Larry Brilliant: The case for informed optimism

翻译人员: Tony Yet 校对人员: Wang Qian

I'm going to try to give you a view of the world as I see it,

我要跟大家分享一下我眼里的世界

the problems and the opportunities that we face,

我们所面临的问题以及现存的机遇

and then ask the question if we should be optimistic or pessimistic.

接着我会提出我们应当做乐观主义者还是悲观主义者这个问题

And then I'll let you in on a secret, which is why I am an incurable optimist.

而后我会告诉大家一个秘密，就是我为何会成为一个不可救药的乐观主义者

Let me start off showing you an Al Gore movie that you may have seen before.

我们还是从戈尔（美国前副总统）的影片开始，你们有些人看过了

Now, you've all seen "Inconvenient Truth." This is a little more inconvenient.

大家都看过《不可忽视的真相》，但是这一个剪辑片段也许让你感到更加不舒服

(Video): Man: ... extremely dangerous questions.

（视频）……这是极端危险的问题。

Because, with our present knowledge, we have no idea what would happen.

因为，按照我们现有的知识，我们根本就无从得知到底会发生什么

Even now, man may be unwittingly changing the world's climate

即便是今天，人类也许就已经在不经意中改变了地球的气候

through the waste products of his civilization.

这都来源于人类文明所创造的废物

Due to our release, through factories and automobiles every year,

每一年，工厂以及汽车尾气所排出的CO2

of more than six billion tons of carbon dioxide --

总数为60亿吨

which helps air absorb heat from the sun --

这就使得大气更多的吸收来自太阳的热量

our atmosphere seems to be getting warmer.

我们的大气层也因而正变得温暖起来

This is bad?

这是坏消息吗？

Well, it's been calculated a few degrees' rise in the earth's temperature would

据估算，即使是地表温度升高几度

melt the polar ice caps.

都足以使得两极的冰川融化

And if this happens, an inland sea would fill a good portion of the Mississippi Valley.

假如真的发生这样的情况，那么流入内陆的海水将淹没密西西比谷地的大部分地区

Tourists in glass-bottomed boats would be viewing the drowned towers of Miami

那时候，乘坐着玻璃底的游客也将可以看到迈阿密那里浸没的塔楼

through 150 feet of tropical water.

那时候，迈阿密河的河水深度将达150英尺

For, in weather, we're not only dealing with forces of a far greater variety

我们将遇到比以往任何时候都更多样的气候

than even the atomic physicist encounters, but with life itself.

此外就是看到更多不同的生物

Larry Brilliant: Should we feel good, or should we feel bad

看完这个，我们是应当感到高兴，还是应当感到悲伤？

that 50 years of foreknowledge accomplished so little?

我们50年前就已经预测到这样的结果，但我们却没做任何干预？

Well, it depends, really, on what your goals are.

这个嘛，要看你到底是要达到什么样的目的

And I think, as my goals, I always go back to Gandhi's talisman.

我认为，至少我自己会回到甘地的talisman那里

When Mahatma Gandhi was asked,

那时候，有人问

"How do you know if the next act that you are about to do is the right one

你如何判断你所做的下一步是正确的还是错误的？

or the wrong one?" he said, "Consider the face of the poorest,

甘地的回答是，“你要考虑那些最贫穷

most vulnerable human being that you ever chanced upon,

最无力的人

and ask yourself if the act that you contemplate will be of benefit to that person.

然后问自己，你所做的事情是否会让他们受益。

And if it will be, it's the right thing to do, and if not, rethink it."

假如是，那就是好事。假如不是，你就要重新思考了。

For those of us in this room, it's not just the poorest and the most vulnerable individual,

而对于我们这个房间里的人而言，我们要考虑的不单是最贫穷、最无力的人

it's the community, it's the culture, it's the world itself.

我们要考虑整一个社区、文化以及整个世界

And the trends for those who are at the periphery of our society,

以及那些生活在我们都市边缘的人们

who are the poorest and the most vulnerable,

他们往往是最贫穷、最无力的

the trends give rise to a great case for pessimism.

这一切，也许就会让我们感到无尽的悲观

But there's also a wonderful case for optimism.

但与此同时，我们也看到了一片美好的乐观图景

Let's review them both. First of all, the megatrends.

我们分别谈谈这两方面。首先，从大趋势来看，

There's two degrees, or three degrees of climate change baked into the system.

现在有2到3摄氏度的升温是必然的

It will cause rising seas. It will cause saline deposited into wells and into lands.

这将会导致海平面上升，海水倒灌

It will disproportionately harm the poorest and the most vulnerable,

使得穷人以及无力者受到最大的伤害

as will the increasing rise of population.

还有就是人口数量依然会增长

Even though we've dodged Paul Ehrlich's population bomb,

虽然我们有幸逃过了Paul Ehrlich所预言的“人口爆炸”的危机

and we will not see 20 billion people in this decade, as he had forecast,

至少在这个十年里，地球上不会出现200亿人

we eat as if we were 20 billion.

但我们所消耗的食物数量与200亿人相当

And we consume so much that again, a rise of 6.5 billion to 9.5 billion

我们所消费的东西是如此之多，因此，到了我们的孙辈那一代，

in our grandchildren's lifetime will disproportionately hurt

人口将上升到65到95亿，

the poorest and the most vulnerable.

那将使得最穷的人以及最无力的人成为最大的输家

That's why they migrate to cities.

这就是他们迁往城市的原因

That's why in June of this year, we passed, as a species, 51 percent of us living in cities,

今年6月，有51%的人居住在城市和贫民窟里，

and bustees, and slums, and shantytowns.

这是人类这一物种的第一次

The rural areas are no longer producing as much food as they did.

农村地区不再如往常那样出产大量的粮食

The green revolution never reached Africa.

绿色革命未曾惠及非洲

And with desertification, sandstorms, the Gobi Desert, the Ogaden,

还有就是沙漠化、沙尘暴、戈壁滩、Ogaden

we are finding increasing difficulty of a hectare

我们现在很难找到一小块可以耕作，并且

to produce as many calories as it did even 15 years ago.

可以产生出跟15年前一样多粮食的土地

So humans are turning more towards animal consumption.

另外，人类也越来越喜欢吃肉

In Africa last year, Africans ate 600 million wild animals,

单是去年一年，非洲人就吃掉了6亿头野生动物

and consumed two billion kilograms of bush meat.

还吃掉了20亿公斤的丛林肉

And every kilogram of bush meat contained hundreds of thousands of novel viruses

每一公斤的丛林肉都包含数以万计的新型病菌

that have never been charted, the genomic sequences of which we don't know.

它们以前从未被监测到过，我们也还不知道它们的基因组图

Their fitness for creating pandemics we are unaware of,

也许它们可以成为新型流行病的温床

but we are ripe for zoonotic-borne, emerging communicable diseases.

我们即将要面对的，就是诞生于热带地区、易于传播的各种新型疾病

Increasingly, I would say explosive growth of technology.

还有，随着技术的爆炸式增长

Most of us are the beneficiaries of that growth. But it has a dark side

我们这里大多数人都是这一增长的受益者。但是，这样的增长也是存在黑暗点的

-- in bioweapons, and in technology that puts us on a collision course

生物武器以及其他足以助长人们之间的

to magnify any anger, hatred or feeling of marginalization.

仇恨、怨怒以及使得部分人被边缘化的形式

And in fact, with increasing globalization --

随着全球化进程之加速，

for which there are big winners and even bigger losers

这一进程将伴随着巨大的赢家以及更多的输家

-- today the world is more diverse and unfair than perhaps it has ever been in history.

今日之世界比以往任何时候都更加多元也更加不公平

One percent of us own 40 percent of all the goods and services.

1%的人口占有了40%的资源以及服务

What will happen if the billion people today who live on less than one dollar a day

假如在未来30年内，那些生活在贫困线底下的人口数量

rise to three billion in the next 30 years?

从10亿上升到30亿，会发生些什么？

The one percent will own even more than 40 percent of all the world's goods

那么1%的人将占有多于40%的资源及服务

and services. Not because they've grown richer,

事实上不是他们变得更富裕了

but because the rest of the world has grown increasingly poorer.

而是因为世界别的地区的人正变得越来越贫穷

Last week, Bill Clinton at the TED Awards said,

上周，克林顿在TED大奖获奖感言里说

"This situation is unprecedented, unequal, unfair and unstable."

“这样一种情况是前所未有的、不公平的、不公正的，也不稳定的。”

So there's lots of reason for pessimism.

因此，持悲观主义的心态似乎是有充分的理由

Darfur is, at its origin, a resource war.

达尔富尔危机从本质上说就是一场资源争夺战

Last year, there were 85,000 riots in China,

去年一年，中国发生了85000起的骚乱

230 a day, that required police or military intervention.

平均每天230起是需要武力进行干涉的

Most of them were about resources.

其中大部分都是为了争夺资源

We are facing an unprecedented number, scale of disasters.

我们正面对前所未有的危机

Some are weather-related, human-rights related, epidemics.

有些是关乎天气的，有些是关乎人的

And the newly emerging diseases may make H5N1 and bird flu

而那些新兴的疾病将会使得H5N1以及禽流感相形见绌

a quaint forerunner of things to come. It's a destabilized world.

它们不过是更大型病毒之前奏而已。这确实是一个不安宁的世界。

And unlike destabilized world in the past, it will be broadcast to you on YouTube,

与过往的那些不安宁事件不一样的是，如今这个世界所发生的一切都将通过YouTube直播到你的桌面

you will see it on digital television and on your cell phones.

你将会在数字电视以及手机上看到实况转播

What will that lead to?

这将带来什么后果？

For some, it will lead to anger, religious and sectarian violence and terrorism.

对有些人而言，将意味着愤怒，宗教或非宗教的暴力以及恐怖主义

For others, withdrawal, nihilism, materialism.

对于其他人而言，将意味着退却、虚无以及拜物主义

For us, where does it take us, as social activists and entrepreneurs?

但对于我们这些社会活动家以及企业家而言，这将意味着什么？

As we look at these trends, do we become despondent, or will we become energized?

看到这样的趋势，我们是变得沮丧，还是变得倍受鼓舞？

Let's look at one case, the case of Bangladesh.

我们来看看孟加拉的例子吧。

First, even if carbon dioxide emissions stopped today,

首先，即使人类的CO2排放于今天停止，

global warming would continue.

全球变暖的趋势依然会继续

And even with global warming -- if you can see these blue lines,

大家可以看到那些蓝色的线条

the dotted line shows that even if emissions of greenhouse gasses stopped today,

假使温室气体的排放今天就完全中止

the next decades will see rising sea levels.

我们在下一个十年将依然会看到海平面的上升

A minimum of 20 to 30 inches of increase in sea levels is the best case

最保守的估计是有20到30英寸的上升

that we can hope for, and it could be 10 times that.

但事实可能是那个的10倍

What will that do to Bangladesh? Let's take a look.

这会给孟加拉带来什么变化?

So here's Bangladesh.

我们不妨看看，这里就是孟加拉，

70 percent of Bangladesh is at less than five feet above sea level.

该国70%的国土海拔仅仅为五英尺

Let's go up and take a look at the Himalayas.

我们来看看喜马拉雅山

And we'll watch as global warming makes them melt. More water comes down,

我们看看喜马拉雅山因气候变暖而出现冰川融化的情景。雨水越来越多

the deforested areas, here in the Tarai, will be unable to absorb the effluent,

积聚在森林消失的地方。在Tarai一地，那里的土地将不能吸收雨水

because trees are like straws that suck up the extra seasonal water.

因为树木可以像秸秆那样吸收多余的雨水并且贮存起来的

Now we're looking down south, through the Kali Gandaki.

好，我们再透过 Kali Gandaki 看看南部的地区

Many of you, I think, have probably trekked here.

我想你们当中很多人应当是徒步去到过那里

And we're going to cruise down and take a look at Bangladesh

我们就一直往南走，直到孟加拉

and see what the impact will be of twin increases in water

我们看看这里会发生什么：北部的冰川融水会不断的增多

coming from the north, and in the seas rising from the south.

同时，南部的海水也在不断的上涨

Looking at the five major rivers that feed Bangladesh.

再看看途径孟加拉的五大河流

And now let's look from the south, looking up, and let's see this in relief.

再从南往北看，看看这个三维的图像

A minimum of 20 to 40 inches of increase in seas,

我们将发现，这里的海面会有20到40英寸的上升

coupled with increasing flows from the Himalayas. And take a look at this.

还有来自喜马拉雅的融水。再看看这里

As many as 100 million refugees from Bangladesh could be expected to migrate

将会有一亿的难民从孟加拉

into India and into China.

逃难到印度和中国

This is the difficulty that one country faces.

这就是其中一个国家即将面临的难题

But if you look at the globe, all around the earth, wherever there is low-lying area,

假如你放眼全球，看看那些低洼地带

populated areas near the water,

看看那些河岸线上的人口密集的地区

you will find increase in sea level that will challenge our way of life.

你会看到，海平面之上涨会改变我们的生活

Sub-Saharan Africa, and even our own San Francisco Bay Area.

不管是在撒哈拉以南的沙漠还是在我们这里的旧金山湾区

We're all in this together.

我们可谓同济共舟

This is not something that happens far away to people that we don't know.

这不是只会影响到一些边远地区的人的事件

Global warming is something that happens to all of us, all at once.

它是会在我们每一个人身上发生的事情

As are these newly emerging communicable diseases,

同样会发生的就是这些传染病

names that you hadn't heard 20 years ago: ebola, lhasa fever, monkey pox.

这些名字你20年前还不会听说过：伊博拉、拉萨热、猴痘

With the erosion of the green belt separating animals from humans,

还有，随着人与动物之间的那段绿色保护带在逐渐消失

we live in each other's viral environment.

我们就生活在每一个人的病毒环境里

Do you remember, 20 years ago, no one had ever heard of West Nile fever?

你能想象吗，20年前，还没有人会听说过西尼罗河热呢！

And then we watched, as one case arrived on the East Coast of the United States

接着，我们就看到第一例感染个案出现在美国东海岸

and it marched every year, westwardly.

其后每一年都逐渐西移

Do you remember no one had heard of ebola

你知道吗？在我们听说中非有数百人因为感染这一病毒而死亡之前

until we heard of hundreds of people dying in Central Africa from it?

没有人听说过这个病毒！

It's just the beginning, unfortunately.

不幸的是，这一切都仅仅是开始

There have been 30 novel emerging communicable diseases

过去30年，出现了30种新型传染病毒

that begin in animals that have jumped species in the last 30 years.

都是最先出现在动物身上，而后传到人体的

It's more than enough reason for pessimism.

看来使人悲观的事情还非常多

But now let's look at the case for optimism. (Laughter)

但我们还是来看一下乐观的理由吧

Enough of the bad news. Human beings have always risen to the challenge.

坏消息？够多了。人类总会勇于面对挑战

You just need to look at the list of Nobel laureates to remind ourselves.

看看诺贝尔奖获得者的名单就可以理解这点

We've been here before, paralyzed by fear, paralyzed into inaction,

我们过去不也曾遇到同类困境吗？我们被恐惧吓坏了，不行动

when some -- probably one of you in this room -- jumped into the breach

但有些人——也许就是你们其中一些人——则不顾这么多

and created an organization like Physicians for Social Responsibility,

就创立了一个像“物理学家社会责任协会”这样的组织

which fought against the nuclear threat,

你们站起来对抗核子威胁

Medicins Sans Frontieres, that renewed our commitment to disaster relief,

还有医生无国界，它继承了我们紧急救援的传统

Mohamed ElBaradei, and the tremendous hope and optimism that he

还有国际原子能机构总干事巴拉迪，他的希望与乐观

brought all of us, and our own Muhammad Yunus.

还有尤奴斯

We've seen the eradication of smallpox.

我们亲眼看到了天花之消失

We may see the eradication of polio this year.

我们也许今年就会看到小儿麻痹症被消灭

Last year, there were only 2,000 cases in the world.

去年，全世界就只有2000例

We may see the eradication of guinea worm next year --

明年，也许我们就能看到几内亚虫被消灭

there are only 35,000 cases left in the world.

现在世界上只剩下35000个感染个案了

20 years ago, there were three and a half million.

20年前，有350万的人感染这一病毒

And we've seen a new disease, not like the 30 novel emerging communicable diseases.

我们也认识了一些新的传染病，它跟过去30年出现的流行传染病不大一样

This disease is called sudden wealth syndrome. (Laughter)

它的名字叫“暴富综合症”（笑）

It's an amazing phenomenon.

这是一个相当有趣的现象

All throughout the technology world, we're seeing young people bitten by this

环顾科技界，我们看到了许多的年轻人

disease of sudden wealth syndrome.

正是被这一综合症所感染

But they're using their wealth in a way that their forefathers never did.

但他们花费金钱的方式是其父辈从未想到的

They're not waiting until they die to create foundations.

他们不会等到临死才去创立基金会

They're actively guiding their money, their resources, their hearts, their commitments,

他们正在将自己的金钱、资源、心血以及热忱

to make the world a better place.

贡献出来，为的是让世界变得更好

Certainly, nothing can give you more optimism than that.

可以说，没有别的东西可以给你更大的乐观情绪了

More reasons to be optimistic:

还有更多使你乐观的理由

in the '60s, and I am a creature of the '60s, there was a movement.

60年代的时候发生过一场运动，我就是那时候长大的

We all felt that we were part of it, that a better world was right around the corner,

我们都认为自己是其中的一部分，我们认为一个更加美好的世界就在前面

that we were watching the birth of a world free of hatred and violence and prejudice.

我们创造的是一个没有仇恨、暴力以及偏见的世界

Today, there's another kind of movement. It's a movement to save the earth.

今天，我们看到了另外一场运动。这场运动的目的在于拯救地球

It's just beginning.

如今才刚开始

Five weeks ago, a group of activists from the business community gathered together

五个星期之前，来自商业界的一班活跃人士聚集到一起

to stop a Texas utility from building nine coal-fired electrical plants

阻止德州电力局修建9座煤炭电力电厂

that would have contributed to destroying the environment.

因为那种电力生产模式会破坏环境

Six months ago, a group of business activists gathered together to join with the

6个月前，又是一班商业界的活跃人士

Republican governor in California to pass AB 32,

支持加州州长通过了AB 32法案

the most far-reaching legislation in environmental history.

这是环境运动史上最具深远意义的法案

Al Gore made presentations in the House and the Senate as an expert witness.

戈尔以专家身份在参众两院作证

Can you imagine? (Laughter)

你能想象这一切吗？（笑）

We're seeing an entente cordiale between science and religion that five years ago

我们看到了科学与宗教走向联合

I would not have believed, as the evangelical community

因为他们都看到了气候变暖之严峻

has understood the desperate situation of global warming.

这在几年前又是不可思议的

And now 4,000 churches have joined the environmental movement.

现在有4000座教堂加入了环保运动的行列

It is something to be greatly optimistic about.

这又是值得乐观的

The European 20-20-20 plan is an amazing breakthrough,

欧盟的20-20-20计划又是一个伟大的突破

something that should make all of us feel that hope is on the horizon.

它让我们看到了地平线上希望的曙光

And on April 14th, there will be Step Up Day, where there will be a thousand

4月14日，将会是行动日

individual mobilized social activist movements in the United States on protest

美国将有数千活跃人士自发的发起

against legislation -- pushing for legislation to stop global warming.

游行，声援关于阻止气候变暖的立法

And on July 7th, around the world, I learned only yesterday,

我昨天得知，7月7日，在世界各地

there will be global Live Earth concerts.

将会有一场Live Earth音乐会

And you can feel this optimistic move to save the earth in the air.

你甚至可以感受到空气中的这股拯救地球气氛

Now, that doesn't mean that people understand that global warming

但所有这一切并不意味着他们都理解一点

hurts the poorest and the weakest the most.

即气候变暖的最大受害者是穷人以及弱势群体

That means that people are beginning the first step,

这一切仅仅表明人们正在迈出第一步

which is acting out of their own self-interest.

也就是为了维护自身的利益而奋起抗争

But I am seeing in the major funders, in CARE, Rockefeller,

但我同时也看到了一些大的基金会，如CARE, 洛克菲勒基金会

Rockefeller Brothers Fund, Hewlett, Mercy Corps, you guys, Google,

洛克菲勒兄弟基金会、Hewlett, Mercy Corps, 以及Google基金会

so many other organizations, a beginning of understanding that we need

都开始认识到一点

to work not just on primary prevention of global warming,

即我们不能单单为了防止气候变暖而抗争

but on the secondary prevention of the consequences of global warming

而且要为气候变暖带来的后果作准备

on the poorest and the most vulnerable.

特别是因为这样的后果对于穷人以及弱势群体影响是最大的

But for me, I have another reason to be an incurable optimist.

但对于我自己而言，我还有别的让我感到乐观的理由

And you've heard so many inspiring stories here, and I heard so many last night

你们在这里听说了很多有趣的故事，我昨晚就听到很多个

that I thought I would share a little bit of mine.

这里我想分享一下我自己 的故事

My background is not exactly conventional medical training.

我不是学医出身的

And I lived in a Himalayan monastery, and I studied with a very wise teacher,

我曾住在喜马拉雅山的寺庙里，从师与一位非常智慧的人

who kicked me out of the monastery one day and told me that it was my destiny --

有一天，他把我带到寺庙外，告诉我，

it felt like Yoda -- it is your destiny to go to work for WHO

我的使命就是为世卫工作

and to help eradicate smallpox,

帮助他们消灭天花

at a time when there was no smallpox program.

那时候还没有此类项目

It should make you optimistic that smallpox no longer exists

今天，我们确实达到了这一目的，这让我充满乐观的信心

because it was the worst disease in history.

因为天花曾经是最恶毒的一种疾病之一

In the last century -- that's the one that was seven years ago --

就在上个世纪--也就是7年前

half a billion people died from smallpox:

有5亿人因为感染天花而死

more than all the wars in history,

这一数字比历史上所有因为战争死亡的人数还要多

more than any other infectious disease in the history of the world.

也比任何其他感染性疾病带来的死亡个案更高

In the Summer of Love, in 1967, two million people, children, died of smallpox.

1967年夏季，有两百万人因为感染天花而死

It's not ancient history.

天花由来已久

When you read the biblical plague of boils, that was smallpox.

你阅读《圣经》的时候，你读到灼伤的章节，就应当知道那是在讲天花感染

Pharaoh Ramses the Fifth, whose picture is here, died of smallpox.

Ramses法老就是因为感染天花而死的

To eradicate smallpox, we had to gather the largest United Nations army in history.

为了消灭天花，我们召集了联合国史上最大的一支部队

We visited every house in India, searching for smallpox -- 120 million houses,

我们在印度逐家逐户去敲门，询问是否有人感染天花，一共有1.2亿户人家

once every month, for nearly two years.

每个月一次，连续进行了两年

In a cruel reversal, after we had almost conquered smallpox --

在我们马上要消灭天花的一个关键时刻

and this is what you must learn as a social entrepreneur, the realm of the final inch.

这也是你作为一个社会企业家应当学习的，就是到了最后的那一个拐点上该怎么做

When we had almost eradicated smallpox, it came back again,

当我们马上就要消灭天花的时候，它又重新猖獗起来

because the company town of Tatanagar drew laborers,

原因在于 Tatanagar 镇吸引了大批的劳工

who could come there and get employment.

他们来到那里寻找工作

And they caught smallpox in the one remaining place that had smallpox,

不幸的是，他们在一个未曾消灭天花的地方感染了这个病

and they went home to die.

而后回到家里等待死亡

And when they did, they took smallpox to 10 other countries

一路上把病毒带到了其他十个国家

and reignited the epidemic.

使得病毒死灰复燃

And we had to start all over again.

我们不得不重新开始

But, in the end, we succeeded, and the last case of smallpox:

但我们最后还是胜利了，最后的一例天花:

this little girl, Rahima Banu -- Barisal, in Bangladesh --

就是这个女孩，她叫Rahima Banu 她住在孟加拉的巴里萨尔市

when she coughed or breathed, and the last virus of smallpox left her lungs

当她通过咳嗽将最后一个天花病毒吐出口中

and fell on the dirt and the sun killed that last virus,

病毒落到地面，被太阳晒死

thus ended a chain of transmission of history's greatest horror.

这意味着历史上最可怕的病毒感染宣告终结

How can that not make you optimistic?

听到这样的故事，你难道会不感到乐观吗？

A disease which killed hundreds of thousands in India, and blinded half of

这个病毒单在印度就夺去了成千上万人的生命，

all of those who were made blind in India, ended.

还有那个使得许许多多人失明的病毒也消失了

And most importantly for us here in this room, a bond was created.

对于我们而言，最重要的是我们建立了一种联系

Doctors, health workers, from 30 different countries,

来自30多个国家、不同种族、不同宗教信仰、不同肤色、

of every race, every religion, every color, worked together,

的医生、医疗工作者并肩工作

fought alongside each other,

合力对抗病菌

fought against a common enemy, didn't fight against each other.

万万没应对共同的敌人，我们不是内斗

How can that not make you feel optimistic for the future?

这样的事情难道不会让你对未来充满信心吗？

Thank you very much.

感谢大家。

(Applause)

（鼓掌）