The data behind Hollywood's sexism | Stacy Smith

121,960 views ・ 2017-03-21

TED


Please double-click on the English subtitles below to play the video.

00:12
Today, I want to tell you about a pressing social issue.
0
12700
3816
00:16
Now, it's not nuclear arms,
1
16540
2336
00:18
it's not immigration,
2
18900
1576
00:20
and it's not malaria.
3
20500
1936
00:22
I'm here to talk about movies.
4
22460
3456
00:25
Now, in all seriousness, movies are actually really important.
5
25940
3560
00:30
In film, we can be wildly entertained,
6
30300
4176
00:34
and we can also be transported through storytelling.
7
34500
4320
00:39
Storytelling is so important.
8
39300
1816
00:41
Stories tell us what societies value,
9
41140
3536
00:44
they offer us lessons,
10
44700
1976
00:46
and they share and preserve our history.
11
46700
3176
00:49
Stories are amazing.
12
49900
1600
00:52
But stories don't give everyone
13
52260
2936
00:55
the same opportunity to appear within them,
14
55220
4456
00:59
particularly not stories
15
59700
2456
01:02
compartmentalized in the form of American movies.
16
62180
4136
01:06
In film, interestingly enough,
17
66340
2296
01:08
females are still erased and marginalized
18
68660
3576
01:12
in a lot of our stories.
19
72260
2056
01:14
And I learned this for the first time about 10 years ago
20
74340
2856
01:17
when I did my first study on gender role in G-rated films.
21
77220
3776
01:21
Since then, we've conducted more than 30 investigations.
22
81020
3576
01:24
My team is tired.
23
84620
1856
01:26
And I've committed my life
24
86500
3376
01:29
as researcher and activist
25
89900
2496
01:32
to fighting the inclusion crisis
26
92420
2696
01:35
in Hollywood.
27
95140
1856
01:37
So today, what I'd like to do is tell you about that crisis.
28
97020
3496
01:40
I want to talk about gender inequality in film.
29
100540
2576
01:43
I want to tell you how it is perpetuated,
30
103140
2376
01:45
and then I'm going to tell you how we're going to fix it.
31
105540
4016
01:49
However, one caveat before I begin:
32
109580
3816
01:53
my data are really depressing.
33
113420
3336
01:56
So I want to apologize in advance,
34
116780
2056
01:58
because I'm going to put you all in a really bad mood.
35
118860
3136
02:02
But I'm going to bring it up at the end,
36
122020
3376
02:05
and I'm going to present a silver lining
37
125420
2856
02:08
to fix this mess that we've been in
38
128300
2376
02:10
for a very, very long time.
39
130700
2576
02:13
So, let's start with the gravity of the situation.
40
133300
3936
02:17
Each year, my research team examines the top 100 grossing films
41
137260
3616
02:20
in the United States.
42
140900
1616
02:22
What we do is we look at every speaking or named character on-screen.
43
142540
4216
02:26
Now, to count in one of my investigations,
44
146780
2936
02:29
all a character has to do is say one word.
45
149740
4176
02:33
This is a very low bar.
46
153940
2576
02:36
(Laughter)
47
156540
1456
02:38
Thus far, we've looked at 800 movies,
48
158020
2416
02:40
from 2007 to 2015,
49
160460
2016
02:42
cataloguing every speaking character on-screen for gender, race, ethnicity,
50
162500
4856
02:47
LGBT and characters with a disability.
51
167380
3360
02:51
Let's take a look at really some problematic trends.
52
171740
3856
02:55
First, females are still noticeably absent on-screen in film.
53
175620
4576
03:00
Across 800 movies and 35,205 speaking characters,
54
180220
4336
03:04
less than a third of all roles go to girls and women.
55
184580
3696
03:08
Less than a third!
56
188300
1296
03:09
There's been no change from 2007 to 2015,
57
189620
3456
03:13
and if you compare our results
58
193100
1429
03:14
to a small sample of films from 1946 to 1955,
59
194553
4643
03:19
there's been no change in over a half of a century.
60
199220
4296
03:23
Over half of a century!
61
203540
1376
03:24
But we're half of the population.
62
204940
2616
03:27
Now, if we look at this data intersectionally,
63
207580
2816
03:30
which has been a focus of today,
64
210420
2136
03:32
the picture becomes even more problematic.
65
212580
3096
03:35
Across the top 100 films of just last year,
66
215700
3016
03:38
48 films didn't feature one black or African-American speaking character,
67
218740
4296
03:43
not one.
68
223060
1256
03:44
70 films were devoid of Asian or Asian-American speaking characters
69
224340
4216
03:48
that were girls or women.
70
228580
1416
03:50
None.
71
230020
1616
03:51
Eighty-four films didn't feature one female character that had a disability.
72
231660
4376
03:56
And 93 were devoid of lesbian, bisexual or transgender female speaking characters.
73
236060
6576
04:02
This is not underrepresentation.
74
242660
3176
04:05
This is erasure,
75
245860
1896
04:07
and I call this the epidemic of invisibility.
76
247780
4816
04:12
Now, when we move from prevalence to protagonist,
77
252620
3696
04:16
the story is still problematic.
78
256340
2456
04:18
Out of a hundred films last year,
79
258820
1616
04:20
only 32 featured a female lead or colead driving the action.
80
260460
4616
04:25
Only three out of a hundred films
81
265100
2136
04:27
featured an underrepresented female driving the story,
82
267260
3776
04:31
and only one diverse woman
83
271060
2296
04:33
that was 45 years of age or older at the time of theatrical release.
84
273380
4736
04:38
Now let's look at portrayal.
85
278140
1480
04:40
In addition to the numbers you just saw,
86
280740
1936
04:42
females are far more likely to be sexualized in film
87
282700
3616
04:46
than their male counterparts.
88
286340
1736
04:48
Matter of fact, they're about three times as likely
89
288100
2416
04:50
to be shown in sexually revealing clothing,
90
290540
2016
04:52
partially naked,
91
292580
1216
04:53
and they're far more likely to be thin.
92
293820
2576
04:56
Now, sometimes, in animation, females are so thin
93
296420
3736
05:00
that their waist size approximates the circumference of their upper arm.
94
300180
4656
05:04
(Laughter)
95
304860
1656
05:06
We like to say that these gals have no room for a womb
96
306540
3416
05:09
or any other internal organ.
97
309980
2576
05:12
(Laughter)
98
312580
2016
05:14
Now, all joking aside,
99
314620
1576
05:16
theories suggest, research confirms,
100
316220
1936
05:18
exposure to thin ideals and objectifying content
101
318180
2376
05:20
can lead to body dissatisfaction, internalization of the thin ideal
102
320580
3816
05:24
and self-objectification among some female viewers.
103
324420
4416
05:28
Obviously, what we see on-screen
104
328860
1976
05:30
and what we see in the world,
105
330860
1976
05:32
they do not match.
106
332860
1736
05:34
They do not match!
107
334620
1256
05:35
Matter of fact, if we lived in the screen world,
108
335900
2256
05:38
we would have a population crisis on our hands.
109
338180
3600
05:42
So, as soon as I recognized these patterns,
110
342620
2056
05:44
I wanted to find out why,
111
344700
1256
05:45
and it turns out that there are two drivers to inequality on-screen:
112
345980
3896
05:49
content creator gender and misperceptions of the audience.
113
349900
3096
05:53
Let's unpack them really quick.
114
353020
1736
05:54
If you want to change any of the patterns I just talked about,
115
354780
2936
05:57
all you have to do is hire female directors.
116
357740
2456
06:00
Turns out, the female directors
117
360220
2016
06:02
are associated with, in terms of short films and indie films,
118
362260
4496
06:06
more girls and women on-screen,
119
366780
1816
06:08
more stories with women in the center,
120
368620
2616
06:11
more stories with women 40 years of age or older on-screen,
121
371260
4536
06:15
which I think is good news for this crowd.
122
375820
2896
06:18
More underrepresented --
123
378740
1936
06:20
(Laughter)
124
380700
1336
06:22
Sorry.
125
382060
1216
06:23
(Laughter)
126
383300
1776
06:25
Sorry but not sorry.
127
385100
1256
06:26
More underrepresented characters in terms of race and ethnicity,
128
386380
3656
06:30
and most importantly,
129
390060
1296
06:31
more women working behind the camera
130
391380
2376
06:33
in key production roles.
131
393780
2096
06:35
Easy answer to the problems that we just talked about.
132
395900
3736
06:39
Or is it?
133
399660
1216
06:40
It's actually not.
134
400900
1776
06:42
800 films, 2007-2015,
135
402700
3256
06:45
886 directors.
136
405980
1576
06:47
Only 4.1 percent are women.
137
407580
3616
06:51
Only three are African-American or black,
138
411220
2896
06:54
and only one woman was Asian.
139
414140
2480
06:57
So why is it so difficult
140
417340
3496
07:00
to have female directors
141
420860
1776
07:02
if they're part of the solution?
142
422660
2656
07:05
Well, to answer this question,
143
425340
1776
07:07
we conducted a study.
144
427140
1200
07:08
We interviewed dozens of industry insiders
145
428940
2296
07:11
and asked them about directors.
146
431260
2416
07:13
Turns out, both male and female executives,
147
433700
3816
07:17
when they think director,
148
437540
1656
07:19
they think male.
149
439220
1576
07:20
They perceive the traits of leadership
150
440820
2856
07:23
to be masculine in nature.
151
443700
2256
07:25
So when they're going to hire a director
152
445980
3176
07:29
to command a crew, lead a ship,
153
449180
2296
07:31
be a visionary or be General Patton,
154
451500
2376
07:33
all the things that we've heard --
155
453900
2256
07:36
their thoughts and ideations pull male.
156
456180
3000
07:39
The perception of director or a leader
157
459660
2456
07:42
is inconsistent with the perception of a woman.
158
462140
3656
07:45
The roles are incongruous,
159
465820
2016
07:47
which is consistent with a lot of research in the psychological arena.
160
467860
4136
07:52
Second factor contributing to inequality on-screen
161
472020
3136
07:55
is misperceptions of the audience.
162
475180
2576
07:57
I don't need to tell this crowd:
163
477780
1656
07:59
50 percent of the people that go to the box office and buy tickets
164
479460
3256
08:02
are girls and women in this country.
165
482740
1976
08:04
Right?
166
484740
1216
08:05
But we're not perceived to be a viable or financially lucrative target audience.
167
485980
5336
08:11
Further, there's some misperceptions
168
491340
2216
08:13
about whether females can open a film.
169
493580
3096
08:16
Open a film means that if you place a female at the center,
170
496700
2856
08:19
it doesn't have the return on investment
171
499580
1936
08:21
that if you place a male at the center of a story does.
172
501540
2960
08:25
This misperception is actually costly.
173
505260
3656
08:28
Right?
174
508940
1216
08:30
Especially in the wake of franchise successes
175
510180
2296
08:32
like "The Hunger Games,"
176
512500
2096
08:34
"Pitch Perfect"
177
514620
1216
08:35
or that small little indie film, "Star Wars: The Force Awakens."
178
515860
4680
08:41
Our own economic analyses show that gender of the lead character
179
521660
3376
08:45
doesn't play a role in economic success in the United States.
180
525060
3496
08:48
But what does?
181
528580
1296
08:49
Production costs alone
182
529900
1856
08:51
or in conjunction with how widely a film is distributed in this country.
183
531780
5600
08:58
It's not the gender of the lead character.
184
538220
2080
09:00
So at this point, we should all be sufficiently depressed.
185
540780
4376
09:05
No change in 50 years,
186
545180
1536
09:06
few female directors working behind the camera
187
546740
2376
09:09
and the entertainment industry does not trust us as an audience.
188
549140
4040
09:14
Well, I told you there would be a silver lining,
189
554060
2376
09:16
and there is.
190
556460
1200
09:18
There are actually simple and tangible solutions
191
558500
3296
09:21
to fixing this problem
192
561820
1536
09:23
that involve content creators,
193
563380
1616
09:25
executives and consumers
194
565020
2216
09:27
like the individuals in this room.
195
567260
2336
09:29
Let's talk about a few of them.
196
569620
1896
09:31
The first is what I call "just add five."
197
571540
2456
09:34
Did you know if we looked at the top 100 films next year
198
574020
3056
09:37
and simply added five female speaking characters on-screen
199
577100
3216
09:40
to each of those films,
200
580340
1416
09:41
it would create a new norm.
201
581780
1616
09:43
If we were to do this for three contiguous years,
202
583420
2776
09:46
we would be at gender parity
203
586220
2016
09:48
for the first time in over a half of a century.
204
588260
4560
09:53
Now, this approach is advantageous for a variety of reasons.
205
593460
3256
09:56
One? It doesn't take away jobs for male actors.
206
596740
3936
10:00
Heaven forbid.
207
600700
1336
10:02
(Laughter)
208
602060
2416
10:04
Two, it's actually cost-effective. It doesn't cost that much.
209
604500
3936
10:08
Three, it builds a pipeline for talent.
210
608460
1896
10:10
And four, it humanizes the production process.
211
610380
2616
10:13
Why? Because it makes sure that there's women on set.
212
613020
3760
10:17
Second solution is for A-list talent.
213
617180
2800
10:20
A-listers, as we all know, can make demands in their contracts,
214
620620
3576
10:24
particularly the ones that work on the biggest Hollywood films.
215
624220
3696
10:27
What if those A-listers
216
627940
1736
10:29
simply added an equity clause or an inclusion rider
217
629700
4096
10:33
into their contract?
218
633820
2056
10:35
Now, what does that mean?
219
635900
1936
10:37
Well, you probably don't know
220
637860
1696
10:39
but the typical feature film
221
639580
1336
10:40
has about 40 to 45 speaking characters in it.
222
640940
2680
10:44
I would argue that only 8 to 10 of those characters
223
644340
3416
10:47
are actually relevant to the story.
224
647780
3016
10:50
Except maybe "Avengers." Right?
225
650820
2016
10:52
A few more in "Avengers."
226
652860
1680
10:55
The remaining 30 or so roles,
227
655500
2376
10:57
there's no reason why those minor roles
228
657900
2416
11:00
can't match or reflect the demography
229
660340
2896
11:03
of where the story is taking place.
230
663260
3200
11:06
An equity rider by an A-lister in their contract
231
666940
3576
11:10
can stipulate that those roles
232
670540
2416
11:12
reflect the world in which we actually live.
233
672980
3296
11:16
Now, there's no reason why a network,
234
676300
2536
11:18
a studio or a production company
235
678860
2176
11:21
cannot adopt the same contractual language
236
681060
3616
11:24
in their negotiation processes.
237
684700
2816
11:27
Third solution:
238
687540
1656
11:29
this would be for the entertainment industry,
239
689220
2336
11:31
Hollywood in particular,
240
691580
1216
11:32
to adopt the Rooney Rule
241
692820
2936
11:35
when it comes to hiring practices around directors.
242
695780
3656
11:39
Now, in the NFL, the Rooney Rule stipulates
243
699460
2616
11:42
that if a team wants to hire a coach from outside the organization,
244
702100
3856
11:45
what they have to do is interview an underrepresented candidate.
245
705980
3936
11:49
The exact same principle can apply to Hollywood films.
246
709940
4096
11:54
How?
247
714060
1216
11:55
Well, on these top films,
248
715300
1456
11:56
executives and agents can make sure
249
716780
3456
12:00
that women and people of color are not only on the consideration list,
250
720260
5216
12:05
but they're actually interviewed for the job.
251
725500
3376
12:08
Now, one might say,
252
728900
1496
12:10
why is this important?
253
730420
1416
12:11
Because it exposes or introduces executives to female directors
254
731860
5216
12:17
who otherwise fall prey to exclusionary hiring practices.
255
737100
4440
12:22
The fourth solution
256
742260
1456
12:23
is for consumers like me and you.
257
743740
2240
12:27
If we want to see more films by, for and about women,
258
747100
2976
12:30
we have to support them.
259
750100
1680
12:32
It may mean going to the independent theater chain
260
752300
2496
12:34
instead of the multiplex.
261
754820
1936
12:36
Or it might mean scrolling down a little further online
262
756780
3496
12:40
to find a film by a female director.
263
760300
2576
12:42
Or it may be writing a check and funding a film,
264
762900
2856
12:45
particularly by a female director from an underrepresented background.
265
765780
4496
12:50
Right?
266
770300
1216
12:51
We need to write, call and email companies
267
771540
2656
12:54
that are making and distributing films,
268
774220
1858
12:56
and we need to post on our social media accounts
269
776102
2894
12:59
when we want to see inclusive representation,
270
779020
3096
13:02
women on-screen,
271
782140
1256
13:03
and most importantly, women behind the camera.
272
783420
3360
13:07
We need to make our voices heard and our dollars count.
273
787340
5080
13:13
Now, we actually have the ability to change the world on this one.
274
793220
5560
13:19
The US and its content,
275
799460
2456
13:21
films in particular,
276
801940
1496
13:23
have captured the imaginations of audiences worldwide.
277
803460
5016
13:28
Worldwide.
278
808500
1200
13:30
So that means that the film industry has unprecedented access
279
810660
4376
13:35
to be able to distribute stories about equality
280
815060
5016
13:40
all around the world.
281
820100
2216
13:42
Imagine what would happen
282
822340
1896
13:44
if the film industry aligned its values
283
824260
3536
13:47
with what it shows on-screen.
284
827820
1720
13:50
It could foster inclusion
285
830100
2096
13:52
and acceptance for girls and women,
286
832220
3256
13:55
people of color,
287
835500
1496
13:57
the LGBT community,
288
837020
1856
13:58
individuals with disabilities,
289
838900
1776
14:00
and so many more around the world.
290
840700
3920
14:05
The only thing that the film industry has to do is unleash its secret weapon,
291
845340
6536
14:11
and that's storytelling.
292
851900
2280
14:15
Now, at the beginning of this talk,
293
855140
2376
14:17
I said that films --
294
857540
2416
14:19
that they can actually transport us,
295
859980
2536
14:22
but I would like to argue that films, they can transform us.
296
862540
5360
14:28
None of us in this room
297
868580
1896
14:30
have grown up or experienced a storytelling landscape
298
870500
4256
14:34
with fully realized female characters,
299
874780
3496
14:38
none of us,
300
878300
1496
14:39
because the numbers haven't changed.
301
879820
2736
14:42
What would happen if the next generation of audiences
302
882580
4096
14:46
grew up with a whole different screen reality?
303
886700
4376
14:51
What would happen?
304
891100
1256
14:52
Well I'm here to tell you today
305
892380
1976
14:54
that it's not only possible to change what we see on-screen
306
894380
4056
14:58
but I am impatient for it to get here.
307
898460
4080
15:03
So let's agree to take action today
308
903220
4296
15:07
to eradicate the epidemic of invisibility.
309
907540
3600
15:11
And let's agree to take action today
310
911780
2296
15:14
to agree that US audiences and global viewers
311
914100
4416
15:18
demand and deserve more.
312
918540
3136
15:21
And let's agree today
313
921700
2576
15:24
that the next generation of viewers and audiences,
314
924300
5176
15:29
that they deserve to see the stories
315
929500
3176
15:32
we were never able to see.
316
932700
3136
15:35
Thank you.
317
935860
1216
15:37
(Applause)
318
937100
5724
About this website

This site will introduce you to YouTube videos that are useful for learning English. You will see English lessons taught by top-notch teachers from around the world. Double-click on the English subtitles displayed on each video page to play the video from there. The subtitles scroll in sync with the video playback. If you have any comments or requests, please contact us using this contact form.

https://forms.gle/WvT1wiN1qDtmnspy7