How our friendship survives our opposing politics | Caitlin Quattromani and Lauran Arledge

96,195 views ・ 2017-09-25

TED


Please double-click on the English subtitles below to play the video.

00:12
Caitlin Quattromani: The election of 2016 felt different.
0
12681
3183
00:16
Political conversations with our family and friends
1
16398
3023
00:19
uncovered a level of polarization
2
19445
1786
00:21
that many of us had not previously experienced.
3
21255
2594
00:24
People who we always thought were reasonable and intelligent
4
24490
3523
00:28
seemed like strangers.
5
28037
1585
00:29
We said to ourselves, "How could you think that?
6
29646
2659
00:32
I thought you were smart."
7
32329
1872
00:34
Lauran Arledge: Caitlin and I met in the summer of 2011,
8
34225
3393
00:37
and we bonded around being working moms
9
37642
1890
00:39
and trying to keep our very energetic boys busy.
10
39556
3066
00:42
And we soon found out we had almost everything in common.
11
42646
3000
00:46
From our love of Colorado to our love of sushi,
12
46138
3493
00:49
there wasn't much we didn't agree on.
13
49655
2070
00:52
We also discovered that we share a deep love of this country
14
52481
2993
00:55
and feel a responsibility to be politically active.
15
55498
2960
00:59
But no one's perfect --
16
59076
1651
01:00
(Laughter)
17
60751
1048
01:01
and I soon found out two disappointing things about Caitlin.
18
61823
4003
01:05
First, she hates camping.
19
65850
2623
01:08
CQ: I think camping is the worst.
20
68497
2048
01:10
LA: So there would not be any joint camping trips in our future.
21
70569
3618
01:14
The second thing is that she's politically active all right --
22
74901
3660
01:18
as a conservative.
23
78585
1220
01:20
CQ: I may hate camping, but I love politics.
24
80410
3302
01:23
I listen to conservative talk radio just about every day,
25
83736
3205
01:26
and I've volunteered for a few different conservative political campaigns.
26
86965
3699
01:31
LA: And I'd say I'm a little to the left,
27
91131
2302
01:33
like all the way to the left.
28
93457
1414
01:34
(Laughter)
29
94895
1579
01:36
I've always been interested in politics.
30
96498
2096
01:38
I was a political science major,
31
98618
1578
01:40
and I worked as a community organizer and on a congressional campaign.
32
100220
3383
01:43
CQ: So as Lauran and I were getting to know each other,
33
103998
2650
01:46
it was right in the middle of that 2012 presidential campaign,
34
106672
2923
01:49
and most of our early political conversations
35
109619
2493
01:52
were really just based in jokes and pranks.
36
112136
2515
01:55
So as an example, I would change Lauran's computer screen saver
37
115064
3032
01:58
to a picture of Mitt Romney,
38
118120
1429
01:59
or she would put an Obama campaign magnet on the back of my car.
39
119573
3397
02:02
(Laughter)
40
122994
1011
02:04
LA: Car, not minivan.
41
124029
2040
02:06
CQ: But over time, those conversations grew more serious
42
126093
3008
02:09
and really became a core of our friendship.
43
129125
2659
02:11
And somewhere along the line,
44
131808
1418
02:13
we decided we didn't want to have any topic be off limits for discussion,
45
133250
3979
02:17
even if those topics pushed us way outside of our friendship comfort zone.
46
137253
4174
02:21
LA: And so to most of us,
47
141731
1204
02:22
political conversations are a zero-sum game.
48
142959
2596
02:25
There's a winner and there's a loser.
49
145579
1977
02:27
We go for the attack and we spot a weakness in someone's argument.
50
147580
3253
02:30
And here's the important part:
51
150857
1483
02:32
we tend to take every comment or opinion that's expressed
52
152364
3096
02:35
as a personal affront to our own values and beliefs.
53
155484
3086
02:39
But what if changed the way we think about these conversations?
54
159337
3103
02:43
What if, in these heated moments,
55
163035
2262
02:45
we chose dialogue over debate?
56
165321
2277
02:48
When we engage in dialogue, we flip the script.
57
168606
2880
02:52
We replace our ego and our desire to win
58
172118
2777
02:54
with curiosity, empathy
59
174919
2079
02:57
and a desire to learn.
60
177022
1485
02:58
Instead of coming from a place of judgment,
61
178531
2066
03:00
we are genuinely interested in the other person's experiences,
62
180621
3872
03:04
their values and their concerns.
63
184517
2000
03:07
CQ: You make it sound so simple, Lauran.
64
187040
2142
03:09
But getting to that place of true dialogue is hard,
65
189601
2821
03:12
especially when we're talking about politics.
66
192446
2411
03:14
It is so easy to get emotionally fired up
67
194881
2615
03:17
about issues that we're passionate about,
68
197520
2116
03:19
and we can let our ego get in the way of truly hearing
69
199660
2935
03:22
the other person's perspective.
70
202619
1733
03:24
And in this crazy political climate we're in right now,
71
204376
2573
03:26
unfortunately, we're seeing an extreme result
72
206973
2792
03:29
of those heated political conversations,
73
209789
2346
03:32
to the point where people are willing to walk away from their relationships.
74
212159
3969
03:36
In fact, Rasmussen released a poll earlier this year
75
216152
2969
03:39
that said 40 percent of people reported that the 2016 election
76
219145
4714
03:43
negatively impacted a personal relationship,
77
223883
3024
03:46
and the Journal of Cognitive Neuroscience tells us
78
226931
2436
03:49
that people tend to feel their way to their beliefs
79
229391
2929
03:52
rather than using reasoning,
80
232344
1713
03:54
and that when reason and emotion collide,
81
234081
3057
03:57
it's emotion that invariably wins.
82
237162
2420
03:59
So no wonder it's hard to talk about these issues.
83
239606
2579
04:02
LA: And look, we're just two regular friends
84
242209
2049
04:04
who happen to think very differently
85
244282
2310
04:06
about politics and the role that government should play in our lives.
86
246616
3300
04:10
And I know we were all taught not to talk about politics
87
250235
2636
04:12
because it's not polite,
88
252895
1444
04:14
but we need to be able to talk about it,
89
254363
1913
04:16
because it's important to us and it's a part of who we are.
90
256300
3155
04:19
CQ: We have chosen to avoid political debate
91
259479
2762
04:22
and instead engage in dialogue
92
262265
2223
04:24
in order to maintain what we fondly call
93
264512
2541
04:27
our bipartisan friendship.
94
267077
1777
04:28
(Laughter)
95
268878
1730
04:30
LA: And this election and all of the craziness that has followed
96
270632
3008
04:33
has given us several opportunities to practice this skill.
97
273664
3029
04:36
(Laughter)
98
276717
1842
04:38
Let's start with January and the Women's March.
99
278583
2192
04:40
At this point, you can probably guess which one of us participated.
100
280799
3427
04:44
(Laughter)
101
284250
1343
04:45
CQ: Oh, the Women's March.
102
285617
1969
04:47
I was annoyed and irritated that entire day,
103
287610
2802
04:50
really because of two things.
104
290436
1791
04:52
Number one, the name "Women's March."
105
292251
2865
04:55
As a conservative woman,
106
295140
1236
04:56
the march's platform of issues didn't represent me,
107
296400
2992
04:59
and that's OK,
108
299416
1174
05:00
but hearing it talked about as this demonstration of sisterhood
109
300614
3271
05:03
and solidarity for all women
110
303909
1667
05:05
didn't ring true for me.
111
305600
1659
05:07
The other piece was the timing of the event,
112
307283
2049
05:09
the fact that it was the day after the presidential inauguration.
113
309356
3308
05:12
It felt like we weren't even giving the new administration
114
312688
2716
05:15
to actually do anything, good or bad,
115
315428
2153
05:17
before people felt the need to demonstrate against it.
116
317605
2730
05:20
LA: And under normal circumstances, I would agree with Caitlin.
117
320706
2954
05:23
I think an administration does deserve the benefit of the doubt.
118
323684
3001
05:26
But in this case, I was marching to show my concern
119
326709
3267
05:30
that a man with such a poor track record with women and other groups
120
330000
3469
05:33
had been elected as president.
121
333493
1514
05:35
I had to be part of the collective voice
122
335645
1968
05:37
that wanted to send a clear message to the new president
123
337637
2942
05:40
that we did not accept or condone
124
340603
2264
05:42
his behavior or rhetoric during the election.
125
342891
2456
05:45
CQ: So I'm already feeling kind of aggravated,
126
345885
2558
05:48
and then I see this Facebook from Lauran pop up in my social media feed.
127
348467
4413
05:52
(Laughter)
128
352904
1007
05:53
Seeing Lauran's sons at the march and holding signs
129
353935
3317
05:57
took it to a new level for me, and not in a good way,
130
357276
3294
06:00
because I know these boys,
131
360594
1596
06:02
I love these boys,
132
362214
1436
06:03
and I didn't feel they were old enough
133
363674
1882
06:05
to understand what the march stood for.
134
365580
1912
06:07
I didn't understand why Lauran would choose
135
367516
2047
06:09
to have them participate in that way,
136
369587
1793
06:11
and I assumed it wasn't a choice that the boys made for themselves.
137
371404
3324
06:14
But I also know Lauran.
138
374752
2378
06:17
You're an incredible mom
139
377154
1215
06:18
who would never exploit your boys in any way,
140
378393
2535
06:20
so I had to stop and check myself.
141
380952
1747
06:22
I had a decision to make.
142
382723
1664
06:24
I could take the easy way out
143
384411
1604
06:26
and just choose not to say anything to her,
144
386039
2750
06:28
and instead just kind of simmer in my frustration,
145
388813
3017
06:31
or I could ask her to learn more about her motivations.
146
391854
3207
06:35
LA: And I shared with Caitlin
147
395085
1382
06:36
that we actually started talking about the March
148
396491
2309
06:38
weeks before we participated.
149
398824
1646
06:40
And my boys were curious as to why the event was being organized,
150
400494
3204
06:43
and this led to some very interesting family conversations.
151
403722
3205
06:47
We talked about how in this country, we have the right and the privilege
152
407403
3524
06:50
to demonstrate against something we don't agree with,
153
410951
2722
06:53
and my husband shared with them why he thought it was so important
154
413697
3112
06:56
that men joined the Women's March.
155
416833
1950
06:58
But the most significant reason we marched as a family
156
418807
2881
07:01
is that it was a way for us to honor my parents' legacy.
157
421712
3110
07:05
They spent their careers
158
425187
1473
07:06
working to defend the rights of some of our most vulnerable citizens,
159
426684
3884
07:10
and they passed these values down to me and my brother,
160
430592
2573
07:13
and we want to do the same with our sons.
161
433189
2154
07:15
CQ: After talking to Lauran,
162
435367
1339
07:16
I really understood not only why she felt it was so important to march,
163
436730
3857
07:20
but why she had her boys with her.
164
440611
1889
07:22
And frankly, my assumptions were wrong.
165
442524
2247
07:24
It was the boys who wanted to march
166
444795
1705
07:26
after they talked about the issues as a family.
167
446524
2191
07:29
But what's most important about this example
168
449163
2108
07:31
is to think about the alternative.
169
451295
1801
07:33
Had Lauran and I not talked about it,
170
453120
1819
07:34
I would have been annoyed with her,
171
454963
1668
07:36
and it could have resulted in an undercurrent of disrespect
172
456655
2777
07:39
in our friendship.
173
459456
1166
07:40
But by asking Lauran questions, it allowed us to use dialogue
174
460646
3154
07:43
to get to a place of true understanding.
175
463824
2024
07:46
Now, to be clear,
176
466203
1569
07:47
our conversation didn't really change my mind about how I felt about the March,
177
467796
3865
07:51
but it absolutely changed my thinking around why she brought her boys with her.
178
471685
4140
07:55
And for both of us, that dialogue allowed us to understand
179
475849
2985
07:58
each other's perspective about the Women's March
180
478858
2269
08:01
even though we disagreed.
181
481151
1317
08:03
LA: The second topic that challenged our ability to engage in dialogue
182
483135
3615
08:06
was around my need to understand
183
486774
2013
08:08
how Caitlin could vote for Trump.
184
488811
1936
08:11
(Laughter)
185
491318
5262
08:17
Caitlin is a successful professional woman
186
497303
3425
08:20
who is deeply caring and compassionate,
187
500752
2607
08:23
and the Caitlin I know
188
503383
1381
08:24
would never excuse any man from talking about women
189
504788
3159
08:27
the way that Trump did during the campaign.
190
507971
2134
08:30
It was hard for me to reconcile these two things in my mind.
191
510571
3059
08:33
How could you overlook the things that were said?
192
513654
2401
08:36
CQ: So I'm guessing I may not be the only one here that thought
193
516757
2954
08:39
we didn't have the best choices for the presidential election last year.
194
519735
3382
08:43
(Laughter)
195
523141
1419
08:44
The Republican candidate who I did support didn't make it out of the primary,
196
524584
3896
08:48
so when it came time to vote, I had a decision to make.
197
528504
2794
08:51
And you're right, there were some terrible things
198
531604
2287
08:53
that came out during the Trump campaign,
199
533915
2113
08:56
so much so that I almost decided to just abstain
200
536052
2523
08:58
rather than voting for president,
201
538599
1585
09:00
something I had never even considered doing before.
202
540208
2754
09:02
But ultimately, I did vote for Donald Trump,
203
542986
2199
09:05
and for me it was really a vote for party over person,
204
545209
3521
09:08
especially recognizing how important that presidential pick is
205
548754
3722
09:12
on influencing our judicial branch.
206
552500
2000
09:15
But I shared with Lauran it was a decision I really wrestled with,
207
555148
3175
09:18
and not one that I made lightly.
208
558347
1737
09:20
LA: And so after our conversation, I was struck by a few things.
209
560676
3407
09:24
First, I had fallen victim to my own confirmation bias.
210
564107
3409
09:27
Because of my strong feelings about Trump,
211
567846
2348
09:30
I had given all Trump voters the same attributes,
212
570218
2668
09:32
and none of them forgiving.
213
572910
1564
09:34
(Laughter)
214
574498
1150
09:35
But knowing Caitlin, I started to ask questions.
215
575672
3484
09:39
What were Trump voters really concerned about?
216
579846
2490
09:42
Under all the divisive language, what was really going on?
217
582360
3182
09:46
What could we learn about ourselves and our country
218
586003
2705
09:48
from this unlikely event?
219
588732
1526
09:51
I also learned that we shared a deep disappointment in this election,
220
591156
4358
09:55
and that we have growing concerns about our two-party political system.
221
595538
3570
09:59
But the most important thing about this conversation
222
599635
2615
10:02
is that it happened at all.
223
602274
1385
10:04
Without an open and honest dialogue between the two of us,
224
604894
3388
10:08
this election would have been the elephant in the room
225
608306
2652
10:10
for the next four years, pun intended.
226
610982
2665
10:13
(Laughter)
227
613671
4420
10:18
CQ: So, look --
228
618115
1151
10:19
(Applause)
229
619290
2262
10:21
So, look -- we know it takes work to get past the difficult,
230
621576
3389
10:24
frustrating and sometimes emotional parts
231
624989
2365
10:27
of having discussions about issues like the Women's March
232
627378
2961
10:30
or why your friend may have voted for a candidate that you can't stand.
233
630363
4134
10:35
But we need to have these conversations.
234
635072
2215
10:37
Our ability to move past political debate
235
637311
2547
10:39
into true dialogue
236
639882
1476
10:41
is a critical skill we should all be focused on right now,
237
641382
3002
10:44
especially with the people that we care about the most.
238
644408
2696
10:47
LA: And it's not just as adults that we need to bottle this behavior.
239
647724
3263
10:51
It's critical that we do it for our children as well.
240
651011
2671
10:54
My sons were inundated with this election.
241
654023
2670
10:56
We were listening to the news in the morning,
242
656717
2144
10:58
and they were having conversations with their friends at school.
243
658885
3069
11:02
I was concerned that they were picking up so much polarizing misinformation,
244
662380
4120
11:06
and they were growing really fearful of a Trump presidency.
245
666524
3078
11:10
Then one day, after the election, I was taking my sons to school,
246
670554
4501
11:15
and my younger son, completely out of the blue,
247
675079
2469
11:17
said, "Mom, we don't know anybody who voted for Trump, right?"
248
677572
4904
11:22
(Laughter)
249
682500
2969
11:25
And I paused and I took a deep breath.
250
685493
3936
11:30
"Yes, we do."
251
690063
1182
11:31
(Laughter)
252
691269
1000
11:32
"The Quattromanis."
253
692293
1150
11:33
And his response was so great.
254
693764
2069
11:35
He kind of got this confused look on his face, and he said ...
255
695857
3190
11:39
"But we love them."
256
699539
1151
11:40
(Laughter)
257
700714
2968
11:43
And I answered, "Yes, we do."
258
703706
1793
11:45
(Laughter)
259
705523
1054
11:46
And then he said, "Why would they vote for him?"
260
706601
2758
11:50
And I remember stopping and thinking
261
710232
1716
11:51
that it was really important how I answered this question.
262
711972
2800
11:55
Somehow, I had to honor our own family values
263
715409
2762
11:58
and show respect for our friends.
264
718195
1809
12:00
So I finally said,
265
720697
1572
12:02
"They think that's the right direction for this country."
266
722293
2668
12:04
And before I had even gotten the whole sentence out,
267
724985
2794
12:07
he had moved on to the soccer game he was going to play at recess.
268
727803
3143
12:10
CQ: So life with boys.
269
730970
1172
12:12
(Laughter)
270
732166
1033
12:13
So what Lauran and I have discovered through our bipartisan friendship
271
733223
3360
12:16
is the possibility that lives in dialogue.
272
736607
2980
12:19
We have chosen to be genuinely curious
273
739611
2342
12:21
about each other's ideas and perspectives
274
741977
2678
12:24
and to be willing to listen to one another even when we disagree.
275
744679
3820
12:28
And by putting aside our ego and our preconceived ideas,
276
748523
3125
12:31
we've opened ourselves up to limitless learning.
277
751672
2563
12:34
And perhaps most importantly for our relationship,
278
754602
2802
12:37
we have made the commitment to each other
279
757428
2032
12:39
that our friendship is way more important
280
759484
2865
12:42
than either of us being right or winning a conversation about politics.
281
762373
4110
12:47
So today, we're asking you to have a conversation.
282
767020
3181
12:50
Talk to someone outside of your political party
283
770225
2267
12:52
who might challenge your thinking.
284
772516
1621
12:54
Make an effort to engage with someone
285
774161
1825
12:56
with whom you might typically avoid a political conversation.
286
776010
2969
12:59
But remember, the goal isn't to win,
287
779003
2865
13:01
the goal is to listen and to understand
288
781892
2638
13:04
and to be open to learning something new.
289
784554
2250
13:07
LA: So let's go back to election night.
290
787587
1963
13:09
As the polls were closing
291
789884
1263
13:11
and it became clear that Trump was going to be our new president,
292
791171
3309
13:14
I was devastated.
293
794504
1198
13:16
I was sad, I was confused,
294
796485
2631
13:19
and I'll be honest -- I was angry.
295
799140
1784
13:21
And then just before midnight,
296
801873
1683
13:23
I received this text message from Caitlin.
297
803580
2357
13:25
[I know this is a hard night for you guys.
298
805961
3372
13:29
We are thinking of you. Love you.]
299
809357
3104
13:32
And where there so easy could have been weeks or months of awkwardness
300
812485
3810
13:36
and unspoken hostility, there was this --
301
816319
2959
13:40
an offering of empathy rooted in friendship.
302
820002
2618
13:43
And I knew, in that moment, that we would make it through this.
303
823554
2953
13:47
CQ: So we must find a way to engage in meaningful conversations
304
827512
3616
13:51
that are going to move us forward as a nation,
305
831152
2352
13:53
and we can no longer wait
306
833528
1421
13:54
for our elected officials to elevate our national discourse.
307
834973
3379
13:58
LA: The challenges ahead are going to require all of us
308
838889
3218
14:02
to participate in a deeper and more meaningful way ...
309
842131
2904
14:05
and it starts with each one of us
310
845770
2278
14:08
building connection through dialogue --
311
848072
2159
14:10
in our relationships, our communities
312
850255
3667
14:13
and as a country.
313
853946
1150
14:15
Thank you.
314
855999
1151
14:17
(Applause)
315
857174
6860
About this website

This site will introduce you to YouTube videos that are useful for learning English. You will see English lessons taught by top-notch teachers from around the world. Double-click on the English subtitles displayed on each video page to play the video from there. The subtitles scroll in sync with the video playback. If you have any comments or requests, please contact us using this contact form.

https://forms.gle/WvT1wiN1qDtmnspy7