How the US government spies on people who protest -- including you | Jennifer Granick

101,687 views ・ 2017-09-14

TED


Please double-click on the English subtitles below to play the video.

00:12
We are all activists now.
0
12653
2127
00:15
(Applause)
1
15420
1296
00:16
Thank you.
2
16740
1200
00:18
I'll just stop here.
3
18500
1336
00:19
(Laughter)
4
19859
1177
00:21
From the families who are fighting to maintain funding for public schools,
5
21060
4680
00:26
the tens of thousands of people who joined Occupy Wall Street
6
26460
4376
00:30
or marched with Black Lives Matter
7
30860
2176
00:33
to protest police brutality against African Americans,
8
33060
3560
00:37
families that join rallies,
9
37580
2496
00:40
pro-life and pro-choice,
10
40100
2000
00:43
those of us who are afraid
11
43420
1736
00:45
that our friends and neighbors are going to be deported
12
45180
3376
00:48
or that they'll be added to lists
13
48580
1976
00:50
because they are Muslim,
14
50580
1320
00:53
people who advocate for gun rights and for gun control
15
53300
4240
00:58
and the millions of people who joined the women's marches
16
58460
3496
01:01
all across the country this last January.
17
61980
2776
01:04
(Applause)
18
64780
2656
01:07
We are all activists now,
19
67460
2096
01:09
and that means that we all have something to worry about from surveillance.
20
69580
4480
01:15
Surveillance means government collection and use
21
75140
2696
01:17
of private and sensitive data about us.
22
77860
3216
01:21
And surveillance is essential
23
81100
1936
01:23
to law enforcement and to national security.
24
83060
3096
01:26
But the history of surveillance
25
86180
1976
01:28
is one that includes surveillance abuses
26
88180
3496
01:31
where this sensitive information has been used against people
27
91700
3456
01:35
because of their race,
28
95180
1536
01:36
their national origin,
29
96740
1776
01:38
their sexual orientation,
30
98540
2056
01:40
and in particular, because of their activism,
31
100620
3176
01:43
their political beliefs.
32
103820
1600
01:46
About 53 years ago,
33
106580
2616
01:49
Dr. Martin Luther King Jr. gave his "I have a dream" speech
34
109220
3536
01:52
on the Mall in Washington.
35
112780
1280
01:54
And today the ideas behind this speech of racial equality and tolerance
36
114860
4696
01:59
are so noncontroversial
37
119580
1936
02:01
that my daughters study the speech in third grade.
38
121540
2680
02:04
But at the time,
39
124980
1336
02:06
Dr. King was extremely controversial.
40
126340
2400
02:09
The legendary and notorious FBI Director J. Edgar Hoover believed,
41
129340
5496
02:14
or wanted to believe,
42
134860
1816
02:16
that the Civil Rights Movement was a Soviet communist plot
43
136700
3575
02:20
intended to destabilize the American government.
44
140299
3161
02:23
And so Hoover had his agents put bugs in Dr. King's hotel rooms,
45
143900
6256
02:30
and those bugs picked up conversations between civil rights leaders
46
150180
5536
02:35
talking about the strategies and tactics of the Civil Rights Movement.
47
155740
4440
02:40
They also picked up sounds of Dr. King
48
160900
2216
02:43
having sex with women who were not his wife,
49
163140
2856
02:46
and J. Edgar Hoover saw the opportunity here
50
166020
2736
02:48
to discredit and undermine the Civil Rights Movement.
51
168780
3640
02:53
The FBI sent a package of these recordings
52
173220
3616
02:56
along with a handwritten note to Dr. King,
53
176860
3080
03:00
and a draft of this note was found in FBI archives years later,
54
180700
5680
03:07
and the letter said,
55
187100
1736
03:08
"You are no clergyman and you know it.
56
188860
2776
03:11
King, like all frauds, your end is approaching."
57
191660
3560
03:15
The letter even seemed to encourage Dr. King to commit suicide,
58
195860
4840
03:21
saying, "King, there is only one thing left for you to do.
59
201380
3776
03:25
You know what it is.
60
205180
1576
03:26
You better take it before your filthy, abnormal, fraudulent self
61
206780
4336
03:31
is bared to the nation."
62
211140
1856
03:33
But the important thing is,
63
213020
1416
03:34
Dr. King was not abnormal.
64
214460
1680
03:36
Every one of us has something that we want to hide from somebody.
65
216700
4160
03:41
And even more important,
66
221820
1816
03:43
J. Edgar Hoover wasn't abnormal either.
67
223660
2480
03:46
The history of surveillance abuses
68
226900
1936
03:48
is not the history of one bad, megalomaniacal man.
69
228860
3400
03:52
Throughout his decades at the FBI,
70
232900
3016
03:55
J. Edgar Hoover enjoyed the support of the presidents that he served,
71
235940
3736
03:59
Democratic and Republican alike.
72
239700
2280
04:02
After all, it was John F. Kennedy and his brother Robert Kennedy
73
242500
3336
04:05
who knew about and approved the surveillance of Dr. King.
74
245860
2960
04:10
Hoover ran a program called COINTELPRO for 15 years
75
250460
4416
04:14
which was designed to spy on and undermine civic groups
76
254900
4776
04:19
that were devoted to things like civil rights,
77
259700
2736
04:22
the Women's Rights Movement,
78
262460
1736
04:24
and peace groups and anti-war movements.
79
264220
2736
04:26
And the surveillance didn't stop there.
80
266980
2359
04:29
Lyndon Baines Johnson,
81
269779
1697
04:31
during the election campaign,
82
271500
2016
04:33
had the campaign airplane of his rival Barry Goldwater bugged
83
273540
5976
04:39
as part of his effort to win that election.
84
279540
2800
04:43
And then, of course, there was Watergate.
85
283020
2680
04:47
Burglars were caught
86
287340
1456
04:48
breaking into the Democratic National Committee headquarters
87
288820
2856
04:51
at the Watergate Hotel,
88
291700
1536
04:53
the Nixon administration was involved in covering up the burglary,
89
293260
4176
04:57
and eventually Nixon had to step down as president.
90
297460
3480
05:01
COINTELPRO and Watergate were a wake-up call for Americans.
91
301860
4736
05:06
Surveillance was out of control
92
306620
1856
05:08
and it was being used to squelch political challengers.
93
308500
3840
05:13
And so Americans rose to the occasion
94
313060
2536
05:15
and what we did was we reformed surveillance law.
95
315620
3440
05:19
And the primary tool we used to reform surveillance law
96
319980
4376
05:24
was to require a search warrant
97
324380
2696
05:27
for the government to be able to get access to our phone calls and our letters.
98
327100
5960
05:33
Now, the reason why a search warrant is important
99
333540
2856
05:36
is because it interposes a judge
100
336420
2336
05:38
in the relationship between investigators and the citizens,
101
338780
3616
05:42
and that judge's job is to make sure
102
342420
2976
05:45
that there's good cause for the surveillance,
103
345420
2616
05:48
that the surveillance is targeted at the right people,
104
348060
3416
05:51
and that the information that's collected
105
351500
2496
05:54
is going to be used for legitimate government purposes
106
354020
3616
05:57
and not for discriminatory ones.
107
357660
2936
06:00
This was our system,
108
360620
1216
06:01
and what this means is
109
361860
1256
06:03
that President Obama did not wiretap Trump Tower.
110
363140
3816
06:06
The system is set up to prevent something like that from happening
111
366980
4816
06:11
without a judge being involved.
112
371820
1840
06:14
But what happens when we're not talking about phone calls or letters anymore?
113
374300
4600
06:20
Today, we have technology
114
380340
2696
06:23
that makes it cheap and easy for the government to collect information
115
383060
4176
06:27
on ordinary everyday people.
116
387260
2680
06:30
Your phone call records
117
390380
2696
06:33
can reveal whether you have an addiction,
118
393100
3616
06:36
what your religion is,
119
396740
1456
06:38
what charities you donate to,
120
398220
2656
06:40
what political candidate you support.
121
400900
2480
06:43
And yet, our government collected, dragnet-style,
122
403860
4096
06:47
Americans' calling records for years.
123
407980
2960
06:52
In 2012, the Republican National Convention
124
412140
4136
06:56
highlighted a new technology it was planning to use,
125
416300
3376
06:59
facial recognition,
126
419700
1496
07:01
to identify people who were going to be in the crowd
127
421220
2976
07:04
who might be activists or troublemakers
128
424220
2456
07:06
and to stop them ahead of time.
129
426700
1560
07:09
Today, over 50 percent of American adults
130
429020
3696
07:12
have their faceprint in a government database.
131
432740
2400
07:15
The Bureau of Alcohol, Tobacco, Firearms and Explosives
132
435740
3296
07:19
concocted a plan
133
439060
1536
07:20
to find out what Americans were going to gun shows
134
440620
3536
07:24
by using license plate detectors
135
444180
2496
07:26
to scan the license plates of cars
136
446700
2096
07:28
that were in the parking lots of these events.
137
448820
2240
07:31
Today, we believe that over 70 percent of police departments
138
451700
4416
07:36
have automatic license plate detection technology
139
456140
3096
07:39
that they're using to track people's cars as they drive through town.
140
459260
3440
07:43
And all of this information,
141
463780
2616
07:46
the license plates, the faceprints,
142
466420
2936
07:49
the phone records,
143
469380
1576
07:50
your address books, your buddy lists,
144
470980
2816
07:53
the photos that you upload to Dropbox or Google Photos,
145
473820
4416
07:58
and sometimes even your chats and your emails
146
478260
3976
08:02
are not protected by a warrant requirement.
147
482260
2560
08:05
So what that means is we have all of this information on regular people
148
485580
5576
08:11
that's newly available at very low expense.
149
491180
3200
08:14
It is the golden age for surveillance.
150
494860
2080
08:18
Now, every parent is going to understand what this means.
151
498300
5296
08:23
When you have a little baby
152
503620
2136
08:25
and the baby's young,
153
505780
1936
08:27
that child is not able to climb out of its crib.
154
507740
3256
08:31
But eventually your little girl gets older
155
511020
2896
08:33
and she's able to climb out of the crib,
156
513940
2936
08:36
but you tell her, "Don't climb out of the crib. OK?"
157
516900
3776
08:40
And every parent knows what's going to happen.
158
520700
2176
08:42
Some of those babies are going to climb out of the crib.
159
522900
3000
08:46
Right? That's the difference between ability and permission.
160
526379
3657
08:50
Well, the same thing is true with the government today.
161
530060
2616
08:52
It used to be that our government didn't have the ability
162
532700
2775
08:55
to do widespread, massive surveillance on hundreds of millions of Americans
163
535499
3577
08:59
and then abuse that information.
164
539100
1560
09:01
But now our government has grown up,
165
541340
1856
09:03
and we have that technology today.
166
543220
1960
09:06
The government has the ability,
167
546020
2576
09:08
and that means the law is more important than ever before.
168
548620
3576
09:12
The law is supposed to say
169
552220
1736
09:13
when the government has permission to do it,
170
553980
4016
09:18
and it's supposed to ensure that there's some kind of ramification.
171
558020
4136
09:22
We notice when those laws are broken
172
562180
2496
09:24
and there's some of kind of ramification or punishment.
173
564700
2696
09:27
The law is more important than ever because we are now living in a world
174
567420
3416
09:30
where only rules are stopping the government
175
570860
2096
09:32
from abusing this information.
176
572980
1440
09:34
But the law has fallen down on the job.
177
574940
2320
09:37
Particularly since September 11 the law has fallen down on the job,
178
577660
3936
09:41
and we do not have the rules in place that we need.
179
581620
2680
09:45
And we are seeing the ramifications of that.
180
585220
2440
09:48
So fusion centers are these joint task forces
181
588020
3256
09:51
between local, state and federal government
182
591300
2296
09:53
that are meant to ferret out domestic terrorism.
183
593620
3216
09:56
And what we've seen is fusion center reports
184
596860
2496
09:59
that say that you might be dangerous
185
599380
3776
10:03
if you voted for a third-party candidate,
186
603180
2936
10:06
or you own a "Don't Tread On Me" flag,
187
606140
3176
10:09
or you watched movies that are anti-tax.
188
609340
3760
10:13
These same fusion centers have spied on Muslim community groups' reading lists
189
613700
4776
10:18
and on Quakers who are resisting military recruiting in high schools.
190
618500
4320
10:24
The Internal Revenue Service has disproportionately audited
191
624500
4176
10:28
groups that have "Tea Party" or "Patriot" in their name.
192
628700
3656
10:32
And now customs and border patrol
193
632380
2576
10:34
is stopping people as they come into the country
194
634980
2776
10:37
and demanding our social networking passwords
195
637780
3176
10:40
which will allow them to see who our friends are,
196
640980
2576
10:43
what we say
197
643580
1216
10:44
and even to impersonate us online.
198
644820
2720
10:48
Now, civil libertarians like myself
199
648340
2656
10:51
have been trying to draw people's attention to these things
200
651020
4136
10:55
and fighting against them for years.
201
655180
2576
10:57
This was a huge problem during the Obama administration,
202
657780
4200
11:02
but now the problem is worse.
203
662780
2280
11:06
When the New York Police Department
204
666340
2456
11:08
spies on Muslims
205
668820
1696
11:10
or a police department uses license plate detectors
206
670540
3856
11:14
to find out where the officers' spouses are
207
674420
3896
11:18
or those sorts of things,
208
678340
1256
11:19
that is extremely dangerous.
209
679620
1440
11:21
But when a president repurposes the power
210
681740
3056
11:24
of federal surveillance and the federal government
211
684820
2496
11:27
to retaliate against political opposition,
212
687340
3056
11:30
that is a tyranny.
213
690420
1200
11:32
And so we are all activists now,
214
692300
3320
11:36
and we all have something to fear from surveillance.
215
696460
3320
11:40
But just like in the time of Dr. Martin Luther King,
216
700580
3776
11:44
we can reform the way things are.
217
704380
2080
11:47
First of all, use encryption.
218
707740
2400
11:50
Encryption protects your information
219
710940
2896
11:53
from being inexpensively and opportunistically collected.
220
713860
4816
11:58
It rolls back the golden age for surveillance.
221
718700
3120
12:03
Second, support surveillance reform.
222
723900
2760
12:07
Did you know that if you have a friend
223
727540
2176
12:09
who works for the French or German governments
224
729740
3096
12:12
or for an international human rights group
225
732860
3136
12:16
or for a global oil company
226
736020
3376
12:19
that your friend is a valid foreign intelligence target?
227
739420
3960
12:23
And what that means is that when you have conversations with that friend,
228
743740
4136
12:27
the US government may be collecting that information.
229
747900
3160
12:32
And when that information is collected,
230
752140
3256
12:35
even though it's conversations with Americans,
231
755420
2176
12:37
it can then be funneled to the FBI
232
757620
3096
12:40
where the FBI is allowed to search through it
233
760740
2456
12:43
without getting a warrant,
234
763220
1376
12:44
without probable cause,
235
764620
1656
12:46
looking for information about Americans
236
766300
2216
12:48
and whatever crimes we may have committed
237
768540
3416
12:51
with no need to document any kind of suspicion.
238
771980
3040
12:55
The law that allows some of this to happen
239
775740
2976
12:58
is called Section 702 of the FISA Amendments Act,
240
778740
4096
13:02
and we have a great opportunity this year,
241
782860
2536
13:05
because Section 702 is going to expire at the end of 2017,
242
785420
4736
13:10
which means that Congress's inertia is on our side
243
790180
4616
13:14
if we want reform.
244
794820
1576
13:16
And we can pressure our representatives
245
796420
3696
13:20
to actually implement important reforms to this law
246
800140
3496
13:23
and protect our data from this redirection and misuse.
247
803660
3360
13:28
And finally, one of the reasons why things have gotten so out of control
248
808380
5016
13:33
is because so much of what happens with surveillance --
249
813420
2896
13:36
the technology, the enabling rules and the policies
250
816340
4536
13:40
that are either there or not there to protect us --
251
820900
3576
13:44
are secret or classified.
252
824500
2416
13:46
We need transparency, and we need to know as Americans
253
826940
4216
13:51
what the government is doing in our name
254
831180
2536
13:53
so that the surveillance that takes place and the use of that information
255
833740
4576
13:58
is democratically accounted for.
256
838340
2480
14:02
We are all activists now,
257
842220
2096
14:04
which means that we all have something to worry about from surveillance.
258
844340
3640
14:08
But like in the time of Dr. Martin Luther King,
259
848540
3416
14:11
there is stuff that we can do about it.
260
851980
2296
14:14
So please join me, and let's get to work.
261
854300
3920
14:18
Thank you.
262
858820
1216
14:20
(Applause)
263
860060
3760
About this website

This site will introduce you to YouTube videos that are useful for learning English. You will see English lessons taught by top-notch teachers from around the world. Double-click on the English subtitles displayed on each video page to play the video from there. The subtitles scroll in sync with the video playback. If you have any comments or requests, please contact us using this contact form.

https://forms.gle/WvT1wiN1qDtmnspy7