Dave deBronkart: Meet e-Patient Dave

55,322 views ・ 2011-07-01

TED


Please double-click on the English subtitles below to play the video.

00:16
It's an amazing thing
0
16315
1151
00:17
that we're here to talk about the year of patients rising.
1
17490
3982
00:22
You heard stories earlier today
2
22266
1720
00:24
about patients who are taking control of their cases,
3
24010
3028
00:27
patients who are saying,
4
27062
1155
00:28
"You know what, I know what the odds are,
5
28241
1974
00:30
but I'm going to look for more information.
6
30239
2150
00:32
I'm going to define what the terms of my success are."
7
32413
3760
00:36
I'm going to be sharing with you how, four years ago, I almost died --
8
36197
3789
00:40
found out I was, in fact, already almost dead --
9
40010
2883
00:42
and what I then found out
10
42917
2238
00:45
about what's called the e-Patient movement.
11
45179
2202
00:47
I'll explain what that term means.
12
47405
1649
00:49
I had been blogging under the name "Patient Dave,"
13
49078
2768
00:51
and when I discovered this,
14
51870
1374
00:53
I just renamed myself e-Patient Dave.
15
53268
2298
00:55
Regarding the word "patient":
16
55939
1703
00:57
When I first started a few years ago getting involved in health care
17
57666
3936
01:01
and attending meetings as just a casual observer,
18
61626
2360
01:04
I noticed that people would talk about patients
19
64010
2239
01:06
as if it was somebody who's not in the room here --
20
66273
2575
01:08
somebody out there.
21
68872
1394
01:10
Some of our talks today, we still act like that.
22
70290
2513
01:12
But I'm here to tell you:
23
72827
1912
01:14
"patient" is not a third-person word.
24
74763
2722
01:18
All right?
25
78145
1163
01:19
You yourself will find yourself in a hospital bed --
26
79332
3220
01:22
or your mother, your child --
27
82576
1655
01:24
there are heads nodding, people who say,
28
84255
1918
01:26
"Yes, I know exactly what you mean."
29
86197
1741
01:27
So when you hear what I'm going to talk about here today,
30
87962
3024
01:31
first of all, I want to say that I am here
31
91010
3030
01:34
on behalf of all the patients that I have ever met,
32
94064
2580
01:36
all the ones I haven't met.
33
96668
1703
01:38
This is about letting patients play a more active role
34
98395
3773
01:42
in helping health care, in fixing health care.
35
102192
2977
01:45
One of the senior doctors at my hospital,
36
105193
1999
01:47
Charlie Safran, and his colleague, Warner Slack,
37
107216
2574
01:49
have been saying for decades
38
109814
1518
01:51
that the most underutilized resource in all of health care
39
111356
3760
01:55
is the patient.
40
115140
1175
01:56
They have been saying that since the 1970s.
41
116859
2666
01:59
Now, I'm going to step back in history.
42
119549
1956
02:01
This is from July, 1969.
43
121529
1886
02:03
I was a freshman in college,
44
123439
1662
02:05
and this was when we first landed on the Moon.
45
125125
2603
02:08
And it was the first time
46
128113
1431
02:09
we had ever seen from another surface --
47
129568
2763
02:12
that's the place where you and I are right now,
48
132355
2244
02:14
where we live.
49
134623
1158
02:15
The world was changing.
50
135805
1547
02:17
It was about to change in ways that nobody could foresee.
51
137376
2977
02:20
A few weeks later, Woodstock happened.
52
140377
3658
02:24
Three days of fun and music.
53
144645
2080
02:26
Here, just for historical authenticity,
54
146749
2100
02:28
is a picture of me in that year.
55
148873
1799
02:30
(Laughter)
56
150696
3226
02:33
Yeah, the wavy hair, the blue eyes --
57
153946
1977
02:35
it was really something.
58
155947
1213
02:37
That fall of 1969,
59
157610
1977
02:39
the Whole Earth Catalog came out.
60
159611
1887
02:41
It was a hippie journal of self-sufficiency.
61
161522
3464
02:45
We think of hippies of being just hedonists,
62
165010
3031
02:48
but there's a very strong component -- I was in that movement --
63
168065
3201
02:51
a very strong component of being responsible for yourself.
64
171290
3344
02:54
This book's title's subtitle is "Access to Tools."
65
174658
3897
02:58
It talked about how to build your own house,
66
178579
2296
03:00
how to grow your own food, all kinds of things.
67
180899
2405
03:03
In the 1980s,
68
183328
1404
03:04
this young doctor, Tom Ferguson,
69
184756
2134
03:06
was the medical editor of the Whole Earth Catalog.
70
186914
2627
03:09
He saw that the great majority of what we do in medicine and health care
71
189565
4771
03:14
is taking care of ourselves.
72
194360
1475
03:16
In fact, he said it was 70 to 80 percent
73
196271
2351
03:18
of how we actually take care of our bodies.
74
198646
2269
03:20
Well, he also saw that when health care turns to medical care
75
200939
4678
03:25
because of a more serious disease,
76
205641
1910
03:27
the key thing that holds us back is access to information.
77
207575
3324
03:30
And when the Web came along, that changed everything,
78
210923
3266
03:34
because not only could we find information,
79
214213
2593
03:36
we could find other people like ourselves
80
216830
2716
03:39
who could gather, who could bring us information.
81
219570
2591
03:42
And he coined this term "e-Patients" --
82
222185
2515
03:44
equipped, engaged, empowered, enabled.
83
224724
2331
03:47
Obviously, at this stage of life
84
227079
1701
03:48
he was in a somewhat more dignified form than he was back then.
85
228804
3967
03:52
Now, I was an engaged patient long before I ever heard of the term.
86
232795
3954
03:56
In 2006, I went to my doctor for a regular physical,
87
236773
2976
03:59
and I had said, "I have a sore shoulder."
88
239773
2299
04:02
Well, I got an X-ray,
89
242096
1573
04:03
and the next morning --
90
243693
1648
04:05
you may have noticed, those of you who have been through a medical crisis
91
245365
3525
04:08
will understand this.
92
248914
1200
04:10
This morning, some of the speakers named the date when they found out
93
250138
4462
04:14
about their condition.
94
254624
1271
04:15
For me, it was 9am
95
255919
2413
04:18
on January 3, 2007.
96
258356
2704
04:21
I was at the office; my desk was clean.
97
261084
2495
04:23
I had the blue partition carpet on the walls.
98
263603
3307
04:27
The phone rang and it was my doctor.
99
267347
2050
04:30
He said, "Dave, I pulled up the X-ray image
100
270167
2819
04:33
on the screen on the computer at home."
101
273010
2090
04:35
He said, "Your shoulder is going to be fine,
102
275124
2067
04:37
but Dave, there's something in your lung."
103
277215
2085
04:39
And if you look in that red oval,
104
279324
1908
04:41
that shadow was not supposed to be there.
105
281256
2803
04:45
To make a long story short,
106
285010
1976
04:47
I said, "So you need me to get back in there?"
107
287010
2155
04:49
He said, "Yeah, we're going to need to do a CT scan of your chest."
108
289189
3251
04:52
In parting, I said, "Is there anything I should do?"
109
292464
2641
04:55
He said -- think about this one,
110
295129
1857
04:57
this is the advice your doctor gives you:
111
297010
1976
04:59
"Just go home and have a glass of wine with your wife."
112
299010
3000
05:04
I went in for the CAT scan.
113
304283
1826
05:07
It turns out there were five of these things in both my lungs.
114
307478
3227
05:10
So at that point we knew that it was cancer.
115
310729
2162
05:12
We knew it wasn't lung cancer.
116
312915
1604
05:14
That meant it was metastasized from somewhere.
117
314978
2517
05:18
The question was, where from?
118
318388
1663
05:20
So I went in for an ultrasound.
119
320494
2626
05:23
I got to do what many women have --
120
323144
2493
05:25
the jelly on the belly and the, "Bzzzz!"
121
325661
2855
05:29
My wife came with me.
122
329010
1638
05:31
She's a veterinarian,
123
331195
1605
05:32
so she's seen lots of ultrasounds.
124
332824
1797
05:34
I mean, she knows I'm not a dog.
125
334645
1584
05:36
(Laughter)
126
336253
1644
05:37
This is an MRI image.
127
337921
2977
05:40
This is much sharper than an ultrasound would be.
128
340922
2422
05:43
What we saw in that kidney
129
343368
1901
05:46
was that big blob there.
130
346142
1511
05:47
There were actually two of these: one was growing out the front
131
347677
3040
05:50
and had already erupted and latched onto the bowel.
132
350741
2423
05:53
One was growing out the back and it attached to the psoas muscle,
133
353188
3219
05:56
which is a big muscle in the back that I'd never heard of,
134
356431
2785
05:59
but all of a sudden I cared about it.
135
359240
1833
06:01
(Laughter)
136
361097
999
06:02
I went home.
137
362120
1163
06:03
Now, I've been Googling --
138
363307
1274
06:04
I've been online since 1989, on CompuServe.
139
364605
2390
06:07
I went home, and I know you can't read the details here;
140
367019
2630
06:09
that's not important.
141
369673
1166
06:10
My point is, I went to a respected medical website, WebMD,
142
370863
4204
06:15
because I know how to filter out junk.
143
375091
2258
06:17
I also found my wife online.
144
377373
1976
06:19
Before I met her,
145
379898
1682
06:21
I went through some suboptimal search results.
146
381604
2476
06:24
(Laughter)
147
384104
1548
06:25
So I looked for quality information.
148
385676
3154
06:28
There's so much about trust --
149
388854
1732
06:30
what sources of information can we trust?
150
390610
2503
06:33
Where does my body end and an invader start?
151
393137
4764
06:37
A cancer, a tumor, is something you grow out of your own tissue.
152
397925
3138
06:41
How does that happen?
153
401087
1565
06:42
Where does medical ability end and start?
154
402676
4019
06:46
Well, so what I read on WebMD:
155
406719
1885
06:49
"The prognosis is poor for progressing renal cell cancer.
156
409175
4986
06:54
Almost all patients are incurable."
157
414185
2214
06:57
I've been online long enough to know if I don't like the first results I get,
158
417567
3715
07:01
I go look for more.
159
421306
1153
07:02
And what I found on other websites was,
160
422483
2662
07:05
even by the third page of Google results:
161
425169
2364
07:07
"Outlook is bleak."
162
427557
1434
07:09
"Prognosis is grim."
163
429612
1976
07:12
And I'm thinking, "What the heck?"
164
432199
2096
07:14
I didn't feel sick at all.
165
434319
1732
07:16
I mean, I'd been getting tired in the evening,
166
436075
2190
07:18
but I was 56 years old, you know?
167
438289
2016
07:20
I was slowly losing weight,
168
440329
1657
07:22
but for me, that was what the doctor told me to do.
169
442010
3890
07:26
It was really something.
170
446258
1672
07:27
And this is the diagram of stage 4 kidney cancer
171
447954
3180
07:31
from the drug I eventually got.
172
451158
1757
07:32
Totally by coincidence, there's that thing in my lung.
173
452939
2566
07:36
In the left femur, the left thigh bone, there's another one.
174
456009
2977
07:39
I had one. My leg eventually snapped.
175
459010
2365
07:41
I fainted and landed on it, and it broke.
176
461399
2922
07:44
There's one in the skull,
177
464345
1248
07:45
and then for good measure, I had these other tumors,
178
465617
2463
07:48
including, by the time my treatment started,
179
468104
2071
07:50
one was growing out of my tongue.
180
470199
1589
07:51
I had kidney cancer growing out of my tongue.
181
471812
2144
07:53
And what I read
182
473980
1159
07:55
was that my median survival was 24 weeks.
183
475163
2388
07:58
This was bad.
184
478424
1455
07:59
I was facing the grave.
185
479903
1796
08:02
I thought, "What's my mother's face going to look like
186
482303
2574
08:04
on the day of my funeral?"
187
484901
1310
08:06
I had to sit down with my daughter and say, "Here's the situation."
188
486605
5485
08:12
Her boyfriend was with her.
189
492114
1414
08:13
I said, "I don't want you guys to get married prematurely,
190
493552
2801
08:16
just so you can do it while Dad's still alive."
191
496377
2782
08:20
It's really serious.
192
500339
1569
08:21
If you wonder why patients are motivated and want to help,
193
501932
3580
08:25
think about this.
194
505536
1158
08:26
Well, my doctor prescribed a patient community, ACOR.org,
195
506718
4030
08:30
a network of cancer patients, of all amazing things.
196
510772
3214
08:34
Very quickly they told me,
197
514010
1976
08:36
"Kidney cancer is an uncommon disease.
198
516010
1976
08:38
Get yourself to a specialist center.
199
518010
1977
08:40
There is no cure, but there's something that sometimes works --
200
520011
2999
08:43
it usually doesn't --
201
523034
1556
08:44
called high-dosage interleukin.
202
524614
1814
08:46
Most hospitals don't offer it,
203
526452
2008
08:48
so they won't even tell you it exists.
204
528484
2175
08:50
Don't let them give you anything else first.
205
530683
2119
08:52
And by the way, here are four doctors in your part of the United States
206
532826
3373
08:56
who offer it, and their phone numbers."
207
536223
1951
08:58
How amazing is that?
208
538198
2438
09:00
(Applause)
209
540660
2814
09:03
Here's the thing:
210
543498
1196
09:04
Here we are, four years later --
211
544718
1588
09:06
you can't find a website that gives patients that information.
212
546330
3576
09:09
Government-approved, American Cancer Society,
213
549930
2533
09:12
but patients know what patients want to know.
214
552487
2976
09:16
It's the power of patient networks.
215
556094
2771
09:18
This amazing substance -- again, I mentioned:
216
558889
3229
09:22
Where does my body end?
217
562142
1354
09:23
My oncologist and I talk a lot these days
218
563520
2394
09:25
because I try to keep my talks technically accurate.
219
565938
2501
09:28
And he said, "You know, the immune system is good at detecting invaders,
220
568463
4328
09:33
bacteria coming from outside,
221
573537
2317
09:35
but when it's your own tissue that you've grown,
222
575878
2474
09:38
it's a whole different thing."
223
578376
1519
09:39
And I went through a mental exercise, actually,
224
579919
2956
09:42
because I started a patient support community of my own on a website,
225
582899
4818
09:47
and one of my friends -- one of my relatives, actually -- said,
226
587741
3034
09:50
"Look, Dave, who grew this thing?
227
590799
1750
09:54
Are you going to set yourself up as mentally attacking yourself?"
228
594154
4023
09:58
So we went into it.
229
598201
1604
09:59
The story of how all that happened is in the book.
230
599829
2717
10:02
Anyway, this is the way the numbers unfolded.
231
602570
2424
10:05
Me being me, I put the numbers from my hospital's website,
232
605018
3131
10:08
for my tumor sizes,
233
608173
1159
10:09
into a spreadsheet.
234
609356
1151
10:10
Don't worry about the numbers.
235
610531
1455
10:12
You see, that's the immune system.
236
612010
1752
10:13
Amazing thing, those two yellow lines
237
613786
1977
10:15
are where I got the two doses of interleukin two months apart.
238
615787
4199
10:20
And look at how the tumor sizes plummeted in between.
239
620010
3130
10:23
Just incredible.
240
623164
1459
10:24
Who knows what we'll be able to do when we learn to make more use of it?
241
624647
3430
10:28
The punch line is that a year and a half later,
242
628101
2316
10:30
I was there when this magnificent young woman, my daughter,
243
630441
4300
10:34
got married.
244
634765
1163
10:35
And when she came down those steps,
245
635952
1811
10:38
and it was just her and me for that moment,
246
638351
2230
10:40
I was so glad that she didn't have to say to her mother,
247
640605
3222
10:43
"I wish Dad could have been here."
248
643851
2056
10:45
And this is what we're doing when we make health care better.
249
645931
3880
10:49
Now, I want to talk briefly about a couple of other patients
250
649835
2903
10:52
who are doing everything in their power to improve health care.
251
652762
3009
10:55
This is Regina Holliday,
252
655795
1639
10:57
a painter in Washington DC, whose husband died of kidney cancer
253
657458
4199
11:01
a year after my disease.
254
661681
1500
11:03
She's painting, here, a mural
255
663205
1781
11:05
of his horrible final weeks in the hospital.
256
665010
2976
11:08
One of the things that she discovered
257
668010
2447
11:10
was that her husband's medical record in this paper folder
258
670481
4284
11:14
was just disorganized.
259
674789
1526
11:16
And she thought, "You know, if I have a nutrition facts label
260
676339
3265
11:19
on the side of a cereal box,
261
679628
1723
11:21
why can't there be something that simple
262
681375
1955
11:23
telling every new nurse who comes on duty,
263
683354
2544
11:25
every new doctor,
264
685922
1225
11:27
the basics about my husband's condition?"
265
687171
2110
11:29
So she painted this medical facts mural with a nutrition label,
266
689305
5276
11:34
something like that,
267
694605
1157
11:35
in a diagram of him.
268
695786
1200
11:37
She then, last year, painted this diagram.
269
697010
2976
11:40
She studied health care like me.
270
700010
1884
11:41
She came to realize there were a lot of people
271
701918
2436
11:44
who'd written patient-advocate books
272
704378
2010
11:46
that you just don't hear about at medical conferences.
273
706412
2843
11:49
Patients are such an underutilized resource.
274
709279
2755
11:52
Well, as it said in my introduction,
275
712939
1725
11:54
I've gotten somewhat known for saying
276
714688
1782
11:56
that patients should have access to their data.
277
716494
2207
11:58
I actually said at one conference a couple of years ago,
278
718725
2676
12:01
"Give me my damn data,
279
721425
1163
12:02
because you people can't be trusted to keep it clean."
280
722612
2603
12:05
And here, she has our "damned" data --
281
725239
2747
12:08
it's a pun --
282
728010
1294
12:09
which is starting to break out, starting to break through --
283
729328
2928
12:12
the water symbolizes our data.
284
732280
2096
12:14
And in fact,
285
734400
1151
12:15
I want to do a little something improvisational for you.
286
735575
2704
12:18
There's a guy on Twitter that I know, a health IT guy outside Boston,
287
738303
3869
12:22
and he wrote the e-Patient rap.
288
742196
2532
12:24
And it goes like this.
289
744752
1698
12:26
(Laughter)
290
746474
1618
12:28
(Beatboxing)
291
748116
4060
12:32
(Rapping) Gimme my damn data
292
752200
2025
12:34
I wanna be an e-Patient just like Dave
293
754249
2468
12:36
Gimme my damn data, 'cause it's my life to save
294
756741
2536
12:39
(Normal voice) Now, I'm not going to go any further --
295
759301
2578
12:41
(Applause) (Cheering)
296
761903
6531
12:56
Well, thank you. That shot the timing.
297
776265
2405
12:58
(Laughter)
298
778694
1641
13:00
Think about the possibility.
299
780359
1471
13:01
Why is it that iPhones and iPads advance far faster
300
781854
4386
13:06
than the health tools that are available to you
301
786264
2240
13:08
to help take care of your family?
302
788528
2228
13:10
Here's a website, VisibleBody.com, that I stumbled across.
303
790780
4120
13:14
And I thought, "You know, I wonder what my psoas muscle is?"
304
794924
2934
13:17
So you can click on things and remove it.
305
797882
1977
13:19
And I saw, "Aha! That's the kidney and the psoas muscle."
306
799883
2977
13:22
I was rotating it in 3D and saying, "I understand now."
307
802884
3961
13:26
And then I realized it reminded me of Google Earth,
308
806869
2935
13:29
where you can fly to any address.
309
809828
2313
13:32
And I thought, "Why not take this and connect it to my digital scan data
310
812605
5328
13:37
and have Google Earth for my body?"
311
817957
2284
13:40
What did Google come out with this year?
312
820866
2120
13:43
Now there's Google Body browser.
313
823010
2004
13:45
But you see, it's still generic.
314
825618
1977
13:47
It's not my data.
315
827619
1880
13:49
But if we can get that data out from behind the dam
316
829523
3074
13:52
so software innovators can pounce on it
317
832621
2977
13:55
the way software innovators like to do,
318
835622
2276
13:57
who knows what we'll be able to come up with.
319
837922
2186
14:00
One final story.
320
840132
1151
14:01
This is Kelly Young, a rheumatoid arthritis patient from Florida.
321
841307
4575
14:06
This is a live story, unfolding just in the last few weeks.
322
846258
3519
14:09
RA patients, as they call themselves -- her blog is "RA Warrior" --
323
849801
5544
14:15
have a big problem,
324
855369
1357
14:16
because 40 percent of them have no visible symptoms.
325
856750
2778
14:20
And that makes it really hard to tell how the disease is going,
326
860010
3058
14:23
and some doctors think, "Yeah right, you're really in pain."
327
863092
3157
14:26
Well, she found, through her online research,
328
866273
2713
14:29
a nuclear bone scan that's usually used for cancer,
329
869010
3388
14:32
but it can also reveal inflammation.
330
872422
2789
14:35
And she saw that if there is no inflammation,
331
875235
3910
14:39
then the scan is a uniform gray.
332
879169
2460
14:41
So she took it.
333
881653
1195
14:42
And the radiologist's report said, "No cancer found."
334
882872
4281
14:47
Well, that's not what he was supposed to do with it.
335
887177
2479
14:49
So she wanted to have it read again,
336
889680
2421
14:52
and her doctor fired her.
337
892125
1861
14:54
She pulled up the CD.
338
894010
1883
14:55
He said, "If you don't want to follow my instructions, go away."
339
895917
3707
15:00
So she pulled up the CD of the scan images,
340
900219
2767
15:03
and look at all those hot spots.
341
903010
1976
15:05
And she's now actively engaged on her blog
342
905010
2976
15:08
in looking for assistance in getting better care.
343
908010
2795
15:11
See, that is an empowered patient -- no medical training.
344
911320
2792
15:14
We are, you are,
345
914136
1971
15:16
the most underused resource in health care.
346
916131
2695
15:18
What she was able to do
347
918850
1516
15:20
was because she had access to the raw data.
348
920390
2742
15:23
How big a deal was this?
349
923156
1372
15:24
Well at TED2009,
350
924552
1746
15:26
Tim Berners-Lee himself, inventor of the Web,
351
926322
3274
15:29
gave a talk where he said the next big thing
352
929620
2977
15:32
is not to have your browser find other people's articles about the data,
353
932621
4675
15:37
but the raw data.
354
937320
1182
15:38
And he got them chanting by the end of the talk,
355
938526
2770
15:41
"Raw data now! Raw data now!"
356
941320
3667
15:45
And I ask you,
357
945011
1514
15:46
three words, please, to improve health care:
358
946549
2716
15:49
Let patients help!
359
949827
1977
15:51
Let patients help!
360
951828
1714
15:53
Let patients help!
361
953566
1855
15:55
Let patients help!
362
955445
1918
15:57
Thank you.
363
957387
1264
15:58
(Applause)
364
958675
6768
16:15
For all the patients around the world watching this on the Webcast,
365
975422
5386
16:20
God bless you, everyone. Let patients help.
366
980832
2321
16:23
Host: And bless yourself. Thank you very much.
367
983177
2638
About this website

This site will introduce you to YouTube videos that are useful for learning English. You will see English lessons taught by top-notch teachers from around the world. Double-click on the English subtitles displayed on each video page to play the video from there. The subtitles scroll in sync with the video playback. If you have any comments or requests, please contact us using this contact form.

https://forms.gle/WvT1wiN1qDtmnspy7