How teachers can help kids find their political voices | Sydney Chaffee

48,059 views ・ 2018-08-28

TED


Please double-click on the English subtitles below to play the video.

00:13
To me, social justice is a simple concept.
0
13897
3064
00:16
It's the notion that all people in a society
1
16985
2437
00:19
deserve fair and equitable rights, opportunities and access to resources.
2
19446
5348
00:25
But it's become controversial and nebulous,
3
25270
3041
00:28
because we've stopped talking
4
28335
1433
00:29
about what working for social justice actually looks like.
5
29792
3646
00:34
Working for social justice can look like this ...
6
34350
2342
00:37
or this.
7
37592
1150
00:39
It can look like this ...
8
39255
1468
00:41
or it can look like this ...
9
41452
1742
00:43
or my favorite ...
10
43218
1899
00:45
it can look like that.
11
45141
1840
00:47
Those are my students,
12
47543
1239
00:48
and whenever I'm asked to articulate my work or my priorities as a teacher,
13
48806
4231
00:53
I explain that I believe education can be a tool for social justice.
14
53061
5106
00:59
But a few months ago, I logged onto Twitter -- as I do --
15
59282
3643
01:02
and I saw that a fellow teacher had taken issue with that belief.
16
62949
3998
01:07
"Teachers," he said, "should not be social justice warriors,
17
67521
4418
01:11
because the purpose of education is to educate."
18
71963
2979
01:15
And he ended his argument by saying,
19
75630
2335
01:17
"I teach my subject."
20
77989
2035
01:20
But I reject that simplification,
21
80816
2873
01:23
because teachers don't just teach subjects,
22
83713
3245
01:26
we teach people.
23
86982
1231
01:28
When our students walk into our classrooms,
24
88988
3445
01:32
they bring their identities with them.
25
92457
2174
01:34
Everything they experience in our rooms is bound up in historical context,
26
94655
4405
01:39
and so if we insist that education happens in a vacuum,
27
99084
3529
01:42
we do our students a disservice.
28
102637
1984
01:45
We teach them that education doesn't really matter,
29
105304
2977
01:48
because it's not relevant to what's happening all around them.
30
108305
3106
01:52
And what's happening all around them?
31
112468
1772
01:55
Well, racism for one.
32
115101
1841
01:57
According to results of the Implicit Association Test,
33
117263
3084
02:00
fully 88 percent of white people harbored subconscious biases against black people,
34
120371
6284
02:06
believing them to be less intelligent, lazier and more dangerous than whites.
35
126679
5782
02:12
And that's just one concrete example of the insidious effects
36
132485
3817
02:16
of historic and systemic racism on our country.
37
136326
3136
02:19
For more evidence, we could look at incarceration rates;
38
139959
3350
02:23
we could look at statistics on police violence against black people;
39
143333
3298
02:26
we could look at the opportunity gap in education --
40
146655
2436
02:29
so yeah, social justice belongs in our schools.
41
149115
4101
02:34
Social justice should be a part of the mission of every school
42
154139
3717
02:37
and every teacher in America,
43
157880
2145
02:40
if we want "liberty and justice for all" to be more than a slogan ...
44
160049
3833
02:45
because schools are crucial places for children to become active citizens
45
165176
5037
02:50
and to learn the skills and the tools that they need to change the world.
46
170237
4173
02:54
So what are those skills?
47
174906
1215
02:56
OK, here's a secret:
48
176442
1661
02:58
many of the skills that people need
49
178127
1800
02:59
to orchestrate the kinds of change that will lead to justice
50
179951
3078
03:03
are already built into the work of schools.
51
183053
2462
03:05
Things like problem-solving,
52
185539
2315
03:07
critical thinking, collaboration, perseverance --
53
187878
2317
03:10
none of that should be revolutionary on its own.
54
190219
2550
03:13
Combine that with the ability to understand history
55
193502
3076
03:16
not as one static and objective narrative on which we all agree,
56
196602
4946
03:21
but as a series of intertwined events
57
201572
2700
03:24
about which there can be countless interpretations.
58
204296
2702
03:27
If we deliberately choose to explore history with our students
59
207525
3327
03:30
rather than just teach it,
60
210876
1790
03:32
we help them understand that history is ongoing
61
212690
2766
03:35
and that it's connected to current movements for justice.
62
215480
3412
03:38
And we help them see themselves as potential players
63
218916
2750
03:41
within a living history.
64
221690
1754
03:44
So those are the skills I'm talking about
65
224694
1961
03:46
when I say that education can be a place
66
226679
2112
03:48
to help kids learn how to work for justice.
67
228815
2396
03:52
But maybe the reason
68
232583
1279
03:53
that my Twitter critic wasn't happy with that idea
69
233886
3147
03:57
is because he doesn't agree with my definition of justice.
70
237057
2868
04:00
Fair enough.
71
240496
1176
04:01
Maybe he and I don't see eye to eye, politically.
72
241696
2368
04:04
But here's the thing:
73
244724
1649
04:06
our aim is to encourage students to articulate their own opinions,
74
246397
4797
04:11
not to coerce them into agreeing with us,
75
251218
2443
04:13
so it actually doesn't matter if he and I agree.
76
253685
3015
04:17
What matters is that we're helping students have those conversations
77
257208
3256
04:20
with each other.
78
260488
1150
04:22
And that means that as adults,
79
262027
1429
04:23
we need to learn how to become effective facilitators
80
263480
3062
04:26
of our students' activism.
81
266566
1621
04:28
We've got to help them learn how to have really tricky conversations,
82
268576
3508
04:32
we have to expose them to different opinions,
83
272108
3192
04:35
and we have to help them see
84
275324
1977
04:37
how what they're learning in school connects to the world outside.
85
277325
3165
04:41
So here's an example of that.
86
281230
1528
04:42
Every year, my students study the history of apartheid in South Africa
87
282782
3493
04:46
as a case study of injustice.
88
286299
1870
04:48
Now for those of you who don't know,
89
288750
1715
04:50
apartheid was a brutally racist system,
90
290489
2097
04:52
and the white-ruled government in South Africa imposed racist laws
91
292610
3420
04:56
to oppress people of color,
92
296054
1799
04:57
and if you resisted those laws, you risked jail time, violence or death.
93
297877
4006
05:02
And around the world, other countries' governments,
94
302459
3934
05:06
including ours in the United States,
95
306417
2085
05:08
hesitated to sanction South Africa, because ...
96
308526
3097
05:11
well ...
97
311647
1151
05:12
we benefited from its resources.
98
312822
1732
05:15
So in 1976, the South African government passed a new law
99
315214
4325
05:19
which required that all students in South Africa
100
319563
2469
05:22
learn in the language Afrikaans,
101
322056
2148
05:24
which was a white language,
102
324228
1378
05:25
and many black South Africans referred to that language
103
325630
2572
05:28
as the language of the oppressor.
104
328226
1950
05:30
So not surprisingly,
105
330784
1151
05:31
students of color were outraged at this law.
106
331959
2137
05:34
They already attended segregated schools
107
334738
2479
05:37
with overcrowded classrooms,
108
337241
2055
05:39
a lack of resources
109
339320
1364
05:40
and a frankly racist curriculum,
110
340708
2083
05:42
and now they were being told to learn
111
342815
1769
05:44
in a language neither they nor their teachers spoke.
112
344608
3088
05:48
So on the morning of June 16, 1976,
113
348652
3618
05:52
thousands of kids from the township of Soweto
114
352294
2987
05:55
walked out of schools.
115
355305
1558
05:56
And they marched peacefully through the streets to protest the law.
116
356887
3515
06:01
At an intersection, they met up with the police,
117
361384
2809
06:04
and when the kids refused to turn back,
118
364217
2154
06:06
the police officers set dogs on them ...
119
366395
2372
06:09
and then they opened fire ...
120
369888
1538
06:12
and the Soweto uprising ended in tragedy.
121
372818
2350
06:16
Apartheid itself didn't end until almost 20 years later,
122
376131
3807
06:21
but the activism of those kids in Soweto profoundly changed
123
381039
4295
06:25
the way the world viewed what was happening in South Africa.
124
385358
3604
06:29
News outlets all around the world published this photo
125
389922
3173
06:33
of 13-year-old Hector Pieterson,
126
393119
2164
06:35
who was one of the first people killed by police in Soweto,
127
395307
3665
06:38
and it became nearly impossible to ignore the brutality
128
398996
3064
06:42
of the apartheid regime.
129
402084
1734
06:43
In the months and the years that followed the Soweto uprising,
130
403842
3255
06:47
more and more countries exerted political and economic pressure
131
407121
3270
06:50
on the South African government to end apartheid,
132
410415
2880
06:53
and it was largely due to the activism of those kids in Soweto.
133
413319
4464
06:59
So every year my kids learn about this.
134
419833
2730
07:02
And invariably, they start to draw connections
135
422587
2998
07:05
between those kids in Soweto and themselves.
136
425609
2359
07:08
And they start to ask themselves
137
428486
1757
07:10
what kind of political power and agency they have.
138
430267
3341
07:14
They ask themselves whether there would ever be a reason
139
434345
2776
07:17
they would risk their lives
140
437145
1926
07:19
so that a future generation could live in a more just world.
141
439095
3176
07:22
And most profoundly for me, every single year,
142
442813
3200
07:26
they ask themselves whether adults will ever listen to their voices.
143
446037
5312
07:32
A few years ago,
144
452788
1151
07:33
my principal got an anonymous email from one of our students.
145
453963
3333
07:37
It informed him that the following day,
146
457681
1872
07:39
the students planned to walk out of school.
147
459577
2230
07:42
This was in the wake of Michael Brown's death
148
462263
2196
07:44
in Ferguson, Missouri,
149
464483
1150
07:45
and the students were planning to join a walkout and march
150
465657
3123
07:48
in support of the Black Lives Matter movement.
151
468804
2366
07:51
So at this point,
152
471622
1151
07:52
the staff at the school had a decision to make.
153
472797
2198
07:55
Would we use our authority and our power to try to control the students
154
475363
4101
07:59
and prevent them from leaving,
155
479488
1667
08:01
or would we support them
156
481179
2178
08:03
as they put into practice the principles of social justice
157
483381
3116
08:06
that we had taught them about since the ninth-grade year?
158
486521
3118
08:10
So the next morning, the kids left school en masse
159
490412
2722
08:13
and they gathered on the lawn.
160
493158
1555
08:14
And one of the seniors jumped up on a picnic table
161
494737
2604
08:17
and went over safety expectations.
162
497365
1944
08:19
(Laughter)
163
499333
1008
08:20
And the younger kids took it very seriously.
164
500365
2247
08:22
And as teachers and as staff we told them,
165
502636
2530
08:25
"OK, be safe,"
166
505190
1292
08:26
and we watched as they marched off.
167
506506
1933
08:28
The kids who chose to stay spent that afternoon in class.
168
508808
3580
08:32
They debated the merits of protest,
169
512412
2181
08:34
they talked about the history of the Black Lives Matter movement,
170
514617
3100
08:37
and they went on with classes as scheduled.
171
517741
2009
08:39
And those who chose to leave participated in a citywide student walkout
172
519774
4297
08:44
and raised their collective voice for justice.
173
524095
2637
08:47
But no matter where they chose to spend the afternoon,
174
527810
3002
08:50
our kids learned valuable lessons that day.
175
530836
2620
08:54
They learned that the adults in their lives would support them
176
534521
2933
08:57
even as we worried for their safety.
177
537478
2289
09:00
And they learned that they didn't need us to tell them how or when
178
540395
3195
09:03
or even why to protest.
179
543614
1738
09:05
They learned that they were members of a community of young people
180
545911
3096
09:09
with a shared vision of a more equitable society,
181
549031
3048
09:12
and they learned that they had power within that society.
182
552103
2810
09:15
They learned that events like the Soweto uprising
183
555893
2318
09:18
are not ancient history,
184
558235
2219
09:20
and they don't have to end in tragedy.
185
560478
2268
09:23
And that's what education as a tool for social justice can look like.
186
563882
4271
09:29
And here's the thing:
187
569349
1151
09:30
our kids are ready for this kind of work.
188
570524
2053
09:32
So in 2015,
189
572601
1171
09:33
incoming college freshmen were surveyed,
190
573796
2247
09:36
and 8.5 percent of them said
191
576067
2351
09:38
that there was a "very good chance" they would participate in a protest
192
578442
3334
09:41
sometime during their college career.
193
581800
1891
09:43
That might not seem very impressive,
194
583715
2152
09:45
but consider the fact
195
585891
1201
09:47
that it's the largest number of students to say that since 1967.
196
587116
4160
09:52
And 75 percent of those kids
197
592073
1739
09:53
said that helping other people who are having difficulty
198
593836
2625
09:56
was a "very important" or "essential" goal for them.
199
596485
2431
09:58
Again, the highest number of people to say that since the late 1960s.
200
598940
3514
10:02
And research shows us that working for justice doesn't just follow
201
602984
4963
10:07
from building all those skills I talked about earlier --
202
607971
2628
10:10
it actually goes the other way, too.
203
610623
1749
10:12
So working for justice, engaging in activism,
204
612396
3086
10:15
helps students build skills like leadership and critical thinking,
205
615506
4264
10:19
and it correlates positively with their political participation
206
619794
3107
10:22
and their civic engagement
207
622925
1374
10:24
and their commitment to their communities later in life.
208
624323
2620
10:26
So in other words,
209
626967
1472
10:28
students are telling us that social justice matters to them
210
628463
3869
10:32
and researchers are telling us that it helps students learn.
211
632356
3455
10:36
So now it's up to us to listen,
212
636530
2643
10:39
and that might not be easy.
213
639197
1836
10:41
In 1976, one of those kids who participated in the Soweto uprising,
214
641984
4416
10:46
he said that that event represented divorce
215
646424
2643
10:49
between black children and their families,
216
649091
2026
10:51
because their families had grown up under apartheid,
217
651141
2580
10:53
and they knew how dangerous it was to speak out.
218
653745
2239
10:56
They wanted their kids to lay low and stay safe.
219
656008
2427
10:58
And when our kids threatened to walk out,
220
658459
1970
11:00
a lot of the adults in our community were really conflicted, too.
221
660453
3461
11:04
Some of us worried that they might encounter violence.
222
664515
2918
11:07
Other people worried that they would walk out
223
667457
2154
11:09
but they wouldn't really know why they were protesting.
224
669635
2572
11:12
And some, including some students' families,
225
672231
2080
11:14
were really angry that the school hadn't done more
226
674335
2357
11:16
to prevent them from leaving.
227
676716
1402
11:18
And all of those fears that adults have about getting this stuff wrong --
228
678142
4232
11:22
all of those fears make total sense.
229
682833
2015
11:25
But despite those fears,
230
685680
2121
11:27
we have got to prove to our students that we will listen to their voices
231
687825
4642
11:32
and that they do have the power to effect change.
232
692491
2931
11:36
It's our responsibility to equip our students
233
696058
3292
11:39
with the tools and the skills that they need
234
699374
2518
11:41
to insist on a more equitable world --
235
701916
2265
11:44
and then sometimes, to get out of their way,
236
704811
2796
11:47
and let them apply those skills to things that they care about.
237
707631
3450
11:52
Living up to that vision is going to require
238
712830
3120
11:55
that we are flexible,
239
715974
1562
11:57
and it's going to require that we're creative.
240
717560
2175
11:59
It's going to require that we're brave enough
241
719759
2215
12:01
to stand up in the face of people who try to silence
242
721998
3524
12:05
or delegitimize dissenting voices.
243
725546
2430
12:08
And hardest of all,
244
728304
1247
12:09
it's going to require accepting the fact that sometimes we will be the ones
245
729575
4365
12:13
our students will rebel against.
246
733964
1976
12:15
(Laughter)
247
735964
1370
12:17
Sometimes they're going to point out ways in which systems that we have created,
248
737358
4040
12:21
or in which we are complicit,
249
741422
1688
12:23
contribute to inequity.
250
743134
1893
12:25
It's going to be uncomfortable, and it's going to be painful
251
745051
2997
12:28
as they push us to question our own assumptions and beliefs.
252
748072
3656
12:32
But what if we change the way we think about rebellion in our kids?
253
752519
4014
12:37
When our kids rebel --
254
757842
1378
12:39
when they thoughtfully push back against our ideas
255
759244
2697
12:41
or the way that we do things,
256
761965
1783
12:43
what if we chose to see that as a sign that we're doing something right
257
763772
4345
12:48
and that they're becoming liberated?
258
768141
2019
12:51
I know it would be easier
259
771474
1836
12:53
if their critical thinking skills manifested in more convenient ways --
260
773334
4122
12:57
on their essays or their standardized tests --
261
777480
2953
13:00
I get it --
262
780457
1150
13:01
but convenience and justice do not often go hand in hand.
263
781631
3682
13:05
And when our kids learn to think critically about the world around them,
264
785671
3587
13:09
they become the kinds of engaged citizens
265
789282
2650
13:11
who will recognize and question injustice when they see it
266
791956
3311
13:15
and work to do something about it.
267
795291
1786
13:17
Welcoming rebellion into our schools is going to require some rethinking
268
797980
4162
13:22
about what teaching and learning look like,
269
802166
2203
13:24
because there's this misconception
270
804393
2025
13:26
that if we give students any wiggle room, they're going to walk all over us
271
806442
3983
13:30
and classrooms and dinner tables will devolve into total chaos.
272
810449
4797
13:35
And if we expect kids to sit silently and passively receive knowledge from us,
273
815270
5818
13:41
then their voices will always feel overwhelming.
274
821112
3203
13:45
But if we accept instead that learning is sometimes messy,
275
825488
4919
13:50
that it requires opportunities to brainstorm and mess up
276
830431
3579
13:54
and try again,
277
834034
1521
13:55
that our kids dislike chaos and want to learn
278
835579
3075
13:58
when they come to school,
279
838678
1981
14:00
then we can set up schools to facilitate that kind of learning.
280
840683
3726
14:05
So do me a favor and close your eyes for a second
281
845015
2811
14:07
and imagine schools where teachers are thought partners,
282
847850
4388
14:12
letting students grapple with complex, hard issues
283
852262
3987
14:16
and not necessarily giving them the right answers.
284
856273
2783
14:20
And imagine schools where we let students make choices --
285
860482
3888
14:24
we trust them enough to do that
286
864394
2298
14:26
and we let them experience the consequences of those choices.
287
866716
3388
14:31
Imagine schools where we let students be humans,
288
871714
4764
14:36
with all of the messiness and the uncertainty
289
876502
2711
14:39
that is bound to come with that.
290
879237
1930
14:42
Whatever you just imagined,
291
882900
1759
14:45
it's not mythical,
292
885509
2192
14:47
it's not unrealistically idealistic,
293
887725
3633
14:51
because teachers all over the country are already pushing the boundaries
294
891382
5082
14:56
of what teaching and learning can look like
295
896488
2014
14:58
with amazing results for kids.
296
898526
2214
15:00
They're doing that in all kinds of schools,
297
900764
2282
15:03
and there are countless models for teachers who want to get better
298
903070
3337
15:06
at helping students learn in a way that's more authentic
299
906431
3252
15:09
and engaging and empowering.
300
909707
2310
15:13
I was a reading a book recently,
301
913837
1572
15:15
it's called "The Students Are Watching,"
302
915433
1953
15:17
and it was by Ted and Nancy Sizer,
303
917410
1635
15:19
and in that book, they said that the work of education
304
919069
2607
15:21
is often described as a series of nouns,
305
921700
2369
15:24
like "respect," "honesty," "integrity."
306
924093
3047
15:27
And they say those nouns sound really impressive,
307
927164
3762
15:30
but often, they fail to actually mean anything in practice.
308
930950
3793
15:35
But verbs, they say, are "active,
309
935084
2589
15:37
no less demanding
310
937697
1522
15:39
but requiring constant engagement.
311
939243
2513
15:42
Verbs are not structures but, rather, engines."
312
942440
3494
15:46
And so as I read that, I wondered:
313
946618
1673
15:48
How do we make justice into an engine driving our work as teachers?
314
948315
5245
15:54
What's the verb form of justice?
315
954478
2681
15:58
I think there might be an answer to be found in the words of Cornel West,
316
958618
3456
16:02
who famously said that "justice is what love looks like in public."
317
962098
4245
16:07
And all of my nerdy English teachers in the crowd
318
967544
2850
16:10
know that love can be a noun and a verb.
319
970418
2975
16:14
School has to be bigger.
320
974653
2763
16:17
It has to mean more than "I teach my subject."
321
977970
4398
16:23
School has to be about teaching people
322
983059
3471
16:26
to change the world for the better.
323
986554
2271
16:30
If we believe that,
324
990132
1310
16:31
then teaching will always be a political act.
325
991466
3195
16:36
We can't be afraid of our students' power.
326
996296
3097
16:40
Their power will help them make tomorrow better.
327
1000185
3469
16:43
But before they can do that,
328
1003678
1338
16:45
we have to give them chances to practice today.
329
1005040
2836
16:49
And that practice should start in our schools.
330
1009001
3570
16:53
Thank you very much.
331
1013578
1151
16:54
(Applause)
332
1014753
3556
About this website

This site will introduce you to YouTube videos that are useful for learning English. You will see English lessons taught by top-notch teachers from around the world. Double-click on the English subtitles displayed on each video page to play the video from there. The subtitles scroll in sync with the video playback. If you have any comments or requests, please contact us using this contact form.

https://forms.gle/WvT1wiN1qDtmnspy7