Quyen Nguyen: Color-coded surgery

103,500 views ・ 2011-12-13

TED


Please double-click on the English subtitles below to play the video.

00:15
I want to talk to you
0
15330
2000
00:17
about one of the biggest myths in medicine,
1
17330
2000
00:19
and that is the idea
2
19330
2000
00:21
that all we need are more medical breakthroughs
3
21330
3000
00:24
and then all of our problems will be solved.
4
24330
3000
00:27
Our society loves to romanticize
5
27330
3000
00:30
the idea of the single, solo inventor
6
30330
2000
00:32
who, working late in the lab one night,
7
32330
3000
00:35
makes an earthshaking discovery,
8
35330
3000
00:38
and voila, overnight everything's changed.
9
38330
4000
00:42
That's a very appealing picture,
10
42330
2000
00:44
however, it's just not true.
11
44330
3000
00:47
In fact, medicine today is a team sport.
12
47330
3000
00:50
And in many ways,
13
50330
2000
00:52
it always has been.
14
52330
2000
00:54
I'd like to share with you a story
15
54330
2000
00:56
about how I've experienced this very dramatically
16
56330
3000
00:59
in my own work.
17
59330
2000
01:01
I'm a surgeon,
18
61330
2000
01:03
and we surgeons have always had
19
63330
2000
01:05
this special relationship with light.
20
65330
3000
01:08
When I make an incision inside a patient's body, it's dark.
21
68330
4000
01:12
We need to shine light to see what we're doing.
22
72330
3000
01:15
And this is why, traditionally,
23
75330
3000
01:18
surgeries have always started so early in the morning --
24
78330
2000
01:20
to take advantage of daylight hours.
25
80330
2000
01:22
And if you look at historical pictures
26
82330
2000
01:24
of the early operating rooms,
27
84330
2000
01:26
they have been on top of buildings.
28
86330
3000
01:29
For example, this is the oldest operating room in the Western world,
29
89330
2000
01:31
in London,
30
91330
2000
01:33
where the operating room
31
93330
2000
01:35
is actually on top of a church
32
95330
2000
01:37
with a skylight coming in.
33
97330
2000
01:39
And then this is a picture
34
99330
2000
01:41
of one of the most famous hospitals in America.
35
101330
3000
01:44
This is Mass General in Boston.
36
104330
2000
01:46
And do you know where the operating room is?
37
106330
2000
01:48
Here it is
38
108330
2000
01:50
on the top of the building
39
110330
2000
01:52
with plenty of windows to let light in.
40
112330
3000
01:55
So nowadays in the operating room,
41
115330
2000
01:57
we no longer need to use sunlight.
42
117330
3000
02:00
And because we no longer need to use sunlight,
43
120330
3000
02:03
we have very specialized lights
44
123330
2000
02:05
that are made for the operating room.
45
125330
2000
02:07
We have an opportunity
46
127330
2000
02:09
to bring in other kinds of lights --
47
129330
2000
02:11
lights that can allow us to see
48
131330
2000
02:13
what we currently don't see.
49
133330
3000
02:16
And this is what I think
50
136330
2000
02:18
is the magic of fluorescence.
51
138330
2000
02:20
So let me back up a little bit.
52
140330
2000
02:22
When we are in medical school,
53
142330
3000
02:25
we learn our anatomy from illustrations such as this
54
145330
3000
02:28
where everything's color-coded.
55
148330
3000
02:31
Nerves are yellow, arteries are red,
56
151330
2000
02:33
veins are blue.
57
153330
2000
02:35
That's so easy anybody could become a surgeon, right?
58
155330
4000
02:39
However, when we have a real patient on the table,
59
159330
3000
02:42
this is the same neck dissection --
60
162330
3000
02:45
not so easy to tell the difference
61
165330
2000
02:47
between different structures.
62
167330
2000
02:49
We heard over the last couple days
63
169330
3000
02:52
what an urgent problem
64
172330
2000
02:54
cancer still is in our society,
65
174330
2000
02:56
what a pressing need it is
66
176330
2000
02:58
for us to not have
67
178330
2000
03:00
one person die every minute.
68
180330
4000
03:04
Well if cancer can be caught early,
69
184330
2000
03:06
enough such that someone can have their cancer taken out,
70
186330
5000
03:11
excised with surgery,
71
191330
2000
03:13
I don't care if it has this gene or that gene,
72
193330
2000
03:15
or if it has this protein or that protein,
73
195330
2000
03:17
it's in the jar.
74
197330
2000
03:19
It's done, it's out, you're cured of cancer.
75
199330
3000
03:22
This is how we excise cancers.
76
202330
2000
03:24
We do our best, based upon our training
77
204330
3000
03:27
and the way the cancer looks and the way it feels
78
207330
3000
03:30
and its relationship to other structures and all of our experience,
79
210330
3000
03:33
we say, you know what, the cancer's gone.
80
213330
3000
03:36
We've made a good job. We've taken it out.
81
216330
3000
03:39
That's what the surgeon is saying in the operating room
82
219330
2000
03:41
when the patient's on the table.
83
221330
2000
03:43
But then we actually don't know that it's all out.
84
223330
3000
03:46
We actually have to take samples from the surgical bed,
85
226330
3000
03:49
what's left behind in the patient,
86
229330
2000
03:51
and then send those bits to the pathology lab.
87
231330
4000
03:55
In the meanwhile, the patient's on the operating room table.
88
235330
2000
03:57
The nurses, anesthesiologist, the surgeon,
89
237330
2000
03:59
all the assistants are waiting around.
90
239330
2000
04:01
And we wait.
91
241330
2000
04:03
The pathologist takes that sample,
92
243330
2000
04:05
freezes it, cuts it, looks in the microscope one by one
93
245330
3000
04:08
and then calls back into the room.
94
248330
2000
04:10
And that may be 20 minutes later per piece.
95
250330
2000
04:12
So if you've sent three specimens,
96
252330
2000
04:14
it's an hour later.
97
254330
2000
04:16
And very often they say,
98
256330
2000
04:18
"You know what, points A and B are okay,
99
258330
3000
04:21
but point C, you still have some residual cancer there.
100
261330
2000
04:23
Please go cut that piece out."
101
263330
3000
04:26
So we go back and we do that again, and again.
102
266330
3000
04:29
And this whole process:
103
269330
2000
04:31
"Okay you're done.
104
271330
2000
04:33
We think the entire tumor is out."
105
273330
2000
04:35
But very often several days later,
106
275330
3000
04:38
the patient's gone home,
107
278330
2000
04:40
we get a phone call:
108
280330
2000
04:42
"I'm sorry,
109
282330
2000
04:44
once we looked at the final pathology,
110
284330
2000
04:46
once we looked at the final specimen,
111
286330
2000
04:48
we actually found that there's a couple other spots
112
288330
3000
04:51
where the margins are positive.
113
291330
3000
04:54
There's still cancer in your patient."
114
294330
3000
04:57
So now you're faced with telling your patient, first of all,
115
297330
3000
05:00
that they may need another surgery,
116
300330
2000
05:02
or that they need additional therapy
117
302330
2000
05:04
such as radiation or chemotherapy.
118
304330
4000
05:08
So wouldn't it be better
119
308330
2000
05:10
if we could really tell,
120
310330
2000
05:12
if the surgeon could really tell,
121
312330
3000
05:15
whether or not there's still cancer on the surgical field?
122
315330
3000
05:18
I mean, in many ways, the way that we're doing it,
123
318330
3000
05:21
we're still operating in the dark.
124
321330
4000
05:25
So in 2004, during my surgical residency,
125
325330
3000
05:28
I had the great fortune
126
328330
2000
05:30
to meet Dr. Roger Tsien,
127
330330
3000
05:33
who went on to win the Nobel Prize for chemistry
128
333330
3000
05:36
in 2008.
129
336330
2000
05:38
Roger and his team
130
338330
2000
05:40
were working on a way to detect cancer,
131
340330
3000
05:43
and they had a very clever molecule
132
343330
2000
05:45
that they had come up with.
133
345330
2000
05:47
The molecule they had developed
134
347330
2000
05:49
had three parts.
135
349330
2000
05:51
The main part of it is the blue part, polycation,
136
351330
3000
05:54
and it's basically very sticky
137
354330
2000
05:56
to every tissue in your body.
138
356330
2000
05:58
So imagine that you make a solution
139
358330
2000
06:00
full of this sticky material
140
360330
2000
06:02
and inject it into the veins of someone who has cancer,
141
362330
2000
06:04
everything's going to get lit up.
142
364330
2000
06:06
Nothing will be specific.
143
366330
2000
06:08
There's no specificity there.
144
368330
2000
06:10
So they added two additional components.
145
370330
2000
06:12
The first one is a polyanionic segment,
146
372330
3000
06:15
which basically acts as a non-stick backing
147
375330
2000
06:17
like the back of a sticker.
148
377330
2000
06:19
So when those two are together, the molecule is neutral
149
379330
3000
06:22
and nothing gets stuck down.
150
382330
2000
06:24
And the two pieces are then linked
151
384330
3000
06:27
by something that can only be cut
152
387330
3000
06:30
if you have the right molecular scissors --
153
390330
2000
06:32
for example, the kind of protease enzymes
154
392330
2000
06:34
that tumors make.
155
394330
2000
06:36
So here in this situation,
156
396330
2000
06:38
if you make a solution full of this three-part molecule
157
398330
4000
06:42
along with the dye, which is shown in green,
158
402330
2000
06:44
and you inject it into the vein
159
404330
3000
06:47
of someone who has cancer,
160
407330
2000
06:49
normal tissue can't cut it.
161
409330
2000
06:51
The molecule passes through and gets excreted.
162
411330
3000
06:54
However, in the presence of the tumor,
163
414330
2000
06:56
now there are molecular scissors
164
416330
2000
06:58
that can break this molecule apart
165
418330
2000
07:00
right there at the cleavable site.
166
420330
2000
07:02
And now, boom,
167
422330
2000
07:04
the tumor labels itself
168
424330
2000
07:06
and it gets fluorescent.
169
426330
2000
07:08
So here's an example of a nerve
170
428330
3000
07:11
that has tumor surrounding it.
171
431330
2000
07:13
Can you tell where the tumor is?
172
433330
2000
07:15
I couldn't when I was working on this.
173
435330
3000
07:18
But here it is. It's fluorescent.
174
438330
2000
07:20
Now it's green.
175
440330
2000
07:22
See, so every single one in the audience
176
442330
3000
07:25
now can tell where the cancer is.
177
445330
3000
07:28
We can tell in the operating room, in the field,
178
448330
3000
07:31
at a molecular level,
179
451330
2000
07:33
where is the cancer and what the surgeon needs to do
180
453330
2000
07:35
and how much more work they need to do
181
455330
2000
07:37
to cut that out.
182
457330
3000
07:40
And the cool thing about fluorescence
183
460330
2000
07:42
is that it's not only bright,
184
462330
3000
07:45
it actually can shine through tissue.
185
465330
3000
07:48
The light that the fluorescence emits
186
468330
3000
07:51
can go through tissue.
187
471330
2000
07:53
So even if the tumor is not right on the surface,
188
473330
3000
07:56
you'll still be able to see it.
189
476330
3000
07:59
In this movie, you can see
190
479330
2000
08:01
that the tumor is green.
191
481330
3000
08:04
There's actually normal muscle on top of it. See that?
192
484330
3000
08:07
And I'm peeling that muscle away.
193
487330
2000
08:09
But even before I peel that muscle away,
194
489330
2000
08:11
you saw that there was a tumor underneath.
195
491330
3000
08:14
So that's the beauty of having a tumor
196
494330
3000
08:17
that's labeled with fluorescent molecules.
197
497330
3000
08:20
That you can, not only see the margins
198
500330
2000
08:22
right there on a molecular level,
199
502330
2000
08:24
but you can see it even if it's not right on the top --
200
504330
3000
08:27
even if it's beyond your field of view.
201
507330
3000
08:30
And this works for metastatic lymph nodes also.
202
510330
3000
08:33
Sentinel lymph node dissection
203
513330
2000
08:35
has really changed the way that we manage breast cancer, melanoma.
204
515330
4000
08:39
Women used to get
205
519330
2000
08:41
really debilitating surgeries
206
521330
2000
08:43
to excise all of the axillary lymph nodes.
207
523330
3000
08:46
But when sentinel lymph node
208
526330
3000
08:49
came into our treatment protocol,
209
529330
3000
08:52
the surgeon basically looks for the single node
210
532330
3000
08:55
that is the first draining lymph node of the cancer.
211
535330
3000
08:58
And then if that node has cancer,
212
538330
3000
09:01
the woman would go on to get
213
541330
2000
09:03
the axillary lymph node dissection.
214
543330
2000
09:05
So what that means
215
545330
2000
09:07
is if the lymph node did not have cancer,
216
547330
3000
09:10
the woman would be saved
217
550330
2000
09:12
from having unnecessary surgery.
218
552330
2000
09:14
But sentinel lymph node, the way that we do it today,
219
554330
3000
09:17
is kind of like having a road map
220
557330
2000
09:19
just to know where to go.
221
559330
2000
09:21
So if you're driving on the freeway
222
561330
2000
09:23
and you want to know where's the next gas station,
223
563330
2000
09:25
you have a map to tell you that that gas station is down the road.
224
565330
3000
09:28
It doesn't tell you whether or not
225
568330
2000
09:30
the gas station has gas.
226
570330
2000
09:32
You have to cut it out, bring it back home,
227
572330
3000
09:35
cut it up, look inside
228
575330
2000
09:37
and say, "Oh yes, it does have gas."
229
577330
2000
09:39
So that takes more time.
230
579330
2000
09:41
Patients are still on the operating room table.
231
581330
2000
09:43
Anesthesiologists, surgeons are waiting around.
232
583330
2000
09:45
That takes time.
233
585330
2000
09:47
So with our technology, we can tell right away.
234
587330
3000
09:50
You see a lot of little, roundish bumps there.
235
590330
3000
09:53
Some of these are swollen lymph nodes
236
593330
3000
09:56
that look a little larger than others.
237
596330
2000
09:58
Who amongst us hasn't had swollen lymph nodes with a cold?
238
598330
3000
10:01
That doesn't mean that there's cancer inside.
239
601330
2000
10:03
Well with our technology,
240
603330
2000
10:05
the surgeon is able to tell immediately
241
605330
3000
10:08
which nodes have cancer.
242
608330
2000
10:10
I won't go into this very much,
243
610330
2000
10:12
but our technology, besides being able
244
612330
2000
10:14
to tag tumor and metastatic lymph nodes with fluorescence,
245
614330
4000
10:18
we can also use the same smart three-part molecule
246
618330
4000
10:22
to tag gadolinium onto the system
247
622330
3000
10:25
so you can do this noninvasively.
248
625330
2000
10:27
The patient has cancer,
249
627330
2000
10:29
you want to know if the lymph nodes have cancer
250
629330
2000
10:31
even before you go in.
251
631330
2000
10:33
Well you can see this on an MRI.
252
633330
3000
10:36
So in surgery,
253
636330
2000
10:38
it's important to know what to cut out.
254
638330
3000
10:41
But equally important
255
641330
2000
10:43
is to preserve things
256
643330
3000
10:46
that are important for function.
257
646330
3000
10:49
So it's very important to avoid inadvertent injury.
258
649330
3000
10:52
And what I'm talking about
259
652330
2000
10:54
are nerves.
260
654330
2000
10:56
Nerves, if they are injured,
261
656330
2000
10:58
can cause paralysis,
262
658330
2000
11:00
can cause pain.
263
660330
3000
11:03
In the setting of prostate cancer,
264
663330
2000
11:05
up to 60 percent of men
265
665330
2000
11:07
after prostate cancer surgery
266
667330
2000
11:09
may have urinary incontinence
267
669330
2000
11:11
and erectile disfunction.
268
671330
2000
11:13
That's a lot of people to have a lot of problems --
269
673330
3000
11:16
and this is even in
270
676330
2000
11:18
so-called nerve-sparing surgery,
271
678330
2000
11:20
which means that the surgeon is aware of the problem,
272
680330
4000
11:24
and they are trying to avoid the nerves.
273
684330
2000
11:26
But you know what, these little nerves are so small,
274
686330
3000
11:29
in the context of prostate cancer,
275
689330
3000
11:32
that they are actually never seen.
276
692330
2000
11:34
They are traced
277
694330
2000
11:36
just by their known anatomical path
278
696330
2000
11:38
along vasculature.
279
698330
2000
11:40
And they're known because somebody has decided to study them,
280
700330
4000
11:44
which means that we're still learning
281
704330
2000
11:46
about where they are.
282
706330
2000
11:48
Crazy to think that we're having surgery,
283
708330
3000
11:51
we're trying to excise cancer, we don't know where the cancer is.
284
711330
3000
11:54
We're trying to preserve nerves; we can't see where they are.
285
714330
3000
11:57
So I said, wouldn't it be great
286
717330
2000
11:59
if we could find a way
287
719330
2000
12:01
to see nerves with fluorescence?
288
721330
3000
12:04
And at first this didn't get a lot of support.
289
724330
4000
12:08
People said, "We've been doing it this way for all these years.
290
728330
2000
12:10
What's the problem?
291
730330
2000
12:12
We haven't had that many complications."
292
732330
3000
12:15
But I went ahead anyway.
293
735330
2000
12:17
And Roger helped me.
294
737330
2000
12:19
And he brought his whole team with him.
295
739330
3000
12:22
So there's that teamwork thing again.
296
742330
4000
12:26
And we eventually discovered molecules
297
746330
3000
12:29
that were specifically labeling nerves.
298
749330
2000
12:31
And when we made a solution of this,
299
751330
2000
12:33
tagged with the fluorescence
300
753330
2000
12:35
and injected in the body of a mouse,
301
755330
3000
12:38
their nerves literally glowed.
302
758330
2000
12:40
You can see where they are.
303
760330
2000
12:42
Here you're looking at a sciatic nerve of a mouse,
304
762330
4000
12:46
and you can see that that big, fat portion you can see very easily.
305
766330
3000
12:49
But in fact, at the tip of that where I'm dissecting now,
306
769330
3000
12:52
there's actually very fine arborizations
307
772330
3000
12:55
that can't really be seen.
308
775330
2000
12:57
You see what looks like little Medusa heads coming out.
309
777330
4000
13:01
We have been able to see nerves
310
781330
2000
13:03
for facial expression, for facial movement, for breathing --
311
783330
3000
13:06
every single nerve --
312
786330
2000
13:08
nerves for urinary function around the prostate.
313
788330
3000
13:11
We've been able to see every single nerve.
314
791330
3000
13:14
When we put these two probes together ...
315
794330
4000
13:18
So here's a tumor.
316
798330
2000
13:20
Do you guys know where the margins of this tumor is?
317
800330
3000
13:23
Now you do.
318
803330
3000
13:26
What about the nerve that's going into this tumor?
319
806330
3000
13:29
That white portion there is easy to see.
320
809330
2000
13:31
But what about the part that goes into the tumor?
321
811330
2000
13:33
Do you know where it's going?
322
813330
2000
13:35
Now you do.
323
815330
2000
13:37
Basically, we've come up with a way
324
817330
2000
13:39
to stain tissue
325
819330
2000
13:41
and color-code the surgical field.
326
821330
2000
13:43
This was a bit of a breakthrough.
327
823330
3000
13:46
I think that it'll change the way that we do surgery.
328
826330
4000
13:50
We published our results
329
830330
2000
13:52
in the proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences
330
832330
2000
13:54
and in Nature Biotechnology.
331
834330
2000
13:56
We received commentary in Discover magazine,
332
836330
3000
13:59
in The Economist.
333
839330
2000
14:01
And we showed it to a lot of my surgical colleagues.
334
841330
3000
14:04
They said, "Wow!
335
844330
2000
14:06
I have patients
336
846330
2000
14:08
who would benefit from this.
337
848330
2000
14:10
I think that this will result in my surgeries
338
850330
2000
14:12
with a better outcome
339
852330
2000
14:14
and fewer complications."
340
854330
3000
14:17
What needs to happen now
341
857330
2000
14:19
is further development of our technology
342
859330
3000
14:22
along with development
343
862330
2000
14:24
of the instrumentation
344
864330
2000
14:26
that allows us to see
345
866330
2000
14:28
this sort of fluorescence in the operating room.
346
868330
3000
14:31
The eventual goal
347
871330
2000
14:33
is that we'll get this into patients.
348
873330
3000
14:36
However, we've discovered
349
876330
3000
14:39
that there's actually no straightforward mechanism
350
879330
2000
14:41
to develop a molecule
351
881330
2000
14:43
for one-time use.
352
883330
2000
14:45
Understandably, the majority of the medical industry
353
885330
3000
14:48
is focused on multiple-use drugs,
354
888330
4000
14:52
such as long-term daily medications.
355
892330
3000
14:55
We are focused on making this technology better.
356
895330
3000
14:58
We're focused on adding drugs,
357
898330
3000
15:01
adding growth factors,
358
901330
2000
15:03
killing nerves that are causing problems
359
903330
2000
15:05
and not the surrounding tissue.
360
905330
3000
15:08
We know that this can be done and we're committed to doing it.
361
908330
4000
15:12
I'd like to leave you with this final thought.
362
912330
4000
15:16
Successful innovation
363
916330
2000
15:18
is not a single breakthrough.
364
918330
3000
15:21
It is not a sprint.
365
921330
3000
15:24
It is not an event for the solo runner.
366
924330
4000
15:28
Successful innovation
367
928330
2000
15:30
is a team sport, it's a relay race.
368
930330
3000
15:33
It requires one team for the breakthrough
369
933330
4000
15:37
and another team
370
937330
2000
15:39
to get the breakthrough accepted and adopted.
371
939330
2000
15:41
And this takes the long-term steady courage
372
941330
3000
15:44
of the day-in day-out struggle
373
944330
2000
15:46
to educate, to persuade
374
946330
3000
15:49
and to win acceptance.
375
949330
3000
15:52
And that is the light that I want to shine
376
952330
2000
15:54
on health and medicine today.
377
954330
2000
15:56
Thank you very much.
378
956330
2000
15:58
(Applause)
379
958330
4000

Original video on YouTube.com
About this website

This site will introduce you to YouTube videos that are useful for learning English. You will see English lessons taught by top-notch teachers from around the world. Double-click on the English subtitles displayed on each video page to play the video from there. The subtitles scroll in sync with the video playback. If you have any comments or requests, please contact us using this contact form.

https://forms.gle/WvT1wiN1qDtmnspy7