Sebastian Deterding: What your designs say about you

33,106 views ・ 2012-05-31

TED


Please double-click on the English subtitles below to play the video.

00:15
We are today talking about moral persuasion:
0
15651
2586
00:18
What is moral and immoral in trying to change people's behaviors
1
18261
3982
00:22
by using technology and using design?
2
22267
2453
00:24
And I don't know what you expect,
3
24744
1832
00:26
but when I was thinking about that issue,
4
26600
1953
00:28
I early on realized what I'm not able to give you are answers.
5
28577
4039
00:33
I'm not able to tell you what is moral or immoral,
6
33203
2771
00:35
because we're living in a pluralist society.
7
35998
2547
00:38
My values can be radically different from your values,
8
38569
4242
00:42
which means that what I consider moral or immoral based on that
9
42835
3177
00:46
might not necessarily be what you consider moral or immoral.
10
46036
3612
00:50
But I also realized there is one thing that I could give you,
11
50029
3214
00:53
and that is what this guy behind me gave the world --
12
53267
2533
00:55
Socrates.
13
55824
1150
00:56
It is questions.
14
56998
1395
00:58
What I can do and what I would like to do with you
15
58417
2633
01:01
is give you, like that initial question,
16
61074
1945
01:03
a set of questions to figure out for yourselves,
17
63043
3410
01:06
layer by layer, like peeling an onion,
18
66477
3641
01:10
getting at the core of what you believe is moral or immoral persuasion.
19
70142
5020
01:15
And I'd like to do that with a couple of examples of technologies
20
75559
4041
01:19
where people have used game elements to get people to do things.
21
79624
4980
01:25
So it's at first a very simple, very obvious question
22
85343
3040
01:28
I would like to give you:
23
88407
1196
01:29
What are your intentions if you are designing something?
24
89627
2687
01:32
And obviously, intentions are not the only thing,
25
92668
3373
01:36
so here is another example for one of these applications.
26
96065
3178
01:39
There are a couple of these kinds of Eco dashboards right now --
27
99267
3087
01:42
dashboards built into cars --
28
102378
1460
01:43
which try to motivate you to drive more fuel-efficiently.
29
103862
2832
01:46
This here is Nissan's MyLeaf,
30
106718
1773
01:48
where your driving behavior is compared with the driving behavior
31
108515
3064
01:51
of other people,
32
111603
1151
01:52
so you can compete for who drives a route the most fuel-efficiently.
33
112778
3277
01:56
And these things are very effective, it turns out --
34
116079
2477
01:58
so effective that they motivate people to engage in unsafe driving behaviors,
35
118580
3939
02:02
like not stopping at a red light,
36
122543
1762
02:04
because that way you have to stop and restart the engine,
37
124329
2715
02:07
and that would use quite some fuel, wouldn't it?
38
127068
2723
02:10
So despite this being a very well-intended application,
39
130338
4409
02:14
obviously there was a side effect of that.
40
134771
2375
02:17
Here's another example for one of these side effects.
41
137170
2548
02:19
Commendable: a site that allows parents to give their kids little badges
42
139742
4784
02:24
for doing the things that parents want their kids to do,
43
144550
2658
02:27
like tying their shoes.
44
147232
1316
02:28
And at first that sounds very nice,
45
148572
2244
02:30
very benign, well-intended.
46
150840
2150
02:33
But it turns out, if you look into research on people's mindset,
47
153014
3770
02:36
caring about outcomes,
48
156808
1487
02:38
caring about public recognition,
49
158319
1773
02:40
caring about these kinds of public tokens of recognition
50
160116
3861
02:44
is not necessarily very helpful
51
164001
1994
02:46
for your long-term psychological well-being.
52
166019
2307
02:48
It's better if you care about learning something.
53
168350
2676
02:51
It's better when you care about yourself
54
171050
1905
02:52
than how you appear in front of other people.
55
172979
2574
02:56
So that kind of motivational tool that is used actually, in and of itself,
56
176021
5041
03:01
has a long-term side effect,
57
181086
1908
03:03
in that every time we use a technology
58
183018
1810
03:04
that uses something like public recognition or status,
59
184852
3174
03:08
we're actually positively endorsing this
60
188050
2376
03:10
as a good and normal thing to care about --
61
190450
3410
03:13
that way, possibly having a detrimental effect
62
193884
2864
03:16
on the long-term psychological well-being of ourselves as a culture.
63
196772
3855
03:20
So that's a second, very obvious question:
64
200651
2644
03:23
What are the effects of what you're doing --
65
203319
2311
03:25
the effects you're having with the device, like less fuel,
66
205654
4124
03:29
as well as the effects of the actual tools you're using
67
209802
2705
03:32
to get people to do things --
68
212531
1674
03:34
public recognition?
69
214229
1571
03:35
Now is that all -- intention, effect?
70
215824
2921
03:38
Well, there are some technologies which obviously combine both.
71
218769
3134
03:41
Both good long-term and short-term effects
72
221927
2787
03:44
and a positive intention like Fred Stutzman's "Freedom,"
73
224738
2809
03:47
where the whole point of that application is --
74
227571
2207
03:49
well, we're usually so bombarded with constant requests by other people,
75
229802
3725
03:53
with this device,
76
233551
1156
03:54
you can shut off the Internet connectivity of your PC of choice
77
234731
3480
03:58
for a pre-set amount of time,
78
238235
1448
03:59
to actually get some work done.
79
239707
1971
04:01
And I think most of us will agree that's something well-intended,
80
241702
3151
04:04
and also has good consequences.
81
244877
2220
04:07
In the words of Michel Foucault,
82
247121
1646
04:08
it is a "technology of the self."
83
248791
1940
04:10
It is a technology that empowers the individual
84
250755
2837
04:13
to determine its own life course,
85
253616
1815
04:15
to shape itself.
86
255455
1519
04:17
But the problem is, as Foucault points out,
87
257410
2984
04:20
that every technology of the self
88
260418
1785
04:22
has a technology of domination as its flip side.
89
262227
3445
04:25
As you see in today's modern liberal democracies,
90
265696
4603
04:30
the society, the state, not only allows us to determine our self,
91
270323
4683
04:35
to shape our self,
92
275030
1151
04:36
it also demands it of us.
93
276205
1991
04:38
It demands that we optimize ourselves,
94
278220
1961
04:40
that we control ourselves,
95
280205
1840
04:42
that we self-manage continuously,
96
282069
2711
04:44
because that's the only way in which such a liberal society works.
97
284804
3893
04:48
These technologies want us to stay in the game
98
288721
4268
04:53
that society has devised for us.
99
293013
2773
04:55
They want us to fit in even better.
100
295810
2287
04:58
They want us to optimize ourselves to fit in.
101
298121
2578
05:01
Now, I don't say that is necessarily a bad thing;
102
301628
3079
05:05
I just think that this example points us to a general realization,
103
305293
4328
05:09
and that is: no matter what technology or design you look at,
104
309645
3803
05:13
even something we consider as well-intended
105
313472
3021
05:16
and as good in its effects as Stutzman's Freedom,
106
316517
2966
05:19
comes with certain values embedded in it.
107
319507
2707
05:22
And we can question these values.
108
322238
1936
05:24
We can question: Is it a good thing
109
324198
1944
05:26
that all of us continuously self-optimize ourselves
110
326166
3484
05:29
to fit better into that society?
111
329674
2011
05:31
Or to give you another example:
112
331709
1492
05:33
What about a piece of persuasive technology
113
333225
2476
05:35
that convinces Muslim women to wear their headscarves?
114
335725
3191
05:38
Is that a good or a bad technology
115
338940
2052
05:41
in its intentions or in its effects?
116
341016
2563
05:43
Well, that basically depends on the kind of values you bring to bear
117
343603
4254
05:47
to make these kinds of judgments.
118
347881
2237
05:50
So that's a third question:
119
350142
1528
05:51
What values do you use to judge?
120
351694
1528
05:53
And speaking of values:
121
353848
1341
05:55
I've noticed that in the discussion about moral persuasion online
122
355213
3356
05:58
and when I'm talking with people,
123
358593
1637
06:00
more often than not, there is a weird bias.
124
360254
2667
06:03
And that bias is that we're asking:
125
363463
2896
06:06
Is this or that "still" ethical?
126
366383
2813
06:09
Is it "still" permissible?
127
369220
2650
06:11
We're asking things like:
128
371894
1198
06:13
Is this Oxfam donation form,
129
373116
2189
06:15
where the regular monthly donation is the preset default,
130
375329
3048
06:18
and people, maybe without intending it,
131
378401
2079
06:20
are encouraged or nudged into giving a regular donation
132
380504
3812
06:24
instead of a one-time donation,
133
384340
1489
06:25
is that "still' permissible?
134
385853
1343
06:27
Is it "still" ethical?
135
387220
1363
06:28
We're fishing at the low end.
136
388607
1479
06:30
But in fact, that question, "Is it 'still' ethical?"
137
390879
2474
06:33
is just one way of looking at ethics.
138
393377
1781
06:35
Because if you look at the beginning of ethics in Western culture,
139
395182
4892
06:40
you see a very different idea of what ethics also could be.
140
400098
3532
06:43
For Aristotle, ethics was not about the question,
141
403970
3997
06:47
"Is that still good, or is it bad?"
142
407991
2272
06:50
Ethics was about the question of how to live life well.
143
410287
3428
06:54
And he put that in the word "arête,"
144
414216
2181
06:56
which we, from [Ancient Greek], translate as "virtue."
145
416421
2755
06:59
But really, it means "excellence."
146
419200
1640
07:00
It means living up to your own full potential as a human being.
147
420864
5431
07:06
And that is an idea that, I think,
148
426937
1656
07:08
Paul Richard Buchanan put nicely in a recent essay,
149
428617
2697
07:11
where he said, "Products are vivid arguments
150
431338
2143
07:13
about how we should live our lives."
151
433505
2123
07:16
Our designs are not ethical or unethical
152
436086
2577
07:18
in that they're using ethical or unethical means of persuading us.
153
438687
4590
07:23
They have a moral component
154
443661
1570
07:25
just in the kind of vision and the aspiration of the good life
155
445255
4227
07:29
that they present to us.
156
449506
1348
07:31
And if you look into the designed environment around us
157
451441
3503
07:34
with that kind of lens,
158
454968
1172
07:36
asking, "What is the vision of the good life
159
456164
2453
07:38
that our products, our design, present to us?",
160
458641
2738
07:41
then you often get the shivers,
161
461403
2276
07:43
because of how little we expect of each other,
162
463703
2328
07:46
of how little we actually seem to expect of our life,
163
466055
3890
07:49
and what the good life looks like.
164
469969
2034
07:53
So that's a fourth question I'd like to leave you with:
165
473110
3023
07:56
What vision of the good life do your designs convey?
166
476157
4362
08:01
And speaking of design,
167
481249
1372
08:02
you'll notice that I already broadened the discussion,
168
482645
4190
08:06
because it's not just persuasive technology that we're talking about here,
169
486859
4444
08:11
it's any piece of design that we put out here in the world.
170
491327
4077
08:15
I don't know whether you know
171
495428
1400
08:16
the great communication researcher Paul Watzlawick who, back in the '60s,
172
496852
3555
08:20
made the argument that we cannot not communicate.
173
500431
2511
08:22
Even if we choose to be silent, we chose to be silent,
174
502966
2601
08:25
and we're communicating something by choosing to be silent.
175
505591
2956
08:28
And in the same way that we cannot not communicate,
176
508571
2735
08:31
we cannot not persuade:
177
511330
1531
08:32
whatever we do or refrain from doing,
178
512885
2011
08:34
whatever we put out there as a piece of design, into the world,
179
514920
4365
08:39
has a persuasive component.
180
519309
2047
08:41
It tries to affect people.
181
521380
1873
08:43
It puts a certain vision of the good life out there in front of us,
182
523277
3747
08:47
which is what Peter-Paul Verbeek,
183
527048
1625
08:48
the Dutch philosopher of technology, says.
184
528697
2716
08:51
No matter whether we as designers intend it or not,
185
531437
3948
08:55
we materialize morality.
186
535409
2142
08:57
We make certain things harder and easier to do.
187
537575
2803
09:00
We organize the existence of people.
188
540402
2211
09:02
We put a certain vision
189
542637
1151
09:03
of what good or bad or normal or usual is
190
543812
3404
09:07
in front of people,
191
547240
1151
09:08
by everything we put out there in the world.
192
548415
2400
09:11
Even something as innocuous as a set of school chairs
193
551247
3086
09:14
is a persuasive technology,
194
554357
2047
09:16
because it presents and materializes a certain vision of the good life --
195
556428
4690
09:21
a good life in which teaching and learning and listening
196
561142
2857
09:24
is about one person teaching, the others listening;
197
564023
3099
09:27
in which it is about learning-is-done-while-sitting;
198
567146
4053
09:31
in which you learn for yourself;
199
571223
1595
09:32
in which you're not supposed to change these rules,
200
572842
2420
09:35
because the chairs are fixed to the ground.
201
575286
2447
09:38
And even something as innocuous as a single-design chair,
202
578888
2911
09:41
like this one by Arne Jacobsen,
203
581823
1572
09:43
is a persuasive technology,
204
583419
1776
09:45
because, again, it communicates an idea of the good life:
205
585219
3043
09:48
a good life -- a life that you, as a designer, consent to by saying,
206
588735
4925
09:53
"In a good life, goods are produced as sustainably or unsustainably
207
593684
3507
09:57
as this chair.
208
597215
1611
09:58
Workers are treated as well or as badly
209
598850
1977
10:00
as the workers were treated that built that chair."
210
600851
2572
10:03
The good life is a life where design is important
211
603762
2301
10:06
because somebody obviously took the time and spent the money
212
606087
2921
10:09
for that kind of well-designed chair;
213
609032
1784
10:10
where tradition is important,
214
610840
1404
10:12
because this is a traditional classic and someone cared about this;
215
612268
3166
10:15
and where there is something as conspicuous consumption,
216
615458
2690
10:18
where it is OK and normal to spend a humongous amount of money
217
618172
2956
10:21
on such a chair,
218
621152
1151
10:22
to signal to other people what your social status is.
219
622327
2573
10:24
So these are the kinds of layers, the kinds of questions
220
624924
3317
10:28
I wanted to lead you through today;
221
628265
1970
10:30
the question of: What are the intentions that you bring to bear
222
630259
3034
10:33
when you're designing something?
223
633317
1560
10:34
What are the effects, intended and unintended, that you're having?
224
634901
3252
10:38
What are the values you're using to judge those?
225
638177
2801
10:41
What are the virtues, the aspirations
226
641002
1973
10:42
that you're actually expressing in that?
227
642999
2028
10:45
And how does that apply,
228
645400
1857
10:47
not just to persuasive technology,
229
647281
1986
10:49
but to everything you design?
230
649291
2048
10:51
Do we stop there?
231
651912
1291
10:53
I don't think so.
232
653815
1167
10:55
I think that all of these things are eventually informed
233
655291
4438
10:59
by the core of all of this,
234
659753
1423
11:01
and this is nothing but life itself.
235
661200
3091
11:04
Why, when the question of what the good life is
236
664594
2717
11:07
informs everything that we design,
237
667335
2339
11:09
should we stop at design and not ask ourselves:
238
669698
2794
11:12
How does it apply to our own life?
239
672516
1990
11:14
"Why should the lamp or the house be an art object,
240
674881
2712
11:17
but not our life?"
241
677617
1176
11:18
as Michel Foucault puts it.
242
678817
1483
11:20
Just to give you a practical example of Buster Benson.
243
680696
3611
11:24
This is Buster setting up a pull-up machine
244
684331
2258
11:26
at the office of his new start-up, Habit Labs,
245
686613
2612
11:29
where they're trying to build other applications like "Health Month"
246
689249
3215
11:32
for people.
247
692488
1158
11:33
And why is he building a thing like this?
248
693670
1962
11:35
Well, here is the set of axioms
249
695656
2033
11:37
that Habit Labs, Buster's start-up, put up for themselves
250
697713
3398
11:41
on how they wanted to work together as a team
251
701135
2705
11:43
when they're building these applications --
252
703864
2029
11:45
a set of moral principles they set themselves
253
705917
2189
11:48
for working together --
254
708130
1361
11:49
one of them being,
255
709515
1238
11:50
"We take care of our own health and manage our own burnout."
256
710777
3087
11:54
Because ultimately, how can you ask yourselves
257
714221
3500
11:57
and how can you find an answer on what vision of the good life
258
717745
3930
12:01
you want to convey and create with your designs
259
721699
3169
12:04
without asking the question:
260
724892
1730
12:06
What vision of the good life do you yourself want to live?
261
726646
3832
12:11
And with that,
262
731018
1174
12:12
I thank you.
263
732945
1412
12:14
(Applause)
264
734381
4156
About this website

This site will introduce you to YouTube videos that are useful for learning English. You will see English lessons taught by top-notch teachers from around the world. Double-click on the English subtitles displayed on each video page to play the video from there. The subtitles scroll in sync with the video playback. If you have any comments or requests, please contact us using this contact form.

https://forms.gle/WvT1wiN1qDtmnspy7