Who would the rest of the world vote for in your country's election? | Simon Anholt

65,764 views ・ 2017-04-14

TED


Please double-click on the English subtitles below to play the video.

00:12
Well, as many of you know,
0
12100
1535
00:13
the results of the recent election were as follows:
1
13659
2382
00:16
Hillary Clinton, the Democratic candidate
2
16980
2616
00:19
won a landslide victory
3
19620
1896
00:21
with 52 percent of the overall vote.
4
21540
2080
00:24
Jill Stein, the Green candidate,
5
24340
2256
00:26
came a distant second, with 19 percent.
6
26620
2600
00:29
Donald J. Trump, the Republic candidate,
7
29900
2456
00:32
was hot on her heels with 14 percent,
8
32380
2280
00:35
and the remainder of the vote were shared between abstainers
9
35500
3416
00:38
and Gary Johnson, the Libertarian candidate.
10
38940
3040
00:45
(Laughter)
11
45080
1570
00:47
Now, what parallel universe do you suppose I live in?
12
47180
3920
00:52
Well, I don't live in a parallel universe.
13
52580
2016
00:54
I live in the world, and that is how the world voted.
14
54620
2800
00:58
So let me take you back and explain what I mean by that.
15
58980
2640
01:02
In June this year,
16
62620
1216
01:03
I launched something called the Global Vote.
17
63860
2160
01:06
And the Global Vote does exactly what it says on the tin.
18
66620
3080
01:10
For the first time in history,
19
70460
1656
01:12
it lets anybody, anywhere in the world,
20
72140
2736
01:14
vote in the elections of other people's countries.
21
74900
3000
01:18
Now, why would you do that?
22
78860
1286
01:20
What's the point?
23
80940
1616
01:22
Well, let me show you what it looks like.
24
82580
2336
01:24
You go to a website,
25
84940
1400
01:27
rather a beautiful website,
26
87620
1286
01:29
and then you select an election.
27
89660
2816
01:32
Here's a bunch that we've already covered.
28
92500
2040
01:35
We do about one a month, or thereabouts.
29
95780
3136
01:38
So you can see Bulgaria, the United States of America,
30
98940
2816
01:41
Secretary-General of the United Nations,
31
101780
2496
01:44
the Brexit referendum at the end there.
32
104300
2936
01:47
You select the election that you're interested in,
33
107260
2776
01:50
and you pick the candidates.
34
110060
3256
01:53
These are the candidates from the recent presidential election
35
113340
2936
01:56
in the tiny island nation of São Tomé and Príncipe,
36
116300
3096
01:59
199,000 inhabitants,
37
119420
2376
02:01
off the coast of West Africa.
38
121820
1381
02:04
And then you can look at the brief summary of each of those candidates
39
124340
4496
02:08
which I dearly hope is very neutral,
40
128860
2496
02:11
very informative and very succinct.
41
131380
2816
02:14
And when you've found the one you like, you vote.
42
134220
2320
02:17
These were the candidates
43
137460
1536
02:19
in the recent Icelandic presidential election,
44
139020
2856
02:21
and that's the way it goes.
45
141900
1286
02:24
So why on earth would you want to vote in another country's election?
46
144740
4720
02:30
Well, the reason that you wouldn't want to do it,
47
150540
3096
02:33
let me reassure you,
48
153660
1216
02:34
is in order to interfere in the democratic processes of another country.
49
154900
3896
02:38
That's not the purpose at all.
50
158820
1656
02:40
In fact, you can't,
51
160500
1416
02:41
because usually what I do is I release the results
52
161940
2456
02:44
after the electorate in each individual country has already voted,
53
164420
3536
02:47
so there's no way that we could interfere in that process.
54
167980
2816
02:50
But more importantly,
55
170820
1376
02:52
I'm not particularly interested
56
172220
1576
02:53
in the domestic issues of individual countries.
57
173820
2256
02:56
That's not what we're voting on.
58
176100
1560
02:58
So what Donald J. Trump or Hillary Clinton proposed to do for the Americans
59
178500
3936
03:02
is frankly none of our business.
60
182460
2016
03:04
That's something that only the Americans can vote on.
61
184500
3016
03:07
No, in the global vote, you're only considering one aspect of it,
62
187540
3536
03:11
which is what are those leaders going to do for the rest of us?
63
191100
3200
03:15
And that's so very important because we live,
64
195300
2656
03:17
as no doubt you're sick of hearing people tell you,
65
197980
2416
03:20
in a globalized, hyperconnected, massively interdependent world
66
200420
4240
03:25
where the political decisions of people in other countries
67
205700
2736
03:28
can and will have an impact on our lives
68
208460
2216
03:30
no matter who we are, no matter where we live.
69
210700
2240
03:34
Like the wings of the butterfly
70
214260
1856
03:36
beating on one side of the Pacific
71
216140
2296
03:38
that can apparently create a hurricane on the other side,
72
218460
3536
03:42
so it is with the world that we live in today
73
222020
2656
03:44
and the world of politics.
74
224700
1696
03:46
There is no longer a dividing line between domestic and international affairs.
75
226420
4200
03:51
Any country, no matter how small,
76
231740
2416
03:54
even if it's São Tomé and Príncipe,
77
234180
2056
03:56
could produce the next Nelson Mandela
78
236260
2536
03:58
or the next Stalin.
79
238820
1200
04:01
They could pollute the atmosphere and the oceans, which belong to all of us,
80
241460
3976
04:05
or they could be responsible and they could help all of us.
81
245460
2920
04:09
And yet, the system is so strange
82
249420
3096
04:12
because the system hasn't caught up with this globalized reality.
83
252540
3696
04:16
Only a small number of people are allowed to vote for those leaders,
84
256260
3216
04:19
even though their impact is gigantic
85
259500
2056
04:21
and almost universal.
86
261580
1200
04:23
What number was it?
87
263860
1416
04:25
140 million Americans voted
88
265300
2536
04:27
for the next president of the United States,
89
267860
2256
04:30
and yet, as all of us knows, in a few weeks time,
90
270140
2935
04:33
somebody is going to hand over the nuclear launch codes
91
273099
2617
04:35
to Donald J. Trump.
92
275740
1200
04:37
Now, if that isn't having a potential impact on all of us,
93
277540
2816
04:40
I don't know what is.
94
280380
1200
04:42
Similarly, the election for the referendum on the Brexit vote,
95
282340
5720
04:49
a small number of millions of British people voted on that,
96
289020
3416
04:52
but the outcome of the vote, whichever way it went,
97
292460
2696
04:55
would have had a significant impact
98
295180
1696
04:56
on the lives of tens, hundreds of millions of people around the world.
99
296900
4416
05:01
And yet, only a tiny number could vote.
100
301340
1880
05:03
What kind of democracy is that?
101
303780
1480
05:06
Huge decisions that affect all of us
102
306420
1736
05:08
being decided by relatively very small numbers of people.
103
308180
3856
05:12
And I don't know about you,
104
312060
1336
05:13
but I don't think that sounds very democratic.
105
313420
2160
05:16
So I'm trying to clear it up.
106
316180
1776
05:17
But as I say,
107
317980
1456
05:19
we don't ask about domestic questions.
108
319460
1856
05:21
In fact, I only ever ask two questions of all of the candidates.
109
321340
3056
05:24
I send them the same two questions every single time.
110
324420
2496
05:26
I say, one,
111
326940
1416
05:28
if you get elected, what are you going to do for the rest of us,
112
328380
3136
05:31
for the remainder of the seven billion who live on this planet?
113
331540
3416
05:34
Second question:
114
334980
1936
05:36
What is your vision for your country's future in the world?
115
336940
3216
05:40
What role do you see it playing?
116
340180
1560
05:42
Every candidate, I send them those questions.
117
342380
2120
05:45
They don't all answer. Don't get me wrong.
118
345180
2096
05:47
I reckon if you're standing
119
347300
1776
05:49
to become the next president of the United States,
120
349100
2376
05:51
you're probably pretty tied up most of the time,
121
351500
2376
05:53
so I'm not altogether surprised that they don't all answer, but many do.
122
353900
4056
05:57
More every time.
123
357980
1496
05:59
And some of them do much more than answer.
124
359500
2056
06:01
Some of them answer in the most enthusiastic and most exciting way
125
361580
3136
06:04
you could imagine.
126
364740
1216
06:05
I just want to say a word here for Saviour Chishimba,
127
365980
2496
06:08
who was one of the candidates
128
368500
1416
06:09
in the recent Zambian presidential election.
129
369940
2256
06:12
His answers to those two questions were basically an 18-page dissertation
130
372220
4536
06:16
on his view of Zambia's potential role in the world
131
376780
3656
06:20
and in the international community.
132
380460
2016
06:22
I posted it on the website so anybody could read it.
133
382500
2440
06:25
Now, Saviour won the global vote,
134
385740
2320
06:28
but he didn't win the Zambian election.
135
388780
1880
06:31
So I found myself wondering,
136
391140
1376
06:32
what am I going to do with this extraordinary group of people?
137
392540
2936
06:35
I've got some wonderful people here who won the global vote.
138
395500
2856
06:38
We always get it wrong, by the way.
139
398380
1696
06:40
The one that we elect
140
400100
1216
06:41
is never the person who's elected by the domestic electorate.
141
401340
2880
06:45
That may be partly because we always seem to go for the woman.
142
405460
2920
06:49
But I think it may also be a sign
143
409220
2136
06:51
that the domestic electorate is still thinking very nationally.
144
411380
3576
06:54
They're still thinking very inwardly.
145
414980
2136
06:57
They're still asking themselves: What's in it for me? ...
146
417140
3496
07:00
instead of what they should be asking today,
147
420660
2096
07:02
which is, what's in it for we?
148
422780
1760
07:05
But there you go.
149
425820
1216
07:07
So suggestions, please, not right now,
150
427060
2136
07:09
but send me an email if you've got an idea
151
429220
2000
07:11
about what we can do with this amazing team of glorious losers.
152
431244
3276
07:14
(Laughter)
153
434520
1076
07:15
We've got Saviour Chishimba, who I mentioned before.
154
435620
2456
07:18
We've got Halla Tómasdóttir,
155
438100
1376
07:19
who was the runner up in the Icelandic presidential election.
156
439500
2896
07:22
Many of you may have seen her amazing talk at TEDWomen
157
442420
2696
07:25
just a few weeks ago
158
445140
1216
07:26
where she spoke about the need for more women to get into politics.
159
446380
3576
07:29
We've got Maria das Neves from São Tomé and Príncipe.
160
449980
2520
07:33
We've got Hillary Clinton.
161
453340
1616
07:34
I don't know if she's available.
162
454980
2056
07:37
We've got Jill Stein.
163
457060
1200
07:39
And we covered also the election
164
459300
2856
07:42
for the next Secretary-General of the United Nations.
165
462180
2480
07:45
We've got the ex-prime minister of New Zealand,
166
465285
2191
07:47
who would be a wonderful member of the team.
167
467500
2096
07:49
So I think maybe those people,
168
469620
1496
07:51
the glorious loser's club, could travel around the world
169
471140
2656
07:53
wherever there's an election
170
473820
1376
07:55
and remind people of the necessity in our modern age
171
475220
3376
07:58
of thinking a little bit outwards
172
478620
1616
08:00
and thinking of the international consequences.
173
480260
2191
08:04
So what comes next for the global vote?
174
484260
1896
08:06
Well, obviously,
175
486180
1776
08:07
the Donald and Hillary show is a bit of a difficult one to follow,
176
487980
4456
08:12
but there are some other really important elections coming up.
177
492460
2936
08:15
In fact, they seem to be multiplying.
178
495420
1816
08:17
There's something going on, I'm sure you've noticed, in the world.
179
497260
3136
08:20
And the next row of elections are all critically important.
180
500420
3240
08:25
In just a few day's time
181
505100
1496
08:26
we've got the rerun of the Austrian presidential election,
182
506620
3056
08:29
with the prospect of Norbert Hofer
183
509700
1776
08:31
becoming what is commonly described
184
511500
1976
08:33
as the first far-right head of state in Europe since the Second World War.
185
513500
3480
08:38
Next year we've got Germany,
186
518100
1416
08:39
we've got France,
187
519540
1216
08:40
we've got presidential elections in Iran
188
520780
2136
08:42
and a dozen others.
189
522940
1200
08:44
It doesn't get less important.
190
524739
2137
08:46
It gets more and more important.
191
526900
1599
08:50
Clearly, the global vote is not a stand-alone project.
192
530220
3776
08:54
It's not just there on its own.
193
534020
1479
08:56
It has some background.
194
536580
1256
08:57
It's part of a project which I launched back in 2014,
195
537860
4016
09:01
which I call the Good Country.
196
541900
1560
09:04
The idea of the Good Country is basically very simple.
197
544260
2560
09:07
It's my simple diagnosis of what's wrong with the world
198
547660
3456
09:11
and how we can fix it.
199
551140
1200
09:13
What's wrong with the world I've already hinted at.
200
553620
2416
09:16
Basically, we face an enormous and growing number
201
556060
2736
09:18
of gigantic, existential global challenges:
202
558820
3176
09:22
climate change, human rights abuses,
203
562020
2656
09:24
mass migration, terrorism, economic chaos, weapons proliferation.
204
564700
4200
09:29
All of these problems which threaten to wipe us out
205
569900
3176
09:33
are by their very nature globalized problems.
206
573100
2136
09:35
No individual country has the capability of tackling them on its own.
207
575260
4400
09:40
And so very obviously
208
580580
1736
09:42
we have to cooperate and we have to collaborate as nations
209
582340
3616
09:45
if we're going to solve these problems.
210
585980
1858
09:48
It's so obvious, and yet we don't.
211
588380
2360
09:51
We don't do it nearly often enough.
212
591700
1880
09:54
Most of the time, countries still persist in behaving
213
594460
3576
09:58
as if they were warring, selfish tribes battling against each other,
214
598060
4656
10:02
much as they have done since the nation-state was invented
215
602740
2736
10:05
hundreds of years ago.
216
605500
1576
10:07
And this has got to change.
217
607100
2136
10:09
This is not a change in political systems or a change in ideology.
218
609260
3336
10:12
This is a change in culture.
219
612620
1936
10:14
We, all of us, have to understand
220
614580
2000
10:17
that thinking inwards is not the solution to the world's problems.
221
617460
4016
10:21
We have to learn how to cooperate and collaborate a great deal more
222
621500
3976
10:25
and compete just a tiny bit less.
223
625500
2400
10:29
Otherwise things are going to carry on getting bad
224
629020
2376
10:31
and they're going to get much worse, much sooner than we anticipate.
225
631420
3200
10:35
This change will only happen
226
635580
1896
10:37
if we ordinary people
227
637500
1736
10:39
tell our politicians that things have changed.
228
639260
2816
10:42
We have to tell them that the culture has changed.
229
642100
2536
10:44
We have to tell them that they've got a new mandate.
230
644660
2576
10:47
The old mandate was very simple and very single:
231
647260
2896
10:50
if you're in a position of power or authority,
232
650180
2176
10:52
you're responsible for your own people and your own tiny slice of territory,
233
652380
3616
10:56
and that's it.
234
656020
1216
10:57
And if in order to do the best thing for your own people,
235
657260
2696
10:59
you screw over everybody else on the planet, that's even better.
236
659980
3056
11:03
That's considered to be a bit macho.
237
663060
1736
11:04
Today, I think everybody in a position of power and responsibility
238
664820
3376
11:08
has got a dual mandate,
239
668220
1616
11:09
which says if you're in a position of power and responsibility,
240
669860
2976
11:12
you're responsible for your own people
241
672860
1856
11:14
and for every single man, woman, child and animal on the planet.
242
674740
3240
11:19
You're responsible for your own slice of territory
243
679100
2376
11:21
and for every single square mile of the earth's surface
244
681500
3696
11:25
and the atmosphere above it.
245
685220
1376
11:26
And if you don't like that responsibility, you should not be in power.
246
686620
3336
11:29
That for me is the rule of the modern age,
247
689980
2056
11:32
and that's the message that we've got to get across to our politicians,
248
692060
3376
11:35
and show them that that's the way things are done these days.
249
695460
3296
11:38
Otherwise, we're all screwed.
250
698780
1680
11:41
I don't have a problem, actually,
251
701860
1616
11:43
with Donald Trump's credo of "America first."
252
703500
2936
11:46
It seems to me that that's a pretty banal statement
253
706460
2416
11:48
of what politicians have always done and probably should always do.
254
708900
3176
11:52
Of course they're elected to represent the interests of their own people.
255
712100
3440
11:56
But what I find so boring and so old-fashioned
256
716300
2976
11:59
and so unimaginative about his take on that
257
719300
2736
12:02
is that America first means everyone else last,
258
722060
2520
12:06
that making America great again means making everybody else small again,
259
726100
4176
12:10
and it's just not true.
260
730300
1200
12:12
In my job as a policy advisor over the last 20 years or so,
261
732460
2896
12:15
I've seen so many hundreds of examples of policies
262
735380
3616
12:19
that harmonize the international and the domestic needs,
263
739020
3536
12:22
and they make better policy.
264
742580
1976
12:24
I'm not asking nations to be altruistic or self-sacrificing.
265
744580
3576
12:28
That would be ridiculous.
266
748180
1336
12:29
No nation would ever do that.
267
749540
1400
12:31
I'm asking them to wake up and understand that we need a new form of governance,
268
751660
3816
12:35
which is possible
269
755500
1200
12:37
and which harmonizes those two needs,
270
757460
1816
12:39
those good for our own people and those good for everybody else.
271
759300
3040
12:43
Since the US election and since Brexit
272
763340
2216
12:45
it's become more and more obvious to me
273
765580
2376
12:47
that those old distinctions of left wing and right wing
274
767980
2616
12:50
no longer make sense.
275
770620
1296
12:51
They really don't fit the pattern.
276
771940
1640
12:54
What does seem to matter today
277
774580
2296
12:56
is very simple,
278
776900
1616
12:58
whether your view of the world is
279
778540
2176
13:00
that you take comfort from looking inwards and backwards,
280
780740
3696
13:04
or whether, like me, you find hope in looking forwards and outwards.
281
784460
4720
13:10
That's the new politics.
282
790060
1496
13:11
That's the new division that is splitting the world right down the middle.
283
791580
3640
13:16
Now, that may sound judgmental, but it's not meant to be.
284
796620
2896
13:19
I don't at all misunderstand
285
799540
1936
13:21
why so many people find their comfort in looking inwards and backwards.
286
801500
4120
13:26
When times are difficult, when you're short of money,
287
806380
2496
13:28
when you're feeling insecure and vulnerable,
288
808900
2096
13:31
it's almost a natural human tendency to turn inwards,
289
811020
2496
13:33
to think of your own needs
290
813540
2016
13:35
and to discard everybody else's,
291
815580
2096
13:37
and perhaps to start to imagine that the past was somehow better
292
817700
3736
13:41
than the present or the future could ever be.
293
821460
2400
13:44
But I happen to believe that that's a dead end.
294
824540
2456
13:47
History shows us that it's a dead end.
295
827020
2256
13:49
When people turn inwards and turn backwards,
296
829300
2136
13:51
human progress becomes reversed
297
831460
1776
13:53
and things get worse for everybody very quickly indeed.
298
833260
3560
13:58
If you're like me
299
838540
1416
13:59
and you believe in forwards and outwards,
300
839980
2696
14:02
and you believe that the best thing about humanity is its diversity,
301
842700
4696
14:07
and the best thing about globalization
302
847420
2776
14:10
is the way that it stirs up that diversity, that cultural mixture
303
850220
4296
14:14
to make something more creative, more exciting, more productive
304
854540
3016
14:17
than there's ever been before in human history,
305
857580
2936
14:20
then, my friends, we've got a job on our hands,
306
860540
2520
14:23
because the inwards and backwards brigade
307
863980
2896
14:26
are uniting as never before,
308
866900
2536
14:29
and that creed of inwards and backwards,
309
869460
1936
14:31
that fear, that anxiety,
310
871420
2560
14:34
playing on the simplest instincts,
311
874860
1816
14:36
is sweeping across the world.
312
876700
2536
14:39
Those of us who believe,
313
879260
1936
14:41
as I believe, in forwards and outwards,
314
881220
2736
14:43
we have to get ourselves organized,
315
883980
1880
14:46
because time is running out very, very quickly.
316
886900
3640
14:52
Thank you.
317
892060
1216
14:53
(Applause)
318
893300
1320
About this website

This site will introduce you to YouTube videos that are useful for learning English. You will see English lessons taught by top-notch teachers from around the world. Double-click on the English subtitles displayed on each video page to play the video from there. The subtitles scroll in sync with the video playback. If you have any comments or requests, please contact us using this contact form.

https://forms.gle/WvT1wiN1qDtmnspy7