What "Orwellian" really means - Noah Tavlin

3,219,428 views ・ 2015-10-01

TED-Ed


Please double-click on the English subtitles below to play the video.

00:06
If you've watched the news or followed politics
0
6342
3021
00:09
chances are you've heard the term Orwellian
1
9363
2476
00:11
thrown around in one context or another.
2
11839
2995
00:14
But have you ever stopped to think about what it really means,
3
14834
2987
00:17
or why it's used so often?
4
17821
2604
00:20
The term was named after British author Eric Blair
5
20425
3050
00:23
known by his pen name George Orwell.
6
23475
3408
00:26
Because his most famous work, the novel "1984,"
7
26883
3477
00:30
depicts an oppressive society under a totalitarian government,
8
30360
4017
00:34
"Orwellian" is often used simply to mean authoritarian.
9
34377
4527
00:38
But using the term in this way
10
38904
1904
00:40
not only fails to fully convey Orwell's message,
11
40808
3111
00:43
it actually risks doing precisely what he tried to warn against.
12
43919
6236
00:50
Orwell was indeed opposed to all forms of tyranny,
13
50155
3449
00:53
spending much of his life fighting against anti-democratic forces
14
53604
3621
00:57
of both the left-wing and the right.
15
57225
3305
01:00
But he was also deeply concerned with how such ideologies proliferate.
16
60530
5183
01:05
And one of his most profound insights
17
65713
1893
01:07
was the importance that language plays in shaping our thoughts and opinions.
18
67606
6106
01:13
The government of "1984"'s Oceania controls its people's actions and speech
19
73712
5623
01:19
in some ways that are obvious.
20
79335
3245
01:22
Their every move and word is watched and heard,
21
82580
3823
01:26
and the threat of what happens to those who step out of line
22
86403
2959
01:29
is always looming overhead.
23
89362
3851
01:33
Other forms of control are not so obvious.
24
93213
3601
01:36
The population is inundated with a constant barrage of propaganda
25
96814
3853
01:40
made up of historical facts and statistics manufactured in the Ministry of Truth.
26
100667
7266
01:47
The Ministry of Peace is the military.
27
107933
3113
01:51
Labor camps are called "Joycamps."
28
111046
2926
01:53
Political prisoners are detained and tortured in the Ministry of Love.
29
113972
5835
01:59
This deliberate irony is an example of doublespeak,
30
119807
3838
02:03
when words are used not to convey meaning but to undermine it,
31
123645
4367
02:08
corrupting the very ideas they refer to.
32
128012
4207
02:12
The regime's control of language goes even further,
33
132219
2817
02:15
eliminating words from the English language
34
135036
2094
02:17
to create the official dialect of Newspeak,
35
137130
3372
02:20
a crudely limited collection of acronyms and simple concrete nouns
36
140502
4341
02:24
lacking any words complex enough to encourage nuanced or critical thought.
37
144843
6070
02:30
This has an effect on the psyche Orwell calls, "Doublethink,"
38
150913
4231
02:35
a hypnotic state of cognitive dissonance
39
155144
2308
02:37
in which one is compelled to disregard their own perception
40
157452
3381
02:40
in place of the officially dictated version of events,
41
160833
3747
02:44
leaving the individual completely dependent
42
164580
2159
02:46
on the State's definition of reality itself.
43
166739
4158
02:50
The result is a world
44
170897
1182
02:52
in which even the privacy of one's own thought process is violated,
45
172079
4529
02:56
where one may be found guilty of thoughtcrime by talking in their sleep,
46
176608
5653
03:02
and keeping a diary or having a love affair
47
182261
2626
03:04
equals a subversive act of rebellion.
48
184887
5200
03:10
This might sound like something that can only happen in totalitarian regimes,
49
190087
5403
03:15
but Orwell was warning us about the potential for this occurring
50
195490
3468
03:18
even in democratic societies.
51
198958
3338
03:22
And this is why "authoritarian" alone does not "Orwellian" make.
52
202296
6326
03:28
In his essay, "Politics and the English Language,"
53
208622
2659
03:31
he described techniques like using pretentious words to project authority,
54
211281
4475
03:35
or making atrocities sound acceptable by burying them in euphemisms
55
215756
4141
03:39
and convoluted sentence structures.
56
219897
2951
03:42
But even more mundane abuses of language can affect the way we think about things.
57
222848
4818
03:47
The words you see and hear in everyday advertising
58
227666
3115
03:50
have been crafted to appeal to you and affect your behavior,
59
230781
5071
03:55
as have the soundbites and talking points of political campaigns
60
235852
4186
04:00
which rarely present the most nuanced perspective on the issues.
61
240038
4879
04:04
And the way that we use ready-made phrases and responses gleaned from media reports
62
244917
4908
04:09
or copied from the Internet
63
249825
2093
04:11
makes it easy to get away with not thinking too deeply
64
251918
3560
04:15
or questioning your assumptions.
65
255478
2956
04:18
So the next time you hear someone use the word Orwellian,
66
258434
2890
04:21
pay close attention.
67
261324
1828
04:23
If they're talking about the deceptive and manipulative use of language,
68
263152
3436
04:26
they're on the right track.
69
266588
2479
04:29
If they're talking about mass surveillance and intrusive government,
70
269067
3307
04:32
they're describing something authoritarian but not necessarily Orwellian.
71
272374
5767
04:38
And if they use it as an all-purpose word for any ideas they dislike,
72
278141
4207
04:42
it's possible their statements are more Orwellian
73
282348
3699
04:46
than whatever it is they're criticizing.
74
286047
4272
04:50
Words have the power to shape thought.
75
290319
1839
04:52
Language is the currency of politics,
76
292158
3817
04:55
forming the basis of society from the most common, everyday interactions
77
295975
3886
04:59
to the highest ideals.
78
299861
2956
05:02
Orwell urged us to protect our language
79
302817
2758
05:05
because ultimately our ability to think and communicate clearly
80
305575
3730
05:09
is what stands between us and a world where war is peace
81
309305
4076
05:13
and freedom is slavery.
82
313381
2538
About this website

This site will introduce you to YouTube videos that are useful for learning English. You will see English lessons taught by top-notch teachers from around the world. Double-click on the English subtitles displayed on each video page to play the video from there. The subtitles scroll in sync with the video playback. If you have any comments or requests, please contact us using this contact form.

https://forms.gle/WvT1wiN1qDtmnspy7