Why language is humanity's greatest invention | David Peterson

92,398 views ・ 2019-10-25

TED


Please double-click on the English subtitles below to play the video.

00:13
Spoons.
0
13659
1150
00:16
Cardboard boxes.
1
16944
1382
00:19
Toddler-size electric trains.
2
19302
2420
00:22
Holiday ornaments.
3
22522
1332
00:24
Bounce houses.
4
24442
1390
00:26
Blankets.
5
26292
1285
00:27
Baskets.
6
27601
1150
00:29
Carpets.
7
29228
1246
00:30
Tray tables.
8
30498
1151
00:31
Smartphones.
9
31673
1404
00:33
Pianos.
10
33101
1280
00:35
Robes.
11
35284
1314
00:36
Photographs.
12
36622
1150
00:38
What do all of these things have in common,
13
38415
2032
00:40
aside from the fact they're photos that I took in the last three months,
14
40471
3433
00:43
and therefore, own the copyright to?
15
43928
1842
00:45
(Laughter)
16
45794
1505
00:47
They're all inventions
17
47323
1532
00:48
that were created with the benefit of language.
18
48879
3650
00:52
None of these things would have existed without language.
19
52553
2696
00:55
Imagine creating any one of those things
20
55273
1960
00:57
or, like, building an entire building like this,
21
57257
2746
01:00
without being able to use language
22
60027
2356
01:02
or without benefiting from any knowledge that was got by the use of language.
23
62407
4542
01:06
Basically, language is the most important thing
24
66973
4048
01:11
in the entire world.
25
71045
1174
01:12
All of our civilization rests upon it.
26
72243
3041
01:15
And those who devote their lives to studying it --
27
75308
2452
01:17
both how language emerged, how human languages differ,
28
77784
4992
01:22
how they differ from animal communication systems --
29
82800
2510
01:25
are linguists.
30
85334
1150
01:27
Formal linguistics is a relatively young field, more or less.
31
87141
4979
01:33
And it's uncovered a lot of really important stuff.
32
93099
2397
01:35
Like, for example, that human communication systems
33
95520
2532
01:38
differ crucially from animal communication systems,
34
98076
2761
01:40
that all languages are equally expressive,
35
100861
2661
01:43
even if they do it in different ways.
36
103546
2039
01:45
And yet, despite this,
37
105998
3274
01:49
there are a lot of people who just love to pop off about language
38
109296
4622
01:53
like they have an equal understanding of it as a linguist,
39
113942
3619
01:57
because, of course, they speak a language.
40
117585
2032
01:59
And if you speak a language, that means you have just as much right
41
119641
3172
02:02
to talk about its function as anybody else.
42
122837
2093
02:04
Imagine if you were talking to a surgeon,
43
124954
1992
02:06
and you say, "Listen, buddy.
44
126970
1504
02:08
I've had a heart for, like, 40 years now.
45
128498
1968
02:10
I think I know a thing or two about aortic valve replacements.
46
130490
2950
02:13
I think my opinion is just as valid as yours."
47
133464
2215
02:15
And yet, that's exactly what happens.
48
135703
1795
02:17
This is Neil deGrasse Tyson, saying that in the film "Arrival,"
49
137522
4427
02:21
he would have brought a cryptographer --
50
141973
2151
02:24
somebody who can unscramble a message in a language they already know --
51
144148
3818
02:27
rather than a linguist,
52
147990
1278
02:29
to communicate with the aliens,
53
149292
1634
02:30
because what would a linguist --
54
150950
2111
02:33
why would that be useful in talking to somebody
55
153085
2214
02:35
speaking a language we don't even know?
56
155323
1906
02:37
Though, of course, the "Arrival" film is not off the hook.
57
157253
2737
02:40
I mean, come on -- listen, film. Hey, buddy:
58
160014
2063
02:42
there are aliens that come down to our planet in gigantic ships,
59
162101
3040
02:45
and they want to do nothing except for communicate with us,
60
165165
3786
02:48
and you hire one linguist?
61
168975
2275
02:51
(Laughter)
62
171274
1010
02:52
What's the US government on a budget or something?
63
172308
2344
02:55
(Laughter)
64
175029
1588
02:56
A lot of these things can be chalked up to misunderstandings,
65
176641
2904
02:59
both about what language is and about the formal study of language,
66
179569
3476
03:03
about linguistics.
67
183069
1311
03:05
And I think there's something that underlies a lot of these misunderstandings
68
185568
4428
03:10
that can be summed up by this delightful article in "Forbes,"
69
190020
4539
03:14
about why high school students shouldn't learn foreign languages.
70
194583
3695
03:18
I'm going to pull out some quotes from this,
71
198302
2133
03:20
and I want you to see if you can figure out
72
200459
2058
03:22
what underlies some of these opinions and ideas.
73
202541
3630
03:26
"Americans rarely read the classics, even in translation."
74
206929
4083
03:31
So in other words, why bother learning a foreign language
75
211036
2701
03:33
when they're not even going to read the classic in the original anyway?
76
213761
3442
03:37
What's the point?
77
217227
1184
03:38
"Studying foreign languages in school is a waste of time,
78
218435
2778
03:41
compared to other things that you could be doing in school."
79
221237
3660
03:45
"Europe has a lot of language groups clustered in a relatively small space."
80
225887
3912
03:49
So for Americans, ah, what's the point of learning another language?
81
229823
3509
03:53
You're not really going to get a lot of bang for your buck out of that.
82
233356
3356
03:56
This is my favorite,
83
236736
1159
03:57
"A student in Birmingham would have to travel
84
237919
2143
04:00
about a thousand miles to get to the Mexican border,
85
240086
2486
04:02
and even then, there would be enough people who speak English to get around."
86
242596
4008
04:06
In other words, if you can kind of wave your arms around,
87
246628
2699
04:09
and you can get to where you're going,
88
249351
1820
04:11
then there's really no point in learning another language anyway.
89
251195
3056
04:14
What underlies a lot of these attitudes is the conceptual metaphor,
90
254275
5032
04:19
language is a tool.
91
259331
1563
04:20
And there's something that rings very true about this metaphor.
92
260918
2960
04:23
Language is kind of a tool
93
263902
1247
04:25
in that, if you know the local language, you can do more than if you didn't.
94
265173
3604
04:28
But the implication is that language is only a tool,
95
268801
3000
04:31
and this is absolutely false.
96
271825
1992
04:33
If language was a tool, it would honestly be a pretty poor tool.
97
273841
3301
04:37
And we would have abandoned it long ago for something that was a lot better.
98
277166
3610
04:40
Think about just any sentence.
99
280800
1532
04:42
Here's a sentence that I'm sure I've said in my life: "Yesterday I saw Kyn."
100
282356
3639
04:46
I have a friend named Kyn.
101
286019
1249
04:47
And when I say this sentence, "Yesterday I saw Kyn,"
102
287292
2784
04:50
do you think it's really the case
103
290100
1726
04:51
that everything in my mind is now implanted in your mind
104
291850
3222
04:55
via this sentence?
105
295096
1182
04:56
Hardly, because there's a lot of other stuff going on.
106
296302
2537
04:58
Like, when I say "yesterday,"
107
298863
1388
05:00
I might think what the weather was like yesterday because I was there.
108
300275
3309
05:03
And if I'm remembering,
109
303608
1150
05:04
I'll probably remember there was something I forgot to mail, which I did.
110
304782
3444
05:08
This was a preplanned joke, but I really did forget to mail something.
111
308250
3316
05:11
And so that means I'm going to have to do it Monday,
112
311590
2850
05:14
because that's when I'm going to get back home.
113
314464
2193
05:16
And of course, when I think of Monday,
114
316681
1820
05:18
I'll think of "Manic Monday" by the Bangles. It's a good song.
115
318525
2946
05:21
And when I say the word "saw," I think of this phrase:
116
321495
3257
05:24
"'I see!' said the blind man as he picked up his hammer and saw."
117
324776
3087
05:27
I always do.
118
327887
1151
05:29
Anytime I hear the word "saw" or say it, I always think of that,
119
329062
3071
05:32
because my grandfather always used to say it,
120
332157
2097
05:34
so it makes me think of my grandfather.
121
334278
1871
05:36
And we're back to "Manic Monday" again, for some reason.
122
336173
2641
05:38
And with Kyn, when I'm saying something like, "Yesterday I saw Kyn,"
123
338838
3262
05:42
I'll think of the circumstances under which I saw him.
124
342124
3103
05:45
And this happened to be that day. Here he is with my cat.
125
345251
2779
05:48
And of course, if I'm thinking of Kyn,
126
348054
1825
05:49
I'll think he's going to Long Beach State right now,
127
349903
2468
05:52
and I'll remember that my good friend John and my mother
128
352395
2637
05:55
both graduated from Long Beach State,
129
355056
1774
05:56
my cousin Katie is going to Long Beach State right now.
130
356854
2844
05:59
And it's "Manic Monday" again.
131
359722
1434
06:01
But this is just a fraction of what's going on in your head
132
361180
2782
06:03
at any given time while you are speaking.
133
363986
2292
06:06
And all we have to represent the entire mess
134
366302
2595
06:08
that is going on in our head, is this.
135
368921
2894
06:11
I mean, that's all we got.
136
371839
1302
06:13
(Laughter)
137
373165
1164
06:14
Is it any wonder that our system is so poor?
138
374353
2605
06:16
So imagine, if I can give you an analogy,
139
376982
2478
06:19
imagine if you wanted to know what is it like to eat a cake,
140
379484
3142
06:22
if instead of just eating the cake,
141
382650
2356
06:25
you instead had to ingest the ingredients of a cake,
142
385030
3222
06:28
one by one,
143
388276
1531
06:29
along with instructions
144
389831
1512
06:31
about how these ingredients can be combined to form a cake.
145
391367
3385
06:34
You had to eat the instructions, too.
146
394776
1904
06:36
(Laughter)
147
396704
1064
06:37
If that was how we had to experience cake,
148
397792
2059
06:39
we would never eat cake.
149
399875
1511
06:42
And yet, language is the only way -- the only way --
150
402485
3560
06:46
that we can figure out what is going on here, in our minds.
151
406069
4194
06:50
This is our interiority,
152
410287
1854
06:52
the thing that makes us human,
153
412165
1444
06:53
the thing that makes us different from other animals,
154
413633
3238
06:56
is all inside here somewhere,
155
416895
1833
06:58
and all we have to do to represent it is our own languages.
156
418752
3944
07:02
A language is our best way of showing what's going on in our head.
157
422720
3115
07:05
Imagine if I wanted to ask a big question, like:
158
425859
2251
07:08
"What is the nature of human thought and emotion?"
159
428134
2333
07:10
What you'd want to do
160
430491
1090
07:11
is you'd want to examine as many different languages
161
431605
3163
07:14
as possible.
162
434792
1595
07:16
One isn't just going to do it.
163
436411
2015
07:18
To give you an example,
164
438450
1362
07:19
here's a picture I took of little Roman,
165
439836
2849
07:22
that I took with a 12-megapixel camera.
166
442709
2979
07:25
Now, here's that same picture with a lot fewer pixels.
167
445712
3432
07:29
Obviously, neither of these pictures is a real cat.
168
449168
3883
07:33
But one gives you a lot better sense of what a cat is than the other.
169
453075
3634
07:38
Language is not merely a tool.
170
458649
1984
07:40
It is our legacy,
171
460657
1159
07:41
it's our way of conveying what it means to be human.
172
461840
2442
07:44
And of course, by "our" legacy, I mean all humans everywhere.
173
464306
4391
07:48
And losing even one language makes that picture a lot less clear.
174
468721
5065
07:53
So as a job for the past 10 years
175
473810
4045
07:57
and also as recreation, just for fun,
176
477879
3285
08:01
I create languages.
177
481188
1711
08:02
These are called "conlangs,"
178
482923
1860
08:04
short for "constructed languages."
179
484807
2135
08:06
Now, presenting these facts back to back,
180
486966
2079
08:09
that we're losing languages on our planet
181
489069
1978
08:11
and that I create brand-new languages,
182
491071
1819
08:12
you might think that there's some nonsuperficial connection
183
492914
2782
08:15
between these two.
184
495720
1166
08:16
In fact, a lot of people have drawn a line between those dots.
185
496910
2916
08:19
This is a guy who got all bent out of shape
186
499850
2027
08:21
that there was a conlang in James Cameron's "Avatar."
187
501901
2814
08:24
He says,
188
504739
1707
08:26
"But in the three years it took James Cameron
189
506470
2222
08:28
to get Avatar to the screen, a language died."
190
508716
2253
08:30
Probably a lot more than that, actually.
191
510993
1928
08:32
"Na'vi, alas, won't fill the hole where it used to be ..."
192
512945
3444
08:36
A truly profound and poignant statement --
193
516413
2312
08:38
if you don't think about it at all.
194
518749
2617
08:41
(Laughter)
195
521390
1155
08:42
But when I was here at Cal,
196
522569
2043
08:44
I completed two majors.
197
524636
1379
08:46
One of them was linguistics, but the other one was English.
198
526039
2801
08:48
And of course, the English major, the study of English,
199
528864
2588
08:51
is not actually the study of the English language, as we know,
200
531476
2962
08:54
it's the study of literature.
201
534462
1395
08:55
Literature is just a wonderful thing,
202
535881
1797
08:57
because basically, literature, more broadly, is kind of like art;
203
537702
3791
09:01
it falls under the rubric of art.
204
541517
1663
09:03
And what we do with literature,
205
543204
1548
09:04
authors create new, entire beings and histories.
206
544776
5079
09:09
And it's interesting to us to see
207
549879
3016
09:12
what kind of depth and emotion and just unique spirit
208
552919
5087
09:18
authors can invest into these fictional beings.
209
558030
2608
09:20
So much so, that, I mean -- take a look at this.
210
560662
2621
09:23
There's an entire series of books
211
563307
2254
09:25
that are written about fictional characters.
212
565585
2239
09:27
Like, the entire book is just about one fictional, fake human being.
213
567848
3967
09:31
There's an entire book on George F. Babbitt
214
571839
2171
09:34
from Sinclair Lewis's "Babbitt,"
215
574034
1837
09:35
and I guarantee you, that book is longer than "Babbitt,"
216
575895
2667
09:38
which is a short book.
217
578586
1198
09:39
Does anybody even remember that one?
218
579808
1739
09:41
It's pretty good, I actually think it's better than "Main Street."
219
581571
3191
09:44
That's my hot take.
220
584786
1370
09:46
So we've never questioned the fact that literature is interesting.
221
586180
3709
09:50
But despite the fact,
222
590434
1555
09:52
not even linguists are actually interested in what created languages can tell us
223
592013
4064
09:56
about the depth of the human spirit just as an artistic endeavor.
224
596101
3867
10:00
I'll give you a nice little example here.
225
600520
2877
10:03
There was an article written about me
226
603421
2723
10:06
in the California alumni magazine a while back.
227
606168
2840
10:09
And when they wrote this article,
228
609032
1601
10:10
they wanted to get somebody from the opposing side,
229
610657
2420
10:13
which, in hindsight, seems like a weird thing to do.
230
613101
2460
10:15
You're just talking about a person,
231
615585
1690
10:17
and you want to get somebody from the opposing side of that person.
232
617299
3143
10:20
(Laughter)
233
620466
1276
10:21
Essentially, this is just a puff piece, but whatever.
234
621766
2659
10:24
So, they happened to get
235
624449
2523
10:26
one of the most brilliant linguists of our time,
236
626996
2325
10:29
George Lakoff, who's a linguist here at Berkeley.
237
629345
3026
10:32
And his work has basically forever changed the fields of linguistics
238
632395
3562
10:35
and cognitive science.
239
635981
1477
10:37
And when asked about my work and about language creation in general,
240
637482
3275
10:40
he said, "But there's a lot of things to be done in the study of language.
241
640781
3645
10:44
You should spend the time on something real."
242
644450
2756
10:47
Yeah.
243
647230
1151
10:48
"Something real." Does this remind you of anything?
244
648405
2459
10:50
To use the very framework that he himself invented,
245
650888
3739
10:54
let me refer back to this conceptual metaphor:
246
654651
2695
10:57
language is a tool.
247
657370
1268
10:58
And he appears to be laboring under this conceptual metaphor;
248
658662
3431
11:02
that is, language is useful when it can be used for communication.
249
662117
4067
11:06
Language is useless when it can't be used for communication.
250
666208
3298
11:09
It might make you wonder: What do we do with dead languages?
251
669530
2842
11:12
But anyway.
252
672396
1216
11:13
So, because of this idea,
253
673636
1407
11:15
it might seem like the very height of absurdity
254
675067
3862
11:18
to have a Duolingo course on the High Valyrian language
255
678953
3413
11:22
that I created for HBO's "Game of Thrones."
256
682390
2548
11:24
You might wonder what, exactly, are 740,000 people learning?
257
684962
3624
11:29
(Laughter)
258
689368
2262
11:31
Well, let's take a look at it.
259
691654
2063
11:33
What are they learning?
260
693741
1635
11:35
What could they possibly be learning?
261
695400
2360
11:37
Well, bearing in mind that the other language for this --
262
697784
2799
11:40
it's for people that speak English --
263
700607
2534
11:43
English speakers are learning quite a bit.
264
703165
2055
11:45
Here's a sentence that they will probably never use for communication
265
705244
3314
11:48
in their entire lives:
266
708582
1164
11:49
"Vala ābre urnes."
267
709770
1566
11:51
"The man sees the woman."
268
711360
1373
11:52
The little middle line is the gloss,
269
712757
1890
11:54
so it's word for word, that's what it says.
270
714671
2216
11:56
And they're actually learning some very fascinating things,
271
716911
2789
11:59
especially if they're English speakers.
272
719724
1876
12:01
They're learning that a verb can come at the very end of a sentence.
273
721624
3230
12:04
Doesn't really do that in English when you have two arguments.
274
724878
2968
12:07
They're learning that sometimes
275
727870
1738
12:09
a language doesn't have an equivalent for the word "the" -- it's totally absent.
276
729632
3858
12:13
That's something language can do.
277
733514
1619
12:15
They're learning that a long vowel can actually be longer in duration,
278
735157
3785
12:18
as opposed to different in quality,
279
738966
1961
12:20
which is what our long vowels do; they're actually the same length.
280
740951
3182
12:24
They're learning that there are these little inflections.
281
744157
3500
12:27
Hmm? Hmm?
282
747681
1155
12:28
There are inflections called "cases" on the end of nouns --
283
748860
3312
12:32
(Laughter)
284
752196
1016
12:33
that tell you who does what to whom in a sentence.
285
753236
3301
12:36
Even if you leave the order of the words the same
286
756561
3027
12:39
and switch the endings,
287
759612
1722
12:41
it changes who does what to whom.
288
761358
2992
12:44
What they're learning is that languages do things, the same things, differently.
289
764374
5764
12:50
And that learning languages can be fun.
290
770513
2332
12:53
What they're learning is respect for Language: capital "L" Language.
291
773997
3770
12:57
And given the fact that 88 percent of Americans only speak English at home,
292
777791
4183
13:01
I don't think that's necessarily a bad thing.
293
781998
2611
13:04
You know why languages die on our planet?
294
784633
3803
13:08
It's not because government imposes one language on a smaller group,
295
788796
5222
13:14
or because an entire group of speakers is wiped out.
296
794042
2514
13:16
That certainly has happened in the past, and it's happening now,
297
796580
3076
13:19
but it's not the main reason.
298
799680
2025
13:22
The main reason is that a child is born to a family
299
802268
2778
13:25
that speaks a language that is not widely spoken in their community,
300
805070
3555
13:28
and that child doesn't learn it.
301
808649
2007
13:30
Why?
302
810680
1285
13:31
Because that language is not valued in their community.
303
811989
4302
13:36
Because the language isn't useful.
304
816315
1913
13:38
Because the child can't go and get a job if they speak that language.
305
818252
4984
13:43
Because if language is just a tool,
306
823260
4031
13:47
then learning their native language
307
827315
2377
13:49
is about as useful as learning High Valyrian,
308
829716
2245
13:51
so why bother?
309
831985
1464
13:55
Now ...
310
835387
1150
13:58
Maybe language study isn't going to lead to a lot more linguistic fluency.
311
838514
4389
14:02
But maybe that's not such a big deal.
312
842927
2250
14:05
Maybe if more people are studying more languages,
313
845855
3111
14:08
it will lead to more linguistic tolerance
314
848990
2618
14:11
and less linguistic imperialism.
315
851632
1888
14:13
Maybe if we actually respect language for what it is --
316
853949
2984
14:16
literally, the greatest invention in the history of humankind --
317
856957
4892
14:21
then in the future,
318
861873
1206
14:23
we can celebrate endangered languages as living languages,
319
863103
3889
14:27
as opposed to museum pieces.
320
867016
1667
14:29
(High Valyrian) Kirimvose. Thank you.
321
869182
1786
14:30
(Applause)
322
870992
1396
About this website

This site will introduce you to YouTube videos that are useful for learning English. You will see English lessons taught by top-notch teachers from around the world. Double-click on the English subtitles displayed on each video page to play the video from there. The subtitles scroll in sync with the video playback. If you have any comments or requests, please contact us using this contact form.

https://forms.gle/WvT1wiN1qDtmnspy7