Eric Liu: Why ordinary people need to understand power

621,819 views ・ 2014-08-14

TED


Please double-click on the English subtitles below to play the video.

00:12
I'm a teacher and a practitioner
0
12133
1881
00:14
of civics in America.
1
14014
2485
00:16
Now, I will kindly ask those of you who have just fallen asleep
2
16499
3072
00:19
to please wake up. (Laughter)
3
19571
2112
00:21
Why is it that the very word "civics"
4
21683
2291
00:23
has such a soporific, even a narcoleptic effect
5
23974
2891
00:26
on us?
6
26865
1306
00:28
I think it's because the very word signifies something
7
28171
4141
00:32
exceedingly virtuous, exceedingly important,
8
32312
3108
00:35
and exceedingly boring.
9
35420
2410
00:37
Well, I think it's the responsibility of people like us,
10
37830
3053
00:40
people who show up for gatherings like this
11
40883
1754
00:42
in person or online, in any way we can,
12
42637
2747
00:45
to make civics sexy again,
13
45384
2901
00:48
as sexy as it was during the American Revolution,
14
48285
2826
00:51
as sexy as it was during the Civil Rights Movement.
15
51111
3443
00:54
And I believe the way we make civics sexy again
16
54554
3206
00:57
is to make explicitly about the teaching of power.
17
57760
4350
01:02
The way we do that, I believe,
18
62110
2493
01:04
is at the level of the city.
19
64603
2394
01:06
This is what I want to talk about today,
20
66997
1799
01:08
and I want to start by defining some terms
21
68796
2312
01:11
and then I want to describe the scale
22
71108
2075
01:13
of the problem I think we face
23
73183
1863
01:15
and then suggest the ways that I believe cities
24
75046
2426
01:17
can be the seat of the solution.
25
77472
2520
01:19
So let me start with some definitions.
26
79992
3788
01:23
By civics, I simply mean the art
27
83780
1777
01:25
of being a pro-social, problem-solving contributor
28
85557
3251
01:28
in a self-governing community.
29
88808
2127
01:30
Civics is the art of citizenship,
30
90935
2429
01:33
what Bill Gates Sr. calls simply
31
93364
2115
01:35
showing up for life,
32
95479
2092
01:37
and it encompasses three things:
33
97571
2385
01:39
a foundation of values,
34
99956
3544
01:43
an understanding of the systems that make the world go round,
35
103500
3766
01:47
and a set of skills
36
107266
2354
01:49
that allow you to pursue goals
37
109620
1484
01:51
and to have others join in that pursuit.
38
111104
3673
01:54
And that brings me to my definition of power,
39
114777
2259
01:57
which is simply this:
40
117036
2168
01:59
the capacity to make others do
41
119204
2666
02:01
what you would have them do.
42
121870
2761
02:04
It sounds menacing, doesn't it?
43
124631
2681
02:07
We don't like to talk about power.
44
127312
2341
02:09
We find it scary. We find it somehow evil.
45
129653
5694
02:15
We feel uncomfortable naming it.
46
135347
1782
02:17
In the culture and mythology of democracy,
47
137129
2413
02:19
power resides with the people.
48
139542
1743
02:21
Period. End of story.
49
141285
1793
02:23
Any further inquiry not necessary
50
143078
1575
02:24
and not really that welcome.
51
144653
1980
02:26
Power has a negative moral valence.
52
146633
4058
02:30
It sounds Machiavellian inherently.
53
150691
2782
02:33
It seems inherently evil.
54
153473
2634
02:36
But in fact power is no more inherently good or evil
55
156107
3805
02:39
than fire or physics.
56
159912
3118
02:43
It just is.
57
163030
2110
02:45
And power governs
58
165140
1206
02:46
how any form of government operates,
59
166346
1601
02:47
whether a democracy or a dictatorship.
60
167947
3480
02:51
And the problem we face today, here in America in particular,
61
171427
3241
02:54
but all around the world,
62
174668
1530
02:56
is that far too many people are profoundly illiterate
63
176198
3285
02:59
in power —
64
179483
1980
03:01
what it is, who has it,
65
181463
2070
03:03
how it operates, how it flows,
66
183533
2463
03:05
what part of it is visible, what part of it is not,
67
185996
2520
03:08
why some people have it, why that's compounded.
68
188516
3612
03:12
And as a result of this illiteracy,
69
192128
3489
03:15
those few who do understand
70
195617
2866
03:18
how power operates in civic life,
71
198483
2490
03:20
those who understand
72
200973
1338
03:22
how a bill becomes a law, yes,
73
202311
1823
03:24
but also how a friendship becomes a subsidy,
74
204134
4155
03:28
or how a bias becomes a policy,
75
208289
3405
03:31
or how a slogan becomes a movement,
76
211694
2935
03:34
the people who understand those things
77
214629
1980
03:36
wield disproportionate influence,
78
216609
1571
03:38
and they're perfectly happy
79
218180
1480
03:39
to fill the vacuum created by the ignorance
80
219660
3080
03:42
of the great majority.
81
222740
2547
03:47
This is why it is so fundamental for us right now
82
227124
3419
03:50
to grab hold of this idea of power
83
230543
4456
03:54
and to democratize it.
84
234999
1756
03:56
One of the things that is so profoundly exciting
85
236755
4544
04:01
and challenging about this moment
86
241299
1983
04:03
is that as a result of this power illiteracy
87
243282
3202
04:06
that is so pervasive,
88
246484
2667
04:09
there is a concentration
89
249151
3089
04:12
of knowledge, of understanding, of clout.
90
252240
4251
04:16
I mean, think about it:
91
256491
2087
04:18
How does a friendship become a subsidy?
92
258578
3415
04:21
Seamlessly,
93
261993
1277
04:23
when a senior government official decides
94
263270
2635
04:25
to leave government and become a lobbyist
95
265905
2497
04:28
for a private interest
96
268402
1914
04:30
and convert his or her relationships into capital
97
270316
2702
04:33
for their new masters.
98
273018
2307
04:35
How does a bias become a policy?
99
275325
2425
04:37
Insidiously, just the way that
100
277750
3600
04:41
stop-and-frisk, for instance,
101
281350
2160
04:43
became over time a bureaucratic numbers game.
102
283510
3656
04:47
How does a slogan become a movement?
103
287166
3105
04:50
Virally, in the way that the Tea Party, for instance,
104
290271
2981
04:53
was able to take the "Don't Tread on Me" flag
105
293252
3466
04:56
from the American Revolution,
106
296718
1747
04:58
or how, on the other side,
107
298465
1850
05:00
a band of activists could take a magazine headline,
108
300315
2964
05:03
"Occupy Wall Street,"
109
303279
1937
05:05
and turn that into a global meme and movement.
110
305216
2916
05:08
The thing is, though, most people
111
308132
2506
05:10
aren't looking for and don't want to see these realities.
112
310638
3252
05:13
So much of this ignorance, this civic illiteracy,
113
313890
3435
05:17
is willful.
114
317325
1797
05:19
There are some millennials, for instance,
115
319122
1848
05:20
who think the whole business is just sordid.
116
320970
2666
05:23
They don't want to have anything to do with politics.
117
323636
1676
05:25
They'd rather just opt out
118
325312
1079
05:26
and engage in volunteerism.
119
326391
2788
05:29
There are some techies out there
120
329179
2193
05:31
who believe that the cure-all
121
331372
1296
05:32
for any power imbalance or power abuse
122
332668
2548
05:35
is simply more data,
123
335216
2394
05:37
more transparency.
124
337610
2483
05:40
There are some on the left who think power resides
125
340093
2215
05:42
only with corporations,
126
342308
1859
05:44
and some on the right who think power
127
344167
1923
05:46
resides only with government,
128
346090
1513
05:47
each side blinded by their selective outrage.
129
347603
4361
05:51
There are the naive who believe that
130
351964
2044
05:54
good things just happen
131
354008
1307
05:55
and the cynical who believe that bad things just happen,
132
355315
3350
05:58
the fortunate and unfortunate alike
133
358665
2352
06:01
who think that their lot is simply what they deserve
134
361017
3523
06:04
rather than the eminently alterable result
135
364540
3961
06:08
of a prior arrangement, an inherited allocation,
136
368501
3282
06:11
of power.
137
371783
3663
06:15
As a result of all of this creeping fatalism in public life,
138
375446
3676
06:19
we here, particularly in America today,
139
379122
2137
06:21
have depressingly low levels
140
381259
1882
06:23
of civic knowledge, civic engagement, participation,
141
383141
3058
06:26
awareness.
142
386199
3181
06:29
The whole business of politics has been
143
389380
1878
06:31
effectively subcontracted out to a band of professionals,
144
391258
3692
06:34
money people, outreach people,
145
394950
1811
06:36
message people, research people.
146
396761
2090
06:38
The rest of us are meant to feel like amateurs
147
398851
3071
06:41
in the sense of suckers.
148
401922
2166
06:44
We become demotivated to learn more
149
404088
2526
06:46
about how things work.
150
406614
1382
06:47
We begin to opt out.
151
407996
2255
06:53
Well, this problem, this challenge,
152
413590
3631
06:57
is a thing that we must now confront,
153
417221
2689
06:59
and I believe that when you have
154
419910
991
07:00
this kind of disengagement, this willful ignorance,
155
420901
2979
07:03
it becomes both a cause and a consequence
156
423880
3479
07:07
of this concentration of opportunity
157
427359
2876
07:10
of wealth and clout that I was describing a moment ago,
158
430235
2361
07:12
this profound civic inequality.
159
432596
3738
07:16
This is why it is so important in our time right now
160
436334
3141
07:19
to reimagine civics as the teaching of power.
161
439475
3447
07:22
Perhaps it's never been more important
162
442922
2644
07:25
at any time in our lifetimes.
163
445566
5389
07:30
If people don't learn power,
164
450955
1935
07:32
people don't wake up,
165
452890
1568
07:34
and if they don't wake up,
166
454458
1755
07:36
they get left out.
167
456213
2767
07:38
Now, part of the art of practicing power
168
458980
4472
07:43
means being awake and having a voice,
169
463452
2060
07:45
but it also is about having an arena
170
465512
2385
07:47
where you can plausibly practice deciding.
171
467897
4062
07:51
All of civics boils down to the simple question
172
471959
2182
07:54
of who decides,
173
474141
1758
07:55
and you have to play that out
174
475899
1762
07:57
in a place, in an arena.
175
477661
2033
07:59
And this brings me to the third point that I want to make today,
176
479694
2928
08:02
which is simply that there is no better arena
177
482622
3611
08:06
in our time for the practicing of power
178
486233
3049
08:09
than the city.
179
489282
2892
08:12
Think about the city where you live,
180
492174
1854
08:14
where you're from.
181
494028
1857
08:15
Think about a problem in the common life of your city.
182
495885
3251
08:19
It can be something small,
183
499136
1033
08:20
like where a street lamp should go,
184
500169
2507
08:22
or something medium like
185
502676
1621
08:24
which library should have its hours extended or cut,
186
504297
3937
08:28
or maybe something bigger,
187
508234
1570
08:29
like whether a dilapidated waterfront should be
188
509804
2698
08:32
turned into a highway or a greenway,
189
512502
2935
08:35
or whether all the businesses in your town
190
515437
1698
08:37
should be required to pay a living wage.
191
517135
4050
08:41
Think about the change that you want in your city,
192
521185
2351
08:43
and then think about how you would get it,
193
523536
3712
08:47
how you would make it happen.
194
527248
3632
08:50
Take an inventory of all the forms of power
195
530880
2330
08:53
that are at play in your city's situation:
196
533210
3144
08:56
money, of course, people, yes,
197
536354
4339
09:00
ideas, information, misinformation,
198
540693
4910
09:05
the threat of force, the force of norms.
199
545603
3624
09:09
All of these form of power are at play.
200
549227
1911
09:11
Now think about how you would activate
201
551138
1542
09:12
or perhaps neutralize these various forms of power.
202
552680
4803
09:17
This is not some Game of Thrones
203
557483
3206
09:20
empire-level set of questions.
204
560689
2336
09:23
These are questions that play out
205
563025
1893
09:24
in every single place on the planet.
206
564918
2746
09:27
I'll just tell you quickly about two stories
207
567664
2159
09:29
drawn from recent headlines.
208
569823
2036
09:31
In Boulder, Colorado,
209
571859
1442
09:33
voters not too long ago approved a process
210
573301
3989
09:37
to replace the private power company,
211
577290
2892
09:40
literally the power company, the electric company Xcel,
212
580182
2312
09:42
with a publicly owned utility
213
582494
2296
09:44
that would forego profits
214
584790
1346
09:46
and attend far more to climate change.
215
586136
3709
09:49
Well, Xcel fought back,
216
589845
2125
09:51
and Xcel has now put in play a ballot measure
217
591970
2360
09:54
that would undermine or undo
218
594330
1896
09:56
this municipalization.
219
596226
1796
09:58
And so the citizen activists in Boulder who have been pushing this
220
598022
2614
10:00
now literally have to fight the power
221
600636
2734
10:03
in order to fight for power.
222
603370
2599
10:05
In Tuscaloosa, at the University of Alabama,
223
605969
4373
10:10
there's an organization on campus
224
610342
1936
10:12
called, kind of menacingly, the Machine,
225
612278
3873
10:16
and it draws from largely white sororities
226
616151
3371
10:19
and fraternities on campus,
227
619522
1440
10:20
and for decades, the Machine has dominated
228
620962
2419
10:23
student government elections.
229
623381
1853
10:25
Well now, recently, the Machine
230
625234
2396
10:27
has started to get involved
231
627630
1297
10:28
in actual city politics,
232
628927
1683
10:30
and they've engineered the election
233
630610
1658
10:32
of a former Machine member,
234
632268
1372
10:33
a young, pro-business recent graduate
235
633640
2706
10:36
to the Tuscaloosa city school board.
236
636346
3514
10:39
Now, as I say, these are just two examples
237
639860
2836
10:42
drawn almost at random from the headlines.
238
642696
2704
10:45
Every day, there are thousands more like them.
239
645400
3200
10:48
And you may like or dislike
240
648600
1764
10:50
the efforts I'm describing here
241
650364
1905
10:52
in Boulder or in Tuscaloosa,
242
652269
1329
10:53
but you cannot help but admire
243
653598
2642
10:56
the power literacy of the players involved,
244
656240
3071
10:59
their skill.
245
659311
1175
11:00
You cannot help but reckon with and recognize
246
660486
2976
11:03
the command they have
247
663462
1611
11:05
of the elemental questions
248
665073
2535
11:07
of civic power —
249
667608
1876
11:09
what objective, what strategy, what tactics,
250
669484
4038
11:13
what is the terrain, who are your enemies,
251
673522
2978
11:16
who are your allies?
252
676500
2150
11:18
Now I want you to return
253
678650
1745
11:20
to thinking about that problem or that opportunity
254
680395
3395
11:23
or that challenge in your city,
255
683790
2161
11:25
and the thing it was that you want to fix
256
685951
1873
11:27
or create in your city,
257
687824
1811
11:29
and ask yourself,
258
689635
2315
11:31
do you have command of these elemental questions of power?
259
691950
3650
11:35
Could you put into practice effectively
260
695600
3050
11:38
what it is that you know?
261
698650
3014
11:41
This is the challenge and the opportunity for us.
262
701664
4397
11:46
We live in a time right now
263
706061
2516
11:48
where in spite of globalization
264
708577
2987
11:51
or perhaps because of globalization,
265
711564
2160
11:53
all citizenship is ever more resonantly,
266
713724
2036
11:55
powerfully local.
267
715760
1780
11:57
Indeed, power in our time is flowing
268
717540
2708
12:00
ever faster to the city.
269
720248
2362
12:02
Here in the United States, the national government
270
722610
1648
12:04
has tied itself up in partisan knots.
271
724258
3001
12:07
Civic imagination and innovation and creativity
272
727259
2922
12:10
are emerging from local ecosystems now
273
730181
2617
12:12
and radiating outward,
274
732798
1890
12:14
and this great innovation,
275
734688
3440
12:18
this great wave
276
738128
2927
12:21
of localism that's now arriving,
277
741055
3926
12:24
and you see it in how people eat
278
744981
1665
12:26
and work and share and buy and move
279
746646
2648
12:29
and live their everyday lives,
280
749294
1695
12:30
this isn't some precious parochialism,
281
750989
3153
12:34
this isn't some retreat into insularity, no.
282
754142
3314
12:37
This is emergent.
283
757456
2363
12:39
The localism of our time is networked powerfully.
284
759819
3791
12:43
And so, for instance,
285
763610
1263
12:44
consider the ways that strategies
286
764873
2163
12:47
for making cities more bike-friendly
287
767036
2434
12:49
have spread so rapidly from Copenhagen
288
769470
2546
12:52
to New York to Austin to Boston to Seattle.
289
772016
5122
12:57
Think about how experiments in participatory budgeting,
290
777138
3564
13:00
where everyday citizens get a chance
291
780702
1473
13:02
to allocate and decide upon
292
782175
2801
13:04
the allocation of city funds.
293
784976
2934
13:07
Those experiments have spread from Porto Alegre, Brazil
294
787910
3580
13:11
to here in New York City, to the wards of Chicago.
295
791490
4350
13:15
Migrant workers from Rome to Los Angeles
296
795853
2138
13:17
and many cities between
297
797991
2350
13:20
are now organizing to stage strikes
298
800341
2283
13:22
to remind the people who live in their cities
299
802624
2070
13:24
what a day without immigrants would look like.
300
804694
3286
13:27
In China, all across that country,
301
807980
2458
13:30
members of the New Citizens' Movement
302
810438
2208
13:32
are beginning to activate and organize
303
812646
1586
13:34
to fight official corruption and graft,
304
814232
2654
13:36
and they're drawing the ire of officials there,
305
816886
2104
13:38
but they're also drawing the attention
306
818990
1743
13:40
of anti-corruption activists all around the world.
307
820733
3555
13:44
In Seattle, where I'm from,
308
824288
1935
13:46
we've become part of a great global array of cities
309
826223
2446
13:48
that are now working together
310
828669
1559
13:50
bypassing government altogether,
311
830228
1530
13:51
national government altogether,
312
831758
2380
13:54
in order to try to meet the carbon reduction goals
313
834138
2349
13:56
of the Kyoto Protocol.
314
836487
2140
13:58
All of these citizens, united,
315
838627
3043
14:01
are forming a web,
316
841670
1675
14:03
a great archipelago of power
317
843345
2013
14:05
that allows us to bypass
318
845358
2407
14:07
brokenness and monopolies of control.
319
847765
3904
14:11
And our task now is to accelerate this work.
320
851669
2881
14:14
Our task now is to bring more and more people
321
854550
2114
14:16
into the fold of this work.
322
856664
2031
14:18
That's why my organization, Citizen University,
323
858695
2749
14:21
has undertaken a project now
324
861444
2004
14:23
to create an everyman's curriculum
325
863448
2845
14:26
in civic power.
326
866293
2317
14:28
And this curriculum starts with this triad
327
868610
2205
14:30
that I described earlier of values,
328
870815
2015
14:32
systems and skills.
329
872830
3126
14:35
And what I'd like to do is to invite all of you
330
875956
2852
14:38
to help create this curriculum
331
878808
2650
14:41
with the stories and the experiences
332
881458
2427
14:43
and the challenges that each of you lives and faces,
333
883885
3257
14:47
to create something powerfully collective.
334
887142
3004
14:50
And I want to invite you in particular to try
335
890146
2411
14:52
a simple exercise drawn
336
892557
2099
14:54
from the early frameworks of this curriculum.
337
894656
2543
14:57
I want you to write a narrative,
338
897199
2431
14:59
a narrative from the future of your city,
339
899630
3050
15:02
and you can date it, set it out one year from now,
340
902680
3541
15:06
five years from now, a decade from now,
341
906221
1744
15:07
a generation from now,
342
907965
1801
15:09
and write it as a case study looking back,
343
909766
3845
15:13
looking back at the change
344
913611
1645
15:15
that you wanted in your city,
345
915256
2096
15:17
looking back at the cause that you were championing,
346
917352
2739
15:20
and describing the ways that that change
347
920091
2734
15:22
and that cause came, in fact, to succeed.
348
922825
4211
15:27
Describe the values
349
927036
1912
15:28
of your fellow citizens that you activated,
350
928948
2385
15:31
and the sense of moral purpose that you were able to stir.
351
931333
3607
15:34
Recount all the different ways
352
934940
1662
15:36
that you engaged the systems of government,
353
936602
2628
15:39
of the marketplace,
354
939230
1511
15:40
of social institutions, of faith organizations,
355
940741
2205
15:42
of the media.
356
942946
3202
15:46
Catalog all the skills you had to deploy,
357
946148
3965
15:50
how to negotiate, how to advocate,
358
950113
2414
15:52
how to frame issues,
359
952527
1395
15:53
how to navigate diversity in conflict,
360
953922
2541
15:56
all those skills that enabled you
361
956463
1819
15:58
to bring folks on board
362
958282
2071
16:00
and to overcome resistance.
363
960353
2697
16:03
What you'll be doing when you write that narrative
364
963050
3372
16:06
is you'll be discovering how to read power,
365
966422
4079
16:10
and in the process, how to write power.
366
970501
5197
16:15
So share what you write,
367
975698
2205
16:17
do you what you write,
368
977903
1338
16:19
and then share what you do.
369
979241
3817
16:23
I invite you to literally share
370
983058
1994
16:25
the narratives that you create
371
985052
1894
16:26
on our Facebook page for Citizen University.
372
986946
2944
16:29
But even beyond that, it's in the conversations
373
989890
2682
16:32
that we have today
374
992572
1556
16:34
all around the world in the simultaneous gatherings
375
994128
2261
16:36
that are happening on this topic at this moment,
376
996389
2850
16:39
and to think about how we can become
377
999239
1751
16:40
one another's teachers and students in power.
378
1000990
3600
16:44
If we do that, then together
379
1004590
2273
16:46
we can make civics sexy again.
380
1006863
2413
16:49
Together, we can democratize democracy
381
1009276
2402
16:51
and make it safe again for amateurs.
382
1011678
3210
16:54
Together, we can create a great network of city
383
1014888
4349
16:59
that will be the most powerful collective laboratory
384
1019237
2532
17:01
for self-government this planet has ever seen.
385
1021769
3466
17:05
We have the power to do that.
386
1025235
2986
17:08
Thank you very much.
387
1028221
2469
17:10
(Applause)
388
1030690
3243
About this website

This site will introduce you to YouTube videos that are useful for learning English. You will see English lessons taught by top-notch teachers from around the world. Double-click on the English subtitles displayed on each video page to play the video from there. The subtitles scroll in sync with the video playback. If you have any comments or requests, please contact us using this contact form.

https://forms.gle/WvT1wiN1qDtmnspy7