The sound the universe makes | Janna Levin

196,962 views ・ 2011-03-15

TED


Please double-click on the English subtitles below to play the video.

00:15
I want to ask you all to consider for a second
0
15260
3000
00:18
the very simple fact
1
18260
2000
00:20
that, by far,
2
20260
2000
00:22
most of what we know about the universe
3
22260
2000
00:24
comes to us from light.
4
24260
2000
00:26
We can stand on the Earth and look up at the night sky
5
26260
3000
00:29
and see stars with our bare eyes.
6
29260
3000
00:32
The Sun burns our peripheral vision.
7
32260
2000
00:34
We see light reflected off the Moon.
8
34260
3000
00:37
And in the time since Galileo pointed that rudimentary telescope
9
37260
4000
00:41
at the celestial bodies,
10
41260
3000
00:44
the known universe has come to us through light,
11
44260
3000
00:47
across vast eras in cosmic history.
12
47260
3000
00:50
And with all of our modern telescopes,
13
50260
3000
00:53
we've been able to collect
14
53260
2000
00:55
this stunning silent movie of the universe --
15
55260
3000
00:58
these series of snapshots
16
58260
3000
01:01
that go all the way back to the Big Bang.
17
61260
3000
01:04
And yet, the universe is not a silent movie
18
64260
3000
01:07
because the universe isn't silent.
19
67260
2000
01:09
I'd like to convince you
20
69260
2000
01:11
that the universe has a soundtrack
21
71260
2000
01:13
and that soundtrack is played on space itself,
22
73260
4000
01:17
because space can wobble like a drum.
23
77260
3000
01:20
It can ring out a kind of recording
24
80260
3000
01:23
throughout the universe
25
83260
2000
01:25
of some of the most dramatic events as they unfold.
26
85260
3000
01:28
Now we'd like to be able to add
27
88260
3000
01:31
to a kind of glorious visual composition
28
91260
3000
01:34
that we have of the universe --
29
94260
2000
01:36
a sonic composition.
30
96260
2000
01:38
And while we've never heard the sounds from space,
31
98260
4000
01:42
we really should, in the next few years,
32
102260
3000
01:45
start to turn up the volume on what's going on out there.
33
105260
2000
01:47
So in this ambition
34
107260
2000
01:49
to capture songs from the universe,
35
109260
3000
01:52
we turn our focus
36
112260
2000
01:54
to black holes and the promise they have,
37
114260
2000
01:56
because black holes can bang on space-time
38
116260
3000
01:59
like mallets on a drum
39
119260
2000
02:01
and have a very characteristic song,
40
121260
2000
02:03
which I'd like to play for you -- some of our predictions
41
123260
3000
02:06
for what that song will be like.
42
126260
2000
02:08
Now black holes are dark against a dark sky.
43
128260
3000
02:11
We can't see them directly.
44
131260
2000
02:13
They're not brought to us with light, at least not directly.
45
133260
3000
02:16
We can see them indirectly,
46
136260
2000
02:18
because black holes wreak havoc on their environment.
47
138260
3000
02:21
They destroy stars around them.
48
141260
2000
02:23
They churn up debris in their surroundings.
49
143260
3000
02:26
But they won't come to us directly through light.
50
146260
2000
02:28
We might one day see a shadow
51
148260
2000
02:30
a black hole can cast on a very bright background,
52
150260
3000
02:33
but we haven't yet.
53
153260
2000
02:35
And yet black holes may be heard
54
155260
2000
02:37
even if they're not seen,
55
157260
2000
02:39
and that's because they bang on space-time like a drum.
56
159260
4000
02:43
Now we owe the idea that space can ring like a drum
57
163260
3000
02:46
to Albert Einstein -- to whom we owe so much.
58
166260
3000
02:49
Einstein realized that if space were empty,
59
169260
2000
02:51
if the universe were empty,
60
171260
2000
02:53
it would be like this picture,
61
173260
3000
02:56
except for maybe without the helpful grid drawn on it.
62
176260
3000
02:59
But if we were freely falling through the space,
63
179260
3000
03:02
even without this helpful grid,
64
182260
2000
03:04
we might be able to paint it ourselves,
65
184260
2000
03:06
because we would notice that we traveled along straight lines,
66
186260
3000
03:09
undeflected straight paths
67
189260
2000
03:11
through the universe.
68
191260
2000
03:13
Einstein also realized --
69
193260
2000
03:15
and this is the real meat of the matter --
70
195260
2000
03:17
that if you put energy or mass in the universe,
71
197260
3000
03:20
it would curve space,
72
200260
2000
03:22
and a freely falling object
73
202260
2000
03:24
would pass by, let's say, the Sun
74
204260
2000
03:26
and it would be deflected
75
206260
2000
03:28
along the natural curves in the space.
76
208260
2000
03:30
It was Einstein's great general theory of relativity.
77
210260
4000
03:34
Now even light will be bent by those paths.
78
214260
3000
03:37
And you can be bent so much
79
217260
2000
03:39
that you're caught in orbit around the Sun,
80
219260
2000
03:41
as the Earth is, or the Moon around the Earth.
81
221260
2000
03:43
These are the natural curves in space.
82
223260
3000
03:46
What Einstein did not realize
83
226260
2000
03:48
was that, if you took our Sun
84
228260
2000
03:50
and you crushed it down to six kilometers --
85
230260
3000
03:53
so you took a million times the mass of the Earth
86
233260
3000
03:56
and you crushed it to six kilometers across,
87
236260
3000
03:59
you would make a black hole,
88
239260
2000
04:01
an object so dense
89
241260
2000
04:03
that if light veered too close, it would never escape --
90
243260
3000
04:06
a dark shadow against the universe.
91
246260
3000
04:09
It wasn't Einstein who realized this,
92
249260
2000
04:11
it was Karl Schwarzschild
93
251260
2000
04:13
who was a German Jew in World War I --
94
253260
2000
04:15
joined the German army already an accomplished scientist,
95
255260
3000
04:18
working on the Russian front.
96
258260
3000
04:21
I like to imagine Schwarzschild in the war in the trenches
97
261260
3000
04:24
calculating ballistic trajectories for cannon fire,
98
264260
4000
04:28
and then, in between,
99
268260
2000
04:30
calculating Einstein's equations --
100
270260
2000
04:32
as you do in the trenches.
101
272260
2000
04:34
And he was reading Einstein's recently published
102
274260
2000
04:36
general theory of relativity,
103
276260
2000
04:38
and he was thrilled by this theory.
104
278260
2000
04:40
And he quickly surmised
105
280260
2000
04:42
an exact mathematical solution
106
282260
2000
04:44
that described something very extraordinary:
107
284260
2000
04:46
curves so strong
108
286260
2000
04:48
that space would rain down into them,
109
288260
3000
04:51
space itself would curve like a waterfall
110
291260
2000
04:53
flowing down the throat of a hole.
111
293260
2000
04:55
And even light could not escape this current.
112
295260
3000
04:58
Light would be dragged down the hole
113
298260
2000
05:00
as everything else would be,
114
300260
2000
05:02
and all that would be left would be a shadow.
115
302260
2000
05:04
Now he wrote to Einstein,
116
304260
2000
05:06
and he said, "As you will see,
117
306260
2000
05:08
the war has been kind to me enough.
118
308260
3000
05:11
Despite the heavy gunfire,
119
311260
3000
05:14
I've been able to get away from it all
120
314260
2000
05:16
and walk through the land of your ideas."
121
316260
3000
05:19
And Einstein was very impressed with his exact solution,
122
319260
3000
05:22
and I should hope also the dedication of the scientist.
123
322260
3000
05:25
This is the hardworking scientist under harsh conditions.
124
325260
3000
05:28
And he took Schwarzschild's idea
125
328260
2000
05:30
to the Prussian Academy of Sciences the next week.
126
330260
3000
05:33
But Einstein always thought black holes were a mathematical oddity.
127
333260
3000
05:36
He did not believe they existed in nature.
128
336260
3000
05:39
He thought nature would protect us from their formation.
129
339260
3000
05:42
It was decades
130
342260
2000
05:44
before the term "black hole" was coined
131
344260
2000
05:46
and people realized
132
346260
2000
05:48
that black holes are real astrophysical objects --
133
348260
2000
05:50
in fact they're the death state
134
350260
2000
05:52
of very massive stars
135
352260
2000
05:54
that collapse catastrophically
136
354260
2000
05:56
at the end of their lifetime.
137
356260
2000
05:58
Now our Sun will not collapse to a black hole.
138
358260
2000
06:00
It's actually not massive enough.
139
360260
2000
06:02
But if we did a little thought experiment --
140
362260
2000
06:04
as Einstein was very fond of doing --
141
364260
2000
06:06
we could imagine
142
366260
2000
06:08
putting the Sun crushed down to six kilometers,
143
368260
3000
06:11
and putting a tiny little Earth around it in orbit,
144
371260
3000
06:14
maybe 30 kilometers
145
374260
2000
06:16
outside of the black-hole sun.
146
376260
3000
06:19
And it would be self-illuminated,
147
379260
2000
06:21
because now the Sun's gone, we have no other source of light --
148
381260
2000
06:23
so let's make our little Earth self-illuminated.
149
383260
3000
06:26
And you would realize you could put the Earth in a happy orbit
150
386260
2000
06:28
even 30 km
151
388260
2000
06:30
outside of this crushed black hole.
152
390260
3000
06:33
This crushed black hole
153
393260
2000
06:35
actually would fit inside Manhattan, more or less.
154
395260
2000
06:37
It might spill off into the Hudson a little bit
155
397260
2000
06:39
before it destroyed the Earth.
156
399260
2000
06:41
But basically that's what we're talking about.
157
401260
2000
06:43
We're talking about an object that you could crush down
158
403260
2000
06:45
to half the square area of Manhattan.
159
405260
2000
06:47
So we move this Earth very close --
160
407260
2000
06:49
30 kilometers outside --
161
409260
2000
06:51
and we notice it's perfectly fine orbiting around the black hole.
162
411260
3000
06:54
There's a sort of myth
163
414260
2000
06:56
that black holes devour everything in the universe,
164
416260
2000
06:58
but you actually have to get very close to fall in.
165
418260
3000
07:01
But what's very impressive is that, from our vantage point,
166
421260
3000
07:04
we can always see the Earth.
167
424260
2000
07:06
It cannot hide behind the black hole.
168
426260
2000
07:08
The light from the Earth, some of it falls in,
169
428260
2000
07:10
but some of it gets lensed around and brought back to us.
170
430260
3000
07:13
So you can't hide anything behind a black hole.
171
433260
2000
07:15
If this were Battlestar Galactica
172
435260
2000
07:17
and you're fighting the Cylons,
173
437260
2000
07:19
don't hide behind the black hole.
174
439260
2000
07:21
They can see you.
175
441260
3000
07:24
Now, our Sun will not collapse to a black hole --
176
444260
2000
07:26
it's not massive enough --
177
446260
2000
07:28
but there are tens of thousands of black holes in our galaxy.
178
448260
4000
07:32
And if one were to eclipse the Milky Way,
179
452260
3000
07:35
this is what it would look like.
180
455260
2000
07:37
We would see a shadow of that black hole
181
457260
3000
07:40
against the hundred billion stars
182
460260
2000
07:42
in the Milky Way Galaxy and its luminous dust lanes.
183
462260
3000
07:45
And if we were to fall towards this black hole,
184
465260
3000
07:48
we would see all of that light lensed around it,
185
468260
3000
07:51
and we could even start to cross into that shadow
186
471260
3000
07:54
and really not notice that anything dramatic had happened.
187
474260
3000
07:57
It would be bad if we tried to fire our rockets and get out of there
188
477260
3000
08:00
because we couldn't,
189
480260
2000
08:02
anymore than light can escape.
190
482260
2000
08:04
But even though the black hole is dark from the outside,
191
484260
3000
08:07
it's not dark on the inside,
192
487260
2000
08:09
because all of the light from the galaxy can fall in behind us.
193
489260
3000
08:12
And even though, due to a relativistic effect known as time dilation,
194
492260
4000
08:16
our clocks would seem to slow down
195
496260
3000
08:19
relative to galactic time,
196
499260
3000
08:22
it would look as though the evolution of the galaxy
197
502260
3000
08:25
had been sped up and shot at us,
198
505260
2000
08:27
right before we were crushed to death by the black hole.
199
507260
3000
08:30
It would be like a near-death experience
200
510260
2000
08:32
where you see the light at the end of the tunnel,
201
512260
2000
08:34
but it's a total death experience.
202
514260
2000
08:36
(Laughter)
203
516260
2000
08:38
And there's no way of telling anybody
204
518260
2000
08:40
about the light at the end of the tunnel.
205
520260
2000
08:42
Now we've never seen a shadow like this of a black hole,
206
522260
3000
08:45
but black holes can be heard,
207
525260
2000
08:47
even if they're not seen.
208
527260
2000
08:49
Imagine now taking an astrophysically realistic situation --
209
529260
4000
08:53
imagine two black holes that have lived a long life together.
210
533260
3000
08:56
Maybe they started as stars
211
536260
2000
08:58
and collapsed to two black holes --
212
538260
2000
09:00
each one 10 times the mass of the Sun.
213
540260
3000
09:03
So now we're going to crush them down to 60 kilometers across.
214
543260
3000
09:06
They can be spinning
215
546260
2000
09:08
hundreds of times a second.
216
548260
2000
09:10
At the end of their lives,
217
550260
2000
09:12
they're going around each other very near the speed of light.
218
552260
3000
09:15
So they're crossing thousands of kilometers
219
555260
2000
09:17
in a fraction of a second,
220
557260
2000
09:19
and as they do so, they not only curve space,
221
559260
2000
09:21
but they leave behind in their wake
222
561260
2000
09:23
a ringing of space,
223
563260
2000
09:25
an actual wave on space-time.
224
565260
2000
09:27
Space squeezes and stretches
225
567260
2000
09:29
as it emanates out from these black holes
226
569260
2000
09:31
banging on the universe.
227
571260
2000
09:33
And they travel out into the cosmos
228
573260
2000
09:35
at the speed of light.
229
575260
2000
09:37
This computer simulation
230
577260
2000
09:39
is due to a relativity group at NASA Goddard.
231
579260
3000
09:42
It took almost 30 years for anyone in the world to crack this problem.
232
582260
3000
09:45
This was one of the groups.
233
585260
2000
09:47
It shows two black holes in orbit around each other,
234
587260
2000
09:49
again, with these helpfully painted curves.
235
589260
2000
09:51
And if you can see -- it's kind of faint --
236
591260
3000
09:54
but if you can see the red waves emanating out,
237
594260
3000
09:57
those are the gravitational waves.
238
597260
2000
09:59
They're literally the sounds of space ringing,
239
599260
3000
10:02
and they will travel out from these black holes at the speed of light
240
602260
2000
10:04
as they ring down and coalesce
241
604260
3000
10:07
to one spinning, quiet black hole
242
607260
2000
10:09
at the end of the day.
243
609260
2000
10:11
If you were standing near enough,
244
611260
2000
10:13
your ear would resonate
245
613260
2000
10:15
with the squeezing and stretching of space.
246
615260
2000
10:17
You would literally hear the sound.
247
617260
2000
10:19
Now of course, your head would be squeezed and stretched unhelpfully,
248
619260
4000
10:23
so you might have trouble understanding what's going on.
249
623260
3000
10:26
But I'd like to play for you
250
626260
2000
10:28
the sound that we predict.
251
628260
2000
10:30
This is from my group --
252
630260
2000
10:32
a slightly less glamorous computer modeling.
253
632260
3000
10:35
Imagine a lighter black hole
254
635260
2000
10:37
falling into a very heavy black hole.
255
637260
2000
10:39
The sound you're hearing
256
639260
2000
10:41
is the light black hole banging on space
257
641260
3000
10:44
each time it gets close.
258
644260
2000
10:46
If it gets far away, it's a little too quiet.
259
646260
3000
10:49
But it comes in like a mallet,
260
649260
2000
10:51
and it literally cracks space,
261
651260
2000
10:53
wobbling it like a drum.
262
653260
2000
10:55
And we can predict what the sound will be.
263
655260
3000
10:58
We know that, as it falls in,
264
658260
2000
11:00
it gets faster and it gets louder.
265
660260
2000
11:02
And eventually,
266
662260
2000
11:04
we're going to hear the little guy just fall into the bigger guy.
267
664260
3000
11:07
(Thumping)
268
667260
17000
11:24
Then it's gone.
269
684260
2000
11:26
Now I've never heard it that loud -- it's actually more dramatic.
270
686260
2000
11:28
At home it sounds kind of anticlimactic.
271
688260
2000
11:30
It's sort of like ding, ding, ding.
272
690260
2000
11:32
This is another sound from my group.
273
692260
4000
11:36
No, I'm not showing you any images,
274
696260
2000
11:38
because black holes don't leave behind
275
698260
2000
11:40
helpful trails of ink,
276
700260
2000
11:42
and space is not painted,
277
702260
2000
11:44
showing you the curves.
278
704260
2000
11:46
But if you were to float by in space on a space holiday
279
706260
2000
11:48
and you heard this,
280
708260
2000
11:50
you want to get moving.
281
710260
2000
11:52
(Laughter)
282
712260
2000
11:54
Want to get away from the sound.
283
714260
2000
11:56
Both black holes are moving.
284
716260
2000
11:58
Both black holes are getting closer together.
285
718260
3000
12:01
In this case, they're both wobbling quite a lot.
286
721260
3000
12:04
And then they're going to merge.
287
724260
2000
12:06
(Thumping)
288
726260
8000
12:14
Now it's gone.
289
734260
2000
12:16
Now that chirp is very characteristic of black holes merging --
290
736260
3000
12:19
that it chirps up at the end.
291
739260
3000
12:22
Now that's our prediction
292
742260
2000
12:24
for what we'll see.
293
744260
2000
12:26
Luckily we're at this safe distance in Long Beach, California.
294
746260
2000
12:28
And surely, somewhere in the universe
295
748260
2000
12:30
two black holes have merged.
296
750260
2000
12:32
And surely, the space around us
297
752260
2000
12:34
is ringing
298
754260
2000
12:36
after traveling maybe a million light years, or a million years,
299
756260
3000
12:39
at the speed of light to get to us.
300
759260
3000
12:42
But the sound is too quiet for any of us to ever hear.
301
762260
3000
12:45
There are very industrious experiments being built on Earth --
302
765260
3000
12:48
one called LIGO --
303
768260
2000
12:50
which will detect deviations
304
770260
2000
12:52
in the squeezing and stretching of space
305
772260
3000
12:55
at less than the fraction of a nucleus of an atom
306
775260
3000
12:58
over four kilometers.
307
778260
2000
13:00
It's a remarkably ambitious experiment,
308
780260
2000
13:02
and it's going to be at advanced sensitivity
309
782260
2000
13:04
within the next few years -- to pick this up.
310
784260
3000
13:07
There's also a mission proposed for space,
311
787260
2000
13:09
which hopefully will launch in the next ten years,
312
789260
2000
13:11
called LISA.
313
791260
2000
13:13
And LISA will be able to see super-massive black holes --
314
793260
3000
13:16
black holes millions or billions of times
315
796260
3000
13:19
the mass of the Sun.
316
799260
2000
13:21
In this Hubble image, we see two galaxies.
317
801260
3000
13:24
They look like they're frozen in some embrace.
318
804260
3000
13:27
And each one probably harbors
319
807260
2000
13:29
a super-massive black hole at its core.
320
809260
3000
13:32
But they're not frozen;
321
812260
2000
13:34
they're actually merging.
322
814260
2000
13:36
These two black holes are colliding,
323
816260
2000
13:38
and they will merge over a billion-year time scale.
324
818260
3000
13:41
It's beyond our human perception
325
821260
2000
13:43
to pick up a song of that duration.
326
823260
3000
13:46
But LISA could see the final stages
327
826260
2000
13:48
of two super-massive black holes
328
828260
2000
13:50
earlier in the universe's history,
329
830260
2000
13:52
the last 15 minutes before they fall together.
330
832260
3000
13:55
And it's not just black holes,
331
835260
2000
13:57
but it's also any big disturbance in the universe --
332
837260
3000
14:00
and the biggest of them all is the Big Bang.
333
840260
2000
14:02
When that expression was coined, it was derisive --
334
842260
3000
14:05
like, "Oh, who would believe in a Big Bang?"
335
845260
2000
14:07
But now it actually might be more technically accurate
336
847260
2000
14:09
because it might bang.
337
849260
2000
14:11
It might make a sound.
338
851260
2000
14:13
This animation from my friends at Proton Studios
339
853260
3000
14:16
shows looking at the Big Bang from the outside.
340
856260
2000
14:18
We don't ever want to do that actually. We want to be inside the universe
341
858260
3000
14:21
because there's no such thing as standing outside the universe.
342
861260
3000
14:24
So imagine you're inside the Big Bang.
343
864260
2000
14:26
It's everywhere, it's all around you,
344
866260
2000
14:28
and the space is wobbling chaotically.
345
868260
2000
14:30
Fourteen billion years pass
346
870260
2000
14:32
and this song is still ringing all around us.
347
872260
3000
14:35
Galaxies form,
348
875260
2000
14:37
and generations of stars form in those galaxies,
349
877260
2000
14:39
and around one star,
350
879260
2000
14:41
at least one star,
351
881260
2000
14:43
is a habitable planet.
352
883260
2000
14:45
And here we are frantically building these experiments,
353
885260
3000
14:48
doing these calculations, writing these computer codes.
354
888260
2000
14:50
Imagine a billion years ago,
355
890260
3000
14:53
two black holes collided.
356
893260
2000
14:55
That song has been ringing through space
357
895260
2000
14:57
for all that time.
358
897260
2000
14:59
We weren't even here.
359
899260
2000
15:01
It gets closer and closer --
360
901260
2000
15:03
40,000 years ago, we're still doing cave paintings.
361
903260
2000
15:05
It's like hurry, build your instruments.
362
905260
2000
15:07
It's getting closer and closer, and in 20 ...
363
907260
3000
15:10
whatever year it will be
364
910260
2000
15:12
when our detectors are finally at advanced sensitivity --
365
912260
2000
15:14
we'll build them, we'll turn on the machines
366
914260
2000
15:16
and, bang, we'll catch it -- the first song from space.
367
916260
3000
15:19
If it was the Big Bang we were going to pick up,
368
919260
2000
15:21
it would sound like this.
369
921260
2000
15:23
(Static) It's a terrible sound.
370
923260
3000
15:26
It's literally the definition of noise.
371
926260
2000
15:28
It's white noise; it's such a chaotic ringing.
372
928260
2000
15:30
But it's around us everywhere, presumably,
373
930260
3000
15:33
if it hasn't been wiped out
374
933260
2000
15:35
by some other process in the universe.
375
935260
2000
15:37
And if we pick it up, it will be music to our ears
376
937260
3000
15:40
because it will be the quiet echo
377
940260
2000
15:42
of that moment of our creation,
378
942260
2000
15:44
of our observable universe.
379
944260
2000
15:46
So within the next few years,
380
946260
2000
15:48
we'll be able to turn up the soundtrack a little bit,
381
948260
3000
15:51
render the universe in audio.
382
951260
3000
15:54
But if we detect those earliest moments,
383
954260
3000
15:57
it'll bring us that much closer
384
957260
2000
15:59
to an understanding of the Big Bang,
385
959260
2000
16:01
which brings us that much closer
386
961260
3000
16:04
to asking some of the hardest, most elusive, questions.
387
964260
3000
16:07
If we run the movie of our universe backwards,
388
967260
3000
16:10
we know that there was a Big Bang in our past,
389
970260
3000
16:13
and we might even hear the cacophonous sound of it,
390
973260
4000
16:17
but was our Big Bang the only Big Bang?
391
977260
2000
16:19
I mean we have to ask, has it happened before?
392
979260
3000
16:22
Will it happen again?
393
982260
2000
16:24
I mean, in the spirit of rising to TED's challenge
394
984260
3000
16:27
to reignite wonder,
395
987260
2000
16:29
we can ask questions, at least for this last minute,
396
989260
3000
16:32
that honestly might evade us forever.
397
992260
2000
16:34
But we have to ask:
398
994260
2000
16:36
Is it possible that our universe
399
996260
2000
16:38
is just a plume off of some greater history?
400
998260
3000
16:41
Or, is it possible that we're just a branch off of a multiverse --
401
1001260
4000
16:45
each branch with its own Big Bang in its past --
402
1005260
4000
16:49
maybe some of them with black holes playing drums,
403
1009260
2000
16:51
maybe some without --
404
1011260
2000
16:53
maybe some with sentient life, and maybe some without --
405
1013260
3000
16:56
not in our past, not in our future,
406
1016260
2000
16:58
but somehow fundamentally connected to us?
407
1018260
3000
17:01
So we have to wonder, if there is a multiverse,
408
1021260
2000
17:03
in some other patch of that multiverse,
409
1023260
2000
17:05
are there creatures?
410
1025260
2000
17:07
Here's my multiverse creatures.
411
1027260
2000
17:09
Are there other creatures in the multiverse,
412
1029260
2000
17:11
wondering about us
413
1031260
2000
17:13
and wondering about their own origins?
414
1033260
3000
17:16
And if they are,
415
1036260
2000
17:18
I can imagine them as we are,
416
1038260
3000
17:21
calculating, writing computer code,
417
1041260
2000
17:23
building instruments,
418
1043260
2000
17:25
trying to detect that faintest sound
419
1045260
3000
17:28
of their origins
420
1048260
2000
17:30
and wondering who else is out there.
421
1050260
2000
17:32
Thank you. Thank you.
422
1052260
3000
17:35
(Applause)
423
1055260
2000
About this website

This site will introduce you to YouTube videos that are useful for learning English. You will see English lessons taught by top-notch teachers from around the world. Double-click on the English subtitles displayed on each video page to play the video from there. The subtitles scroll in sync with the video playback. If you have any comments or requests, please contact us using this contact form.

https://forms.gle/WvT1wiN1qDtmnspy7