How judges can show respect | Victoria Pratt

79,765 views ・ 2017-12-01

TED


Please double-click on the English subtitles below to play the video.

00:13
"Judge, I want to tell you something. I want to tell you something.
0
13000
3936
00:16
I been watching you
1
16960
1736
00:18
and you're not two-faced.
2
18720
1896
00:20
You treat everybody the same."
3
20640
2360
00:23
That was said to me by a transgender prostitute
4
23680
3416
00:27
who before I had gotten on the bench
5
27120
2256
00:29
had fired her public defender,
6
29400
2536
00:31
insulted the court officer
7
31960
1976
00:33
and yelled at the person sitting next to her,
8
33960
2136
00:36
"I don't know what you're looking at. I look better than the girl you're with."
9
36120
3736
00:39
(Laughter)
10
39880
1696
00:41
She said this to me
11
41600
1896
00:43
after I said her male name low enough
12
43520
2536
00:46
so that it could be picked up by the record,
13
46080
2936
00:49
but I said her female name loud enough
14
49040
2056
00:51
so that she could walk down the aisle towards counselor's table with dignity.
15
51120
4640
00:56
This is procedural justice, also known as procedural fairness,
16
56280
3696
01:00
at its best.
17
60000
1576
01:01
You see, I am the daughter of an African-American garbageman
18
61600
3696
01:05
who was born in Harlem
19
65320
1256
01:06
and spent his summers in the segregated South.
20
66600
3016
01:09
Soy la hija de una peluquera dominicana.
21
69640
2776
01:12
I do that to make sure you're still paying attention.
22
72440
2496
01:14
(Laughter)
23
74960
1336
01:16
I'm the daughter of a Dominican beautician
24
76319
2257
01:18
who came to this country for a better life for her unborn children.
25
78600
3816
01:22
My parents taught me, you treat everyone you meet with dignity and respect,
26
82440
4016
01:26
no matter how they look, no matter how they dress,
27
86480
2416
01:28
no matter how they spoke.
28
88920
2256
01:31
You see, the principles of fairness
29
91200
2616
01:33
were taught to me at an early age,
30
93840
3736
01:37
and unbeknownst to me, it would be the most important lesson
31
97600
2936
01:40
that I carried with me to the Newark Municipal Court bench.
32
100560
3816
01:44
And because I was dragged off the playground
33
104400
2816
01:47
at the early age of 10 to translate for family members
34
107240
3736
01:51
as they began to migrate to the United States,
35
111000
3376
01:54
I understand how daunting it can be for a person, a novice,
36
114400
5136
01:59
to navigate any government system.
37
119560
2480
02:02
Every day across America and around the globe,
38
122920
2896
02:05
people encounter our courts,
39
125840
2136
02:08
and it is a place that is foreign, intimidating
40
128000
3856
02:11
and often hostile towards them.
41
131880
2240
02:15
They are confused about the nature of their charges,
42
135240
3896
02:19
annoyed about their encounters with the police
43
139160
3216
02:22
and facing consequences that might impact their relationships, their finances
44
142400
4936
02:27
and even their liberty.
45
147360
1976
02:29
Let me paint a picture for you
46
149360
1456
02:30
of what it's like for the average person who encounters our courts.
47
150840
3560
02:35
First, they're annoyed as they're probed going through court security.
48
155520
4856
02:40
They finally get through court security, they walk around the building,
49
160400
3376
02:43
they ask different people the same question
50
163800
3016
02:46
and get different answers.
51
166840
1480
02:49
When they finally get to where they're supposed to be,
52
169200
2576
02:51
it gets really bad when they encounter the courts.
53
171800
2600
02:55
What would you think if I told you
54
175280
1656
02:56
that you could improve people's court experience,
55
176960
3136
03:00
increase their compliance with the law
56
180120
2280
03:03
and court orders,
57
183680
1456
03:05
all the while increasing the public's trust
58
185160
2816
03:08
in the justice system
59
188000
1256
03:09
with a simple idea?
60
189280
1560
03:11
Well, that simple idea is procedural justice
61
191520
3120
03:15
and it's a concept that says
62
195960
1496
03:17
that if people perceive they are treated fairly
63
197480
2496
03:20
and with dignity and respect,
64
200000
2176
03:22
they'll obey the law.
65
202200
1440
03:24
Well, that's what Yale professor Tom Tyler found
66
204320
2656
03:27
when he began to study as far back in the '70s
67
207000
3376
03:30
why people obey the law.
68
210400
1920
03:33
He found that if people see the justice system
69
213080
2856
03:35
as a legitimate authority to impose rules and regulations,
70
215960
4016
03:40
they would follow them.
71
220000
1896
03:41
His research concluded
72
221920
1896
03:43
that people would be satisfied
73
223840
3496
03:47
with the judge's rulings,
74
227360
1936
03:49
even when the judge ruled against them,
75
229320
2016
03:51
if they perceived that they were treated fairly
76
231360
2576
03:53
and with dignity and respect.
77
233960
1880
03:56
And that perception of fairness begins with what?
78
236440
3016
03:59
Begins with how judges speak to court participants.
79
239480
4200
04:04
Now, being a judge
80
244960
1376
04:06
is sometimes like having a reserve seat to a tragic reality show
81
246360
5976
04:12
that has no commercial interruptions
82
252360
2136
04:14
and no season finale.
83
254520
1560
04:17
It's true.
84
257480
1416
04:18
People come before me handcuffed,
85
258920
2656
04:21
drug-sick, depressed, hungry
86
261600
3016
04:24
and mentally ill.
87
264640
2040
04:28
When I saw that their need for help
88
268120
3096
04:31
was greater than my fear of appearing vulnerable on the bench,
89
271240
3736
04:35
I realized that not only did I need to do something,
90
275000
3056
04:38
but that in fact I could do something.
91
278080
2200
04:41
The good news is is that the principles of procedural justice are easy
92
281320
3776
04:45
and can be implemented as quickly as tomorrow.
93
285120
3056
04:48
The even better news, that it can be done for free.
94
288200
2416
04:50
(Laughter)
95
290640
1016
04:51
The first principle is voice.
96
291680
1976
04:53
Give people an opportunity to speak,
97
293680
2176
04:55
even when you're not going to let them speak.
98
295880
2136
04:58
Explain it.
99
298040
1256
04:59
"Sir, I'm not letting you speak right now.
100
299320
2576
05:01
You don't have an attorney.
101
301920
1336
05:03
I don't want you to say anything that's going to hurt your case."
102
303280
3056
05:06
For me, assigning essays to defendants
103
306360
1856
05:08
has been a tremendous way of giving them voice.
104
308240
2880
05:12
I recently gave an 18-year-old college student an essay.
105
312440
3856
05:16
He lamented his underage drinking charge.
106
316320
3160
05:20
As he stood before me reading his essay,
107
320120
2056
05:22
his voice cracking and his hands trembling,
108
322200
2496
05:24
he said that he worried that he had become an alcoholic like his mom,
109
324720
4136
05:28
who had died a couple of months prior due to alcohol-related liver disease.
110
328880
4920
05:34
You see, assigning a letter to my father, a letter to my son,
111
334480
3856
05:38
"If I knew then what I know now ..."
112
338360
2296
05:40
"If I believed one positive thing about myself,
113
340680
2616
05:43
how would my life be different?"
114
343320
1816
05:45
gives the person an opportunity to be introspective,
115
345160
3696
05:48
go on the inside,
116
348880
1296
05:50
which is where all the answers are anyway.
117
350200
2376
05:52
But it also gives them an opportunity
118
352600
1816
05:54
to share something with the court that goes beyond their criminal record
119
354440
3976
05:58
and their charges.
120
358440
1240
06:01
The next principle is neutrality.
121
361080
2696
06:03
When increasing public trust in the justice system,
122
363800
3296
06:07
neutrality is paramount.
123
367120
1776
06:08
The judge cannot be perceived to be favoring one side over the other.
124
368920
4896
06:13
The judge has to make a conscious decision not to say things like,
125
373840
3976
06:17
"my officer," "my prosecutor," "my defense attorney."
126
377840
3856
06:21
And this is challenging when we work in environments
127
381720
2776
06:24
where you have people assigned to your courts,
128
384520
2536
06:27
the same people coming in and out of your courts as well.
129
387080
3280
06:31
When I think of neutrality,
130
391120
1456
06:32
I'm reminded of when I was a new Rutgers Law grad
131
392600
4096
06:36
and freshly minted attorney,
132
396720
2056
06:38
and I entered an arbitration and I was greeted by two grey-haired men
133
398800
4496
06:43
who were joking about the last game of golf they played together
134
403320
3816
06:47
and planning future social outings.
135
407160
2296
06:49
I knew my client couldn't get a fair shot in that forum.
136
409480
3520
06:54
The next principle is understand.
137
414000
3416
06:57
It is critical that court participants understand the process,
138
417440
5256
07:02
the consequences of the process
139
422720
2376
07:05
and what's expected of them.
140
425120
2056
07:07
I like to say that legalese is the language we use to confuse.
141
427200
5296
07:12
(Laughter)
142
432520
1056
07:13
I am keenly aware that the people who appear before me,
143
433600
2736
07:16
many of them have very little education
144
436360
2576
07:18
and English is often their second language.
145
438960
2536
07:21
So I speak plain English in court.
146
441520
2456
07:24
A great example of this was when I was a young judge --
147
444000
2616
07:26
oh no, I mean younger judge.
148
446640
1896
07:28
(Laughter)
149
448560
1016
07:29
When I was a younger judge, a senior judge comes to me,
150
449600
2616
07:32
gives me a script and says,
151
452240
1336
07:33
"If you think somebody has mental health issues,
152
453600
2256
07:35
ask them these questions and you can get your evaluation."
153
455880
2736
07:38
So the first time I saw someone
154
458640
1536
07:40
who had what I thought was a mental health issue,
155
460200
2336
07:42
I went for my script and I started to ask questions.
156
462560
2456
07:45
"Um, sir, do you take psycho -- um, psychotrop --
157
465040
3096
07:48
psychotropic medication?"
158
468160
1640
07:50
"Nope."
159
470480
1200
07:52
"Uh, sir, have you treated with a psychiatrist before?"
160
472400
3280
07:56
"Nope."
161
476560
1216
07:57
But it was obvious that the person was suffering from mental illness.
162
477800
4016
08:01
One day, in my frustration, I decided to scrap the script and ask one question.
163
481840
3736
08:05
"Ma'am, do you take medication to clear your mind?"
164
485600
2416
08:08
"Yeah, judge, I take Haldol for my schizophrenia,
165
488040
2616
08:10
Xanax for my anxiety."
166
490680
1960
08:13
The question works even when it doesn't.
167
493240
2656
08:15
"Mr. L, do you take medication to clear your mind?"
168
495920
2736
08:18
"No, judge, I don't take no medication to clear my mind.
169
498680
2656
08:21
I take medication to stop the voices in my head,
170
501360
2416
08:23
but my mind is fine."
171
503800
1256
08:25
(Laughter)
172
505080
1576
08:26
You see, once people understand the question,
173
506680
3056
08:29
they can give you valuable information
174
509760
1856
08:31
that allows the court to make meaningful decisions
175
511640
2376
08:34
about the cases that are before them.
176
514040
1960
08:36
The last principle is respect,
177
516920
2616
08:39
that without it none of the other principles can work.
178
519560
3856
08:43
Now, respect can be as simple as,
179
523440
2736
08:46
"Good afternoon, sir." "Good morning, ma'am."
180
526200
2280
08:49
It's looking the person in the eye who is standing before you,
181
529000
3376
08:52
especially when you're sentencing them.
182
532400
1880
08:55
It's when I say, "Um, how are you doing today?
183
535159
2177
08:57
And what's going on with you?"
184
537360
1456
08:58
And not as a greeting,
185
538840
1256
09:00
but as someone who is actually interested in the response.
186
540120
2720
09:03
Respect is the difference between saying,
187
543840
2896
09:06
"Ma'am, are you having difficulty
188
546760
1616
09:08
understanding the information in the paperwork?"
189
548400
2376
09:10
versus, "You can read and write, can't you?"
190
550800
2456
09:13
when you've realized there's a literacy issue.
191
553280
3216
09:16
And the good thing about respect is that it's contagious.
192
556520
2696
09:19
People see you being respectful to other folks
193
559240
2296
09:21
and they impute that respect to themselves.
194
561560
2376
09:23
You see, that's what the transgender prostitute was telling me.
195
563960
3696
09:27
I'm judging you just as much as you think you may be judging me.
196
567680
3160
09:31
Now, I am not telling you what I think,
197
571480
2416
09:33
I am telling you what I have lived,
198
573920
2056
09:36
using procedural justice to change the culture at my courthouse
199
576000
4536
09:40
and in the courtroom.
200
580560
1520
09:42
After sitting comfortably for seven months
201
582640
3056
09:45
as a traffic court judge,
202
585720
1936
09:47
I was advised that I was being moved to the criminal court,
203
587680
4136
09:51
Part Two, criminal courtroom.
204
591840
3176
09:55
Now, I need you to understand,
205
595040
1616
09:56
this was not good news.
206
596680
2216
09:58
(Laughter)
207
598920
1016
09:59
It was not.
208
599960
1256
10:01
Part Two was known as the worst courtroom in the city,
209
601240
3376
10:04
some folks would even say in the state.
210
604640
2536
10:07
It was your typical urban courtroom with revolving door justice,
211
607200
4656
10:11
you know, your regular lineup of low-level offenders --
212
611880
2616
10:14
you know, the low-hanging fruit,
213
614520
2216
10:16
the drug-addicted prostitute,
214
616760
2416
10:19
the mentally ill homeless person with quality-of-life tickets,
215
619200
4136
10:23
the high school dropout petty drug dealer and the misguided young people --
216
623360
5256
10:28
you know, those folks doing a life sentence
217
628640
2456
10:31
30 days at a time.
218
631120
1440
10:34
Fortunately, the City of Newark decided that Newarkers deserved better,
219
634120
3776
10:37
and they partnered with the Center for Court Innovation
220
637920
2736
10:40
and the New Jersey Judiciary
221
640680
1416
10:42
to create Newark Community Solutions,
222
642120
2576
10:44
a community court program
223
644720
2096
10:46
that provided alternative sanctions.
224
646840
3016
10:49
This means now a judge
225
649880
2456
10:52
can sentence a defendant to punishment with assistance.
226
652360
3816
10:56
So a defendant who would otherwise get a jail sentence
227
656200
2576
10:58
would now be able to get individual counseling sessions,
228
658800
2656
11:01
group counseling sessions as well as community giveback,
229
661480
2696
11:04
which is what we call community service.
230
664200
1920
11:06
The only problem is that this wonderful program
231
666920
2616
11:09
was now coming to Newark and was going to be housed where?
232
669560
2936
11:12
Part Two criminal courtroom.
233
672520
2456
11:15
And the attitudes there were terrible.
234
675000
2776
11:17
And the reason that the attitudes were terrible there
235
677800
2496
11:20
was because everyone who was sent there
236
680320
1896
11:22
understood they were being sent there as punishment.
237
682240
2456
11:24
The officers who were facing disciplinary actions at times,
238
684720
3616
11:28
the public defender and prosecutor
239
688360
2456
11:30
felt like they were doing a 30-day jail sentence on their rotation,
240
690840
4176
11:35
the judges understood they were being hazed
241
695040
2896
11:37
just like a college sorority or fraternity.
242
697960
2840
11:42
I was once told that an attorney who worked there
243
702160
2336
11:44
referred to the defendants as "the scum of the earth"
244
704520
4416
11:48
and then had to represent them.
245
708960
2256
11:51
I would hear things from folks like,
246
711240
1736
11:53
"Oh, how could you work with those people? They're so nasty.
247
713000
2856
11:55
You're a judge, not a social worker."
248
715880
2296
11:58
But the reality is that as a society, we criminalize social ills,
249
718200
4456
12:02
then sent people to a judge and say, "Do something."
250
722680
2600
12:06
I decided that I was going to lead by example.
251
726000
2816
12:08
So my first foray into the approach came when a 60-something-year-old man
252
728840
4016
12:12
appeared before me handcuffed.
253
732880
2056
12:14
His head was lowered and his body was showing the signs of drug withdrawal.
254
734960
4776
12:19
I asked him how long he had been addicted, and he said, "30 years."
255
739760
3816
12:23
And I asked him, "Do you have any kids?"
256
743600
2360
12:26
And he said, "Yeah, I have a 32-year-old son."
257
746600
2496
12:29
And I said, "Oh, so you've never had the opportunity
258
749120
3096
12:32
to be a father to your son because of your addiction."
259
752240
3160
12:36
He began to cry.
260
756560
1360
12:38
I said, "You know what, I'm going to let you go home,
261
758800
2496
12:41
and you'll come back in two weeks,
262
761320
1656
12:43
and when you come back, we'll give you some assistance for your addiction."
263
763000
3536
12:46
Surprisingly, two weeks passed and he was sitting the courtroom.
264
766560
3240
12:50
When he came up, he said, "Judge, I came back to court
265
770480
2576
12:53
because you showed me more love than I had for myself."
266
773080
3456
12:56
And I thought, my God, he heard love from the bench?
267
776560
3656
13:00
I could do this all day.
268
780240
1416
13:01
(Laughter)
269
781680
1016
13:02
Because the reality is that when the court behaves differently,
270
782720
3136
13:05
then naturally people respond differently.
271
785880
2696
13:08
The court becomes a place you can go to for assistance,
272
788600
3056
13:11
like the 60-something-year-old schizophrenic homeless woman
273
791680
3736
13:15
who was in distress
274
795440
1416
13:16
and fighting with the voices in her head,
275
796880
1976
13:18
and barges into court, and screams, "Judge!
276
798880
2376
13:21
I just came by to see how you were doing."
277
801280
2976
13:24
I had been monitoring her case for a couple of months,
278
804280
2696
13:27
her compliance with her medication,
279
807000
2016
13:29
and had just closed out her case a couple of weeks ago.
280
809040
2976
13:32
On this day she needed help,
281
812040
2616
13:34
and she came to court.
282
814680
1256
13:35
And after four hours of coaxing by the judge,
283
815960
3416
13:39
the police officers and the staff,
284
819400
2296
13:41
she is convinced to get into the ambulance
285
821720
2816
13:44
that will take her to crisis unit
286
824560
2096
13:46
so that she can get her medication.
287
826680
1840
13:49
People become connected to their community
288
829400
2616
13:52
when the court changes,
289
832040
2136
13:54
like the 50-something-year-old man
290
834200
2416
13:56
who told me, "Community service was terrible, Judge.
291
836640
2496
13:59
I had to clean the park, and it was full of empty heroin envelopes,
292
839160
3176
14:02
and the kids had to play there."
293
842360
2216
14:04
As he wrung his hands, he confessed,
294
844600
3096
14:07
"Judge, I realized that it was my fault,
295
847720
2416
14:10
because I used that same park to get high,
296
850160
3136
14:13
and before you sent me there to do community service,
297
853320
2496
14:15
I had never gone to the park when I wasn't high,
298
855840
2376
14:18
so I never noticed the children playing there."
299
858240
3400
14:22
Every addict in the courtroom lowered their head.
300
862120
2976
14:25
Who better to teach that lesson?
301
865120
1840
14:28
It helps the court reset its relationship with the community,
302
868600
5216
14:33
like with the 20-something-year-old guy
303
873840
2256
14:36
who gets a job interview through the court program.
304
876120
3656
14:39
He gets a job interview at an office cleaning company,
305
879800
2576
14:42
and he comes back to court to proudly say,
306
882400
2216
14:44
"Judge, I even worked in my suit after the interview,
307
884640
4696
14:49
because I wanted the guy to see how bad I wanted the job."
308
889360
3400
14:54
It's what happens when a person in authority
309
894400
3656
14:58
treats you with dignity and respect,
310
898080
2376
15:00
like the 40-something-year-old guy who struts down the aisle
311
900480
3296
15:03
and says, "Judge, do you notice anything different?"
312
903800
2776
15:06
And when I look up,
313
906600
1336
15:07
he's pointing at his new teeth
314
907960
2416
15:10
that he was able to get after getting a referral from the program,
315
910400
3336
15:13
but he was able to get them to replace the old teeth
316
913760
3376
15:17
that he lost as a result of years of heroin addiction.
317
917160
3816
15:21
When he looks in the mirror,
318
921000
1576
15:22
now he sees somebody who is worth saving.
319
922600
3056
15:25
You see, I have a dream
320
925680
1976
15:27
and that dream is that judges will use these tools
321
927680
4096
15:31
to revolutionize the communities that they serve.
322
931800
3216
15:35
Now, these tools are not miracle cure-alls,
323
935040
2736
15:37
but they get us light-years closer to where we want to be,
324
937800
3296
15:41
and where we want to be is a place that people enter our halls of justice
325
941120
4416
15:45
and believe they will be treated with dignity and respect
326
945560
2816
15:48
and know that justice will be served there.
327
948400
3080
15:52
Imagine that, a simple idea.
328
952040
3136
15:55
Thank you.
329
955200
1216
15:56
(Applause)
330
956440
6320
About this website

This site will introduce you to YouTube videos that are useful for learning English. You will see English lessons taught by top-notch teachers from around the world. Double-click on the English subtitles displayed on each video page to play the video from there. The subtitles scroll in sync with the video playback. If you have any comments or requests, please contact us using this contact form.

https://forms.gle/WvT1wiN1qDtmnspy7