Is the world getting better or worse? A look at the numbers | Steven Pinker
1,490,947 views ・ 2018-05-21
请双击下面的英文字幕来播放视频。
翻译人员: jacks peng
校对人员: Melody Tang
00:13
Many people face the news each morning
0
13680
2736
每天早晨,很多人都面对着
00:16
with trepidation and dread.
1
16440
2456
充满不安和恐惧的新闻。
00:18
Every day, we read of shootings,
2
18920
2656
每天,我们都会读到枪击案,
00:21
inequality, pollution, dictatorship,
3
21600
3896
不平等、污染、独裁统治、
00:25
war and the spread of nuclear weapons.
4
25520
3176
战争和核武器扩散的消息。
00:28
These are some of the reasons
5
28720
1736
这些是 2016 年
00:30
that 2016 was called
the "Worst. Year. Ever."
6
30480
5456
被称为“史上最糟糕的一年”的部分原因。
00:35
Until 2017 claimed that record --
7
35960
2576
直到 2017 年再创新高——
00:38
(Laughter)
8
38560
1056
(笑声)
00:39
and left many people longing
for earlier decades,
9
39640
2576
这使得很多人不禁
怀念几十年前的日子,
00:42
when the world seemed safer,
cleaner and more equal.
10
42240
3320
那时世界看来更安全,清净和平等。
00:46
But is this a sensible way
to understand the human condition
11
46560
3576
但这是理解 21 世纪人类生存状况的
00:50
in the 21st century?
12
50160
1976
合理方式吗?
00:52
As Franklin Pierce Adams pointed out,
13
52160
2776
就如富兰克林 · 皮尔斯 · 亚当斯指出的那样:
00:54
"Nothing is more responsible
for the good old days
14
54960
2696
“怀念往昔美好时光的人的记忆
00:57
than a bad memory."
15
57680
1216
一定糟透了。“
00:58
(Laughter)
16
58920
2736
(笑声)
01:01
You can always fool yourself
into seeing a decline
17
61680
3376
如果你拿现在的新闻头条
01:05
if you compare bleeding
headlines of the present
18
65080
2696
跟过去玫瑰色的图片相对比,
01:07
with rose-tinted images of the past.
19
67800
3096
你就总会以为自己
正面临着世风日下的局面。
01:10
What does the trajectory
of the world look like
20
70920
2416
当我们用恒定的尺度
来衡量幸福感时,
01:13
when we measure well-being over time
using a constant yardstick?
21
73360
4256
世界的变化轨迹会是什么样呢?
01:17
Let's compare the most recent
data on the present
22
77640
2696
让我们用同样的方法
来比较最新的数据
01:20
with the same measures 30 years ago.
23
80360
2000
和 30 年前的数据。
01:23
Last year, Americans killed each other
at a rate of 5.3 per hundred thousand,
24
83320
5136
去年,美国每 10 万人中有
5.3 人死于凶杀,
01:28
had seven percent
of their citizens in poverty
25
88480
3376
7%的贫困人口,
01:31
and emitted 21 million tons
of particulate matter
26
91880
3256
排放了 2100 万吨的微粒物质,
01:35
and four million tons of sulfur dioxide.
27
95160
3096
以及 400 万吨的二氧化硫。
01:38
But 30 years ago, the homicide rate
was 8.5 per hundred thousand,
28
98280
4136
而 30 年前,每 10 万人中
有 8.5 人死于凶杀,
01:42
poverty rate was 12 percent
29
102440
2096
贫困率为 12 %,
01:44
and we emitted 35 million tons
of particulate matter
30
104560
3176
我们排放了 3500 万吨的微粒物质,
01:47
and 20 million tons of sulfur dioxide.
31
107760
2720
以及 2000 万吨的二氧化硫。
01:51
What about the world as a whole?
32
111400
2056
那么世界整体情况如何?
01:53
Last year, the world had 12 ongoing wars,
33
113480
3416
去年,全球共有 12 场战争,
01:56
60 autocracies,
34
116920
2136
60 个独裁政权,
01:59
10 percent of the world population
in extreme poverty
35
119080
3616
10% 的极端贫穷人口
02:02
and more than 10,000 nuclear weapons.
36
122720
2976
以及超过 1 万件核武器。
02:05
But 30 years ago, there were 23 wars,
37
125720
2496
而 30 年前,一共有 23 场战争,
02:08
85 autocracies,
38
128240
1896
85 个独裁政权,
02:10
37 percent of the world population
in extreme poverty
39
130160
3616
37 %的全球人口极度贫困
02:13
and more than 60,000 nuclear weapons.
40
133800
2800
以及超过 6 万件核武器。
02:17
True, last year was a terrible year
for terrorism in Western Europe,
41
137200
4535
的确,去年是西欧恐怖主义
十分猖獗的一年,
02:21
with 238 deaths,
42
141759
2217
共造成 238 人死亡,
02:24
but 1988 was worse with 440 deaths.
43
144000
3200
但 1988 年更糟,有 440 人死亡。
02:28
What's going on?
44
148440
1536
这是怎么回事?
02:30
Was 1988 a particularly bad year?
45
150000
3496
1988 年是尤其糟糕的一年吗?
02:33
Or are these improvements a sign
that the world, for all its struggles,
46
153520
4056
或者,这是世界进步的迹象,
02:37
gets better over time?
47
157600
1640
在挣扎中,越变越好?
02:39
Might we even invoke the admittedly
old-fashioned notion of progress?
48
159800
4800
我们是否可以援引
公认的过时了进步观念?
02:45
To do so is to court
a certain amount of derision,
49
165880
3296
这样做会招来一些嘲笑,
02:49
because I have found
that intellectuals hate progress.
50
169200
3776
因为我发现知识分子憎恨进步。
02:53
(Laughter)
51
173000
1816
(笑声)
02:54
(Applause)
52
174840
2816
(鼓掌)
02:57
And intellectuals who call themselves
progressive really hate progress.
53
177680
3696
自称进步的知识分子真的讨厌进步。
03:01
(Laughter)
54
181400
1136
(笑声)
03:02
Now, it's not that they hate
the fruits of progress, mind you.
55
182560
3336
请注意,我并不是说
他们讨厌进步的成果。
03:05
Most academics and pundits
56
185920
2616
大多数学者和专家
03:08
would rather have their surgery
with anesthesia than without it.
57
188560
3440
做手术时还是会选择用麻醉,
而非什么都不用。
03:13
It's the idea of progress
that rankles the chattering class.
58
193080
4256
让这些喋喋不休的人不满的,
是进步的观点。
03:17
If you believe that humans
can improve their lot, I have been told,
59
197360
3736
如果你相信人类可以改善命运,
正如我被告知的那样,
03:21
that means that you have a blind faith
60
201120
2376
这意味着你有着盲目的信仰,
03:23
and a quasi-religious belief
in the outmoded superstition
61
203520
4576
一种类似宗教的落后迷信,
相信对不可阻挡的进步神话的
03:28
and the false promise
of the myth of the onward march
62
208120
3816
03:31
of inexorable progress.
63
211960
2040
虚假承诺。
03:34
You are a cheerleader
for vulgar American can-doism,
64
214640
4336
你是粗俗的美国佬的啦啦队长,
03:39
with the rah-rah spirit
of boardroom ideology,
65
219000
3216
拥有董事会的意识形态,硅谷和商会的
03:42
Silicon Valley
and the Chamber of Commerce.
66
222240
3056
拉拉队精神。
03:45
You are a practitioner of Whig history,
67
225320
2856
你是辉格历史的实践者,
03:48
a naive optimist, a Pollyanna
and, of course, a Pangloss,
68
228200
4136
一位天真的乐观主义者,
你就像是潘格劳斯,
03:52
alluding to the Voltaire
character who declared,
69
232360
2656
伏尔泰小说里的角色,曾宣称:
03:55
"All is for the best
in the best of all possible worlds."
70
235040
3336
“在理想的最美好的世界中,
一切都是为最美好的目的而设。“
03:58
Well, Professor Pangloss,
as it happens, was a pessimist.
71
238400
3496
好吧,潘格劳斯教授
碰巧是个悲观主义者。
04:01
A true optimist believes
there can be much better worlds
72
241920
2656
一个真正的乐观主义者相信
存在着比我们今天拥有的
04:04
than the one we have today.
73
244600
1536
更好的世界。
04:06
But all of this is irrelevant,
74
246160
1656
但所有这些都无关紧要,
04:07
because the question
of whether progress has taken place
75
247840
2776
因为进步是否发生
04:10
is not a matter of faith
76
250640
1736
与信念无关,
04:12
or having an optimistic temperament
or seeing the glass as half full.
77
252400
3816
也不取决于是否拥有乐观气质,
或是看到了半杯水(而不是半个空杯子)。
04:16
It's a testable hypothesis.
78
256240
1840
而是一个可检验的假设。
04:18
For all their differences,
79
258720
1376
尽管各有分歧,
04:20
people largely agree
on what goes into human well-being:
80
260120
4376
在很大程度上人们会一致认为,
人类的幸福包括以下因素:
04:24
life, health, sustenance, prosperity,
peace, freedom, safety, knowledge,
81
264520
5696
生命、健康、生计、繁荣、
和平、自由、安全、知识、
04:30
leisure, happiness.
82
270240
1976
休闲、快乐。
04:32
All of these things can be measured.
83
272240
1896
这些东西都可以测量。
04:34
If they have improved over time,
that, I submit, is progress.
84
274160
4336
如果它们随时间得到改善,
我认为就是进步。
04:38
Let's go to the data,
85
278520
1616
让我们看看数据。
04:40
beginning with the most
precious thing of all, life.
86
280160
3616
从最珍贵的东西开始,生命。
04:43
For most of human history,
life expectancy at birth was around 30.
87
283800
4576
在人类历史长河的大部分时期中,
预期寿命为 30 岁上下。
04:48
Today, worldwide, it is more than 70,
88
288400
2776
今天,全球平均寿命超过了70岁,
04:51
and in the developed parts of the world,
89
291200
1936
在发达国家,
则超过80岁。
04:53
more than 80.
90
293160
1200
04:55
250 years ago, in the richest
countries of the world,
91
295040
3136
250 年前,在全球最富有的国家,
04:58
a third of the children
did not live to see their fifth birthday,
92
298200
4016
在风险被降低一百倍之前,
05:02
before the risk was brought
down a hundredfold.
93
302240
3336
1/3 的儿童活不到五岁。
05:05
Today, that fate befalls
less than six percent of children
94
305600
3256
今天,婴儿死亡率在全球最贫穷的国家
05:08
in the poorest countries of the world.
95
308880
1840
也已经降低到 6 %以下。
05:11
Famine is one of the Four Horsemen
of the Apocalypse.
96
311600
3416
饥荒是世界末日的四骑士之一。
05:15
It could bring devastation
to any part of the world.
97
315040
3256
它可以给世界上任何地方带来毁灭。
05:18
Today, famine has been banished
98
318320
1936
今天,饥荒已经被驱逐至
05:20
to the most remote
and war-ravaged regions.
99
320280
2600
最偏远和饱受战争蹂躏的地区。
05:23
200 years ago, 90 percent
of the world's population
100
323680
3136
200 年前,90 %的世界人口
05:26
subsisted in extreme poverty.
101
326840
2176
处于极端贫困。
05:29
Today, fewer than 10 percent of people do.
102
329040
2560
今天只有不到 10 %的人如此。
05:32
For most of human history,
103
332720
1496
在人类大部分的历史中,
05:34
the powerful states and empires
104
334240
2056
强大的国家和帝国
05:36
were pretty much always
at war with each other,
105
336320
2616
总是彼此交战,
05:38
and peace was a mere
interlude between wars.
106
338960
3456
而和平只是战争之间的插曲。
05:42
Today, they are never
at war with each other.
107
342440
2256
今天,他们不再彼此开战。
05:44
The last great power war
108
344720
1296
上一场大国之间的战争
05:46
pitted the United States
against China 65 years ago.
109
346040
3120
发生在 65 年前的中国和美国。
05:50
More recently, wars of all kinds
have become fewer and less deadly.
110
350160
4736
最近,各种各样的战争发生得
越来越少,伤亡人数也有所下降。
05:54
The annual rate of war has fallen from
about 22 per hundred thousand per year
111
354920
4456
每年的战争死亡率
从 50 年代的 10 万分之 22
05:59
in the early '50s to 1.2 today.
112
359400
3616
下降至今天的 10 万分之 1.2。
06:03
Democracy has suffered obvious setbacks
113
363040
2576
民主在委内瑞拉,俄罗斯,土耳其
06:05
in Venezuela, in Russia, in Turkey
114
365640
3616
遭受了明显的挫折,
06:09
and is threatened by the rise
of authoritarian populism
115
369280
3096
并在东欧和美国受到了
06:12
in Eastern Europe and the United States.
116
372400
2616
来自独裁民粹主义崛起的威胁。
06:15
Yet the world has never been
more democratic
117
375040
2696
但是相比过去的时代,
06:17
than it has been in the past decade,
118
377760
1976
世界从来没有如此民主,
06:19
with two-thirds of the world's people
living in democracies.
119
379760
3200
全球 2/3 的人口生活在民主国家。
06:24
Homicide rates plunge whenever anarchy
and the code of vendetta
120
384280
4136
每当无政府状态和仇杀行为
被法治取代时,
06:28
are replaced by the rule of law.
121
388440
2376
凶杀犯罪率就会下降。
06:30
It happened when feudal Europe was brought
under the control of centralized kingdoms,
122
390840
4216
这发生在封建的欧洲
被中央王国控制时,
06:35
so that today a Western European
123
395080
2136
所以今天西欧人
06:37
has 1/35th the chance of being murdered
124
397240
2576
被谋杀的几率是
06:39
compared to his medieval ancestors.
125
399840
2576
他们中世纪祖先的 1/35。
06:42
It happened again in colonial New England,
126
402440
2456
这也发生在新英格兰的殖民地,
06:44
in the American Wild West
when the sheriffs moved to town,
127
404920
3536
治安官进驻后的美国西部小镇,
06:48
and in Mexico.
128
408480
1696
以及墨西哥等地。
06:50
Indeed, we've become safer
in just about every way.
129
410200
3520
我们的确在各个方面
都变得更安全了。
06:54
Over the last century,
we've become 96 percent less likely
130
414560
3536
上个世纪以来,
我们死于交通事故的概率
06:58
to be killed in a car crash,
131
418120
2256
降低了 96 %。
07:00
88 percent less likely
to be mowed down on the sidewalk,
132
420400
3936
在人行道上被撞倒的概率
降低了88 %。
07:04
99 percent less likely
to die in a plane crash,
133
424360
3736
飞机事故死亡率下降了 99 %。
07:08
95 percent less likely
to be killed on the job,
134
428120
3656
因公殉职的概率也降低了 95 %。
07:11
89 percent less likely
to be killed by an act of God,
135
431800
3616
死于大自然因素的
概率也降低了 89 %,
07:15
such as a drought, flood,
wildfire, storm, volcano,
136
435440
3936
比如干旱,洪水,野火,风暴,火山,
07:19
landslide, earthquake or meteor strike,
137
439400
2656
山崩、地震或流星撞击。
07:22
presumably not because God
has become less angry with us
138
442080
3256
应该不是因为
上帝对我们不再那么生气了,
07:25
but because of improvements
in the resilience of our infrastructure.
139
445360
4736
而是因为我们的基础设施的
应变能力提高了。
07:30
And what about
the quintessential act of God,
140
450120
3256
那么,典型的天灾,
07:33
the projectile hurled by Zeus himself?
141
453400
3496
宙斯自己投掷的炮弹呢?
07:36
Yes, we are 97 percent less likely
to be killed by a bolt of lightning.
142
456920
4240
没错,我们被闪电击中的
概率降低了 97 %。
07:43
Before the 17th century,
143
463480
1656
17 世纪以前,
07:45
no more than 15 percent of Europeans
could read or write.
144
465160
3536
不到 15 %的欧洲人能读会写。
07:48
Europe and the United States
achieved universal literacy
145
468720
3136
欧洲和美国在 20 世纪中叶
07:51
by the middle of the 20th century,
146
471880
1936
就消灭了文盲,
07:53
and the rest of the world is catching up.
147
473840
2496
世界其他地方也在陆续跟上。
07:56
Today, more than 90 percent
of the world's population
148
476360
3416
今天,全球年龄在 25 岁以下的人中,
07:59
under the age of 25 can read and write.
149
479800
2440
超过 90 %的人口能读会写。
08:03
In the 19th century, Westerners
worked more than 60 hours per week.
150
483440
3976
在 19 世纪,西方人每周工作时间
远远超过 60 个小时。
08:07
Today, they work fewer than 40.
151
487440
1920
今天,这个数字已经低于 40 小时。
08:10
Thanks to the universal penetration
of running water and electricity
152
490440
4416
得益于发达国家
自来水和电的普及,
08:14
in the developed world
153
494880
1376
08:16
and the widespread adoption
of washing machines, vacuum cleaners,
154
496280
3976
以及洗衣机,真空吸尘器,
08:20
refrigerators, dishwashers,
stoves and microwaves,
155
500280
3976
冰箱、洗碗机、炉子和
微波炉的广泛使用,
08:24
the amount of our lives
that we forfeit to housework
156
504280
2896
我们花费在家务上的时间
08:27
has fallen from 60 hours a week
157
507200
2376
从一周 60 个小时
08:29
to fewer than 15 hours a week.
158
509600
1960
下降至每周不到 15 小时。
08:32
Do all of these gains in health,
wealth, safety, knowledge and leisure
159
512760
4536
在健康、财富、安全、知识
和休闲方面的这些进步
08:37
make us any happier?
160
517320
1696
让我们更加幸福了吗?
08:39
The answer is yes.
161
519040
1216
答案是肯定的。
08:40
In 86 percent of the world's countries,
162
520280
2176
全球 86 %的国家中,
08:42
happiness has increased in recent decades.
163
522480
2360
幸福指数在最近几十年来都在增长。
08:45
Well, I hope to have convinced you
164
525799
1736
好了,我希望我已经说服你们
08:47
that progress is not a matter
of faith or optimism,
165
527559
3417
进步无关信念或乐观,
08:51
but is a fact of human history,
166
531000
2135
而是人类历史的事实,
08:53
indeed the greatest fact in human history.
167
533159
2561
确实是人类历史上最伟大的事实。
08:56
And how has this fact
been covered in the news?
168
536480
2816
而这些事实是如何
被新闻媒体报道的呢?
08:59
(Laughter)
169
539320
3160
(笑声)
09:03
A tabulation of positive and negative
emotion words in news stories
170
543360
3976
新闻故事中积极和消极的情绪词汇表
09:07
has shown that during the decades
in which humanity has gotten healthier,
171
547360
3656
已证明,在过去几十年里
人类变得更健康,
09:11
wealthier, wiser, safer and happier,
172
551040
2816
更富有,更聪明,更安全,更快乐。
09:13
the "New York Times"
has become increasingly morose
173
553880
4096
《纽约时报》的措辞却变得越来越阴郁,
全球的广播节目的腔调
也变得越来越阴沉。
09:18
and the world's broadcasts too
have gotten steadily glummer.
174
558000
3600
09:22
Why don't people appreciate progress?
175
562720
2696
为什么人们不感激这些进步?
09:25
Part of the answer comes
from our cognitive psychology.
176
565440
2976
部分答案来自于我们的认知心理学。
09:28
We estimate risk using a mental shortcut
called the "availability heuristic."
177
568440
5016
我们用一个名为“可得性启发”的
心理捷径来估计危险。
09:33
The easier it is to recall
something from memory,
178
573480
2776
一件越容易被回忆起来的事,
09:36
the more probable we judge it to be.
179
576280
2000
我们就越可能认为它就是那样。
09:39
The other part of the answer
comes from the nature of journalism,
180
579200
3616
另外一部分答案来自于新闻业的本质,
09:42
captured in this satirical headline
from "The Onion,"
181
582840
3376
这个讽刺性的头条取自“洋葱新闻“,
09:46
"CNN Holds Morning Meeting to Decide
182
586240
2056
“美国有线电视新闻网 CNN 开早会决定
09:48
What Viewers Should
Panic About For Rest of Day."
183
588320
2296
观众在这一天应当对什么感到恐慌。“
09:50
(Laughter)
184
590640
1696
(笑声)
09:52
(Applause)
185
592360
4040
(掌声)
09:57
News is about stuff that happens,
not stuff that doesn't happen.
186
597160
3816
新闻是报道那些正在发生的事,
而不是没有发生的事。
10:01
You never see a journalist who says,
187
601000
2376
你从没见过一个记者说,
10:03
"I'm reporting live from a country
that has been at peace for 40 years,"
188
603400
4216
“我正在一个40年来
局势都很稳定的国家直播”,
10:07
or a city that has not
been attacked by terrorists.
189
607640
2640
或者在一个从来没有被
恐怖分子袭击的城市直播。
10:10
Also, bad things can happen quickly,
190
610960
2336
另外,坏事可能会瞬间发生,
10:13
but good things aren't built in a day.
191
613320
2416
但是好事却不是一天能成的。
10:15
The papers could have run the headline,
192
615760
1896
新闻媒体可以在
过去25年中。每天都使用
10:17
"137,000 people escaped
from extreme poverty yesterday"
193
617680
4376
“昨天有 13 万 7 千人脱离了极端贫困”
10:22
every day for the last 25 years.
194
622080
2856
这个标题。
10:24
That's one and a quarter billion people
leaving poverty behind,
195
624960
4216
也就是说,总共有 12.5 亿人脱离了贫困,
10:29
but you never read about it.
196
629200
2016
但是你从来没有看到过这一条新闻。
10:31
Also, the news capitalizes
on our morbid interest
197
631240
3296
而且,新闻报道还会利用我们对
哪里会出现问题的病态兴趣,
10:34
in what can go wrong,
198
634560
1256
10:35
captured in the programming policy,
"If it bleeds, it leads."
199
635840
4336
其规划政策是“越血腥越吸睛”。
10:40
Well, if you combine our cognitive biases
with the nature of news,
200
640200
3736
如果将我们的认知偏差和
新闻的本质相结合,
10:43
you can see why the world
has been coming to an end
201
643960
2696
你就可以了解为什么这个世界
10:46
for a very long time indeed.
202
646680
1960
的确是在很久以前
就开始走向末日了。
10:50
Let me address
some questions about progress
203
650840
2096
让我提出几个关于进步的问题,
10:52
that no doubt have occurred
to many of you.
204
652960
2360
豪无疑问这些进步
在你们很多人身上都发生过。
10:56
First, isn't it good to be pessimistic
205
656320
2736
首先,成为一个悲观主义者,
10:59
to safeguard against complacency,
206
659080
2416
可以防范自满、清清除糟粕,
11:01
to rake the muck, to speak truth to power?
207
661520
2656
向当权者说实话,这有什么不好吗?
11:04
Well, not exactly.
208
664200
1976
其实,这样未必好。
11:06
It's good to be accurate.
209
666200
1976
能做到精确是很好的。
11:08
Of course we should be aware
of suffering and danger
210
668200
2456
当然我们都应当知道
痛苦和危险发生的地方,
11:10
wherever they occur,
211
670680
1416
11:12
but we should also be aware
of how they can be reduced,
212
672120
3016
但是我们也应当知道
如何去减少它们。
11:15
because there are dangers
to indiscriminate pessimism.
213
675160
3496
因为不分青红皂白的
悲观主义是危险的。
11:18
One of them is fatalism.
214
678680
1656
其中一个例子就是宿命论。
11:20
If all our efforts at improving the world
215
680360
2176
如果我们所有
推动这个世界进步的努力
11:22
have been in vain,
216
682560
1296
都是徒劳的,
11:23
why throw good money after bad?
217
683880
1856
为什么我们还要去做无用功?
11:25
The poor will always be with you.
218
685760
1572
反正贫穷无论如何都会一直跟随你。
11:28
And since the world will end soon --
219
688280
2296
并且既然这个世界
很快就要完蛋了——
11:30
if climate change doesn't kill us all,
220
690600
1856
如果气候变化没有将我们全都干掉,
11:32
then runaway artificial
intelligence will --
221
692480
2456
那么失控的人工智能也会——
11:34
a natural response is
to enjoy life while we can,
222
694960
3616
自然的反应就是,乐在当下吧,
11:38
eat, drink and be merry,
for tomorrow we die.
223
698600
2760
吃喝玩乐,同时坐以待毙。
11:42
The other danger of thoughtless
pessimism is radicalism.
224
702840
3296
轻率的悲观主义的
另一个危险是激进主义。
11:46
If our institutions are all failing
and beyond hope for reform,
225
706160
4016
如果我们的机构都失败了,
改革的希望也破灭了,
11:50
a natural response
is to seek to smash the machine,
226
710200
3656
自然的反应就是砸烂机器,
11:53
drain the swamp,
227
713880
1216
抽干沼泽,
11:55
burn the empire to the ground,
228
715120
1776
把帝国烧成灰烬,
11:56
on the hope that whatever
rises out of the ashes
229
716920
3296
抱着灰烬中无论长出什么
12:00
is bound to be better
than what we have now.
230
720240
2240
都要好于当下的幻想。
12:03
Well, if there is
such a thing as progress,
231
723920
2056
那么,如果真的有进步这个东西,
12:06
what causes it?
232
726000
1256
是什么导致了进步呢?
12:07
Progress is not some mystical force
or dialectic lifting us ever higher.
233
727280
5176
进步并不是某种神秘力量或辩证法,
可以将我们推向更高的境界。
12:12
It's not a mysterious arc of history
bending toward justice.
234
732480
3576
它不是一条屈服于正义的神秘弧线。
12:16
It's the result of human efforts
governed by an idea,
235
736080
3736
进步是人类在一种思想
指引下努力的结果。
12:19
an idea that we associate
with the 18th century Enlightenment,
236
739840
4016
这个思想与 18 世纪的启蒙运动有关,
12:23
namely that if we apply reason and science
237
743880
4336
那就是,如果我们运用理性和科学
12:28
that enhance human well-being,
238
748240
2056
来提高人类的幸福水平,
12:30
we can gradually succeed.
239
750320
1640
我们就可以逐渐取得成功。
12:32
Is progress inevitable? Of course not.
240
752680
3456
进步是不可避免的吗?
当然不是。
12:36
Progress does not mean
that everything becomes better
241
756160
3016
进步并不意味着所有人在任何地方,
任何时候都能变得更好。
12:39
for everyone everywhere all the time.
242
759200
2936
12:42
That would be a miracle,
and progress is not a miracle
243
762160
3256
那就算得上是一个奇迹,
但进步并不是奇迹,
12:45
but problem-solving.
244
765440
1200
而是解决问题的过程。
12:47
Problems are inevitable
245
767360
1856
问题不可避免,
12:49
and solutions create new problems
which have to be solved in their turn.
246
769240
3680
解决问题的方案还会带来新的问题,
这些问题在未来必须解决。
12:53
The unsolved problems
facing the world today are gargantuan,
247
773760
3696
当今世界面临的
未解决的问题是巨大的,
12:57
including the risks of climate change
248
777480
2776
包括气候变化
13:00
and nuclear war,
249
780280
1616
和核武战争的风险。
13:01
but we must see them
as problems to be solved,
250
781920
2536
我们必须将其视为需要解决的问题,
13:04
not apocalypses in waiting,
251
784480
2416
不能坐以待毙,
13:06
and aggressively pursue solutions
252
786920
2256
而要积极寻求解决之道,
13:09
like Deep Decarbonization
for climate change
253
789200
2856
比如以深脱碳技术对应气候变化,
13:12
and Global Zero for nuclear war.
254
792080
2200
和全球零核战。
13:15
Finally, does the Enlightenment
go against human nature?
255
795760
3896
最后一点,启蒙运动
是否违背了人类的本性?
13:19
This is an acute question for me,
256
799680
2296
这对我来说是个尖锐的问题,
13:22
because I'm a prominent advocate
of the existence of human nature,
257
802000
3416
因为我是人类本性天然存在
这一观点的主要倡导者,
13:25
with all its shortcomings
and perversities.
258
805440
3416
尽管其中存在许多的缺点和不足。
13:28
In my book "The Blank Slate,"
259
808880
1416
在我的书《白板》中,
13:30
I argued that the human prospect
is more tragic than utopian
260
810320
4136
我认为人类的前景比乌托邦更悲惨,
13:34
and that we are not stardust,
we are not golden
261
814480
2736
我们不是星尘,我们不是金色的,
13:37
and there's no way
we are getting back to the garden.
262
817240
2536
我们不可能回到伊甸园。
13:39
(Laughter)
263
819800
2496
(笑声)
13:42
But my worldview has lightened up
264
822320
2296
但是我的世界观
13:44
in the 15 years since
"The Blank Slate" was published.
265
824640
2936
随着 15 年前《白板》的出版改变了。
13:47
My acquaintance with
the statistics of human progress,
266
827600
2936
我对人类进步的统计数据的接触——
13:50
starting with violence
267
830560
1336
从暴力开始,
13:51
but now encompassing
every other aspect of our well-being,
268
831920
3776
到现在涵盖了我们幸福的每一个方面——
13:55
has fortified my belief
269
835720
1576
强化了我的信念,
13:57
that in understanding
our tribulations and woes,
270
837320
3176
即我们的困难和困境,
14:00
human nature is the problem,
271
840520
1776
人性是主要的问题,
14:02
but human nature, channeled
by Enlightenment norms and institutions,
272
842320
4336
但是人性,在启蒙运动的
规范和制度引导下,
14:06
is also the solution.
273
846680
1200
也可以是解决方案。
14:09
Admittedly, it's not easy
to replicate my own data-driven epiphany
274
849200
4896
不可否认,让人类普遍复制
我通过数据得到的洞察
14:14
with humanity at large.
275
854120
2336
并不容易。
14:16
Some intellectuals have responded
276
856480
1816
有些学者愤怒地反击
14:18
with fury to my book "Enlightenment Now,"
277
858320
2696
我的书《当下的启蒙》说:
14:21
saying first how dare he claim
that intellectuals hate progress,
278
861040
4256
首先,他怎么敢宣称
知识分子痛恨进步,
14:25
and second, how dare he claim
that there has been progress.
279
865320
3136
第二,他怎么敢宣称
世界已经取得了进步。
14:28
(Laughter)
280
868480
2680
(笑声)
14:32
With others, the idea of progress
just leaves them cold.
281
872240
3616
和其他人一样,
进步的概念对他们毫无意义。
14:35
Saving the lives of billions,
282
875880
1696
拯救数十亿人的生命,
14:37
eradicating disease, feeding the hungry,
283
877600
2896
消灭疾病,养活饥民,
14:40
teaching kids to read?
284
880520
1440
教孩子识字?
14:42
Boring.
285
882560
1200
太无聊了。
14:44
At the same time, the most common response
I have received from readers is gratitude,
286
884720
4496
同时,我得到的最常见的
反馈是读者的感谢,
14:49
gratitude for changing
their view of the world
287
889240
2376
为改变了他们对世界的看法而感激,
14:51
from a numb and helpless fatalism
288
891640
2536
从麻木和无助的宿命论
14:54
to something more constructive,
289
894200
1656
变得更具建设性,
14:55
even heroic.
290
895880
1736
甚至更英勇。
14:57
I believe that the ideals
of the Enlightenment
291
897640
2176
我相信启蒙运动的理想
14:59
can be cast a stirring narrative,
292
899840
2016
可以是一种激动人心的叙述。
15:01
and I hope that people
with greater artistic flare
293
901880
2816
我希望那些比我拥有
更丰富的艺术灵感
15:04
and rhetorical power than I
294
904720
2016
和修辞力量的人,
15:06
can tell it better and spread it further.
295
906760
3016
能够把这个故事讲述得更好,
并传播得更远。
15:09
It goes something like this.
296
909800
1440
听起来就像这样:
15:12
We are born into a pitiless universe,
297
912320
2576
我们生于无情的宇宙,
15:14
facing steep odds
against life-enabling order
298
914920
3176
面对着维持生命秩序的巨大挑战,
15:18
and in constant jeopardy of falling apart.
299
918120
2400
并不断陷入分裂的危险之中。
15:21
We were shaped by a process
that is ruthlessly competitive.
300
921360
3400
我们成长于残酷的竞争过程。
15:25
We are made from crooked timber,
301
925720
1776
我们是弯木头做的,
15:27
vulnerable to illusions, self-centeredness
302
927520
3016
容易幻想,以自我为中心,
15:30
and at times astounding stupidity.
303
930560
2240
有时愚蠢到令人发指。
15:33
Yet human nature has also
been blessed with resources
304
933800
2736
然而,人类本性也被赋予了资源,
15:36
that open a space
for a kind of redemption.
305
936560
2280
为一种救赎打开了空间。
15:39
We are endowed with the power
to combine ideas recursively,
306
939640
3256
我们被赋予了以递归的方式
组合思想的力量,
15:42
to have thoughts about our thoughts.
307
942920
2456
能够对个人的想法进行自省。
15:45
We have an instinct for language,
308
945400
1896
我们有语言的本能,
15:47
allowing us to share the fruits
of our ingenuity and experience.
309
947320
3440
让我们可以分享智慧和经验成果。
15:51
We are deepened
with the capacity for sympathy,
310
951760
2656
我们因拥有怜悯、想象、
15:54
for pity, imagination,
compassion, commiseration.
311
954440
4120
慈悲、同理心的能力而深化。
15:59
These endowments have found ways
to magnify their own power.
312
959480
3776
这些天赐的能力也找到了
扩大其作用的方法。
16:03
The scope of language has been augmented
313
963280
2016
语言的覆盖范围因手写,
16:05
by the written, printed
and electronic word.
314
965320
2840
印刷和电子文字而增加。
16:09
Our circle of sympathy has been expanded
315
969280
2016
我们的同情圈
因历史,新闻和叙事艺术而扩大。
16:11
by history, journalism
and the narrative arts.
316
971320
3080
16:15
And our puny rational faculties
have been multiplied
317
975160
2856
通过理性的规范和制度,
16:18
by the norms and institutions of reason,
318
978040
2696
好奇心,公开辩论,
16:20
intellectual curiosity, open debate,
319
980760
3296
对权威和教条的怀疑,
16:24
skepticism of authority and dogma
320
984080
2696
以及与现实对抗来验证想法的举证责任,
16:26
and the burden of proof to verify ideas
321
986800
2376
我们微小的理性思考能力
16:29
by confronting them against reality.
322
989200
1880
就会成倍增加。
16:32
As the spiral of recursive improvement
323
992320
2536
随着递归改进的螺旋上升的
16:34
gathers momentum,
324
994880
1616
势头不断增强,
16:36
we eke out victories
against the forces that grind us down,
325
996520
3536
我们战胜了让我们沮丧的力量,
16:40
not least the darker parts
of our own nature.
326
1000080
3256
尤其是本性中较黑暗的部分。
16:43
We penetrate the mysteries
of the cosmos, including life and mind.
327
1003360
4736
我们深入宇宙的奥秘,
包括生命和心灵。
16:48
We live longer, suffer less, learn more,
328
1008120
3856
我们活得更久,遭遇更少,学得更多,
16:52
get smarter and enjoy more small pleasures
329
1012000
2856
变得更聪明,享受更多的小乐趣
16:54
and rich experiences.
330
1014880
1320
以及更丰富的体验。
16:57
Fewer of us are killed,
assaulted, enslaved, exploited
331
1017080
4616
更少的人被杀害,被袭击,
被奴役,被剥削,
17:01
or oppressed by the others.
332
1021720
2016
或被人压迫。
17:03
From a few oases, the territories
with peace and prosperity are growing
333
1023760
4496
从最初的几块绿洲,
和平与繁荣的领土正在增长,
17:08
and could someday encompass the globe.
334
1028280
2360
终有一天,世界将会被其包围。
17:11
Much suffering remains
335
1031840
1896
苦难依旧,
17:13
and tremendous peril,
336
1033760
1736
危险尚存,
17:15
but ideas on how to reduce them
have been voiced,
337
1035520
2736
但减少它们的方法已经被提出,
17:18
and an infinite number of others
are yet to be conceived.
338
1038280
3895
还有无数其他的方法仍在孕育中。
17:22
We will never have a perfect world,
339
1042200
2416
我们永远不会拥有完美的世界,
17:24
and it would be dangerous to seek one.
340
1044640
2256
寻找完美世界的过程危机重重。
17:26
But there's no limit
to the betterments we can attain
341
1046920
2535
如果我们继续将知识用于人类福祉,
17:29
if we continue to apply knowledge
to enhance human flourishing.
342
1049480
3879
就会源源不断的获得更美好的东西。
17:34
This heroic story
is not just another myth.
343
1054760
3136
这个英雄故事不是另一个神话。
17:37
Myths are fictions, but this one is true,
344
1057920
3056
神话是虚构的,但这是真的。
17:41
true to the best of our knowledge,
which is the only truth we can have.
345
1061000
3936
这是我们所知道的最好的真理,
也是我们唯一能拥有的真理。
17:44
As we learn more,
346
1064960
1216
当我们懂得更多,
17:46
we can show which parts of the story
continue to be true and which ones false,
347
1066200
4456
我们就可以展示故事的哪些部分
继续为真,哪些为假,
17:50
as any of them might be
and any could become.
348
1070680
2800
而这一结果是随机的。
17:54
And this story belongs not to any tribe
349
1074320
2536
这个故事不属于任何一个部落,
17:56
but to all of humanity,
350
1076880
1856
而属于全人类,
17:58
to any sentient creature
with the power of reason
351
1078760
3696
属于任何拥有离职和情感,
18:02
and the urge to persist in its being,
352
1082480
2896
以及维系自己生命的欲望的生物。
18:05
for it requires only the convictions
353
1085400
1936
因为它只需要相信
18:07
that life is better than death,
354
1087360
2176
活着好过死亡,
18:09
health is better than sickness,
355
1089560
1936
健康好过疾病,
18:11
abundance is better than want,
356
1091520
2136
富足好于渴求,
18:13
freedom is better than coercion,
357
1093680
2416
自由好于强迫,
18:16
happiness is better than suffering
358
1096120
2176
幸福好于痛苦,
18:18
and knowledge is better
than ignorance and superstition.
359
1098320
3400
知识胜于无知和迷信。
18:22
Thank you.
360
1102520
1216
谢谢。
18:23
(Applause)
361
1103760
3800
(鼓掌)
New videos
Original video on YouTube.com
关于本网站
这个网站将向你介绍对学习英语有用的YouTube视频。你将看到来自世界各地的一流教师教授的英语课程。双击每个视频页面上显示的英文字幕,即可从那里播放视频。字幕会随着视频的播放而同步滚动。如果你有任何意见或要求,请使用此联系表与我们联系。