Andreas Schleicher: Use data to build better schools

100,070 views ・ 2013-02-21

TED


Please double-click on the English subtitles below to play the video.

00:00
Translator: Joseph Geni Reviewer: Morton Bast
0
0
7000
00:15
Radical openness is still a distant future
1
15855
3120
00:18
in the field of school education.
2
18975
2296
00:21
We have such a hard time figuring out
3
21271
1889
00:23
that learning is not a place but an activity.
4
23160
4221
00:27
But I want to tell you the story of PISA,
5
27381
3471
00:30
OECD's test to measure the knowledge and skills
6
30852
2378
00:33
of 15-year-olds around the world,
7
33230
1629
00:34
and it's really a story of how international comparisons
8
34859
4522
00:39
have globalized the field of education that we usually treat
9
39381
3275
00:42
as an affair of domestic policy.
10
42656
2935
00:45
Look at how the world looked in the 1960s,
11
45591
2424
00:48
in terms of the proportion of people
12
48015
1831
00:49
who had completed high school.
13
49846
2740
00:52
You can see the United States ahead of everyone else,
14
52586
3820
00:56
and much of the economic success of the United States
15
56406
2713
00:59
draws on its long-standing advantage
16
59119
2744
01:01
as the first mover in education.
17
61863
2872
01:04
But in the 1970s, some countries caught up.
18
64735
3223
01:07
In the 1980s, the global expansion
19
67958
2689
01:10
of the talent pool continued.
20
70647
2596
01:13
And the world didn't stop in the 1990s.
21
73243
3700
01:16
So in the '60s, the U.S. was first.
22
76943
2024
01:18
In the '90s, it was 13th,
23
78967
2936
01:21
and not because standards had fallen,
24
81903
2401
01:24
but because they had risen so much faster elsewhere.
25
84304
3755
01:28
Korea shows you what's possible in education.
26
88059
3530
01:31
Two generations ago, Korea had the standard of living
27
91589
2945
01:34
of Afghanistan today,
28
94534
2431
01:36
and was one of the lowest education performers.
29
96965
4141
01:41
Today, every young Korean finishes high school.
30
101106
5552
01:46
So this tells us that, in a global economy,
31
106658
2976
01:49
it is no longer national improvement that's the benchmark for success,
32
109634
4581
01:54
but the best performing education systems internationally.
33
114215
5181
01:59
The trouble is that
34
119396
2443
02:01
measuring how much time people spend in school
35
121839
1870
02:03
or what degree they have got is not always
36
123709
2024
02:05
a good way of seeing what they can actually do.
37
125733
5024
02:10
Look at the toxic mix of unemployed graduates on our streets,
38
130757
3673
02:14
while employers say they cannot find the people
39
134430
2194
02:16
with the skills they need.
40
136624
3799
02:20
And that tells you that better degrees don't automatically translate
41
140423
3664
02:24
into better skills and better jobs and better lives.
42
144087
4370
02:28
So with PISA, we try to change this
43
148457
2609
02:31
by measuring the knowledge and skills
44
151066
1871
02:32
of people directly.
45
152937
3436
02:36
And we took a very special angle to this.
46
156373
1898
02:38
We were less interested in whether students can simply
47
158271
2482
02:40
reproduce what they have learned in school,
48
160753
3101
02:43
but we wanted to test whether they can extrapolate
49
163854
2716
02:46
from what they know
50
166570
1913
02:48
and apply their knowledge in novel situations.
51
168483
3879
02:52
Now, some people have criticized us for this.
52
172362
2832
02:55
They say, you know, such a way of measuring outcomes
53
175194
1947
02:57
is terribly unfair to people, because we test students
54
177141
2812
02:59
with problems they haven't seen before.
55
179953
2973
03:02
But if you take that logic, you know,
56
182926
2041
03:04
you should consider life unfair, because
57
184967
2928
03:07
the test of truth in life is not whether we can remember
58
187895
3189
03:11
what we learned in school,
59
191084
1120
03:12
but whether we are prepared for change,
60
192204
3321
03:15
whether we are prepared for jobs that haven't been created,
61
195525
2421
03:17
to use technologies that haven't been invented,
62
197946
2346
03:20
to solve problems we just can't anticipate today.
63
200292
4917
03:25
And once hotly contested,
64
205209
2185
03:27
our way of measuring outcomes has actually quickly become the standard.
65
207394
3437
03:30
In our latest assessment in 2009,
66
210831
2242
03:33
we measured 74 school systems
67
213073
3412
03:36
that together cover 87 percent of the economy.
68
216485
3587
03:40
This chart shows you the performance of countries.
69
220072
3674
03:43
In red, sort of below OECD average.
70
223746
2887
03:46
Yellow is so-so, and in green are the countries doing really well.
71
226633
3376
03:50
You can see Shanghai, Korea, Singapore in Asia;
72
230009
4354
03:54
Finland in Europe;
73
234363
1690
03:56
Canada in North America doing really well.
74
236053
4366
04:00
You can also see that there is a gap of almost
75
240419
2441
04:02
three and a half school years between
76
242860
2077
04:04
15-year-olds in Shanghai and 15-year-olds in Chile,
77
244937
3368
04:08
and the gap grows to seven school years
78
248305
2705
04:11
when you include the countries with really poor performance.
79
251010
3623
04:14
There's a world of difference in the way in which
80
254633
2471
04:17
young people are prepared for today's economy.
81
257104
5202
04:22
But I want to introduce a second important dimension
82
262306
3546
04:25
into this picture.
83
265852
2221
04:28
Educators like to talk about equity.
84
268073
4375
04:32
With PISA, we wanted to measure how they actually deliver equity,
85
272448
3710
04:36
in terms of ensuring that people
86
276158
2227
04:38
from different social backgrounds have equal chances.
87
278385
3440
04:41
And we see that in some countries, the impact
88
281825
1735
04:43
of social background on learning outcomes
89
283560
1879
04:45
is very, very strong.
90
285439
1138
04:46
Opportunities are unequally distributed.
91
286577
2918
04:49
A lot of potential of young children is wasted.
92
289495
3615
04:53
We see in other countries that it matters much less
93
293110
3068
04:56
into which social context you're born.
94
296178
3493
04:59
We all want to be there, in the upper right quadrant,
95
299671
2395
05:02
where performance is strong and learning opportunities are equally distributed.
96
302066
4496
05:06
Nobody, and no country, can afford to be there,
97
306562
2671
05:09
where performance is poor
98
309233
1381
05:10
and there are large social disparities.
99
310614
3345
05:13
And then we can debate, you know, is it better
100
313959
2155
05:16
to be there, where performance is strong
101
316114
1799
05:17
at the price of large disparities?
102
317913
2960
05:20
Or do we want to focus on equity and accept mediocrity?
103
320873
5619
05:26
But actually, if you look at how countries come out on this picture,
104
326492
2982
05:29
you see there are a lot of countries that actually
105
329474
2743
05:32
are combining excellence with equity.
106
332217
4768
05:36
In fact, one of the most important lessons from this comparison
107
336985
2608
05:39
is that you don't have to compromise equity
108
339593
3106
05:42
to achieve excellence.
109
342699
2847
05:45
These countries have moved on from providing excellence
110
345546
2439
05:47
for just some to providing excellence for all,
111
347985
3269
05:51
a very important lesson.
112
351254
1972
05:53
And that also challenges the paradigms of many school systems
113
353226
4976
05:58
that believe they are mainly there to sort people.
114
358202
4303
06:02
And ever since those results came out, policymakers,
115
362505
2512
06:05
educators, researchers from around the world
116
365017
1977
06:06
have tried to figure out
117
366994
1361
06:08
what's behind the success of those systems.
118
368355
3430
06:11
But let's step back for a moment
119
371785
1824
06:13
and focus on the countries that actually started PISA,
120
373609
3014
06:16
and I'm giving them a colored bubble now.
121
376623
2546
06:19
And I'm making the size of the bubble
122
379169
3492
06:22
proportional
123
382661
1542
06:24
to the amount of money that countries spent on students.
124
384203
3795
06:27
If money would tell you everything
125
387998
1552
06:29
about the quality of learning outcomes,
126
389550
2079
06:31
you would find all the large bubbles at the top, no?
127
391629
3331
06:34
But that's not what you see.
128
394960
2545
06:37
Spending per student only explains about,
129
397505
2305
06:39
well, less than 20 percent
130
399810
2296
06:42
of the performance variation among countries,
131
402106
3518
06:45
and Luxembourg, for example, the most expensive system,
132
405624
2290
06:47
doesn't do particularly well.
133
407914
2464
06:50
What you see is that two countries with similar spending
134
410378
2376
06:52
achieve very different results.
135
412754
1920
06:54
You also see -- and I think that's one of the most encouraging findings --
136
414674
4249
06:58
that we no longer live in a world that is neatly divided
137
418923
3589
07:02
between rich and well-educated countries,
138
422512
2690
07:05
and poor and badly-educated ones,
139
425202
2320
07:07
a very, very important lesson.
140
427522
3595
07:11
Let's look at this in greater detail.
141
431117
2582
07:13
The red dot shows you
142
433699
1806
07:15
spending per student relative to a country's wealth.
143
435505
4457
07:19
One way you can spend money is by paying teachers well,
144
439962
2807
07:22
and you can see Korea investing a lot
145
442769
2505
07:25
in attracting the best people into the teaching profession.
146
445274
3024
07:28
And Korea also invests into long school days,
147
448298
1926
07:30
which drives up costs further.
148
450224
2756
07:32
Last but not least, Koreans want their teachers
149
452980
2140
07:35
not only to teach but also to develop.
150
455120
2280
07:37
They invest in professional development and collaboration
151
457400
2335
07:39
and many other things.
152
459735
2080
07:41
All that costs money.
153
461815
1641
07:43
How can Korea afford all of this?
154
463456
2670
07:46
The answer is, students in Korea learn in large classes.
155
466126
3740
07:49
This is the blue bar which is driving costs down.
156
469866
4468
07:54
You go to the next country on the list, Luxembourg,
157
474334
2895
07:57
and you can see the red dot is exactly where it is for Korea,
158
477229
3103
08:00
so Luxembourg spends the same per student as Korea does.
159
480332
3533
08:03
But, you know, parents and teachers and policymakers
160
483865
2894
08:06
in Luxembourg all like small classes.
161
486759
2447
08:09
You know, it's very pleasant to walk into a small class.
162
489206
2768
08:11
So they have invested all their money into there,
163
491974
1904
08:13
and the blue bar, class size, is driving costs up.
164
493878
3346
08:17
But even Luxembourg can spend its money only once,
165
497224
4161
08:21
and the price for this is that
166
501385
2205
08:23
teachers are not paid particularly well.
167
503590
2104
08:25
Students don't have long hours of learning.
168
505694
2679
08:28
And basically, teachers have little time to do anything else than teaching.
169
508373
3242
08:31
So you can see two countries spent their money very differently,
170
511615
3681
08:35
and actually how they spent their money
171
515296
2320
08:37
matters a lot more than how much they invest in education.
172
517616
6003
08:43
Let's go back to the year 2000.
173
523619
2554
08:46
Remember, that was the year before the iPod was invented.
174
526173
3995
08:50
This is how the world looked then
175
530168
2124
08:52
in terms of PISA performance.
176
532292
4261
08:56
The first thing you can see is that the bubbles were a lot smaller, no?
177
536553
2815
08:59
We spent a lot less on education,
178
539368
1631
09:00
about 35 percent less on education.
179
540999
2072
09:03
So you ask yourself, if education has become so much more expensive,
180
543071
3745
09:06
has it become so much better?
181
546816
3353
09:10
And the bitter truth really is that, you know,
182
550169
2999
09:13
not in many countries.
183
553168
2445
09:15
But there are some countries which have seen
184
555613
2083
09:17
impressive improvements.
185
557696
2948
09:20
Germany, my own country, in the year 2000,
186
560644
3796
09:24
featured in the lower quadrant,
187
564440
1888
09:26
below average performance, large social disparities.
188
566328
3165
09:29
And remember, Germany, we used to be one of those countries
189
569493
2003
09:31
that comes out very well when you just count people who have degrees.
190
571496
3728
09:35
Very disappointing results.
191
575224
1761
09:36
People were stunned by the results.
192
576985
2737
09:39
And for the very first time, the public debate in Germany
193
579722
3791
09:43
was dominated for months by education,
194
583513
3706
09:47
not tax, not other kinds of issues, but education
195
587219
2734
09:49
was the center of the public debate.
196
589953
2551
09:52
And then policymakers began to respond to this.
197
592504
3219
09:55
The federal government dramatically raised its investment in education.
198
595723
4230
09:59
A lot was done to increase the life chances of students
199
599953
3629
10:03
with an immigrant background or from social disadvantage.
200
603582
2962
10:06
And what's really interesting is that this wasn't just about
201
606544
4508
10:11
optimizing existing policies,
202
611052
3759
10:14
but data transformed some of the beliefs and paradigms
203
614811
3413
10:18
underlying German education.
204
618224
1787
10:20
For example, traditionally, the education of the very young children
205
620011
3886
10:23
was seen as the business of families, and you would have cases
206
623897
2618
10:26
where women were seen as neglecting their family responsibilities
207
626515
3032
10:29
when they sent their children to kindergarten.
208
629547
3088
10:32
PISA has transformed that debate,
209
632635
2648
10:35
and pushed early childhood education right at the center
210
635283
2773
10:38
of public policy in Germany.
211
638056
2392
10:40
Or traditionally, the German education divides children
212
640448
3701
10:44
at the age of 10, very young children,
213
644149
2748
10:46
between those deemed to pursue careers of knowledge workers
214
646897
4189
10:51
and those who would end up working for the knowledge workers,
215
651086
3350
10:54
and that mainly along socioeconomic lines,
216
654436
2476
10:56
and that paradigm is being challenged now too.
217
656912
4168
11:01
A lot of change.
218
661080
2484
11:03
And the good news is, nine years later,
219
663564
2954
11:06
you can see improvements in quality and equity.
220
666518
3099
11:09
People have taken up the challenge, done something about it.
221
669617
2276
11:11
Or take Korea, at the other end of the spectrum.
222
671893
2128
11:14
In the year 2000, Korea did already very well,
223
674021
2545
11:16
but the Koreans were concerned that only a small share
224
676566
3325
11:19
of their students achieved the really high levels of excellence.
225
679891
4359
11:24
They took up the challenge,
226
684250
1814
11:26
and Korea was able to double the proportion of students
227
686064
3534
11:29
achieving excellence in one decade in the field of reading.
228
689598
4402
11:34
Well, if you only focus on your brightest students,
229
694000
2553
11:36
you know what happens is disparities grow,
230
696553
1919
11:38
and you can see this bubble moving slightly to the other direction,
231
698472
3800
11:42
but still, an impressive improvement.
232
702272
2711
11:44
A major overhaul of Poland's education
233
704983
2586
11:47
helped to dramatically reduce between variability among schools,
234
707569
3633
11:51
turn around many of the lowest-performing schools,
235
711202
2694
11:53
and raise performance by over half a school year.
236
713896
4834
11:58
And you can see other countries as well.
237
718730
1791
12:00
Portugal was able to consolidate its fragmented school system,
238
720521
2943
12:03
raise quality and improve equity,
239
723464
2992
12:06
and so did Hungary.
240
726456
1876
12:08
So what you can actually see, there's been a lot of change.
241
728332
3431
12:11
And even those people who complain and say that
242
731763
2933
12:14
the relative standing of countries
243
734696
1689
12:16
on something like PISA is just an artifact of culture,
244
736385
3422
12:19
of economic factors, of social issues,
245
739807
3042
12:22
of homogeneity of societies, and so on,
246
742849
3062
12:25
these people must now concede that education improvement is possible.
247
745911
4842
12:30
You know, Poland hasn't changed its culture.
248
750753
3040
12:33
It didn't change its economy. It didn't change
249
753793
2504
12:36
the compositions of its population.
250
756297
2092
12:38
It didn't fire its teachers. It changed its education policies
251
758389
2854
12:41
and practice. Very impressive.
252
761243
2640
12:43
And all that raises, of course, the question: What can we learn
253
763883
2965
12:46
from those countries in the green quadrant
254
766848
2104
12:48
who have achieved high levels of equity,
255
768952
2275
12:51
high levels of performance, and raised outcomes?
256
771227
3732
12:54
And, of course, the question is, can what works in one context
257
774959
3914
12:58
provide a model elsewhere?
258
778873
2716
13:01
Of course, you can't copy and paste education systems wholesale,
259
781589
3330
13:04
but these comparisons have identified a range of factors
260
784919
3927
13:08
that high-performing systems share.
261
788846
3321
13:12
Everybody agrees that education is important.
262
792167
2560
13:14
Everybody says that.
263
794727
1987
13:16
But the test of truth is, how do you weigh that priority
264
796714
3255
13:19
against other priorities?
265
799969
2296
13:22
How do countries pay their teachers
266
802265
2013
13:24
relative to other highly skilled workers?
267
804278
3105
13:27
Would you want your child to become a teacher
268
807383
2485
13:29
rather than a lawyer?
269
809868
2112
13:31
How do the media talk about schools and teachers?
270
811980
2002
13:33
Those are the critical questions, and what we have learned
271
813982
2505
13:36
from PISA is that, in high-performing education systems,
272
816487
4094
13:40
the leaders have convinced their citizens to make choices
273
820581
3550
13:44
that value education, their future,
274
824131
2378
13:46
more than consumption today.
275
826509
2672
13:49
And you know what's interesting? You won't believe it,
276
829181
2046
13:51
but there are countries in which the most attractive place
277
831227
2986
13:54
to be is not the shopping center but the school.
278
834213
2920
13:57
Those things really exist.
279
837133
2267
13:59
But placing a high value on education
280
839400
1973
14:01
is just part of the picture.
281
841373
2851
14:04
The other part is the belief that all children
282
844224
3029
14:07
are capable of success.
283
847253
3435
14:10
You have some countries where students
284
850688
1761
14:12
are segregated early in their ages.
285
852449
2239
14:14
You know, students are divided up,
286
854688
2046
14:16
reflecting the belief that only some children
287
856734
2335
14:19
can achieve world-class standards.
288
859069
3552
14:22
But usually that is linked to very strong social disparities.
289
862621
4055
14:26
If you go to Japan in Asia, or Finland in Europe,
290
866676
3384
14:30
parents and teachers in those countries
291
870060
2106
14:32
expect every student to succeed,
292
872166
3911
14:36
and you can see that actually mirrored in student behavior.
293
876077
3492
14:39
When we asked students what counts
294
879569
2716
14:42
for success in mathematics,
295
882285
2736
14:45
students in North America would typically tell us,
296
885021
2392
14:47
you know, it's all about talent.
297
887413
1546
14:48
If I'm not born as a genius in math, I'd better study something else.
298
888959
4626
14:53
Nine out of 10 Japanese students say
299
893585
2726
14:56
that it depends on my own investment, on my own effort,
300
896311
4246
15:00
and that tells you a lot about the system that is around them.
301
900557
4735
15:05
In the past, different students were taught in similar ways.
302
905292
4809
15:10
High performers on PISA embrace diversity
303
910101
3332
15:13
with differentiated pedagogical practices.
304
913433
3748
15:17
They realize that
305
917181
1976
15:19
ordinary students have extraordinary talents,
306
919157
3144
15:22
and they personalize learning opportunities.
307
922301
3360
15:25
High-performing systems also share
308
925661
2036
15:27
clear and ambitious standards across the entire spectrum.
309
927697
3606
15:31
Every student knows what matters.
310
931303
2202
15:33
Every student knows what's required to be successful.
311
933505
4087
15:37
And nowhere does the quality of an education system
312
937592
2865
15:40
exceed the quality of its teachers.
313
940457
2443
15:42
High-performing systems are very careful
314
942900
3068
15:45
in how they recruit and select their teachers
315
945968
2134
15:48
and how they train them.
316
948102
1721
15:49
They watch how they improve the performances of teachers
317
949823
2830
15:52
in difficulties who are struggling,
318
952653
2320
15:54
and how they structure teacher pay.
319
954973
2909
15:57
They provide an environment also in which teachers work together
320
957882
3696
16:01
to frame good practice.
321
961578
3557
16:05
And they provide intelligent pathways for teachers to grow
322
965135
4161
16:09
in their careers.
323
969296
2115
16:11
In bureaucratic school systems,
324
971411
1624
16:13
teachers are often left alone in classrooms
325
973035
1993
16:15
with a lot of prescription on what they should be teaching.
326
975028
3167
16:18
High-performing systems are very clear what good performance is.
327
978195
3210
16:21
They set very ambitious standards, but then they enable
328
981405
2774
16:24
their teachers to figure out,
329
984179
1777
16:25
what do I need to teach to my students today?
330
985956
4115
16:30
The past was about delivered wisdom in education.
331
990071
4546
16:34
Now the challenge is to enable user-generated wisdom.
332
994617
5242
16:39
High performers have moved on from professional
333
999859
3640
16:43
or from administrative forms of accountability and control --
334
1003499
3664
16:47
sort of, how do you check whether people do what they're supposed to do in education --
335
1007163
3237
16:50
to professional forms of work organization.
336
1010400
3666
16:54
They enable their teachers to make innovations in pedagogy.
337
1014066
3872
16:57
They provide them with the kind of development they need
338
1017938
2490
17:00
to develop stronger pedagogical practices.
339
1020428
4062
17:04
The goal of the past was standardization and compliance.
340
1024490
5658
17:10
High-performing systems have made teachers
341
1030148
2734
17:12
and school principals inventive.
342
1032882
3286
17:16
In the past, the policy focus was on outcomes,
343
1036168
2699
17:18
on provision.
344
1038867
2182
17:21
The high-performing systems have helped teachers
345
1041049
2803
17:23
and school principals to look outwards to the next teacher,
346
1043852
2441
17:26
the next school around their lives.
347
1046293
2693
17:28
And the most impressive outcomes of world-class systems
348
1048986
2166
17:31
is that they achieve high performance across the entire system.
349
1051152
3147
17:34
You've seen Finland doing so well on PISA,
350
1054299
2197
17:36
but what makes Finland so impressive
351
1056496
1690
17:38
is that only five percent of the performance variation
352
1058186
3977
17:42
amongst students lies between schools.
353
1062163
2456
17:44
Every school succeeds.
354
1064619
2316
17:46
This is where success is systemic.
355
1066935
2731
17:49
And how do they do that?
356
1069666
1704
17:51
They invest resources where they can make the most difference.
357
1071370
2692
17:54
They attract the strongest principals into the toughest schools,
358
1074062
5108
17:59
and the most talented teachers
359
1079170
2208
18:01
into the most challenging classroom.
360
1081378
1943
18:03
Last but not least, those countries align policies
361
1083321
3129
18:06
across all areas of public policy.
362
1086450
2220
18:08
They make them coherent over sustained periods of time,
363
1088670
3133
18:11
and they ensure that what they do is consistently implemented.
364
1091803
4703
18:16
Now, knowing what successful systems are doing
365
1096506
2304
18:18
doesn't yet tell us how to improve.
366
1098810
2791
18:21
That's also clear, and that's where some of the limits
367
1101601
2458
18:24
of international comparisons of PISA are.
368
1104059
3475
18:27
That's where other forms of research need to kick in,
369
1107534
2703
18:30
and that's also why PISA doesn't venture into
370
1110237
2458
18:32
telling countries what they should be doing.
371
1112695
1760
18:34
But its strength lies in telling them
372
1114455
1823
18:36
what everybody else has been doing.
373
1116278
2755
18:39
And the example of PISA shows that data
374
1119033
2196
18:41
can be more powerful than administrative control of financial subsidy
375
1121229
3318
18:44
through which we usually run education systems.
376
1124547
3941
18:48
You know, some people argue that
377
1128488
3038
18:51
changing educational administration
378
1131526
2188
18:53
is like moving graveyards.
379
1133714
2441
18:56
You just can't rely on the people out there to help you with this. (Laughter)
380
1136155
4887
19:01
But PISA has shown what's possible in education.
381
1141042
4867
19:05
It has helped countries to see that improvement is possible.
382
1145909
3805
19:09
It has taken away excuses from those who are complacent.
383
1149714
4208
19:13
And it has helped countries to set meaningful targets
384
1153922
3433
19:17
in terms of measurable goals achieved by the world's leaders.
385
1157355
3098
19:20
If we can help every child, every teacher, every school,
386
1160453
4550
19:25
every principal, every parent see what improvement is possible,
387
1165003
3655
19:28
that only the sky is the limit to education improvement,
388
1168658
2736
19:31
we have laid the foundations
389
1171394
1896
19:33
for better policies and better lives.
390
1173290
2183
19:35
Thank you.
391
1175473
2533
19:38
(Applause)
392
1178006
4000
About this website

This site will introduce you to YouTube videos that are useful for learning English. You will see English lessons taught by top-notch teachers from around the world. Double-click on the English subtitles displayed on each video page to play the video from there. The subtitles scroll in sync with the video playback. If you have any comments or requests, please contact us using this contact form.

https://forms.gle/WvT1wiN1qDtmnspy7