Jorge Ramos: Why journalists have an obligation to challenge power (with English subtitles) | TED

108,195 views ・ 2017-07-27

TED


Please double-click on the English subtitles below to play the video.

00:00
Translator: Camille Martínez
0
0
7000
00:13
I'm a journalist,
1
13620
1247
00:14
and I'm an immigrant.
2
14891
1939
00:16
And these two conditions define me.
3
16854
3230
00:20
I was born in Mexico,
4
20108
1418
00:21
but I've spent more than half my life reporting in the United States,
5
21550
3726
00:25
a country which was itself created by immigrants.
6
25300
2984
00:28
As a reporter
7
28308
2910
00:31
and as a foreigner,
8
31242
1702
00:32
I've learned that neutrality,
9
32968
2339
00:36
silence
10
36139
1197
00:37
and fear aren't the best options --
11
37844
2882
00:40
not in journalism, nor in life.
12
40750
2204
00:42
Neutrality
13
42978
1179
00:45
is often an excuse that we journalists use
14
45046
3206
00:48
to hide from our true responsibility.
15
48276
3309
00:51
What is that responsibility?
16
51609
1814
00:54
It is to question
17
54120
1239
00:56
and to challenge
18
56052
1513
00:57
those in positions of power.
19
57589
1357
00:58
That's what journalism is for.
20
58970
1459
01:00
That's the beauty of journalism:
21
60453
1775
01:02
to question and challenge the powerful.
22
62252
2493
01:05
Of course, we have the obligation to report reality as it is,
23
65401
3437
01:08
not how we would like it to be.
24
68862
1738
01:10
In that sense, I agree with the principle of objectivity:
25
70624
3456
01:14
if a house is blue, I say that it's blue.
26
74104
2458
01:16
If there are a million unemployed people, I say there are a million.
27
76586
3228
01:19
But neutrality
28
79838
1280
01:21
won't necessarily lead me to the truth.
29
81142
3262
01:25
Even if I'm unequivocally scrupulous,
30
85021
3539
01:28
and I present both sides of a news item --
31
88584
3669
01:32
the Democratic and the Republican,
32
92928
2111
01:35
the liberal and the conservative,
33
95063
1637
01:36
the government's and the opposition's --
34
96724
1949
01:38
in the end, I have no guarantee,
35
98697
2459
01:41
nor are any of us guaranteed that we'll know what's true
36
101180
3191
01:44
and what's not true.
37
104395
1408
01:45
Life is much more complicated,
38
105827
1901
01:47
and I believe journalism should reflect that very complexity.
39
107752
5015
01:53
To be clear: I refuse
40
113522
2494
01:57
to be a tape recorder.
41
117154
1342
01:58
I didn't become a journalist to be a tape recorder.
42
118520
2409
02:00
I know what you're going to say: no one uses tape recorders nowadays.
43
120953
3308
02:04
(Laughter)
44
124285
1067
02:05
In that case, I refuse to take out my cell phone
45
125376
3790
02:09
and hit the record button
46
129190
2429
02:11
and point it in front of me as if I were at a concert,
47
131643
2630
02:14
like a fan at a concert.
48
134297
1475
02:16
That is not true journalism.
49
136346
2570
02:18
Contrary to what many people think,
50
138940
2380
02:21
journalists are making value judgments all the time,
51
141344
4549
02:25
ethical and moral judgments.
52
145917
1849
02:27
And we're always making decisions that are exceedingly personal
53
147790
5154
02:33
and extraordinarily subjective.
54
153642
2165
02:35
For example:
55
155831
1204
02:37
What happens if you're called to cover a dictatorship,
56
157797
2579
02:40
like Augusto Pinochet's regime in Chile
57
160400
2065
02:42
or Fidel Castro's in Cuba?
58
162489
2820
02:45
Are you going to report only what the general and commander want,
59
165333
3749
02:49
or will you confront them?
60
169106
1420
02:50
What happens if you find out that in your country
61
170997
3131
02:54
or in the country next door,
62
174919
1818
02:56
students are disappearing
63
176761
3012
02:59
and hidden graves are appearing,
64
179797
2001
03:01
or that millions of dollars are disappearing from the budget
65
181822
2968
03:04
and that ex-presidents are magically now multimillionaires?
66
184814
4410
03:09
Will you report only the official version?
67
189248
2049
03:11
Or what happens
68
191321
1226
03:13
if you're assigned to cover
69
193445
1325
03:15
the presidential elections of the primary superpower,
70
195766
5023
03:20
and one of the candidates makes comments that are racist,
71
200813
4383
03:26
sexist
72
206397
1175
03:28
and xenophobic?
73
208064
1251
03:31
That happened to me.
74
211004
1237
03:33
And I want to tell you what I did,
75
213098
1876
03:34
but first, let me explain where I'm coming from,
76
214998
2568
03:37
so you can understand my reaction.
77
217590
2146
03:42
I grew up in Mexico City, the oldest of five brothers,
78
222510
2884
03:45
and our family simply couldn't afford to pay for all of our college tuition.
79
225418
4672
03:50
So I studied in the morning, and worked in the afternoon.
80
230114
3414
03:53
Eventually,
81
233552
1493
03:55
I got the job I had always wanted:
82
235838
3113
03:58
television reporter.
83
238975
1325
04:00
It was a big opportunity.
84
240324
1700
04:02
But as I was working on my third story, I ended up
85
242048
2749
04:05
criticizing the president,
86
245645
1404
04:07
and questioning the lack of democracy in Mexico.
87
247676
3454
04:11
In Mexico, from 1929 to 2000, elections were always rigged;
88
251154
4871
04:16
the incumbent president would hand-pick his successor.
89
256049
4144
04:20
That's not true democracy.
90
260217
3362
04:23
To me it seemed like a brilliant idea to expose the president,
91
263603
3005
04:26
but to my boss --
92
266632
1227
04:27
(Laughter)
93
267883
1833
04:29
My boss didn't think it was such a great idea.
94
269740
2206
04:31
At that time, the presidential office, Los Pinos, had issued a direct censor
95
271970
3727
04:35
against the media.
96
275721
1474
04:37
My boss, who, aside from being in charge of the show I worked for,
97
277219
3762
04:41
was also in charge of a soccer team.
98
281005
3855
04:44
I always suspected that he was more interested in goals
99
284884
2808
04:47
than in the news.
100
287716
1378
04:49
He censored my report.
101
289118
1318
04:50
He asked me to change it, I said no,
102
290950
2121
04:53
so he put another journalist on the story
103
293095
2936
04:56
to write what I was supposed to say.
104
296055
2553
04:59
I did not want to be a censored journalist.
105
299809
3565
05:03
I don't know where I found the strength,
106
303398
2255
05:05
but I wrote my letter of resignation.
107
305677
1768
05:07
And so at 24 years of age -- just 24 --
108
307972
4306
05:12
I made the most difficult and most transcendental decision of my life.
109
312302
3372
05:15
Not only did I resign from television,
110
315698
2153
05:17
but I had also decided to leave my country.
111
317875
2879
05:21
I sold my car, a beat-up little red Volkswagen,
112
321328
3717
05:25
came up with some money
113
325069
1791
05:26
and said goodbye to my family,
114
326884
1774
05:28
to my friends,
115
328682
1199
05:29
to my streets,
116
329905
1356
05:31
to my favorite haunts -- to my tacos --
117
331285
2089
05:33
(Laughter)
118
333398
1277
05:34
and I bought a one-way ticket
119
334699
2197
05:36
to Los Angeles, California.
120
336920
1522
05:39
And so I became
121
339123
1227
05:41
one of the 250 million immigrants that exist in the world.
122
341052
4826
05:45
Ask any immigrant
123
345902
1816
05:47
about the first day they arrived in their new country,
124
347742
2546
05:50
and you'll find that they remember absolutely everything,
125
350312
2727
05:53
like it was a movie with background music.
126
353063
2058
05:55
In my case, I arrived in Los Angeles, the sun was setting,
127
355145
3992
05:59
and everything I owned --
128
359161
1741
06:00
a guitar, a suitcase and some documents --
129
360926
2608
06:03
I could carry all of it
130
363558
1861
06:05
with my two hands.
131
365959
1159
06:07
That feeling of absolute freedom,
132
367142
2942
06:10
I haven't experienced since.
133
370108
1781
06:11
And I survived with what little I had.
134
371913
2651
06:15
I obtained a student visa; I was studying.
135
375350
4035
06:19
I ate a lot of lettuce and bread, because that's all I had.
136
379976
2955
06:22
Finally, in 1984,
137
382955
2079
06:26
I landed my first job as a TV reporter in the United States.
138
386008
4223
06:30
And the first thing I noticed was that in the US,
139
390255
4047
06:34
my colleagues criticized -- and mercilessly --
140
394326
2183
06:36
then president Ronald Reagan,
141
396533
1485
06:38
and absolutely nothing happened; no one censored them.
142
398042
2888
06:40
And I thought:
143
400954
1240
06:42
I love this country.
144
402666
1498
06:44
(Laughter)
145
404188
2934
06:47
(Applause)
146
407146
3372
06:50
And that's how it's been
147
410542
1538
06:52
for more than 30 years:
148
412709
1600
06:55
reporting with total freedom,
149
415181
1930
06:57
and being treated as an equal despite being an immigrant --
150
417135
2906
07:00
until, without warning,
151
420065
1650
07:01
I was assigned to cover the recent US presidential election.
152
421739
4575
07:08
On June 16, 2015,
153
428356
3046
07:12
a candidate who would eventually become the president of the United States
154
432148
4093
07:16
said that Mexican immigrants
155
436265
2986
07:20
were criminals,
156
440268
1598
07:23
drug traffickers
157
443096
1808
07:24
and rapists.
158
444928
1160
07:26
And I knew
159
446112
1184
07:28
that he was lying.
160
448125
1152
07:29
I knew he was wrong for one very simple reason:
161
449301
2841
07:32
I'm a Mexican immigrant.
162
452166
1512
07:34
And we're not like that.
163
454277
1359
07:35
So I did what any other reporter would have done:
164
455660
3358
07:39
I wrote him a letter by hand
165
459933
1885
07:42
requesting an interview,
166
462993
1771
07:44
and I sent it to his Tower in New York.
167
464788
2378
07:47
The next day
168
467190
1230
07:49
I was at work,
169
469105
1199
07:50
and I suddenly began to receive hundreds of calls and texts
170
470328
3573
07:53
on my cell phone,
171
473925
1489
07:55
some more insulting than others.
172
475438
1542
07:57
I didn't know what was happening until my friend came into my office
173
477004
3497
08:00
and said, "They published your cell number online."
174
480525
3768
08:05
They actually did that.
175
485428
1445
08:07
Here's the letter they sent
176
487764
3374
08:11
where they gave out my number.
177
491162
2218
08:13
Don't bother writing it down, OK? I already changed it.
178
493800
2662
08:16
(Laughter)
179
496486
1512
08:18
But I learned two things.
180
498022
1608
08:19
The first one is that you should never, never, ever
181
499654
3539
08:24
give your cell number to Donald Trump.
182
504129
2865
08:27
(Laughter)
183
507018
2804
08:29
(Applause)
184
509846
3376
08:33
The second lesson was that I needed to stop being neutral
185
513246
4337
08:37
at that point.
186
517607
1161
08:38
From then on, my mission as a journalist changed.
187
518792
2681
08:41
I would confront the candidate
188
521497
2622
08:44
and show that he was wrong,
189
524143
1649
08:45
that what he said about immigrants in the US was not true.
190
525816
3350
08:49
Let me give you some figures.
191
529190
1418
08:50
Ninety-seven percent of all undocumented people in the United States
192
530632
4170
08:54
are good people.
193
534826
1308
08:56
Less than three percent have committed a serious crime,
194
536158
2853
08:59
or "felony," as they say in English.
195
539035
1732
09:00
In comparison, six percent of US citizens have committed a serious crime.
196
540791
4570
09:05
The conclusion is that undocumented immigrants behave much better
197
545385
5838
09:11
than US citizens.
198
551247
1513
09:12
Based on that data, I made a plan.
199
552784
2844
09:15
Eight weeks after they published my cell number,
200
555652
3325
09:19
I obtained a press pass for a press conference
201
559874
2715
09:22
for the candidate gaining momentum in the polls.
202
562613
3424
09:26
I decided to confront him
203
566062
1537
09:28
in person.
204
568361
1175
09:30
But ...
205
570340
1154
09:32
things didn't turn out exactly as I had planned; watch:
206
572192
3555
09:37
[Donald Trump Press Conference Dubuque, Iowa]
207
577349
2902
09:42
(Video) Jorge Ramos: Mr. Trump, I have a question about immigration.
208
582709
3200
09:45
Donald Trump: Who's next? Yes, please.
209
585933
1866
09:47
JR: Your immigration plan is full of empty promises.
210
587823
2437
09:50
DT: Excuse me, you weren't called. Sit down. Sit down!
211
590284
2533
09:52
JR: I'm a reporter; as an immigrant and as a US citizen,
212
592841
2678
09:55
I have the right to ask a question.
213
595543
1675
09:57
DT: No you don't. JR: I have the right to ask --
214
597242
2283
09:59
DT: Go back to Univision.
215
599549
1193
10:00
JR: This is the question:
216
600766
1196
10:01
You cannot deport 11 million people.
217
601986
2432
10:04
You cannot build a 1900-mile wall.
218
604828
3163
10:08
You cannot deny citizenship to children in this country.
219
608015
3685
10:11
DT: Sit down. JR: And with those ideas --
220
611724
1941
10:13
DT: You weren't called.
221
613689
1152
10:14
JR: I'm a reporter and I have -- Don't touch me, sir.
222
614865
2643
10:17
Guard 1: Please don't disrupt. You're being disruptive.
223
617913
2598
10:20
JR: I have the right to ask a question. G1: Yes, in order. In turn, sir.
224
620535
3558
10:24
Guard 2: Do you have your media credential?
225
624117
2021
10:26
JR: I have the right --
226
626162
1153
10:27
G2: Where? Let me see. JR: It's over there.
227
627339
2009
10:29
Man: Whoever's coming out, stay out.
228
629372
1730
10:31
G2: You've just got to wait your turn.
229
631126
1842
10:32
Man: You're very rude. It's not about you.
230
632992
2027
10:35
JR: It's not about you -- Man: Get out of my country!
231
635043
2528
10:37
Man: It's not about you.
232
637595
1169
10:38
JR: I'm a US citizen, too.
233
638788
1252
10:40
Man: Well ...whatever. No, Univision. It's not about you.
234
640064
2677
10:42
JR: It's not about you. It's about the United States.
235
642765
2639
10:48
(Applause)
236
648095
2913
10:59
(Applause ends)
237
659181
1900
11:02
Whenever I see that video,
238
662771
1835
11:04
the first thing I always think is that hate
239
664630
3290
11:07
is contagious.
240
667944
1269
11:09
If you notice, after the candidate says, "Go back to Univision" -- that's code;
241
669237
4290
11:13
what he's telling me is, "Get out of here."
242
673551
2195
11:15
One member of his entourage, as if he had been given permission, said,
243
675770
3837
11:19
"Get out of my country,"
244
679631
2395
11:22
not knowing that I'm also a US citizen.
245
682050
2804
11:26
After watching this video many times,
246
686903
2513
11:29
I also think that in order to break free from neutrality --
247
689440
2994
11:32
and for it to be a true break --
248
692458
1549
11:34
one has to lose their fear,
249
694031
2172
11:36
and then learn how to say, "No;
250
696227
2205
11:38
I'm not going to be quiet.
251
698456
1489
11:40
I'm not going to sit down.
252
700568
1534
11:42
And I'm not going to leave."
253
702899
1349
11:44
The word "no" --
254
704795
1485
11:46
(Applause)
255
706304
4605
11:50
"no" is the most powerful word that exists in any language,
256
710933
3872
11:54
and it always precedes any important change in our lives.
257
714829
3272
11:58
And I think there's enormous dignity
258
718125
2193
12:00
and it generates a great deal of respect
259
720342
1930
12:02
to be able to step back
260
722296
1529
12:03
and to push back and say,
261
723849
1611
12:06
"No."
262
726009
1166
12:07
Elie Wiesel -- Holocaust survivor,
263
727199
2582
12:09
Nobel Peace Prize recipient
264
729805
1334
12:11
and who, unfortunately, we lost very recently --
265
731163
2814
12:14
said some very wise words:
266
734001
2327
12:16
"We must take a side.
267
736352
1409
12:18
Neutrality helps only the oppressor,
268
738776
2516
12:21
never the victim."
269
741316
1151
12:22
And he's completely right.
270
742491
1245
12:23
We journalists are obligated to take sides in certain circumstances;
271
743760
3842
12:27
in cases of racism,
272
747626
1429
12:29
discrimination,
273
749476
1202
12:31
corruption,
274
751246
1371
12:32
lying to the public,
275
752641
1484
12:34
dictatorships and human rights,
276
754149
1912
12:36
we need to set aside neutrality and indifference.
277
756085
2927
12:39
Spanish has a great word
278
759616
1976
12:42
to describe the stance that journalists should take.
279
762140
4039
12:46
The word is "contrapoder [anti-establishment]."
280
766203
2238
12:48
Basically, we journalists should be on the opposite side
281
768465
3261
12:52
from those in power.
282
772386
1592
12:54
But if you're in bed with politicians,
283
774002
2574
12:56
if you go to the baptism or wedding of the governor's son
284
776600
2697
12:59
or if you want to be the president's buddy,
285
779321
2049
13:01
how are you going to criticize them?
286
781394
1841
13:03
When I'm assigned to interview a powerful or influential person,
287
783259
3289
13:06
I always keep two things in mind:
288
786572
1749
13:08
if I don't ask this difficult and uncomfortable question,
289
788345
2744
13:11
no one else is going to;
290
791113
1280
13:13
and that I'm never going to see this person again.
291
793718
2943
13:16
So I'm not looking to make a good impression
292
796685
3140
13:20
or to forge a connection.
293
800772
1304
13:22
In the end, if I have to choose between being the president's friend
294
802100
3243
13:25
or enemy,
295
805367
1158
13:26
I always prefer to be their enemy.
296
806549
2824
13:31
In closing:
297
811001
1166
13:33
I know this is a difficult time to be an immigrant and a journalist,
298
813160
4894
13:38
but now more than ever,
299
818078
1878
13:39
we need journalists who are prepared,
300
819980
3161
13:43
at any given moment,
301
823165
1571
13:44
to set neutrality aside.
302
824760
1794
13:47
Personally, I feel like I've been preparing for this moment
303
827177
2838
13:50
my whole life.
304
830039
1154
13:51
When they censored me when I was 24,
305
831217
2286
13:53
I learned that neutrality, fear and silence often make you an accomplice
306
833527
6670
14:00
in crime, abuse
307
840221
1857
14:02
and injustice.
308
842667
1547
14:04
And being an accomplice to power
309
844238
2025
14:06
is never good journalism.
310
846287
2540
14:09
Now, at 59 years old,
311
849394
2670
14:12
I only hope to have a tiny bit
312
852088
1814
14:14
of the courage and mental clarity I had at 24,
313
854910
4007
14:18
and that way, never again
314
858941
1473
14:21
remain quiet.
315
861285
1373
14:22
Thank you very much.
316
862682
1268
14:23
(Applause)
317
863974
2639
14:26
Thank you.
318
866637
1183
14:27
(Applause)
319
867844
2000
About this website

This site will introduce you to YouTube videos that are useful for learning English. You will see English lessons taught by top-notch teachers from around the world. Double-click on the English subtitles displayed on each video page to play the video from there. The subtitles scroll in sync with the video playback. If you have any comments or requests, please contact us using this contact form.

https://forms.gle/WvT1wiN1qDtmnspy7