Alex Wissner-Gross: A new equation for intelligence

198,751 views ・ 2014-02-06

TED


Please double-click on the English subtitles below to play the video.

00:12
Intelligence -- what is it?
0
12899
3667
00:16
If we take a look back at the history
1
16566
2291
00:18
of how intelligence has been viewed,
2
18857
2624
00:21
one seminal example has been
3
21481
3618
00:25
Edsger Dijkstra's famous quote that
4
25099
3477
00:28
"the question of whether a machine can think
5
28576
3111
00:31
is about as interesting
6
31687
1310
00:32
as the question of whether a submarine
7
32997
2971
00:35
can swim."
8
35968
1790
00:37
Now, Edsger Dijkstra, when he wrote this,
9
37758
3844
00:41
intended it as a criticism
10
41602
2054
00:43
of the early pioneers of computer science,
11
43656
3000
00:46
like Alan Turing.
12
46656
1747
00:48
However, if you take a look back
13
48403
2499
00:50
and think about what have been
14
50902
1965
00:52
the most empowering innovations
15
52867
1996
00:54
that enabled us to build
16
54863
1879
00:56
artificial machines that swim
17
56742
2234
00:58
and artificial machines that [fly],
18
58976
2573
01:01
you find that it was only through understanding
19
61549
3547
01:05
the underlying physical mechanisms
20
65096
2608
01:07
of swimming and flight
21
67704
2779
01:10
that we were able to build these machines.
22
70483
3172
01:13
And so, several years ago,
23
73655
2256
01:15
I undertook a program to try to understand
24
75911
3249
01:19
the fundamental physical mechanisms
25
79160
2634
01:21
underlying intelligence.
26
81794
2768
01:24
Let's take a step back.
27
84562
1860
01:26
Let's first begin with a thought experiment.
28
86422
3149
01:29
Pretend that you're an alien race
29
89571
2854
01:32
that doesn't know anything about Earth biology
30
92425
3041
01:35
or Earth neuroscience or Earth intelligence,
31
95466
3116
01:38
but you have amazing telescopes
32
98582
2192
01:40
and you're able to watch the Earth,
33
100774
2362
01:43
and you have amazingly long lives,
34
103136
2332
01:45
so you're able to watch the Earth
35
105468
1499
01:46
over millions, even billions of years.
36
106967
3442
01:50
And you observe a really strange effect.
37
110409
3015
01:53
You observe that, over the course of the millennia,
38
113424
4312
01:57
Earth is continually bombarded with asteroids
39
117736
4285
02:02
up until a point,
40
122021
2087
02:04
and that at some point,
41
124108
1531
02:05
corresponding roughly to our year, 2000 AD,
42
125639
4192
02:09
asteroids that are on
43
129831
1716
02:11
a collision course with the Earth
44
131547
1931
02:13
that otherwise would have collided
45
133478
1975
02:15
mysteriously get deflected
46
135453
2415
02:17
or they detonate before they can hit the Earth.
47
137868
3072
02:20
Now of course, as earthlings,
48
140940
2083
02:23
we know the reason would be
49
143023
1544
02:24
that we're trying to save ourselves.
50
144567
1756
02:26
We're trying to prevent an impact.
51
146323
3080
02:29
But if you're an alien race
52
149403
1711
02:31
who doesn't know any of this,
53
151114
1146
02:32
doesn't have any concept of Earth intelligence,
54
152260
2514
02:34
you'd be forced to put together
55
154774
1728
02:36
a physical theory that explains how,
56
156502
2918
02:39
up until a certain point in time,
57
159420
2538
02:41
asteroids that would demolish the surface of a planet
58
161958
4449
02:46
mysteriously stop doing that.
59
166407
3231
02:49
And so I claim that this is the same question
60
169638
4204
02:53
as understanding the physical nature of intelligence.
61
173842
3998
02:57
So in this program that I undertook several years ago,
62
177840
3882
03:01
I looked at a variety of different threads
63
181722
2765
03:04
across science, across a variety of disciplines,
64
184487
3162
03:07
that were pointing, I think,
65
187649
1892
03:09
towards a single, underlying mechanism
66
189541
2548
03:12
for intelligence.
67
192089
1581
03:13
In cosmology, for example,
68
193670
2546
03:16
there have been a variety of different threads of evidence
69
196216
2747
03:18
that our universe appears to be finely tuned
70
198963
3407
03:22
for the development of intelligence,
71
202370
2153
03:24
and, in particular, for the development
72
204523
2389
03:26
of universal states
73
206912
1886
03:28
that maximize the diversity of possible futures.
74
208798
4098
03:32
In game play, for example, in Go --
75
212896
2344
03:35
everyone remembers in 1997
76
215240
3025
03:38
when IBM's Deep Blue beat Garry Kasparov at chess --
77
218265
3951
03:42
fewer people are aware
78
222216
1523
03:43
that in the past 10 years or so,
79
223739
2018
03:45
the game of Go,
80
225757
1198
03:46
arguably a much more challenging game
81
226955
1956
03:48
because it has a much higher branching factor,
82
228911
2425
03:51
has also started to succumb
83
231336
1702
03:53
to computer game players
84
233038
1865
03:54
for the same reason:
85
234903
1573
03:56
the best techniques right now for computers playing Go
86
236476
2800
03:59
are techniques that try to maximize future options
87
239276
3696
04:02
during game play.
88
242972
2014
04:04
Finally, in robotic motion planning,
89
244986
3581
04:08
there have been a variety of recent techniques
90
248567
2182
04:10
that have tried to take advantage
91
250749
1902
04:12
of abilities of robots to maximize
92
252651
3146
04:15
future freedom of action
93
255797
1506
04:17
in order to accomplish complex tasks.
94
257303
3097
04:20
And so, taking all of these different threads
95
260400
2355
04:22
and putting them together,
96
262755
1622
04:24
I asked, starting several years ago,
97
264377
2640
04:27
is there an underlying mechanism for intelligence
98
267017
2850
04:29
that we can factor out
99
269867
1673
04:31
of all of these different threads?
100
271540
1774
04:33
Is there a single equation for intelligence?
101
273314
4593
04:37
And the answer, I believe, is yes. ["F = T ∇ Sτ"]
102
277907
3371
04:41
What you're seeing is probably
103
281278
1913
04:43
the closest equivalent to an E = mc²
104
283191
3294
04:46
for intelligence that I've seen.
105
286485
2830
04:49
So what you're seeing here
106
289315
1702
04:51
is a statement of correspondence
107
291017
2669
04:53
that intelligence is a force, F,
108
293686
4435
04:58
that acts so as to maximize future freedom of action.
109
298121
4650
05:02
It acts to maximize future freedom of action,
110
302771
2375
05:05
or keep options open,
111
305146
1628
05:06
with some strength T,
112
306774
2225
05:08
with the diversity of possible accessible futures, S,
113
308999
4777
05:13
up to some future time horizon, tau.
114
313776
2550
05:16
In short, intelligence doesn't like to get trapped.
115
316326
3209
05:19
Intelligence tries to maximize future freedom of action
116
319535
3055
05:22
and keep options open.
117
322590
2673
05:25
And so, given this one equation,
118
325263
2433
05:27
it's natural to ask, so what can you do with this?
119
327696
2532
05:30
How predictive is it?
120
330228
1351
05:31
Does it predict human-level intelligence?
121
331579
2135
05:33
Does it predict artificial intelligence?
122
333714
2818
05:36
So I'm going to show you now a video
123
336532
2042
05:38
that will, I think, demonstrate
124
338574
3420
05:41
some of the amazing applications
125
341994
2288
05:44
of just this single equation.
126
344282
2319
05:46
(Video) Narrator: Recent research in cosmology
127
346601
1979
05:48
has suggested that universes that produce
128
348580
2047
05:50
more disorder, or "entropy," over their lifetimes
129
350627
3481
05:54
should tend to have more favorable conditions
130
354108
2478
05:56
for the existence of intelligent beings such as ourselves.
131
356586
3016
05:59
But what if that tentative cosmological connection
132
359602
2574
06:02
between entropy and intelligence
133
362176
1843
06:04
hints at a deeper relationship?
134
364019
1771
06:05
What if intelligent behavior doesn't just correlate
135
365790
2564
06:08
with the production of long-term entropy,
136
368354
1844
06:10
but actually emerges directly from it?
137
370198
2318
06:12
To find out, we developed a software engine
138
372516
2406
06:14
called Entropica, designed to maximize
139
374922
2503
06:17
the production of long-term entropy
140
377425
1768
06:19
of any system that it finds itself in.
141
379193
2576
06:21
Amazingly, Entropica was able to pass
142
381769
2155
06:23
multiple animal intelligence tests, play human games,
143
383924
3456
06:27
and even earn money trading stocks,
144
387380
2146
06:29
all without being instructed to do so.
145
389526
2111
06:31
Here are some examples of Entropica in action.
146
391637
2518
06:34
Just like a human standing upright without falling over,
147
394155
3205
06:37
here we see Entropica
148
397360
1230
06:38
automatically balancing a pole using a cart.
149
398590
2885
06:41
This behavior is remarkable in part
150
401475
2012
06:43
because we never gave Entropica a goal.
151
403487
2331
06:45
It simply decided on its own to balance the pole.
152
405818
3157
06:48
This balancing ability will have appliactions
153
408975
2132
06:51
for humanoid robotics
154
411107
1397
06:52
and human assistive technologies.
155
412504
2515
06:55
Just as some animals can use objects
156
415019
2001
06:57
in their environments as tools
157
417020
1442
06:58
to reach into narrow spaces,
158
418462
1987
07:00
here we see that Entropica,
159
420449
1882
07:02
again on its own initiative,
160
422331
1838
07:04
was able to move a large disk representing an animal
161
424169
2910
07:07
around so as to cause a small disk,
162
427079
2345
07:09
representing a tool, to reach into a confined space
163
429424
2771
07:12
holding a third disk
164
432195
1537
07:13
and release the third disk from its initially fixed position.
165
433732
2972
07:16
This tool use ability will have applications
166
436704
2189
07:18
for smart manufacturing and agriculture.
167
438893
2359
07:21
In addition, just as some other animals
168
441252
1944
07:23
are able to cooperate by pulling opposite ends of a rope
169
443196
2696
07:25
at the same time to release food,
170
445892
2053
07:27
here we see that Entropica is able to accomplish
171
447945
2295
07:30
a model version of that task.
172
450240
1988
07:32
This cooperative ability has interesting implications
173
452228
2522
07:34
for economic planning and a variety of other fields.
174
454750
3435
07:38
Entropica is broadly applicable
175
458185
2071
07:40
to a variety of domains.
176
460256
1943
07:42
For example, here we see it successfully
177
462199
2442
07:44
playing a game of pong against itself,
178
464641
2559
07:47
illustrating its potential for gaming.
179
467200
2343
07:49
Here we see Entropica orchestrating
180
469543
1919
07:51
new connections on a social network
181
471462
1839
07:53
where friends are constantly falling out of touch
182
473301
2760
07:56
and successfully keeping the network well connected.
183
476061
2856
07:58
This same network orchestration ability
184
478917
2298
08:01
also has applications in health care,
185
481215
2328
08:03
energy, and intelligence.
186
483543
3232
08:06
Here we see Entropica directing the paths
187
486775
2085
08:08
of a fleet of ships,
188
488860
1486
08:10
successfully discovering and utilizing the Panama Canal
189
490346
3175
08:13
to globally extend its reach from the Atlantic
190
493521
2458
08:15
to the Pacific.
191
495979
1529
08:17
By the same token, Entropica
192
497508
1727
08:19
is broadly applicable to problems
193
499235
1620
08:20
in autonomous defense, logistics and transportation.
194
500855
5302
08:26
Finally, here we see Entropica
195
506173
2030
08:28
spontaneously discovering and executing
196
508203
2723
08:30
a buy-low, sell-high strategy
197
510926
2067
08:32
on a simulated range traded stock,
198
512993
2178
08:35
successfully growing assets under management
199
515171
2331
08:37
exponentially.
200
517502
1424
08:38
This risk management ability
201
518926
1308
08:40
will have broad applications in finance
202
520234
2487
08:42
and insurance.
203
522721
3328
08:46
Alex Wissner-Gross: So what you've just seen
204
526049
2091
08:48
is that a variety of signature human intelligent
205
528140
4392
08:52
cognitive behaviors
206
532532
1757
08:54
such as tool use and walking upright
207
534289
2831
08:57
and social cooperation
208
537120
2029
08:59
all follow from a single equation,
209
539149
2972
09:02
which drives a system
210
542121
1932
09:04
to maximize its future freedom of action.
211
544053
3911
09:07
Now, there's a profound irony here.
212
547964
3007
09:10
Going back to the beginning
213
550971
2024
09:12
of the usage of the term robot,
214
552995
3273
09:16
the play "RUR,"
215
556268
2903
09:19
there was always a concept
216
559171
2235
09:21
that if we developed machine intelligence,
217
561406
3226
09:24
there would be a cybernetic revolt.
218
564632
3027
09:27
The machines would rise up against us.
219
567659
3551
09:31
One major consequence of this work
220
571210
2319
09:33
is that maybe all of these decades,
221
573529
2769
09:36
we've had the whole concept of cybernetic revolt
222
576298
2976
09:39
in reverse.
223
579274
2011
09:41
It's not that machines first become intelligent
224
581285
3279
09:44
and then megalomaniacal
225
584564
2015
09:46
and try to take over the world.
226
586579
2224
09:48
It's quite the opposite,
227
588803
1434
09:50
that the urge to take control
228
590237
2906
09:53
of all possible futures
229
593143
2261
09:55
is a more fundamental principle
230
595404
2118
09:57
than that of intelligence,
231
597522
1363
09:58
that general intelligence may in fact emerge
232
598885
3700
10:02
directly from this sort of control-grabbing,
233
602585
3559
10:06
rather than vice versa.
234
606144
4185
10:10
Another important consequence is goal seeking.
235
610329
3769
10:14
I'm often asked, how does the ability to seek goals
236
614098
4360
10:18
follow from this sort of framework?
237
618458
1620
10:20
And the answer is, the ability to seek goals
238
620078
3028
10:23
will follow directly from this
239
623106
1882
10:24
in the following sense:
240
624988
1834
10:26
just like you would travel through a tunnel,
241
626822
2865
10:29
a bottleneck in your future path space,
242
629687
2505
10:32
in order to achieve many other
243
632192
1871
10:34
diverse objectives later on,
244
634063
2021
10:36
or just like you would invest
245
636084
2372
10:38
in a financial security,
246
638456
1787
10:40
reducing your short-term liquidity
247
640243
2237
10:42
in order to increase your wealth over the long term,
248
642480
2400
10:44
goal seeking emerges directly
249
644880
2337
10:47
from a long-term drive
250
647217
1729
10:48
to increase future freedom of action.
251
648946
4037
10:52
Finally, Richard Feynman, famous physicist,
252
652983
3528
10:56
once wrote that if human civilization were destroyed
253
656511
3672
11:00
and you could pass only a single concept
254
660183
1893
11:02
on to our descendants
255
662076
1371
11:03
to help them rebuild civilization,
256
663447
2307
11:05
that concept should be
257
665754
1686
11:07
that all matter around us
258
667440
1852
11:09
is made out of tiny elements
259
669292
2323
11:11
that attract each other when they're far apart
260
671615
2508
11:14
but repel each other when they're close together.
261
674123
3330
11:17
My equivalent of that statement
262
677453
1781
11:19
to pass on to descendants
263
679234
1268
11:20
to help them build artificial intelligences
264
680502
2712
11:23
or to help them understand human intelligence,
265
683214
2949
11:26
is the following:
266
686163
1267
11:27
Intelligence should be viewed
267
687430
2053
11:29
as a physical process
268
689483
1413
11:30
that tries to maximize future freedom of action
269
690896
2965
11:33
and avoid constraints in its own future.
270
693861
3616
11:37
Thank you very much.
271
697477
1358
11:38
(Applause)
272
698835
4000
About this website

This site will introduce you to YouTube videos that are useful for learning English. You will see English lessons taught by top-notch teachers from around the world. Double-click on the English subtitles displayed on each video page to play the video from there. The subtitles scroll in sync with the video playback. If you have any comments or requests, please contact us using this contact form.

https://forms.gle/WvT1wiN1qDtmnspy7