America’s Forgotten Working Class | J.D. Vance | TED

1,263,445 views ・ 2016-10-17

TED


Please double-click on the English subtitles below to play the video.

00:12
I remember the very first time I went to a nice restaurant,
0
12880
2815
00:15
a really nice restaurant.
1
15719
1617
00:17
It was for a law firm recruitment dinner,
2
17360
2136
00:19
and I remember beforehand the waitress walked around
3
19520
2456
00:22
and asked whether we wanted some wine,
4
22000
1856
00:23
so I said, "Sure, I'll take some white wine."
5
23880
2120
00:26
And she immediately said,
6
26800
1736
00:28
"Would you like sauvignon blanc or chardonnay?"
7
28560
2440
00:31
And I remember thinking,
8
31680
1936
00:33
"Come on, lady, stop with the fancy French words
9
33640
2856
00:36
and just give me some white wine."
10
36520
1720
00:39
But I used my powers of deduction
11
39400
1616
00:41
and recognized that chardonnay and sauvignon blanc
12
41040
2416
00:43
were two separate types of white wine,
13
43480
1896
00:45
and so I told her that I would take the chardonnay,
14
45400
2416
00:47
because frankly that was the easiest one to pronounce for me.
15
47840
2858
00:51
So I had a lot of experiences like that
16
51960
2096
00:54
during my first couple of years as a law student at Yale,
17
54080
2680
00:57
because, despite all outward appearances, I'm a cultural outsider.
18
57480
3240
01:01
I didn't come from the elites.
19
61240
1576
01:02
I didn't come from the Northeast or from San Francisco.
20
62840
4336
01:07
I came from a southern Ohio steel town,
21
67200
2096
01:09
and it's a town that's really struggling in a lot of ways,
22
69320
2736
01:12
ways that are indicative of the broader struggles
23
72080
2456
01:14
of America's working class.
24
74560
1440
01:16
Heroin has moved in,
25
76720
1336
01:18
killing a lot of people, people I know.
26
78080
2040
01:20
Family violence, domestic violence, and divorce have torn apart families.
27
80680
3960
01:25
And there's a very unique sense of pessimism that's moved in.
28
85400
4176
01:29
Think about rising mortality rates in these communities
29
89600
2616
01:32
and recognize that for a lot of these folks,
30
92240
2176
01:34
the problems that they're seeing
31
94440
1576
01:36
are actually causing rising death rates in their own communities,
32
96040
3696
01:39
so there's a very real sense of struggle.
33
99760
2400
01:43
I had a very front-row seat to that struggle.
34
103160
2536
01:45
My family has been part of that struggle for a very long time.
35
105720
4120
01:51
I come from a family that doesn't have a whole lot of money.
36
111080
4336
01:55
The addiction that plagued my community
37
115440
2416
01:57
also plagued my family, and even, sadly, my own mom.
38
117880
3120
02:01
There were a lot of problems that I saw in my own family,
39
121760
4136
02:05
problems caused sometimes by a lack of money,
40
125920
2856
02:08
problems caused sometimes by a lack of access to resources and social capital
41
128800
4336
02:13
that really affected my life.
42
133160
2040
02:16
If you had looked at my life when I was 14 years old
43
136400
2776
02:19
and said, "Well, what's going to happen to this kid?"
44
139200
3056
02:22
you would have concluded that I would have struggled
45
142280
2856
02:25
with what academics call upward mobility.
46
145160
2520
02:28
So upward mobility is an abstract term,
47
148560
2976
02:31
but it strikes at something that's very core
48
151560
2736
02:34
at the heart of the American Dream.
49
154320
1696
02:36
It's the sense,
50
156040
1216
02:37
and it measures whether kids like me
51
157280
1776
02:39
who grow up in poor communities are going to live a better life,
52
159080
3016
02:42
whether they're going to have a chance to live a materially better existence,
53
162120
5376
02:47
or whether they're going to stay in the circumstances where they came from.
54
167520
3536
02:51
And one of the things we've learned, unfortunately,
55
171080
2416
02:53
is that upward mobility isn't as high as we'd like it to be in this country,
56
173520
3936
02:57
and interestingly, it's very geographically distributed.
57
177480
4000
03:02
So take Utah, for instance.
58
182080
1960
03:04
In Utah a poor kid is actually doing OK,
59
184840
3536
03:08
very likely to live their share and their part in the American Dream.
60
188400
4136
03:12
But if you think of where I'm from,
61
192560
1856
03:14
in the South, in Appalachia, in southern Ohio,
62
194440
3936
03:18
it's very unlikely that kids like that will rise.
63
198400
4216
03:22
The American Dream in those parts of the country
64
202640
2256
03:24
is in a very real sense just a dream.
65
204920
2040
03:27
So why is that happening?
66
207960
1200
03:30
So one reason is obviously economic or structural.
67
210120
2816
03:32
So you think of these areas.
68
212960
1536
03:34
They're beset by these terrible economic trends,
69
214520
2616
03:37
built around industries like coal and steel
70
217160
2616
03:39
that make it harder for folks to get ahead.
71
219800
2040
03:42
That's certainly one problem.
72
222320
1576
03:43
There's also the problem of brain drain, where the really talented people,
73
223920
3496
03:47
because they can't find high-skilled work at home,
74
227440
2376
03:49
end up moving elsewhere,
75
229840
1256
03:51
so they don't build a business or non-profit where they're from,
76
231120
3016
03:54
they end up going elsewhere and taking their talents with them.
77
234160
2976
03:57
There are failing schools in a lot of these communities,
78
237160
2656
03:59
failing to give kids the educational leg up
79
239840
2056
04:01
that really makes it possible for kids to have opportunities later in life.
80
241920
3536
04:05
These things are all important.
81
245480
1536
04:07
I don't mean to discount these structural barriers.
82
247040
2416
04:09
But when I look back at my life and my community,
83
249480
2336
04:11
something else was going on, something else mattered.
84
251840
2880
04:15
It's difficult to quantify, but it was no less real.
85
255840
3280
04:20
So for starters, there was a very real sense of hopelessness
86
260120
3656
04:23
in the community that I grew up in.
87
263800
1776
04:25
There was a sense that kids had that their choices didn't matter.
88
265600
3136
04:28
No matter what happened, no matter how hard they worked,
89
268760
2656
04:31
no matter how hard they tried to get ahead,
90
271440
2096
04:33
nothing good would happen.
91
273560
1640
04:36
So that's a tough feeling to grow up around.
92
276160
3056
04:39
That's a tough mindset to penetrate,
93
279240
3176
04:42
and it leads sometimes to very conspiratorial places.
94
282440
4280
04:47
So let's just take one political issue that's pretty hot,
95
287240
3936
04:51
affirmative action.
96
291200
1496
04:52
So depending on your politics, you might think that affirmative action
97
292720
3296
04:56
is either a wise or an unwise way to promote diversity in the workplace
98
296040
3376
04:59
or the classroom.
99
299440
1296
05:00
But if you grow up in an area like this,
100
300760
2016
05:02
you see affirmative action as a tool to hold people like you back.
101
302800
3736
05:06
That's especially true if you're a member of the white working class.
102
306560
3256
05:09
You see it as something that isn't just about good or bad policy.
103
309840
3416
05:13
You see it as something that's actively conspiring,
104
313280
2696
05:16
where people with political and financial power
105
316000
2256
05:18
are working against you.
106
318280
1616
05:19
And there are a lot of ways that you see that conspiracy against you --
107
319920
4920
05:25
perceived, real, but it's there,
108
325520
2896
05:28
and it warps expectations.
109
328440
1640
05:31
So if you think about what do you do when you grow up in that world,
110
331040
3216
05:34
you can respond in a couple of ways.
111
334280
1736
05:36
One, you can say, "I'm not going to work hard,
112
336040
2176
05:38
because no matter how hard I work, it's not going to matter."
113
338240
2896
05:41
Another thing you might do is say,
114
341160
1656
05:42
"Well, I'm not going to go after the traditional markers of success,
115
342840
3216
05:46
like a university education or a prestigious job,
116
346080
2336
05:48
because the people who care about those things are unlike me.
117
348440
2896
05:51
They're never going to let me in."
118
351360
1620
05:53
When I got admitted to Yale, a family member asked me
119
353004
2477
05:55
if I had pretended to be a liberal to get by the admissions committee.
120
355505
3311
05:58
Seriously.
121
358840
1776
06:00
And it's obviously not the case that there was a liberal box to check
122
360640
4016
06:04
on the application,
123
364680
1496
06:06
but it speaks to a very real insecurity in these places
124
366200
3656
06:09
that you have to pretend to be somebody you're not
125
369880
2376
06:12
to get past these various social barriers.
126
372280
2200
06:15
It's a very significant problem.
127
375080
1524
06:17
Even if you don't give in to that hopelessness,
128
377640
2416
06:20
even if you think, let's say,
129
380080
1816
06:21
that your choices matter and you want to make the good choices,
130
381920
3616
06:25
you want to do better for yourself and for your family,
131
385560
2896
06:28
it's sometimes hard to even know what those choices are
132
388480
3176
06:31
when you grow up in a community like I did.
133
391680
2096
06:33
I didn't know, for example,
134
393800
1616
06:35
that you had to go to law school to be a lawyer.
135
395440
2240
06:38
I didn't know that elite universities, as research consistently tells us,
136
398360
3936
06:42
are cheaper for low-income kids
137
402320
1776
06:44
because these universities have bigger endowments,
138
404120
2576
06:46
can offer more generous financial aid.
139
406720
2176
06:48
I remember I learned this
140
408920
1256
06:50
when I got the financial aid letter from Yale for myself,
141
410200
2816
06:53
tens of thousands of dollars in need-based aid,
142
413040
2696
06:55
which is a term I had never heard before.
143
415760
2136
06:57
But I turned to my aunt when I got that letter and said,
144
417920
2656
07:00
"You know, I think this just means that for the first time in my life,
145
420600
3296
07:03
being poor has paid really well."
146
423920
1600
07:07
So I didn't have access to that information
147
427360
2816
07:10
because the social networks around me didn't have access to that information.
148
430200
3656
07:13
I learned from my community how to shoot a gun, how to shoot it well.
149
433880
3656
07:17
I learned how to make a damn good biscuit recipe.
150
437560
2456
07:20
The trick, by the way, is frozen butter, not warm butter.
151
440040
3160
07:24
But I didn't learn how to get ahead.
152
444080
1896
07:26
I didn't learn how to make the good decisions
153
446000
2576
07:28
about education and opportunity
154
448600
1856
07:30
that you need to make
155
450480
2696
07:33
to actually have a chance in this 21st century knowledge economy.
156
453200
3176
07:36
Economists call the value that we gain from our informal networks,
157
456400
4136
07:40
from our friends and colleagues and family "social capital."
158
460560
3616
07:44
The social capital that I had wasn't built for 21st century America,
159
464200
3816
07:48
and it showed.
160
468040
1200
07:50
There's something else that's really important that's going on
161
470360
2936
07:53
that our community doesn't like to talk about,
162
473320
2176
07:55
but it's very real.
163
475520
1576
07:57
Working-class kids are much more likely
164
477120
1896
07:59
to face what's called adverse childhood experiences,
165
479040
2736
08:01
which is just a fancy word for childhood trauma:
166
481800
3720
08:06
getting hit or yelled at, put down by a parent repeatedly,
167
486280
3576
08:09
watching someone hit or beat your parent,
168
489880
2416
08:12
watching someone do drugs or abuse alcohol.
169
492320
3376
08:15
These are all instances of childhood trauma,
170
495720
2536
08:18
and they're pretty commonplace in my family.
171
498280
2080
08:20
Importantly, they're not just commonplace in my family right now.
172
500960
3416
08:24
They're also multigenerational.
173
504400
2016
08:26
So my grandparents,
174
506440
1560
08:28
the very first time that they had kids,
175
508640
2776
08:31
they expected that they were going to raise them in a way
176
511440
2696
08:34
that was uniquely good.
177
514160
1616
08:35
They were middle class,
178
515800
1256
08:37
they were able to earn a good wage in a steel mill.
179
517080
2381
08:39
But what ended up happening
180
519485
1331
08:40
is that they exposed their kids to a lot of the childhood trauma
181
520840
3016
08:43
that had gone back many generations.
182
523880
2696
08:46
My mom was 12 when she saw my grandma set my grandfather on fire.
183
526600
4760
08:52
His crime was that he came home drunk
184
532120
2816
08:54
after she told him,
185
534960
1216
08:56
"If you come home drunk, I'm gonna kill you."
186
536200
2160
08:59
And she tried to do it.
187
539240
1200
09:01
Think about the way that that affects a child's mind.
188
541440
3480
09:05
And we think of these things as especially rare,
189
545520
2936
09:08
but a study by the Wisconsin Children's Trust Fund found
190
548480
3976
09:12
that 40 percent of low-income kids face multiple instances of childhood trauma,
191
552480
5680
09:18
compared to only 29 percent for upper-income kids.
192
558800
3296
09:22
And think about what that really means.
193
562120
2656
09:24
If you're a low-income kid,
194
564800
1736
09:26
almost half of you face multiple instances of childhood trauma.
195
566560
4456
09:31
This is not an isolated problem.
196
571040
1816
09:32
This is a very significant issue.
197
572880
2120
09:35
We know what happens to the kids who experience that life.
198
575800
3120
09:39
They're more likely to do drugs, more likely to go to jail,
199
579920
3296
09:43
more likely to drop out of high school,
200
583240
2296
09:45
and most importantly,
201
585560
1416
09:47
they're more likely to do to their children
202
587000
2216
09:49
what their parents did to them.
203
589240
1840
09:51
This trauma, this chaos in the home,
204
591640
3096
09:54
is our culture's very worst gift to our children,
205
594760
3456
09:58
and it's a gift that keeps on giving.
206
598240
2520
10:02
So you combine all that,
207
602280
1816
10:04
the hopelessness, the despair,
208
604120
2696
10:06
the cynicism about the future,
209
606840
2336
10:09
the childhood trauma,
210
609200
1240
10:11
the low social capital,
211
611440
1896
10:13
and you begin to understand why me,
212
613360
2296
10:15
at the age of 14,
213
615680
1576
10:17
was ready to become just another statistic,
214
617280
2336
10:19
another kid who failed to beat the odds.
215
619640
2320
10:22
But something unexpected happened.
216
622640
2696
10:25
I did beat the odds.
217
625360
1736
10:27
Things turned up for me.
218
627120
2136
10:29
I graduated from high school, from college, I went to law school,
219
629280
3736
10:33
and I have a pretty good job now.
220
633040
1600
10:35
So what happened?
221
635320
1200
10:37
Well, one thing that happened is that my grandparents,
222
637320
2536
10:39
the same grandparents of setting someone on fire fame,
223
639880
2536
10:42
they really shaped up by the time I came around.
224
642440
2240
10:45
They provided me a stable home,
225
645320
3056
10:48
a stable family.
226
648400
1296
10:49
They made sure
227
649720
1216
10:50
that when my parents weren't able to do the things that kids need,
228
650960
3136
10:54
they stepped in and filled that role.
229
654120
1880
10:56
My grandma especially did two things that really matter.
230
656880
2656
10:59
One, she provided that peaceful home that allowed me to focus on homework
231
659560
3496
11:03
and the things that kids should be focused on.
232
663080
2616
11:05
But she was also this incredibly perceptive woman,
233
665720
2376
11:08
despite not even having a middle school education.
234
668120
2376
11:10
She recognized the message that my community had for me,
235
670520
2656
11:13
that my choices didn't matter,
236
673200
2056
11:15
that the deck was stacked against me.
237
675280
1816
11:17
She once told me,
238
677120
1216
11:18
"JD, never be like those losers who think the deck is stacked against them.
239
678360
3976
11:22
You can do anything you want to."
240
682360
2336
11:24
And yet she recognized that life wasn't fair.
241
684720
3216
11:27
It's hard to strike that balance,
242
687960
1616
11:29
to tell a kid that life isn't fair,
243
689600
2016
11:31
but also recognize and enforce in them the reality that their choices matter.
244
691640
5256
11:36
But mamaw was able to strike that balance.
245
696920
2120
11:41
The other thing that really helped was the United States Marine Corps.
246
701040
3296
11:44
So we think of the Marine Corps as a military outfit, and of course it is,
247
704360
3496
11:47
but for me, the US Marine Corps was a four-year crash course
248
707880
2856
11:50
in character education.
249
710760
1216
11:52
It taught me how to make a bed, how to do laundry,
250
712000
2376
11:54
how to wake up early, how to manage my finances.
251
714400
2256
11:56
These are things my community didn't teach me.
252
716680
2176
11:58
I remember when I went to go buy a car for the very first time,
253
718880
2953
12:01
I was offered a dealer's low, low interest rate of 21.9 percent,
254
721857
4319
12:06
and I was ready to sign on the dotted line.
255
726200
2600
12:09
But I didn't take that deal,
256
729680
1856
12:11
because I went and took it to my officer
257
731560
2016
12:13
who told me, "Stop being an idiot,
258
733600
2136
12:15
go to the local credit union, and get a better deal."
259
735760
2496
12:18
And so that's what I did.
260
738280
1456
12:19
But without the Marine Corps,
261
739760
1416
12:21
I would have never had access to that knowledge.
262
741200
2256
12:23
I would have had a financial calamity, frankly.
263
743480
2200
12:26
The last thing I want to say is that I had a lot of good fortune
264
746720
3136
12:29
in the mentors and people
265
749880
1576
12:31
who have played an important role in my life.
266
751480
2136
12:33
From the Marines, from Ohio State, from Yale,
267
753640
3056
12:36
from other places,
268
756720
1256
12:38
people have really stepped in
269
758000
1656
12:39
and ensured that they filled that social capital gap
270
759680
2816
12:42
that it was pretty obvious, apparently, that I had.
271
762520
2400
12:45
That comes from good fortune,
272
765480
1560
12:47
but a lot of children aren't going to have that good fortune,
273
767840
3296
12:51
and I think that raises really important questions for all of us
274
771160
3696
12:54
about how we're going to change that.
275
774880
1762
12:57
We need to ask questions about how we're going to give low-income kids
276
777600
3976
13:01
who come from a broken home access to a loving home.
277
781600
3536
13:05
We need to ask questions
278
785160
1256
13:06
about how we're going to teach low-income parents
279
786440
2336
13:08
how to better interact with their children,
280
788800
2136
13:10
with their partners.
281
790960
1496
13:12
We need to ask questions about how we give social capital,
282
792480
4456
13:16
mentorship to low-income kids who don't have it.
283
796960
3376
13:20
We need to think about how we teach working class children
284
800360
3056
13:23
about not just hard skills,
285
803440
2496
13:25
like reading, mathematics,
286
805960
2096
13:28
but also soft skills,
287
808080
1336
13:29
like conflict resolution and financial management.
288
809440
2840
13:33
Now, I don't have all of the answers.
289
813440
3216
13:36
I don't know all of the solutions to this problem,
290
816680
2920
13:40
but I do know this:
291
820360
1200
13:42
in southern Ohio right now,
292
822600
1736
13:44
there's a kid who is anxiously awaiting their dad,
293
824360
3776
13:48
wondering whether, when he comes through the door,
294
828160
2376
13:50
he'll walk calmly or stumble drunkly.
295
830560
2400
13:54
There's a kid
296
834000
1200
13:56
whose mom sticks a needle in her arm
297
836560
2336
13:58
and passes out,
298
838920
1496
14:00
and he doesn't know why she doesn't cook him dinner,
299
840440
2896
14:03
and he goes to bed hungry that night.
300
843360
1800
14:06
There's a kid who has no hope for the future
301
846400
3936
14:10
but desperately wants to live a better life.
302
850360
3256
14:13
They just want somebody to show it to them.
303
853640
2200
14:16
I don't have all the answers,
304
856680
1856
14:18
but I know that unless our society starts asking better questions
305
858560
4936
14:23
about why I was so lucky
306
863520
2096
14:25
and about how to get that luck to more of our communities
307
865640
3056
14:28
and our country's children,
308
868720
1656
14:30
we're going to continue to have a very significant problem.
309
870400
3256
14:33
Thank you.
310
873680
1216
14:34
(Applause)
311
874920
2400
About this website

This site will introduce you to YouTube videos that are useful for learning English. You will see English lessons taught by top-notch teachers from around the world. Double-click on the English subtitles displayed on each video page to play the video from there. The subtitles scroll in sync with the video playback. If you have any comments or requests, please contact us using this contact form.

https://forms.gle/WvT1wiN1qDtmnspy7