Milton Glaser: How great design makes ideas new

78,621 views ・ 2010-04-01

TED


Please double-click on the English subtitles below to play the video.

00:18
'Theme and variations' is one of those forms that
0
18330
3000
00:21
require a certain kind of intellectual activity,
1
21330
5000
00:26
because you are always comparing the variation
2
26330
3000
00:29
with the theme that you hold in your mind.
3
29330
3000
00:32
You might say that the theme is nature
4
32330
4000
00:36
and everything that follows is a variation on the subject.
5
36330
8000
00:46
I was asked, I guess about six years ago,
6
46330
8000
00:54
to do a series of paintings
7
54330
5000
00:59
that in some way would celebrate the birth of Piero della Francesca.
8
59330
7000
01:06
And it was very difficult for me to imagine
9
66330
4000
01:10
how to paint pictures that were based on Piero
10
70330
9000
01:19
until I realized that I could look at Piero as nature --
11
79330
5000
01:26
that I would have the same attitude towards looking at Piero della Francesca
12
86330
7000
01:33
as I would if I were looking out a window at a tree.
13
93330
3000
01:36
And that was enormously liberating to me.
14
96330
3000
01:39
Perhaps it's not a very insightful observation,
15
99330
4000
01:43
but that really started me on a path to be able to do a kind of theme and variations
16
103330
6000
01:49
based on a work by Piero,
17
109330
4000
01:53
in this case that remarkable painting that's in the Uffizi, "The Duke of Montefeltro,"
18
113330
7000
02:00
who faces his consort, Battista.
19
120330
5000
02:05
Once I realized that I could take some liberties with the subject,
20
125330
4000
02:09
I did the following series of drawings.
21
129330
3000
02:13
That's the real Piero della Francesca --
22
133330
4000
02:18
one of the greatest portraits in human history.
23
138330
5000
02:23
And these, I'll just show these without comment.
24
143330
4000
02:27
It's just a series of variations on the head of the Duke of Montefeltro,
25
147330
6000
02:33
who's a great, great figure in the Renaissance,
26
153330
3000
02:36
and probably the basis for Machiavelli's "The Prince."
27
156330
3000
02:39
He apparently lost an eye in battle,
28
159330
3000
02:42
which is why he is always shown in profile.
29
162330
3000
02:45
And this is Battista.
30
165330
3000
02:50
And then I decided I could move them around a little bit --
31
170330
5000
02:56
so that for the first time in history, they're facing the same direction.
32
176330
3000
02:59
Whoops! Passed each other.
33
179330
3000
03:06
And then a visitor from another painting by Piero,
34
186330
3000
03:09
this is from "The Resurrection of Christ" --
35
189330
3000
03:12
as though the cast had just gotten of the set to have a chat.
36
192330
5000
03:17
And now, four large panels:
37
197330
3000
03:20
this is upper left;
38
200330
2000
03:22
upper right;
39
202330
2000
03:26
lower left;
40
206330
2000
03:29
lower right.
41
209330
2000
03:31
Incidentally, I've never understood the conflict between abstraction and naturalism.
42
211330
6000
03:38
Since all paintings are inherently abstract to begin with
43
218330
4000
03:42
there doesn't seem to be an argument there.
44
222330
3000
03:45
On another subject --
45
225330
3000
03:48
(Laughter) --
46
228330
2000
03:51
I was driving in the country one day with my wife,
47
231330
4000
03:55
and I saw this sign,
48
235330
2000
03:57
and I said, "That is a fabulous piece of design."
49
237330
3000
04:00
And she said, "What are you talking about?"
50
240330
3000
04:03
I said, "Well, it's so persuasive,
51
243330
2000
04:05
because the purpose of that sign is to get you into the garage,
52
245330
5000
04:10
and since most people are so suspicious of garages,
53
250330
5000
04:15
and know that they're going to be ripped off,
54
255330
3000
04:18
they use the word 'reliable.'
55
258330
3000
04:21
But everybody says they're reliable.
56
261330
2000
04:23
But, reliable Dutchman" --
57
263330
3000
04:26
(Laughter) --
58
266330
2000
04:28
"Fantastic!"
59
268330
2000
04:30
Because as soon as you hear the word Dutchman --
60
270330
3000
04:33
which is an archaic word, nobody calls Dutch people "Dutchmen" anymore --
61
273330
3000
04:36
but as soon as you hear Dutchman,
62
276330
2000
04:38
you get this picture of the kid with his finger in the dike,
63
278330
3000
04:41
preventing the thing from falling and flooding Holland, and so on.
64
281330
3000
04:44
And so the entire issue is detoxified by the use of "Dutchman."
65
284330
7000
04:51
Now, if you think I'm exaggerating at all in this,
66
291330
3000
04:54
all you have to do is substitute something else, like "Indonesian."
67
294330
4000
04:58
(Laughter)
68
298330
8000
05:06
Or even "French."
69
306330
3000
05:09
(Laughter)
70
309330
5000
05:14
Now, "Swiss" works, but you know it's going to cost a lot of money.
71
314330
4000
05:18
(Laughter)
72
318330
3000
05:21
I'm going to take you quickly through the actual process of doing a poster.
73
321330
6000
05:27
I do a lot of work for the School of Visual Arts, where I teach,
74
327330
3000
05:30
and the director of this school -- a remarkable man named Silas Rhodes --
75
330330
3000
05:33
often gives you a piece of text and he says, "Do something with this."
76
333330
5000
05:38
And so he did.
77
338330
2000
05:40
And this was the text -- "In words as fashion the same rule will hold/
78
340330
3000
05:43
Alike fantastic if too new or old/
79
343330
1000
05:44
Be not the first by whom the new are tried/
80
344330
4000
05:48
Nor yet the last to lay the old aside."
81
348330
3000
05:51
I could make nothing of that.
82
351330
2000
05:53
And I really struggled with this one.
83
353330
2000
05:55
And the first thing I did, which was sort of in the absence of another idea,
84
355330
3000
05:58
was say I'll sort of write it out and make some words big,
85
358330
2000
06:01
and I'll have some kind of design on the back somehow,
86
361330
5000
06:06
and I was hoping -- as one often does -- to stumble into something.
87
366330
3000
06:09
So I took another crack at it --
88
369330
3000
06:12
you've got to keep it moving --
89
372330
2000
06:14
and I Xeroxed some words on pieces of colored paper
90
374330
2000
06:16
and I pasted them down on an ugly board.
91
376330
2000
06:19
I thought that something would come out of it,
92
379330
3000
06:22
like "Words rule fantastic new old first last Pope"
93
382330
3000
06:25
because it's by Alexander Pope,
94
385330
3000
06:28
but I sort of made a mess out of it,
95
388330
2000
06:30
and then I thought I'd repeat it in some way so it was legible.
96
390330
2000
06:32
So, it was going nowhere.
97
392330
2000
06:35
Sometimes, in the middle of a resistant problem,
98
395330
4000
06:39
I write down things that I know about it.
99
399330
3000
06:42
But you can see the beginning of an idea there,
100
402330
2000
06:44
because you can see the word "new" emerging from the "old."
101
404330
3000
06:47
That's what happens.
102
407330
2000
06:49
There's a relationship between the old and the new;
103
409330
3000
06:52
the new emerges from the context of the old.
104
412330
2000
06:54
And then I did some variations of it,
105
414330
2000
06:56
but it still wasn't coalescing graphically at all.
106
416330
4000
07:00
I had this other version which had something interesting about it
107
420330
3000
07:03
in terms of being able to put it together in your mind from clues.
108
423330
6000
07:09
The W was clearly a W, the N was clearly an N,
109
429330
3000
07:12
even though they were very fragmentary
110
432330
4000
07:16
and there wasn't a lot of information in it.
111
436330
2000
07:18
Then I got the words "new" and "old"
112
438330
2000
07:20
and now I had regressed back to a point where there seemed to be no return.
113
440330
5000
07:25
(Laughter)
114
445330
2000
07:27
I was really desperate at this point.
115
447330
3000
07:30
And so, I do something I'm truthfully ashamed of,
116
450330
4000
07:34
which is that I took two drawings I had made for another purpose
117
454330
4000
07:38
and I put them together.
118
458330
4000
07:43
It says "dreams" at the top.
119
463330
3000
07:46
And I was going to do a thing, I say, "Well, change the copy.
120
466330
3000
07:49
Let it say something about dreams, and come to SVA
121
469330
4000
07:53
and you'll sort of fulfill your dreams."
122
473330
2000
07:55
But, to my credit,
123
475330
2000
07:57
I was so embarrassed about doing that
124
477330
3000
08:00
that I never submitted this sketch.
125
480330
3000
08:04
And, finally, I arrived at the following solution.
126
484330
5000
08:09
Now, it doesn't look terribly interesting,
127
489330
4000
08:13
but it does have something
128
493330
3000
08:16
that distinguishes it from a lot of other posters.
129
496330
5000
08:22
For one thing, it transgresses the idea of what a poster's supposed to be,
130
502330
4000
08:26
which is to be understood and seen immediately, and not explained.
131
506330
8000
08:34
I remember hearing all of you in the graphic arts --
132
514330
3000
08:37
"If you have to explain it, it ain't working."
133
517330
3000
08:40
And one day I woke up and I said, "Well, suppose that's not true?"
134
520330
4000
08:44
(Laughter)
135
524330
6000
08:50
So here's what it says in my explanation at the bottom left.
136
530330
4000
08:55
It says, "Thoughts: This poem is impossible.
137
535330
6000
09:01
Silas usually has a better touch with his choice of quotations.
138
541330
4000
09:05
This one generates no imagery at all."
139
545330
2000
09:07
I am now exposing myself to my audience, right?
140
547330
3000
09:10
Which is something you never want to do professionally.
141
550330
3000
09:13
"Maybe the words can make the image without anything else happening.
142
553330
4000
09:17
What's the heart of this poem?
143
557330
2000
09:19
Don't be trendy if you want to be serious.
144
559330
2000
09:21
Is doing the poster this way trendy in itself?
145
561330
3000
09:24
I guess one could reduce the idea further
146
564330
2000
09:26
by suggesting that the new emerges behind and through the old,
147
566330
4000
09:30
like this."
148
570330
2000
09:32
And then I show you a little drawing --
149
572330
2000
09:34
you see, you remember that old thing I discarded?
150
574330
3000
09:37
Well, I found a way to use it.
151
577330
2000
09:39
So, there's that little alternative over there,
152
579330
3000
09:42
and I say, "Not bad," -- criticizing myself --
153
582330
4000
09:46
"but more didactic than visual.
154
586330
3000
09:49
Maybe what wants to be said is that old and the new are locked in a dialectical embrace,
155
589330
3000
09:52
a kind of dance where each defines the other."
156
592330
2000
09:54
And then more self-questioning -- "Am I being simple-minded?
157
594330
4000
09:58
Is this the kind of simple that looks obvious, or the kind that looks profound?
158
598330
4000
10:02
There's a significant difference.
159
602330
2000
10:04
This could be embarrassing.
160
604330
2000
10:06
Actually, I realize fear of embarrassment drives me as much as any ambition.
161
606330
4000
10:10
Do you think this sort of thing could really attract a student to the school?"
162
610330
4000
10:14
(Laughter)
163
614330
7000
10:21
Well, I think there are two fresh things here -- two fresh things.
164
621330
5000
10:26
One is the sort of willingness to expose myself to a critical audience,
165
626330
7000
10:33
and not to suggest that I am confident about what I'm doing.
166
633330
6000
10:39
And as you know, you have to have a front.
167
639330
4000
10:43
I mean -- you've got to be confident;
168
643330
2000
10:45
if you don't believe in your work, who else is going to believe in it?
169
645330
3000
10:48
So that's one thing,
170
648330
2000
10:50
to introduce the idea of doubt into graphics.
171
650330
5000
10:55
That can be a big contribution.
172
655330
2000
10:57
The other thing is to actually give you two solutions for the price of one;
173
657330
4000
11:01
you get the big one
174
661330
3000
11:04
and if you don't like that, how about the little one?
175
664330
3000
11:07
(Laughter)
176
667330
2000
11:09
And that too is a relatively new idea.
177
669330
3000
11:12
And here's just a series of experiments
178
672330
3000
11:15
where I ask the question of -- does a poster have to be square?
179
675330
5000
11:20
Now, this is a little illusion.
180
680330
3000
11:23
That poster is not folded.
181
683330
2000
11:25
It's not folded, that's a photograph
182
685330
3000
11:28
and it's cut on the diagonal.
183
688330
2000
11:31
Same cheap trick in the upper left-hand corner.
184
691330
3000
11:36
And here,
185
696330
2000
11:38
a very peculiar poster because,
186
698330
2000
11:40
simply because of using the isometric perspective in the computer,
187
700330
5000
11:45
it won't sit still in the space.
188
705330
3000
11:48
At times, it seems to be wider at the back than the front,
189
708330
3000
11:51
and then it shifts.
190
711330
2000
11:53
And if you sit here long enough, it'll float off the page into the audience.
191
713330
4000
11:58
But, we don't have time.
192
718330
2000
12:00
(Laughter)
193
720330
1000
12:01
And then an experiment --
194
721330
2000
12:03
a little bit about the nature of perspective,
195
723330
3000
12:06
where the outside shape is determined by the peculiarity of perspective,
196
726330
4000
12:10
but the shape of the bottle -- which is identical to the outside shape --
197
730330
4000
12:14
is seen frontally.
198
734330
2000
12:16
And another piece for the art directors' club
199
736330
4000
12:20
is "Anna Rees" casting long shadows.
200
740330
4000
12:24
This is another poster from the School of Visual Arts.
201
744330
3000
12:27
There were 10 artists invited to participate in it,
202
747330
5000
12:32
and it was one of those things where it was extremely competitive
203
752330
2000
12:34
and I didn't want to be embarrassed,
204
754330
2000
12:36
so I worked very hard on this.
205
756330
3000
12:39
The idea was -- and it was a brilliant idea --
206
759330
2000
12:41
was to have 10 posters distributed throughout the city's subway system
207
761330
4000
12:45
so every time you got on the subway you'd be passing a different poster,
208
765330
4000
12:49
all of which had a different idea of what art is.
209
769330
4000
12:53
But I was absolutely stuck on the idea of "art is"
210
773330
6000
12:59
and trying to determine what art was.
211
779330
4000
13:03
But then I gave up and I said, "Well, art is whatever."
212
783330
4000
13:07
And as soon as I said that,
213
787330
2000
13:09
I discovered that the word "hat" was hidden in the word "whatever,"
214
789330
3000
13:12
and that led me to the inevitable conclusion.
215
792330
3000
13:15
But then again, it's on my list of didactic posters.
216
795330
4000
13:19
My intent is to have a literary accompaniment that explains the poster,
217
799330
4000
13:23
in case you don't get it.
218
803330
3000
13:26
(Laughter)
219
806330
2000
13:28
Now this says, "Note to the viewer:
220
808330
2000
13:30
I thought I might use a visual cliche of our time -- Magritte's everyman --
221
810330
3000
13:33
to express the idea that art is mystery, continuity and history.
222
813330
4000
13:37
I'm also convinced that, in an age of computer manipulation,
223
817330
3000
13:40
surrealism has become banal,
224
820330
3000
13:43
a shadow of its former self.
225
823330
2000
13:45
The phrase 'Art is whatever'
226
825330
2000
13:47
expresses the current inclusiveness that surrounds art-making --
227
827330
3000
13:50
a sort of 'it ain't what you do, it's the way that you do it' notion.
228
830330
3000
13:53
The shadow of Magritte falls across the central part of the poster
229
833330
4000
13:57
a poetic event that occurs as the shadow man isolates the word 'hat,'
230
837330
5000
14:02
hidden in the word 'whatever.'
231
842330
2000
14:04
The four hats shown in the poster suggests how art might be defined:
232
844330
3000
14:07
as a thing itself, the worth of the thing, the shadow of the thing,
233
847330
4000
14:11
and the shape of the thing.
234
851330
2000
14:13
Whatever."
235
853330
2000
14:15
(Applause)
236
855330
1000
14:16
OK.
237
856330
1000
14:17
(Applause)
238
857330
5000
14:22
And the one that I did not submit,
239
862330
3000
14:25
which I still like,
240
865330
2000
14:27
I wanted to use the same phrase.
241
867330
2000
14:29
There were wonderful experiments by Bruno Munari
242
869330
6000
14:35
on letterforms some years ago --
243
875330
2000
14:37
sort of, see how far you could go and still be able to read them.
244
877330
2000
14:39
And that idea stuck in my head.
245
879330
2000
14:41
But then I took the pieces that I had taken off and put them at the bottom.
246
881330
4000
14:46
And, of course those are the remains, and they're so labeled.
247
886330
5000
14:51
But what really happens is that you read it as:
248
891330
3000
14:54
"Art is whatever remains."
249
894330
3000
14:57
Thank you.
250
897330
2000
14:59
(Applause)
251
899330
9000
About this website

This site will introduce you to YouTube videos that are useful for learning English. You will see English lessons taught by top-notch teachers from around the world. Double-click on the English subtitles displayed on each video page to play the video from there. The subtitles scroll in sync with the video playback. If you have any comments or requests, please contact us using this contact form.

https://forms.gle/WvT1wiN1qDtmnspy7