How to deconstruct racism, one headline at a time | Baratunde Thurston

1,383,133 views ・ 2019-06-26

TED


Please double-click on the English subtitles below to play the video.

00:12
My parents gave me an extraordinary name:
0
12708
4726
00:17
Baratunde Rafiq Thurston.
1
17458
4584
00:23
Now, Baratunde is based on a Yoruba name from Nigeria,
2
23250
3143
00:26
but we're not Nigerian.
3
26417
1559
00:28
(Laughter)
4
28000
1018
00:29
That's just how black my mama was.
5
29042
1976
00:31
(Laughter)
6
31042
1017
00:32
"Get this boy the blackest name possible. What does the book say?"
7
32083
3143
00:35
(Laughter)
8
35250
1559
00:36
Rafiq is an Arabic name, but we are not Arabs.
9
36833
3726
00:40
My mom just wanted me to have difficulty boarding planes in the 21st century.
10
40583
4393
00:45
(Laughter)
11
45000
1018
00:46
She foresaw America's turn toward nativism.
12
46042
2767
00:48
She was a black futurist.
13
48833
1768
00:50
(Laughter)
14
50625
1684
00:52
Thurston is a British name, but we are not British.
15
52333
4768
00:57
Shoutout to the multigenerational, dehumanizing economic institution
16
57125
3518
01:00
of American chattel slavery, though.
17
60667
2559
01:03
Also, Thurston makes for a great Starbucks name.
18
63250
2434
01:05
Really expedites the process.
19
65708
1726
01:07
(Laughter)
20
67458
1875
01:11
My mother was a renaissance woman.
21
71417
3267
01:14
Arnita Lorraine Thurston
22
74708
2560
01:17
was a computer programmer, former domestic worker,
23
77292
2767
01:20
survivor of sexual assault,
24
80083
2185
01:22
an artist and an activist.
25
82292
2559
01:24
She prepared me for this world with lessons in black history,
26
84875
4143
01:29
in martial arts, in urban farming,
27
89042
2767
01:31
and then she sent me in the seventh grade to the private Sidwell Friends School,
28
91833
3893
01:35
where US presidents send their daughters,
29
95750
2476
01:38
and where she sent me looking like this.
30
98250
2559
01:40
(Laughter)
31
100833
3310
01:44
I had two key tasks going to that school:
32
104167
3059
01:47
don't lose your blackness and don't lose your glasses.
33
107250
2559
01:49
This accomplished both.
34
109833
1976
01:51
(Laughter)
35
111833
3810
01:55
Sidwell was a great place to learn the arts and the sciences,
36
115667
3226
01:58
but also the art of living amongst whiteness.
37
118917
4184
02:03
That would prepare me for life later at Harvard,
38
123125
2934
02:06
or doing corporate consulting,
39
126083
1476
02:07
or for my jobs at "The Daily Show" and "The Onion."
40
127583
2393
02:10
I would write down many of these lessons in my memoir, "How to Be Black,"
41
130000
3518
02:13
which if you haven't read yet, makes you a racist, because --
42
133542
3267
02:16
(Laughter)
43
136833
1226
02:18
you've had plenty of time to read the book.
44
138083
2125
02:23
But America insists on reminding me
45
143208
3060
02:26
and teaching me
46
146292
1434
02:27
what it means to be black in America.
47
147750
3143
02:30
It's December 2018,
48
150917
1976
02:32
I'm with my fiancé in the suburbs of Wisconsin.
49
152917
3726
02:36
We are visiting her parents, both of whom are white,
50
156667
3101
02:39
which makes her white.
51
159792
1267
02:41
That's how it works. I don't make the rules.
52
161083
2101
02:43
(Laughter)
53
163208
1143
02:44
She's had some drinks, so I drive us in her parents' car,
54
164375
4268
02:48
and we get pulled over by the police.
55
168667
2291
02:51
I'm scared.
56
171875
1434
02:53
I turn on the flashing lights to indicate compliance.
57
173333
3476
02:56
I pull over slowly
58
176833
1393
02:58
under the brightest streetlight I can find
59
178250
2643
03:00
in case I need witnesses or dashcam footage.
60
180917
2958
03:05
We get out my identification, the car registration,
61
185417
3059
03:08
lay it out in the open, roll down the windows,
62
188500
2184
03:10
my hands are placed on the steering wheel,
63
190708
2310
03:13
all before the officer exits the vehicle.
64
193042
3416
03:17
This is how to stay alive.
65
197292
3000
03:21
As we wait, I think about these headlines --
66
201042
3226
03:24
"Police shoot another unarmed black person" --
67
204292
3767
03:28
and I don't want to join them.
68
208083
1875
03:31
The good news is, our officer was friendly.
69
211208
3143
03:34
She told us our tags were expired.
70
214375
2726
03:37
So to all the white parents out there,
71
217125
1893
03:39
if your child is involved with a person
72
219042
2434
03:41
whose skin tone is rated Dwayne "The Rock" Johnson or darker --
73
221500
3351
03:44
(Laughter)
74
224875
2518
03:47
you need to get that car inspected, update the paperwork every time we visit.
75
227417
3642
03:51
That's just common courtesy.
76
231083
1393
03:52
(Laughter)
77
232500
1268
03:53
(Applause)
78
233792
3601
03:57
I got lucky.
79
237417
2017
03:59
I got a law enforcement professional.
80
239458
3143
04:02
I survived something that should not require survival.
81
242625
3750
04:07
And I think about this series of stories --
82
247375
2976
04:10
"Police shoot another unarmed black person" --
83
250375
2643
04:13
and that season when those stories popped up everywhere.
84
253042
4351
04:17
I would scroll through my feed
85
257417
2101
04:19
and I would see a baby announcement photo.
86
259542
2642
04:22
I'd see an ad for a product
87
262208
1893
04:24
I had just whispered to a friend about yesterday.
88
264125
3393
04:27
I would see a video of a police officer gunning down someone
89
267542
3184
04:30
who looked just like me.
90
270750
1934
04:32
And I'd see a think piece
91
272708
1268
04:34
about how millennials have replaced sex with avocado toast.
92
274000
3143
04:37
(Laughter)
93
277167
1601
04:38
It was a confusing time.
94
278792
2726
04:41
Those stories kept popping up,
95
281542
2101
04:43
but in 2018, those stories got changed out for a different type of story,
96
283667
5851
04:49
stories like, "White Woman Calls Cops On Black Woman Waiting For An Uber."
97
289542
4434
04:54
That was Brooklyn Becky.
98
294000
2559
04:56
Then there was, "White Woman Calls Police
99
296583
1976
04:58
On Eight-Year-Old Black Girl Selling Water."
100
298583
2101
05:00
That was Permit Patty.
101
300708
1435
05:02
Then there was, "Woman Calls Police
102
302167
1726
05:03
On Black Family BBQing At Lake In Oakland."
103
303917
2517
05:06
That was now infamous BBQ Becky.
104
306458
3685
05:10
And I contend that these stories of living while black
105
310167
3184
05:13
are actually progress.
106
313375
1768
05:15
We used to find out after the extrajudicial police killings.
107
315167
3976
05:19
Now, we're getting video of people calling 911.
108
319167
2976
05:22
We're moving upstream,
109
322167
1726
05:23
closer to the problem and closer to the solution.
110
323917
3125
05:27
So I started a collection
111
327917
2601
05:30
of as many of these stories as I could find.
112
330542
2476
05:33
I built an evolving, still-growing database
113
333042
2726
05:35
at baratunde.com/livingwhileblack.
114
335792
2851
05:38
Seeking understanding, I realized the process
115
338667
3017
05:41
was really diagramming sentences to understand these headlines.
116
341708
4893
05:46
And I want to thank my Sidwell English teacher Erica Berry
117
346625
3309
05:49
and all English teachers.
118
349958
1435
05:51
You have given us tools to fight for our own freedom.
119
351417
2958
05:55
What I found was a process to break down the headline
120
355583
2976
05:58
and understand the consistent layers
121
358583
2726
06:01
in each one:
122
361333
1351
06:02
a subject takes an action against a target engaged in some activity,
123
362708
4768
06:07
so that "White Woman Calls Police On Eight-Year-Old Black Girl"
124
367500
4101
06:11
is the same as "White Man Calls Police On Black Woman Using Neighborhood Pool"
125
371625
4518
06:16
is the same as "Woman Calls Cops On Black Oregon Lawmaker
126
376167
3434
06:19
Campaigning In Her District."
127
379625
2542
06:22
They're the same.
128
382833
1250
06:25
Diagramming the sentences allowed me to diagram the white supremacy
129
385000
4184
06:29
which allowed such sentences to be true,
130
389208
1935
06:31
and I will pause to define my terms.
131
391167
2892
06:34
When I say "white supremacy,"
132
394083
1476
06:35
I'm not just talking about Nazis
133
395583
2518
06:38
or white power activists,
134
398125
1893
06:40
and I'm definitely not saying that all white people are racist.
135
400042
4601
06:44
What I'm referring to
136
404667
1476
06:46
is a system of structural advantage that favors white people over others
137
406167
5351
06:51
in social, economic and political arenas.
138
411542
2684
06:54
It's what Bryan Stevenson at the Equal Justice Initiative
139
414250
3268
06:57
calls the narrative of racial difference,
140
417542
2809
07:00
the story we told ourselves to justify slavery and Jim Crow
141
420375
4601
07:05
and mass incarceration and beyond.
142
425000
2643
07:07
So when I saw this pattern repeating,
143
427667
3226
07:10
I got angry,
144
430917
1809
07:12
but I also got inspired
145
432750
2559
07:15
to create a game,
146
435333
1893
07:17
a game of words that would allow me to transform this traumatic exposure
147
437250
5351
07:22
into more of a healing experience.
148
442625
2934
07:25
I'm going to talk you through the game.
149
445583
2101
07:27
The first level is a training level, and I need your participation.
150
447708
3726
07:31
Our objective: to determine if this is real or fake.
151
451458
3518
07:35
Did this happen or not?
152
455000
1601
07:36
Here is the example:
153
456625
1351
07:38
"Catholic University Law Librarian Calls Police On Student
154
458000
4059
07:42
For 'Being Argumentative.'"
155
462083
2268
07:44
Clap your hands if you think this is real.
156
464375
2226
07:46
(Applause)
157
466625
3309
07:49
Clap your hands if you think this is fake.
158
469958
2310
07:52
(Applause)
159
472292
3226
07:55
The reals have it, unfortunately,
160
475542
2767
07:58
and a point of information,
161
478333
2185
08:00
being argumentative in a law library
162
480542
2392
08:02
is the exact right place to do that.
163
482958
2101
08:05
(Laughter)
164
485083
1101
08:06
This student should be promoted to professor.
165
486208
2125
08:09
Training level complete, so we move on to the real levels.
166
489167
3351
08:12
Level one, our objective is simple:
167
492542
2601
08:15
reverse the roles.
168
495167
1976
08:17
That means "Woman Calls Cops On Black Oregon Lawmaker"
169
497167
3101
08:20
becomes "Black Oregon Lawmaker Calls Cops On Woman."
170
500292
3892
08:24
That means "White Man Calls Police On Black Woman
171
504208
2643
08:26
Using Neighborhood Pool"
172
506875
1601
08:28
becomes "Black Woman Calls Police On White Man Using Neighborhood Pool."
173
508500
4643
08:33
How do you like them reverse racist apples?
174
513167
2041
08:36
That's it, level one complete,
175
516625
2476
08:39
and so we level up to level two,
176
519125
2768
08:41
where our objective is to increase the believability of the reversal.
177
521917
4434
08:46
Let's face it, a black woman calling police on a white man using a pool
178
526375
3333
08:49
isn't absurd enough,
179
529732
1911
08:51
but what if that white man was trying to touch her hair without asking,
180
531667
3750
08:56
or maybe he was making oat milk while riding a unicycle,
181
536917
3916
09:02
or maybe he's just talking over everyone in a meeting.
182
542417
2892
09:05
(Laughter)
183
545333
1185
09:06
We've all been there, right?
184
546542
2017
09:08
Seriously, we've all been there.
185
548583
1584
09:11
So that's it, level two complete.
186
551917
2976
09:14
But it comes with a warning:
187
554917
2059
09:17
simply reversing the flow of injustice is not justice.
188
557000
4809
09:21
That is vengeance, that is not our mission,
189
561833
2143
09:24
that's a different game so we level up to level three,
190
564000
4393
09:28
where the objective is to change the action,
191
568417
3059
09:31
also known as "calling the police is not your only option
192
571500
3518
09:35
OMG, what is wrong with you people!"
193
575042
1726
09:36
(Applause)
194
576792
1434
09:38
And I need to pause the game to remind us of the structure.
195
578250
4268
09:42
A subject takes an action against a target engaged in some activity.
196
582542
4851
09:47
"White Woman Calls Police On Black Real Estate Investor
197
587417
2892
09:50
Inspecting His Own Property."
198
590333
2101
09:52
"California Safeway Calls Cops On Black Woman
199
592458
2810
09:55
Donating Food To The Homeless."
200
595292
2559
09:57
"Gold Club Twice Calls Cops On Black Women For Playing Too Slow."
201
597875
4750
10:03
In all these cases, the subject is usually white,
202
603667
3517
10:07
the target is usually black,
203
607208
1976
10:09
and the activities are anything,
204
609208
2685
10:11
from sitting in a Starbucks
205
611917
2642
10:14
to using the wrong type of barbecue
206
614583
2435
10:17
to napping
207
617042
1351
10:18
to walking "agitated" on the way to work,
208
618417
3226
10:21
which I just call "walking to work."
209
621667
2351
10:24
(Laughter)
210
624042
1559
10:25
And, my personal favorite,
211
625625
2059
10:27
not stopping his dog from humping her dog,
212
627708
3976
10:31
which is clearly a case for dog police,
213
631708
2601
10:34
not people police.
214
634333
1625
10:36
All of these activities add up to living.
215
636625
4125
10:42
Our existence is being interpreted as crime.
216
642292
4809
10:47
Now, this is the obligatory moment in the presentation where I have to say,
217
647125
3809
10:50
not everything is about race.
218
650958
2268
10:53
Crime is a thing, should be reported,
219
653250
2559
10:55
but ask yourself, do we need armed men to show up and resolve this situation,
220
655833
5976
11:01
because when they show up for me,
221
661833
2518
11:04
it's different.
222
664375
1292
11:06
We know that police officers
223
666417
2476
11:08
use force more with black people than with white people,
224
668917
4434
11:13
and we are learning the role of 911 calls in this.
225
673375
3643
11:17
Thanks to preliminary research from the Center for Policing Equity,
226
677042
3601
11:20
we're learning that in some cities,
227
680667
1726
11:22
most of the interactions between cops and citizens
228
682417
2601
11:25
is due to 911 calls,
229
685042
1809
11:26
not officer-initiated stops,
230
686875
2059
11:28
and most of the violence, the use of force by police on citizens,
231
688958
3893
11:32
is in response to those calls.
232
692875
2184
11:35
Further, when those officers responding to calls use force,
233
695083
4143
11:39
that increases in areas
234
699250
2351
11:41
where the percentage of the white population
235
701625
2101
11:43
has also increased,
236
703750
1309
11:45
aka gentrification,
237
705083
2060
11:47
aka unicycles and oat milk,
238
707167
2892
11:50
aka when BBQ Becky feels threatened,
239
710083
2893
11:53
she becomes a threat to me in my own neighborhood,
240
713000
4309
11:57
which forces me and people like me
241
717333
2310
11:59
to police ourselves.
242
719667
2017
12:01
We quiet ourselves, we walk on eggshells,
243
721708
3018
12:04
we maybe pull over to the side of the road
244
724750
2684
12:07
under the brightest light we can find
245
727458
1976
12:09
so that our murder
246
729458
1851
12:11
might be caught cleanly on camera,
247
731333
2893
12:14
and we do this because we live in a system
248
734250
2976
12:17
in which white people can too easily call on deadly force
249
737250
4018
12:21
to ensure their comfort.
250
741292
2208
12:24
(Applause)
251
744542
3125
12:30
The California Safeway
252
750042
1309
12:31
didn't just call cops on black woman donating food to homeless.
253
751375
4809
12:36
They ordered armed, unaccountable men upon her.
254
756208
3393
12:39
They essentially called in a drone strike.
255
759625
2792
12:43
This is weaponized discomfort,
256
763125
3434
12:46
and it is not new.
257
766583
1459
12:48
From 1877 to 1950,
258
768958
2351
12:51
there were at least 4,400 documented racial terror lynchings of black people
259
771333
5518
12:56
in the United States.
260
776875
1893
12:58
They had headlines as well.
261
778792
2226
13:01
"Rev. T.A. Allen was lynched in Hernando, Mississippi
262
781042
3392
13:04
for organizing local sharecroppers."
263
784458
3185
13:07
"Oliver Moore was lynched in Edgecomb County, North Carolina,
264
787667
2851
13:10
for frightening a white girl."
265
790542
1434
13:12
"Nathan Bird was lynched near Luling, Texas,
266
792000
2059
13:14
for refusing to turn his son over to a mob."
267
794083
3292
13:18
We need to change the action,
268
798417
2351
13:20
whether that action is "lynches"
269
800792
1851
13:22
or "calls police."
270
802667
2059
13:24
And now that I have shortened the distance between those two,
271
804750
3518
13:28
let's get back to our game, to our mission.
272
808292
2684
13:31
Our objective in level three is to change the action.
273
811000
3018
13:34
So what if, instead of
274
814042
1809
13:35
"Calls Cops On Black Woman Donating Food To Homeless,"
275
815875
2934
13:38
that California Safeway simply thanks her.
276
818833
2584
13:42
Thanking is far cheaper than bringing law enforcement to the scene.
277
822500
3226
13:45
(Applause)
278
825750
1268
13:47
Or, instead,
279
827042
2392
13:49
they could give the food they would have wasted to her,
280
829458
2601
13:52
upped their civic cred.
281
832083
1750
13:54
Or, the white woman who called the police on the eight-year-old black girl,
282
834708
3560
13:58
she could have bought all the inventory from that little black girl,
283
838292
3392
14:01
support a small business.
284
841708
2185
14:03
And the white woman who called the police on the black real estate investor,
285
843917
3601
14:07
we would all be better off, the cops agree,
286
847542
2059
14:09
if she had simply ignored him and minded her own damn business.
287
849625
2976
14:12
(Laughter)
288
852625
1559
14:14
Minding one's own damn business is an excellent choice, excellent choice.
289
854208
4435
14:18
Choose it more often.
290
858667
1809
14:20
Level three is complete, but there is a final bonus level,
291
860500
4601
14:25
where the objective is inclusion.
292
865125
2768
14:27
We have also seen headlines like this:
293
867917
2476
14:30
"Powerful Man Masturbates In Front Of Young Women
294
870417
2976
14:33
Visiting His Office."
295
873417
1375
14:35
What an odd choice for powerful man to make.
296
875542
3767
14:39
So many other actions available to him.
297
879333
2893
14:42
(Laughter)
298
882250
1018
14:43
Like, such as, "listens to,"
299
883292
3642
14:46
"mentors,"
300
886958
1268
14:48
"inspired by, starts joint venture, everybody rich now."
301
888250
4268
14:52
(Laughter)
302
892542
1267
14:53
I want to live in that world of everybody rich now,
303
893833
2435
14:56
but because of his poor choice, we are all in a poorer world.
304
896292
3916
15:01
Doesn't have to be this way.
305
901125
1934
15:03
This word game reminded me that there is a structure to white supremacy,
306
903083
4560
15:07
as there is to misogyny,
307
907667
1601
15:09
as there is to all systemic abuses of power.
308
909292
3351
15:12
Structure is what makes them systemic.
309
912667
2958
15:17
I'm asking people here
310
917083
1935
15:19
to see the structure,
311
919042
2059
15:21
where the power is in it,
312
921125
2393
15:23
and even more importantly to see the humanity
313
923542
3351
15:26
of those of us made targets by this structure.
314
926917
3458
15:31
I am here because I was loved and invested in and protected and lucky,
315
931042
6142
15:37
because I went to the right schools, I'm semifamous, mostly happy,
316
937208
3143
15:40
meditate twice a day,
317
940375
1768
15:42
and yet,
318
942167
1809
15:44
I walk around in fear,
319
944000
2393
15:46
because I know that someone seeing me as a threat
320
946417
4434
15:50
can become a threat to my life,
321
950875
2476
15:53
and I am tired.
322
953375
1667
15:56
I am tired of carrying
323
956000
1434
15:57
this invisible burden of other people's fears,
324
957458
3851
16:01
and many of us are,
325
961333
2060
16:03
and we shouldn't have to,
326
963417
2184
16:05
because we can change this,
327
965625
2893
16:08
because we can change the action, which changes the story,
328
968542
4517
16:13
which changes the system
329
973083
2042
16:16
that allows those stories to happen.
330
976292
1851
16:18
Systems are just collective stories we all buy into.
331
978167
3916
16:23
When we change them,
332
983083
2143
16:25
we write a better reality for us all to be a part of.
333
985250
4518
16:29
I am asking us
334
989792
2101
16:31
to use our power to choose.
335
991917
2476
16:34
I am asking us to level up.
336
994417
3517
16:37
Thank you.
337
997958
1268
16:39
I am Baratunde Rafiq Thurston.
338
999250
2434
16:41
(Applause)
339
1001708
4792
About this website

This site will introduce you to YouTube videos that are useful for learning English. You will see English lessons taught by top-notch teachers from around the world. Double-click on the English subtitles displayed on each video page to play the video from there. The subtitles scroll in sync with the video playback. If you have any comments or requests, please contact us using this contact form.

https://forms.gle/WvT1wiN1qDtmnspy7