Philip Evans: How data will transform business

373,496 views ・ 2014-04-18

TED


Please double-click on the English subtitles below to play the video.

00:12
I'm going to talk a little bit about strategy
0
12586
2063
00:14
and its relationship with technology.
1
14649
4174
00:18
We tend to think of business strategy
2
18823
2895
00:21
as being a rather abstract body
3
21718
1963
00:23
of essentially economic thought,
4
23681
1715
00:25
perhaps rather timeless.
5
25396
1630
00:27
I'm going to argue that, in fact,
6
27026
1940
00:28
business strategy has always been premised
7
28966
2555
00:31
on assumptions about technology,
8
31521
2419
00:33
that those assumptions are changing,
9
33940
1973
00:35
and, in fact, changing quite dramatically,
10
35913
2717
00:38
and that therefore what that will drive us to
11
38630
3072
00:41
is a different concept of what we mean
12
41702
2903
00:44
by business strategy.
13
44605
2438
00:47
Let me start, if I may,
14
47043
1481
00:48
with a little bit of history.
15
48524
2770
00:51
The idea of strategy in business
16
51294
1744
00:53
owes its origins to two intellectual giants:
17
53038
3300
00:56
Bruce Henderson, the founder of BCG,
18
56338
2134
00:58
and Michael Porter, professor at the Harvard Business School.
19
58472
3772
01:02
Henderson's central idea was what you might call
20
62244
2832
01:05
the Napoleonic idea of concentrating mass
21
65076
2991
01:08
against weakness, of overwhelming the enemy.
22
68067
2869
01:10
What Henderson recognized was that,
23
70936
1793
01:12
in the business world,
24
72729
1396
01:14
there are many phenomena which are characterized
25
74125
2655
01:16
by what economists would call increasing returns --
26
76780
2035
01:18
scale, experience.
27
78815
1363
01:20
The more you do of something,
28
80178
1874
01:22
disproportionately the better you get.
29
82052
2397
01:24
And therefore he found a logic for investing
30
84449
2963
01:27
in such kinds of overwhelming mass
31
87412
2742
01:30
in order to achieve competitive advantage.
32
90154
2553
01:32
And that was the first introduction
33
92707
2068
01:34
of essentially a military concept of strategy
34
94775
2664
01:37
into the business world.
35
97439
2982
01:40
Porter agreed with that premise,
36
100421
2735
01:43
but he qualified it.
37
103156
1551
01:44
He pointed out, correctly, that that's all very well,
38
104707
2989
01:47
but businesses actually have multiple steps to them.
39
107696
3875
01:51
They have different components,
40
111571
1573
01:53
and each of those components might be driven
41
113144
2532
01:55
by a different kind of strategy.
42
115676
1785
01:57
A company or a business might actually be advantaged
43
117461
2328
01:59
in some activities but disadvantaged in others.
44
119789
3478
02:03
He formed the concept of the value chain,
45
123267
2101
02:05
essentially the sequence of steps with which
46
125368
3070
02:08
a, shall we say, raw material, becomes a component,
47
128438
3152
02:11
becomes assembled into a finished product,
48
131590
1363
02:12
and then is distributed, for example,
49
132953
2641
02:15
and he argued that advantage accrued
50
135594
2416
02:18
to each of those components,
51
138010
1541
02:19
and that the advantage of the whole
52
139551
1714
02:21
was in some sense the sum or the average
53
141265
2131
02:23
of that of its parts.
54
143396
2348
02:25
And this idea of the value chain was predicated
55
145744
2577
02:28
on the recognition that
56
148321
2568
02:30
what holds a business together is transaction costs,
57
150889
3646
02:34
that in essence you need to coordinate,
58
154535
2295
02:36
organizations are more efficient at coordination
59
156830
2575
02:39
than markets, very often,
60
159405
1662
02:41
and therefore the nature and role and boundaries
61
161067
3056
02:44
of the cooperation are defined by transaction costs.
62
164123
3839
02:47
It was on those two ideas,
63
167962
2564
02:50
Henderson's idea of increasing returns
64
170526
3386
02:53
to scale and experience,
65
173912
1548
02:55
and Porter's idea of the value chain,
66
175460
2423
02:57
encompassing heterogenous elements,
67
177883
1913
02:59
that the whole edifice of business strategy
68
179796
3335
03:03
was subsequently erected.
69
183131
2777
03:05
Now what I'm going to argue is
70
185908
2429
03:08
that those premises are, in fact, being invalidated.
71
188337
5714
03:14
First of all, let's think about transaction costs.
72
194051
2554
03:16
There are really two components to transaction costs.
73
196605
2397
03:19
One is about processing information, and the other is about communication.
74
199002
2870
03:21
These are the economics of processing and communicating
75
201872
3281
03:25
as they have evolved over a long period of time.
76
205153
2474
03:27
As we all know from so many contexts,
77
207627
3010
03:30
they have been radically transformed
78
210637
2256
03:32
since the days when Porter and Henderson
79
212893
2312
03:35
first formulated their theories.
80
215205
2094
03:37
In particular, since the mid-'90s,
81
217299
2066
03:39
communications costs have actually been falling
82
219365
1868
03:41
even faster than transaction costs,
83
221233
1991
03:43
which is why communication, the Internet,
84
223224
2559
03:45
has exploded in such a dramatic fashion.
85
225783
4615
03:50
Now, those falling transaction costs
86
230398
2170
03:52
have profound consequences,
87
232568
1976
03:54
because if transaction costs are the glue
88
234544
1793
03:56
that hold value chains together, and they are falling,
89
236337
2422
03:58
there is less to economize on.
90
238759
1642
04:00
There is less need for vertically integrated organization,
91
240401
2932
04:03
and value chains at least can break up.
92
243333
2878
04:06
They needn't necessarily, but they can.
93
246211
2499
04:08
In particular, it then becomes possible for
94
248710
2140
04:10
a competitor in one business
95
250850
1766
04:12
to use their position in one step of the value chain
96
252616
3325
04:15
in order to penetrate or attack
97
255941
1832
04:17
or disintermediate the competitor in another.
98
257773
3164
04:20
That is not just an abstract proposition.
99
260937
2661
04:23
There are many very specific stories
100
263598
1679
04:25
of how that actually happened.
101
265277
1772
04:27
A poster child example was the encyclopedia business.
102
267049
3493
04:30
The encyclopedia business
103
270542
1449
04:31
in the days of leatherbound books
104
271991
2102
04:34
was basically a distribution business.
105
274093
1704
04:35
Most of the cost was the commission to the salesmen.
106
275797
2454
04:38
The CD-ROM and then the Internet came along,
107
278251
2626
04:40
new technologies made the distribution of knowledge
108
280877
3416
04:44
many orders of magnitude cheaper,
109
284293
2279
04:46
and the encyclopedia industry collapsed.
110
286572
2714
04:49
It's now, of course, a very familiar story.
111
289286
2832
04:52
This, in fact, more generally was the story
112
292118
2042
04:54
of the first generation of the Internet economy.
113
294160
2509
04:56
It was about falling transaction costs
114
296669
2200
04:58
breaking up value chains
115
298869
1475
05:00
and therefore allowing disintermediation,
116
300344
2629
05:02
or what we call deconstruction.
117
302973
2337
05:05
One of the questions I was occasionally asked was,
118
305310
2317
05:07
well, what's going to replace the encyclopedia
119
307627
2516
05:10
when Britannica no longer has a business model?
120
310143
2651
05:12
And it was a while before the answer became manifest.
121
312794
2166
05:14
Now, of course, we know what it is: it's the Wikipedia.
122
314960
2787
05:17
Now what's special about the Wikipedia is not its distribution.
123
317747
3223
05:20
What's special about the Wikipedia is the way it's produced.
124
320970
2404
05:23
The Wikipedia, of course, is an encyclopedia
125
323374
2240
05:25
created by its users.
126
325614
2527
05:28
And this, in fact, defines what you might call
127
328141
1880
05:30
the second decade of the Internet economy,
128
330021
2488
05:32
the decade in which the Internet as a noun
129
332509
3360
05:35
became the Internet as a verb.
130
335869
1907
05:37
It became a set of conversations,
131
337776
1869
05:39
the era in which user-generated content and social networks
132
339645
4076
05:43
became the dominant phenomenon.
133
343721
2691
05:46
Now what that really meant
134
346412
1898
05:48
in terms of the Porter-Henderson framework
135
348310
3374
05:51
was the collapse of certain kinds of economies of scale.
136
351684
3391
05:55
It turned out that tens of thousands
137
355075
2338
05:57
of autonomous individuals writing an encyclopedia
138
357413
3083
06:00
could do just as good a job,
139
360496
1546
06:02
and certainly a much cheaper job,
140
362042
1691
06:03
than professionals in a hierarchical organization.
141
363733
2979
06:06
So basically what was happening was that one layer
142
366712
2457
06:09
of this value chain was becoming fragmented,
143
369169
2894
06:12
as individuals could take over
144
372063
1844
06:13
where organizations were no longer needed.
145
373907
3287
06:17
But there's another question that obviously this graph poses,
146
377194
2632
06:19
which is, okay, we've gone through two decades --
147
379826
2283
06:22
does anything distinguish the third?
148
382109
2678
06:24
And what I'm going to argue is that indeed
149
384787
2115
06:26
something does distinguish the third,
150
386902
1505
06:28
and it maps exactly on to the kind of
151
388407
2446
06:30
Porter-Henderson logic that we've been talking about.
152
390853
2468
06:33
And that is, about data.
153
393321
2587
06:35
If we go back to around 2000,
154
395908
1669
06:37
a lot of people were talking about the information revolution,
155
397577
2359
06:39
and it was indeed true that the world's stock of data
156
399936
2301
06:42
was growing, indeed growing quite fast.
157
402237
2274
06:44
but it was still at that point overwhelmingly analog.
158
404511
2858
06:47
We go forward to 2007,
159
407369
1818
06:49
not only had the world's stock of data exploded,
160
409187
3185
06:52
but there'd been this massive substitution
161
412372
2520
06:54
of digital for analog.
162
414892
2015
06:56
And more important even than that,
163
416907
1869
06:58
if you look more carefully at this graph,
164
418776
1740
07:00
what you will observe is that about a half
165
420516
2020
07:02
of that digital data
166
422536
1614
07:04
is information that has an I.P. address.
167
424150
2386
07:06
It's on a server or it's on a P.C.
168
426536
2851
07:09
But having an I.P. address means that it
169
429387
1807
07:11
can be connected to any other data
170
431194
2170
07:13
that has an I.P. address.
171
433364
1863
07:15
It means it becomes possible
172
435227
1646
07:16
to put together half of the world's knowledge
173
436873
3087
07:19
in order to see patterns,
174
439960
1652
07:21
an entirely new thing.
175
441612
2357
07:23
If we run the numbers forward to today,
176
443969
1968
07:25
it probably looks something like this.
177
445937
1426
07:27
We're not really sure.
178
447363
1168
07:28
If we run the numbers forward to 2020,
179
448531
2028
07:30
we of course have an exact number, courtesy of IDC.
180
450559
2900
07:33
It's curious that the future is so much more predictable than the present.
181
453459
4340
07:37
And what it implies is a hundredfold multiplication
182
457799
4395
07:42
in the stock of information that is connected
183
462194
2973
07:45
via an I.P. address.
184
465167
2228
07:47
Now, if the number of connections that we can make
185
467395
3461
07:50
is proportional to the number of pairs of data points,
186
470856
3140
07:53
a hundredfold multiplication in the quantity of data
187
473996
2463
07:56
is a ten-thousandfold multiplication
188
476459
2103
07:58
in the number of patterns
189
478562
1565
08:00
that we can see in that data,
190
480127
2077
08:02
this just in the last 10 or 11 years.
191
482204
2660
08:04
This, I would submit, is a sea change,
192
484864
2824
08:07
a profound change in the economics
193
487688
2084
08:09
of the world that we live in.
194
489772
1951
08:11
The first human genome,
195
491723
1164
08:12
that of James Watson,
196
492887
1566
08:14
was mapped as the culmination of the Human Genome Project in the year 2000,
197
494453
3920
08:18
and it took about 200 million dollars
198
498373
2177
08:20
and about 10 years of work to map
199
500550
1981
08:22
just one person's genomic makeup.
200
502531
2415
08:24
Since then, the costs of mapping the genome have come down.
201
504946
2605
08:27
In fact, they've come down in recent years
202
507551
1887
08:29
very dramatically indeed,
203
509438
1674
08:31
to the point where the cost is now below 1,000 dollars,
204
511112
2446
08:33
and it's confidently predicted that by the year 2015
205
513558
2951
08:36
it will be below 100 dollars --
206
516509
1731
08:38
a five or six order of magnitude drop
207
518240
3196
08:41
in the cost of genomic mapping
208
521436
1945
08:43
in just a 15-year period,
209
523381
2423
08:45
an extraordinary phenomenon.
210
525804
2395
08:48
Now, in the days when mapping a genome
211
528199
4405
08:52
cost millions, or even tens of thousands,
212
532604
3009
08:55
it was basically a research enterprise.
213
535613
1978
08:57
Scientists would gather some representative people,
214
537591
2542
09:00
and they would see patterns, and they would try
215
540133
1214
09:01
and make generalizations about human nature and disease
216
541347
2890
09:04
from the abstract patterns they find
217
544237
1591
09:05
from these particular selected individuals.
218
545828
3460
09:09
But when the genome can be mapped for 100 bucks,
219
549288
2833
09:12
99 dollars while you wait,
220
552121
2348
09:14
then what happens is, it becomes retail.
221
554469
2190
09:16
It becomes above all clinical.
222
556659
1857
09:18
You go the doctor with a cold,
223
558516
1212
09:19
and if he or she hasn't done it already,
224
559728
1934
09:21
the first thing they do is map your genome,
225
561662
2238
09:23
at which point what they're now doing
226
563900
1655
09:25
is not starting from some abstract knowledge of genomic medicine
227
565555
4529
09:30
and trying to work out how it applies to you,
228
570084
2064
09:32
but they're starting from your particular genome.
229
572148
2569
09:34
Now think of the power of that.
230
574717
1440
09:36
Think of where that takes us
231
576157
1789
09:37
when we can combine genomic data
232
577946
2946
09:40
with clinical data
233
580892
1489
09:42
with data about drug interactions
234
582381
1959
09:44
with the kind of ambient data that devices
235
584340
2289
09:46
like our phone and medical sensors
236
586629
1759
09:48
will increasingly be collecting.
237
588388
1858
09:50
Think what happens when we collect all of that data
238
590246
2461
09:52
and we can put it together
239
592707
1473
09:54
in order to find patterns we wouldn't see before.
240
594180
2488
09:56
This, I would suggest, perhaps it will take a while,
241
596668
2911
09:59
but this will drive a revolution in medicine.
242
599579
2441
10:02
Fabulous, lots of people talk about this.
243
602020
2320
10:04
But there's one thing that doesn't get much attention.
244
604340
2439
10:06
How is that model of colossal sharing
245
606779
3284
10:10
across all of those kinds of databases
246
610063
2646
10:12
compatible with the business models
247
612709
2492
10:15
of institutions and organizations and corporations
248
615201
2614
10:17
that are involved in this business today?
249
617815
2297
10:20
If your business is based on proprietary data,
250
620112
2776
10:22
if your competitive advantage is defined by your data,
251
622888
3043
10:25
how on Earth is that company or is that society
252
625931
3520
10:29
in fact going to achieve the value
253
629451
2098
10:31
that's implicit in the technology? They can't.
254
631549
3005
10:34
So essentially what's happening here,
255
634554
2047
10:36
and genomics is merely one example of this,
256
636601
2644
10:39
is that technology is driving
257
639245
2314
10:41
the natural scaling of the activity
258
641559
2569
10:44
beyond the institutional boundaries within which
259
644128
2927
10:47
we have been used to thinking about it,
260
647055
2158
10:49
and in particular beyond the institutional boundaries
261
649213
2163
10:51
in terms of which business strategy
262
651376
2254
10:53
as a discipline is formulated.
263
653630
3455
10:57
The basic story here is that what used to be
264
657085
3486
11:00
vertically integrated, oligopolistic competition
265
660571
3662
11:04
among essentially similar kinds of competitors
266
664233
2791
11:07
is evolving, by one means or another,
267
667024
2459
11:09
from a vertical structure to a horizontal one.
268
669483
3361
11:12
Why is that happening?
269
672844
1715
11:14
It's happening because transaction costs are plummeting
270
674559
2505
11:17
and because scale is polarizing.
271
677064
1928
11:18
The plummeting of transaction costs
272
678992
1742
11:20
weakens the glue that holds value chains together,
273
680734
2638
11:23
and allows them to separate.
274
683372
1668
11:25
The polarization of scale economies
275
685040
1935
11:26
towards the very small -- small is beautiful --
276
686975
3126
11:30
allows for scalable communities
277
690101
2668
11:32
to substitute for conventional corporate production.
278
692769
3117
11:35
The scaling in the opposite direction,
279
695886
2004
11:37
towards things like big data,
280
697890
2033
11:39
drive the structure of business
281
699923
1409
11:41
towards the creation of new kinds of institutions
282
701332
2723
11:44
that can achieve that scale.
283
704055
1978
11:46
But either way, the typically vertical structure
284
706033
2758
11:48
gets driven to becoming more horizontal.
285
708791
3004
11:51
The logic isn't just about big data.
286
711795
2415
11:54
If we were to look, for example, at the telecommunications industry,
287
714210
3326
11:57
you can tell the same story about fiber optics.
288
717536
2375
11:59
If we look at the pharmaceutical industry,
289
719911
2136
12:02
or, for that matter, university research,
290
722047
1893
12:03
you can say exactly the same story
291
723940
1674
12:05
about so-called "big science."
292
725614
1739
12:07
And in the opposite direction,
293
727353
1535
12:08
if we look, say, at the energy sector,
294
728888
2197
12:11
where all the talk is about how households
295
731085
2860
12:13
will be efficient producers of green energy
296
733945
3584
12:17
and efficient conservers of energy,
297
737529
2628
12:20
that is, in fact, the reverse phenomenon.
298
740157
1880
12:22
That is the fragmentation of scale
299
742037
1870
12:23
because the very small can substitute
300
743907
2354
12:26
for the traditional corporate scale.
301
746261
2594
12:28
Either way, what we are driven to
302
748855
1791
12:30
is this horizontalization of the structure of industries,
303
750646
3371
12:34
and that implies fundamental changes
304
754017
2590
12:36
in how we think about strategy.
305
756607
2062
12:38
It means, for example, that we need to think
306
758669
2032
12:40
about strategy as the curation
307
760701
2547
12:43
of these kinds of horizontal structure,
308
763248
2645
12:45
where things like business definition
309
765893
1640
12:47
and even industry definition
310
767533
1562
12:49
are actually the outcomes of strategy,
311
769095
2802
12:51
not something that the strategy presupposes.
312
771897
3181
12:55
It means, for example, we need to work out
313
775078
3156
12:58
how to accommodate collaboration
314
778234
2357
13:00
and competition simultaneously.
315
780591
1866
13:02
Think about the genome.
316
782457
1086
13:03
We need to accommodate the very large
317
783543
1778
13:05
and the very small simultaneously.
318
785321
2135
13:07
And we need industry structures
319
787456
1943
13:09
that will accommodate very, very different motivations,
320
789399
2942
13:12
from the amateur motivations of people in communities
321
792341
2633
13:14
to maybe the social motivations
322
794974
1973
13:16
of infrastructure built by governments,
323
796947
2336
13:19
or, for that matter, cooperative institutions
324
799283
2625
13:21
built by companies that are otherwise competing,
325
801908
2492
13:24
because that is the only way that they can get to scale.
326
804400
2994
13:27
These kinds of transformations
327
807394
1977
13:29
render the traditional premises of business strategy obsolete.
328
809371
3725
13:33
They drive us into a completely new world.
329
813096
2569
13:35
They require us, whether we are
330
815665
1421
13:37
in the public sector or the private sector,
331
817086
2767
13:39
to think very fundamentally differently
332
819853
2300
13:42
about the structure of business,
333
822153
1820
13:43
and, at last, it makes strategy interesting again.
334
823973
3454
13:47
Thank you.
335
827427
2813
13:50
(Applause)
336
830240
2515
About this website

This site will introduce you to YouTube videos that are useful for learning English. You will see English lessons taught by top-notch teachers from around the world. Double-click on the English subtitles displayed on each video page to play the video from there. The subtitles scroll in sync with the video playback. If you have any comments or requests, please contact us using this contact form.

https://forms.gle/WvT1wiN1qDtmnspy7