A climate solution where all sides can win | Ted Halstead

350,290 views ・ 2017-06-08

TED


Please double-click on the English subtitles below to play the video.

00:13
I have a two-year-old daughter named Naya
0
13185
2477
00:15
who is under the mistaken impression
1
15686
1866
00:17
that this conference is named in honor of her father.
2
17576
3563
00:21
(Laughter)
3
21163
1299
00:22
Who am I to contradict my baby girl?
4
22486
2136
00:25
As many of you know, there's something about becoming a parent
5
25495
3870
00:29
that concentrates the mind on long-term problems like climate change.
6
29389
4460
00:34
It was the birth of my daughter that inspired me
7
34404
2465
00:36
to launch this climate organization,
8
36893
2554
00:39
in order to counteract the excessive polarization of this issue
9
39471
3871
00:43
in the United States,
10
43366
1309
00:44
and to find a conservative pathway forward.
11
44699
4453
00:49
Yes, folks, a Republican climate solution is possible,
12
49970
4633
00:54
and you know what?
13
54627
1325
00:55
It may even be better.
14
55976
2332
00:58
(Laughter)
15
58332
1611
00:59
Let me try to prove that to you.
16
59967
1661
01:03
What we really need is a killer app to climate policy.
17
63089
4574
01:07
In the technology world, a killer app is an application so transformative
18
67687
4417
01:12
that it creates its own market,
19
72128
1479
01:13
like Uber.
20
73631
1565
01:15
In the climate world,
21
75220
1627
01:16
a killer app is a new solution so promising
22
76871
4925
01:21
that it can break through the seemingly insurmountable
23
81820
3547
01:25
barriers to progress.
24
85391
1861
01:27
These include the psychological barrier.
25
87276
3525
01:30
Climate advocates have long been encouraging their fellow citizens
26
90825
3213
01:34
to make short-term sacrifices now
27
94062
1910
01:35
for benefits that accrue to other people
28
95996
2037
01:38
in other countries 30 or 40 years in the future.
29
98057
3344
01:41
It just doesn't fly because it runs contrary to basic human nature.
30
101425
4303
01:46
Next is the geopolitical barrier.
31
106507
3313
01:49
Under the current rules of global trade,
32
109844
2268
01:52
countries have a strong incentive to free ride off the emissions reductions
33
112136
4346
01:56
of other nations,
34
116506
1259
01:57
instead of strengthening their own programs.
35
117789
2232
02:00
This has been the curse
36
120045
1558
02:01
of every international climate negotiations, including Paris.
37
121627
3963
02:06
Finally, we have the partisan barrier.
38
126243
3055
02:09
Even the most committed countries --
39
129322
2071
02:11
Germany, the United Kingdom, Canada --
40
131417
3200
02:14
are nowhere near reducing emissions at the required scale and speed.
41
134641
4721
02:19
Not even close.
42
139386
1468
02:20
And the partisan climate divide is far more acute
43
140878
4250
02:25
here in the United States.
44
145152
1873
02:27
We are fundamentally stuck,
45
147623
2106
02:29
and that is why we need a killer app of climate policy
46
149753
3560
02:33
to break through each of these barriers.
47
153337
2741
02:36
I'm convinced that the road to climate progress in the United States
48
156570
5668
02:42
runs through the Republican Party
49
162262
2615
02:44
and the business community.
50
164901
2084
02:48
So in launching the Climate Leadership Council,
51
168072
2756
02:50
I started by reaching out to a who's who of Republican elder statesmen
52
170852
3914
02:54
and business leaders,
53
174790
1190
02:56
including James Baker and George Schultz,
54
176004
3377
02:59
the two most respected Republican elder statesmen in America;
55
179405
4120
03:03
Martin Feldstein and Greg Mankiw,
56
183549
1869
03:05
the two most respected conservative economists in the country;
57
185442
3642
03:09
and Henry Paulson and Rob Walton,
58
189108
2093
03:11
two of the most successful and admired business leaders.
59
191225
2969
03:14
Together, we co-authored
60
194218
2301
03:16
"The Conservative Case For Carbon Dividends."
61
196543
3064
03:19
This represents the first time
62
199631
2535
03:22
that Republican leaders put forth
63
202190
3591
03:25
a concrete market-based climate solution.
64
205805
2513
03:28
(Applause)
65
208342
1381
03:29
Thank you.
66
209747
1069
03:30
(Applause)
67
210840
2603
03:33
We presented our plan at the White House
68
213467
2327
03:35
two weeks after President Trump moved in.
69
215818
2702
03:39
Almost every leading editorial board in the country
70
219465
3878
03:43
has since endorsed our plan,
71
223367
2247
03:45
and Fortune 100 companies from a wide range of industries
72
225638
4685
03:50
are now getting behind it.
73
230347
2351
03:52
So by now you're probably wondering,
74
232722
1961
03:54
what exactly is this plan?
75
234707
2402
03:57
Well, our carbon dividends solution is based on four pillars.
76
237133
4368
04:01
The first is a gradually rising carbon tax.
77
241525
3910
04:05
Although capitalism is a wonderful system,
78
245459
2527
04:08
like many operating systems, it's prone to bugs,
79
248010
3175
04:11
which, in this case, are called "market failures."
80
251209
3193
04:14
By far the largest is that market prices fail to take
81
254426
3522
04:17
social and environmental costs into account.
82
257972
3739
04:21
That means every market transaction is based on incorrect information.
83
261735
5340
04:27
This fundamental bug of capitalism, more than any other single factor,
84
267099
4098
04:31
is to blame for our climate predicament.
85
271221
2756
04:34
Now in theory, this should be an easy problem to fix.
86
274580
3311
04:37
Economists agree
87
277915
1366
04:39
that the best solution is to put a price on the carbon content of fossil fuels,
88
279305
4788
04:44
otherwise known as a carbon tax.
89
284117
2274
04:46
This would discourage carbon emissions
90
286415
3728
04:50
in every single economic transaction,
91
290167
2320
04:52
every day of the year.
92
292511
1710
04:54
However, a carbon tax by itself has proven to be unpopular
93
294245
5346
04:59
and a political dead end.
94
299615
1668
05:01
The answer is to return all the money raised
95
301813
3525
05:05
directly to citizens,
96
305362
2292
05:07
in the form of equal monthly dividends.
97
307678
3351
05:11
This would transform an unpopular carbon tax
98
311499
3532
05:15
into a popular and populist solution,
99
315055
3242
05:18
and it would also solve
100
318321
1824
05:20
the underlying psychological barrier that we discussed,
101
320169
3313
05:23
by giving everyone a concrete benefit in the here and now.
102
323506
4677
05:29
And these benefits would be significant.
103
329127
2289
05:31
Assuming a carbon tax rate that starts at 40 dollars per ton,
104
331440
3742
05:35
a family of four would receive 2,000 dollars per year
105
335206
3423
05:38
from the get-go.
106
338653
1231
05:40
According to the US Treasury Department,
107
340463
2243
05:43
the bottom 70 percent of Americans would receive more in dividends
108
343459
5030
05:48
than they would pay in increased energy prices.
109
348513
3291
05:51
That means 223 million Americans would win economically
110
351828
6993
05:58
from solving climate change.
111
358845
2010
06:01
And that --
112
361631
1162
06:02
(Applause)
113
362817
1055
06:03
is revolutionary,
114
363896
1550
06:05
and could fundamentally alter climate politics.
115
365470
3731
06:10
But there's another revolutionary element here.
116
370598
2817
06:13
The amount of the dividend would grow
117
373439
3480
06:16
as the carbon tax rate increases.
118
376943
2361
06:19
The more we protect our climate,
119
379328
2076
06:21
the more our citizens benefit.
120
381428
1855
06:23
This creates a positive feedback loop,
121
383307
2222
06:25
which is crucial,
122
385553
1530
06:27
because the only way we will reach our long-term emission-reduction goals
123
387107
3896
06:31
is if the carbon tax rate goes up every year.
124
391027
2756
06:34
The third pillar of our program is eliminating regulations
125
394799
3966
06:38
that are no longer needed
126
398789
1539
06:40
once a carbon dividends plan is enacted.
127
400352
3078
06:43
This is a key selling point to Republicans and business leaders.
128
403454
6429
06:50
So why should we trade
129
410919
1525
06:52
climate regulations for a price on carbon?
130
412986
2531
06:55
Well, let me show you.
131
415541
1778
06:57
Our plan would achieve nearly twice the emissions reductions
132
417996
4428
07:02
of all Obama-era climate regulations combined,
133
422448
4156
07:06
and nearly three times the new baseline
134
426628
3610
07:10
after President Trump repeals all of those regulations.
135
430262
4157
07:14
That assumes a carbon tax starting at 40 dollars per ton,
136
434443
3763
07:18
which translates into roughly an extra 36 cents per gallon of gas.
137
438230
4993
07:23
Our plan by itself
138
443882
2509
07:26
would meet the high end of America's commitment
139
446415
3573
07:30
under the Paris Climate Agreement,
140
450012
2278
07:32
and as you can see,
141
452314
1674
07:34
the emissions reductions would continue over time.
142
454012
2986
07:37
This illustrates the power of a conservative climate solution
143
457521
5568
07:43
based on free markets and limited government.
144
463113
2888
07:46
We would end up with less regulation
145
466025
3179
07:49
and far less pollution at the same time,
146
469228
3092
07:52
while helping working-class Americans get ahead.
147
472344
3984
07:56
Doesn't that sound like something we could all support?
148
476352
3238
07:59
(Applause)
149
479614
2433
08:05
The fourth and final pillar of our program is a new climate domino effect,
150
485723
4519
08:10
based on border carbon adjustments.
151
490266
2654
08:12
Now that may sound complicated,
152
492944
2103
08:15
but it, too, is revolutionary,
153
495071
1865
08:16
because it provides us a whole new strategy
154
496960
2861
08:19
to reach a global price on carbon,
155
499845
2548
08:22
which is ultimately what we need.
156
502417
1867
08:24
Let me show you an example.
157
504308
1932
08:26
Suppose Country A adopts a carbon dividends plan,
158
506264
3501
08:29
and Country B does not.
159
509789
1447
08:31
Well, to level the playing field
160
511260
2403
08:33
and protect the competitiveness of its industries,
161
513687
3235
08:36
Country A would tax imports from Country B
162
516946
3898
08:40
based on their carbon content.
163
520868
1839
08:42
Fair enough.
164
522731
1517
08:44
But here's where it gets really interesting,
165
524272
2144
08:46
because the money raised at the border would increase the dividends
166
526440
3638
08:50
going to the citizens of Country A.
167
530102
2254
08:52
Well, how long do you think it would take the public in Country B to realize
168
532380
4172
08:56
that that money should be going to them,
169
536576
1932
08:58
and to push for a carbon dividends plan in their own land?
170
538533
2989
09:01
Add a few more countries,
171
541546
1499
09:03
and we get a new climate domino effect.
172
543069
3457
09:07
Once one major country or region adopts carbon dividends
173
547337
4289
09:11
with border carbon adjustments,
174
551650
1625
09:13
other countries are compelled to follow suit.
175
553299
2459
09:15
One by one the dominoes fall.
176
555782
2912
09:18
And this domino effect could start anywhere.
177
558718
2329
09:21
My preference, strongly, is the United States,
178
561071
3410
09:24
but it could also start in the United Kingdom,
179
564505
2527
09:27
in Germany or another European country,
180
567056
2208
09:29
or even in China.
181
569288
1528
09:31
Let's take China as an example.
182
571832
2010
09:33
China is committed to reducing greenhouse gas emissions,
183
573866
4544
09:38
but what its leaders care even more about
184
578434
2341
09:40
is transitioning their economy to consumer-led economic development.
185
580799
4977
09:45
Well, nothing could do more to hasten that transition
186
585800
2876
09:48
than giving every Chinese citizen a monthly dividend.
187
588700
3279
09:52
In fact, this is the only policy solution
188
592003
3521
09:55
that would enable China to meet its environmental and economic goals
189
595548
3642
09:59
at the same time.
190
599214
1358
10:00
That's why this is the killer app of climate policy,
191
600596
3377
10:03
because it would enable us to overcome
192
603997
3339
10:07
each of the barriers we discussed earlier:
193
607360
2313
10:09
the psychological barrier, the partisan barrier,
194
609697
3084
10:12
and, as we've just seen, the geopolitical barrier.
195
612805
3460
10:16
All we need is a country to lead the way.
196
616289
3978
10:20
And one method of finding what you're looking for
197
620291
2429
10:22
is to take out an ad.
198
622744
1660
10:24
So let's read this one together.
199
624428
1979
10:26
Wanted: country to pioneer carbon dividends plan.
200
626431
3810
10:30
Cost to country: zero.
201
630265
1859
10:32
Starting date: as soon as possible.
202
632732
2279
10:35
Advantages: most effective climate solution,
203
635035
3442
10:38
popular and populist,
204
638501
1757
10:40
pro-growth and pro-business,
205
640282
1842
10:42
shrinks government and helps the working class.
206
642148
3342
10:47
Additional compensation: gratitude of current and future generations,
207
647101
5317
10:53
including my daughter.
208
653458
2168
10:56
Thank you.
209
656031
1152
10:57
(Applause)
210
657207
7000
11:04
Chris Anderson: Just one question for you, Ted.
211
664461
2246
11:09
I'm actually not sure
212
669221
1150
11:10
I've seen a conservative get a standing O at TED before that.
213
670396
2877
11:13
That's pretty cool.
214
673317
1428
11:15
The logic seems really powerful,
215
675554
1825
11:17
but some people you talk to in politics
216
677404
2069
11:19
say it's hard to imagine this still getting through Congress.
217
679498
4071
11:23
How are you feeling about momentum behind this?
218
683593
2214
11:26
Ted Halstead: So I understand that many are very pessimistic
219
686132
3624
11:29
about what's happening in the United States with President Trump.
220
689781
3049
11:32
I'm less pessimistic; here's why.
221
692854
1578
11:34
The actions of this White House, the early actions on climate,
222
694457
3005
11:37
are just the first move in a complex game of climate chess.
223
697487
5579
11:43
So far it's been a repeal-only strategy;
224
703090
2610
11:45
the pressure is going to mount for a replacement program,
225
705725
2849
11:48
which is where we come in.
226
708599
1246
11:49
And there are three reasons why, which I'll go through real quickly.
227
709869
3198
11:53
One, the business community is fundamentally parting ways
228
713091
3212
11:56
with the White House on climate change.
229
716328
2435
11:58
In fact, we're finding
230
718788
1150
11:59
a number of Fortune 100 companies supporting our program.
231
719963
3110
12:03
Within two months, we're going to be announcing
232
723098
2198
12:05
some really surprising names coming out in favor of this program.
233
725321
3055
12:08
Two, there is no issue in American politics
234
728400
3132
12:11
where there's a more fundamental gap between the Republican base
235
731557
3809
12:15
and the Republican leadership than climate change.
236
735391
2635
12:18
And three, thinking of this analogy of chess,
237
738050
4730
12:23
the big decision up ahead is: Does the administration stay in Paris?
238
743225
4229
12:27
Well, let's pan it out both ways.
239
747478
1587
12:29
If it stays in Paris, as many are pushing for in the administration,
240
749129
3706
12:32
well then that begs a question: What's the plan?
241
752946
2516
12:35
We have the plan.
242
755565
1230
12:37
But if they don't stay in Paris,
243
757049
2070
12:39
the international pressure will be overwhelming.
244
759144
2452
12:41
Our Secretary of State will be asking other countries for NATO contributions,
245
761620
3626
12:45
and they'll be saying, "No, give us our Paris commitment.
246
765271
2901
12:48
Come through on your commitments, we'll come through on ours."
247
768197
2912
12:51
So, international, business and even the Republican base
248
771133
3294
12:54
will all be calling for a Republican replacement plan.
249
774451
3765
12:58
And, hopefully, we've provided one.
250
778397
2692
13:01
CA: Thank you so much, Ted.
251
781351
1286
13:02
TH: Thank you, Chris.
252
782662
1150
13:03
(Applause)
253
783837
3562
About this website

This site will introduce you to YouTube videos that are useful for learning English. You will see English lessons taught by top-notch teachers from around the world. Double-click on the English subtitles displayed on each video page to play the video from there. The subtitles scroll in sync with the video playback. If you have any comments or requests, please contact us using this contact form.

https://forms.gle/WvT1wiN1qDtmnspy7