How we explore unanswered questions in physics | James Beacham

108,062 views ・ 2017-01-20

TED


Please double-click on the English subtitles below to play the video.

00:00
Translator: Leslie Gauthier Reviewer: Camille MartΓ­nez
0
0
7000
00:13
There is something about physics
1
13087
4185
00:17
that has been really bothering me since I was a little kid.
2
17296
4000
00:23
And it's related to a question
3
23010
1809
00:24
that scientists have been asking for almost 100 years,
4
24843
3244
00:28
with no answer.
5
28111
1169
00:31
How do the smallest things in nature,
6
31108
3010
00:34
the particles of the quantum world,
7
34142
2153
00:36
match up with the largest things in nature --
8
36319
3031
00:39
planets and stars and galaxies held together by gravity?
9
39374
3247
00:43
As a kid, I would puzzle over questions just like this.
10
43250
2773
00:46
I would fiddle around with microscopes and electromagnets,
11
46047
2892
00:48
and I would read about the forces of the small
12
48963
2195
00:51
and about quantum mechanics
13
51182
1334
00:52
and I would marvel at how well that description matched up
14
52540
3564
00:56
to our observation.
15
56128
1170
00:58
Then I would look at the stars,
16
58220
1583
00:59
and I would read about how well we understand gravity,
17
59827
2524
01:02
and I would think surely, there must be some elegant way
18
62375
3350
01:05
that these two systems match up.
19
65749
2645
01:09
But there's not.
20
69021
1401
01:11
And the books would say,
21
71673
1160
01:12
yeah, we understand a lot about these two realms separately,
22
72857
3183
01:16
but when we try to link them mathematically,
23
76064
2610
01:18
everything breaks.
24
78698
1330
01:20
And for 100 years,
25
80674
1310
01:22
none of our ideas as to how to solve this basically physics disaster,
26
82008
5028
01:27
has ever been supported by evidence.
27
87060
1814
01:30
And to little old me --
28
90271
1654
01:31
little, curious, skeptical James --
29
91949
1810
01:33
this was a supremely unsatisfying answer.
30
93783
2868
01:38
So, I'm still a skeptical little kid.
31
98011
2233
01:40
Flash-forward now to December of 2015,
32
100268
3810
01:45
when I found myself smack in the middle
33
105029
2474
01:47
of the physics world being flipped on its head.
34
107527
2940
01:51
It all started when we at CERN saw something intriguing in our data:
35
111999
3320
01:55
a hint of a new particle,
36
115343
2274
01:57
an inkling of a possibly extraordinary answer to this question.
37
117641
4216
02:03
So I'm still a skeptical little kid, I think,
38
123777
2127
02:05
but I'm also now a particle hunter.
39
125928
2133
02:08
I am a physicist at CERN's Large Hadron Collider,
40
128085
3463
02:11
the largest science experiment ever mounted.
41
131572
3471
02:15
It's a 27-kilometer tunnel on the border of France and Switzerland
42
135877
3535
02:19
buried 100 meters underground.
43
139436
1850
02:21
And in this tunnel,
44
141310
1154
02:22
we use superconducting magnets colder than outer space
45
142488
3953
02:26
to accelerate protons to almost the speed of light
46
146465
3061
02:29
and slam them into each other millions of times per second,
47
149550
3877
02:33
collecting the debris of these collisions
48
153451
2826
02:36
to search for new, undiscovered fundamental particles.
49
156301
3971
02:40
Its design and construction took decades of work
50
160727
2464
02:43
by thousands of physicists from around the globe,
51
163215
3032
02:46
and in the summer of 2015,
52
166271
2541
02:48
we had been working tirelessly to switch on the LHC
53
168836
3424
02:52
at the highest energy that humans have ever used in a collider experiment.
54
172284
4467
02:57
Now, higher energy is important
55
177735
2523
03:00
because for particles, there is an equivalence
56
180282
2187
03:02
between energy and particle mass,
57
182493
2201
03:04
and mass is just a number put there by nature.
58
184718
2461
03:08
To discover new particles,
59
188068
1318
03:09
we need to reach these bigger numbers.
60
189410
2122
03:11
And to do that, we have to build a bigger, higher energy collider,
61
191556
3254
03:14
and the biggest, highest energy collider in the world
62
194834
2565
03:17
is the Large Hadron Collider.
63
197423
1466
03:20
And then, we collide protons quadrillions of times,
64
200271
4899
03:25
and we collect this data very slowly, over months and months.
65
205194
4284
03:30
And then new particles might show up in our data as bumps --
66
210813
4335
03:35
slight deviations from what you expect,
67
215172
2445
03:37
little clusters of data points that make a smooth line not so smooth.
68
217641
3967
03:42
For example, this bump,
69
222379
1721
03:45
after months of data-taking in 2012,
70
225010
2533
03:47
led to the discovery of the Higgs particle --
71
227567
2129
03:49
the Higgs boson --
72
229720
1205
03:50
and to a Nobel Prize for the confirmation of its existence.
73
230949
3365
03:55
This jump up in energy in 2015
74
235972
3558
04:00
represented the best chance that we as a species had ever had
75
240628
3292
04:03
of discovering new particles --
76
243944
1477
04:05
new answers to these long-standing questions,
77
245445
2112
04:07
because it was almost twice as much energy as we used
78
247581
3097
04:10
when we discovered the Higgs boson.
79
250702
1922
04:12
Many of my colleagues had been working their entire careers for this moment,
80
252648
3741
04:16
and frankly, to little curious me,
81
256413
2076
04:18
this was the moment I'd been waiting for my entire life.
82
258513
2910
04:21
So 2015 was go time.
83
261447
1731
04:24
So June 2015,
84
264654
2210
04:27
the LHC is switched back on.
85
267722
2659
04:31
My colleagues and I held our breath and bit our fingernails,
86
271040
2877
04:33
and then finally we saw the first proton collisions
87
273941
2511
04:36
at this highest energy ever.
88
276476
1956
04:38
Applause, champagne, celebration.
89
278456
2076
04:40
This was a milestone for science,
90
280556
3596
04:44
and we had no idea what we would find in this brand-new data.
91
284176
4622
04:51
And then a few weeks later, we found a bump.
92
291990
2178
04:56
It wasn't a very big bump,
93
296192
1676
04:58
but it was big enough to make you raise your eyebrow.
94
298952
2512
05:01
But on a scale of one to 10 for eyebrow raises,
95
301488
2251
05:03
if 10 indicates that you've discovered a new particle,
96
303763
2610
05:06
this eyebrow raise is about a four.
97
306397
1727
05:08
(Laughter)
98
308148
1150
05:10
I spent hours, days, weeks in secret meetings,
99
310432
5211
05:15
arguing with my colleagues over this little bump,
100
315667
2360
05:18
poking and prodding it with our most ruthless experimental sticks
101
318051
3236
05:21
to see if it would withstand scrutiny.
102
321311
1977
05:23
But even after months of working feverishly --
103
323988
3461
05:27
sleeping in our offices and not going home,
104
327473
2432
05:29
candy bars for dinner,
105
329929
2077
05:32
coffee by the bucketful --
106
332030
1570
05:33
physicists are machines for turning coffee into diagrams --
107
333624
4243
05:37
(Laughter)
108
337891
1399
05:39
This little bump would not go away.
109
339314
2536
05:42
So after a few months,
110
342704
2138
05:44
we presented our little bump to the world with a very clear message:
111
344866
3710
05:49
this little bump is interesting but it's not definitive,
112
349457
2711
05:52
so let's keep an eye on it as we take more data.
113
352192
3329
05:55
So we were trying to be extremely cool about it.
114
355872
2291
05:59
And the world ran with it anyway.
115
359463
2188
06:02
The news loved it.
116
362383
1632
06:04
People said it reminded them of the little bump
117
364735
2555
06:07
that was shown on the way toward the Higgs boson discovery.
118
367314
3423
06:10
Better than that, my theorist colleagues --
119
370761
3128
06:14
I love my theorist colleagues --
120
374548
2317
06:16
my theorist colleagues wrote 500 papers about this little bump.
121
376889
3612
06:20
(Laughter)
122
380525
1455
06:22
The world of particle physics had been flipped on its head.
123
382574
3966
06:27
But what was it about this particular bump
124
387745
4242
06:32
that caused thousands of physicists to collectively lose their cool?
125
392011
4090
06:37
This little bump was unique.
126
397596
1436
06:40
This little bump indicated
127
400198
1369
06:41
that we were seeing an unexpectedly large number of collisions
128
401591
3022
06:44
whose debris consisted of only two photons,
129
404637
3331
06:47
two particles of light.
130
407992
1244
06:49
And that's rare.
131
409260
1237
06:51
Particle collisions are not like automobile collisions.
132
411069
2620
06:53
They have different rules.
133
413713
1519
06:55
When two particles collide at almost the speed of light,
134
415256
2650
06:57
the quantum world takes over.
135
417930
1421
06:59
And in the quantum world,
136
419375
1260
07:00
these two particles can briefly create a new particle
137
420659
3193
07:03
that lives for a tiny fraction of a second
138
423876
2780
07:06
before splitting into other particles that hit our detector.
139
426680
2881
07:09
Imagine a car collision where the two cars vanish upon impact,
140
429585
3405
07:13
a bicycle appears in their place --
141
433014
2269
07:15
(Laughter)
142
435307
1071
07:16
And then that bicycle explodes into two skateboards,
143
436402
2461
07:18
which hit our detector.
144
438887
1181
07:20
(Laughter)
145
440092
1379
07:21
Hopefully, not literally.
146
441495
1953
07:23
They're very expensive.
147
443472
1342
07:26
Events where only two photons hit out detector are very rare.
148
446191
3748
07:29
And because of the special quantum properties of photons,
149
449963
3722
07:33
there's a very small number of possible new particles --
150
453709
3788
07:37
these mythical bicycles --
151
457521
1497
07:39
that can give birth to only two photons.
152
459042
2243
07:41
But one of these options is huge,
153
461812
2836
07:44
and it has to do with that long-standing question
154
464672
2836
07:47
that bothered me as a tiny little kid,
155
467532
2522
07:50
about gravity.
156
470078
1360
07:53
Gravity may seem super strong to you,
157
473946
2672
07:56
but it's actually crazily weak compared to the other forces of nature.
158
476642
4100
08:00
I can briefly beat gravity when I jump,
159
480766
2631
08:04
but I can't pick a proton out of my hand.
160
484390
2843
08:08
The strength of gravity compared to the other forces of nature?
161
488463
3216
08:12
It's 10 to the minus 39.
162
492480
2190
08:14
That's a decimal with 39 zeros after it.
163
494694
2537
08:17
Worse than that,
164
497255
1157
08:18
all of the other known forces of nature are perfectly described
165
498436
3027
08:21
by this thing we call the Standard Model,
166
501487
2037
08:23
which is our current best description of nature at its smallest scales,
167
503548
3435
08:27
and quite frankly,
168
507007
1156
08:28
one of the most successful achievements of humankind --
169
508187
4177
08:32
except for gravity, which is absent from the Standard Model.
170
512388
4012
08:36
It's crazy.
171
516424
1150
08:38
It's almost as though most of gravity has gone missing.
172
518046
3100
08:42
We feel a little bit of it,
173
522394
1667
08:44
but where's the rest of it?
174
524085
1676
08:45
No one knows.
175
525785
1282
08:48
But one theoretical explanation proposes a wild solution.
176
528003
4403
08:54
You and I --
177
534120
1339
08:55
even you in the back --
178
535483
1578
08:57
we live in three dimensions of space.
179
537085
2145
08:59
I hope that's a non-controversial statement.
180
539254
2557
09:01
(Laughter)
181
541835
1829
09:03
All of the known particles also live in three dimensions of space.
182
543688
3438
09:07
In fact, a particle is just another name
183
547150
2190
09:09
for an excitation in a three-dimensional field;
184
549364
3009
09:12
a localized wobbling in space.
185
552397
1920
09:15
More importantly, all the math that we use to describe all this stuff
186
555288
3529
09:18
assumes that there are only three dimensions of space.
187
558841
3073
09:21
But math is math, and we can play around with our math however we want.
188
561938
3381
09:25
And people have been playing around with extra dimensions of space
189
565343
3166
09:28
for a very long time,
190
568533
1155
09:29
but it's always been an abstract mathematical concept.
191
569712
2585
09:32
I mean, just look around you -- you at the back, look around --
192
572321
3172
09:35
there's clearly only three dimensions of space.
193
575517
2281
09:38
But what if that's not true?
194
578954
1559
09:42
What if the missing gravity is leaking into an extra-spatial dimension
195
582109
6255
09:48
that's invisible to you and I?
196
588388
1956
09:51
What if gravity is just as strong as the other forces
197
591355
3094
09:54
if you were to view it in this extra-spatial dimension,
198
594473
3141
09:57
and what you and I experience is a tiny slice of gravity
199
597638
2900
10:00
make it seem very weak?
200
600562
1897
10:04
If this were true,
201
604158
1175
10:05
we would have to expand our Standard Model of particles
202
605357
2748
10:08
to include an extra particle, a hyperdimensional particle of gravity,
203
608129
4086
10:12
a special graviton that lives in extra-spatial dimensions.
204
612239
2995
10:15
I see the looks on your faces.
205
615258
1465
10:16
You should be asking me the question,
206
616747
1819
10:18
"How in the world are we going to test this crazy, science fiction idea,
207
618590
3644
10:22
stuck as we are in three dimensions?"
208
622258
2491
10:24
The way we always do,
209
624773
1282
10:26
by slamming together two protons --
210
626079
2139
10:28
(Laughter)
211
628242
1152
10:29
Hard enough that the collision reverberates
212
629418
2564
10:32
into any extra-spatial dimensions that might be there,
213
632006
2691
10:34
momentarily creating this hyperdimensional graviton
214
634721
2599
10:37
that then snaps back into the three dimensions of the LHC
215
637344
4380
10:41
and spits off two photons,
216
641748
1822
10:44
two particles of light.
217
644278
1338
10:47
And this hypothetical, extra-dimensional graviton
218
647417
2910
10:50
is one of the only possible, hypothetical new particles
219
650351
3707
10:54
that has the special quantum properties
220
654082
2135
10:56
that could give birth to our little, two-photon bump.
221
656241
4236
11:02
So, the possibility of explaining the mysteries of gravity
222
662000
5820
11:07
and of discovering extra dimensions of space --
223
667844
3498
11:11
perhaps now you get a sense
224
671366
1592
11:12
as to why thousands of physics geeks collectively lost their cool
225
672982
4124
11:17
over our little, two-photon bump.
226
677130
1882
11:19
A discovery of this type would rewrite the textbooks.
227
679036
2900
11:22
But remember,
228
682739
1152
11:23
the message from us experimentalists
229
683915
1724
11:25
that actually were doing this work at the time,
230
685663
2239
11:27
was very clear:
231
687926
1154
11:29
we need more data.
232
689104
1174
11:30
With more data,
233
690302
1519
11:31
the little bump will either turn into a nice, crisp Nobel Prize --
234
691845
4024
11:35
(Laughter)
235
695893
1760
11:37
Or the extra data will fill in the space around the bump
236
697677
2964
11:40
and turn it into a nice, smooth line.
237
700665
1866
11:43
So we took more data,
238
703515
1218
11:44
and with five times the data, several months later,
239
704757
2577
11:47
our little bump
240
707358
1690
11:49
turned into a smooth line.
241
709072
2348
11:55
The news reported on a "huge disappointment," on "faded hopes,"
242
715217
3484
11:58
and on particle physicists "being sad."
243
718725
2510
12:01
Given the tone of the coverage,
244
721259
1811
12:03
you'd think that we had decided to shut down the LHC and go home.
245
723094
3488
12:06
(Laughter)
246
726606
1150
12:08
But that's not what we did.
247
728628
1603
12:13
But why not?
248
733057
2014
12:16
I mean, if I didn't discover a particle -- and I didn't --
249
736475
2845
12:20
if I didn't discover a particle, why am I here talking to you?
250
740209
3029
12:23
Why didn't I just hang my head in shame
251
743262
2437
12:25
and go home?
252
745723
1224
12:31
Particle physicists are explorers.
253
751169
3351
12:35
And very much of what we do is cartography.
254
755421
2952
12:39
Let me put it this way: forget about the LHC for a second.
255
759468
2852
12:42
Imagine you are a space explorer arriving at a distant planet,
256
762344
3382
12:45
searching for aliens.
257
765750
1325
12:47
What is your first task?
258
767099
1522
12:49
To immediately orbit the planet, land, take a quick look around
259
769931
3076
12:53
for any big, obvious signs of life,
260
773031
1886
12:54
and report back to home base.
261
774941
1819
12:56
That's the stage we're at now.
262
776784
1624
12:59
We took a first look at the LHC
263
779269
1487
13:00
for any new, big, obvious-to-spot particles,
264
780780
2284
13:03
and we can report that there are none.
265
783088
1950
13:05
We saw a weird-looking alien bump on a distant mountain,
266
785631
2673
13:08
but once we got closer, we saw it was a rock.
267
788328
2170
13:10
But then what do we do? Do we just give up and fly away?
268
790816
2640
13:13
Absolutely not;
269
793480
1287
13:14
we would be terrible scientists if we did.
270
794791
2305
13:17
No, we spend the next couple of decades exploring,
271
797120
3613
13:20
mapping out the territory,
272
800757
1480
13:22
sifting through the sand with a fine instrument,
273
802261
2365
13:24
peeking under every stone,
274
804650
1458
13:26
drilling under the surface.
275
806132
1554
13:28
New particles can either show up immediately
276
808106
2593
13:30
as big, obvious-to-spot bumps,
277
810723
2133
13:32
or they can only reveal themselves after years of data taking.
278
812880
3941
13:38
Humanity has just begun its exploration at the LHC at this big high energy,
279
818103
4410
13:42
and we have much searching to do.
280
822537
1791
13:44
But what if, even after 10 or 20 years, we still find no new particles?
281
824352
5825
13:51
We build a bigger machine.
282
831053
1695
13:52
(Laughter)
283
832772
1574
13:54
We search at higher energies.
284
834370
1690
13:56
We search at higher energies.
285
836476
1570
13:58
Planning is already underway for a 100-kilometer tunnel
286
838946
3053
14:02
that will collide particles at 10 times the energy of the LHC.
287
842612
2976
14:05
We don't decide where nature places new particles.
288
845612
2337
14:08
We only decide to keep exploring.
289
848366
1646
14:10
But what if, even after a 100-kilometer tunnel
290
850036
2558
14:12
or a 500-kilometer tunnel
291
852618
1860
14:14
or a 10,000-kilometer collider floating in space
292
854502
2841
14:17
between the Earth and the Moon,
293
857367
1578
14:18
we still find no new particles?
294
858969
3062
14:23
Then perhaps we're doing particle physics wrong.
295
863597
2694
14:26
(Laughter)
296
866315
1791
14:28
Perhaps we need to rethink things.
297
868130
1957
14:31
Maybe we need more resources, technology, expertise
298
871127
3262
14:34
than what we currently have.
299
874413
1508
14:36
We already use artificial intelligence and machine learning techniques
300
876610
3341
14:39
in parts of the LHC,
301
879975
1153
14:41
but imagine designing a particle physics experiment
302
881152
2406
14:43
using such sophisticated algorithms
303
883582
1669
14:45
that it could teach itself to discover a hyperdimensional graviton.
304
885275
3168
14:48
But what if?
305
888467
1157
14:49
What if the ultimate question:
306
889648
1445
14:51
What if even artificial intelligence can't help us answer our questions?
307
891117
3473
14:54
What if these open questions, for centuries,
308
894614
2111
14:56
are destined to be unanswered for the foreseeable future?
309
896749
2669
14:59
What if the stuff that's bothered me since I was a little kid
310
899442
2929
15:02
is destined to be unanswered in my lifetime?
311
902395
2523
15:06
Then that ...
312
906395
1156
15:08
will be even more fascinating.
313
908282
2094
15:12
We will be forced to think in completely new ways.
314
912144
3225
15:16
We'll have to go back to our assumptions,
315
916361
2058
15:18
and determine if there was a flaw somewhere.
316
918443
2339
15:21
And we'll need to encourage more people to join us in studying science
317
921401
3395
15:24
since we need fresh eyes on these century-old problems.
318
924820
3062
15:27
I don't have the answers, and I'm still searching for them.
319
927906
3134
15:31
But someone -- maybe she's in school right now,
320
931064
2329
15:33
maybe she's not even born yet --
321
933417
1684
15:35
could eventually guide us to see physics in a completely new way,
322
935783
3133
15:38
and to point out that perhaps we're just asking the wrong questions.
323
938940
4268
15:44
Which would not be the end of physics,
324
944112
2410
15:46
but a novel beginning.
325
946546
1406
15:49
Thank you.
326
949204
1150
15:50
(Applause)
327
950378
2541
About this website

This site will introduce you to YouTube videos that are useful for learning English. You will see English lessons taught by top-notch teachers from around the world. Double-click on the English subtitles displayed on each video page to play the video from there. The subtitles scroll in sync with the video playback. If you have any comments or requests, please contact us using this contact form.

https://forms.gle/WvT1wiN1qDtmnspy7