What it means to be intersex | Susannah Temko

107,151 views ・ 2020-09-16

TED


Please double-click on the English subtitles below to play the video.

00:00
Transcriber: Leslie Gauthier Reviewer: Krystian Aparta
0
0
7000
00:12
I have a confession to make, right off the bat.
1
12759
3941
00:16
I don't know what you were doing at 16,
2
16724
2625
00:19
but I'm a really big fan of "Harry Potter"
3
19373
2899
00:22
and was waiting way too long to receive my letter
4
22296
3274
00:25
inviting me to Hogwarts School of Witchcraft and Wizardry --
5
25594
3429
00:29
I could have gone for sixth form.
6
29047
1647
00:31
I was also waiting for an invitation to the Jedi Temple
7
31143
5366
00:36
or a tap on the shoulder to invite me to the X-Men.
8
36533
4402
00:41
I was that kid.
9
41464
1247
00:43
When I was 16 years old, I got my wish.
10
43846
3746
00:48
I was taken into a doctor's office
11
48910
2143
00:51
and told that I am in fact part of a group of people
12
51077
4445
00:55
who are still largely invisible and misunderstood.
13
55546
5515
01:02
I am intersex.
14
62214
1974
01:05
That's my superpower.
15
65005
1363
01:07
For many of you in this room,
16
67388
1405
01:08
it will be the first time you've even heard the word "intersex."
17
68817
3558
01:12
Intersex is anatomy.
18
72399
2147
01:14
It refers to people who were born with one or more
19
74894
3540
01:18
of a variation of sex characteristics.
20
78458
2776
01:21
That's your genitals, your hormones, your chromosomes
21
81258
4605
01:25
that fall outside of the traditional conceptions of male and female bodies.
22
85887
5323
01:32
In other words,
23
92733
1509
01:34
the most basic assumption we've made about our species --
24
94266
4633
01:38
what we're taught in schools that sex is binary,
25
98923
3564
01:42
just male and female --
26
102511
2815
01:45
is not correct.
27
105350
1405
01:47
Like most things in this world,
28
107682
1739
01:49
it is much more complicated than that.
29
109445
2679
01:53
Intersex people who fall outside of this false sex binary
30
113581
4863
01:58
have always existed, throughout human history.
31
118468
3403
02:02
Like the wizards of "Harry Potter,"
32
122929
2832
02:05
we are pretty much invisible.
33
125785
2589
02:09
Some of us don't even know that we are intersex.
34
129406
2610
02:13
Like the X-Men,
35
133072
1842
02:14
some of our traits are obvious at birth
36
134938
3653
02:18
and others turn up around the time when puberty is supposed to kick in.
37
138615
5408
02:25
When we find out we are intersex,
38
145957
1719
02:27
some of us believe we are the only ones in the world.
39
147700
3689
02:33
Me, specifically, I have XY chromosomes,
40
153805
5236
02:39
which you may have understood to be typically male.
41
159065
3598
02:43
I was also born with gonads instead of ovaries.
42
163734
4062
02:49
Standing here on this stage would have been my worst nightmare
43
169432
4673
02:54
only five years ago.
44
174129
2223
02:57
It would have been impossible.
45
177706
2027
03:01
I use the metaphor of the superhuman,
46
181100
3033
03:04
but really, we are just like you.
47
184157
2823
03:07
Intersex people are thought to make up to 1.7 percent of the population.
48
187971
5081
03:13
That means more, depending on where you are in the world,
49
193788
2688
03:16
but you get the picture.
50
196500
1359
03:18
We are in front of you, getting coffee;
51
198546
2437
03:21
we are sitting next to you on the train;
52
201007
1958
03:22
we are swiping you left and right on dating apps --
53
202989
2865
03:25
(Laughter)
54
205878
2906
03:28
So why haven't you heard of us?
55
208808
2871
03:33
If we are so common, why don't you see us?
56
213497
4202
03:38
How has the world responded to us?
57
218559
2877
03:43
We often think of disciplines like medicine and the law
58
223066
4043
03:47
as supposedly neutral --
59
227133
2505
03:49
immune to bias.
60
229662
1314
03:52
The law is "reason free from passion."
61
232015
2849
03:55
The doctors' Hippocratic oath states
62
235721
2453
03:58
that "warmth, sympathy and understanding
63
238198
2628
04:00
may outweigh the surgeon's knife or the chemist's pill."
64
240850
4435
04:06
In truth, these disciplines that touch our lives are impressive,
65
246372
6196
04:12
but they are filled with our prejudices.
66
252592
2457
04:15
They are not immune,
67
255516
2080
04:17
just as we are not immune to the effects of that prejudice,
68
257620
4481
04:22
which can be devastating.
69
262125
2132
04:25
In medicine, intersex babies who are born with ambiguous genitalia
70
265769
6408
04:32
are routinely operated on without consent,
71
272201
5421
04:37
without medical need,
72
277646
2797
04:40
irreversibly,
73
280467
1925
04:42
in order to make their healthy anatomy appear more "normal."
74
282416
5693
04:49
This is before they've even said their first words,
75
289951
4034
04:54
indicated a sexuality or a gender identity.
76
294009
4456
05:00
Many people are never told the truth about their intersex traits,
77
300382
5738
05:06
and those who are are instructed, often, not to tell anyone.
78
306144
5177
05:12
Secrecy is enforced and shame is a close shadow.
79
312314
3843
05:17
In the law,
80
317959
1245
05:19
intersex people fall outside of categorization,
81
319228
4483
05:23
and more importantly, protection.
82
323735
2396
05:27
This concerns the banal tasks --
83
327231
2401
05:29
if you can imagine the number of forms you've filled out
84
329656
2621
05:32
that you had to check "M" of "F" on --
85
332301
2546
05:34
to lacking protection under any law,
86
334871
4426
05:39
specifically, the Gender Recognition or Equality Act.
87
339321
3572
05:44
And intersex people cannot correct the sex classification
88
344609
4847
05:49
they've been given at birth
89
349480
2019
05:51
unless they declare they are transgender.
90
351523
2298
05:55
After decades of activism,
91
355813
3040
05:58
these life-altering problems are starting to be addressed.
92
358877
3745
06:04
So why does this matter to those of you who aren't intersex,
93
364098
5046
06:09
who don't have variations of sex characteristics?
94
369168
3163
06:14
I imagine many people in this audience have,
95
374354
3492
06:17
in the privacy of their own bathrooms,
96
377870
2840
06:20
wondered ...
97
380734
1445
06:23
"Are my labia too long?"
98
383110
2017
06:25
"Are my testicles uneven?"
99
385151
1453
06:26
"Is my penis too small?"
100
386628
1970
06:28
"Is my vagina too wide or too shallow?"
101
388622
2690
06:31
Nothing that hurts or gets in the way, just aesthetically:
102
391336
4812
06:36
"Are mine 'normal?'"
103
396172
2165
06:39
I imagine that many people in this audience have those small concerns
104
399743
5298
06:45
but generally go about their lives not thinking about it.
105
405065
4321
06:50
These variations in our bodies,
106
410212
1691
06:51
like the color of our eyes or the size of our feet,
107
411927
3414
06:55
rarely affect our health, materially.
108
415365
2291
06:59
To put it another way,
109
419366
2240
07:01
to give you an idea of the intersex experience,
110
421630
4451
07:06
what if when you were an infant,
111
426105
2754
07:08
your parents or your doctors looked at your labia,
112
428883
4554
07:13
your penis, your testicles,
113
433461
3652
07:17
and thought,
114
437137
1919
07:19
"They're healthy, feeling,
115
439080
3038
07:22
but they're not 'normal,'"
116
442142
3246
07:25
even before you knew what you wanted to do with them,
117
445412
2835
07:28
or you know, want to put them.
118
448271
1727
07:30
(Laughter)
119
450022
2676
07:33
What if they went so far
120
453090
3557
07:36
as to assign you a different sex based off these measurements ...
121
456671
6300
07:45
And then they lied to you about what they'd done?
122
465031
2698
07:50
What if these surgeries sterilized you?
123
470709
3041
07:56
What if they resulted in immense pain and scarring?
124
476024
3981
08:02
What if you had to take medicine for the rest of your life
125
482310
3923
08:06
to replace the healthy organs they took away,
126
486257
3619
08:09
and you had to pay for that medicine yourself?
127
489900
2206
08:13
And then every time you went to a doctor's office for a cold,
128
493828
5142
08:18
you were questioned about your sex life,
129
498994
3711
08:22
your gender identity,
130
502729
1533
08:24
what your private parts looked like.
131
504286
2268
08:27
And then more doctors and medical students were invited
132
507107
3802
08:30
to add to these questions,
133
510933
2114
08:33
ask you to drop your trousers
134
513071
2267
08:35
or submit to an unnecessary medical exam.
135
515362
3832
08:41
This is a picture of what is happening to the intersex community --
136
521438
6242
08:47
people like me, every day, around the world.
137
527704
4043
08:53
Our community is not antimedicine or antisurgery.
138
533006
4814
08:58
We are for the right to make decisions about our bodies
139
538239
4818
09:03
and our lives.
140
543081
1739
09:05
The current approach to intersex people stems from a now-debunked academic study
141
545875
6929
09:12
from a man who, over 50 years ago,
142
552828
2096
09:14
believed that you could raise a child in any gender
143
554948
4397
09:19
by changing their genitals, never telling them
144
559369
3008
09:22
and reinforcing that gender over and over again.
145
562401
3694
09:27
It also stems from referring to healthy intersex variations as abnormal
146
567603
6563
09:34
or disordered.
147
574190
1460
09:36
This makes sense.
148
576578
1460
09:38
If you refer to something as a disorder, it suggests there's a fix.
149
578062
3861
09:42
It also stems [from] the fear and stigma of being intersex,
150
582913
4826
09:47
from homophobia, transphobia, sexism
151
587763
4163
09:51
and ultimately, our colonial past.
152
591950
2579
09:56
I am not here to say that the categories of men and women don't exist.
153
596839
5174
10:02
I'm saying, like most things in this world,
154
602420
2866
10:05
it is more complicated than that.
155
605310
2198
10:08
The world is complex,
156
608848
1254
10:10
and we can choose to see that as beautiful,
157
610126
3443
10:13
or we can choose to continue to deny the existence of that complexity,
158
613593
5745
10:19
push people into artificial, binary boxes,
159
619362
4176
10:23
fix what isn't broken
160
623562
2471
10:26
and restrict our own field of vision.
161
626057
2631
10:30
One of the challenges that intersex people face today
162
630816
3977
10:34
is making ourselves visible
163
634817
3247
10:38
and making ourselves safe at the same time.
164
638088
2515
10:41
By that, I mean we are appealing to the humanity of lawmakers
165
641182
4962
10:46
to make us safe
166
646168
2391
10:48
whilst putting ourselves into the public eye,
167
648583
3007
10:51
sharing our stories,
168
651614
1460
10:53
trying to build community with people like us ...
169
653098
3381
10:57
Even when it isn't safe to do so.
170
657807
2630
11:02
For parents of intersex children listening and watching,
171
662613
4302
11:06
for those in the audience
172
666939
1191
11:08
who may become the guardians of intersex people,
173
668154
3063
11:11
I want you to know I love my life,
174
671241
3714
11:16
but it has not be free of issue,
175
676222
2008
11:18
especially in relation to being intersex.
176
678254
2872
11:21
No life is free of issue.
177
681756
1692
11:24
All coins have two sides.
178
684103
1960
11:27
On the one side,
179
687890
1940
11:29
I have been humiliated in doctors' offices.
180
689854
3818
11:34
I have stood in front of prospective partners and felt afraid
181
694966
4776
11:39
and so not good enough.
182
699766
2283
11:43
I have watched other women pass me in the street
183
703908
2866
11:46
and imagine the ways that they were more woman than me,
184
706798
4181
11:51
more human than me.
185
711003
1366
11:54
I have questioned whether I have a place in this world.
186
714092
3643
12:00
On the other,
187
720473
1405
12:01
I have been deeply loved for everything that I am,
188
721902
6225
12:08
in friendship and romantically.
189
728151
2314
12:12
I have learned compassion and empathy for a wider range of society.
190
732178
5619
12:18
I have taken the time to love my body
191
738674
3334
12:22
and not judge the bodies of others.
192
742032
2359
12:25
I have developed a strength and a hope
193
745997
3294
12:29
that would have been impossible without this particular life.
194
749315
4650
12:36
The instinct to protect children is instinctive and it's admirable,
195
756540
6285
12:42
but the truth is that love, acceptance
196
762849
4247
12:47
and refusing to bathe that child in shame
197
767120
3099
12:50
will protect them more than trying to fix something that isn't broken.
198
770243
5080
12:56
This is why it is in our interest to protect intersex people
199
776711
4731
13:01
and make them visible.
200
781466
1919
13:04
For as long as societies reinforce one form of acceptable,
201
784302
5056
13:09
of "normal,"
202
789382
2054
13:11
everyone will face insecurity for being different in any way.
203
791460
4873
13:18
Simply trying to erase variation, difference,
204
798730
5374
13:24
builds shame.
205
804128
1284
13:28
Being intersex has not materialized the powers
206
808683
3391
13:32
that I wished for as a teenager ...
207
812098
3038
13:35
beyond being able to see where this false sex binary harms us all.
208
815160
5187
13:41
It is my belief
209
821967
2158
13:44
that if intersex people can gain equality,
210
824149
4991
13:49
can be seen,
211
829164
1760
13:50
can be accepted
212
830948
1970
13:52
and can be loved,
213
832942
2000
13:54
then we all will.
214
834966
1729
13:56
Thank you.
215
836719
1151
13:57
(Applause and cheers)
216
837894
3309
About this website

This site will introduce you to YouTube videos that are useful for learning English. You will see English lessons taught by top-notch teachers from around the world. Double-click on the English subtitles displayed on each video page to play the video from there. The subtitles scroll in sync with the video playback. If you have any comments or requests, please contact us using this contact form.

https://forms.gle/WvT1wiN1qDtmnspy7