Don Tapscott: Four principles for the open world

118,116 views ・ 2012-06-28

TED


Please double-click on the English subtitles below to play the video.

00:00
Translator: Joseph Geni Reviewer: Morton Bast
0
0
7000
00:16
Openness. It's a word that
1
16700
2365
00:19
denotes opportunity and possibilities.
2
19065
3079
00:22
Open-ended, open hearth,
3
22144
2040
00:24
open source, open door policy,
4
24184
3353
00:27
open bar. (Laughter)
5
27537
3536
00:31
And everywhere the world is opening up,
6
31073
2520
00:33
and it's a good thing.
7
33593
1500
00:35
Why is this happening?
8
35093
1776
00:36
The technology revolution is opening the world.
9
36869
2964
00:39
Yesterday's Internet was a platform
10
39833
2545
00:42
for the presentation of content.
11
42378
2592
00:44
The Internet of today is a platform for computation.
12
44970
3255
00:48
The Internet is becoming a giant
13
48225
1607
00:49
global computer, and every time you go on it,
14
49832
2601
00:52
you upload a video, you do a Google search,
15
52433
2657
00:55
you remix something,
16
55090
1654
00:56
you're programming this big global computer
17
56744
2547
00:59
that we all share.
18
59291
1240
01:00
Humanity is building a machine,
19
60531
3234
01:03
and this enables us to collaborate in new ways.
20
63765
3074
01:06
Collaboration can occur on
21
66839
1316
01:08
an astronomical basis.
22
68155
2974
01:11
Now a new generation is opening up the world as well.
23
71129
3408
01:14
I started studying kids about 15 years ago,
24
74537
2689
01:17
-- so actually 20 years ago now --
25
77226
1959
01:19
and I noticed how my own children were
26
79185
1595
01:20
effortlessly able to use all this sophisticated technology,
27
80780
3517
01:24
and at first I thought,
28
84297
1217
01:25
"My children are prodigies!" (Laughter)
29
85514
2965
01:28
But then I noticed all their friends were like them,
30
88479
2126
01:30
so that was a bad theory.
31
90605
1944
01:32
So I've started working with a few hundred kids,
32
92549
2995
01:35
and I came to the conclusion
33
95544
1595
01:37
that this is the first generation to come of age
34
97139
2058
01:39
in the digital age,
35
99197
1134
01:40
to be bathed in bits.
36
100331
1621
01:41
I call them the Net Generation.
37
101952
2336
01:44
I said, these kids are different.
38
104288
1350
01:45
They have no fear of technology, because it's not there.
39
105638
2878
01:48
It's like the air.
40
108516
1461
01:49
It's sort of like, I have no fear of a refrigerator.
41
109977
3823
01:53
And — (Laughter)
42
113800
2530
01:56
And there's no more powerful force to change
43
116330
1838
01:58
every institution than the first generation of digital natives.
44
118168
4708
02:02
I'm a digital immigrant.
45
122876
1354
02:04
I had to learn the language.
46
124230
2941
02:07
The global economic crisis is opening up the world as well.
47
127171
3269
02:10
Our opaque institutions from the Industrial Age,
48
130440
3030
02:13
everything from old models of the corporation,
49
133470
2369
02:15
government, media, Wall Street,
50
135839
2481
02:18
are in various stages of being stalled or frozen
51
138320
3576
02:21
or in atrophy or even failing,
52
141896
2926
02:24
and this is now creating a burning platform in the world.
53
144822
3010
02:27
I mean, think about Wall Street.
54
147832
1829
02:29
The core modus operandi of Wall Street almost brought down
55
149661
3211
02:32
global capitalism.
56
152872
2498
02:35
Now, you know the idea of a burning platform,
57
155370
1563
02:36
that you're somewhere where the costs of staying where you are
58
156933
4170
02:41
become greater than the costs of moving to something different,
59
161103
3201
02:44
perhaps something radically different.
60
164304
3173
02:47
And we need to change
61
167477
1728
02:49
and open up all of our institutions.
62
169205
2093
02:51
So this technology push,
63
171298
1682
02:52
a demographic kick from a new generation
64
172980
2892
02:55
and a demand pull from a new
65
175872
2868
02:58
economic global environment
66
178740
2427
03:01
is causing the world to open up.
67
181167
1693
03:02
Now, I think, in fact,
68
182860
3120
03:05
we're at a turning point in human history,
69
185980
3203
03:09
where we can finally now rebuild
70
189183
1945
03:11
many of the institutions of the Industrial Age
71
191128
2438
03:13
around a new set of principles.
72
193566
1557
03:15
Now, what is openness?
73
195123
2364
03:17
Well, as it turns out, openness
74
197487
1575
03:19
has a number of different meanings,
75
199062
2242
03:21
and for each there's a corresponding principle
76
201304
2903
03:24
for the transformation of
77
204207
1669
03:25
civilization.
78
205876
2024
03:27
The first is collaboration.
79
207900
3275
03:31
Now, this is openness in the sense of the boundaries
80
211175
2815
03:33
of organizations becoming more porous and fluid
81
213990
2959
03:36
and open.
82
216949
1864
03:38
The guy in the picture here,
83
218813
1536
03:40
I'll tell you his story.
84
220349
1129
03:41
His name is Rob McEwen.
85
221478
1905
03:43
I'd like to say, "I have this think tank, we scour the world
86
223383
2582
03:45
for amazing case studies."
87
225965
1654
03:47
The reason I know this story
88
227619
1658
03:49
is because he's my neighbor. (Laughter)
89
229277
4161
03:53
He actually moved across the street from us,
90
233438
1767
03:55
and he held a cocktail party
91
235205
1279
03:56
to meet the neighbors, and he says, "You're Don Tapscott.
92
236484
2445
03:58
I've read some of your books."
93
238929
909
03:59
I said, "Great. What do you do?"
94
239838
1100
04:00
And he says, "Well I used to be a banker
95
240938
1317
04:02
and now I'm a gold miner."
96
242255
1448
04:03
And he tells me this amazing story.
97
243703
2990
04:06
He takes over this gold mine, and his geologists
98
246693
2491
04:09
can't tell him where the gold is.
99
249184
1287
04:10
He gives them more money for geological data,
100
250471
1727
04:12
they come back, they can't tell
101
252198
1629
04:13
him where to go into production.
102
253827
1862
04:15
After a few years, he's so frustrated he's ready
103
255689
3980
04:19
to give up, but he has an epiphany one day.
104
259669
2377
04:22
He wonders, "If my geologists don't know where the gold is,
105
262046
2774
04:24
maybe somebody else does."
106
264820
2370
04:27
So he does a "radical" thing.
107
267190
2003
04:29
He takes his geological data,
108
269193
1507
04:30
he publishes it and he holds a contest on the Internet
109
270700
2763
04:33
called the Goldcorp Challenge.
110
273463
1491
04:34
It's basically half a million dollars in prize money
111
274954
3580
04:38
for anybody who can tell me, do I have any gold,
112
278534
2712
04:41
and if so, where is it? (Laughter)
113
281246
3936
04:45
He gets submissions from all around the world.
114
285182
2147
04:47
They use techniques that he's never heard of,
115
287329
2257
04:49
and for his half a million dollars in prize money,
116
289586
2168
04:51
Rob McEwen finds 3.4 billion dollars worth of gold.
117
291754
4185
04:55
The market value of his company
118
295939
1773
04:57
goes from 90 million to 10 billion dollars,
119
297712
2318
05:00
and I can tell you, because he's my neighbor,
120
300030
2692
05:02
he's a happy camper. (Laughter)
121
302722
3490
05:06
You know, conventional wisdom says talent is inside, right?
122
306212
3688
05:09
Your most precious asset goes out the elevator every night.
123
309900
3111
05:13
He viewed talent differently.
124
313011
2505
05:15
He wondered, who are their peers?
125
315516
2296
05:17
He should have fired his geology department, but he didn't.
126
317812
4069
05:21
You know, some of the best submissions
127
321881
2331
05:24
didn't come from geologists.
128
324212
2231
05:26
They came from computer scientists, engineers.
129
326443
2496
05:28
The winner was a computer graphics company
130
328939
1251
05:30
that built a three dimensional model of the mine
131
330190
1816
05:32
where you can helicopter underground
132
332006
1823
05:33
and see where the gold is.
133
333829
2670
05:36
He helped us understand that social media's becoming
134
336499
3103
05:39
social production.
135
339602
2073
05:41
It's not about hooking up online.
136
341675
1744
05:43
This is a new means of production in the making.
137
343419
3075
05:46
And this Ideagora that he created, an open market, agora,
138
346494
3997
05:50
for uniquely qualified minds,
139
350491
2999
05:53
was part of a change, a profound change in the deep structure
140
353490
4735
05:58
and architecture of our organizations,
141
358225
2458
06:00
and how we sort of orchestrate capability to innovate,
142
360683
3602
06:04
to create goods and services,
143
364285
1700
06:05
to engage with the rest of the world,
144
365985
1123
06:07
in terms of government, how we create public value.
145
367108
4405
06:11
Openness is about collaboration.
146
371513
1986
06:13
Now secondly, openness is about transparency.
147
373499
2366
06:15
This is different. Here, we're talking about the communication
148
375865
2190
06:18
of pertinent information to stakeholders of organizations:
149
378055
3835
06:21
employees, customers, business partners, shareholders,
150
381890
2917
06:24
and so on.
151
384807
1762
06:26
And everywhere, our institutions are becoming naked.
152
386569
4273
06:30
People are all bent out of shape about WikiLeaks,
153
390842
2487
06:33
but that's just the tip of the iceberg.
154
393329
2456
06:35
You see, people at their fingertips now, everybody,
155
395785
2705
06:38
not just Julian Assange,
156
398490
2225
06:40
have these powerful tools for finding out what's going on,
157
400715
2591
06:43
scrutinizing, informing others,
158
403306
1457
06:44
and even organizing collective responses.
159
404763
3590
06:48
Institutions are becoming naked,
160
408353
2290
06:50
and if you're going to be naked,
161
410643
1807
06:52
well, there's some corollaries that flow from that.
162
412450
2715
06:55
I mean, one is,
163
415165
863
06:56
fitness is no longer optional. (Laughter)
164
416028
2781
06:58
You know? Or if you're going to be naked, you'd better get buff.
165
418809
4321
07:03
Now, by buff I mean, you need to have good value,
166
423130
3465
07:06
because value is evidenced like never before.
167
426595
1980
07:08
You say you have good products.
168
428575
964
07:09
They'd better be good.
169
429539
1041
07:10
But you also need to have values.
170
430580
1951
07:12
You need to have integrity as part of your bones
171
432531
2943
07:15
and your DNA as an organization,
172
435474
2408
07:17
because if you don't, you'll be unable to build trust,
173
437882
2473
07:20
and trust is a sine qua non of this new network world.
174
440355
3989
07:24
So this is good. It's not bad.
175
444344
3271
07:27
Sunlight is the best disinfectant.
176
447615
2695
07:30
And we need a lot of sunlight in this troubled world.
177
450310
3983
07:34
Now, the third meaning and corresponding principle
178
454293
2996
07:37
of openness is about sharing.
179
457289
2130
07:39
Now this is different than transparency.
180
459419
1721
07:41
Transparency is about the communication of information.
181
461140
2743
07:43
Sharing is about giving up assets, intellectual property.
182
463883
4418
07:48
And there are all kinds of famous stories about this.
183
468301
2270
07:50
IBM gave away 400 million dollars of software
184
470571
2937
07:53
to the Linux movement, and that gave them
185
473508
2101
07:55
a multi-billion dollar payoff.
186
475609
3011
07:58
Now, conventional wisdom says,
187
478620
1960
08:00
"Well, hey, our intellectual property belongs to us,
188
480580
2735
08:03
and if someone tries to infringe it, we're going to get out
189
483315
2303
08:05
our lawyers and we're going to sue them."
190
485618
2348
08:07
Well, it didn't work so well for the record labels, did it?
191
487966
3413
08:11
I mean, they took — They had a technology disruption,
192
491379
5104
08:16
and rather than taking a business model innovation
193
496483
2689
08:19
to correspond to that, they took and sought a legal solution
194
499172
3952
08:23
and the industry that brought you Elvis and the Beatles
195
503124
2313
08:25
is now suing children
196
505437
2032
08:27
and is in danger of collapse.
197
507469
4167
08:31
So we need to think differently about intellectual property.
198
511636
2841
08:34
I'll give you an example.
199
514477
1029
08:35
The pharmaceutical industry is in deep trouble.
200
515506
2882
08:38
First of all, there aren't a lot of big inventions
201
518388
2605
08:40
in the pipeline, and this is a big problem for human health,
202
520993
2354
08:43
and the pharmaceutical industry has got a bigger problem,
203
523347
5161
08:48
that they're about to fall off something
204
528508
1923
08:50
called the patent cliff.
205
530431
1521
08:51
Do you know about this?
206
531952
768
08:52
They're going to lose 20 to 35 percent of their revenue
207
532720
3004
08:55
in the next 12 months.
208
535724
1627
08:57
And what are you going to do,
209
537351
1331
08:58
like, cut back on paper clips or something? No.
210
538682
3110
09:01
We need to reinvent the whole model of scientific research.
211
541792
4713
09:06
The pharmaceutical industry needs to place assets
212
546505
3464
09:09
in a commons. They need to start sharing precompetitive research.
213
549969
3935
09:13
They need to start sharing
214
553904
2343
09:16
clinical trial data,
215
556247
1458
09:17
and in doing so, create a rising tide that could lift all boats,
216
557705
4271
09:21
not just for the industry but
217
561976
1942
09:23
for humanity.
218
563918
2791
09:26
Now, the fourth meaning
219
566709
2405
09:29
of openness,
220
569114
2146
09:31
and corresponding principle, is about empowerment.
221
571260
1999
09:33
And I'm not talking about the motherhood sense here.
222
573259
2216
09:35
Knowledge and intelligence is power,
223
575475
3474
09:38
and as it becomes more distributed, there's a
224
578949
2839
09:41
concomitant distribution
225
581788
2545
09:44
and decentralization and disaggregation of power
226
584333
3631
09:47
that's underway in the world today.
227
587964
1929
09:49
The open world is bringing freedom.
228
589893
3090
09:52
Now, take the Arab Spring.
229
592983
2349
09:55
The debate about the role of social media
230
595332
1912
09:57
and social change has been settled.
231
597244
1994
09:59
You know, one word: Tunisia.
232
599238
3238
10:02
And then it ended up having a whole bunch of other words too.
233
602476
2346
10:04
But in the Tunisian revolution,
234
604822
2342
10:07
the new media didn't cause the revolution;
235
607164
2127
10:09
it was caused by injustice.
236
609291
1780
10:11
Social media didn't create the revolution;
237
611071
4237
10:15
it was created by a new generation of young people
238
615308
2321
10:17
who wanted jobs and hope and
239
617629
1808
10:19
who didn't want to be treated as subjects anymore.
240
619437
4026
10:23
But just as the Internet drops transaction and collaboration
241
623463
3065
10:26
costs in business and government,
242
626528
2368
10:28
it also drops the cost of dissent, of rebellion,
243
628896
2757
10:31
and even insurrection
244
631653
1829
10:33
in ways that people didn't understand.
245
633482
2092
10:35
You know, during the Tunisian revolution,
246
635574
1823
10:37
snipers associated with the regime were killing
247
637397
2694
10:40
unarmed students in the street.
248
640091
1744
10:41
So the students would take their mobile devices,
249
641835
3021
10:44
take a picture, triangulate the location,
250
644856
2653
10:47
send that picture to friendly military units,
251
647509
2201
10:49
who'd come in and take out the snipers.
252
649710
2409
10:52
You think that social media is about hooking up online?
253
652119
2534
10:54
For these kids, it was a military tool
254
654653
3027
10:57
to defend unarmed people from murderers.
255
657680
3126
11:00
It was a tool of self-defense.
256
660806
2133
11:02
You know, as we speak today, young people
257
662939
2355
11:05
are being killed in Syria,
258
665294
2010
11:07
and up until three months ago,
259
667304
1810
11:09
if you were injured on the street,
260
669114
2199
11:11
an ambulance would pick you up,
261
671313
1452
11:12
take you to the hospital, you'd go in, say, with a broken leg,
262
672765
2900
11:15
and you'd come out with a bullet in your head.
263
675665
2479
11:18
So these 20-somethings created
264
678144
2911
11:21
an alternative health care system,
265
681055
2294
11:23
where what they did is they used Twitter and basic
266
683349
2390
11:25
publicly available tools that when someone's injured,
267
685739
3245
11:28
a car would show up, it would pick them up,
268
688984
2680
11:31
take them to a makeshift medical clinic, where you'd get
269
691664
2559
11:34
medical treatment, as opposed to being executed.
270
694223
3542
11:37
So this is a time of great change.
271
697765
3185
11:40
Now, it's not without its problems.
272
700950
2634
11:43
Up until two years ago,
273
703584
2646
11:46
all revolutions in human history had a leadership,
274
706230
3153
11:49
and when the old regime fell, the leadership
275
709383
2792
11:52
and the organization would take power.
276
712175
978
11:53
Well, these wiki revolutions happen so fast
277
713153
2525
11:55
they create a vacuum, and
278
715678
1498
11:57
politics abhors a vacuum,
279
717176
1735
11:58
and unsavory forces can fill that,
280
718911
2072
12:00
typically the old regime,
281
720983
3126
12:04
or extremists, or fundamentalist forces.
282
724109
2346
12:06
You can see this playing out today in Egypt.
283
726455
2735
12:09
But that doesn't matter,
284
729190
1663
12:10
because this is moving forward.
285
730853
2137
12:12
The train has left the station. The cat is out of the bag.
286
732990
2976
12:15
The horse is out of the barn. Help me out here, okay?
287
735966
3378
12:19
(Laughter) The toothpaste is out of the tube.
288
739344
2142
12:21
I mean, we're not putting this one back.
289
741486
2223
12:23
The open world is bringing empowerment and freedom.
290
743709
3733
12:27
I think, at the end of these four days,
291
747442
2784
12:30
that you'll come to conclude that the arc of history
292
750226
2766
12:32
is a positive one, and it's towards openness.
293
752992
3496
12:36
If you go back a few hundred years,
294
756488
2481
12:38
all around the world it was a very closed society.
295
758969
2384
12:41
It was agrarian, and the means of production
296
761353
1569
12:42
and political system was called feudalism, and knowledge
297
762922
2715
12:45
was concentrated in the church and the nobility.
298
765637
3938
12:49
People didn't know about things.
299
769575
1607
12:51
There was no concept of progress.
300
771182
2475
12:53
You were born, you lived your life and you died.
301
773657
1903
12:55
But then Johannes Gutenberg came along with his great invention,
302
775560
4596
13:00
and, over time, the society opened up.
303
780156
3552
13:03
People started to learn about things, and when they did,
304
783708
2041
13:05
the institutions of feudal society appeared
305
785749
1385
13:07
to be stalled, or frozen, or failing.
306
787134
3703
13:10
It didn't make sense for the church to be responsible
307
790837
2776
13:13
for medicine when people had knowledge.
308
793613
2282
13:15
So we saw the Protestant Reformation.
309
795895
1947
13:17
Martin Luther called the printing press
310
797842
1870
13:19
"God's highest act of grace."
311
799712
2397
13:22
The creation of a corporation, science, the university,
312
802109
3511
13:25
eventually the Industrial Revolution,
313
805620
1687
13:27
and it was all good.
314
807307
2174
13:29
But it came with a cost.
315
809481
2147
13:31
And now, once again, the technology genie
316
811628
2712
13:34
is out of the bottle, but this time it's different.
317
814340
3320
13:37
The printing press gave us access to the written word.
318
817660
2865
13:40
The Internet enables each of us to be a producer.
319
820525
3459
13:43
The printing press gave us access to recorded knowledge.
320
823984
2814
13:46
The Internet gives us access,
321
826798
1910
13:48
not just to information and knowledge, but
322
828708
1649
13:50
to the intelligence contained in the crania of other people
323
830357
3376
13:53
on a global basis.
324
833733
1537
13:55
To me, this is not an information age,
325
835270
3239
13:58
it's an age of networked intelligence.
326
838509
2874
14:01
It's an age of vast promise,
327
841383
3872
14:05
an age of collaboration,
328
845255
3128
14:08
where the boundaries of our organizations are changing,
329
848383
4179
14:12
of transparency, where sunlight
330
852562
2715
14:15
is disinfecting civilization,
331
855277
3223
14:18
an age of sharing and understanding
332
858500
3556
14:22
the new power of the commons,
333
862056
1706
14:23
and it's an age of empowerment
334
863762
2643
14:26
and of freedom.
335
866405
2891
14:29
Now, what I'd like to do is,
336
869296
3536
14:32
to close, to share with you
337
872832
2648
14:35
some research that I've been doing.
338
875480
2609
14:38
I've tried to study all kinds of organizations
339
878089
2511
14:40
to understand what the future might look like,
340
880600
3137
14:43
but I've been studying nature recently.
341
883737
3025
14:46
You know, bees come in swarms
342
886762
3630
14:50
and fish come in schools.
343
890392
2711
14:53
Starlings, in the area around Edinburgh,
344
893103
2813
14:55
in the moors of England,
345
895916
1483
14:57
come in something called a murmuration,
346
897399
2094
14:59
and the murmuration refers to the murmuring of the wings
347
899493
2772
15:02
of the birds, and throughout the day the starlings
348
902265
1913
15:04
are out over a 20-mile radius
349
904178
1865
15:06
sort of doing their starling thing.
350
906043
2041
15:08
And at night they come together
351
908084
1764
15:09
and they create one of the most spectacular things
352
909848
2122
15:11
in all of nature,
353
911970
1595
15:13
and it's called a murmuration.
354
913565
2054
15:15
And scientists that have studied this have said
355
915619
2917
15:18
they've never seen an accident.
356
918536
1746
15:20
Now, this thing has a function.
357
920282
1950
15:22
It protects the birds.
358
922232
1862
15:24
You can see on the right here,
359
924094
1600
15:25
there's a predator being chased away by the collective power
360
925694
4505
15:30
of the birds, and apparently this is a frightening thing
361
930199
2990
15:33
if you're a predator of starlings.
362
933189
3464
15:36
And there's leadership,
363
936653
2448
15:39
but there's no one leader.
364
939101
2138
15:41
Now, is this some kind of fanciful analogy,
365
941239
2101
15:43
or could we actually learn something from this?
366
943340
2446
15:45
Well, the murmuration functions to record
367
945786
3056
15:48
a number of principles,
368
948842
1363
15:50
and they're basically the principles that
369
950205
1519
15:51
I have described to you today.
370
951724
1914
15:53
This is a huge collaboration.
371
953638
2806
15:56
It's an openness, it's a sharing
372
956444
1779
15:58
of all kinds of information, not just about location
373
958223
2515
16:00
and trajectory and danger and so on, but about food sources.
374
960738
5015
16:05
And there's a real sense of interdependence,
375
965753
4137
16:09
that the individual birds somehow understand
376
969890
3687
16:13
that their interests are in the interest of the collective.
377
973577
2959
16:16
Perhaps like we should understand
378
976536
2249
16:18
that business can't succeed
379
978785
4168
16:22
in a world that's failing.
380
982953
2160
16:25
Well, I look at this thing,
381
985113
1557
16:26
and I get a lot of hope.
382
986670
2687
16:29
Think about the kids today in the Arab Spring, and
383
989357
5052
16:34
you see something like this that's underway.
384
994409
2856
16:37
And imagine, just consider this idea, if you would:
385
997265
4140
16:41
What if we could connect ourselves in this world
386
1001405
3945
16:45
through a vast network of air and glass?
387
1005350
3845
16:49
Could we go beyond just sharing information and knowledge?
388
1009195
2832
16:52
Could we start to share our intelligence?
389
1012027
2509
16:54
Could we create some kind of
390
1014536
2442
16:56
collective intelligence
391
1016978
1721
16:58
that goes beyond an individual or a group or a team
392
1018699
3920
17:02
to create, perhaps, some kind of consciousness
393
1022619
4148
17:06
on a global basis?
394
1026767
1225
17:07
Well, if we could do this, we could attack some big problems in the world.
395
1027992
3673
17:11
And I look at this thing,
396
1031665
1871
17:13
and, I don't know, I get a lot of hope that maybe this
397
1033536
2915
17:16
smaller, networked, open world
398
1036451
3796
17:20
that our kids inherit might be a better one, and that
399
1040247
3104
17:23
this new age of networked intelligence could be
400
1043351
3313
17:26
an age of promise fulfilled
401
1046664
2624
17:29
and of peril unrequited.
402
1049288
3030
17:32
Let's do this. Thank you.
403
1052318
3346
17:35
(Applause)
404
1055664
9626
About this website

This site will introduce you to YouTube videos that are useful for learning English. You will see English lessons taught by top-notch teachers from around the world. Double-click on the English subtitles displayed on each video page to play the video from there. The subtitles scroll in sync with the video playback. If you have any comments or requests, please contact us using this contact form.

https://forms.gle/WvT1wiN1qDtmnspy7