Clay Shirky: How the Internet will (one day) transform government

145,474 views ・ 2012-09-25

TED


Please double-click on the English subtitles below to play the video.

00:00
Translator: Joseph Geni Reviewer: Morton Bast
0
0
7000
00:15
I want to talk to you today about something
1
15536
1945
00:17
the open-source programming world can teach democracy,
2
17481
3015
00:20
but before that, a little preamble.
3
20496
1635
00:22
Let's start here.
4
22131
1820
00:23
This is Martha Payne. Martha's a 9-year-old Scot
5
23951
3395
00:27
who lives in the Council of Argyll and Bute.
6
27346
2021
00:29
A couple months ago, Payne started a food blog
7
29367
2693
00:32
called NeverSeconds, and she would take her camera
8
32060
2873
00:34
with her every day to school to document
9
34933
2280
00:37
her school lunches.
10
37213
2014
00:39
Can you spot the vegetable? (Laughter)
11
39227
1889
00:41
And, as sometimes happens,
12
41116
3754
00:44
this blog acquired first dozens of readers,
13
44870
2590
00:47
and then hundreds of readers,
14
47460
1680
00:49
and then thousands of readers, as people tuned in
15
49140
2586
00:51
to watch her rate her school lunches,
16
51726
1668
00:53
including on my favorite category,
17
53394
1525
00:54
"Pieces of hair found in food." (Laughter)
18
54919
3592
00:58
This was a zero day. That's good.
19
58511
3471
01:01
And then two weeks ago yesterday, she posted this.
20
61982
3194
01:05
A post that read: "Goodbye."
21
65176
1911
01:07
And she said, "I'm very sorry to tell you this, but
22
67087
3214
01:10
my head teacher pulled me out of class today and told me
23
70301
2744
01:13
I'm not allowed to take pictures in the lunch room anymore.
24
73045
2996
01:16
I really enjoyed doing this.
25
76041
1726
01:17
Thank you for reading. Goodbye."
26
77767
3230
01:20
You can guess what happened next, right? (Laughter)
27
80997
5178
01:26
The outrage was so swift, so voluminous, so unanimous,
28
86175
5918
01:32
that the Council of Argyll and Bute reversed themselves
29
92093
2931
01:35
the same day and said, "We would,
30
95039
1286
01:36
we would never censor a nine-year-old." (Laughter)
31
96325
2166
01:38
Except, of course, this morning. (Laughter)
32
98491
2477
01:40
And this brings up the question,
33
100968
4413
01:45
what made them think they could get away
34
105381
2214
01:47
with something like that? (Laughter)
35
107595
2050
01:49
And the answer is, all of human history prior to now.
36
109645
4717
01:54
(Laughter) So,
37
114362
3548
01:57
what happens when a medium suddenly puts
38
117910
3925
02:01
a lot of new ideas into circulation?
39
121835
3704
02:05
Now, this isn't just a contemporaneous question.
40
125539
2105
02:07
This is something we've faced several times
41
127644
2000
02:09
over the last few centuries.
42
129644
1356
02:11
When the telegraph came along, it was clear
43
131000
1985
02:12
that it was going to globalize the news industry.
44
132985
2218
02:15
What would this lead to?
45
135203
1489
02:16
Well, obviously, it would lead to world peace.
46
136692
3564
02:20
The television, a medium that allowed us not just to hear
47
140256
2810
02:23
but see, literally see, what was going on
48
143066
2767
02:25
elsewhere in the world, what would this lead to?
49
145833
2317
02:28
World peace. (Laughter)
50
148150
2240
02:30
The telephone?
51
150390
957
02:31
You guessed it: world peace.
52
151347
2595
02:33
Sorry for the spoiler alert, but no world peace. Not yet.
53
153942
4974
02:38
Even the printing press, even the printing press
54
158916
2479
02:41
was assumed to be a tool that was going to enforce
55
161395
3129
02:44
Catholic intellectual hegemony across Europe.
56
164524
3653
02:48
Instead, what we got was Martin Luther's 95 Theses,
57
168177
2484
02:50
the Protestant Reformation, and, you know,
58
170661
2020
02:52
the Thirty Years' War. All right,
59
172681
2358
02:55
so what all of these predictions of world peace got right
60
175039
4231
02:59
is that when a lot of new ideas suddenly
61
179270
2531
03:01
come into circulation, it changes society.
62
181801
2926
03:04
What they got exactly wrong was what happens next.
63
184727
3532
03:08
The more ideas there are in circulation,
64
188259
2549
03:10
the more ideas there are for any individual to disagree with.
65
190808
4708
03:15
More media always means more arguing.
66
195516
4773
03:20
That's what happens when the media's space expands.
67
200289
2920
03:23
And yet, when we look back on the printing press
68
203209
2903
03:26
in the early years, we like what happened.
69
206112
3379
03:29
We are a pro-printing press society.
70
209491
3244
03:32
So how do we square those two things,
71
212735
1970
03:34
that it leads to more arguing, but we think it was good?
72
214705
2756
03:37
And the answer, I think, can be found in things like this.
73
217461
2599
03:40
This is the cover of "Philosophical Transactions,"
74
220060
3285
03:43
the first scientific journal ever published in English
75
223345
2622
03:45
in the middle of the 1600s,
76
225967
1882
03:47
and it was created by a group of people who had been
77
227849
1827
03:49
calling themselves "The Invisible College,"
78
229676
1637
03:51
a group of natural philosophers who only later
79
231313
2204
03:53
would call themselves scientists,
80
233517
2605
03:56
and they wanted to improve the way
81
236122
3544
03:59
natural philosophers argued with each other,
82
239666
2657
04:02
and they needed to do two things for this.
83
242323
1990
04:04
They needed openness. They needed to create a norm
84
244313
2484
04:06
which said, when you do an experiment,
85
246797
1859
04:08
you have to publish not just your claims,
86
248656
2685
04:11
but how you did the experiment.
87
251341
1426
04:12
If you don't tell us how you did it, we won't trust you.
88
252767
2797
04:15
But the other thing they needed was speed.
89
255564
2360
04:17
They had to quickly synchronize what
90
257924
2305
04:20
other natural philosophers knew. Otherwise,
91
260229
2454
04:22
you couldn't get the right kind of argument going.
92
262683
2857
04:25
The printing press was clearly the right medium for this,
93
265540
2950
04:28
but the book was the wrong tool. It was too slow.
94
268490
2586
04:31
And so they invented the scientific journal
95
271076
2862
04:33
as a way of synchronizing the argument
96
273938
2786
04:36
across the community of natural scientists.
97
276724
2554
04:39
The scientific revolution wasn't created by the printing press.
98
279278
3498
04:42
It was created by scientists,
99
282776
2146
04:44
but it couldn't have been created if they didn't have
100
284922
1859
04:46
a printing press as a tool.
101
286781
2170
04:48
So what about us? What about our generation,
102
288951
2240
04:51
and our media revolution, the Internet?
103
291191
2003
04:53
Well, predictions of world peace? Check. (Laughter)
104
293194
4119
04:57
More arguing? Gold star on that one. (Laughter)
105
297313
8583
05:05
(Laughter)
106
305896
1311
05:07
I mean, YouTube is just a gold mine. (Laughter)
107
307207
4347
05:11
Better arguing? That's the question.
108
311554
4095
05:15
So I study social media, which means,
109
315649
2044
05:17
to a first approximation, I watch people argue.
110
317693
2611
05:20
And if I had to pick a group that I think is
111
320304
4107
05:24
our Invisible College, is our generation's collection of people
112
324411
3793
05:28
trying to take these tools and to press it into service,
113
328204
3159
05:31
not for more arguments, but for better arguments,
114
331363
2781
05:34
I'd pick the open-source programmers.
115
334144
2395
05:36
Programming is a three-way relationship
116
336539
2262
05:38
between a programmer, some source code,
117
338801
2284
05:41
and the computer it's meant to run on, but computers
118
341085
2614
05:43
are such famously inflexible interpreters of instructions
119
343699
4702
05:48
that it's extraordinarily difficult to write out a set
120
348401
4023
05:52
of instructions that the computer knows how to execute,
121
352424
3038
05:55
and that's if one person is writing it.
122
355462
1866
05:57
Once you get more than one person writing it,
123
357328
2099
05:59
it's very easy for any two programmers to overwrite
124
359427
3084
06:02
each other's work if they're working on the same file,
125
362511
2661
06:05
or to send incompatible instructions
126
365172
2182
06:07
that simply causes the computer to choke,
127
367354
2441
06:09
and this problem grows larger
128
369795
2959
06:12
the more programmers are involved.
129
372754
2769
06:15
To a first approximation, the problem of managing
130
375523
3347
06:18
a large software project is the problem
131
378870
2726
06:21
of keeping this social chaos at bay.
132
381596
3656
06:25
Now, for decades there has been a canonical solution
133
385252
2475
06:27
to this problem, which is to use something called
134
387727
1654
06:29
a "version control system,"
135
389381
1980
06:31
and a version control system does what is says on the tin.
136
391361
2209
06:33
It provides a canonical copy of the software
137
393570
3394
06:36
on a server somewhere.
138
396964
1552
06:38
The only programmers who can change it are people
139
398516
2906
06:41
who've specifically been given permission to access it,
140
401422
3531
06:44
and they're only allowed to access the sub-section of it
141
404953
3767
06:48
that they have permission to change.
142
408720
2430
06:51
And when people draw diagrams of version control systems,
143
411150
3185
06:54
the diagrams always look something like this.
144
414335
2365
06:56
All right. They look like org charts.
145
416700
2878
06:59
And you don't have to squint very hard
146
419578
1407
07:00
to see the political ramifications of a system like this.
147
420985
3465
07:04
This is feudalism: one owner, many workers.
148
424450
4476
07:08
Now, that's fine for the commercial software industry.
149
428926
3324
07:12
It really is Microsoft's Office. It's Adobe's Photoshop.
150
432250
5390
07:17
The corporation owns the software.
151
437640
2832
07:20
The programmers come and go.
152
440472
2314
07:22
But there was one programmer who decided
153
442786
3373
07:26
that this wasn't the way to work.
154
446159
2988
07:29
This is Linus Torvalds.
155
449147
1262
07:30
Torvalds is the most famous open-source programmer,
156
450409
2152
07:32
created Linux, obviously, and Torvalds looked at the way
157
452561
5301
07:37
the open-source movement had been dealing with this problem.
158
457862
3512
07:41
Open-source software, the core promise of the open-source license,
159
461374
4624
07:45
is that everybody should have access to all the source code
160
465998
3746
07:49
all the time, but of course, this creates
161
469744
3253
07:52
the very threat of chaos you have to forestall
162
472997
3307
07:56
in order to get anything working.
163
476304
1578
07:57
So most open-source projects just held their noses
164
477882
2482
08:00
and adopted the feudal management systems.
165
480364
2680
08:03
But Torvalds said, "No, I'm not going to do that."
166
483044
2508
08:05
His point of view on this was very clear.
167
485552
3565
08:09
When you adopt a tool, you also adopt
168
489117
2533
08:11
the management philosophy embedded in that tool,
169
491650
3589
08:15
and he wasn't going to adopt anything that didn't work
170
495239
3136
08:18
the way the Linux community worked.
171
498375
2309
08:20
And to give you a sense of how enormous
172
500684
2532
08:23
a decision like this was, this is a map
173
503216
3668
08:26
of the internal dependencies within Linux,
174
506884
3489
08:30
within the Linux operating system, which sub-parts
175
510373
2607
08:32
of the program rely on which other sub-parts to get going.
176
512980
4445
08:37
This is a tremendously complicated process.
177
517425
3578
08:41
This is a tremendously complicated program,
178
521003
2792
08:43
and yet, for years, Torvalds ran this
179
523795
2665
08:46
not with automated tools but out of his email box.
180
526460
3904
08:50
People would literally mail him changes
181
530364
2473
08:52
that they'd agreed on, and he would merge them by hand.
182
532837
4119
08:56
And then, 15 years after looking at Linux and figuring out
183
536956
4746
09:01
how the community worked, he said, "I think I know
184
541702
2810
09:04
how to write a version control system for free people."
185
544512
4167
09:08
And he called it "Git." Git is distributed version control.
186
548679
5895
09:14
It has two big differences
187
554574
3024
09:17
with traditional version control systems.
188
557598
2063
09:19
The first is that it lives up to the philosophical promise
189
559661
3147
09:22
of open-source. Everybody who works on a project
190
562808
3286
09:26
has access to all of the source code all of the time.
191
566094
3671
09:29
And when people draw diagrams of Git workflow,
192
569765
2674
09:32
they use drawings that look like this.
193
572439
2937
09:35
And you don't have to understand what the circles
194
575376
2318
09:37
and boxes and arrows mean to see that this is a far more
195
577694
3679
09:41
complicated way of working than is supported
196
581373
3095
09:44
by ordinary version control systems.
197
584468
2721
09:47
But this is also the thing that brings the chaos back,
198
587189
4309
09:51
and this is Git's second big innovation.
199
591498
3050
09:54
This is a screenshot from GitHub, the premier Git hosting service,
200
594548
3996
09:58
and every time a programmer uses Git
201
598544
3350
10:01
to make any important change at all,
202
601894
3161
10:05
creating a new file, modifying an existing one,
203
605055
3309
10:08
merging two files, Git creates this kind of signature.
204
608364
4674
10:13
This long string of numbers and letters here
205
613038
3143
10:16
is a unique identifier tied to every single change,
206
616181
5075
10:21
but without any central coordination.
207
621256
2857
10:24
Every Git system generates this number the same way,
208
624113
4489
10:28
which means this is a signature tied directly
209
628602
3342
10:31
and unforgeably to a particular change.
210
631944
3150
10:35
This has the following effect:
211
635094
1936
10:37
A programmer in Edinburgh and a programmer in Entebbe
212
637030
3678
10:40
can both get the same -- a copy of the same piece of software.
213
640708
3702
10:44
Each of them can make changes and they can merge them
214
644410
3826
10:48
after the fact even if they didn't know
215
648236
2935
10:51
of each other's existence beforehand.
216
651171
2959
10:54
This is cooperation without coordination.
217
654130
3499
10:57
This is the big change.
218
657629
2936
11:00
Now, I tell you all of this not to convince you that it's great
219
660565
5210
11:05
that open-source programmers now have a tool
220
665775
3697
11:09
that supports their philosophical way of working,
221
669472
3093
11:12
although I think that is great.
222
672565
2104
11:14
I tell you all of this because of what I think it means
223
674669
2768
11:17
for the way communities come together.
224
677437
2194
11:19
Once Git allowed for cooperation without coordination,
225
679631
6319
11:25
you start to see communities form
226
685950
2940
11:28
that are enormously large and complex.
227
688890
4252
11:33
This is a graph of the Ruby community.
228
693142
2279
11:35
It's an open-source programming language,
229
695421
1529
11:36
and all of the interconnections between the people --
230
696950
2998
11:39
this is now not a software graph, but a people graph,
231
699948
2399
11:42
all of the interconnections among the people
232
702347
2102
11:44
working on that project —
233
704449
2343
11:46
and this doesn't look like an org chart.
234
706792
2990
11:49
This looks like a dis-org chart, and yet,
235
709782
3420
11:53
out of this community, but using these tools,
236
713202
2608
11:55
they can now create something together.
237
715810
2286
11:58
So there are two good reasons to think that
238
718096
4365
12:02
this kind of technique can be applied
239
722461
4173
12:06
to democracies in general and in particular to the law.
240
726634
4533
12:11
When you make the claim, in fact,
241
731167
1858
12:13
that something on the Internet is going to be good
242
733025
2958
12:15
for democracy, you often get this reaction.
243
735983
2441
12:18
(Music) (Laughter)
244
738424
5924
12:24
Which is, are you talking about the thing
245
744348
2526
12:26
with the singing cats? Like, is that the thing
246
746874
2411
12:29
you think is going to be good for society?
247
749285
2629
12:31
To which I have to say, here's the thing
248
751914
2135
12:34
with the singing cats. That always happens.
249
754049
3361
12:37
And I don't just mean that always happens with the Internet,
250
757410
1733
12:39
I mean that always happens with media, full stop.
251
759143
2580
12:41
It did not take long after the rise
252
761723
2040
12:43
of the commercial printing press before someone
253
763763
2676
12:46
figured out that erotic novels were a good idea. (Laughter)
254
766439
3313
12:49
You don't have to have an economic incentive to sell books
255
769752
3042
12:52
very long before someone says, "Hey, you know what I bet
256
772794
3021
12:55
people would pay for?" (Laughter)
257
775815
2168
12:57
It took people another 150 years to even think
258
777983
3550
13:01
of the scientific journal, right? So -- (Laughter) (Applause)
259
781533
6760
13:08
So the harnessing by the Invisible College
260
788293
3038
13:11
of the printing press to create the scientific journal
261
791331
2385
13:13
was phenomenally important, but it didn't happen big,
262
793716
2911
13:16
and it didn't happen quick, and it didn't happen fast, so
263
796627
2759
13:19
if you're going to look for where the change is happening,
264
799386
3298
13:22
you have to look on the margins.
265
802684
2016
13:24
So, the law is also dependency-related.
266
804700
5464
13:30
This is a graph of the U.S. Tax Code,
267
810164
3409
13:33
and the dependencies of one law on other laws
268
813573
3080
13:36
for the overall effect.
269
816653
2398
13:39
So there's that as a site for source code management.
270
819051
3432
13:42
But there's also the fact that law is another place
271
822483
1902
13:44
where there are many opinions in circulation,
272
824385
2274
13:46
but they need to be resolved to one canonical copy,
273
826659
3508
13:50
and when you go onto GitHub, and you look around,
274
830167
2577
13:52
there are millions and millions of projects,
275
832744
2069
13:54
almost all of which are source code,
276
834813
1354
13:56
but if you look around the edges, you can see people
277
836167
2685
13:58
experimenting with the political ramifications
278
838852
2209
14:01
of a system like that.
279
841061
1613
14:02
Someone put up all the Wikileaked cables
280
842674
1810
14:04
from the State Department, along with software used
281
844484
2265
14:06
to interpret them, including my favorite use ever
282
846749
3189
14:09
of the Cablegate cables, which is a tool for detecting
283
849938
2371
14:12
naturally occurring haiku in State Department prose.
284
852309
3015
14:15
(Laughter)
285
855324
5896
14:21
Right. (Laughter)
286
861220
3072
14:24
The New York Senate has put up something called
287
864292
2799
14:27
Open Legislation, also hosting it on GitHub,
288
867091
2407
14:29
again for all of the reasons of updating and fluidity.
289
869498
2386
14:31
You can go and pick your Senator and then you can see
290
871884
2666
14:34
a list of bills they have sponsored.
291
874550
2035
14:36
Someone going by Divegeek has put up the Utah code,
292
876585
3632
14:40
the laws of the state of Utah, and they've put it up there
293
880217
2765
14:42
not just to distribute the code,
294
882982
1449
14:44
but with the very interesting possibility that this could
295
884431
3198
14:47
be used to further the development of legislation.
296
887629
4555
14:52
Somebody put up a tool during the copyright debate
297
892184
3839
14:56
last year in the Senate, saying, "It's strange that Hollywood
298
896023
4186
15:00
has more access to Canadian legislators
299
900209
3124
15:03
than Canadian citizens do. Why don't we use GitHub
300
903333
3816
15:07
to show them what a citizen-developed bill might look like?"
301
907149
4476
15:11
And it includes this very evocative screenshot.
302
911625
3752
15:15
This is a called a "diff," this thing on the right here.
303
915377
2978
15:18
This shows you, for text that many people are editing,
304
918355
2970
15:21
when a change was made, who made it,
305
921325
2201
15:23
and what the change is.
306
923526
1003
15:24
The stuff in red is the stuff that got deleted.
307
924529
1455
15:25
The stuff in green is the stuff that got added.
308
925984
2692
15:28
Programmers take this capability for granted.
309
928676
2782
15:31
No democracy anywhere in the world offers this feature
310
931458
2925
15:34
to its citizens for either legislation or for budgets,
311
934383
3815
15:38
even though those are the things done
312
938198
2530
15:40
with our consent and with our money.
313
940728
3139
15:43
Now, I would love to tell you that the fact
314
943867
3238
15:47
that the open-source programmers have worked out
315
947105
3172
15:50
a collaborative method that is large scale, distributed,
316
950277
3671
15:53
cheap, and in sync with the ideals of democracy, I would love
317
953948
3465
15:57
to tell you that because those tools are in place,
318
957413
2171
15:59
the innovation is inevitable. But it's not.
319
959584
4331
16:03
Part of the problem, of course, is just a lack of information.
320
963915
2993
16:06
Somebody put a question up on Quora saying,
321
966908
1903
16:08
"Why is it that lawmakers don't use
322
968811
2092
16:10
distributed version control?"
323
970903
1407
16:12
This, graphically, was the answer. (Laughter)
324
972310
3621
16:15
(Laughter) (Applause)
325
975931
2091
16:18
And that is indeed part of the problem, but only part.
326
978022
5022
16:23
The bigger problem, of course, is power.
327
983044
3177
16:26
The people experimenting with participation don't have
328
986221
3170
16:29
legislative power, and the people who have legislative
329
989391
2569
16:31
power are not experimenting with participation.
330
991960
3963
16:35
They are experimenting with openness.
331
995923
1545
16:37
There's no democracy worth the name that doesn't have
332
997468
1860
16:39
a transparency move, but transparency is openness
333
999328
2928
16:42
in only one direction, and being given a dashboard
334
1002256
3905
16:46
without a steering wheel has never been the core promise
335
1006161
3170
16:49
a democracy makes to its citizens.
336
1009331
3411
16:52
So consider this.
337
1012742
2350
16:55
The thing that got Martha Payne's opinions
338
1015092
2586
16:57
out into the public was a piece of technology,
339
1017678
3691
17:01
but the thing that kept them there was political will.
340
1021369
3634
17:05
It was the expectation of the citizens
341
1025003
2274
17:07
that she would not be censored.
342
1027277
3535
17:10
That's now the state we're in with these collaboration tools.
343
1030812
5328
17:16
We have them. We've seen them. They work.
344
1036140
4007
17:20
Can we use them?
345
1040147
1051
17:21
Can we apply the techniques that worked here to this?
346
1041198
5126
17:26
T.S. Eliot once said, "One of the most momentous things
347
1046324
3717
17:30
that can happen to a culture
348
1050041
2080
17:32
is that they acquire a new form of prose."
349
1052121
3643
17:35
I think that's wrong, but -- (Laughter)
350
1055764
2248
17:38
I think it's right for argumentation. Right?
351
1058012
3659
17:41
A momentous thing that can happen to a culture
352
1061671
3355
17:45
is they can acquire a new style of arguing:
353
1065026
2814
17:47
trial by jury, voting, peer review, now this. Right?
354
1067840
6670
17:54
A new form of arguing has been invented in our lifetimes,
355
1074556
3069
17:57
in the last decade, in fact.
356
1077625
1887
17:59
It's large, it's distributed, it's low-cost,
357
1079512
4053
18:03
and it's compatible with the ideals of democracy.
358
1083565
3299
18:06
The question for us now is, are we going to let
359
1086864
1986
18:08
the programmers keep it to themselves?
360
1088850
1526
18:10
Or are we going to try and take it and press it into service
361
1090376
2049
18:12
for society at large?
362
1092425
2152
18:14
Thank you for listening. (Applause)
363
1094577
2600
18:17
(Applause)
364
1097177
4138
18:21
Thank you. Thank you. (Applause)
365
1101315
5137
About this website

This site will introduce you to YouTube videos that are useful for learning English. You will see English lessons taught by top-notch teachers from around the world. Double-click on the English subtitles displayed on each video page to play the video from there. The subtitles scroll in sync with the video playback. If you have any comments or requests, please contact us using this contact form.

https://forms.gle/WvT1wiN1qDtmnspy7