Dena Simmons: How students of color confront impostor syndrome | TED

127,275 views ・ 2017-01-17

TED


Please double-click on the English subtitles below to play the video.

00:00
Translator: Joseph Geni Reviewer: Camille Martínez
0
0
7000
00:13
So, my journey began in the Bronx, New York,
1
13112
3951
00:18
in a one-bedroom apartment,
2
18098
1768
00:19
with my two sisters and immigrant mother.
3
19890
2671
00:23
I loved our neighborhood.
4
23712
2807
00:27
It was lively.
5
27382
1508
00:28
There was all this merengue blasting,
6
28914
2445
00:31
neighbors socializing on building stoops
7
31383
2389
00:33
and animated conversations over domino playing.
8
33796
3423
00:38
It was home,
9
38327
1462
00:40
and it was sweet.
10
40852
1492
00:43
But it wasn't simple.
11
43368
1596
00:45
In fact, everyone at school knew the block where we lived,
12
45645
3614
00:49
because it was where people came to buy weed and other drugs.
13
49283
4115
00:53
And with drug-dealing comes conflict,
14
53950
2570
00:56
so we often went to sleep to the sound of gunshots.
15
56544
3869
01:01
I spent much of my childhood worried,
16
61839
2853
01:05
worried about our safety.
17
65121
2428
01:08
And so did our mother.
18
68803
1398
01:11
She worried that the violence we witnessed would overtake our lives;
19
71277
4594
01:16
that our poverty meant
20
76338
1725
01:18
that the neighbors with whom we lived and shared space
21
78087
2675
01:20
would harm us.
22
80786
1285
01:22
Our entire life was in the Bronx,
23
82851
3030
01:26
but my mother's anxiety spurred her into action,
24
86566
2996
01:29
and soon we were driving so fast to Connecticut --
25
89586
4770
01:34
(Laughter)
26
94380
1072
01:35
to boarding school campuses, with full scholarships in tow.
27
95476
4357
01:39
Man, don't underestimate the power of a mother
28
99857
5734
01:45
determined to keep her children safe.
29
105615
2552
01:49
(Cheers)
30
109010
1282
01:50
(Applause)
31
110316
2419
01:55
At boarding school,
32
115553
1451
01:58
for the first time,
33
118658
2137
02:01
I was able to sleep without worry.
34
121867
2317
02:05
I could leave my dorm room unlocked,
35
125391
2005
02:07
walk barefoot in the grass,
36
127968
1835
02:10
and look up to see a night sky full of stars.
37
130291
4119
02:16
Happy novelties.
38
136061
1931
02:19
But there were other novelties as well.
39
139172
2340
02:22
Very quickly, I felt like I didn't belong.
40
142298
3527
02:26
I learned that I didn't speak the right way,
41
146469
2889
02:29
and to demonstrate the proper ways of speaking,
42
149382
3300
02:33
my teachers gave me frequent lessons, in public,
43
153226
4061
02:37
on the appropriate way to enunciate certain words.
44
157759
3532
02:43
A teacher once instructed me in the hallway:
45
163068
2821
02:47
"Aaaaaas-king."
46
167040
2661
02:51
She said this loudly.
47
171535
1600
02:54
"Dena, it's not 'axing,' like you're running around with an axe.
48
174024
4922
02:59
That's silly."
49
179809
1408
03:02
Now at this point, you can imagine the snickers of my classmates,
50
182082
4934
03:08
but she continued:
51
188258
1521
03:11
"Think about breaking the word into 'ass' and 'king,'
52
191246
4928
03:16
and then put the two together to say it correctly --
53
196667
3058
03:20
'Asking.'"
54
200720
1286
03:23
There were some other moments that reminded me that I didn't belong.
55
203918
3403
03:28
Once, I walked into a classmate's dorm room,
56
208186
3105
03:32
and I watched her watch her valuables around me.
57
212028
3110
03:36
Like, why would she do that? I thought to myself.
58
216349
2893
03:40
And then there was the time
59
220385
2439
03:42
when another classmate walked into my dorm room,
60
222848
3439
03:46
and yelled, "Ew!" as I was applying hair grease to my scalp.
61
226311
4030
03:53
There is emotional damage done when young people can't be themselves,
62
233072
4935
03:58
when they are forced to edit who they are in order to be acceptable.
63
238504
4734
04:04
It's a kind of violence.
64
244627
2010
04:08
Ultimately, I'm a quintessential success story.
65
248940
4045
04:13
I attended boarding school and college in New England,
66
253992
3207
04:17
studied abroad in Chile
67
257223
2080
04:19
and returned to the Bronx to be a middle school teacher.
68
259327
3115
04:23
I received a Truman Scholarship,
69
263027
2397
04:25
a Fulbright and a Soros Fellowship.
70
265448
3218
04:28
And I could list more.
71
268690
1530
04:30
(Laughter)
72
270598
1161
04:32
But I won't.
73
272116
1196
04:33
(Laughter)
74
273336
1398
04:35
I earned my doctorate at Columbia University.
75
275908
3133
04:39
(Cheers)
76
279792
1091
04:40
(Applause)
77
280907
1806
04:42
And then I landed a job at Yale.
78
282737
2342
04:45
(Applause)
79
285103
1766
04:47
I am proud of everything that I've been able to accomplish
80
287363
4282
04:52
on my journey thus far.
81
292036
1912
04:56
I have eternal imposter syndrome.
82
296884
2963
05:01
Either I've been invited because I'm a token,
83
301150
2909
05:04
which really isn't about me,
84
304083
2207
05:06
but rather, about a box someone needed to check off.
85
306314
3090
05:10
Or, I am exceptional,
86
310388
2595
05:13
which means I've had to leave the people I love behind.
87
313673
4322
05:19
It's the price that I and so many others pay for learning while black.
88
319528
6045
05:27
(Applause)
89
327595
3166
05:34
I police myself all the time.
90
334689
3781
05:40
Are my pants too tight?
91
340008
1483
05:42
Should I wear my hair up or in a fro?
92
342768
2604
05:46
Should I speak up for myself,
93
346726
2445
05:49
or will the power of my words be reduced to: "She's angry"?
94
349195
4698
05:56
Why did I have to leave the Bronx
95
356114
2610
05:58
to gain access to a better education?
96
358748
2859
06:03
And why, in the process of getting that better education,
97
363433
4461
06:07
did I have to endure the trauma of erasing what made me, me --
98
367918
5880
06:15
a black girl from the Bronx, raised by an Antiguan mother?
99
375449
4503
06:21
So when I think about our current education reform initiatives,
100
381861
4673
06:27
I can't help asking:
101
387390
1813
06:30
What are our students of color learning about themselves?
102
390179
3702
06:35
Three -- three decades of research reveal
103
395830
3287
06:39
that students of color are suspended and expelled
104
399141
3266
06:42
at a rate three times greater than white students,
105
402431
3115
06:46
and are punished in harsher ways for the same infractions.
106
406170
5179
06:53
They also learn this through the absence of their lives and narratives
107
413138
3497
06:56
in the curricula.
108
416659
1199
06:59
The Cooperative Children's Book Center did a review of nearly 4,000 books
109
419432
4885
07:04
and found that only three percent were about African-Americans.
110
424848
4079
07:10
And they further learn this
111
430686
1363
07:12
through the lack of teachers that look like them.
112
432073
2826
07:17
An analysis of data
113
437550
1439
07:19
from the National Center for Education Statistics
114
439013
3714
07:22
found that 45 percent of our nation's pre-K to high school students
115
442751
5156
07:27
were people of color,
116
447931
1627
07:30
while only 17 percent of our teachers are.
117
450300
4424
07:36
Our youth of color pay a profound price
118
456881
2837
07:39
when their schooling sends them the message
119
459742
2118
07:41
that they must be controlled,
120
461884
2129
07:44
that they must leave their identities at home
121
464479
2384
07:46
in order to be successful.
122
466887
2093
07:51
Every child deserves an education
123
471027
3287
07:54
that guarantees the safety to learn
124
474338
3521
07:57
in the comfort of one's own skin.
125
477883
4347
08:03
(Applause)
126
483484
3958
08:11
It is possible to create emotionally and physically safe classrooms
127
491551
5243
08:16
where students also thrive academically.
128
496818
2726
08:20
I know, because I did it in my classroom
129
500511
3390
08:23
when I returned to teach in the Bronx.
130
503925
2126
08:27
So what did that look like?
131
507681
1629
08:31
I centered my instruction
132
511040
2034
08:33
on the lives, histories and identities of my students.
133
513098
4151
08:38
And I did all of this because I wanted my students to know
134
518621
2992
08:41
that everyone around them was supporting them
135
521637
3687
08:45
to be their best self.
136
525348
1907
08:49
So while I could not control the instability of their homes,
137
529054
5243
08:54
the uncertainty of their next meal,
138
534321
2651
08:57
or the loud neighbors that kept them from sleep,
139
537472
2450
09:00
I provided them with a loving classroom
140
540641
3366
09:04
that made them feel proud of who they are,
141
544031
2717
09:07
that made them know that they mattered.
142
547313
2805
09:11
You know,
143
551620
1203
09:14
every time I hear or say the word "asking,"
144
554522
5551
09:22
I am in high school again.
145
562977
1454
09:26
I am thinking about "ass" and "king"
146
566135
4414
09:32
and putting the two together so that I speak in a way
147
572117
4065
09:36
where someone in power will want to listen.
148
576206
3536
09:42
There is a better way,
149
582115
1673
09:44
one that doesn't force kids of color into a double bind;
150
584365
3614
09:48
a way for them to preserve their ties
151
588799
2362
09:51
to their families, homes and communities;
152
591185
2746
09:54
a way that teaches them to trust their instincts
153
594944
4697
10:00
and to have faith in their own creative genius.
154
600555
5555
10:07
Thank you.
155
607144
1183
10:08
(Applause)
156
608351
8019
About this website

This site will introduce you to YouTube videos that are useful for learning English. You will see English lessons taught by top-notch teachers from around the world. Double-click on the English subtitles displayed on each video page to play the video from there. The subtitles scroll in sync with the video playback. If you have any comments or requests, please contact us using this contact form.

https://forms.gle/WvT1wiN1qDtmnspy7