Do 9 out of 10 dentists really recommend that toothpaste? | Am I Normal? with Mona Chalabi

Transcriber:

When it comes to toothpaste commercials,

you've probably heard claims like,

nine out of 10 dentists recommend "Brighter, Whiter."

Or maybe it's four out of five or 80 percent.

But either way, these companies expect you to see a wall of white coats,

trust their authority and think no further.

Now that approach is basically BS, and you probably know it's BS,

but the question is: How can you trust your BS radar?

[Am I Normal? with Mona Chalabi]

Well, when I'm faced with suspicious statistics,

I tend to ask myself three questions.

First, what were people actually asked?

Sometimes the question that is put to survey respondents

is wildly different than the one that ends up on posters and billboards.

For instance, in 2007, one toothpaste ad in the UK

claimed that more than 80 percent of dentists recommended their products.

What that sounds like

is that a majority of dentists prefer their product over all others,

that those dentists were asked if this was the best product.

But when the Advertising Standards Authority looked into it,

they discovered that the dentists were asked to recommend several toothpastes,

not one single choice.

In fact, another brand was found to be almost as popular.

To no one's surprise, the ad was deemed misleading.

Now, the second question to ask is: What aren’t you telling me?

In the 1970s, a sugarless gum company claimed that four out five dentists

recommended their product.

Now, their slogan was pretty upfront

about the fact that these dentists were only recommending the product

to people who already chewed gum,

but they weren't so forthcoming about the fifth dentist.

Decades later, the manufacturer made fun of it in a new ad campaign

where they blamed the fifth dentist's different thinking

on a freak accident, like a sudden squirrel bite.

Now, since I'm all about the deviations in the data,

I decided to look into this a little bit further.

In fact, it's not that the fifth dentist recommended chewing sugary gum.

What they don't say is that most of them recommended

that their patients don't chew gum at all.

The last thing to ask is: What was the survey context?

Because there's a really big difference

between saying "nine out of 10 dentists agree,"

and "nine out of these 10 dentists agree."

Size matters and so does methodology.

According to the American Dental Association,

there are about 200,000 registered dentists in the US.

I’m not going to bore you with the maths here,

but to get a statistically significant sample of 200,000 people,

you need about 400.

So if you're reading in the fine print that only 50 dentists were surveyed,

you know that's not statistically significant.

It's just a marketing ploy.

So the next time you see one of these ads,

ask yourself:

What were people actually asked?

What's gone unsaid?

And what was the survey context?

Hopefully, with those three questions and a little bit of skepticism,

you will be able to understand when the data is legit

and when it's irrelevant.

Nine out of 10 Monas agree.

[*No such survey took place]