Yuko Munakata: The science behind how parents affect child development | TED

470,871 views ・ 2021-06-02

TED


Please double-click on the English subtitles below to play the video.

00:00
Transcriber:
0
0
7000
00:13
A few years ago,
1
13330
1200
00:14
a student came up to me after the second day of my class
2
14563
3234
00:17
on parenting and child development.
3
17830
2067
00:20
She hesitated for a second and then she confessed,
4
20563
3567
00:24
"I'm really interested in this material,
5
24163
2700
00:26
but I was hoping your class would help me to become a better parent
6
26897
3166
00:30
if I have kids someday."
7
30063
1534
00:32
She was disappointed.
8
32097
1666
00:34
We were going to talk about how parents do not have control
9
34730
4200
00:38
in shaping who their children become.
10
38963
2334
00:41
She jumped to the conclusion that my class wouldn't help her.
11
41897
3700
00:46
I was caught off guard.
12
46630
1800
00:48
Would confronting the science of parenting and child development,
13
48430
3767
00:52
not be relevant to being a good parent?
14
52230
2833
00:55
I hope that my class changed her mind.
15
55963
2434
00:59
Parents want what's best for their children,
16
59397
2400
01:01
young and old parents,
17
61830
1867
01:03
rich and poor,
18
63730
2000
01:05
married and divorced.
19
65730
1700
01:07
And parenting books promise to show how to achieve the best outcomes,
20
67930
4700
01:12
to address the difficult decisions that parents face every day
21
72663
4800
01:17
and in the process, to reveal why each of us turned out the way we did.
22
77497
5566
01:23
The problem is that parenting books send conflicting messages.
23
83730
3767
01:27
Tiger parenting or free-range parenting?
24
87997
3433
01:31
Parent like the Dutch to raise the happiest kids in the world
25
91830
4367
01:36
or like the Germans, to raise self-reliant children?
26
96197
3066
01:40
The one consistent message is that if your child isn't succeeding,
27
100097
4866
01:44
you're doing something wrong.
28
104997
1766
01:47
There's good news, though.
29
107097
1633
01:48
The science supports a totally different message
30
108763
3834
01:52
that is ultimately empowering.
31
112630
2467
01:56
Trying to predict how a child will turn out
32
116363
3434
01:59
based on choices made by the parents
33
119830
2833
02:02
is like trying to predict a hurricane
34
122697
2866
02:05
from the flap of a butterfly's wings.
35
125597
2833
02:09
Do you know the butterfly,
36
129497
1666
02:11
the proverbial one, that flaps its wings in China,
37
131197
3533
02:14
perturbing the atmosphere just enough to shift wind currents
38
134763
4834
02:19
that make their way to the skies over tropical white beaches
39
139597
3900
02:23
intensifying the water evaporating from the ocean in a spiral of wind
40
143497
5133
02:28
and fueling a hurricane in the Caribbean
41
148663
2500
02:31
six weeks after that flutter of wings.
42
151197
2533
02:34
If you are a parent,
43
154363
1900
02:36
you are the butterfly flapping your wings.
44
156263
3234
02:40
Your child is the hurricane, a breathtaking force of nature.
45
160263
4234
02:45
You will shape the person your child becomes
46
165330
2367
02:47
like the butterfly shapes the hurricane
47
167730
2933
02:50
in complex, seemingly unpredictable but powerful ways.
48
170697
5566
02:56
The hurricane wouldn't exist without the butterfly.
49
176297
2966
02:59
"Wait," you might ask,
50
179663
1400
03:01
what about all the successful parents with successful children
51
181063
3700
03:04
or the struggling parents with struggling children?"
52
184797
2566
03:07
They might seem to show the simple power of parenting.
53
187963
3434
03:11
But children can be shaped by many forces that are often intertwined,
54
191963
4200
03:16
like successful parents, successful genes,
55
196197
3166
03:19
successful peers
56
199397
1400
03:20
and a culture of success that they grow up in.
57
200830
2733
03:23
This can make it hard to know which forces influence who children become.
58
203597
3866
03:27
"OK," you might think,
59
207897
1733
03:29
"yes, it's hard to pull apart all these possible forces,
60
209663
3267
03:32
but we can make pretty good guesses about the importance of parents."
61
212963
3600
03:36
Perhaps.
62
216930
1167
03:38
Well, how many of you know how a bicycle works?
63
218830
3167
03:43
Right, you've seen people riding bikes,
64
223630
2267
03:45
maybe you've ridden one yourself
65
225930
1667
03:47
or even tried to teach someone else how to do it.
66
227630
2400
03:50
Just like parenting --
67
230530
1600
03:52
you've seen people doing it,
68
232163
1767
03:53
maybe you've done it yourself
69
233963
1567
03:55
or even tried to teach someone else how to do it.
70
235563
3034
03:58
We can feel confident about what we know.
71
238630
2667
04:02
When we say we know how a bicycle works,
72
242030
2767
04:04
we think we have something in our heads like this.
73
244830
3067
04:08
Something that relates the pedals to the chain and to the wheels.
74
248297
4433
04:13
But when you ask people to explain how a bicycle works,
75
253563
4367
04:17
they produce drawings like this.
76
257963
2467
04:22
And like this.
77
262463
1234
04:23
(Laughter)
78
263730
1667
04:25
People have no idea how bicycles work.
79
265797
3500
04:29
Or zippers or rainbows,
80
269297
3366
04:32
or even topics they argue passionately about.
81
272697
3100
04:36
When you push people to explain how these things work,
82
276197
3333
04:39
they usually can't.
83
279563
1500
04:41
Just caring about something, like parenting,
84
281963
3067
04:45
or feeling confident about it,
85
285063
2167
04:47
doesn't guarantee that we understand it.
86
287263
2467
04:49
And everyone can't possibly be right about how parenting works,
87
289763
3767
04:53
given how wildly beliefs have varied.
88
293563
2734
04:57
Mothers in a hunter-gatherer society
89
297397
2233
04:59
regretted when their children cut themselves themselves
90
299630
2600
05:02
while playing with knives,
91
302263
1867
05:04
but they thought the cuts were worth the freedom to explore.
92
304163
3434
05:08
Even within one society like ours,
93
308430
2633
05:11
parenting wasn't a common term until the 1970s.
94
311097
4066
05:15
Before then, parents weren't viewed as active shapers of children's futures.
95
315197
4866
05:21
Years from now,
96
321263
1434
05:22
people may look back on today's views
97
322730
2367
05:25
and feel just as amazed as we feel
98
325130
2433
05:27
when hearing about other times and places.
99
327597
2800
05:31
The science could help parents,
100
331697
2200
05:33
and potential parents like my student,
101
333930
2467
05:36
to understand how they actually shape who their children become.
102
336430
3933
05:40
Millions of children have been studied to disentangle all those shaping forces
103
340397
4566
05:44
that are usually intertwined.
104
344997
2133
05:47
These studies follow identical twins and fraternal twins
105
347530
3700
05:51
and plain old siblings
106
351263
2100
05:53
growing up together or adopted and raised apart.
107
353397
3533
05:57
And it turns out that growing up in the same home
108
357597
4700
06:02
does not make children noticeably more alike in how successful they are,
109
362297
4933
06:07
or how happy or self-reliant and so on.
110
367230
3433
06:11
Imagine if you had been taken from birth
111
371097
2800
06:13
and raised next door by the family to the left
112
373930
3400
06:17
and your brother or sister had been raised next door
113
377363
2500
06:19
by the family to the right,
114
379897
2366
06:22
by and large, that would have made you no more similar or different
115
382297
3966
06:26
than growing up together under the same roof.
116
386263
3000
06:31
On the one hand, these findings seem unbelievable.
117
391197
3233
06:34
Think about all the ways that parents differ from home to home
118
394463
3367
06:37
and how often they argue and whether they helicopter
119
397863
3234
06:41
and how much they shower their children with love.
120
401130
2633
06:44
You would think that would matter enough
121
404163
2134
06:46
to make children growing up in the same home more alike
122
406330
3500
06:49
than if they had been raised apart.
123
409863
2167
06:52
But it doesn't.
124
412063
1200
06:54
In 2015, a meta analysis,
125
414030
2700
06:56
a study of studies,
126
416763
1700
06:58
found this pattern across thousands of studies
127
418497
3133
07:01
following over 14 million twin pairs across 39 countries.
128
421663
4834
07:07
They measured over 17,000 outcomes.
129
427263
3300
07:10
And the researchers concluded
130
430597
1766
07:12
that every single one of those outcomes is heritable.
131
432397
3766
07:16
So genes influence who children become.
132
436197
2533
07:19
But genes didn't explain everything.
133
439163
2500
07:21
The environment mattered too,
134
441697
2233
07:23
just something in the environment
135
443930
1867
07:25
that didn't shape children growing up in the same home to be more alike.
136
445830
4200
07:30
Some people have looked at these findings
137
450830
2500
07:33
and concluded that parenting doesn't matter.
138
453363
2934
07:36
That you would have become the same person you are today,
139
456797
2966
07:39
regardless of who raised you.
140
459797
2066
07:41
On the other hand,
141
461863
1267
07:43
and really, I should say on the other hands,
142
463130
2467
07:45
because there are many caveats to that story,
143
465630
2633
07:48
but I'll focus on one.
144
468297
1633
07:50
On the other hand,
145
470730
1233
07:51
these findings are not all that shocking.
146
471997
2433
07:54
If you think about how the same parent
147
474463
2600
07:57
could shape different children in different ways.
148
477063
3267
08:01
One child might find it helpful when her mother provides structure.
149
481430
3733
08:05
Her sister might find it's stifling.
150
485197
2166
08:08
One child might think his parents are caring
151
488263
2100
08:10
when they ask questions about his friends.
152
490363
2134
08:12
His brother might think they're being nosy.
153
492530
2067
08:14
One child might view a divorce as a tragedy,
154
494597
3333
08:17
while his sister sees it as a relief.
155
497963
3134
08:21
Same event, different experience.
156
501097
3133
08:25
My husband and I experienced this concept 20 years ago
157
505797
3833
08:29
when we were 30,000 feet over the Atlantic,
158
509663
2667
08:32
flying from Chicago to Stockholm to work on a research project.
159
512330
3667
08:36
The flight attendants were clearing the dinner trays,
160
516630
2667
08:39
people were getting ready to sleep.
161
519330
1733
08:42
We hit a patch of bumpy air
162
522097
1900
08:44
and a bunch of teenagers whooped in excitement.
163
524030
2933
08:47
Then all of a sudden, the plane was plummeting,
164
527797
2733
08:50
children and food carts hit the ceiling.
165
530563
2967
08:53
The plane seemed to stabilize,
166
533897
1800
08:55
but then plummeted again.
167
535730
2133
08:57
The ceiling panels flew up into their compartments from the force,
168
537863
3567
09:01
revealing wiring inside.
169
541430
2333
09:03
Debris came crumbling down on us.
170
543797
2433
09:06
People were screaming and sobbing.
171
546263
2300
09:08
The plane plummeted again.
172
548863
1734
09:11
After an eternity, the pilot came on and announced,
173
551997
3633
09:15
"We don't know what that was.
174
555663
1534
09:17
We don't know what's coming. Stay in your seats."
175
557230
2733
09:20
My husband came away from that experience feeling like planes are incredibly safe.
176
560697
5666
09:27
(Laughter)
177
567030
3467
09:30
The airline sent a letter informing us that we hadn't simply been falling
178
570863
4600
09:35
across those thousands of feet of clear air turbulence.
179
575463
3167
09:38
The plane had been subjected to forces greater than 2G.
180
578930
3233
09:42
We learned that planes can withstand forces many times larger.
181
582930
3633
09:47
So my husband feels safe flying.
182
587030
2367
09:49
He seems genuinely baffled by how anyone could feel otherwise.
183
589863
4300
09:54
I get that concept, but only in the abstract.
184
594797
3200
09:58
I've never been able to fly the same way since.
185
598030
3033
10:01
Same event, different experience.
186
601363
2767
10:05
Just because an event doesn't shape people in the same way,
187
605263
3734
10:09
that doesn't mean it had no effect.
188
609030
1933
10:11
Your parenting could be shaping your children,
189
611730
2733
10:14
just not in ways that lead them to become more alike.
190
614497
3000
10:18
Your parenting could be leading your first child to become more serious,
191
618330
4000
10:22
your second child to become more relaxed.
192
622363
2700
10:25
Your first child to want to be like you,
193
625097
2533
10:27
your second child to want to be nothing like you.
194
627663
2500
10:30
You are flapping your butterfly wings to your hurricane children.
195
630830
4267
10:36
This isn't how we typically think about parenting.
196
636297
2566
10:38
It doesn't make for simple advice.
197
638897
2300
10:41
How could parenting books tell people how to raise successful, happy,
198
641763
4200
10:45
self-reliant children,
199
645997
1833
10:47
if the same parenting can lead to different outcomes
200
647830
2733
10:50
for children in the same home?
201
650597
1900
10:52
At this point, you might be thinking,
202
652530
1933
10:54
like students in my class sometimes say,
203
654497
2366
10:56
"OK, we get it.
204
656897
1566
10:58
development is complicated.
205
658497
2200
11:00
And maybe it's not worth studying because it's too complicated."
206
660697
3366
11:04
But meaning can be made from chaos.
207
664930
2967
11:08
Scientists now understand how babies go from these apparent lumps
208
668630
4933
11:13
to become walking, talking, thinking, social independent beings.
209
673563
6134
11:20
They understand this process well enough to intervene,
210
680363
3300
11:23
to test newborns, for example,
211
683697
2033
11:25
and treat them for a genetic condition that used to lead to mental retardation.
212
685763
4634
11:31
Scientists are developing ever more sophisticated understanding
213
691463
3400
11:34
of how parents could shape their children's futures.
214
694897
3133
11:39
Science can tell us a lot.
215
699097
2200
11:41
But it will never tell us everything.
216
701330
2733
11:44
So what can we do with this?
217
704063
1867
11:46
First, know that parents matter.
218
706497
3766
11:50
That might seem obvious,
219
710263
1600
11:51
but smart people are arguing otherwise,
220
711897
2166
11:54
and what seems obvious is not always true, as we've seen.
221
714097
3466
11:57
Second, know that how parents matter is complex and difficult to predict.
222
717563
5200
12:03
For anyone who has ever been a parent, stop blaming yourself,
223
723463
4834
12:08
as if you are in control of your child's path.
224
728330
2867
12:12
You have influence,
225
732163
1367
12:13
but you don't have control.
226
733563
1934
12:15
For anyone who has ever been a child,
227
735530
3133
12:18
stop blaming your parents.
228
738663
2200
12:20
(Laughter)
229
740897
1366
12:22
At least for the idea that you are defined by them.
230
742297
3700
12:26
Stop blaming other parents.
231
746430
2100
12:28
A recent survey of thousands of parents revealed that 90 percent of mothers
232
748563
4967
12:33
and 85 percent of fathers feel judged.
233
753563
3067
12:36
Close to half feel judged all the time or nearly all the time
234
756663
4234
12:40
by people they know and by complete strangers.
235
760930
3667
12:45
These judgments probably don't reflect what's best for the kids.
236
765230
3433
12:48
How could they, given how profoundly parenting has varied around the world
237
768697
3966
12:52
and across time?
238
772663
1634
12:54
And given how the same parents can shape children
239
774330
2800
12:57
under the same roof in such different ways.
240
777130
2700
13:00
Even when parents try their best, they can't satisfy everybody.
241
780663
3734
13:04
There's only so much time.
242
784863
2034
13:08
This is especially true for dragon parents.
243
788663
4000
13:14
The author, Emily Rapp, came up with this term
244
794330
3067
13:17
after her baby was diagnosed with Tay-Sachs disease.
245
797430
3933
13:22
She knew then that Ronan would never walk or talk.
246
802763
4234
13:27
He would likely die before turning four.
247
807630
2667
13:33
I did not know
248
813330
2967
13:36
that this could also be the fate of my firstborn son.
249
816330
3867
13:42
He was born with a condition
250
822197
2133
13:44
that prevents the intestine from absorbing nutrients
251
824363
3067
13:47
or water for the body.
252
827463
1667
13:50
It affects one in five million babies.
253
830297
3133
13:54
One in five million.
254
834297
1866
13:57
It is so rare
255
837430
1533
13:58
that one doctor felt confident telling us that we would be screwed
256
838997
3466
14:02
if that's what our baby had.
257
842463
2067
14:05
He was the one who had to break the news to us later.
258
845863
2900
14:10
Dragon parents have a lot to say about parenting,
259
850397
2733
14:13
even though they know their children will die young,
260
853163
2967
14:16
or in my case,
261
856163
1300
14:17
even if we have no idea whether our babies will live.
262
857463
3400
14:21
Emily Rapp wrote,
263
861797
2833
14:24
"We will not launch our children into a bright and promising future,
264
864663
5200
14:29
but see them into early graves."
265
869897
2366
14:33
This requires a new ferocity,
266
873663
2867
14:36
a new way of thinking, a new animal.
267
876563
3534
14:40
We are dragon parents,
268
880797
1600
14:42
fierce and loyal and loving as hell.
269
882430
4267
14:47
Our experiences have taught us how to parent for the here and now,
270
887397
4800
14:52
for the sake of parenting,
271
892230
1967
14:54
for the humanity implicit in the act itself.
272
894230
3000
14:58
Parenting, I've come to understand, is about loving my child today,
273
898163
6534
15:04
now.
274
904697
1500
15:06
In fact, for any parent anywhere, that's all there is.
275
906230
5033
15:13
I had thought that my expertise in child development
276
913130
2633
15:15
would help prepare me for becoming a parent.
277
915797
3233
15:19
Instead, becoming a parent helped me to see the science in a whole new light.
278
919063
5767
15:24
So third, appreciate how powerful the moments can be
279
924863
5167
15:30
because of what they mean for you and your child right now,
280
930063
4100
15:34
not because of what they mean for your child long term,
281
934197
3033
15:37
which you do not know.
282
937230
1700
15:40
The activist Andrew Solomon noted,
283
940430
2700
15:43
"Though many of us take pride in how different we are from our parents,
284
943163
4267
15:47
we are endlessly sad at how different our children are from us."
285
947463
4234
15:52
Maybe we could be less sad if we were more realistic,
286
952897
3633
15:56
if we let go of the notion
287
956530
1600
15:58
that our children's futures are in our control.
288
958163
2934
16:01
If we can embrace the complexity of our children's development
289
961463
3634
16:05
that can transform how we approach those parenting decisions we face each day
290
965130
5200
16:10
and empower us to realize how much more there is to having a child
291
970363
4134
16:14
than trying to shape a specific outcome.
292
974530
2633
16:17
So much more,
293
977597
1966
16:19
which I appreciate every day in moments with my firstborn son,
294
979563
5400
16:24
who is thriving
295
984997
1666
16:26
and with his younger brother
296
986697
1866
16:28
and the unique paths they are taking.
297
988563
2367
16:31
We are not screwed.
298
991530
2500
16:34
(Laughter)
299
994030
1433
16:36
The science of parents and children,
300
996063
2867
16:38
butterflies and their hurricanes,
301
998963
2300
16:41
can free people to focus on what is most important
302
1001263
4034
16:45
and meaningful in our lives.
303
1005330
2033
16:47
This can make the experience of being a parent
304
1007930
3200
16:51
and the experience of having been a child
305
1011163
3100
16:54
more realistic and satisfying for everyone involved.
306
1014297
4200
16:59
And that, I think, is very relevant to being a good parent.
307
1019163
5300
About this website

This site will introduce you to YouTube videos that are useful for learning English. You will see English lessons taught by top-notch teachers from around the world. Double-click on the English subtitles displayed on each video page to play the video from there. The subtitles scroll in sync with the video playback. If you have any comments or requests, please contact us using this contact form.

https://forms.gle/WvT1wiN1qDtmnspy7