How fear drives American politics | David Rothkopf | TED Talks

167,549 views ・ 2015-10-02

TED


Please double-click on the English subtitles below to play the video.

00:12
What I'd like to do is talk to you a little bit about fear
0
12879
3764
00:16
and the cost of fear
1
16667
1689
00:18
and the age of fear from which we are now emerging.
2
18380
3274
00:22
I would like you to feel comfortable with my doing that
3
22072
3975
00:26
by letting you know that I know something about fear and anxiety.
4
26071
5293
00:31
I'm a Jewish guy from New Jersey.
5
31388
2187
00:33
(Laughter)
6
33599
1484
00:35
I could worry before I could walk.
7
35107
2868
00:37
(Laughter)
8
37999
1506
00:39
Please, applaud that.
9
39529
2442
00:41
(Applause)
10
41995
2388
00:44
Thank you.
11
44407
1319
00:46
But I also grew up in a time where there was something to fear.
12
46954
4685
00:52
We were brought out in the hall when I was a little kid
13
52915
3261
00:56
and taught how to put our coats over our heads
14
56200
3450
00:59
to protect us from global thermonuclear war.
15
59674
3753
01:03
Now even my seven-year-old brain knew that wasn't going to work.
16
63838
4228
01:09
But I also knew
17
69179
1158
01:10
that global thermonuclear war was something to be concerned with.
18
70361
4724
01:15
And yet, despite the fact that we lived for 50 years
19
75109
4161
01:19
with the threat of such a war,
20
79294
2363
01:21
the response of our government and of our society
21
81681
3981
01:25
was to do wonderful things.
22
85686
1880
01:28
We created the space program in response to that.
23
88220
2998
01:31
We built our highway system in response to that.
24
91242
3097
01:34
We created the Internet in response to that.
25
94363
3547
01:37
So sometimes fear can produce a constructive response.
26
97934
4193
01:42
But sometimes it can produce an un-constructive response.
27
102847
3322
01:47
On September 11, 2001,
28
107066
2909
01:49
19 guys took over four airplanes
29
109999
4511
01:54
and flew them into a couple of buildings.
30
114534
2288
01:57
They exacted a horrible toll.
31
117667
2460
02:00
It is not for us to minimize what that toll was.
32
120151
4000
02:04
But the response that we had was clearly disproportionate --
33
124965
6983
02:11
disproportionate to the point of verging on the unhinged.
34
131972
4878
02:16
We rearranged the national security apparatus of the United States
35
136874
3902
02:20
and of many governments
36
140800
1840
02:22
to address a threat that, at the time that those attacks took place,
37
142664
4718
02:27
was quite limited.
38
147406
1303
02:28
In fact, according to our intelligence services,
39
148733
3431
02:32
on September 11, 2001,
40
152188
3368
02:35
there were 100 members of core Al-Qaeda.
41
155580
3229
02:39
There were just a few thousand terrorists.
42
159414
2490
02:42
They posed an existential threat
43
162357
3114
02:45
to no one.
44
165495
1169
02:47
But we rearranged our entire national security apparatus
45
167561
4576
02:52
in the most sweeping way since the end of the Second World War.
46
172161
4081
02:56
We launched two wars.
47
176577
1839
02:58
We spent trillions of dollars.
48
178440
2333
03:00
We suspended our values.
49
180797
2177
03:02
We violated international law.
50
182998
1851
03:04
We embraced torture.
51
184873
1232
03:06
We embraced the idea
52
186129
1673
03:07
that if these 19 guys could do this, anybody could do it.
53
187826
3071
03:11
And therefore, for the first time in history,
54
191385
2856
03:14
we were seeing everybody as a threat.
55
194265
2948
03:17
And what was the result of that?
56
197237
1852
03:19
Surveillance programs that listened in on the emails and phone calls
57
199113
4008
03:23
of entire countries --
58
203145
2165
03:25
hundreds of millions of people --
59
205334
2406
03:27
setting aside whether those countries were our allies,
60
207764
3023
03:30
setting aside what our interests were.
61
210811
2448
03:34
I would argue that 15 years later,
62
214735
3278
03:38
since today there are more terrorists,
63
218037
2393
03:40
more terrorist attacks, more terrorist casualties --
64
220454
3542
03:44
this by the count of the U.S. State Department --
65
224020
3340
03:47
since today the region from which those attacks emanate
66
227384
3069
03:50
is more unstable than at any time in its history,
67
230477
3689
03:54
since the Flood, perhaps,
68
234190
3680
03:57
we have not succeeded in our response.
69
237894
3763
04:02
Now you have to ask, where did we go wrong?
70
242206
2007
04:04
What did we do? What was the mistake that was made?
71
244237
2450
04:06
And you might say, well look, Washington is a dysfunctional place.
72
246711
4129
04:10
There are political food fights.
73
250864
1694
04:12
We've turned our discourse into a cage match.
74
252582
3563
04:16
And that's true.
75
256169
1282
04:18
But there are bigger problems, believe it or not, than that dysfunction,
76
258039
3414
04:21
even though I would argue
77
261477
1868
04:23
that dysfunction that makes it impossible to get anything done
78
263369
4651
04:28
in the richest and most powerful country in the world
79
268044
3681
04:31
is far more dangerous than anything that a group like ISIS could do,
80
271749
5649
04:37
because it stops us in our tracks and it keeps us from progress.
81
277422
3624
04:42
But there are other problems.
82
282183
1472
04:44
And the other problems
83
284127
1164
04:45
came from the fact that in Washington and in many capitals right now,
84
285315
3556
04:48
we're in a creativity crisis.
85
288895
1791
04:51
In Washington, in think tanks,
86
291108
2647
04:53
where people are supposed to be thinking of new ideas,
87
293779
3118
04:56
you don't get bold new ideas,
88
296921
2066
04:59
because if you offer up a bold new idea,
89
299011
2867
05:01
not only are you attacked on Twitter,
90
301902
1852
05:03
but you will not get confirmed in a government job.
91
303778
3351
05:07
Because we are reactive to the heightened venom of the political debate,
92
307153
5229
05:12
you get governments that have an us-versus-them mentality,
93
312406
3110
05:15
tiny groups of people making decisions.
94
315540
2397
05:17
When you sit in a room with a small group of people making decisions,
95
317961
3282
05:21
what do you get?
96
321267
1159
05:22
You get groupthink.
97
322450
1640
05:24
Everybody has the same worldview,
98
324114
1589
05:25
and any view from outside of the group is seen as a threat.
99
325727
3266
05:29
That's a danger.
100
329366
1230
05:31
You also have processes that become reactive to news cycles.
101
331258
4261
05:35
And so the parts of the U.S. government that do foresight, that look forward,
102
335543
4293
05:39
that do strategy --
103
339860
1155
05:41
the parts in other governments that do this -- can't do it,
104
341039
2763
05:43
because they're reacting to the news cycle.
105
343826
2158
05:46
And so we're not looking ahead.
106
346383
1904
05:48
On 9/11, we had a crisis because we were looking the wrong way.
107
348311
3798
05:52
Today we have a crisis because, because of 9/11,
108
352527
3427
05:55
we are still looking in the wrong direction,
109
355978
2651
05:58
and we know because we see transformational trends on the horizon
110
358653
5848
06:04
that are far more important than what we saw on 9/11;
111
364525
4852
06:09
far more important than the threat posed by these terrorists;
112
369401
3802
06:13
far more important even than the instability that we've got
113
373227
3250
06:16
in some areas of the world that are racked by instability today.
114
376501
4251
06:21
In fact, the things that we are seeing in those parts of the world
115
381161
4660
06:25
may be symptoms.
116
385845
2614
06:28
They may be a reaction to bigger trends.
117
388883
3478
06:32
And if we are treating the symptom and ignoring the bigger trend,
118
392385
4704
06:37
then we've got far bigger problems to deal with.
119
397113
3064
06:41
And so what are those trends?
120
401415
1497
06:43
Well, to a group like you,
121
403510
1777
06:45
the trends are apparent.
122
405311
1491
06:48
We are living at a moment in which the very fabric of human society
123
408444
5255
06:53
is being rewoven.
124
413723
1789
06:57
If you saw the cover of The Economist a couple of days ago --
125
417057
3220
07:00
it said that 80 percent of the people on the planet,
126
420301
3546
07:03
by the year 2020, would have a smartphone.
127
423871
2933
07:07
They would have a small computer connected to the Internet in their pocket.
128
427564
3853
07:11
In most of Africa, the cell phone penetration rate is 80 percent.
129
431808
4525
07:17
We passed the point last October
130
437749
2664
07:20
when there were more mobile cellular devices, SIM cards,
131
440437
3971
07:24
out in the world than there were people.
132
444432
2116
07:27
We are within years of a profound moment in our history,
133
447166
5896
07:33
when effectively every single human being on the planet
134
453086
5357
07:38
is going to be part of a man-made system for the first time,
135
458467
4608
07:43
able to touch anyone else --
136
463099
2041
07:45
touch them for good, touch them for ill.
137
465164
2362
07:47
And the changes associated with that are changing the very nature
138
467999
5826
07:53
of every aspect of governance and life on the planet
139
473849
3601
07:57
in ways that our leaders ought to be thinking about,
140
477474
3446
08:00
when they're thinking about these immediate threats.
141
480944
2480
08:03
On the security side,
142
483824
1766
08:05
we've come out of a Cold War in which it was too costly to fight a nuclear war,
143
485614
5504
08:11
and so we didn't,
144
491142
1534
08:12
to a period that I call Cool War, cyber war,
145
492700
3817
08:16
where the costs of conflict are actually so low, that we may never stop.
146
496541
5051
08:22
We may enter a period of constant warfare,
147
502137
2726
08:24
and we know this because we've been in it for several years.
148
504887
4411
08:29
And yet, we don't have the basic doctrines to guide us in this regard.
149
509322
5551
08:35
We don't have the basic ideas formulated.
150
515255
2091
08:37
If someone attacks us with a cyber attack,
151
517370
2540
08:39
do have the ability to respond with a kinetic attack?
152
519934
3115
08:43
We don't know.
153
523787
1207
08:45
If somebody launches a cyber attack, how do we deter them?
154
525573
4085
08:49
When China launched a series of cyber attacks,
155
529682
2187
08:51
what did the U.S. government do?
156
531893
1527
08:53
It said, we're going to indict a few of these Chinese guys,
157
533444
3985
08:57
who are never coming to America.
158
537453
1742
08:59
They're never going to be anywhere near a law enforcement officer
159
539897
3949
09:03
who's going to take them into custody.
160
543870
2005
09:06
It's a gesture -- it's not a deterrent.
161
546252
2890
09:09
Special forces operators out there in the field today
162
549678
3798
09:13
discover that small groups of insurgents with cell phones
163
553500
4871
09:18
have access to satellite imagery that once only superpowers had.
164
558395
5271
09:23
In fact, if you've got a cell phone,
165
563690
2167
09:25
you've got access to power that a superpower didn't have,
166
565881
3316
09:29
and would have highly classified 10 years ago.
167
569221
2155
09:31
In my cell phone, I have an app that tells me
168
571400
2891
09:34
where every plane in the world is, and its altitude, and its speed,
169
574315
4540
09:38
and what kind of aircraft it is,
170
578879
1822
09:40
and where it's going and where it's landing.
171
580725
2916
09:44
They have apps that allow them to know
172
584429
4549
09:49
what their adversary is about to do.
173
589002
2219
09:51
They're using these tools in new ways.
174
591245
2376
09:53
When a cafe in Sydney was taken over by a terrorist,
175
593645
4114
09:57
he went in with a rifle...
176
597783
2293
10:00
and an iPad.
177
600100
1243
10:01
And the weapon was the iPad.
178
601936
2561
10:04
Because he captured people, he terrorized them,
179
604999
3299
10:08
he pointed the iPad at them,
180
608322
2705
10:11
and then he took the video and he put it on the Internet,
181
611051
2672
10:13
and he took over the world's media.
182
613747
2023
10:17
But it doesn't just affect the security side.
183
617861
3468
10:22
The relations between great powers --
184
622132
1829
10:23
we thought we were past the bipolar era.
185
623985
2365
10:27
We thought we were in a unipolar world,
186
627259
1874
10:29
where all the big issues were resolved.
187
629157
1894
10:31
Remember? It was the end of history.
188
631075
1717
10:34
But we're not.
189
634129
1296
10:35
We're now seeing that our basic assumptions about the Internet --
190
635449
4388
10:39
that it was going to connect us, weave society together --
191
639861
4061
10:43
are not necessarily true.
192
643946
1656
10:46
In countries like China, you have the Great Firewall of China.
193
646083
3196
10:49
You've got countries saying no, if the Internet happens within our borders
194
649303
3520
10:52
we control it within our borders.
195
652847
1575
10:54
We control the content. We are going to control our security.
196
654446
2860
10:57
We are going to manage that Internet.
197
657330
1766
10:59
We are going to say what can be on it.
198
659120
1813
11:00
We're going to set a different set of rules.
199
660957
2051
11:03
Now you might think, well, that's just China.
200
663032
2097
11:05
But it's not just China.
201
665153
1714
11:07
It's China, India, Russia.
202
667651
2729
11:10
It's Saudi Arabia, it's Singapore, it's Brazil.
203
670708
3100
11:13
After the NSA scandal, the Russians, the Chinese, the Indians, the Brazilians,
204
673832
4514
11:18
they said, let's create a new Internet backbone,
205
678370
3055
11:21
because we can't be dependent on this other one.
206
681449
2482
11:23
And so all of a sudden, what do you have?
207
683955
1969
11:26
You have a new bipolar world
208
686400
2499
11:28
in which cyber-internationalism,
209
688923
2191
11:31
our belief,
210
691138
1151
11:32
is challenged by cyber-nationalism,
211
692313
2837
11:35
another belief.
212
695174
1265
11:37
We are seeing these changes everywhere we look.
213
697593
3171
11:41
We are seeing the advent of mobile money.
214
701629
1978
11:43
It's happening in the places you wouldn't expect.
215
703631
2297
11:45
It's happening in Kenya and Tanzania,
216
705952
2377
11:48
where millions of people who haven't had access to financial services
217
708353
3269
11:51
now conduct all those services on their phones.
218
711646
2495
11:54
There are 2.5 million people who don't have financial service access
219
714702
4500
11:59
that are going to get it soon.
220
719226
2016
12:01
A billion of them are going to have the ability to access it
221
721740
2813
12:04
on their cell phone soon.
222
724577
1195
12:05
It's not just going to give them the ability to bank.
223
725796
2853
12:08
It's going to change what monetary policy is.
224
728957
2877
12:11
It's going to change what money is.
225
731858
2636
12:15
Education is changing in the same way.
226
735262
2171
12:18
Healthcare is changing in the same way.
227
738430
2461
12:20
How government services are delivered is changing in the same way.
228
740915
3494
12:25
And yet, in Washington, we are debating
229
745607
4262
12:29
whether to call the terrorist group that has taken over Syria and Iraq
230
749893
5465
12:35
ISIS or ISIL or Islamic State.
231
755382
4160
12:40
We are trying to determine
232
760540
3111
12:43
how much we want to give in a negotiation with the Iranians
233
763675
5289
12:48
on a nuclear deal which deals with the technologies of 50 years ago,
234
768988
4799
12:53
when in fact, we know that the Iranians right now are engaged in cyber war with us
235
773811
5358
12:59
and we're ignoring it, partially because businesses are not willing
236
779193
6034
13:05
to talk about the attacks that are being waged on them.
237
785251
3118
13:09
And that gets us to another breakdown
238
789399
2809
13:12
that's crucial,
239
792232
1224
13:13
and another breakdown that couldn't be more important to a group like this,
240
793480
3711
13:17
because the growth of America and real American national security
241
797215
3652
13:20
and all of the things that drove progress even during the Cold War,
242
800891
4441
13:25
was a public-private partnership between science, technology and government
243
805356
4751
13:30
that began when Thomas Jefferson sat alone in his laboratory
244
810131
3508
13:33
inventing new things.
245
813663
1843
13:36
But it was the canals and railroads and telegraph;
246
816528
3810
13:40
it was radar and the Internet.
247
820362
2316
13:43
It was Tang, the breakfast drink --
248
823129
2284
13:45
probably not the most important of those developments.
249
825437
2877
13:48
But what you had was a partnership and a dialogue,
250
828795
2879
13:51
and the dialogue has broken down.
251
831698
2265
13:53
It's broken down because in Washington,
252
833987
2379
13:56
less government is considered more.
253
836390
1766
13:58
It's broken down because there is, believe it or not,
254
838180
2479
14:00
in Washington, a war on science --
255
840683
1840
14:02
despite the fact that in all of human history,
256
842547
3039
14:05
every time anyone has waged a war on science,
257
845610
2960
14:08
science has won.
258
848594
1601
14:11
(Applause)
259
851463
4927
14:16
But we have a government that doesn't want to listen,
260
856712
4196
14:20
that doesn't have people at the highest levels
261
860932
2159
14:23
that understand this.
262
863115
1154
14:24
In the nuclear age,
263
864293
1151
14:25
when there were people in senior national security jobs,
264
865468
3167
14:28
they were expected to speak throw-weight.
265
868659
3028
14:32
They were expected to know the lingo, the vocabulary.
266
872005
3018
14:35
If you went to the highest level of the U.S. government now
267
875047
2799
14:37
and said, "Talk to me about cyber, about neuroscience,
268
877870
2533
14:40
about the things that are going to change the world of tomorrow,"
269
880427
3140
14:43
you'd get a blank stare.
270
883591
1151
14:44
I know, because when I wrote this book,
271
884766
1921
14:46
I talked to 150 people, many from the science and tech side,
272
886711
3040
14:49
who felt like they were being shunted off to the kids' table.
273
889775
3056
14:53
Meanwhile, on the tech side,
274
893389
2082
14:55
we have lots of wonderful people creating wonderful things,
275
895495
3805
14:59
but they started in garages and they didn't need the government
276
899324
2957
15:02
and they don't want the government.
277
902305
1673
15:04
Many of them have a political view that's somewhere between
278
904002
2767
15:06
libertarian and anarchic:
279
906793
1894
15:08
leave me alone.
280
908711
1361
15:11
But the world's coming apart.
281
911305
1814
15:13
All of a sudden, there are going to be massive regulatory changes
282
913668
3389
15:17
and massive issues associated with conflict
283
917081
2918
15:20
and massive issues associated with security and privacy.
284
920023
4285
15:24
And we haven't even gotten to the next set of issues,
285
924332
2495
15:26
which are philosophical issues.
286
926841
1974
15:29
If you can't vote, if you can't have a job,
287
929601
2822
15:32
if you can't bank, if you can't get health care,
288
932447
2492
15:34
if you can't be educated without Internet access,
289
934963
2442
15:37
is Internet access a fundamental right that should be written into constitutions?
290
937429
4911
15:42
If Internet access is a fundamental right,
291
942364
3171
15:45
is electricity access for the 1.2 billion who don't have access to electricity
292
945559
4158
15:49
a fundamental right?
293
949741
1417
15:51
These are fundamental issues. Where are the philosophers?
294
951500
3029
15:54
Where's the dialogue?
295
954553
1660
15:57
And that brings me to the reason that I'm here.
296
957590
2516
16:00
I live in Washington. Pity me.
297
960559
2518
16:03
(Laughter)
298
963101
1770
16:04
The dialogue isn't happening there.
299
964895
2267
16:07
These big issues that will change the world,
300
967932
2395
16:10
change national security, change economics,
301
970351
2648
16:13
create hope, create threats,
302
973023
2883
16:15
can only be resolved when you bring together
303
975930
2714
16:18
groups of people who understand science and technology
304
978668
3381
16:22
back together with government.
305
982073
1673
16:23
Both sides need each other.
306
983770
2180
16:26
And until we recreate that connection,
307
986486
4752
16:31
until we do what helped America grow and helped other countries grow,
308
991262
5431
16:36
then we are going to grow ever more vulnerable.
309
996717
3070
16:40
The risks associated with 9/11 will not be measured
310
1000547
3811
16:44
in terms of lives lost by terror attacks
311
1004382
3006
16:47
or buildings destroyed or trillions of dollars spent.
312
1007412
4085
16:52
They'll be measured in terms of the costs of our distraction from critical issues
313
1012040
4903
16:56
and our inability to get together
314
1016967
3733
17:00
scientists, technologists, government leaders,
315
1020724
4196
17:04
at a moment of transformation akin to the beginning of the Renaissance,
316
1024944
5135
17:10
akin to the beginning of the major transformational eras
317
1030103
3718
17:13
that have happened on Earth,
318
1033845
2489
17:16
and start coming up with, if not the right answers,
319
1036358
4446
17:20
then at least the right questions.
320
1040828
2353
17:23
We are not there yet,
321
1043205
2043
17:25
but discussions like this and groups like you
322
1045272
3064
17:28
are the places where those questions can be formulated and posed.
323
1048360
3786
17:32
And that's why I believe that groups like TED,
324
1052553
4554
17:37
discussions like this around the planet,
325
1057131
2593
17:39
are the place where the future of foreign policy, of economic policy,
326
1059748
4710
17:44
of social policy, of philosophy, will ultimately take place.
327
1064482
5487
17:50
And that's why it's been a pleasure speaking to you.
328
1070394
2430
17:52
Thank you very, very much.
329
1072848
1255
17:54
(Applause)
330
1074127
4866
About this website

This site will introduce you to YouTube videos that are useful for learning English. You will see English lessons taught by top-notch teachers from around the world. Double-click on the English subtitles displayed on each video page to play the video from there. The subtitles scroll in sync with the video playback. If you have any comments or requests, please contact us using this contact form.

https://forms.gle/WvT1wiN1qDtmnspy7