How isolation fuels opioid addiction | Rachel Wurzman

71,579 views ・ 2018-11-19

TED


Please double-click on the English subtitles below to play the video.

00:13
What does it mean to be normal?
0
13634
2067
00:16
And what does it mean to be sick?
1
16857
1876
00:21
I've asked myself this question from the time I was about seven,
2
21087
3457
00:24
when I was diagnosed with Tourette syndrome.
3
24568
2523
00:27
Tourette's is a neurological disorder
4
27115
2104
00:29
characterized by stereotyped movements I perform against my will, called tics.
5
29243
5436
00:35
Now, tics are technically involuntary,
6
35524
3015
00:38
in the sense that they occur without any conscious attention
7
38563
3215
00:41
or intention on my part.
8
41802
1600
00:44
But there's a funny thing about how I experience tics.
9
44228
4769
00:49
They feel more unvoluntary than involuntary,
10
49021
4620
00:53
because I still feel like it's me moving my shoulder,
11
53665
2960
00:56
not some external force.
12
56649
1600
00:58
Also, I get this uncomfortable sensation, called premonitory urge,
13
58696
4825
01:03
right before tics happen,
14
63545
1370
01:04
and particularly when I'm trying to resist them.
15
64939
2384
01:07
Now, I imagine most of you out there understand what I'm saying,
16
67633
3048
01:10
but unless you have Tourette's, you probably think you can't relate.
17
70705
3472
01:15
But I bet you can.
18
75776
1266
01:17
So, let's try a little experiment here and see if I can give you
19
77664
3017
01:20
a taste of what my experience feels like.
20
80705
3102
01:23
Alright, ready?
21
83831
1150
01:25
Don't blink.
22
85776
1277
01:27
No, really, don't blink.
23
87077
1611
01:28
And besides dry eyes, what do you feel?
24
88712
3206
01:33
Phantom pressure?
25
93509
1348
01:35
Eyelids tingling?
26
95794
1309
01:37
A need?
27
97945
1150
01:39
Are you holding your breath?
28
99810
1595
01:41
(Laughter)
29
101429
1151
01:42
Aha.
30
102604
1151
01:43
(Laughter)
31
103779
1150
01:47
That's approximately what my tics feels like.
32
107942
3516
01:52
Now, tics and blinking, neurologically speaking, are not the same,
33
112315
3691
01:56
but my point is that you don't have to have Tourette's
34
116030
4548
02:00
to be able to relate to my experience of my premonitory urges,
35
120602
4999
02:05
because your brain can give you similar experiences and feelings.
36
125625
5647
02:12
So, let's shift the conversation from what it means to be normal versus sick
37
132078
5801
02:17
to what it means that a majority of us are both normal and sick.
38
137903
5278
02:24
Because in the final analysis, we're all humans
39
144697
3357
02:28
whose brains provide for a spectrum of experiences.
40
148078
4850
02:34
And everything on that spectrum of human experiences
41
154563
2746
02:37
is ultimately produced by brain systems
42
157333
4363
02:41
that assume a spectrum of different states.
43
161720
2933
02:45
So again, what does it mean to be normal,
44
165744
2675
02:48
and what does it mean to be sick,
45
168443
1960
02:50
when sickness exists on the extreme end of a spectrum of normal?
46
170427
5015
02:57
As both a researcher who studies differences in how individuals' brains
47
177880
3698
03:01
wire and rewire themselves,
48
181602
1770
03:03
and as a Touretter with other related diagnoses,
49
183396
2999
03:06
I have long been fascinated by failures of self-regulation
50
186419
4606
03:11
on the impulsive and compulsive behavioral spectrums.
51
191049
4269
03:15
Because so much of my own experience of my own body
52
195342
4124
03:19
and my own behavior
53
199490
1238
03:20
has existed all over that map.
54
200752
2325
03:25
So with the spotlight on the opioid crisis,
55
205561
4774
03:31
I've really found myself wondering lately:
56
211636
3420
03:35
Where on the spectrum of unvoluntary behavior
57
215080
3616
03:38
do we put something like abusing opioid painkillers or heroin?
58
218720
5147
03:45
By now, we all know that the opioid crisis and epidemic is out of control.
59
225569
5810
03:52
Ninety-one people die every day in this country from overdose.
60
232084
3024
03:55
And between 2002 and 2015,
61
235464
2649
03:58
the number of deaths from heroin increased by a factor of six.
62
238137
3596
04:04
And something about the way that we treat addiction isn't working,
63
244125
4539
04:08
at least not for everyone.
64
248688
1734
04:11
It is a fact that people suffering from addiction
65
251569
3436
04:15
have lost free will
66
255029
1918
04:16
when it comes to their behavior around drugs, alcohol, food
67
256971
6098
04:23
or other reward-system stimulating behaviors.
68
263093
3067
04:26
That addiction is a brain-based disease state
69
266792
4143
04:30
is a medical, neurobiological reality.
70
270959
3063
04:35
But how we relate to that disease --
71
275625
2524
04:38
indeed, how we relate to the concept of disease when it comes to addiction --
72
278173
5356
04:43
makes an enormous difference for how we treat people with addictions.
73
283553
4112
04:49
So, we tend to think of pretty much everything we do as entirely voluntary.
74
289420
5059
04:55
But it turns out that the brain's default state
75
295000
2887
04:57
is really more like a car idling in drive than a car in park.
76
297911
5981
05:04
Some of what we think we choose to do
77
304672
2508
05:07
is actually things that we have become programmed to do
78
307204
4015
05:11
when the brakes are released.
79
311243
1786
05:14
Have you ever joked that your brain was running on autopilot?
80
314950
4134
05:20
Guess what?
81
320196
1150
05:21
It probably was.
82
321744
1309
05:23
OK?
83
323871
1158
05:25
And the brain's autopilot is in a structure called the striatum.
84
325053
5164
05:31
So the striatum detects emotional and sensory motor conditions
85
331903
5712
05:40
and it knows to trigger whatever behavior you have done most often
86
340006
6429
05:46
in the past under those same conditions.
87
346459
2734
05:51
Do you know why I became a neuroscientist?
88
351546
2444
05:55
Because I wanted to learn what made me tick.
89
355540
2371
05:57
(Laughter)
90
357935
2454
06:00
Thank you, thank you.
91
360413
1546
06:01
(Laughter)
92
361983
1263
06:03
I've been wanting to use that one in front of an audience for years.
93
363270
3228
06:06
(Applause)
94
366522
1642
06:08
So in graduate school, I studied genetic factors
95
368188
3255
06:11
that orchestrate wiring to the striatum during development.
96
371467
3734
06:16
And yes, that is my former license plate.
97
376458
3545
06:20
(Laughter)
98
380027
1412
06:21
And for the record, I don't recommend
99
381463
1810
06:23
any PhD student get a license plate with their thesis topic printed on it,
100
383297
4110
06:27
unless they're prepared for their experiments not to work
101
387431
2673
06:30
for the next two years.
102
390128
1171
06:31
(Laughter)
103
391323
1154
06:32
I eventually did figure it out.
104
392501
1607
06:34
So, my experiments were exploring how miswiring in the striatum
105
394132
5413
06:39
relates to compulsive behaviors.
106
399569
2064
06:41
Meaning, behaviors that are coerced
107
401657
2777
06:44
by uncomfortable urges you can't consciously resist.
108
404458
3377
06:48
So I was really excited when my mice developed
109
408165
3952
06:52
this compulsive behavior,
110
412141
2238
06:54
where they were rubbing their faces and they couldn't seem to stop,
111
414403
3246
06:57
even when they were wounding themselves.
112
417673
1928
06:59
OK, excited is the wrong word,
113
419625
2865
07:02
I actually felt terrible for them.
114
422514
2920
07:06
I thought that they had tics, evidence of striatal miswiring.
115
426514
4302
07:11
And they were compulsive,
116
431973
1809
07:13
but it turned out, on further testing,
117
433806
3873
07:17
that these mice showed an aversion to interacting
118
437703
4763
07:22
and getting to know other unfamiliar mice.
119
442490
2067
07:24
Which was unusual, it was unexpected.
120
444581
2044
07:26
The results implied that the striatum,
121
446649
3270
07:29
which, for sure, is involved in compulsive-spectrum disorders,
122
449943
2999
07:32
is also involved in human social connection and our ability to --
123
452966
5162
07:38
not human social connection, but our ability to connect.
124
458152
2961
07:44
So I delved deeper,
125
464387
2087
07:46
into a field called social neuroscience.
126
466498
2825
07:49
And that is a newer, interdisciplinary field,
127
469347
2294
07:51
and there I found reports that linked the striatum
128
471665
2692
07:54
not just to social anomalies in mice,
129
474381
2815
07:57
but also in people.
130
477220
1452
07:59
As it turns out, the social neurochemistry in the striatum
131
479458
5677
08:06
is linked to things you've probably already heard of.
132
486243
4707
08:10
Like oxytocin,
133
490974
1429
08:12
which is that hormone that makes cuddling feel all warm and fuzzy.
134
492427
4175
08:17
But it also implicates signaling at opioid receptors.
135
497475
3608
08:21
There are naturally occurring opioids in your brain
136
501943
2436
08:24
that are deeply linked to social processes.
137
504403
3389
08:30
Experiments with naloxone, which blocks opioid receptors,
138
510754
4739
08:35
show us just how essential this opioid-receptor signaling is
139
515517
5334
08:40
to social interaction.
140
520875
1572
08:45
When people are given naloxone -- it's an ingredient in Narcan,
141
525736
4318
08:50
that reverses opioid overdoses to save lives.
142
530078
3284
08:53
But when it's given to healthy people,
143
533386
2461
08:55
it actually interfered with their ability to feel connected
144
535871
3666
08:59
to people they already knew and cared about.
145
539561
2812
09:03
So, something about not having opioid-receptor binding
146
543275
5881
09:09
makes it difficult for us to feel the rewards of social interaction.
147
549180
3965
09:14
Now, for the interest of time,
148
554270
1492
09:15
I've necessarily gotten rid of some of the scientific details,
149
555786
3008
09:18
but briefly, here's where we're at.
150
558818
2166
09:22
The effects of social disconnection through opioid receptors,
151
562228
3976
09:26
the effects of addictive drugs
152
566228
2286
09:28
and the effects of abnormal neurotransmission
153
568538
2491
09:31
on involuntary movements and compulsive behaviors
154
571053
2857
09:33
all converge in the striatum.
155
573934
2889
09:38
And the striatum and opioid signaling in it
156
578839
3532
09:42
has been deeply linked with loneliness.
157
582395
2888
09:48
When we don't have enough signaling at opioid receptors,
158
588877
3517
09:52
we can feel alone in a room full of people we care about and love, who love us.
159
592418
5713
09:58
Social neuroscientists, like Dr. Cacioppo at the University of Chicago,
160
598774
4509
10:03
have discovered that loneliness is very dangerous.
161
603307
2840
10:06
And it predisposes people
162
606873
1260
10:08
to entire spectrums of physical and mental illnesses.
163
608157
4173
10:16
Think of it like this: when you're at your hungriest,
164
616515
3358
10:19
pretty much any food tastes amazing, right?
165
619897
3206
10:23
So similarly, loneliness creates a hunger in the brain
166
623127
4720
10:27
which neurochemically hypersensitizes our reward system.
167
627871
5192
10:34
And social isolation acts through receptors
168
634355
2953
10:37
for these naturally occurring opioids and other social neurotransmitters
169
637332
3951
10:41
to leave the striatum in a state
170
641307
2429
10:43
where its response to things that signal reward and pleasure
171
643760
4150
10:47
is completely, completely over the top.
172
647934
2947
10:51
And in this state of hypersensitivity,
173
651307
3032
10:54
our brains signal deep dissatisfaction.
174
654363
4214
10:59
We become restless, irritable and impulsive.
175
659976
4775
11:05
And that's pretty much when I want you to keep the bowl of Halloween chocolate
176
665769
3707
11:09
entirely across the room for me, because I will eat it all.
177
669500
2854
11:12
I will.
178
672378
1151
11:13
And that brings up another thing that makes social disconnection
179
673553
3666
11:17
so dangerous.
180
677243
1444
11:19
If we don't have the ability to connect socially,
181
679346
2334
11:21
we are so ravenous for our social neurochemistry to be rebalanced,
182
681704
4841
11:26
we're likely to seek relief from anywhere.
183
686569
2294
11:28
And if that anywhere is opioid painkillers or heroin,
184
688887
5841
11:34
it is going to be a heat-seeking missile for our social reward system.
185
694752
6061
11:42
Is it any wonder people in today's world are becoming addicted so easily?
186
702601
5704
11:51
Social isolation --
187
711022
1817
11:56
excuse me --
188
716926
1150
11:59
contributes to relapse.
189
719736
1467
12:01
Studies have shown that people who tend to avoid relapse
190
721953
4127
12:06
tend to be people who have broad, reciprocal social relationships
191
726104
4799
12:10
where they can be of service to each other,
192
730927
2029
12:12
where they can be helpful.
193
732980
1264
12:14
Being of service lets people connect.
194
734268
1808
12:18
So --
195
738101
1150
12:21
if we don't have the ability to authentically connect,
196
741863
5402
12:27
our society increasingly lacks this ability to authentically connect
197
747289
4252
12:33
and experience things that are transcendent and beyond ourselves.
198
753101
4254
12:37
We used to get this transcendence
199
757379
1598
12:39
from a feeling of belonging to our families and our communities.
200
759001
3213
12:42
But everywhere, communities are changing.
201
762238
3074
12:45
And social and economic disintegration is making this harder and harder.
202
765800
6561
12:54
I'm not the only person to point out
203
774414
2556
12:56
that the areas in the country most economically hard hit,
204
776994
3444
13:00
where people feel most desolate about their life's meaning,
205
780462
3470
13:03
are also the places
206
783956
2144
13:06
where there have been communities most ravaged by opioids.
207
786124
6554
13:14
Social isolation acts through the brain's reward system
208
794284
3468
13:17
to make this state of affairs literally painful.
209
797776
3000
13:21
So perhaps it's this pain, this loneliness,
210
801720
4310
13:26
this despondence
211
806054
2984
13:29
that's driving so many of us to connect with whatever we can.
212
809062
3378
13:33
Like food.
213
813434
1150
13:35
Like handheld electronics.
214
815757
1800
13:38
And for too many people, to drugs like heroin and fentanyl.
215
818360
3508
13:41
I know someone who overdosed, who was revived by Narcan,
216
821892
3733
13:46
and she was mostly angry that she wasn't simply allowed to die.
217
826753
3682
13:50
Imagine for a second how that feels, that state of hopelessness, OK?
218
830459
4198
13:55
But the striatum is also a source of hope.
219
835959
4029
14:00
Because the striatum gives us a clue of how to bring people back.
220
840012
3683
14:05
So, remember that the striatum is our autopilot,
221
845560
3096
14:08
running our behaviors on habit,
222
848680
1562
14:10
and it's possible to rewire, to reprogram that autopilot,
223
850266
4367
14:14
but it involves neuroplasticity.
224
854657
1681
14:16
So, neuroplasticity is the ability of brains
225
856362
2723
14:19
to reprogram themselves,
226
859109
2762
14:21
and rewire themselves, so we can learn new things.
227
861895
2484
14:24
And maybe you've heard the classic adage of plasticity:
228
864403
2587
14:27
neurons that fire together, wire together.
229
867014
2800
14:30
Right?
230
870323
1184
14:31
So we need to practice social connective behaviors
231
871531
4308
14:35
instead of compulsive behaviors, when we're lonely,
232
875863
3103
14:38
when we are cued to remember our drug.
233
878990
3738
14:45
We need neuronally firing repeated experiences
234
885371
4087
14:49
in order for the striatum to undergo that necessary neuroplasticity
235
889482
3674
14:53
that allows it to take that "go find heroin" autopilot offline.
236
893180
6000
14:59
And what the convergence of social neuroscience, addiction
237
899204
4849
15:04
and compulsive-spectrum disorders in the striatum suggests
238
904077
2794
15:06
is that it's not simply enough
239
906895
1706
15:08
to teach the striatum healthier responses to compulsive urges.
240
908625
3015
15:12
We need social impulses to replace drug-cued compulsive behaviors,
241
912038
5769
15:17
because we need to rebalance, neurochemically, our social reward system.
242
917831
6214
15:24
And unless that happens,
243
924069
1165
15:25
we're going to be left in a state of craving.
244
925258
2663
15:28
No matter what besides our drug we repeatedly practice doing.
245
928331
3476
15:37
I believe that the solution to the opioid crisis
246
937539
4857
15:42
is to explore how social and psychospiritual interventions
247
942420
3625
15:46
can act as neurotechnologies in circuits
248
946069
3921
15:50
that process social and drug-induced rewards.
249
950014
3392
15:54
One possibility is to create and study scalable tools
250
954783
5111
15:59
for people to connect with one another
251
959918
2485
16:02
over a mutual interest
252
962427
1602
16:04
in recovery through psychospiritual practices.
253
964053
2167
16:06
And as such, psychospiritual practice could involve anything
254
966244
3262
16:09
from people getting together as megafans of touring jam bands,
255
969530
3484
16:14
or parkour jams, featuring shared experiences of vulnerability
256
974959
4016
16:18
and personal growth,
257
978999
1190
16:20
or more conventional things, like recovery yoga meetups,
258
980213
3105
16:23
or meetings centered around more traditional conceptions
259
983342
2866
16:26
of spiritual experiences.
260
986232
1848
16:28
But whatever it is,
261
988104
2206
16:30
it needs to activate
262
990334
2600
16:32
all of the neurotransmitter systems in the striatum
263
992958
2921
16:35
that are involved in processing social connection.
264
995903
2777
16:41
Social media can't go deep enough for this.
265
1001411
2364
16:43
Social media doesn't so much encourage us to share,
266
1003799
3278
16:47
as it does to compare.
267
1007101
1587
16:48
It's the difference between having superficial small talk with someone
268
1008712
4500
16:53
and authentic, deeply connected conversation with eye contact.
269
1013236
4535
16:58
And stigma also keeps us separate.
270
1018442
3291
17:01
There's a lot of evidence that it keeps us sick.
271
1021757
3427
17:05
And stigma often makes it safer for addicts to connect with other addicts.
272
1025806
4240
17:10
But recovery groups centered around reestablishing social connections
273
1030656
4793
17:15
could certainly be inclusive of people who are seeking recovery
274
1035473
4885
17:20
for a range of mental health problems.
275
1040382
2960
17:24
My point is, when we connect around what's broken,
276
1044093
3822
17:29
we connect as human beings.
277
1049902
2928
17:33
We heal ourselves from the compulsive self-destruction
278
1053998
5926
17:39
that was our response to the pain of disconnection.
279
1059948
3399
17:44
When we think of neuropsychiatric illnesses as a spectrum of phenomenon
280
1064180
6191
17:50
that are part of what make us human,
281
1070395
2865
17:53
then we remove the otherness of people who struggle with self-destruction.
282
1073284
3563
17:57
We remove the stigma
283
1077307
3405
18:01
between doctors and patients and caregivers.
284
1081924
3462
18:05
We put the question of what it means to be normal versus sick
285
1085966
5333
18:11
back on the spectrum of the human condition.
286
1091323
3000
18:14
And it is on that spectrum where we can all connect
287
1094831
5010
18:19
and seek healing together, for all of our struggles with humanness.
288
1099865
4142
18:24
Thank you for letting me share.
289
1104873
1563
18:26
(Applause)
290
1106460
4055
About this website

This site will introduce you to YouTube videos that are useful for learning English. You will see English lessons taught by top-notch teachers from around the world. Double-click on the English subtitles displayed on each video page to play the video from there. The subtitles scroll in sync with the video playback. If you have any comments or requests, please contact us using this contact form.

https://forms.gle/WvT1wiN1qDtmnspy7