How Boredom Can Lead to Your Most Brilliant Ideas | Manoush Zomorodi | TED

718,096 views ・ 2017-08-29

TED


Please double-click on the English subtitles below to play the video.

00:12
My son and the iPhone were born three weeks apart
0
12731
3816
00:16
in June 2007.
1
16571
2020
00:19
So while those early adopters were lined up outside,
2
19393
3343
00:22
waiting to get their hands on this amazing new gadget,
3
22760
2925
00:25
I was stuck at home with my hands full of something else
4
25709
3944
00:29
that was sending out constant notifications --
5
29677
2246
00:31
(Laughter)
6
31947
1833
00:33
a miserable, colicky baby
7
33804
2612
00:36
who would only sleep in a moving stroller with complete silence.
8
36440
4989
00:42
I literally was walking 10 to 15 miles a day,
9
42177
3010
00:45
and the baby weight came off.
10
45211
1575
00:46
That part was great.
11
46810
1601
00:48
But man, was I bored.
12
48435
2758
00:51
Before motherhood, I had been a journalist
13
51217
2152
00:53
who rushed off when the Concorde crashed.
14
53393
2567
00:55
I was one of the first people into Belgrade
15
55984
2421
00:58
when there was a revolution in Serbia.
16
58429
2501
01:00
Now, I was exhausted.
17
60954
2822
01:04
This walking went on for weeks.
18
64186
2876
01:07
It was only until about three months in that something shifted, though.
19
67086
5443
01:12
As I pounded the pavement,
20
72553
2087
01:14
my mind started to wander, too.
21
74664
3163
01:17
I began imagining what I would do when I finally did sleep again.
22
77851
4250
01:22
So the colic did fade,
23
82125
2008
01:24
and I finally got an iPhone
24
84157
2799
01:26
and I put all those hours of wandering into action.
25
86980
2895
01:29
I created my dream job hosting a public radio show.
26
89899
3916
01:33
So there was no more rushing off to war zones,
27
93839
2160
01:36
but thanks to my new smartphone,
28
96023
1902
01:37
I could be a mother and a journalist.
29
97949
2271
01:40
I could be on the playground and on Twitter at the same time.
30
100244
4352
01:45
Yeah, well, when I thought that,
31
105541
1751
01:47
when the technology came in and took over,
32
107316
2047
01:49
that is when I hit a wall.
33
109387
2150
01:52
So, I want you to picture this:
34
112176
2210
01:54
you host a podcast, and you have to prove
35
114410
2254
01:56
that the investment of precious public radio dollars in you
36
116688
3420
02:00
is worth it.
37
120132
1176
02:01
My goal was to increase my audience size tenfold.
38
121332
4245
02:05
So one day, I sat down to brainstorm,
39
125601
2464
02:08
as you do,
40
128089
1276
02:09
and I came up barren.
41
129389
1969
02:11
This was different than writer's block, right?
42
131382
2171
02:13
It wasn't like there was something there waiting to be unearthed.
43
133577
3075
02:16
There was just nothing.
44
136676
1424
02:18
And so I started to think back:
45
138124
1478
02:19
When was the last time I actually had a good idea?
46
139626
2767
02:22
Yeah, it was when I was pushing that damn stroller.
47
142417
2750
02:25
Now all the cracks in my day were filled with phone time.
48
145872
3409
02:29
I checked the headlines while I waited for my latte.
49
149305
3525
02:32
I updated my calendar while I was sitting on the couch.
50
152854
4072
02:36
Texting turned every spare moment
51
156950
2425
02:39
into a chance to show to my coworkers and my dear husband
52
159399
3289
02:42
what a responsive person I was,
53
162712
2602
02:45
or at least it was a chance to find another perfect couch
54
165338
2885
02:48
for my page on Pinterest.
55
168247
1706
02:50
I realized that I was never bored.
56
170829
2815
02:53
And anyway, don't only boring people get bored?
57
173668
2770
02:57
But then I started to wonder:
58
177028
1382
02:58
What actually happens to us when we get bored?
59
178434
2262
03:00
Or, more importantly: What happens to us if we never get bored?
60
180720
4177
03:04
And what could happen if we got rid of this human emotion entirely?
61
184921
4951
03:09
I started talking to neuroscientists and cognitive psychologists,
62
189896
4251
03:14
and what they told me was fascinating.
63
194171
2925
03:17
It turns out that when you get bored,
64
197120
1793
03:18
you ignite a network in your brain called the "default mode."
65
198937
4084
03:23
So our body, it goes on autopilot while we're folding the laundry
66
203045
4859
03:27
or we're walking to work,
67
207928
1367
03:29
but actually that is when our brain gets really busy.
68
209319
2961
03:32
Here's boredom researcher Dr. Sandi Mann.
69
212304
2872
03:36
(Audio) Dr. Sandi Mann: Once you start daydreaming
70
216081
2349
03:38
and allow your mind to really wander,
71
218454
1816
03:40
you start thinking a little bit beyond the conscious,
72
220294
2559
03:42
a little bit into the subconscious,
73
222877
1723
03:44
which allows sort of different connections to take place.
74
224624
3172
03:47
It's really awesome, actually.
75
227820
1490
03:49
Manoush Zomorodi: Totally awesome, right?
76
229334
2014
03:51
So this is my brain in an fMRI,
77
231864
2203
03:54
and I learned that in the default mode is when we connect disparate ideas,
78
234091
3953
03:58
we solve some of our most nagging problems,
79
238068
2510
04:00
and we do something called "autobiographical planning."
80
240602
3041
04:03
This is when we look back at our lives,
81
243667
1895
04:05
we take note of the big moments, we create a personal narrative,
82
245586
3199
04:08
and then we set goals
83
248809
1508
04:10
and we figure out what steps we need to take to reach them.
84
250341
3117
04:13
But now we chill out on the couch also while updating a Google Doc
85
253482
4449
04:17
or replying to email.
86
257955
1920
04:19
We call it "getting shit done,"
87
259899
2528
04:22
but here's what neuroscientist Dr. Daniel Levitin says
88
262451
3038
04:25
we're actually doing.
89
265513
1316
04:27
(Audio) Dr. Daniel Levitin: Every time you shift your attention
90
267510
3057
04:30
from one thing to another,
91
270591
1312
04:31
the brain has to engage a neurochemical switch
92
271927
2728
04:34
that uses up nutrients in the brain to accomplish that.
93
274679
3231
04:37
So if you're attempting to multitask,
94
277934
2419
04:40
you know, doing four or five things at once,
95
280377
2323
04:42
you're not actually doing four or five things at once,
96
282724
2541
04:45
because the brain doesn't work that way.
97
285289
1925
04:47
Instead, you're rapidly shifting from one thing to the next,
98
287238
2851
04:50
depleting neural resources as you go.
99
290113
2043
04:52
(Audio) MZ: So switch, switch, switch, you're using glucose, glucose, glucose.
100
292180
3787
04:55
(Audio) DL: Exactly right, and we have a limited supply of that stuff.
101
295991
3317
04:59
MZ: A decade ago, we shifted our attention at work
102
299332
2409
05:01
every three minutes.
103
301765
1260
05:03
Now we do it every 45 seconds,
104
303049
2893
05:05
and we do it all day long.
105
305966
1837
05:07
The average person checks email 74 times a day,
106
307827
3336
05:11
and switches tasks on their computer
107
311187
2287
05:13
566 times a day.
108
313498
3896
05:17
I discovered all this talking to professor of informatics,
109
317418
3501
05:20
Dr. Gloria Mark.
110
320943
1724
05:23
(Audio) Dr. Gloria Mark: So we find that when people are stressed,
111
323127
3546
05:26
they tend to shift their attention more rapidly.
112
326697
3171
05:29
We also found, strangely enough,
113
329892
2239
05:32
that the shorter the amount of sleep that a person gets,
114
332155
5700
05:37
the more likely they are to check Facebook.
115
337879
2096
05:39
So we're in this vicious, habitual cycle.
116
339999
4042
05:44
MZ: But could this cycle be broken?
117
344065
2098
05:46
What would happen if we broke this vicious cycle?
118
346187
3682
05:50
Maybe my listeners could help me find out.
119
350487
3493
05:55
What if we reclaimed those cracks in our day?
120
355281
2650
05:58
Could it help us jump-start our creativity?
121
358416
3234
06:03
We called the project "Bored and Brilliant."
122
363042
3426
06:08
And I expected, you know, a couple hundred people to play along,
123
368084
3049
06:11
but thousands of people started signing up.
124
371157
3077
06:14
And they told me the reason they were doing it
125
374258
2172
06:16
was because they were worried that their relationship with their phone
126
376454
3414
06:19
had grown kind of ... "codependent," shall we say.
127
379892
4168
06:24
(Audio) Man: The relationship between a baby and its teddy bear
128
384084
3671
06:27
or a baby and its binky
129
387779
1815
06:29
or a baby that wants its mother's cradle
130
389618
3278
06:32
when it's done with being held by a stranger --
131
392920
3022
06:35
(Laughs)
132
395966
1052
06:37
that's the relationship between me and my phone.
133
397042
2952
06:40
(Audio) Woman: I think of my phone like a power tool:
134
400018
2775
06:42
extremely useful, but dangerous if I'm not handling it properly.
135
402817
3909
06:46
(Audio) Woman 2: If I don't pay close attention,
136
406750
2278
06:49
I'll suddenly realize that I've lost an hour of time
137
409052
2453
06:51
doing something totally mindless.
138
411529
1991
06:53
MZ: OK, but to really measure any improvement,
139
413544
2303
06:55
we needed data, right?
140
415871
1421
06:57
Because that's what we do these days.
141
417316
2191
06:59
So we partnered with some apps that would measure how much time
142
419531
3138
07:02
we were spending every day on our phone.
143
422693
2092
07:04
If you're thinking it's ironic
144
424809
1477
07:06
that I asked people to download another app
145
426310
2049
07:08
so that they would spend less time on their phones:
146
428383
2523
07:10
yeah, but you gotta meet people where they are.
147
430930
2307
07:13
(Laughter)
148
433261
1496
07:14
So before challenge week,
149
434787
1778
07:16
we were averaging two hours a day on our phones
150
436589
2868
07:19
and 60 pickups,
151
439481
1708
07:21
you know, like, a quick check, did I get a new email?
152
441213
2727
07:23
Here's what Tina, a student at Bard College,
153
443964
2210
07:26
discovered about herself.
154
446198
1512
07:28
(Audio) Tina: So far, I've been spending
155
448552
1977
07:30
between 150 and 200 minutes on my phone per day,
156
450553
3462
07:34
and I've been picking up my phone 70 to 100 times per day.
157
454039
3567
07:38
And it's really concerning,
158
458188
1676
07:39
because that's so much time that I could have spent
159
459888
2434
07:42
doing something more productive, more creative, more towards myself,
160
462346
3852
07:46
because when I'm on my phone, I'm not doing anything important.
161
466222
2958
07:49
MZ: Like Tina, people were starting to observe their own behavior.
162
469204
3345
07:52
They were getting ready for challenge week.
163
472573
2574
07:55
And that Monday,
164
475171
1774
07:56
they started to wake up to instructions in their inbox,
165
476969
2875
07:59
an experiment to try.
166
479868
1566
08:01
Day one:
167
481885
1551
08:03
"Put it in your pocket."
168
483460
1585
08:05
Take that phone out of your hand.
169
485069
2292
08:07
See if you can eliminate the reflex to check it all day long,
170
487385
2975
08:10
just for a day.
171
490384
1494
08:11
And if this sounds easy,
172
491902
1481
08:13
you haven't tried it.
173
493407
1249
08:14
Here's listener Amanda Itzko.
174
494680
2060
08:16
(Audio) Amanda Itzko: I am absolutely itching.
175
496764
3740
08:20
I feel a little bit crazy,
176
500528
2456
08:23
because I have noticed that I pick up my phone
177
503008
4684
08:27
when I'm just walking from one room to another,
178
507716
3908
08:31
getting on the elevator,
179
511648
1266
08:32
and even -- and this is the part that I am really embarrassed
180
512938
3777
08:36
to actually say out loud --
181
516739
1987
08:38
in the car.
182
518750
1427
08:40
MZ: Yikes.
183
520201
1173
08:41
Yeah, well, but as Amanda learned,
184
521398
1669
08:43
this itching feeling is not actually her fault.
185
523091
3383
08:46
That is exactly the behavior that the technology is built to trigger.
186
526498
4351
08:50
(Laughter)
187
530873
2908
08:55
I mean, right?
188
535557
2046
08:57
Here's former Google designer, Tristan Harris.
189
537627
2892
09:01
(Audio) Tristan Harris: If I'm Facebook or I'm Netflix or I'm Snapchat,
190
541129
3376
09:04
I have literally a thousand engineers
191
544529
1858
09:06
whose job is to get more attention from you.
192
546411
2571
09:09
I'm very good at this,
193
549006
1539
09:10
and I don't want you to ever stop.
194
550569
1716
09:12
And you know, the CEO of Netflix recently said,
195
552309
2222
09:14
"Our biggest competitors are Facebook, YouTube and sleep."
196
554555
3222
09:17
I mean, so there's a million places to spend your attention,
197
557801
3274
09:21
but there's a war going on to get it.
198
561099
1927
09:23
MZ: I mean, you know the feeling:
199
563050
1698
09:24
that amazing episode of "Transparent" ends,
200
564772
2129
09:26
and then the next one starts playing
201
566925
1752
09:28
so you're like, eh, OK fine, I'll just stay up and watch it.
202
568701
2900
09:31
Or the LinkedIn progress bar says you are this close
203
571625
3079
09:34
to having the perfect profile,
204
574728
2156
09:36
so you add a little more personal information.
205
576908
3108
09:40
As one UX designer told me,
206
580040
1994
09:42
the only people who refer to their customers as "users"
207
582058
3273
09:45
are drug dealers and technologists.
208
585355
2068
09:47
(Laughter)
209
587447
1356
09:48
(Applause)
210
588827
2944
09:55
And users, as we know, are worth a lot of money.
211
595199
3424
09:58
Here's former Facebook product manager and author,
212
598647
3410
10:02
Antonio García Martínez.
213
602081
2566
10:05
(Audio) Antonio García Martínez: The saying is, if any product is free
214
605367
3318
10:08
then you're the product; your attention is the product.
215
608709
2601
10:11
But what is your attention worth?
216
611334
1574
10:12
That's why literally every time you load a page,
217
612932
2253
10:15
not just on Facebook or any app,
218
615209
1540
10:16
there's an auction being held instantly, billions of times a day,
219
616773
3071
10:19
for exactly how much that one ad impression cost.
220
619868
2314
10:22
MZ: By the way, the average person will spend two years of their life
221
622206
3287
10:25
on Facebook.
222
625517
1158
10:27
So, back to challenge week.
223
627042
1542
10:28
Immediately, we saw some creativity kick in.
224
628608
3412
10:32
Here's New Yorker Lisa Alpert.
225
632044
1746
10:34
(Audio) Lisa Alpert: I was bored, I guess.
226
634593
2164
10:36
So I suddenly looked at the stairway that went up to the top of the station,
227
636781
4605
10:41
and I thought, you know,
228
641410
1539
10:42
I had just come down that stairway, but I could go back up
229
642973
3261
10:46
and then come back down and get a little cardio.
230
646258
2485
10:48
So I did,
231
648767
1164
10:49
and then I had a little more time, so I did it again and I did it again,
232
649955
3841
10:53
and I did it 10 times.
233
653820
1806
10:55
And I had a complete cardio workout.
234
655650
2371
10:58
I got on that R train feeling kind of exhausted,
235
658045
2427
11:00
but, like, wow, that had never occurred to me.
236
660496
2664
11:03
How is that possible?
237
663184
1395
11:04
(Laughter)
238
664603
1104
11:05
MZ: So creativity, I learned, means different things to different people.
239
665731
3986
11:09
(Laughter)
240
669741
1000
11:10
But everyone found day three's challenge the hardest.
241
670765
3553
11:14
It was called "Delete that app."
242
674342
2216
11:16
Take that app -- you know the one;
243
676582
1877
11:18
that one that always gets you, it sucks you in --
244
678483
2776
11:21
take it off your phone,
245
681283
1163
11:22
even if just for the day.
246
682470
1388
11:23
I deleted the game Two Dots and nearly cried.
247
683882
3262
11:27
(Laughter)
248
687168
1046
11:28
Yeah, Two Dots players know what I'm talking about.
249
688238
2419
11:30
But my misery had good company.
250
690681
2516
11:36
(Audio) Man 2: This is Liam in Los Angeles,
251
696194
2252
11:38
and I deleted Twitter, Facebook, Instagram, Tumblr, Snapchat and Vine
252
698470
4833
11:43
from my phone
253
703327
1155
11:44
in one fell swoop.
254
704506
1601
11:46
And it was kind of an embarrassingly emotional experience at first.
255
706131
4641
11:50
It felt weirdly lonely to look at that lock screen
256
710796
3872
11:54
with no new notifications on it.
257
714692
2357
11:57
But I really liked deciding for myself
258
717073
3048
12:00
when to think about or access my social networks,
259
720145
3392
12:03
not giving my phone the power to decide that for me.
260
723561
3366
12:07
So thank you.
261
727559
1178
12:08
(Audio) Woman 3: Deleting the Twitter app was very sad,
262
728761
2691
12:11
and I feel I maybe, over the last year when I've been on Twitter,
263
731476
3538
12:15
have developed an addiction to it,
264
735038
1620
12:16
and this "Bored and Brilliant" challenge has really made me realize it.
265
736682
3388
12:20
After a brief period of really horrible withdrawal feeling,
266
740094
3132
12:23
like lack-of-caffeine headache,
267
743250
1969
12:25
I now feel lovely.
268
745243
1576
12:26
I had a lovely dinner with my family,
269
746843
1811
12:28
and I hope to continue this structured use of these powerful tools.
270
748678
4675
12:33
(Audio) Woman 4: I don't have that guilty gut feeling
271
753377
2499
12:35
I have when I know I'm wasting time on my phone.
272
755900
2295
12:38
Maybe I'll have to start giving myself challenges and reminders like this
273
758219
3502
12:41
every morning.
274
761745
1152
12:42
MZ: I mean, yes, this was progress.
275
762921
1693
12:44
I could not wait to see what the numbers said
276
764638
2467
12:47
at the end of that week.
277
767129
1664
12:49
But when the data came in,
278
769971
1903
12:51
it turned out that we had cut down,
279
771898
2273
12:54
on average,
280
774195
1238
12:55
just six minutes --
281
775457
2266
12:57
from 120 minutes a day on our phones
282
777747
2810
13:00
to 114.
283
780581
1837
13:03
Yeah. Whoop-de-do.
284
783474
1619
13:05
So I went back to the scientists feeling kind of low,
285
785117
3710
13:08
and they just laughed at me,
286
788851
1480
13:10
and they said, you know, changing people's behavior
287
790355
2431
13:12
in such a short time period
288
792810
1533
13:14
was ridiculously ambitious,
289
794367
2227
13:16
and actually what you've achieved is far beyond what we thought possible.
290
796618
5219
13:21
Because more important than the numbers, were the people's stories.
291
801861
3836
13:25
They felt empowered.
292
805721
1642
13:27
Their phones had been transformed
293
807387
2639
13:30
from taskmasters
294
810050
1729
13:31
back into tools.
295
811803
1622
13:34
And actually, I found what the young people said most intriguing.
296
814528
3950
13:38
Some of them told me
297
818502
1155
13:39
that they didn't recognize some of the emotions
298
819681
2262
13:41
that they felt during challenge week,
299
821967
1795
13:43
because, if you think about it,
300
823786
1487
13:45
if you have never known life without connectivity,
301
825297
2964
13:48
you may never have experienced boredom.
302
828285
2429
13:51
And there could be consequences.
303
831291
2066
13:53
Researchers at USC have found -- they're studying teenagers
304
833381
3429
13:56
who are on social media while they're talking to their friends
305
836834
2960
13:59
or they're doing homework,
306
839818
1286
14:01
and two years down the road, they are less creative and imaginative
307
841128
3815
14:04
about their own personal futures
308
844967
1854
14:06
and about solving societal problems, like violence in their neighborhoods.
309
846845
4213
14:11
And we really need this next generation
310
851511
2605
14:14
to be able to focus on some big problems:
311
854140
2226
14:16
climate change, economic disparity,
312
856390
2444
14:18
massive cultural differences.
313
858858
2037
14:21
No wonder CEOs in an IBM survey
314
861482
2721
14:24
identified creativity as the number one leadership competency.
315
864227
4613
14:30
OK, here's the good news, though:
316
870034
1668
14:31
In the end, 20,000 people did "Bored and Brilliant" that week.
317
871726
3771
14:35
Ninety percent cut down on their minutes.
318
875521
2432
14:37
Seventy percent got more time to think.
319
877977
2870
14:40
People told me that they slept better.
320
880871
2129
14:43
They felt happier.
321
883024
1317
14:44
My favorite note was from a guy who said he felt like he was waking up
322
884365
3624
14:48
from a mental hibernation.
323
888013
2179
14:51
Some personal data and some neuroscience
324
891961
2444
14:54
gave us permission to be offline a little bit more,
325
894429
3141
14:57
and a little bit of boredom gave us some clarity
326
897594
2943
15:00
and helped some of us set some goals.
327
900561
2319
15:03
I mean, maybe constant connectivity
328
903976
2111
15:06
won't be cool in a couple of years.
329
906111
2646
15:09
But meanwhile, teaching people, especially kids,
330
909893
3558
15:13
how to use technology to improve their lives
331
913475
3127
15:16
and to self-regulate
332
916626
1415
15:18
needs to be part of digital literacy.
333
918065
2575
15:22
So the next time you go to check your phone,
334
922505
2307
15:25
remember that if you don't decide how you're going to use the technology,
335
925452
4072
15:29
the platforms will decide for you.
336
929548
2318
15:32
And ask yourself:
337
932833
1581
15:34
What am I really looking for?
338
934438
1738
15:36
Because if it's to check email, that's fine -- do it and be done.
339
936200
3695
15:39
But if it's to distract yourself from doing the hard work
340
939919
2668
15:42
that comes with deeper thinking,
341
942611
2300
15:44
take a break,
342
944935
1408
15:46
stare out the window
343
946367
1398
15:48
and know that by doing nothing
344
948487
2845
15:51
you are actually being your most productive and creative self.
345
951356
4702
15:56
It might feel weird and uncomfortable at first,
346
956082
2723
15:58
but boredom truly can lead to brilliance.
347
958829
2886
16:02
Thank you.
348
962214
1152
16:03
(Applause)
349
963390
4787
About this website

This site will introduce you to YouTube videos that are useful for learning English. You will see English lessons taught by top-notch teachers from around the world. Double-click on the English subtitles displayed on each video page to play the video from there. The subtitles scroll in sync with the video playback. If you have any comments or requests, please contact us using this contact form.

https://forms.gle/WvT1wiN1qDtmnspy7