My story of love and loss as a transracial adoptee | Sara Jones

48,917 views ・ 2020-06-18

TED


Please double-click on the English subtitles below to play the video.

00:12
When I was three years old,
0
12588
1730
00:14
I was transracially adopted from South Korea
1
14342
3151
00:17
by a white family in Salt Lake City, Utah.
2
17517
3145
00:21
I arrived in America with a mysterious tattoo on my left forearm.
3
21507
4617
00:26
The tattoo was so large and noticeable
4
26148
2701
00:28
that my adoptive parents had it surgically removed right away.
5
28873
3345
00:32
They were worried that other kids would make fun of it.
6
32826
3035
00:35
Today, there's only a light scar where the tattoo once was,
7
35885
2782
00:38
so I've redrawn it in permanent marker so you can see what it looked like.
8
38691
3968
00:43
Korean adoption records in 1976 were notoriously incomplete.
9
43651
5191
00:49
I didn't have any information about my background
10
49365
2628
00:52
or my birth family.
11
52017
1384
00:53
I didn't even know if my name or birth date were real
12
53882
4213
00:58
or if they were assigned.
13
58119
1499
01:00
And no one knew what my tattoo meant.
14
60422
2684
01:04
Transracial adoption is where a child from one race or ethnicity
15
64485
3668
01:08
is adopted by parents from a different race or ethnicity.
16
68177
3902
01:12
In my generation, children who were adopted from Korea
17
72761
2788
01:15
were assimilated into the culture of their adoptive parents.
18
75573
4207
01:19
So I was raised as if I were white.
19
79804
2383
01:23
Growing up, occasionally my family would eat at a Korean restaurant,
20
83117
3261
01:26
or we'd go to the Asian festival.
21
86402
1774
01:29
But I did not identify with being Asian.
22
89184
3293
01:33
Looking back now,
23
93385
1965
01:35
having my tattoo removed is symbolic of losing a connection
24
95374
3283
01:38
with my Korean ethnicity and culture.
25
98681
3136
01:43
And I am not alone.
26
103042
1151
01:44
Since the 1950s, almost 200,000 Korean children have been adopted
27
104217
4850
01:49
all over the world.
28
109091
1517
01:51
A growing body of research shows that children experience trauma
29
111516
4015
01:55
when they're separated from their families of origin.
30
115555
2592
01:58
My story includes such childhood trauma.
31
118920
2915
02:02
I recently found out that my birth mother
32
122879
2202
02:05
left my family shortly after I was born.
33
125105
2605
02:08
When I was two years old, my birth father became injured
34
128587
3156
02:11
and could not provide for my brothers and me.
35
131767
2316
02:15
And so my two older brothers and I were sent to children welfare services.
36
135073
4128
02:19
And there, someone decided, because I was younger,
37
139860
4900
02:25
that I was more adoptable.
38
145772
2067
02:29
And so, I was sent to a separate orphanage,
39
149012
3052
02:32
separated from my brothers who cared for me.
40
152088
3140
02:36
My adoption records say that I wouldn't play
41
156768
2229
02:39
with any of the other children at the orphanage,
42
159021
3350
02:42
and now I know why.
43
162395
1584
02:44
My adoption photos show the picture of a frightened, malnourished little girl.
44
164465
6392
02:51
Just imagine my culture shock a short and lonely nine months later,
45
171462
4446
02:55
as I arrived in America,
46
175932
1549
02:57
where everything was different:
47
177505
2738
03:00
the people,
48
180267
1729
03:02
the buildings,
49
182020
1237
03:03
the food
50
183281
1485
03:04
and the clothing.
51
184790
1326
03:07
As a three-year-old child, I quickly figured out
52
187203
2273
03:09
that no one spoke the Korean language that I spoke,
53
189500
3346
03:12
and so I stopped speaking altogether for six months.
54
192870
3890
03:16
And when I started speaking again, it was in full English.
55
196784
3599
03:21
One of the first phrases I said
56
201159
1790
03:22
as my parents showed me my orphanage photos
57
202973
3333
03:26
was, "Sara sad."
58
206330
2630
03:31
Children who are adopted often put up emotional walls
59
211099
2984
03:34
to protect themselves from being hurt again.
60
214107
2692
03:36
I certainly did this,
61
216823
1687
03:38
and like many transracially adopted children,
62
218534
2208
03:40
there were many moments growing up where I wished that I was white
63
220766
3453
03:44
like the other kids around me.
64
224243
1708
03:46
Other kids made fun of my eyes and nose.
65
226640
2926
03:50
Now, the '80s styles were particularly brutal to me,
66
230222
2977
03:53
with glasses that didn't fit well,
67
233223
2082
03:55
hairstyles --
68
235329
1427
03:56
(Laughter)
69
236780
1049
03:57
that looked ridiculous on me.
70
237853
2672
04:00
(Laughter)
71
240549
1624
04:03
This narrative of adoption might be uncomfortable for you to hear.
72
243381
4504
04:08
The narrative that we usually hear is that of a new parent,
73
248505
4064
04:12
who is eagerly awaiting a child that they've been wanting for so long.
74
252593
3450
04:17
The parents' story is told with love, joy and excitement,
75
257552
3233
04:20
and as they bring a newly adopted child into their home,
76
260809
3293
04:24
family and friends celebrate and congratulate the parents
77
264126
3466
04:27
on their wonderful decision to adopt.
78
267616
2827
04:31
My parents' adoption story was like a beautiful blanket that kept me warm.
79
271622
4688
04:37
But after a while, it felt like the focus was more on the blanket,
80
277556
4040
04:41
covering me and my point of view entirely.
81
281620
3002
04:44
I couldn't emotionally breathe.
82
284646
2537
04:48
My parents would say things to me like,
83
288343
2549
04:50
"I fell in love with you the first time I saw your photo.
84
290916
3854
04:54
My heart broke."
85
294794
1851
04:58
They love me, I know that, and I was wanted.
86
298430
4004
05:03
But I wish that the only birth story I had wasn't so sad,
87
303861
4415
05:08
so humanitarian.
88
308300
1653
05:11
I would often confuse love with gratitude,
89
311009
2457
05:13
especially when other people would say things to me like,
90
313490
3216
05:16
"You're so lucky to be adopted to America,"
91
316730
3424
05:20
or, "Your parents are such angels to adopt you."
92
320178
3790
05:25
To a child, it felt like these comments were constant reminders to be grateful
93
325284
3725
05:29
to my parents' charity.
94
329033
1694
05:31
I resented that I couldn't tell these adults,
95
331157
2613
05:33
"I don't like being reminded all the time that I'm adopted.
96
333794
3113
05:36
I just want to be a normal kid,
97
336931
3030
05:39
and maybe even be ungrateful once in a while."
98
339985
3593
05:43
(Laughter)
99
343602
1587
05:46
But I learned to smile without really smiling,
100
346153
3671
05:49
and as I grew older, I wanted to be able to say,
101
349848
2346
05:52
"Sara is still sad."
102
352218
2597
05:55
But I buried my feelings, and it wasn't until later in life
103
355808
2832
05:58
that I realized I'd never really grieved my own adoption.
104
358664
4154
06:03
While many of us understand that adopting a child
105
363796
2393
06:06
from a different race, culture or country is never simple,
106
366213
3711
06:09
we rarely acknowledge the complex emotions
107
369948
2502
06:12
that children who are adopted can experience.
108
372474
2399
06:15
Some children experience feelings of loss,
109
375444
3225
06:18
feelings of rejection,
110
378693
1845
06:20
grief,
111
380562
1378
06:21
shame,
112
381964
1572
06:23
guilt,
113
383560
1250
06:24
challenges with identity,
114
384834
2381
06:27
difficulty with intimacy
115
387239
1455
06:28
and control issues.
116
388718
1671
06:30
Just ask my kids.
117
390413
2173
06:32
(Laughter)
118
392610
1358
06:33
Children who are adopted can still love their adoptive parents
119
393992
5638
06:39
at the same time as experiencing these complex emotions.
120
399654
3652
06:43
And many of us wonder: If we had had safe emotional spaces
121
403330
3447
06:46
to own our own stories when we were younger,
122
406801
4208
06:51
would we still be struggling to come to terms with adoption as adults?
123
411033
4377
06:56
Where do we find the emotional oxygen to own our own stories?
124
416381
4738
07:03
Since the late 1990s and early 2000s,
125
423912
2767
07:06
researchers like Dr. Richard Lee have focused on different parenting techniques
126
426703
3972
07:10
for transracial adoption.
127
430699
1828
07:12
The hope is to help children and their adoptive parents
128
432551
3271
07:15
better adapt to their unique racial and ethnic circumstances.
129
435846
4048
07:19
There's more enculturation encouraged,
130
439918
2228
07:22
that exposes children to the people,
131
442170
2801
07:24
places, languages and culture of their birth families.
132
444995
3740
07:28
Some parents focus on racial inculcation
133
448759
3256
07:32
to specifically work with their children on the racism and discrimination
134
452039
4369
07:36
that they will experience outside of the home.
135
456432
2896
07:39
And some parents allow children to choose as they get older
136
459352
3317
07:42
the level of exposure to the culture of their birth families.
137
462693
3763
07:47
Now, we might look at these signs of progress
138
467064
2188
07:49
and think we've got it all figured out when it comes to transracial adoption.
139
469276
4094
07:54
The Korean adoptees were the first massive wave of international adoptions,
140
474489
4971
07:59
almost 30 years earlier than most other countries,
141
479484
3863
08:03
and so there are entire generations of Korean adoptees --
142
483371
3462
08:06
from children all the way to adults in their 70s --
143
486857
4523
08:11
dealing with the impact of their assimilation,
144
491404
2784
08:14
and there have only been a handful of studies
145
494212
2844
08:17
that follow transracial adoptees over a lifetime.
146
497080
3034
08:22
I know that people around me could not understand my adoption grief.
147
502260
3600
08:26
Rachel Rostad, another Korean adoptee, expressed what I was feeling
148
506692
3444
08:30
when she said,
149
510160
1196
08:32
"Loss is especially confusing to measure
150
512324
2969
08:35
when it appears as if I haven't lost anything at all.
151
515317
3577
08:40
It's not missing like an organ.
152
520000
2022
08:42
It's missing like wherever dreams go when you blink awake
153
522046
4030
08:46
into the morning light."
154
526100
1618
08:48
Every year, hundreds of South Korean adoptees
155
528707
3054
08:51
search for their birth families.
156
531785
1610
08:53
Korean agencies report that less than 15 percent are successful.
157
533930
4649
08:59
Last year, I found my Korean birth family in just three months.
158
539640
4463
09:05
I posted a photo of my redrawn tattoo on social media,
159
545119
4122
09:09
which Korean groups generously shared.
160
549265
2235
09:12
And a friend of my brother saw the photo,
161
552778
2664
09:15
and he knew instantly what the tattoo meant.
162
555466
3420
09:20
When my father decided to send us to children welfare services,
163
560665
3282
09:23
he was worried that we would be separated and even adopted into foreign countries.
164
563971
5429
09:30
And so he took the unusual step to place a large tattoo
165
570055
4342
09:34
on each of our arms
166
574421
1968
09:36
and on his own,
167
576413
2589
09:39
so that we could find each other someday.
168
579026
2468
09:42
And he tried searching for me.
169
582912
1976
09:45
And he was right:
170
585973
1448
09:48
the tattoo did eventually lead me to find the family that I had lost.
171
588232
4925
09:54
Unfortunately, he passed away nine years before he could see his children reunited.
172
594665
4803
10:00
But last year, I traveled to Korea to meet my two older brothers,
173
600229
4509
10:04
my aunt and uncle,
174
604762
2085
10:06
and I learned a lot of new things about myself,
175
606871
2218
10:09
including my real birth date,
176
609113
1975
10:11
which actually makes me seven months older.
177
611112
2530
10:13
(Laughter)
178
613666
1858
10:15
This middle-aged woman did not love hearing that she is older.
179
615548
3661
10:19
(Laughter)
180
619233
1853
10:21
And that explains all those gifted and talented classes I had in school.
181
621110
3721
10:24
(Laughter)
182
624855
2854
10:29
But the most important thing that I learned
183
629654
2375
10:32
was that I had a loving family in Korea
184
632926
3007
10:35
who remembered me as a little baby
185
635957
3584
10:39
and had never forgotten me.
186
639565
2446
10:42
I wasn't abandoned, like my adoption records said.
187
642860
3573
10:47
I was wanted.
188
647747
1534
10:51
It's time to reframe our views on adoption.
189
651495
3265
10:54
A healthy adoption ecosystem is one in which children,
190
654784
4414
10:59
adoptive families and birth families
191
659222
3332
11:02
each own their unique stories.
192
662578
2443
11:05
When these narratives are placed side by side,
193
665494
3467
11:08
it creates better empathy and policies for the lives that adoption impacts.
194
668985
4846
11:14
Here are two things that adults can do
195
674640
2548
11:17
to better protect adopted children's stories.
196
677212
2928
11:20
First, give children safe emotional spaces to express their emotions,
197
680581
5250
11:25
both positive and negative.
198
685855
2373
11:29
Phrases such as "tell me more,"
199
689713
2929
11:32
"what do you wish for"
200
692666
1927
11:34
and "those feelings are normal"
201
694617
2364
11:37
are ways that parents can grant emotional oxygen to their children.
202
697005
5362
11:42
Second, validate a child's adoption story.
203
702970
4197
11:47
Children may express emotions that may feel hurtful
204
707959
3360
11:51
or worry an adoptive parent.
205
711343
2705
11:54
As a parent, work to hold and manage your fears
206
714072
3403
11:57
separately from your child.
207
717499
2080
12:00
Always acknowledge your child's story as valid and important.
208
720413
4539
12:06
Now, it's natural to want to protect children
209
726091
2744
12:08
from experiencing pain.
210
728859
1804
12:12
But my tattoo is a poignant reminder that every adoption starts with loss,
211
732280
5228
12:17
and every child is affected differently.
212
737532
2881
12:20
Children who are adopted can live full, rich lives,
213
740909
3898
12:24
as we accept and build upon this unique set of cards that we were dealt.
214
744831
5191
12:30
And as you listen to our narratives with empathy,
215
750547
2511
12:33
you will hear other things as well:
216
753082
2402
12:36
childlike curiosity,
217
756526
2891
12:39
grace,
218
759441
1373
12:40
resilience,
219
760838
1701
12:42
courage,
220
762563
1168
12:44
love
221
764672
1153
12:46
and yes, even gratitude.
222
766771
3135
12:50
Thank you.
223
770468
1167
12:51
(Applause)
224
771659
2928
About this website

This site will introduce you to YouTube videos that are useful for learning English. You will see English lessons taught by top-notch teachers from around the world. Double-click on the English subtitles displayed on each video page to play the video from there. The subtitles scroll in sync with the video playback. If you have any comments or requests, please contact us using this contact form.

https://forms.gle/WvT1wiN1qDtmnspy7