
17:41
and we also think that the good Slow TV idea,
321
1061665
2903
17:44
that's the idea when people say,
322
1064568
1672
17:46
"Oh no, you can't put that on TV."
323
1066240
3436
17:49
When people smile, it might be a very good slow idea,
324
1069676
3042
17:52
so after all, life is best when it's a bit strange.
325
1072718
4252
17:56
Thank you.
326
1076970
1493
17:58
(Applause)
327
1078463
6584
About this website

This site will introduce you to YouTube videos that are useful for learning English. You will see English lessons taught by top-notch teachers from around the world. Double-click on the English subtitles displayed on each video page to play the video from there. The subtitles scroll in sync with the video playback. If you have any comments or requests, please contact us using this contact form.

https://forms.gle/WvT1wiN1qDtmnspy7