Seth Priebatsch: Building the game layer on top of the world

104,014 views ・ 2010-08-20

TED


Please double-click on the English subtitles below to play the video.

00:16
My name's Seth Priebatsch. I'm the chief ninja of SCVNGR.
0
16410
2684
00:19
I'm a proud Princeton dropout.
1
19118
1468
00:20
Also proud to have relocated here to Boston,
2
20610
2054
00:22
where I actually grew up.
3
22688
1547
00:24
(Applause) Yeah, Boston.
4
24259
1780
00:26
Easy wins, I should just name the counties that we've got around here.
5
26063
3302
00:29
I'm also fairly determined to try and build
6
29389
2191
00:31
a game layer on top of the world.
7
31604
1589
00:33
This is sort of a new concept and it's really important,
8
33217
2660
00:35
because while the last decade was the decade of social,
9
35901
3097
00:39
the decade where the framework in which we connect with other people was built,
10
39022
3781
00:42
this next decade will be the decade where the game framework is built,
11
42827
4323
00:47
where the motivations we use to actually influence behavior
12
47174
2928
00:50
and the framework in which that is constructed,
13
50126
2215
00:52
is decided upon, and that's really important.
14
52365
2119
00:54
I say I want to build a game layer on top of the world,
15
54508
2579
00:57
but that's not quite true,
16
57111
1251
00:58
because it's already under construction; it's already happening.
17
58386
3150
01:01
And it looks like this right now.
18
61560
1860
01:03
It looks like the Web did back in 1997, right?
19
63444
2792
01:06
It's not very good. It's cluttered.
20
66260
1926
01:08
It's filled with lots of different things that, in short, aren't that fun.
21
68210
3890
01:12
There are credit card schemes and airline mile programs,
22
72124
3244
01:15
coupon cards and all these loyalty schemes
23
75392
2640
01:18
that actually do use game dynamics and are building the game layer --
24
78056
3861
01:21
they just suck.
25
81941
1295
01:23
They're not very well-designed.
26
83260
2065
01:25
(Laughter)
27
85349
1044
01:26
So that's unfortunate.
28
86417
1544
01:27
But luckily, as my favorite action hero, Bob the Builder, says,
29
87985
4158
01:32
"We can do better. We can build this better."
30
92167
2236
01:34
And the tools, the resources that we use to build a game layer,
31
94769
3467
01:38
are game dynamics themselves.
32
98260
1809
01:40
And so the crux of this presentation is going to go through
33
100093
2769
01:42
four really important game dynamics,
34
102886
1738
01:44
really interesting things, that, if you use consciously,
35
104648
2785
01:47
you can use to influence behavior,
36
107457
2779
01:50
both for good, for bad, for in-between.
37
110260
2357
01:52
Hopefully for good.
38
112641
1299
01:53
But this is the important stage in which that framework will get built,
39
113964
4000
01:57
and so we want to all be thinking about it consciously now.
40
117988
3097
02:01
Before we jump into that, there's a question of:
41
121109
2257
02:03
Why is this important?
42
123390
1151
02:04
I'm making this claim
43
124565
1154
02:05
that there's a game layer on top of the world,
44
125743
2150
02:07
and it's very important that we build it properly.
45
127917
2338
02:10
The reason it's so important is that, in the last decade,
46
130279
2670
02:12
what we've seen has been building the social layer,
47
132973
2886
02:15
has been this framework for connections,
48
135883
2468
02:18
and construction on that layer is over, it's finished.
49
138375
3564
02:21
There's still a lot to explore,
50
141963
1478
02:23
still a lot of people trying to figure out social
51
143465
2291
02:25
and how we leverage this and how we use this,
52
145780
2102
02:27
but the framework itself is done,
53
147906
1783
02:29
and it's called Facebook.
54
149713
1486
02:32
And that's OK, right? A lot of people are very happy with Facebook.
55
152175
3371
02:35
I like it quite a lot.
56
155570
1589
02:37
They've created this thing called the Open Graph,
57
157183
2303
02:39
and they own all of our connections.
58
159510
1726
02:41
They own half a billion people.
59
161260
1607
02:42
So when you want to build on the social layer,
60
162891
2184
02:45
the framework has been decided; it is the Open Graph API.
61
165099
3212
02:48
And if you're happy with that, fantastic.
62
168335
2010
02:50
If you're not, too bad. There's nothing you can do.
63
170369
2718
02:53
And that's a real thing.
64
173547
2689
02:56
I mean, we want to build frameworks in a way that makes it acceptable
65
176260
4976
03:01
and makes it productive down the road.
66
181260
2087
03:03
So, the social layer is all about these connections.
67
183371
2618
03:06
The game layer is all about influence.
68
186495
2412
03:08
It's not about adding a social fabric to the web
69
188931
2244
03:11
and connecting you to other people
70
191199
1627
03:12
everywhere you are and everywhere you go,
71
192850
1954
03:14
it's actually about using dynamics, using forces,
72
194828
2296
03:17
to influence the behavior of where you are, what you do there,
73
197148
3128
03:20
how you do it.
74
200300
1153
03:21
That's really, really powerful.
75
201477
1494
03:22
And it's going to be more important than the social layer,
76
202995
2732
03:25
and affect our lives more deeply and perhaps more invisibly.
77
205751
2895
03:28
So it's incredibly critical that at this moment,
78
208670
2798
03:31
while it's just getting constructed,
79
211492
1720
03:33
while the frameworks like Facebook or Open Graph
80
213236
2306
03:35
are being created for the game-layer equivalent,
81
215566
2270
03:37
that we think about it very consciously,
82
217860
1924
03:39
and that we do it in a way that is open, available,
83
219808
2388
03:42
and can be leveraged for good.
84
222220
1489
03:43
So that's what I want to talk about for game dynamics,
85
223733
2530
03:46
because construction has just begun,
86
226287
1723
03:48
and the more consciously we can think about this,
87
228034
2349
03:50
the better we'll be able to use it for anything we want.
88
230407
3064
03:53
So like I said, the way you go through and build on the game layer
89
233495
3146
03:56
is not with glass and steel and cement.
90
236665
3127
03:59
And the resources we use are not this two-dimensional swath of land
91
239816
3211
04:03
that we have.
92
243051
1156
04:04
The resources are mindshare,
93
244231
1349
04:05
and the tools, the raw materials, are these game dynamics.
94
245604
2784
04:08
With that, a couple game dynamics to talk about.
95
248412
2253
04:11
Back at SCVNGR, we like to joke
96
251137
1525
04:12
that with seven game dynamics, you can get anyone to do anything.
97
252686
3072
04:15
Today, I'm going to show you four,
98
255782
1638
04:17
because I hope to have a competitive advantage at the end of this, still.
99
257444
3478
04:20
(Laughter)
100
260946
2131
04:23
So the first one, it's a very simple game dynamic.
101
263101
2512
04:25
It's called the appointment dynamic.
102
265637
1792
04:27
It's a dynamic in which to succeed,
103
267453
1807
04:29
players have to do something at a predefined time,
104
269284
2381
04:31
generally at a predefined place.
105
271689
1682
04:33
And these dynamics are a little scary sometimes,
106
273395
2276
04:35
because you think, "Other people can be using forces
107
275695
2740
04:38
that will manipulate how I interact:
108
278459
1876
04:40
what I do, where I do it, when I do it."
109
280359
1977
04:42
This sort of "loss of free will" that occurs in games
110
282360
2488
04:44
can be frightening.
111
284872
1239
04:46
So with each dynamic, I'm going to give three examples:
112
286135
2585
04:48
one that shows how it's already being used in the real world,
113
288744
2866
04:51
so you can rationalize it a bit;
114
291634
1626
04:53
one that shows it in what we consider a conventional game --
115
293284
2818
04:56
I think everything is a game,
116
296126
1392
04:57
but this is more what you'd think of as a game played on a board
117
297542
3015
05:00
or on a computer screen;
118
300581
1153
05:01
and one of how it can be used for good,
119
301758
1867
05:03
so you can see that these forces can be very powerful.
120
303649
2558
05:06
So the first one, the most famous appointment dynamic in the world,
121
306231
3183
05:09
is something called, "Happy Hour."
122
309438
1737
05:11
So I had just recently dropped out of Princeton
123
311656
2482
05:14
and actually ended up for the first time in a bar,
124
314162
2493
05:16
and I saw these happy hour things all over the place.
125
316679
2770
05:19
And this is simply an appointment dynamic: come here at a certain time,
126
319473
3404
05:22
get your drinks half off.
127
322901
1198
05:24
To win, all you have to do is show up at the right place at the right time.
128
324123
3544
05:27
This game dynamic is so powerful,
129
327691
1615
05:29
it doesn't just influence our behavior; it's influenced our entire culture.
130
329330
3560
05:32
That's a really scary thought,
131
332914
1436
05:34
that one game dynamic can change things so powerfully.
132
334374
2737
05:37
It also exists in more conventional game forms.
133
337135
2195
05:39
I'm sure you've all heard of Farmville by now.
134
339354
2151
05:41
If you haven't, I recommend playing it.
135
341529
1886
05:43
You won't do anything else for the rest of your day.
136
343439
2469
05:45
Farmville has more active users than Twitter.
137
345932
2128
05:48
It's incredibly powerful,
138
348084
1207
05:49
and it has this dynamic where you have to return at a certain time
139
349315
3117
05:52
to water your fake crops, or they wilt.
140
352456
2572
05:55
And this is so powerful that when they tweak their stats,
141
355416
3212
05:58
when they say your crops wilt
142
358652
1809
06:00
after eight hours, or after six hours, or after 24 hours,
143
360485
2751
06:03
it changes the life cycle of some 70 million people during the day.
144
363260
4567
06:07
They will return, like clockwork, at different times.
145
367851
2618
06:10
So if they wanted the world to end, if they wanted productivity to stop,
146
370493
3390
06:13
they could make it a 30-minute cycle,
147
373907
1770
06:15
and no one could do anything else, right?
148
375701
1994
06:17
(Laughter)
149
377719
1516
06:19
That's a little scary.
150
379259
1468
06:20
But this could also be used for good.
151
380751
2262
06:23
This local company called Vitality
152
383037
1778
06:24
has created a product to help people take their medicine on time.
153
384839
3135
06:27
That's an appointment.
154
387998
1153
06:29
It's something that people don't do very well.
155
389175
2175
06:31
They have these GlowCaps which flash and email you
156
391374
2396
06:33
and do cool things to remind you to take your medicine.
157
393794
2603
06:36
This isn't a game yet, but really should be.
158
396421
2146
06:38
You should get points for doing it on time
159
398591
2058
06:40
and lose points for not doing it on time.
160
400673
1966
06:42
They should recognize they've built an appointment dynamic,
161
402663
2771
06:45
and leverage the games.
162
405458
1151
06:46
Then you can really achieve good in some interesting ways.
163
406633
2767
06:49
We're going to jump onto the next one.
164
409424
2522
06:51
Influence and status.
165
411970
1265
06:53
This is one of the most famous game dynamics, used all over the place.
166
413259
3977
06:57
It's used in your wallets, right now.
167
417260
2105
06:59
We all want that credit card on the far left, because it's black.
168
419389
3847
07:03
And you see someone at CVS or --
169
423260
1841
07:05
not CVS -- like, Christian Dior --
170
425125
1667
07:06
(Laughter)
171
426816
2020
07:08
I don't know. I don't have a black card; I've got a debit card.
172
428860
3268
07:12
(Laughter)
173
432152
1785
07:13
So they whip it out and you see that black card, and:
174
433961
2603
07:16
"I want that because it means they're cooler than I am,
175
436588
2587
07:19
and I need that."
176
439199
1151
07:20
And this is used in games as well.
177
440374
1690
07:22
"Modern Warfare," one of the most successful selling games of all time.
178
442088
3373
07:25
I'm only a level four, but I desperately want to be a level 10,
179
445485
3001
07:28
because they've got that cool red badge,
180
448510
1917
07:30
and that means that I am somehow better than everyone else.
181
450451
2785
07:33
And that's very powerful to me.
182
453260
1566
07:34
Status is really good motivator.
183
454850
2109
07:36
It's also used in more conventional settings,
184
456983
2140
07:39
and can be used more consciously there.
185
459147
1881
07:41
School -- and remember, I made it through one year,
186
461052
2953
07:44
so I think I'm qualified to talk on school --
187
464029
2617
07:46
is a game; it's just not a terribly well-designed game.
188
466670
3103
07:49
There are levels. There are C. There are B. There's A.
189
469797
2534
07:52
There are statuses. I mean, what is valedictorian, but a status?
190
472355
3068
07:55
If we called valedictorian a "White Knight Paladin level 20,"
191
475447
4380
07:59
I think people would probably work a lot harder.
192
479851
2257
08:02
(Laughter)
193
482132
2000
08:04
(Applause)
194
484156
1179
08:05
So school is a game,
195
485930
1666
08:07
and there has been lots of experimentation on how we do this properly.
196
487620
3315
08:10
But let's use it consciously.
197
490959
1389
08:12
Why have games you can lose? Why go from an A to an F or a B to a C?
198
492372
3253
08:15
That sucks. Why not level-up?
199
495649
1523
08:17
At Princeton, they've actually experimented with this,
200
497196
2555
08:19
with quizzes where you gain experience points,
201
499775
2167
08:21
and you level up from B to an A.
202
501966
1731
08:23
And it's very powerful.
203
503721
1515
08:25
It can be used in interesting ways.
204
505260
2888
08:28
The third one I'll talk about is the progression dynamic,
205
508172
2714
08:30
where you have to make progress, move through different steps
206
510910
2907
08:33
in a very granular fashion.
207
513841
1658
08:35
This is used all over the place, including LinkedIn,
208
515523
2713
08:38
where I am an unwhole individual.
209
518260
2294
08:40
I am only 85 percent complete on LinkedIn,
210
520578
3280
08:43
and that bothers me.
211
523882
1354
08:45
And this is so deep-seated in our psyche
212
525260
3075
08:48
that when we're presented with a progress bar
213
528359
2123
08:50
and presented with easy, granular steps to take
214
530506
2540
08:53
to try and complete that progress bar, we will do it.
215
533070
2587
08:55
We will find a way to move that blue line
216
535681
1970
08:57
all the way to the right edge of the screen.
217
537675
2165
09:00
This is used in conventional games as well.
218
540172
2136
09:02
I mean, this is a Paladin level 10,
219
542332
2193
09:04
and that's a Paladin level 20.
220
544549
1604
09:06
And if you were going to fight Orcs on the fields of Mordor
221
546177
3565
09:09
against the Ra's Al Ghul,
222
549766
1470
09:11
you'd probably want to be the bigger one, right?
223
551260
2286
09:13
I would.
224
553570
1667
09:15
And so people work very hard to level-up.
225
555261
2511
09:17
"World of Warcraft" is one of the most successful games of all time.
226
557796
3230
09:21
The average player spends some six, six-and-a-half hours a day on it,
227
561050
3628
09:24
their most dedicated players -- it's like a full-time job, it's insane.
228
564702
3598
09:28
And they have these systems where you can level-up.
229
568324
2442
09:30
And that's a very powerful thing. Progression is powerful.
230
570790
2780
09:34
It can also be used in very compelling ways for good.
231
574121
3015
09:37
One of the things we work on at SCVNGR is:
232
577160
2022
09:39
How do you use games to drive traffic and business to local businesses,
233
579206
3408
09:42
to something that is very key to the economy?
234
582638
2146
09:44
And here, we have a game that people play.
235
584808
2294
09:47
They go places, do challenges, earn points.
236
587126
2024
09:49
And we've introduced a progression dynamic into it,
237
589174
2584
09:51
where, by going to the same place over and over, doing challenges,
238
591782
3108
09:54
engaging with the business,
239
594914
1294
09:56
you move a green bar from the left edge of the screen to the right,
240
596232
3162
09:59
and unlock rewards.
241
599418
1154
10:00
This is powerful enough that we can see it hooks people into these dynamics,
242
600596
3916
10:04
pulls them back to the same local businesses,
243
604536
2098
10:06
creates loyalty, creates engagement,
244
606658
1734
10:08
and is able to drive meaningful revenue and fun and engagement to businesses.
245
608416
3927
10:12
These progression dynamics are powerful and can be used in the real world.
246
612367
3869
10:16
The final one I want to talk about -- and it's a great one to end on --
247
616260
3353
10:19
is this concept of communal discovery,
248
619637
1857
10:21
a dynamic in which everyone has to work together to achieve something.
249
621518
4258
10:25
Communal discovery is powerful
250
625800
1826
10:27
because it leverages the network that is society
251
627650
3016
10:30
to solve problems.
252
630690
1468
10:33
This is used in some famous consumer web stories like Digg,
253
633071
3778
10:36
which I'm sure you've all heard of.
254
636873
1685
10:38
Digg is a communal dynamic
255
638582
1654
10:40
to try to find and source the best news, the most interesting stories.
256
640260
3976
10:44
And they made this into a game, initially.
257
644260
2000
10:46
They had a leader board where, if you recommended the best stories,
258
646284
3164
10:49
you would get points.
259
649472
1352
10:50
And that really motivated people to find the best stories.
260
650848
2752
10:53
But it became so powerful, there was actually a cabal,
261
653624
2612
10:56
a group of people, the top seven on the leader board,
262
656260
3399
10:59
who would work together to make sure they maintained that position,
263
659683
3179
11:02
recommending people's stories.
264
662886
1445
11:04
The game became more powerful than the goal.
265
664355
2213
11:06
They ended up shutting down the leader board because, while it was effective,
266
666592
3644
11:10
it was so powerful that it stopped sourcing the best stories,
267
670260
2904
11:13
and started having people work to maintain leadership.
268
673188
2547
11:15
So we have to use this one carefully.
269
675759
1767
11:17
It's also used in things like McDonald's Monopoly,
270
677550
2355
11:19
where the game is not the Monopoly you're playing,
271
679929
2389
11:22
but the cottage industries that form to try and find Boardwalk.
272
682342
3329
11:25
There, they're just looking for a sticker that says "Boardwalk,"
273
685695
3214
11:28
but it can also be used to find real things.
274
688933
2058
11:31
This is the DARPA balloon challenge,
275
691015
1733
11:32
where they hid a couple balloons all across the United States and said,
276
692772
3341
11:36
"Use networks. Try and find these balloons fastest,
277
696137
2430
11:38
and the winner will get $40,000."
278
698591
1646
11:40
The winner was a group out of MIT,
279
700261
1847
11:42
where they created sort of a pyramid scheme, a network,
280
702132
2596
11:44
where the first person to recommend the location of a balloon got $2,000,
281
704752
3429
11:48
and anyone else to push that recommendation up also got a cut.
282
708205
2931
11:51
And in 12 hours, they were able to find all these balloons,
283
711160
2991
11:54
all across the country.
284
714175
1466
11:55
Really powerful dynamic.
285
715665
1724
11:57
And so, I've got about 20 seconds left,
286
717413
2823
12:00
so if I'm going to leave you with anything,
287
720260
2048
12:02
last decade was the decade of social.
288
722332
1782
12:04
This next decade is the decade of games.
289
724138
2098
12:06
We use game dynamics to build on it. We build with mindshare.
290
726260
2867
12:09
We can influence behavior.
291
729151
1245
12:10
It's very powerful. It's very exciting.
292
730420
1863
12:12
Let's all build it together, let's do it well and have fun playing.
293
732307
3357
12:15
(Applause)
294
735688
2072
About this website

This site will introduce you to YouTube videos that are useful for learning English. You will see English lessons taught by top-notch teachers from around the world. Double-click on the English subtitles displayed on each video page to play the video from there. The subtitles scroll in sync with the video playback. If you have any comments or requests, please contact us using this contact form.

https://forms.gle/WvT1wiN1qDtmnspy7