Beware of nominalizations (AKA zombie nouns) - Helen Sword

1,115,651 views ・ 2012-10-31

TED-Ed


Please double-click on the English subtitles below to play the video.

00:00
Transcriber: tom carter Reviewer: Bedirhan Cinar
0
0
7000
00:16
Take an adjective such as "implacable,"
1
16143
3081
00:19
or a verb like "proliferate,"
2
19224
2534
00:21
or even another noun, "crony,"
3
21758
2466
00:24
and add a suffix, such as "-ity," or "-tion," or "-ism."
4
24224
6936
00:31
You've created a new noun.
5
31160
2264
00:33
"Implacability," "proliferation," "cronyism."
6
33424
5462
00:38
Sounds impressive, right?
7
38886
2252
00:41
Wrong! You've just unleashed a flesh-eating zombie.
8
41138
4716
00:45
Nouns made from other parts of speech are called nominalizations.
9
45854
4716
00:50
Academics love them.
10
50570
1869
00:52
So do lawyers, bureaucrats, business writers.
11
52439
5115
00:57
I call them zombie nouns, because they consume the living.
12
57554
4450
01:02
They cannibalize active verbs, they suck the lifeblood from adjectives,
13
62004
5301
01:07
and they substitute abstract entities for human beings.
14
67305
4850
01:12
Here's an example.
15
72155
2349
01:14
"The proliferation of nominalizations in a discursive formation may be an indication
16
74504
6165
01:20
of a tendency towards pomposity and abstraction." Huh?
17
80669
5468
01:26
This sentence contains no fewer than seven nominalizations,
18
86137
5068
01:31
yet it fails to tell us who is doing what.
19
91205
3482
01:34
When we eliminate, or reanimate, most of the zombie nouns,
20
94687
3968
01:38
so "tendency" becomes "tend," "abstraction" becomes "abstract,"
21
98655
5600
01:44
then we add a human subject and some active verbs,
22
104255
3716
01:47
the sentence springs back to life.
23
107971
2917
01:50
"Writers who overload their sentences with nominalizations tend to sound pompous and abstract."
24
110888
6868
01:57
Only one zombie noun -- the key word "nominalizations" --
25
117756
4618
02:02
has been allowed to remain standing.
26
122374
3631
02:06
At their best, nominalizations help us express complex ideas,
27
126005
4849
02:10
perception, intelligence, epistemology.
28
130854
5317
02:16
At their worst, they impede clear communication.
29
136171
4233
02:20
To get a feeling for how zombie nouns work, release a few of them into a lively sentence
30
140404
5066
02:25
and watch them sap all its energy.
31
145470
3084
02:28
George Orwell played this game in his essay "Politics in the English Language."
32
148554
4550
02:33
He started with a well-known verse from the book of Ecclesiastes in the Bible.
33
153104
4950
02:38
It says "I returned and saw under the sun, that the race is not to the swift, nor the battle to the strong,
34
158054
8966
02:47
neither yet bread to the wise, nor yet riches to men of understanding, nor yet favor to men of skill;
35
167020
8068
02:55
but time and chance happeneth to them all."
36
175088
4832
02:59
Now here's Orwell's modern English version.
37
179920
4369
03:04
"Objective considerations of contemporary phenomena compel the conclusion that success or failure in competitive activities
38
184289
8448
03:12
exhibits no tendency to be commensurate with innate capacity, but that a considerable element of the unpredictable
39
192737
7268
03:20
must invariably be taken into account."
40
200005
4315
03:24
The Bible passage speaks to our senses and emotions with concrete nouns,
41
204320
4850
03:29
descriptions of people, and punchy, abstract nouns such as "race,"
42
209170
5001
03:34
"battle," "riches," "time," "chance."
43
214171
4499
03:38
Not a zombie among them.
44
218670
2617
03:41
Orwell's satirical translation, on the other hand, is teeming with nominalizations and other vague abstractions.
45
221287
7118
03:48
The zombies have taken over, and the humans have fled the village.
46
228405
6583
03:54
Zombie nouns do their worst damage when they gather in jargon-generating packs
47
234988
4682
03:59
and swallow every noun, verb and adjective in sight.
48
239670
4234
04:03
So "globe" becomes "global," becomes "globalize," becomes "globalization."
49
243904
5483
04:09
The grandfather of all nominalizations, antidisestablishmentarianism,
50
249387
6018
04:15
contains at least two verbs, three adjectives, and six other nouns
51
255405
5449
04:20
inside its distended belly.
52
260854
3353
04:24
A paragraph heavily populated by nominalizations will send your readers straight to sleep.
53
264207
6180
04:30
Rescue them from the zombie apocalypse with vigorous verb-driven sentences
54
270387
5101
04:35
that are concrete and clearly structured.
55
275488
3152
04:38
You want your sentences to live,
56
278640
2946
04:41
not to join the living dead.
57
281586
4655
About this website

This site will introduce you to YouTube videos that are useful for learning English. You will see English lessons taught by top-notch teachers from around the world. Double-click on the English subtitles displayed on each video page to play the video from there. The subtitles scroll in sync with the video playback. If you have any comments or requests, please contact us using this contact form.

https://forms.gle/WvT1wiN1qDtmnspy7