Is the world getting better or worse? A look at the numbers | Steven Pinker

1,485,047 views ・ 2018-05-21

TED


Please double-click on the English subtitles below to play the video.

00:13
Many people face the news each morning
0
13680
2736
00:16
with trepidation and dread.
1
16440
2456
00:18
Every day, we read of shootings,
2
18920
2656
00:21
inequality, pollution, dictatorship,
3
21600
3896
00:25
war and the spread of nuclear weapons.
4
25520
3176
00:28
These are some of the reasons
5
28720
1736
00:30
that 2016 was called the "Worst. Year. Ever."
6
30480
5456
00:35
Until 2017 claimed that record --
7
35960
2576
00:38
(Laughter)
8
38560
1056
00:39
and left many people longing for earlier decades,
9
39640
2576
00:42
when the world seemed safer, cleaner and more equal.
10
42240
3320
00:46
But is this a sensible way to understand the human condition
11
46560
3576
00:50
in the 21st century?
12
50160
1976
00:52
As Franklin Pierce Adams pointed out,
13
52160
2776
00:54
"Nothing is more responsible for the good old days
14
54960
2696
00:57
than a bad memory."
15
57680
1216
00:58
(Laughter)
16
58920
2736
01:01
You can always fool yourself into seeing a decline
17
61680
3376
01:05
if you compare bleeding headlines of the present
18
65080
2696
01:07
with rose-tinted images of the past.
19
67800
3096
01:10
What does the trajectory of the world look like
20
70920
2416
01:13
when we measure well-being over time using a constant yardstick?
21
73360
4256
01:17
Let's compare the most recent data on the present
22
77640
2696
01:20
with the same measures 30 years ago.
23
80360
2000
01:23
Last year, Americans killed each other at a rate of 5.3 per hundred thousand,
24
83320
5136
01:28
had seven percent of their citizens in poverty
25
88480
3376
01:31
and emitted 21 million tons of particulate matter
26
91880
3256
01:35
and four million tons of sulfur dioxide.
27
95160
3096
01:38
But 30 years ago, the homicide rate was 8.5 per hundred thousand,
28
98280
4136
01:42
poverty rate was 12 percent
29
102440
2096
01:44
and we emitted 35 million tons of particulate matter
30
104560
3176
01:47
and 20 million tons of sulfur dioxide.
31
107760
2720
01:51
What about the world as a whole?
32
111400
2056
01:53
Last year, the world had 12 ongoing wars,
33
113480
3416
01:56
60 autocracies,
34
116920
2136
01:59
10 percent of the world population in extreme poverty
35
119080
3616
02:02
and more than 10,000 nuclear weapons.
36
122720
2976
02:05
But 30 years ago, there were 23 wars,
37
125720
2496
02:08
85 autocracies,
38
128240
1896
02:10
37 percent of the world population in extreme poverty
39
130160
3616
02:13
and more than 60,000 nuclear weapons.
40
133800
2800
02:17
True, last year was a terrible year for terrorism in Western Europe,
41
137200
4535
02:21
with 238 deaths,
42
141759
2217
02:24
but 1988 was worse with 440 deaths.
43
144000
3200
02:28
What's going on?
44
148440
1536
02:30
Was 1988 a particularly bad year?
45
150000
3496
02:33
Or are these improvements a sign that the world, for all its struggles,
46
153520
4056
02:37
gets better over time?
47
157600
1640
02:39
Might we even invoke the admittedly old-fashioned notion of progress?
48
159800
4800
02:45
To do so is to court a certain amount of derision,
49
165880
3296
02:49
because I have found that intellectuals hate progress.
50
169200
3776
02:53
(Laughter)
51
173000
1816
02:54
(Applause)
52
174840
2816
02:57
And intellectuals who call themselves progressive really hate progress.
53
177680
3696
03:01
(Laughter)
54
181400
1136
03:02
Now, it's not that they hate the fruits of progress, mind you.
55
182560
3336
03:05
Most academics and pundits
56
185920
2616
03:08
would rather have their surgery with anesthesia than without it.
57
188560
3440
03:13
It's the idea of progress that rankles the chattering class.
58
193080
4256
03:17
If you believe that humans can improve their lot, I have been told,
59
197360
3736
03:21
that means that you have a blind faith
60
201120
2376
03:23
and a quasi-religious belief in the outmoded superstition
61
203520
4576
03:28
and the false promise of the myth of the onward march
62
208120
3816
03:31
of inexorable progress.
63
211960
2040
03:34
You are a cheerleader for vulgar American can-doism,
64
214640
4336
03:39
with the rah-rah spirit of boardroom ideology,
65
219000
3216
03:42
Silicon Valley and the Chamber of Commerce.
66
222240
3056
03:45
You are a practitioner of Whig history,
67
225320
2856
03:48
a naive optimist, a Pollyanna and, of course, a Pangloss,
68
228200
4136
03:52
alluding to the Voltaire character who declared,
69
232360
2656
03:55
"All is for the best in the best of all possible worlds."
70
235040
3336
03:58
Well, Professor Pangloss, as it happens, was a pessimist.
71
238400
3496
04:01
A true optimist believes there can be much better worlds
72
241920
2656
04:04
than the one we have today.
73
244600
1536
04:06
But all of this is irrelevant,
74
246160
1656
04:07
because the question of whether progress has taken place
75
247840
2776
04:10
is not a matter of faith
76
250640
1736
04:12
or having an optimistic temperament or seeing the glass as half full.
77
252400
3816
04:16
It's a testable hypothesis.
78
256240
1840
04:18
For all their differences,
79
258720
1376
04:20
people largely agree on what goes into human well-being:
80
260120
4376
04:24
life, health, sustenance, prosperity, peace, freedom, safety, knowledge,
81
264520
5696
04:30
leisure, happiness.
82
270240
1976
04:32
All of these things can be measured.
83
272240
1896
04:34
If they have improved over time, that, I submit, is progress.
84
274160
4336
04:38
Let's go to the data,
85
278520
1616
04:40
beginning with the most precious thing of all, life.
86
280160
3616
04:43
For most of human history, life expectancy at birth was around 30.
87
283800
4576
04:48
Today, worldwide, it is more than 70,
88
288400
2776
04:51
and in the developed parts of the world,
89
291200
1936
04:53
more than 80.
90
293160
1200
04:55
250 years ago, in the richest countries of the world,
91
295040
3136
04:58
a third of the children did not live to see their fifth birthday,
92
298200
4016
05:02
before the risk was brought down a hundredfold.
93
302240
3336
05:05
Today, that fate befalls less than six percent of children
94
305600
3256
05:08
in the poorest countries of the world.
95
308880
1840
05:11
Famine is one of the Four Horsemen of the Apocalypse.
96
311600
3416
05:15
It could bring devastation to any part of the world.
97
315040
3256
05:18
Today, famine has been banished
98
318320
1936
05:20
to the most remote and war-ravaged regions.
99
320280
2600
05:23
200 years ago, 90 percent of the world's population
100
323680
3136
05:26
subsisted in extreme poverty.
101
326840
2176
05:29
Today, fewer than 10 percent of people do.
102
329040
2560
05:32
For most of human history,
103
332720
1496
05:34
the powerful states and empires
104
334240
2056
05:36
were pretty much always at war with each other,
105
336320
2616
05:38
and peace was a mere interlude between wars.
106
338960
3456
05:42
Today, they are never at war with each other.
107
342440
2256
05:44
The last great power war
108
344720
1296
05:46
pitted the United States against China 65 years ago.
109
346040
3120
05:50
More recently, wars of all kinds have become fewer and less deadly.
110
350160
4736
05:54
The annual rate of war has fallen from about 22 per hundred thousand per year
111
354920
4456
05:59
in the early '50s to 1.2 today.
112
359400
3616
06:03
Democracy has suffered obvious setbacks
113
363040
2576
06:05
in Venezuela, in Russia, in Turkey
114
365640
3616
06:09
and is threatened by the rise of authoritarian populism
115
369280
3096
06:12
in Eastern Europe and the United States.
116
372400
2616
06:15
Yet the world has never been more democratic
117
375040
2696
06:17
than it has been in the past decade,
118
377760
1976
06:19
with two-thirds of the world's people living in democracies.
119
379760
3200
06:24
Homicide rates plunge whenever anarchy and the code of vendetta
120
384280
4136
06:28
are replaced by the rule of law.
121
388440
2376
06:30
It happened when feudal Europe was brought under the control of centralized kingdoms,
122
390840
4216
06:35
so that today a Western European
123
395080
2136
06:37
has 1/35th the chance of being murdered
124
397240
2576
06:39
compared to his medieval ancestors.
125
399840
2576
06:42
It happened again in colonial New England,
126
402440
2456
06:44
in the American Wild West when the sheriffs moved to town,
127
404920
3536
06:48
and in Mexico.
128
408480
1696
06:50
Indeed, we've become safer in just about every way.
129
410200
3520
06:54
Over the last century, we've become 96 percent less likely
130
414560
3536
06:58
to be killed in a car crash,
131
418120
2256
07:00
88 percent less likely to be mowed down on the sidewalk,
132
420400
3936
07:04
99 percent less likely to die in a plane crash,
133
424360
3736
07:08
95 percent less likely to be killed on the job,
134
428120
3656
07:11
89 percent less likely to be killed by an act of God,
135
431800
3616
07:15
such as a drought, flood, wildfire, storm, volcano,
136
435440
3936
07:19
landslide, earthquake or meteor strike,
137
439400
2656
07:22
presumably not because God has become less angry with us
138
442080
3256
07:25
but because of improvements in the resilience of our infrastructure.
139
445360
4736
07:30
And what about the quintessential act of God,
140
450120
3256
07:33
the projectile hurled by Zeus himself?
141
453400
3496
07:36
Yes, we are 97 percent less likely to be killed by a bolt of lightning.
142
456920
4240
07:43
Before the 17th century,
143
463480
1656
07:45
no more than 15 percent of Europeans could read or write.
144
465160
3536
07:48
Europe and the United States achieved universal literacy
145
468720
3136
07:51
by the middle of the 20th century,
146
471880
1936
07:53
and the rest of the world is catching up.
147
473840
2496
07:56
Today, more than 90 percent of the world's population
148
476360
3416
07:59
under the age of 25 can read and write.
149
479800
2440
08:03
In the 19th century, Westerners worked more than 60 hours per week.
150
483440
3976
08:07
Today, they work fewer than 40.
151
487440
1920
08:10
Thanks to the universal penetration of running water and electricity
152
490440
4416
08:14
in the developed world
153
494880
1376
08:16
and the widespread adoption of washing machines, vacuum cleaners,
154
496280
3976
08:20
refrigerators, dishwashers, stoves and microwaves,
155
500280
3976
08:24
the amount of our lives that we forfeit to housework
156
504280
2896
08:27
has fallen from 60 hours a week
157
507200
2376
08:29
to fewer than 15 hours a week.
158
509600
1960
08:32
Do all of these gains in health, wealth, safety, knowledge and leisure
159
512760
4536
08:37
make us any happier?
160
517320
1696
08:39
The answer is yes.
161
519040
1216
08:40
In 86 percent of the world's countries,
162
520280
2176
08:42
happiness has increased in recent decades.
163
522480
2360
08:45
Well, I hope to have convinced you
164
525799
1736
08:47
that progress is not a matter of faith or optimism,
165
527559
3417
08:51
but is a fact of human history,
166
531000
2135
08:53
indeed the greatest fact in human history.
167
533159
2561
08:56
And how has this fact been covered in the news?
168
536480
2816
08:59
(Laughter)
169
539320
3160
09:03
A tabulation of positive and negative emotion words in news stories
170
543360
3976
09:07
has shown that during the decades in which humanity has gotten healthier,
171
547360
3656
09:11
wealthier, wiser, safer and happier,
172
551040
2816
09:13
the "New York Times" has become increasingly morose
173
553880
4096
09:18
and the world's broadcasts too have gotten steadily glummer.
174
558000
3600
09:22
Why don't people appreciate progress?
175
562720
2696
09:25
Part of the answer comes from our cognitive psychology.
176
565440
2976
09:28
We estimate risk using a mental shortcut called the "availability heuristic."
177
568440
5016
09:33
The easier it is to recall something from memory,
178
573480
2776
09:36
the more probable we judge it to be.
179
576280
2000
09:39
The other part of the answer comes from the nature of journalism,
180
579200
3616
09:42
captured in this satirical headline from "The Onion,"
181
582840
3376
09:46
"CNN Holds Morning Meeting to Decide
182
586240
2056
09:48
What Viewers Should Panic About For Rest of Day."
183
588320
2296
09:50
(Laughter)
184
590640
1696
09:52
(Applause)
185
592360
4040
09:57
News is about stuff that happens, not stuff that doesn't happen.
186
597160
3816
10:01
You never see a journalist who says,
187
601000
2376
10:03
"I'm reporting live from a country that has been at peace for 40 years,"
188
603400
4216
10:07
or a city that has not been attacked by terrorists.
189
607640
2640
10:10
Also, bad things can happen quickly,
190
610960
2336
10:13
but good things aren't built in a day.
191
613320
2416
10:15
The papers could have run the headline,
192
615760
1896
10:17
"137,000 people escaped from extreme poverty yesterday"
193
617680
4376
10:22
every day for the last 25 years.
194
622080
2856
10:24
That's one and a quarter billion people leaving poverty behind,
195
624960
4216
10:29
but you never read about it.
196
629200
2016
10:31
Also, the news capitalizes on our morbid interest
197
631240
3296
10:34
in what can go wrong,
198
634560
1256
10:35
captured in the programming policy, "If it bleeds, it leads."
199
635840
4336
10:40
Well, if you combine our cognitive biases with the nature of news,
200
640200
3736
10:43
you can see why the world has been coming to an end
201
643960
2696
10:46
for a very long time indeed.
202
646680
1960
10:50
Let me address some questions about progress
203
650840
2096
10:52
that no doubt have occurred to many of you.
204
652960
2360
10:56
First, isn't it good to be pessimistic
205
656320
2736
10:59
to safeguard against complacency,
206
659080
2416
11:01
to rake the muck, to speak truth to power?
207
661520
2656
11:04
Well, not exactly.
208
664200
1976
11:06
It's good to be accurate.
209
666200
1976
11:08
Of course we should be aware of suffering and danger
210
668200
2456
11:10
wherever they occur,
211
670680
1416
11:12
but we should also be aware of how they can be reduced,
212
672120
3016
11:15
because there are dangers to indiscriminate pessimism.
213
675160
3496
11:18
One of them is fatalism.
214
678680
1656
11:20
If all our efforts at improving the world
215
680360
2176
11:22
have been in vain,
216
682560
1296
11:23
why throw good money after bad?
217
683880
1856
11:25
The poor will always be with you.
218
685760
1572
11:28
And since the world will end soon --
219
688280
2296
11:30
if climate change doesn't kill us all,
220
690600
1856
11:32
then runaway artificial intelligence will --
221
692480
2456
11:34
a natural response is to enjoy life while we can,
222
694960
3616
11:38
eat, drink and be merry, for tomorrow we die.
223
698600
2760
11:42
The other danger of thoughtless pessimism is radicalism.
224
702840
3296
11:46
If our institutions are all failing and beyond hope for reform,
225
706160
4016
11:50
a natural response is to seek to smash the machine,
226
710200
3656
11:53
drain the swamp,
227
713880
1216
11:55
burn the empire to the ground,
228
715120
1776
11:56
on the hope that whatever rises out of the ashes
229
716920
3296
12:00
is bound to be better than what we have now.
230
720240
2240
12:03
Well, if there is such a thing as progress,
231
723920
2056
12:06
what causes it?
232
726000
1256
12:07
Progress is not some mystical force or dialectic lifting us ever higher.
233
727280
5176
12:12
It's not a mysterious arc of history bending toward justice.
234
732480
3576
12:16
It's the result of human efforts governed by an idea,
235
736080
3736
12:19
an idea that we associate with the 18th century Enlightenment,
236
739840
4016
12:23
namely that if we apply reason and science
237
743880
4336
12:28
that enhance human well-being,
238
748240
2056
12:30
we can gradually succeed.
239
750320
1640
12:32
Is progress inevitable? Of course not.
240
752680
3456
12:36
Progress does not mean that everything becomes better
241
756160
3016
12:39
for everyone everywhere all the time.
242
759200
2936
12:42
That would be a miracle, and progress is not a miracle
243
762160
3256
12:45
but problem-solving.
244
765440
1200
12:47
Problems are inevitable
245
767360
1856
12:49
and solutions create new problems which have to be solved in their turn.
246
769240
3680
12:53
The unsolved problems facing the world today are gargantuan,
247
773760
3696
12:57
including the risks of climate change
248
777480
2776
13:00
and nuclear war,
249
780280
1616
13:01
but we must see them as problems to be solved,
250
781920
2536
13:04
not apocalypses in waiting,
251
784480
2416
13:06
and aggressively pursue solutions
252
786920
2256
13:09
like Deep Decarbonization for climate change
253
789200
2856
13:12
and Global Zero for nuclear war.
254
792080
2200
13:15
Finally, does the Enlightenment go against human nature?
255
795760
3896
13:19
This is an acute question for me,
256
799680
2296
13:22
because I'm a prominent advocate of the existence of human nature,
257
802000
3416
13:25
with all its shortcomings and perversities.
258
805440
3416
13:28
In my book "The Blank Slate,"
259
808880
1416
13:30
I argued that the human prospect is more tragic than utopian
260
810320
4136
13:34
and that we are not stardust, we are not golden
261
814480
2736
13:37
and there's no way we are getting back to the garden.
262
817240
2536
13:39
(Laughter)
263
819800
2496
13:42
But my worldview has lightened up
264
822320
2296
13:44
in the 15 years since "The Blank Slate" was published.
265
824640
2936
13:47
My acquaintance with the statistics of human progress,
266
827600
2936
13:50
starting with violence
267
830560
1336
13:51
but now encompassing every other aspect of our well-being,
268
831920
3776
13:55
has fortified my belief
269
835720
1576
13:57
that in understanding our tribulations and woes,
270
837320
3176
14:00
human nature is the problem,
271
840520
1776
14:02
but human nature, channeled by Enlightenment norms and institutions,
272
842320
4336
14:06
is also the solution.
273
846680
1200
14:09
Admittedly, it's not easy to replicate my own data-driven epiphany
274
849200
4896
14:14
with humanity at large.
275
854120
2336
14:16
Some intellectuals have responded
276
856480
1816
14:18
with fury to my book "Enlightenment Now,"
277
858320
2696
14:21
saying first how dare he claim that intellectuals hate progress,
278
861040
4256
14:25
and second, how dare he claim that there has been progress.
279
865320
3136
14:28
(Laughter)
280
868480
2680
14:32
With others, the idea of progress just leaves them cold.
281
872240
3616
14:35
Saving the lives of billions,
282
875880
1696
14:37
eradicating disease, feeding the hungry,
283
877600
2896
14:40
teaching kids to read?
284
880520
1440
14:42
Boring.
285
882560
1200
14:44
At the same time, the most common response I have received from readers is gratitude,
286
884720
4496
14:49
gratitude for changing their view of the world
287
889240
2376
14:51
from a numb and helpless fatalism
288
891640
2536
14:54
to something more constructive,
289
894200
1656
14:55
even heroic.
290
895880
1736
14:57
I believe that the ideals of the Enlightenment
291
897640
2176
14:59
can be cast a stirring narrative,
292
899840
2016
15:01
and I hope that people with greater artistic flare
293
901880
2816
15:04
and rhetorical power than I
294
904720
2016
15:06
can tell it better and spread it further.
295
906760
3016
15:09
It goes something like this.
296
909800
1440
15:12
We are born into a pitiless universe,
297
912320
2576
15:14
facing steep odds against life-enabling order
298
914920
3176
15:18
and in constant jeopardy of falling apart.
299
918120
2400
15:21
We were shaped by a process that is ruthlessly competitive.
300
921360
3400
15:25
We are made from crooked timber,
301
925720
1776
15:27
vulnerable to illusions, self-centeredness
302
927520
3016
15:30
and at times astounding stupidity.
303
930560
2240
15:33
Yet human nature has also been blessed with resources
304
933800
2736
15:36
that open a space for a kind of redemption.
305
936560
2280
15:39
We are endowed with the power to combine ideas recursively,
306
939640
3256
15:42
to have thoughts about our thoughts.
307
942920
2456
15:45
We have an instinct for language,
308
945400
1896
15:47
allowing us to share the fruits of our ingenuity and experience.
309
947320
3440
15:51
We are deepened with the capacity for sympathy,
310
951760
2656
15:54
for pity, imagination, compassion, commiseration.
311
954440
4120
15:59
These endowments have found ways to magnify their own power.
312
959480
3776
16:03
The scope of language has been augmented
313
963280
2016
16:05
by the written, printed and electronic word.
314
965320
2840
16:09
Our circle of sympathy has been expanded
315
969280
2016
16:11
by history, journalism and the narrative arts.
316
971320
3080
16:15
And our puny rational faculties have been multiplied
317
975160
2856
16:18
by the norms and institutions of reason,
318
978040
2696
16:20
intellectual curiosity, open debate,
319
980760
3296
16:24
skepticism of authority and dogma
320
984080
2696
16:26
and the burden of proof to verify ideas
321
986800
2376
16:29
by confronting them against reality.
322
989200
1880
16:32
As the spiral of recursive improvement
323
992320
2536
16:34
gathers momentum,
324
994880
1616
16:36
we eke out victories against the forces that grind us down,
325
996520
3536
16:40
not least the darker parts of our own nature.
326
1000080
3256
16:43
We penetrate the mysteries of the cosmos, including life and mind.
327
1003360
4736
16:48
We live longer, suffer less, learn more,
328
1008120
3856
16:52
get smarter and enjoy more small pleasures
329
1012000
2856
16:54
and rich experiences.
330
1014880
1320
16:57
Fewer of us are killed, assaulted, enslaved, exploited
331
1017080
4616
17:01
or oppressed by the others.
332
1021720
2016
17:03
From a few oases, the territories with peace and prosperity are growing
333
1023760
4496
17:08
and could someday encompass the globe.
334
1028280
2360
17:11
Much suffering remains
335
1031840
1896
17:13
and tremendous peril,
336
1033760
1736
17:15
but ideas on how to reduce them have been voiced,
337
1035520
2736
17:18
and an infinite number of others are yet to be conceived.
338
1038280
3895
17:22
We will never have a perfect world,
339
1042200
2416
17:24
and it would be dangerous to seek one.
340
1044640
2256
17:26
But there's no limit to the betterments we can attain
341
1046920
2535
17:29
if we continue to apply knowledge to enhance human flourishing.
342
1049480
3879
17:34
This heroic story is not just another myth.
343
1054760
3136
17:37
Myths are fictions, but this one is true,
344
1057920
3056
17:41
true to the best of our knowledge, which is the only truth we can have.
345
1061000
3936
17:44
As we learn more,
346
1064960
1216
17:46
we can show which parts of the story continue to be true and which ones false,
347
1066200
4456
17:50
as any of them might be and any could become.
348
1070680
2800
17:54
And this story belongs not to any tribe
349
1074320
2536
17:56
but to all of humanity,
350
1076880
1856
17:58
to any sentient creature with the power of reason
351
1078760
3696
18:02
and the urge to persist in its being,
352
1082480
2896
18:05
for it requires only the convictions
353
1085400
1936
18:07
that life is better than death,
354
1087360
2176
18:09
health is better than sickness,
355
1089560
1936
18:11
abundance is better than want,
356
1091520
2136
18:13
freedom is better than coercion,
357
1093680
2416
18:16
happiness is better than suffering
358
1096120
2176
18:18
and knowledge is better than ignorance and superstition.
359
1098320
3400
18:22
Thank you.
360
1102520
1216
18:23
(Applause)
361
1103760
3800
About this website

This site will introduce you to YouTube videos that are useful for learning English. You will see English lessons taught by top-notch teachers from around the world. Double-click on the English subtitles displayed on each video page to play the video from there. The subtitles scroll in sync with the video playback. If you have any comments or requests, please contact us using this contact form.

https://forms.gle/WvT1wiN1qDtmnspy7