What doctors should know about gender identity | Kristie Overstreet

85,208 views ・ 2018-10-23

TED


Please double-click on the English subtitles below to play the video.

00:12
About six months into my career as a therapist,
0
12880
2696
00:15
I was working at a drug and alcohol rehab facility.
1
15600
3296
00:18
I got a call from one of the nurses down at the detox unit.
2
18920
3576
00:22
She asked me to come down and assess one of the new patients
3
22520
2856
00:25
that had arrived earlier in the day.
4
25400
1856
00:27
So I went down to the unit and had the pleasure of meeting Anne.
5
27280
3416
00:30
Anne's a transgender female, and as her and I started talking,
6
30720
3456
00:34
she was sharing with me about what brought her into treatment,
7
34200
3016
00:37
but I could hear this fear in her voice,
8
37240
2736
00:40
and I could see this worry in her eyes,
9
40000
1896
00:41
and she began to tell me that she didn't fear coming into rehab
10
41920
2976
00:44
and having to give up drugs and alcohol.
11
44920
2376
00:47
Her fear was that the doctors that were going to be treating her
12
47320
3016
00:50
would not treat her as her female self.
13
50360
1880
00:53
She then told me about this ongoing pain that she has experienced her whole life
14
53360
3816
00:57
of being assigned male but knowing she's female.
15
57200
2456
00:59
And what she meant by that is, when she was born,
16
59680
3296
01:03
the doctor held her up to her parents
17
63000
2136
01:05
and based on her genitalia said,
18
65160
1896
01:07
"It's a boy."
19
67080
1736
01:08
She always knew she wasn't a boy.
20
68840
1640
01:11
Many years passed and the feelings that she was feeling
21
71920
2616
01:14
and holding all this in grew and grew,
22
74560
2015
01:16
and she knew she had to come out to her family.
23
76599
2297
01:18
And when she did, it didn't go over so well.
24
78920
2656
01:21
Her parents said, "Absolutely not. You're not a girl.
25
81600
2536
01:24
This is not how we raised you. We don't know what you're thinking.
26
84160
3256
01:27
Get out."
27
87440
1200
01:29
So Anne then found herself on the streets and in and out of homeless shelters,
28
89560
3696
01:33
and it's here where she started using drugs and alcohol
29
93280
3176
01:36
to numb this pain she felt inside.
30
96480
2000
01:39
She told me about her journey of being in and out of hospitals and rehabs
31
99720
3496
01:43
trying to get sober,
32
103240
1256
01:44
and when she did, the health care providers and doctors
33
104520
2936
01:47
wouldn't use the correct female name or pronouns.
34
107480
3056
01:50
This caused her pain.
35
110560
1360
01:53
You see, when I was studying to become a therapist,
36
113120
2416
01:55
I wasn't taught how to work with transgender patients.
37
115560
2560
01:59
I had no idea these would be the patients I'd be working with.
38
119120
2920
02:02
But the more I worked with Anne and other patients like Anne,
39
122800
3296
02:06
I began to see my mission evolve,
40
126120
2296
02:08
and that was to make sure that the transgender community
41
128440
3056
02:11
got their health care needs met.
42
131520
1760
02:14
The more I looked into this, I saw how this very real fear
43
134320
4136
02:18
of violence, discrimination and this lack of acceptance
44
138480
3776
02:22
caused so many of these patients to turn to alcohol and drugs.
45
142280
4136
02:26
And I also heard these horror stories
46
146440
2576
02:29
of when these patients were seeking medical care
47
149040
2936
02:32
and how they were treated,
48
152000
1416
02:33
and how a lot of their medical needs were ignored.
49
153440
2334
02:37
Now let me tell you about Leah.
50
157480
2056
02:39
I had the pleasure of meeting Leah a few years back.
51
159560
3176
02:42
She's a female and she has a wife and a child.
52
162760
3280
02:46
See, Leah was also assigned male at birth
53
166920
2936
02:49
and she knew since she was a young child that she was not a male,
54
169880
3816
02:53
that she was a female.
55
173720
1200
02:55
She hid it from herself and from everyone she knew,
56
175720
3136
02:58
especially from her wife, until the age of 50.
57
178880
2616
03:01
She couldn't take it anymore.
58
181520
1416
03:02
She was like, I can't keep living like this.
59
182960
2096
03:05
I gotta get honest.
60
185080
1216
03:06
She was extremely scared to tell her wife.
61
186320
2656
03:09
What if her wife said,
62
189000
1256
03:10
"This is unacceptable, I want a divorce, get out"?
63
190280
2720
03:14
To her surprise, her wife was accepting.
64
194080
3056
03:17
She said, "I love you regardless of who you are.
65
197160
3016
03:20
I want to help you in every way I can."
66
200200
1880
03:22
So she talked with her wife,
67
202960
1336
03:24
and she made the decision that she wanted to medically transition,
68
204320
4176
03:28
and she was interested in being assessed for hormone replacement therapy,
69
208520
3456
03:32
otherwise known as HRT.
70
212000
1280
03:34
So she made an appointment with her doctor.
71
214320
2040
03:37
She arrived on the day of her appointment early.
72
217560
2576
03:40
She filled out all the paperwork,
73
220160
1616
03:41
put the name correctly down there and waited patiently.
74
221800
2600
03:46
A little bit of time passed and a nurse called her back to the exam room.
75
226120
3440
03:50
When she got back there, she took a deep breath,
76
230400
2576
03:53
and the doctor and the nurse walked in.
77
233000
1880
03:56
She extended her hand to the doctor and said, "Hi, I'm Leah."
78
236160
2880
03:59
The doctor looked at her, didn't shake her hand and said,
79
239840
3296
04:03
"Why are you here?"
80
243160
1200
04:05
She took another deep breath and said,
81
245600
1920
04:09
"Well, I'm a transgender female.
82
249040
1936
04:11
I've known this my whole life, I've hid it from everyone,
83
251000
2696
04:13
but I can't do it anymore.
84
253720
1296
04:15
My wife's supportive, I can financially afford it,
85
255040
2776
04:17
I've got to make these changes.
86
257840
1496
04:19
Please consider me, and let's evaluate me for HRT."
87
259360
3520
04:23
The doctor said, "We can't do anything today.
88
263600
2136
04:25
You need to go get an HIV test."
89
265760
1560
04:29
She couldn't believe it.
90
269160
1200
04:31
She was furious.
91
271160
1215
04:32
She was angry. She was disappointed.
92
272399
1801
04:35
If her doctor treated her this way, how would the rest of the world treat her?
93
275040
3856
04:38
First, he wouldn't shake her hand,
94
278920
2376
04:41
and second, when he heard she was transgender,
95
281320
3136
04:44
all he cared about was getting an HIV test and ending the appointment.
96
284480
3296
04:47
He didn't even ask her any other questions.
97
287800
2040
04:50
See, I can understand where Leah's coming from,
98
290520
2736
04:53
because the years that I've worked with the community,
99
293280
2576
04:55
I hear myths every single day that aren't true at all.
100
295880
3576
04:59
A couple of those are:
101
299480
1936
05:01
every transgender person wants to transition with medication or surgery;
102
301440
4616
05:06
transgender people are mentally ill, this is a disorder;
103
306080
2896
05:09
and: these people aren't real men and women.
104
309000
2480
05:12
These are all myths and untrue.
105
312480
1720
05:15
As this community expands and grows older,
106
315240
3016
05:18
it is imperative that all health care providers be trained
107
318280
3136
05:21
on how to take care of their health care needs.
108
321440
2696
05:24
Back in 2015, a survey was done
109
324160
2496
05:26
and found that 72 percent of health care providers
110
326680
3536
05:30
did not feel well-informed
111
330240
2416
05:32
on the health care needs of the LGBT community.
112
332680
2800
05:37
There's a huge gap in the education and training.
113
337120
2520
05:40
Today, in this talk,
114
340880
1456
05:42
I want to offer a new way of thinking for three groups of people:
115
342360
3176
05:45
doctors, the transgender community and, well, the rest of us.
116
345560
4296
05:49
But before we do, I want to cover a couple of definitions
117
349880
2736
05:52
that's going to help you wrap your head around gender identity a little bit more.
118
352640
3856
05:56
So I hope you've got your paper and pen. Get ready to take some notes.
119
356520
3656
06:00
So let's start out with this idea of a binary system.
120
360200
3296
06:03
And what this means is,
121
363520
1256
06:04
before, we always thought there was only two, male and female.
122
364800
2936
06:07
Get it? Binary? Right?
123
367760
1656
06:09
So we've come to find out that this isn't true.
124
369440
2560
06:12
Gender identity is a spectrum
125
372680
2776
06:15
with maleness on one side
126
375480
1936
06:17
and femaleness over here on the other side.
127
377440
2376
06:19
This spectrum of identities
128
379840
2456
06:22
include identities such as gender-nonconforming,
129
382320
3376
06:25
gender-affirming,
130
385720
1296
06:27
gender-nonbinary,
131
387040
1296
06:28
two-spirited, three-spirited,
132
388360
2256
06:30
as well as people that are intersex.
133
390640
1720
06:33
The term transgender is this umbrella term
134
393120
2856
06:36
that encompasses all these different types of identities.
135
396000
3160
06:39
But for today's talk, I want you to think about transgender
136
399880
2816
06:42
as someone who is assigned a sex at birth that doesn't match
137
402720
3536
06:46
with who they are as a person and their sense of self.
138
406280
2856
06:49
Now, this is very different than biological sex.
139
409160
2256
06:51
So gender identity is sense of self.
140
411440
2376
06:53
So think of it as what's between your ears:
141
413840
3296
06:57
sense of self, who you are.
142
417160
1856
06:59
This is very different than biological sex, right?
143
419040
2736
07:01
Hormones, genitalia, chromosomes:
144
421800
1936
07:03
that's what's between our legs.
145
423760
1640
07:07
Now, you may be thinking, "Dr. Kristie, I have never questioned who I am.
146
427040
3736
07:10
I know I'm a man, or I know I'm a woman."
147
430800
2696
07:13
I get it. You know who you are.
148
433520
1600
07:16
This is how many transgender individuals feel.
149
436200
2336
07:18
They just know who they are
150
438560
1656
07:20
with that same conviction.
151
440240
2080
07:24
It's important to know that there are many different types of identities,
152
444320
3456
07:27
and I identify as a cisgender female.
153
447800
3016
07:30
Now, for all y'all out there that like to know how to spell things,
154
450840
3176
07:34
cis is spelled "c-i-s."
155
454040
2696
07:36
It's the Latin term for "on the same side of."
156
456760
2936
07:39
When I was born,
157
459720
1456
07:41
the doctor held me up to my parents and said,
158
461200
2096
07:43
"It's a girl."
159
463320
1256
07:44
All this, based on my genitalia.
160
464600
2056
07:46
Even though I grew up in a small farm town in Georgia,
161
466680
2776
07:49
very much a tomboy,
162
469480
3216
07:52
I never questioned that I was a female.
163
472720
2016
07:54
I've always known I was a girl,
164
474760
1536
07:56
regardless of how I was as a kid.
165
476320
2416
07:58
Now, this is very different than someone who's transgender.
166
478760
2816
08:01
Now, trans is a Latin term for "on the other side of" --
167
481600
4136
08:05
think about transcontinental airlines,
168
485760
1856
08:07
across, on the other side of --
169
487640
1856
08:09
someone that's assigned a sex at birth
170
489520
3016
08:12
and they identify on the other side of the spectrum.
171
492560
2440
08:15
A transgender male is someone who was assigned female at birth,
172
495680
4016
08:19
but their sense of self, who they are, how they live their life,
173
499720
3336
08:23
is as a male.
174
503080
1536
08:24
And the opposite is, as we talked earlier,
175
504640
2056
08:26
a transgender female, someone that's assigned male at birth
176
506720
2816
08:29
but lives their live and sense of self as a female.
177
509560
3056
08:32
It's also important to point out here
178
512640
1816
08:34
that not everyone that has a nonbinary identity
179
514480
3016
08:37
identifies with the term "transgender."
180
517520
1920
08:40
Just so nobody gets confused, I want to point out sexual identity,
181
520680
3576
08:44
or orientation.
182
524280
1536
08:45
That is simply who we're attracted to,
183
525840
2736
08:48
physically, emotionally, sexually, spiritually.
184
528600
2880
08:52
It's got nothing to do with gender identity.
185
532640
2096
08:54
So just for a quick recap, before we continue on:
186
534760
2336
08:57
gender identity between the ears,
187
537120
1696
08:58
biological sex, just think of it between your legs,
188
538840
3176
09:02
and then sexual identity, well, sometimes we use our heart,
189
542040
2816
09:04
but it's here.
190
544880
1416
09:06
Three very different identity spectrums.
191
546320
2800
09:11
Now, the average medical student
192
551000
2296
09:13
spends about five hours learning about the LGBT health-related needs
193
553320
5296
09:18
while they're in medical school.
194
558640
1816
09:20
Now, this is despite us knowing that there are unique health risks
195
560480
3816
09:24
to this community.
196
564320
1200
09:27
And there's an estimated 10 million American adults
197
567320
3776
09:31
that identify as LGBT.
198
571120
1400
09:34
Most doctors that work with transgender patients,
199
574000
2416
09:36
they learn trial by fire.
200
576440
2040
09:39
That means they figure it out as they go along,
201
579280
2216
09:41
or the patient ends up spending their time
202
581520
2296
09:43
trying to teach the doctor how to take care of them.
203
583840
2440
09:47
Many doctors don't feel comfortable asking about gender identities.
204
587200
3496
09:50
Some don't feel like it's relevant at all to their medical care
205
590720
3296
09:54
and others just don't want to say the wrong thing.
206
594040
2560
09:58
Many doctors who say something inappropriate
207
598400
2416
10:00
or they say something negative,
208
600840
1496
10:02
they may not be coming from a malicious or mean place,
209
602360
3576
10:05
they may have never been trained on how to care for these individuals.
210
605960
3816
10:09
But this can't be accepted as a norm anymore either.
211
609800
2760
10:14
So what happens to a transgender male --
212
614080
3416
10:17
for a quick recap, that's someone who is assigned female at birth
213
617520
3056
10:20
but lives their life as a male --
214
620600
1616
10:22
what happens when this transgender male goes for their yearly gynecological visit?
215
622240
4480
10:28
How that doctor treats that patient
216
628440
2776
10:31
will set the whole tone for the office.
217
631240
2256
10:33
If that doctor treats that male with the correct pronouns, correct name,
218
633520
4576
10:38
gives dignity and respect,
219
638120
2216
10:40
it's highly likely that the rest of the staff will too.
220
640360
2600
10:44
So that's a little bit about my thoughts on doctors,
221
644080
2456
10:46
and now let's move on to the transgender community.
222
646560
2696
10:49
I'm here talking about fear,
223
649280
2256
10:51
but y'all know who is really fearful, right?
224
651560
3136
10:54
It's the transgender community.
225
654720
2376
10:57
Earlier I shared the story about Anne
226
657120
1816
10:58
and how she was so worried about going into treatment
227
658960
2496
11:01
and not being respected as her female self,
228
661480
2056
11:03
and then Leah who was scared about how her doctor would react,
229
663560
2936
11:06
and the second that he didn't shake her hand
230
666500
2076
11:08
and ordered that HIV test, her fears came true.
231
668600
2600
11:12
The transgender community needs to be empowered
232
672680
2656
11:15
to speak up for their health care needs.
233
675360
2696
11:18
The days of remaining silent and taking whatever treatment you can get are over.
234
678080
4120
11:23
If you don't speak up for your health care needs,
235
683000
2856
11:25
no one's going to do it for you.
236
685880
1560
11:29
So what about the rest of us?
237
689080
1400
11:32
A lot of y'all, maybe in the next week or a couple of months,
238
692040
2896
11:34
are going to have a doctor's appointment, right?
239
694960
2256
11:37
So let's say you go to your doctor's appointment
240
697240
2336
11:39
and when it's over,
241
699600
1336
11:40
you feel worse than you did when you got there.
242
700960
2800
11:44
What if you felt dismissed by the doctor,
243
704800
2376
11:47
that they ignored your needs,
244
707200
1616
11:48
or you even felt judged?
245
708840
2080
11:52
That's what happens for many of the 1.4 million transgender adults
246
712360
4576
11:56
here in the US
247
716960
1256
11:58
if they're lucky enough to get an appointment.
248
718240
2160
12:01
Now, you may be thinking, "Why is this important to me?
249
721880
2976
12:04
I'm not transgender. I don't know anybody that's transgender.
250
724880
2896
12:07
Why should I even care?"
251
727800
1240
12:10
Think of it this way.
252
730080
1576
12:11
A transgender individual is human,
253
731680
2616
12:14
just like you and me.
254
734320
1200
12:16
They deserve competent and trained health care providers,
255
736480
2976
12:19
just like you and me.
256
739480
1240
12:22
So let me ask, if you don't mind raising your hand:
257
742120
2496
12:24
Do you know or have you met anyone who is transgender,
258
744640
3736
12:28
gender-nonconforming, agender, intersex, two-spirited, three-spirited?
259
748400
4336
12:32
Thank y'all so much. Lovely. Thank y'all.
260
752760
2320
12:35
Every one of y'all who did not raise your hand,
261
755840
2496
12:38
in the very near future
262
758360
2296
12:40
you will get the opportunity to meet
263
760680
1736
12:42
someone that falls into one of these identities, I guarantee it.
264
762440
3696
12:46
The number of this community is increasing.
265
766160
2480
12:49
That's not because it's a fad or the new thing to do.
266
769480
2800
12:53
It's safer to come out.
267
773120
1880
12:55
There's more awareness. There's more visibility.
268
775680
2976
12:58
There's more safety, so people are speaking up about their true self
269
778680
3216
13:01
like never before.
270
781920
1240
13:04
That's why it's so important that our health care system get on board
271
784160
3976
13:08
and make sure that our doctors and health care providers are trained
272
788160
3816
13:12
to approach these patients with dignity and respect,
273
792000
3256
13:15
just like we expect.
274
795280
1920
13:18
I remember being in my 11th grade literature class,
275
798640
2416
13:21
with one of my favorite teachers, Mr. McClain,
276
801080
2176
13:23
and he shared this quote by Heraclitus that sticks with me to this day.
277
803280
3616
13:26
Y'all may have even heard it.
278
806920
1656
13:28
It's, "The only thing that is constant is that things will change."
279
808600
4000
13:34
Familiar, right?
280
814600
1200
13:36
Every single one of us face changes in our lives,
281
816640
3136
13:39
and often when we're faced with these changes,
282
819800
2336
13:42
we've got some difficult decisions to make.
283
822160
2040
13:45
Will we remain in fear, stay stuck
284
825320
3616
13:48
and not grow?
285
828960
1656
13:50
Or, will we face fear with bravery,
286
830640
4376
13:55
evolve, take the opportunity to grow?
287
835040
2560
13:59
Every one of us face new things.
288
839000
2856
14:01
What will you do?
289
841880
1200
14:03
Will you remain in fear,
290
843920
2256
14:06
or will you grow?
291
846200
1880
14:09
I invite each of you, doctors, the transgender community
292
849040
3656
14:12
and you and I,
293
852720
1336
14:14
to face fear together
294
854080
1696
14:15
as we walk into this brave new world.
295
855800
2736
14:18
Thank you.
296
858560
1216
14:19
(Applause)
297
859800
4400
About this website

This site will introduce you to YouTube videos that are useful for learning English. You will see English lessons taught by top-notch teachers from around the world. Double-click on the English subtitles displayed on each video page to play the video from there. The subtitles scroll in sync with the video playback. If you have any comments or requests, please contact us using this contact form.

https://forms.gle/WvT1wiN1qDtmnspy7