Anne-Marie Slaughter: Can we all "have it all"?

179,923 views ・ 2014-03-12

TED


Please double-click on the English subtitles below to play the video.

00:12
So my moment of truth
0
12834
2038
00:14
did not come all at once.
1
14872
3064
00:17
In 2010, I had the chance to be considered
2
17936
3626
00:21
for promotion from my job
3
21562
2327
00:23
as director of policy planning
4
23889
2072
00:25
at the U.S. State Department.
5
25961
2757
00:28
This was my moment to lean in,
6
28718
3731
00:32
to push myself forward
7
32449
2885
00:35
for what are really only a handful
8
35334
2694
00:38
of the very top foreign policy jobs,
9
38028
3017
00:41
and I had just finished a big, 18-month project
10
41045
3080
00:44
for Secretary Clinton, successfully,
11
44125
2573
00:46
and I knew I could handle a bigger job.
12
46698
4231
00:50
The woman I thought I was
13
50929
3830
00:54
would have said yes.
14
54759
2171
00:56
But I had been commuting for two years
15
56930
2027
00:58
between Washington and Princeton, New Jersey,
16
58957
3143
01:02
where my husband and my two teenage sons lived,
17
62100
3927
01:06
and it was not going well.
18
66027
3266
01:09
I tried on the idea of eking out another two years
19
69293
3705
01:12
in Washington, or maybe uprooting my sons
20
72998
2796
01:15
from their school and my husband from his work
21
75794
2135
01:17
and asking them to join me.
22
77929
2581
01:20
But deep down, I knew
23
80510
3039
01:23
that the right decision was to go home,
24
83549
3531
01:27
even if I didn't fully recognize the woman
25
87080
2916
01:29
who was making that choice.
26
89996
3992
01:33
That was a decision based on love
27
93988
3507
01:37
and responsibility.
28
97495
1944
01:39
I couldn't keep watching my oldest son
29
99439
2899
01:42
make bad choices
30
102338
1425
01:43
without being able to be there for him
31
103763
2695
01:46
when and if he needed me.
32
106458
3783
01:50
But the real change came more gradually.
33
110241
3514
01:53
Over the next year,
34
113755
1759
01:55
while my family was righting itself,
35
115514
2875
01:58
I started to realize
36
118389
1664
02:00
that even if I could go back into government,
37
120053
2939
02:02
I didn't want to.
38
122992
1780
02:04
I didn't want to miss the last five years
39
124772
3947
02:08
that my sons were at home.
40
128719
2832
02:11
I finally allowed myself to accept
41
131551
3886
02:15
what was really most important to me,
42
135437
3006
02:18
not what I was conditioned to want
43
138443
3409
02:21
or maybe what I conditioned myself to want,
44
141852
4698
02:26
and that decision led to a reassessment
45
146550
5061
02:31
of the feminist narrative that I grew up with
46
151611
3023
02:34
and have always championed.
47
154634
3656
02:38
I am still completely committed
48
158290
3852
02:42
to the cause of male-female equality,
49
162142
5185
02:47
but let's think about what that equality really means,
50
167327
4946
02:52
and how best to achieve it.
51
172273
2927
02:55
I always accepted the idea
52
175200
3123
02:58
that the most respected and powerful people
53
178323
2925
03:01
in our society are men at the top of their careers,
54
181248
4505
03:05
so that the measure of male-female equality
55
185753
4175
03:09
ought to be how many women are in those positions:
56
189928
4219
03:14
prime ministers, presidents, CEOs,
57
194147
2919
03:17
directors, managers, Nobel laureates, leaders.
58
197066
5103
03:22
I still think we should do everything we possibly can
59
202169
4277
03:26
to achieve that goal.
60
206446
2080
03:28
But that's only half of real equality,
61
208526
5125
03:33
and I now think we're never going to get there
62
213651
3348
03:36
unless we recognize the other half.
63
216999
5282
03:42
I suggest that real equality,
64
222281
4311
03:46
full equality,
65
226592
2271
03:48
does not just mean valuing women
66
228863
3215
03:52
on male terms.
67
232078
2167
03:54
It means creating a much wider range
68
234245
4618
03:58
of equally respected choices
69
238863
4012
04:02
for women and for men.
70
242875
3051
04:05
And to get there, we have to change our workplaces,
71
245926
3469
04:09
our policies and our culture.
72
249395
2914
04:12
In the workplace,
73
252309
2065
04:14
real equality means valuing family
74
254374
3303
04:17
just as much as work,
75
257677
1623
04:19
and understanding that the two reinforce each other.
76
259300
4563
04:23
As a leader and as a manager,
77
263863
1903
04:25
I have always acted on the mantra,
78
265766
3045
04:28
if family comes first,
79
268811
2280
04:31
work does not come second --
80
271091
2847
04:33
life comes together.
81
273938
2304
04:36
If you work for me, and you have a family issue,
82
276242
4165
04:40
I expect you to attend to it,
83
280407
2434
04:42
and I am confident,
84
282841
1645
04:44
and my confidence has always been borne out,
85
284486
2697
04:47
that the work will get done, and done better.
86
287183
3991
04:51
Workers who have a reason to get home
87
291174
2401
04:53
to care for their children or their family members
88
293575
3379
04:56
are more focused, more efficient,
89
296954
2507
04:59
more results-focused.
90
299461
2023
05:01
And breadwinners who are also caregivers
91
301484
3129
05:04
have a much wider range
92
304613
2607
05:07
of experiences and contacts.
93
307220
2526
05:09
Think about a lawyer who spends part of his time
94
309746
3232
05:12
at school events for his kids
95
312978
2601
05:15
talking to other parents.
96
315579
1826
05:17
He's much more likely to bring in
97
317405
2058
05:19
new clients for his firm
98
319463
1940
05:21
than a lawyer who never leaves his office.
99
321403
3261
05:24
And caregiving itself
100
324664
1889
05:26
develops patience --
101
326553
3782
05:30
a lot of patience --
102
330335
2463
05:32
and empathy, creativity, resilience, adaptability.
103
332798
5620
05:38
Those are all attributes that are ever more important
104
338418
3798
05:42
in a high-speed, horizontal,
105
342216
2093
05:44
networked global economy.
106
344309
4449
05:48
The best companies actually know this.
107
348758
3188
05:51
The companies that win awards
108
351946
1727
05:53
for workplace flexibility in the United States
109
353673
3252
05:56
include some of our most successful corporations,
110
356925
3226
06:00
and a 2008 national study
111
360151
2271
06:02
on the changing workforce
112
362422
2053
06:04
showed that employees
113
364475
1614
06:06
in flexible and effective workplaces
114
366089
3502
06:09
are more engaged with their work,
115
369591
1713
06:11
they're more satisfied and more loyal,
116
371304
2490
06:13
they have lower levels of stress
117
373794
1833
06:15
and higher levels of mental health.
118
375627
2399
06:18
And a 2012 study of employers
119
378026
3710
06:21
showed that deep, flexible practices
120
381736
2853
06:24
actually lowered operating costs
121
384589
2390
06:26
and increased adaptability
122
386979
2465
06:29
in a global service economy.
123
389444
3087
06:32
So you may think
124
392531
3117
06:35
that the privileging of work over family
125
395648
4217
06:39
is only an American problem.
126
399865
3947
06:43
Sadly, though, the obsession with work
127
403812
3538
06:47
is no longer a uniquely American disease.
128
407350
3160
06:50
Twenty years ago,
129
410510
1772
06:52
when my family first started going to Italy,
130
412282
1996
06:54
we used to luxuriate in the culture of siesta.
131
414278
3603
06:57
Siesta is not just about avoiding the heat of the day.
132
417881
2883
07:00
It's actually just as much
133
420764
1866
07:02
about embracing the warmth of a family lunch.
134
422630
3112
07:05
Now, when we go, fewer and fewer businesses
135
425742
3203
07:08
close for siesta,
136
428945
1713
07:10
reflecting the advance of global corporations
137
430658
3538
07:14
and 24-hour competition.
138
434196
2837
07:17
So making a place for those we love
139
437033
2869
07:19
is actually a global imperative.
140
439902
3745
07:23
In policy terms,
141
443647
2730
07:26
real equality means recognizing
142
446377
3436
07:29
that the work that women have traditionally done
143
449813
2958
07:32
is just as important
144
452771
1877
07:34
as the work that men have traditionally done,
145
454648
2663
07:37
no matter who does it.
146
457311
3052
07:40
Think about it: Breadwinning and caregiving
147
460363
3745
07:44
are equally necessary for human survival.
148
464108
3525
07:47
At least if we get beyond a barter economy,
149
467633
3484
07:51
somebody has to earn an income
150
471117
2237
07:53
and someone else has to convert that income
151
473354
2954
07:56
to care and sustenance for loved ones.
152
476308
3784
08:00
Now most of you, when you hear me
153
480092
2138
08:02
talk about breadwinning and caregiving,
154
482230
2725
08:04
instinctively translate those categories
155
484955
3441
08:08
into men's work and women's work.
156
488396
3731
08:12
And we don't typically challenge
157
492127
2836
08:14
why men's work is advantaged.
158
494963
3898
08:18
But consider a same-sex couple
159
498861
2590
08:21
like my friends Sarah and Emily.
160
501451
2019
08:23
They're psychiatrists.
161
503470
1868
08:25
They got married five years ago,
162
505338
1829
08:27
and now they have two-year-old twins.
163
507167
3281
08:30
They love being mothers,
164
510448
2072
08:32
but they also love their work,
165
512520
1568
08:34
and they're really good at what they do.
166
514088
2210
08:36
So how are they going to divide up
167
516298
2021
08:38
breadwinning and caregiving responsibilities?
168
518319
2477
08:40
Should one of them stop working
169
520796
2085
08:42
or reduce hours to be home?
170
522881
2692
08:45
Or should they both change their practices
171
525573
2679
08:48
so they can have much more flexible schedules?
172
528252
3283
08:51
And what criteria should they use
173
531535
1971
08:53
to make that decision?
174
533506
1294
08:54
Is it who makes the most money
175
534800
1774
08:56
or who is most committed to her career?
176
536574
3777
09:00
Or who has the most flexible boss?
177
540351
4561
09:04
The same-sex perspective helps us see
178
544912
3325
09:08
that juggling work and family
179
548237
2464
09:10
are not women's problems,
180
550701
2111
09:12
they're family problems.
181
552812
2638
09:15
And Sarah and Emily are the lucky ones,
182
555450
3023
09:18
because they have a choice
183
558473
1769
09:20
about how much they want to work.
184
560242
2537
09:22
Millions of men and women
185
562779
2829
09:25
have to be both breadwinners and caregivers
186
565608
3337
09:28
just to earn the income they need,
187
568945
3540
09:32
and many of those workers are scrambling.
188
572485
2548
09:35
They're patching together care arrangements
189
575033
2884
09:37
that are inadequate
190
577917
1173
09:39
and often actually unsafe.
191
579090
2411
09:41
If breadwinning and caregiving are really equal,
192
581501
4690
09:46
then why shouldn't a government
193
586191
1588
09:47
invest as much in an infrastructure of care
194
587779
3816
09:51
as the foundation of a healthy society
195
591595
3859
09:55
as it invests in physical infrastructure
196
595454
3112
09:58
as the backbone of a successful economy?
197
598566
3876
10:02
The governments that get it --
198
602442
2336
10:04
no surprises here --
199
604778
1847
10:06
the governments that get it,
200
606625
1840
10:08
Norway, Sweden, Denmark, the Netherlands,
201
608465
4705
10:13
provide universal child care,
202
613170
2930
10:16
support for caregivers at home,
203
616100
2119
10:18
school and early childhood education,
204
618219
3167
10:21
protections for pregnant women,
205
621386
2210
10:23
and care for the elderly and the disabled.
206
623596
4385
10:27
Those governments invest in that infrastructure
207
627981
3681
10:31
the same way they invest in roads and bridges
208
631662
3329
10:34
and tunnels and trains.
209
634991
3135
10:38
Those societies also show you
210
638126
2408
10:40
that breadwinning and caregiving
211
640534
2290
10:42
reinforce each other.
212
642824
2384
10:45
They routinely rank among the top 15 countries
213
645208
5839
10:51
of the most globally competitive economies,
214
651047
3333
10:54
but at the same time,
215
654380
1652
10:56
they rank very high on the OECD Better Life Index.
216
656032
4691
11:00
In fact, they rank higher than other governments,
217
660723
3536
11:04
like my own, the U.S., or Switzerland,
218
664259
2669
11:06
that have higher average levels of income
219
666928
2929
11:09
but lower rankings on work-life balance.
220
669857
5763
11:15
So changing our workplaces
221
675620
2676
11:18
and building infrastructures of care
222
678296
3296
11:21
would make a big difference,
223
681592
1475
11:23
but we're not going to get equally valued choices
224
683067
4484
11:27
unless we change our culture,
225
687551
2505
11:30
and the kind of cultural change required
226
690056
3141
11:33
means re-socializing men.
227
693197
2755
11:35
(Applause)
228
695952
3674
11:39
Increasingly in developed countries,
229
699626
1735
11:41
women are socialized to believe that our place
230
701361
3082
11:44
is no longer only in the home,
231
704443
3660
11:48
but men are actually still where they always were.
232
708103
4896
11:52
Men are still socialized to believe
233
712999
3398
11:56
that they have to be breadwinners,
234
716397
2255
11:58
that to derive their self-worth
235
718652
2875
12:01
from how high they can climb over other men
236
721527
2879
12:04
on a career ladder.
237
724406
2345
12:06
The feminist revolution still has a long way to go.
238
726751
2783
12:09
It's certainly not complete.
239
729534
1902
12:11
But 60 years after
240
731436
1656
12:13
"The Feminine Mystique" was published,
241
733092
2310
12:15
many women actually have
242
735402
2301
12:17
more choices than men do.
243
737703
2978
12:20
We can decide to be a breadwinner,
244
740681
2728
12:23
a caregiver, or any combination of the two.
245
743409
4147
12:27
When a man, on the other hand,
246
747556
2526
12:30
decides to be a caregiver,
247
750082
2889
12:32
he puts his manhood on the line.
248
752971
3304
12:36
His friends may praise his decision,
249
756275
3220
12:39
but underneath, they're scratching their heads.
250
759495
3872
12:43
Isn't the measure of a man
251
763367
3101
12:46
his willingness to compete with other men
252
766468
2931
12:49
for power and prestige?
253
769399
2380
12:51
And as many women hold that view as men do.
254
771779
4096
12:55
We know that lots of women
255
775875
2966
12:58
still judge the attractiveness of a man
256
778841
3319
13:02
based in large part on how successful he is
257
782160
2725
13:04
in his career.
258
784885
1497
13:06
A woman can drop out of the work force
259
786382
2351
13:08
and still be an attractive partner.
260
788733
2160
13:10
For a man, that's a risky proposition.
261
790893
4539
13:15
So as parents and partners,
262
795432
2241
13:17
we should be socializing our sons
263
797673
3187
13:20
and our husbands
264
800860
2451
13:23
to be whatever they want to be,
265
803311
3324
13:26
either caregivers or breadwinners.
266
806635
3619
13:30
We should be socializing them to make caregiving
267
810254
3356
13:33
cool for guys.
268
813610
1987
13:35
(Applause)
269
815597
3765
13:39
I can almost hear lots of you thinking, "No way."
270
819362
6312
13:45
But in fact, the change is actually already happening.
271
825674
4647
13:50
At least in the United States,
272
830321
1957
13:52
lots of men take pride in cooking,
273
832278
2224
13:54
and frankly obsess over stoves.
274
834502
3316
13:57
They are in the birthing rooms.
275
837818
2987
14:00
They take paternity leave when they can.
276
840805
2644
14:03
They can walk a baby or soothe a toddler
277
843449
2462
14:05
just as well as their wives can,
278
845911
2642
14:08
and they are increasingly
279
848553
1749
14:10
doing much more of the housework.
280
850302
2567
14:12
Indeed, there are male college students now
281
852869
2088
14:14
who are starting to say,
282
854957
1527
14:16
"I want to be a stay-at-home dad."
283
856484
1876
14:18
That was completely unthinkable
284
858360
2251
14:20
50 or even 30 years ago.
285
860611
2867
14:23
And in Norway, where men have
286
863478
2891
14:26
an automatic three month's paternity leave,
287
866369
2789
14:29
but they lose it if they decide not to take it,
288
869158
3337
14:32
a high government official told me
289
872495
1925
14:34
that companies are starting to look
290
874420
2232
14:36
at prospective male employees
291
876652
2085
14:38
and raise an eyebrow if they didn't in fact
292
878737
3978
14:42
take their leave when they had kids.
293
882715
2396
14:45
That means that it's starting to seem
294
885111
2829
14:47
like a character defect
295
887940
2202
14:50
not to want to be a fully engaged father.
296
890142
4220
14:57
So I was raised
297
897421
5522
15:02
to believe that championing women's rights
298
902943
3649
15:06
meant doing everything we could
299
906592
2119
15:08
to get women to the top.
300
908711
1774
15:10
And I still hope that I live long enough
301
910485
2719
15:13
to see men and women equally represented
302
913204
3263
15:16
at all levels of the work force.
303
916467
3047
15:19
But I've come to believe that we have to value family
304
919514
4099
15:23
every bit as much as we value work,
305
923613
2832
15:26
and that we should entertain the idea
306
926445
2512
15:28
that doing right by those we love
307
928957
3549
15:32
will make all of us better at everything we do.
308
932506
3916
15:36
Thirty years ago, Carol Gilligan,
309
936422
2068
15:38
a wonderful psychologist, studied adolescent girls
310
938490
2957
15:41
and identified an ethic of care,
311
941447
3057
15:44
an element of human nature every bit as important
312
944504
3155
15:47
as the ethic of justice.
313
947659
1987
15:49
It turns out that "you don't care"
314
949646
3305
15:52
is just as much a part of who we are
315
952951
2921
15:55
as "that's not fair."
316
955872
2280
15:58
Bill Gates agrees.
317
958152
1800
15:59
He argues that the two great forces of human nature
318
959952
3171
16:03
are self-interest and caring for others.
319
963123
4207
16:07
Let's bring them both together.
320
967330
2642
16:09
Let's make the feminist revolution
321
969972
2659
16:12
a humanist revolution.
322
972631
2732
16:15
As whole human beings,
323
975363
1744
16:17
we will be better caregivers and breadwinners.
324
977107
3844
16:20
You may think that can't happen,
325
980951
2108
16:23
but I grew up in a society
326
983059
1700
16:24
where my mother put out small vases
327
984759
2346
16:27
of cigarettes for dinner parties,
328
987105
2662
16:29
where blacks and whites used separate bathrooms,
329
989767
4193
16:33
and where everybody claimed to be heterosexual.
330
993960
5530
16:40
Today, not so much.
331
1000602
4439
16:45
The revolution for human equality
332
1005041
3640
16:48
can happen.
333
1008681
1790
16:50
It is happening.
334
1010471
2246
16:52
It will happen.
335
1012717
2282
16:54
How far and how fast is up to us.
336
1014999
4718
16:59
Thank you.
337
1019717
2143
17:01
(Applause)
338
1021860
4000
About this website

This site will introduce you to YouTube videos that are useful for learning English. You will see English lessons taught by top-notch teachers from around the world. Double-click on the English subtitles displayed on each video page to play the video from there. The subtitles scroll in sync with the video playback. If you have any comments or requests, please contact us using this contact form.

https://forms.gle/WvT1wiN1qDtmnspy7