The lies our culture tells us about what matters --- and a better way to live | David Brooks

2,153,085 views

2019-07-03 ・ TED


New videos

The lies our culture tells us about what matters --- and a better way to live | David Brooks

2,153,085 views ・ 2019-07-03

TED


Please double-click on the English subtitles below to play the video.

00:12
So, we all have bad seasons in life.
0
12911
2108
00:15
And I had one in 2013.
1
15754
1920
00:18
My marriage had just ended,
2
18373
1346
00:19
and I was humiliated by that failed commitment.
3
19743
2652
00:22
My kids had left home for college or were leaving.
4
22419
2802
00:26
I grew up mostly in the conservative movement,
5
26045
2323
00:28
but conservatism had changed,
6
28392
1600
00:30
so I lost a lot of those friends, too.
7
30016
1992
00:32
And so what I did is, I lived alone in an apartment,
8
32441
2989
00:35
and I just worked.
9
35454
1200
00:37
If you opened the kitchen drawers where there should have been utensils,
10
37417
3413
00:40
there were Post-it notes.
11
40854
1523
00:42
If you opened the other drawers where there should have been plates,
12
42916
3215
00:46
I had envelopes.
13
46155
1150
00:47
I had work friends, weekday friends, but I didn't have weekend friends.
14
47885
3397
00:51
And so my weekends were these long, howling silences.
15
51942
3600
00:56
And I was lonely.
16
56268
1372
00:58
And loneliness, unexpectedly, came to me in the form of --
17
58395
3573
01:02
it felt like fear, a burning in my stomach.
18
62399
2849
01:05
And it felt a little like drunkenness,
19
65272
2681
01:07
just making bad decisions, just fluidity, lack of solidity.
20
67977
4930
01:13
And the painful part of that moment was the awareness
21
73911
3266
01:17
that the emptiness in my apartment was just reflective of the emptiness
22
77201
3403
01:20
in myself,
23
80628
1599
01:22
and that I had fallen for some of the lies that our culture tells us.
24
82251
3727
01:27
The first lie is that career success is fulfilling.
25
87196
3409
01:30
I've had a fair bit of career success,
26
90629
1837
01:32
and I've found that it helps me avoid the shame I would feel
27
92490
2838
01:35
if I felt myself a failure,
28
95352
1674
01:37
but it hasn't given me any positive good.
29
97050
2531
01:40
The second lie is I can make myself happy,
30
100201
3596
01:44
that if I just win one more victory,
31
104484
2080
01:46
lose 15 pounds, do a little more yoga,
32
106588
3491
01:50
I'll get happy.
33
110103
1150
01:51
And that's the lie of self-sufficiency.
34
111743
2318
01:54
But as anybody on their deathbed will tell you,
35
114419
2682
01:57
the things that make people happy is the deep relationships of life,
36
117125
3264
02:00
the losing of self-sufficiency.
37
120413
2067
02:03
The third lie is the lie of the meritocracy.
38
123804
2667
02:07
The message of the meritocracy is you are what you accomplish.
39
127591
3199
02:11
The myth of the meritocracy is you can earn dignity
40
131133
2467
02:13
by attaching yourself to prestigious brands.
41
133624
2610
02:16
The emotion of the meritocracy is conditional love,
42
136258
2805
02:19
you can "earn" your way to love.
43
139087
1855
02:20
The anthropology of the meritocracy is you're not a soul to be purified,
44
140966
3421
02:24
you're a set of skills to be maximized.
45
144411
2468
02:26
And the evil of the meritocracy
46
146903
1849
02:28
is that people who've achieved a little more than others
47
148776
2658
02:31
are actually worth a little more than others.
48
151458
2286
02:34
And so the wages of sin are sin.
49
154141
1863
02:36
And my sins were the sins of omission--
50
156815
1884
02:38
not reaching out, failing to show up for my friends,
51
158723
2468
02:41
evasion, avoiding conflict.
52
161215
1515
02:43
And the weird thing was that as I was falling into the valley --
53
163560
3128
02:46
it was a valley of disconnection --
54
166712
1704
02:48
a lot of other people were doing that, too.
55
168440
2034
02:51
And that's sort of the secret to my career;
56
171014
2009
02:53
a lot of the things that happen to me
57
173047
1773
02:54
are always happening to a lot of other people.
58
174844
2158
02:57
I'm a very average person with above average communication skills.
59
177026
3194
03:00
(Laughter)
60
180244
1103
03:01
And so I was detached.
61
181371
1466
03:03
And at the same time, a lot of other people were detached
62
183252
3262
03:06
and isolated and fragmented from each other.
63
186538
2515
03:09
Thirty-five percent of Americans over 45 are chronically lonely.
64
189077
3080
03:12
Only eight percent of Americans report having meaningful conversation
65
192181
3341
03:15
with their neighbors.
66
195546
1150
03:16
Only 32 percent of Americans say they trust their neighbors,
67
196720
2825
03:19
and only 18 percent of millennials.
68
199569
2254
03:21
The fastest-growing political party is unaffiliated.
69
201847
2441
03:24
The fastest-growing religious movement is unaffiliated.
70
204312
2587
03:26
Depression rates are rising, mental health problems are rising.
71
206923
2976
03:29
The suicide rate has risen 30 percent since 1999.
72
209923
3241
03:33
For teen suicides over the last several years,
73
213188
2176
03:35
the suicide rate has risen by 70 percent.
74
215388
2659
03:39
Forty-five thousand Americans kill themselves every year;
75
219249
2675
03:41
72,000 die from opioid addictions;
76
221948
2230
03:44
life expectancy is falling, not rising.
77
224202
3349
03:48
So what I mean to tell you, I flew out here to say
78
228985
2587
03:51
that we have an economic crisis, we have environmental crisis,
79
231596
2928
03:54
we have a political crisis.
80
234548
1365
03:55
We also have a social and relational crisis;
81
235937
2079
03:58
we're in the valley.
82
238040
1339
03:59
We're fragmented from each other,
83
239403
1603
04:01
we've got cascades of lies coming out of Washington ...
84
241030
2592
04:03
We're in the valley.
85
243646
1333
04:05
And so I've spent the last five years --
86
245466
1977
04:07
how do you get out of a valley?
87
247467
1514
04:09
The Greeks used to say, "You suffer your way to wisdom."
88
249356
3113
04:13
And from that dark period where I started, I've had a few realizations.
89
253006
3660
04:17
The first is, freedom sucks.
90
257228
2921
04:20
Economic freedom is OK, political freedom is great,
91
260998
2674
04:23
social freedom sucks.
92
263696
1801
04:26
The unrooted man is the adrift man.
93
266036
2327
04:28
The unrooted man is the unremembered man, because he's uncommitted to things.
94
268387
3983
04:32
Freedom is not an ocean you want to swim in,
95
272776
3534
04:36
it's a river you want to get across,
96
276334
1730
04:38
so you can commit and plant yourself on the other side.
97
278088
2666
04:41
The second thing I learned
98
281270
1659
04:42
is that when you have one of those bad moments in life,
99
282953
2596
04:45
you can either be broken,
100
285573
1295
04:46
or you can be broken open.
101
286892
1539
04:48
And we all know people who are broken.
102
288905
1826
04:50
They've endured some pain or grief, they get smaller,
103
290755
2516
04:53
they get angrier, resentful, they lash out.
104
293295
2380
04:55
As the saying is,
105
295699
1155
04:56
"Pain that is not transformed gets transmitted."
106
296878
2698
04:59
But other people are broken open.
107
299927
1829
05:03
Suffering's great power is that it's an interruption of life.
108
303125
3101
05:06
It reminds you you're not the person you thought you were.
109
306250
2769
05:09
The theologian Paul Tillich said
110
309043
1537
05:10
what suffering does is it carves through what you thought was the floor
111
310604
3417
05:14
of the basement of your soul,
112
314045
1383
05:15
and it carves through that, revealing a cavity below,
113
315452
2510
05:17
and it carves through that, revealing a cavity below.
114
317986
2492
05:20
You realize there are depths of yourself you never anticipated,
115
320502
3009
05:23
and only spiritual and relational food will fill those depths.
116
323535
2951
05:28
And when you get down there, you get out of the head of the ego
117
328173
2968
05:31
and you get into the heart,
118
331165
1682
05:32
the desiring heart.
119
332871
1762
05:34
The idea that what we really yearn for is longing and love for another,
120
334657
3631
05:38
the kind of thing that Louis de Bernières described in his book,
121
338312
3046
05:41
"Captain Corelli's Mandolin."
122
341382
1898
05:43
He had an old guy talking to his daughter
123
343304
1979
05:45
about his relationship with his late wife,
124
345307
2018
05:47
and the old guy says,
125
347349
1387
05:48
"Love itself is whatever is leftover when being in love is burned away.
126
348760
3698
05:52
And this is both an art and a fortunate accident.
127
352482
2857
05:55
Your mother and I had it.
128
355704
1683
05:57
We had roots that grew towards each other underground,
129
357411
2539
05:59
and when all the pretty blossoms had fallen from our branches,
130
359974
2929
06:02
we discovered that we are one tree and not two."
131
362927
2452
06:05
That's what the heart yearns for.
132
365696
1873
06:07
The second thing you discover is your soul.
133
367593
2761
06:10
Now, I don't ask you to believe in God or not believe in God,
134
370932
2878
06:13
but I do ask you to believe that there's a piece of you
135
373834
2587
06:16
that has no shape, size, color or weight,
136
376445
1976
06:18
but that gives you infinite dignity and value.
137
378445
2926
06:21
Rich and successful people don't have more of this
138
381395
2357
06:23
than less successful people.
139
383776
1365
06:25
Slavery is wrong because it's an obliteration of another soul.
140
385974
3182
06:29
Rape is not just an attack on a bunch of physical molecules,
141
389180
2834
06:32
it's an attempt to insult another person's soul.
142
392038
2928
06:34
And what the soul does is it yearns for righteousness.
143
394990
3046
06:38
The heart yearns for fusion with another, the soul yearns for righteousness.
144
398060
3579
06:41
And that led to my third realization, which I borrowed from Einstein:
145
401663
3285
06:45
"The problem you have is not going to be solved
146
405655
2486
06:48
at the level of consciousness on which you created it.
147
408165
2714
06:50
You have to expand to a different level of consciousness."
148
410903
3873
06:54
So what do you do?
149
414800
1214
06:56
Well, the first thing you do is you throw yourself on your friends
150
416038
3110
06:59
and you have deeper conversations that you ever had before.
151
419172
2961
07:02
But the second thing you do,
152
422157
1357
07:03
you have to go out alone into the wilderness.
153
423538
2134
07:05
You go out into that place where there's nobody there to perform,
154
425696
3072
07:08
and the ego has nothing to do, and it crumbles,
155
428792
2380
07:11
and only then are you capable of being loved.
156
431196
2159
07:13
I have a friend who said that when her daughter was born,
157
433712
3337
07:17
she realized that she loved her more than evolution required.
158
437073
3603
07:21
(Laughter)
159
441041
1143
07:22
And I've always loved that.
160
442208
1405
07:23
(Applause)
161
443637
1142
07:24
Because it talks about the peace that's at the deep of ourself,
162
444803
2957
07:27
our inexplicable care for one another.
163
447784
2705
07:30
And when you touch that spot, you're ready to be rescued.
164
450513
2944
07:33
The hard thing about when you're in the valley
165
453815
2316
07:37
is that you can't climb out;
166
457300
1348
07:38
somebody has to reach in and pull you out.
167
458672
2157
07:41
It happened to me.
168
461331
1155
07:42
I got, luckily, invited over to a house by a couple named Kathy and David,
169
462510
3527
07:46
and they were --
170
466061
1405
07:48
They had a kid in the DC public school, his name's Santi.
171
468196
2675
07:50
Santi had a friend who needed a place to stay
172
470895
2102
07:53
because his mom had some health issues.
173
473021
1866
07:54
And then that kid had a friend and that kid had a friend.
174
474911
2682
07:57
When I went to their house six years ago,
175
477617
2008
07:59
I walk in the door, there's like 25 around the kitchen table,
176
479649
2897
08:02
a whole bunch sleeping downstairs in the basement.
177
482570
2349
08:04
I reach out to introduce myself to a kid,
178
484943
2063
08:07
and he says, "We don't really shake hands here.
179
487030
2604
08:10
We just hug here."
180
490331
1448
08:12
And I'm not the huggiest guy on the face of the earth,
181
492323
2976
08:15
but I've been going back to that home every Thursday night when I'm in town,
182
495323
3579
08:18
and just hugging all those kids.
183
498926
1544
08:20
They demand intimacy.
184
500494
1885
08:22
They demand that you behave in a way where you're showing all the way up.
185
502403
3610
08:26
And they teach you a new way to live,
186
506442
1794
08:28
which is the cure for all the ills of our culture
187
508260
2301
08:30
which is a way of direct -- really putting relationship first,
188
510585
2946
08:33
not just as a word, but as a reality.
189
513555
3170
08:37
And the beautiful thing is, these communities are everywhere.
190
517557
4071
08:41
I started something at the Aspen Institute called "Weave: The Social Fabric."
191
521652
3647
08:45
This is our logo here.
192
525323
1156
08:46
And we plop into a place and we find weavers anywhere, everywhere.
193
526503
3733
08:50
We find people like Asiaha Butler, who grew up in --
194
530761
2517
08:54
who lived in Chicago, in Englewood, in a tough neighborhood.
195
534056
2817
08:56
And she was about to move because it was so dangerous,
196
536897
2953
09:00
and she looked across the street and she saw two little girls
197
540173
2868
09:03
playing in an empty lot with broken bottles,
198
543065
2076
09:05
and she turned to her husband and she said, "We're not leaving.
199
545165
3182
09:08
We're not going to be just another family that abandon that."
200
548371
2976
09:11
And she Googled "volunteer in Englewood," and now she runs R.A.G.E.,
201
551371
3208
09:14
the big community organization there.
202
554603
1797
09:16
Some of these people have had tough valleys.
203
556424
2979
09:19
I met a woman named Sarah in Ohio who came home from an antiquing trip
204
559427
3705
09:23
and found that her husband had killed himself and their two kids.
205
563156
3762
09:27
She now runs a free pharmacy, she volunteers in the community,
206
567815
3380
09:31
she helps women cope with violence, she teaches.
207
571219
2992
09:34
She told me, "I grew from this experience because I was angry.
208
574235
3064
09:37
I was going to fight back against what he tried to do to me
209
577323
2770
09:40
by making a difference in the world.
210
580117
1746
09:41
See, he didn't kill me.
211
581887
2055
09:43
My response to him is,
212
583966
1185
09:45
'Whatever you meant to do to me, screw you, you're not going to do it.'"
213
585175
4196
09:50
These weavers are not living an individualistic life,
214
590029
3373
09:53
they're living a relationist life, they have a different set of values.
215
593426
3373
09:56
They have moral motivations.
216
596823
1420
09:58
They have vocational certitude, they have planted themselves down.
217
598267
3128
10:01
I met a guy in Youngstown, Ohio,
218
601419
1587
10:03
who just held up a sign in the town square,
219
603030
2031
10:05
"Defend Youngstown."
220
605085
1151
10:06
They have radical mutuality,
221
606260
1873
10:08
and they are geniuses at relationship.
222
608157
2533
10:11
There's a woman named Mary Gordon
223
611180
1675
10:12
who runs something called Roots of Empathy.
224
612879
2123
10:15
And what they do is they take a bunch of kids, an eighth grade class,
225
615026
3265
10:18
they put a mom and an infant,
226
618315
1739
10:20
and then the students have to guess what the infant is thinking,
227
620078
3024
10:23
to teach empathy.
228
623126
1151
10:24
There was one kid in a class who was bigger than the rest
229
624301
3106
10:27
because he'd been held back, been through the foster care system,
230
627431
3583
10:31
seen his mom get killed.
231
631038
1626
10:32
And he wanted to hold the baby.
232
632688
1881
10:34
And the mom was nervous because he looked big and scary.
233
634593
2635
10:37
But she let this kid, Darren, hold the baby.
234
637252
2595
10:39
He held it, and he was great with it.
235
639871
1849
10:43
He gave the baby back and started asking questions about parenthood.
236
643014
3486
10:47
And his final question was,
237
647015
1929
10:48
"If nobody has ever loved you, do you think you can be a good father?"
238
648968
3301
10:52
And so what Roots of Empathy does
239
652642
1667
10:54
is they reach down and they grab people out of the valley.
240
654333
2720
10:57
And that's what weavers are doing.
241
657077
1853
11:01
Some of them switch jobs.
242
661300
2187
11:03
Some of them stay in their same jobs.
243
663950
2531
11:06
But one thing is, they have an intensity to them.
244
666982
2500
11:09
I read this --
245
669982
1383
11:11
E.O. Wilson wrote a great book called "Naturalist," about his childhood.
246
671389
5987
11:17
When he was seven, his parents were divorcing.
247
677712
2699
11:21
And they sent him to Paradise Beach in North Florida.
248
681291
3167
11:24
And he'd never seen the ocean before.
249
684482
1836
11:26
And he'd never seen a jellyfish before.
250
686731
2331
11:29
He wrote, "The creature was astonishing. It existed beyond my imagination."
251
689086
4091
11:33
He was sitting on the dock one day
252
693596
1661
11:35
and he saw a stingray float beneath his feet.
253
695281
2737
11:38
And at that moment, a naturalist was born in the awe and wonder.
254
698365
4080
11:42
And he makes this observation:
255
702469
2145
11:44
that when you're a child,
256
704638
1217
11:45
you see animals at twice the size as you do as an adult.
257
705879
3147
11:50
And that has always impressed me,
258
710162
1774
11:51
because what we want as kids is that moral intensity,
259
711960
4760
11:56
to be totally given ourselves over to something
260
716744
2944
11:59
and to find that level of vocation.
261
719712
2334
12:02
And when you are around these weavers,
262
722480
1969
12:04
they see other people at twice the size as normal people.
263
724473
2968
12:07
They see deeper into them.
264
727465
1733
12:09
And what they see is joy.
265
729997
2158
12:13
On the first mountain of our life, when we're shooting for our career,
266
733315
3404
12:16
we shoot for happiness.
267
736743
2159
12:19
And happiness is good, it's the expansion of self.
268
739649
3047
12:22
You win a victory,
269
742720
1746
12:24
you get a promotion, your team wins the Super Bowl,
270
744490
3993
12:28
you're happy.
271
748507
1150
12:30
Joy is not the expansion of self, it's the dissolving of self.
272
750149
3721
12:34
It's the moment when the skin barrier disappears between a mother and her child,
273
754764
4238
12:39
it's the moment when a naturalist feels just free in nature.
274
759026
3309
12:43
It's the moment where you're so lost in your work or a cause,
275
763232
2945
12:46
you have totally self-forgotten.
276
766201
2000
12:48
And joy is a better thing to aim for than happiness.
277
768649
2886
12:51
I collect passages of joy, of people when they lose it.
278
771559
3041
12:54
One of my favorite is from Zadie Smith.
279
774624
2247
12:56
In 1999, she was in a London nightclub,
280
776895
3310
13:00
looking for her friends, wondering where her handbag was.
281
780229
3095
13:03
And suddenly, as she writes,
282
783348
2103
13:05
"... a rail-thin man with enormous eyes reached across a sea of bodies
283
785475
3322
13:08
for my hand.
284
788821
1176
13:10
He kept asking me the same thing over and over, 'Are you feeling it?'
285
790021
3739
13:13
My ridiculous heels were killing me, I was terrified that I might die,
286
793784
3849
13:17
yet I felt simultaneously overwhelmed with delight
287
797657
2448
13:20
that 'Can I Kick It?' should happen to be playing
288
800129
2311
13:22
on this precise moment in the history of the world
289
802464
2346
13:24
on the sound system,
290
804834
1155
13:26
and it was now morphing into 'Teen Spirit.'
291
806013
2128
13:28
I took the man's hand, the top of my head blew away,
292
808165
3158
13:31
we danced, we danced, we gave ourselves up to joy."
293
811347
3400
13:35
And so what I'm trying to describe is two different life mindsets.
294
815680
3806
13:39
The first mountain mindset, which is about individual happiness and career success.
295
819998
4468
13:44
And it's a good mindset, I have nothing against it.
296
824490
2563
13:47
But we're in a national valley,
297
827077
2294
13:49
because we don't have the other mindset to balance it.
298
829395
2833
13:52
We no longer feel good about ourselves as a people,
299
832252
2563
13:54
we've lost our defining faith in our future,
300
834839
2690
13:57
we don't see each other deeply, we don't treat each other as well.
301
837553
3382
14:01
And we need a lot of changes.
302
841538
1991
14:03
We need an economic change and environmental change.
303
843553
2706
14:06
But we also need a cultural and relational revolution.
304
846902
2945
14:09
We need to name the language of a recovered society.
305
849871
4270
14:14
And to me, the weavers have found that language.
306
854553
2738
14:17
My theory of social change is that society changes
307
857593
3101
14:20
when a small group of people find a better way to live,
308
860718
2645
14:23
and the rest of us copy them.
309
863387
1675
14:25
And these weavers have found a better way to live.
310
865765
2638
14:28
And you don't have to theorize about it.
311
868427
1953
14:30
They are out there as community builders all around the country.
312
870404
3229
14:34
We just have to shift our lives a little,
313
874277
2277
14:36
so we can say, "I'm a weaver, we're a weaver."
314
876578
2731
14:39
And if we do that,
315
879999
1366
14:42
the hole inside ourselves gets filled,
316
882079
2349
14:44
but more important, the social unity gets repaired.
317
884452
2825
14:47
Thank you very much.
318
887301
1167
14:48
(Applause)
319
888492
4065
About this website

This site will introduce you to YouTube videos that are useful for learning English. You will see English lessons taught by top-notch teachers from around the world. Double-click on the English subtitles displayed on each video page to play the video from there. The subtitles scroll in sync with the video playback. If you have any comments or requests, please contact us using this contact form.

https://forms.gle/WvT1wiN1qDtmnspy7